HONEST TRAILERS MULAN | Reaction | Discussion: White People Playing Asian Voices (not an SJW rant)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 сер 2024
  • Screen Junkies:
    UA-cam: ‪@screenjunkies‬ | / screenjunkies
    Twitter: @ScreenJunkies | / screenjunkies
    Honest Trailers Mulan Link:
    • Honest Trailers | Mulan
    ___________________________________________________
    Jamazing Patrons of October: Sachin Shenoy, Neha Tankha, JN Valente, Avijit Singh, Madhan, Bhavya Singh, Riju Mahna, and Aqeel Shah!
    Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
    / jabykoay
    ___________________________________________________
    SOCIAL MEDIA:
    ~ACHARA KIRK~
    Twitter & Instagram: @AcharaKirk
    / achara
    ~JABY KOAY~
    UA-cam, Twitter, Instagram: @GETJaby
    Facebook: / followjaby
    ___________________________________________________
    JAMAZING SWAG:
    teespring.com/stores/jaby-koay
    *purchasing Jamazing Swag helps to support the channel!
    ___________________________________________________
    Jaby Koay ASIA:
    / jabytv
    Jaby Koay INDIA:
    / jabykoay
    JABY KOAY'S SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
    • JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
    Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
    ua-cam.com/users/subscription_c...
    Thanks for watching!!!
    __________________________________________________
    Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
    Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
    creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
    Song used during intro:
    Acid Jazz Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
    creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 82

  • @akshit318
    @akshit318 4 роки тому +53

    I think, They weren't saying it's her coming out... But reflection is a perfect coming out song

  • @TheChickenlittle11
    @TheChickenlittle11 4 роки тому +11

    Phil Lamarr was also Samurai Jack( Black voice actor playing a Japanese character)

    • @orangeslash1667
      @orangeslash1667 3 роки тому

      But he's not using his green lantern voice so it's ok. that's the problem with celebrities their not very versatile.

  • @ibuprofriends
    @ibuprofriends 4 роки тому +38

    gay coded villains.... hades, scar, ursula, etc. they arent meant to BE gay but their mannerisms/characteristics read that way.

    • @an3582
      @an3582 Рік тому

      Nowadays that would be assuming their sexuality bybhow they present which would be a cardinal sin worthy to have your whole family killed over. Something like that.

    • @triggerfairy4070
      @triggerfairy4070 Рік тому +1

      Hades is more sleezy car salesman coded villain.

  • @ghostlee6434
    @ghostlee6434 4 роки тому +25

    When they were talking about the coming out being gay. They weren't referring to mulan, they were talking about the guy who was attracted to mulan b4 he found out that mulan was female. People brushed it aside because mulan was really a woman. But he was attracted to her when he thought she was a he.

  • @samanthapadilla4813
    @samanthapadilla4813 4 роки тому +3

    Ming Na and the voice of the Emperor weren't the only Asians in the cast. Donny Osmond was only the singing voice of Li Shang, the actual voice actor for Li Shang was actor B. D. Wong, who is most noted for his recurring role as the main psychiatrist on Law and Order SVU,

  • @mckenzie.latham91
    @mckenzie.latham91 Рік тому +1

    Just to point out the lack songs was intentional,
    A girl worth fighting for is the last song before they find the destroyed village and Chinese army massacre
    and the point was that the happy note of songs was done with
    and that the girl worth fighting for was the young girl whose doll they found, but were unable to save from the huns.

  • @adolfopena7358
    @adolfopena7358 4 роки тому +6

    Watch some of the older Honest Trailers.

  • @laDmizuki
    @laDmizuki 4 роки тому +20

    The coming out thing? I think it is in reference to the characterization of Mulan in Once Upon A Time. Mulan is Gay in that retelling of the story.

    • @AniketPatil-nk1vw
      @AniketPatil-nk1vw 4 роки тому +3

      Ohh yeah. I forgot about that.

    • @liselottehildegarde5367
      @liselottehildegarde5367 3 роки тому

      The lyrics of the song itself is like a coming out song. "When will my reflection show who I am inside?"

    • @rachelmcdonald7296
      @rachelmcdonald7296 2 роки тому

      wasn't she bi? At first she was in love with Philip then over time she fell in love with Aurora.

