The Satanic Verses: Dr Ali Ataie
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 сер 2021
- Extract from the video 'The Prophet Muhammad in the Bible with Dr. Ali Ataie' • The Prophet Muhammad i...
Please consider supporting my work on Patreon www.patreon.com/Bloggingtheol...
Paul. through this channel. I was able to defend our prophet (pbuh)against many attempts to accuse of immoral and despicable things by flipping the table on them. they almost never see the point but thank you. you are arming muslims with Useful knowledge.
may Allah be with you on your path.
Aameen
Ameen
How you defend quran? ua-cam.com/video/sdncS-wPafQ/v-deo.html
Im not sure how you flip the table on a man in his 50's having sex with a 9 year child
Brother Paul will be blessed by God. Paul William has been chosen by God to represent and to make it clear with truth to the modern man kind.He is doing God’s work. Thank you Paul have a good day!!! Love you 😘❤️
Two emminent personalites having such beautiful dialogue. My intellect requires more
Brilliant!
Paul, you truly are my new Netflix. I would absolutely love a video, whether it be yourself or an interview like this, where the discussion around Aisha's (may Allah be pleased with her) age is spoken about; so we can move towards ending that particular debate around the Prophet's (pbuh) character once and for all. Thanks again for your channel, from a new revert. :)
Look even if she was 9 does it make a difference, if the bride and groom are happy who are the non believers to object also Hazrat Aisha(RA) was the transmitter of thousands of Hadith which the prophet (pbuh) taught and demonstrated to her. Without her we wouldn't have many Hadith in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim
Dr.Zakir Naik has a video on it please watch it
@@abdullahbukhari1469 Hi! I'm not the one concerned about it - I just really enjoy the way Paul discusses things and feel he is able to speak to a broader audience not just Muslims , which is why I suggested it so others can remove their concerns regarding our Prophet PBUH and be more open to Islam.
@@abdullahbukhari1469 Aisha (RA) is a woman I hold dear to my heart (as all Muslims should) and have no personal "worries" about the age etc, but as someone who is new to Islam, me not understanding the relationship originally is what held me back for a while. I understand your defensiveness but it was merely a request on behalf of others who want more clarity around the situation.
@@thehoneyflower4888salaam sister I appreciate your inquisitiveness and hence I was recommending Dr.Zakir Naik's video he address her age there, let me see if I can find the link
Ali is another level of scholarship. Excellent depth of knowledge.
It is such a delight to tune into Blogging Theology where you get to hear the views and opinions of the finest scholars on religion. My respect for Paul Williams increases with every episode of Blogging Theology I get to watch - what an erudite, open minded, and wonderful human being he is.
❤️
Subscribing to you was the best decision we ever made here on UA-cam 😊. I used to spend more time on tiktok but now I could even enjoy a lengthy video 👍🏻. Thank you for sharing.
Thanks for subbing!
@@BloggingTheology This made my day! Thank you!
ALLAH said"and the man and women who remember ALLAH frequently ALLAH has prepared for them forgiveness and a great reward
Can u explain me the verse
@@nahinzahin8206 please it was and, I hope is good
@@nahinzahin8206 he meant frequently not frequency
Frequently
@Cookiemonster are you another brainwashed lost in the sauce christian? 😂😂😂😂😂
Dr. Ataie is a gem. Well done Paul.
I hope you would release the two hour long talk of this immensely important topic soon
The Imam and one of the biggest Hadith scholars of our time, Al Sheikh Al-Albani has written a book, *entirely* dedicated for this one Hadith, and he showed how weak it was (chain-wise and Matn-wise), highlighting the areas of weakness on multiple hierarchical levels. So I don’t even know why would this be a contention in the first place
Desperation. The enemies of Islam will jump on anything, no matter how false or weak it is. Pathetic really.
Because they can only prey on weak things.
Those who seek to discredit Islam love to qoute this false hadith. People who lack knowledge are often fooled into thinking this hadith is authentic.But the good thing is with videos like this one - both muslims and non-muslims who want to learn the truth with valid references will benefit, Insya Allah.
Those who hate our Deen will find one thing, no matter how weak, and cling on to it. I think the Dr. Presented a great explanation on the issue and should be closed to anyone with logic.
Al albani is not a reference nor an authority in Science of Hadith. He has no isnad.
*It's really a fascinating analysis by dr. Atai. The matter of the pre compositional, compositional, and post compositional context he presented is really remarkable. Also, the fact that Qur'an affirms the apodictic principles of Torah and not necessary the circumstantial laws is really an excellent point. Ironically that's found within torah itself.* *I would like to watch a couple of episodes from him regarding this subject especially about the (Paraclete & and the famous prophecy in Daniel 2.)*
*I really enjoyed watching this. May Allah sw reward you Paul.*
👍❤️
Aameen
Regarding Daniel 2, the word ALLAH will never be erased for His wisdom and might..verse20.
Also, the stone of the kaaba, cut from the mountain not by human hands, will overcome forever all competitors...verse 45.
Thanks Paul for the successful choice of Professor Ali who showed high level of education.
Aslm brother Paul the fact that u had ustadh Ali atai you need a million thumbs up... What a great man may Allah bless both of you and your families
Thank you so much sharing the video may Allah SWT bless you brother🤲❤️
God bless us all...