  • @nightnaughty
    @nightnaughty 4 роки тому +6

    It's very well known that Disney villains are gay coded, when you pay attention they are drawn and characterized with gay stereotypes.
    When it comes to voice actors i don't think they really care about if the match the ethnicity of the character because they are only using there voice to portrayed them and even in motion caption they can use the body and voice but the final result it's up to the people that make the grafics and design.

  • @ted__ryan
    @ted__ryan 4 роки тому

    Now, binge watching Jaby reaction videos.

  • @VIGNESHWARRR
    @VIGNESHWARRR 3 роки тому +1

    Wow just found out that UA-cam thinks that JABY KOAY spells jam peek away 😂🤣😆

  • @RoninMidzu
    @RoninMidzu 3 роки тому +2

    The thing is Jasmine, is from the Middle-East, which starts at the South-Eastern borders of Europe an goes strait through several regions south, including Israel, the Arabic Emirates, Libia, Syria, Iran, Irak, Kuwait and several other states.
    Asia, as it is described here in Russia, starts at Pakistan, India and Mongolia, on the north side. The rest is Central-Asia (like China), South-East (like Vietnam and such) and the Far- East (Japan).
    We have borders to the most of them except the South-East. )))
    Jasmine is some sort of Arabian Princess, she should be whiter than even northern ones, because she would not leave the palace under any circumstances, only her hair and brows would be dark.
    The same goes for any culture were white skin of a lady had shown her status as higher than the commoners, who work in the field.
    That's another piece of lore Disney didn't consider in the story, just stereotyping them as the "brown poeple". )))

  • @saylosrelyks8645
    @saylosrelyks8645 4 роки тому +13

    I still love this movie and it's better than most of Disney's films, especially more recent ones.

  • @jonlee6774
    @jonlee6774 4 роки тому

    You guys should react to the Train To Busan Presents Peninsula movie trailer. looks crazy good.

  • @michaelcarbone6101
    @michaelcarbone6101 28 днів тому

    Milan fought the original Klingons, not Warf and co.

  • @happyaulakh5436
    @happyaulakh5436 4 роки тому +4

    React to Jackson Wang's '100 ways'

  • @RazvanMihaeanu
    @RazvanMihaeanu 4 роки тому +1

    6:16 Szechuan Sauce!

  • @leosanalien9904
    @leosanalien9904 4 роки тому

    Coding and interpreting is two different processes. If it’s already coded in, then interpreting either way isn’t projecting. But it’s be fun to acknowledge the other point of few.

  • @parsa1372
    @parsa1372 3 роки тому

    Lol they thought the first wave would end :) how cute

  • @ThePinkDragon
    @ThePinkDragon 4 роки тому +2

    Lilo was played by a white child but Nani and David were Hawian or part

    • @alexmag342
      @alexmag342 4 роки тому

      It doesn't really matter as Hawaiians don't really have a distinctive accent

    • @ThePinkDragon
      @ThePinkDragon 4 роки тому

      @@alexmag342 oh

  • @michaelcarbone6101
    @michaelcarbone6101 28 днів тому

    B D Wong, James Hong. I don’t know who else

  • @bamao_light345
    @bamao_light345 4 роки тому

    Its funny how they dont get the szechuan sauce joke

  • @mermidion7552
    @mermidion7552 4 роки тому

    "Mulan isn't gay, She likes Nipples." now thats a funny take on the Trailer i did not expect xD

  • @ClandestineGoose
    @ClandestineGoose 9 місяців тому

    Still my favourite Disney movie

  • @serenityq26
    @serenityq26 4 роки тому +1

    donny osmond only did the singing voice, b.d wong (who is chinese-american) did li shang's singing voice so no, ming na wen is not the only asian voice actor

  • @bomamba9402
    @bomamba9402 2 роки тому

    Scar from Lion King is, like, a gay icon despite not being gay

  • @gmatgmat
    @gmatgmat 4 роки тому +1

    Breakfast at Tiffany's serious miss.

  • @kimberlylatrice1981
    @kimberlylatrice1981 4 роки тому +2

    Straight people never pick up on certain things. It's a typical reaction their having. "Reflection"- man, EVERYTHING about that song and visual sequence was loud and clear for anyone who was LGBTPQA.

  • @legion4162
    @legion4162 4 роки тому

    React to Greenland movie trailer

  • @Darexred
    @Darexred 4 роки тому

    Oh I want to taste that shezwaan sauce

  • @ssumit196
    @ssumit196 4 роки тому

    My 2 bits: Movies like Mulan, Crouching Tiger HIdden Dragon, Slumdog Millionaire are hollywood movies that are made for the american or international audience and not the local audience. I love Mulan and Crouching Tiger but hate Slumdog Millionnaire.
    Unfortunately the producers have to make money through their movies and they have the right to choose 'white' actors or non asian actors if they think that will help.
    I'm a left liberal btw, i would love to see more ethnic , black, lgbtq, asian or other diverse characters.

  • @mjb2187
    @mjb2187 4 роки тому

    hey guys plz react on this song or even the movie trailer , the beautiful artistic dance of rani mukherji of the movie the rising with aamir khan , u reacted on aishwaria and madhuri and priyanka dance before but not on rani she is an excellent dancer

  • @asiran4571
    @asiran4571 Рік тому

    Achara is Thai?

  • @themuffin_man
    @themuffin_man 4 роки тому

    i think a purple three eyed alien should only be voiced by purple three eyed alien if not then cancel it

  • @CondemnedInformer
    @CondemnedInformer 4 роки тому +1

    Yeah, I am not sure bring up 'gay' and 'China' in the same sentence is a good idea. Especially with the CCP.

  • @eduardgherasim2896
    @eduardgherasim2896 4 роки тому

    Guys, Honest Trailers is made a comedy channel so they make fun of everything. Don't look things too deep into it. They even roast their favorite movies.

  • @Zoro.7180
    @Zoro.7180 4 роки тому +1

    @jabykoay plz plz plz.... React to trailer and anime movie. - - - - YOUR NAME - - - 🙁🙁🙁

  • @shudhanshurai5538
    @shudhanshurai5538 11 місяців тому +1

    Original historic tale was much better.

  • @mychanel2887
    @mychanel2887 4 роки тому

    React on Abhishek upmanyu stand up comedy porn

  • @alexmag342
    @alexmag342 4 роки тому +2

    People shouldn't care about race when casting voice actors but which one achieves the intended purpose, in the voice acting world is not that there is discrimination is more like the rest of Hollywood which is very small group of well connected "elitist", the problem isn't discrimination but more as it is "gatekeeping"

    • @ibuprofriends
      @ibuprofriends 4 роки тому +2

      and who is doing the gatekeeping? white people.

    • @gaspenpayne6755
      @gaspenpayne6755 4 роки тому +2

      I don't get it, if the character is black then cast a black person instead of a white person imitating a black guy, that's just weird 😅 it's the same if the character is asian, why you gotta imitate an asian guy instead of just getting an asian? 😅

    • @oduinn7948
      @oduinn7948 Рік тому

      @@gaspenpayne6755 If the character has an accent maybe, but otherwise....? You're just being obtuse. Hire the best person for the job plain and simple. Unless you're saying Blacks must sound a certain way, Asians must sound a certain way, etc etc; if that's the case them you might want to look inwards for a problem rather than outwardly.

    • @stevenviljoen160
      @stevenviljoen160 Рік тому

      Voice actors really should not matter, just the quality of the act.
      There are countles POC playing white characters and vice versa and it should not matter because the ethnicity of the character itself is not changed based on the VA.
      One of my fave examples is Kratos from GOW who is played and always has been by a black guy despite being pale being one of Kratos most defining chararistic.
      Him being pale is a integral part of his character just like black panthers is being african but the VA is extremely good and has always played the character fantastically.

    • @sabin97
      @sabin97 Рік тому

      @@gaspenpayne6755
      the white guy who played apu did an awesome job.
      the white guy who plays cleveland also does an awesome job.
      the WOMAN who plays bart also does an awesome job.
      i think for voice acting you should care less of what an actor looks like(yeah, voice actors dont need to look like the character they are voicing), and more about them sounding the way you want the character to sound.
      their skin tone and genitals should be irrelevant.

  • @pulkitkhosla1488
    @pulkitkhosla1488 3 роки тому

    I love you guys and y'all's videos but I'll have to mention this, queercoding in villains is so so so so so damn common that people don't even catch the code anymore. The people who are, in fact, LGBT+ can easily pick on so much queer coding. and it's almost always the villains.
    But in Mulan, i don't think the queercoding was in her character for even a villain, tbh. in the live action film, the male love interest was shown to be pretty interested in mulan before he even knew that she was a woman, so i think that's where the queer coding comes into the mulan plotline.
    On the other hand, a lot of disney/pixar movies that have characters that have such a song sense of queerness that we just assume they're lgbt and run with it, thought it may technically be projection.
    When it comes to western media, we can't deny how scriptwriters manage to throw in a stereotypical and highkey offensive portrayal of queer identities and actively get away with it.
    (my opinion as a big Disney/Pixar/DreamWorks fan and an out lgbt person)

  • @rajeshbordepatil
    @rajeshbordepatil 4 роки тому

    Hey jaby achara i am watching your videos from years please start watching videos of Sadhguru they are amazing just search sadhguru on youtube

  • @guudnewdle6910
    @guudnewdle6910 4 роки тому

    How did he get such a disturbing laugh? 😥

  • @alexmag342
    @alexmag342 4 роки тому +3

    The "racism" and "discrimination" card can be used against blacks and Asians aswell, white people aren't just one mono culture, Portuguese are not the same as the French and the French are Not the same as the Italians and the Italians are not the same as the Germans and the Germans are not the same as the Greeks and The Greeks are not the same as the English and so on, we are united as being the Heirs of Rome and Hellas and the civilization we forged, the Western Civilization the greatest to ever exist.

    • @ibuprofriends
      @ibuprofriends 4 роки тому

      lmaoooooo

    • @sabin97
      @sabin97 Рік тому

      dont worry, your hegemony is ending.
      and also i just wanna point out that most of "the west" isnt white.
      i say this as a brown westerner.

  • @triggerfairy4070
    @triggerfairy4070 3 роки тому

    This honest trailer did not age well

  • @mysticstrikeforce5957
    @mysticstrikeforce5957 4 роки тому

    This movie is all based on the me to movement not the actual book has they actually said it them self cause really they cut a lot of things off from the movie/books like the guy is not there to give her hopes and dreams and a reality check and the dragon is not even a dragon or talks funny is just a flying bird that just flies. So basically this is just another female empowerment brand to say Asian females can fight to even though we do have lot of famous female chinese fighters but most of them were in jackie chans film. But i actually liked the disney film it made me fall in love with her and have yellow fever.

  • @raghav_kunjunni
    @raghav_kunjunni 4 роки тому +1

    First!!!!!

  • @kannan-sar1758
    @kannan-sar1758 4 роки тому +1

    Wtf is mulan

  • @serenityq26
    @serenityq26 4 роки тому +3

    you dont see it cause you're not a desparate gay disney kid seeking representation. never saw whitelan and never will just looks super boring but the gays love her and say she is a gay icon and the guy bd wong played is supposed to be bi ugh. american gays are so sad. i never needed people to be gay, black or yoruba growing up so why cant yall be self sufficient? i dont get it

  • @michaelcarbone6101
    @michaelcarbone6101 28 днів тому

    Nipples:(y/n)

  • @Zoro.7180
    @Zoro.7180 4 роки тому +1

    @jabykoay plz plz plz.... React to trailer and anime movie. - - - - YOUR NAME - - - 🙁🙁🙁

  • @mychanel2887
    @mychanel2887 4 роки тому

    React to Abhishek upmanyu stand up comedy porn

  • @Zoro.7180
    @Zoro.7180 4 роки тому +1

    @jabykoay plz plz plz.... React to trailer and anime movie. - - - - YOUR NAME - - - 🙁🙁🙁

  • @Zoro.7180
    @Zoro.7180 4 роки тому +1

    @jabykoay plz plz plz.... React to trailer and anime movie. - - - - YOUR NAME - - - 🙁🙁🙁

  • @mychanel2887
    @mychanel2887 4 роки тому

    React to Abhishek upmanyu stand up comedy porn

  • @mychanel2887
    @mychanel2887 4 роки тому

    React to Abhishek upmanyu stand up comedy porn

  • @mychanel2887
    @mychanel2887 4 роки тому

    React to Abhishek upmanyu stand up comedy porn