Hope meeting brother Paul in afterlife... ❤
Obviously in a blessed resting place... Jannah
❤️
Is 72 virgins a weak haddis?
@@bbccnn8836 i think the context of the hadits itself, when jahilliyah asks prophet, he explained it in simple form such as 72 virgins, but to sophisticated scholars he explained them that you cannot ever think what heaven is like
@@bbccnn8836 the same as if ali asks prophet what is the biggest deed, and prophet explain it differently to each shahabah w
Knowing their limitation and capability limitations
@@bbccnn8836 i suggest you watch the YT channel: Marvelous Quran where Dr hany explains 'hoor'. You will not be disappointed inshaAlla.
Love this channel, bless you Paul.
Peace be upon you Paul, I really appreciate your honesty and rationale. May Allah SWT bless you with Iman.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge and just continue on this way. 👍
JazakaAllah Brother Ali Atai and JazakaAllah Brother Paul! May Allah bless you and accept your service. Aameen!
May Allah preserve, bless and give success to Dr ataie and uncle Paul.
A truly outstanding and intoxicating discussion
Thank you very much indeed!
Amazing height of religious and quranic education of Dr. Ali. Great enlightening discussion.
د.علي الطائي اسأل الله ان يزيدك علما وايمانا.
Just because something clashes with something, it does not mean that it did not happen.
I didn't even know about this, I was watching something, and then came across a video of Salman Rushie something like that, I was appalled at some Muslims feeling that their faith was shaking just because this guy wrote this book, someone wrote she read the book and it was utter rubbish. Shukran Paul for this video. As Muslims, we should know that the Holy Quran is protected by Allah and will never be wrong. Allahu Akbar
Dr. Ali Ataie is a gem! Jazaakumullaahu khairan brother Paul
An interesting discussion and expose' on an infamous subject - enjoyed the upload.
Loved the analysis provided by Dr Ali Ataie.
Absolutely fascinating discussion.
I am the man of logic and Dr. Ali Ataie is so logical and reasonable may Allah SWT bless you both
Subhanallah!! Fantastic!! Amazing channel. May Allah Bless u’ll.
*❤️❤️❤️May Allah bless you so much and really appreciate it for beautiful talk ❤️❤️❤️*
When you are upon the truth, you have the entire weight of the truth behind you, and so, you've no need to doubt - as there is only one truth.
Thanks brother Paul and Dr. Ali. Another excellent production and very informative.
Paul, I think this is the fastest-growing Islamic channel on UA-cam. Keep up the great work, akhi.
*_Masha'Allah, Brilliant_*
MashaALLAH outstanding conversation
Masha Allah I like to listen Dr ataia he is a great intellect man with great knowledge in the two Bible tks from somaliland
Ma shA Allah what amount of knowledge Allah gave them
Brilliant
Insightful with a touch of genius
The best explanation on this topic I have heard or read so far
Well done Paul
Thank you Mr. Williams. I found your channel on Instagram. By the first few #shorts, I became committed. I always look up to those who can wed faith and reason, especially at the level of your intellect. Hope more Imams emulate you.
👍❤️
Linguistic miracle of Quran: quran is unique fusion of prose and poetry, a unique literary form unlike anything ever heard by an Arab so they accused prophet of magic
Prophecies of prophet like std, interest being pervelant, khilafah lasting for 30 years etc
Check videos in my playlists for details.
It is not poetry.
More like check my retarded argument about islam
@@craigthebrute8339 yes it another unique literary form
Quran
revealed in Arabic language;
The words of Quran in itself miracle ;unmatched and unrivaled so that its difficult to translate briefly, concisely and perfectly; some good meanings might be lost so that you must refer to the Arabic version of Quran,
Quran ;we only could explain throughout generations not only the first or second generation ; each one word in Quran packed with meanings to bring new meanings and new signs for each generation and everyone !!! uniquely evolving through time of reading ; its miracle in itself!!!!!!!!!
Please read it carefully, thoughtfully more and more!!!!!!!!!
The word Quran means :to be read all over your lifetime patiently and carefully and thoughtfully , even if it is one verse!!!!!! ,
You would discover what will amaze you, and signs that prove Quran revealed from God !!!! So that it called Quran that means to be read carefully time and again to discover new signs and miracles!!!! It's enough for anyone to comprehend one or two Quranic Verses to be reassured that Quran is not the making of a man, or even the whole of mankind together , that is still a standing challenge from Allah to all mankind and Jinn to bring a book like glory Quran!!!!!!!. They could not!!!!
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
قُل لَّئِنِ اجْتَمَعَتِ الْإِنسُ وَالْجِنُّ عَلَىٰ أَن يَأْتُوا بِمِثْلِ هَٰذَا الْقُرْآنِ لَا يَأْتُونَ بِمِثْلِهِ وَلَوْ كَانَ بَعْضُهُمْ لِبَعْضٍ ظَهِيرًا
(سورة الاسراء88)
(chapter no. 17 verse no 88)
"Say :" if mankind and Jinn were together to produce the like of this Qura'n, they could not produce the like thereof, even if they helped one another. "
Quran
have revealed in brief of everything ;the best of ethics,good values, the best stories of wisdom, and history and literature, economy, judgment, future events and references of sciences in sociology, psychology, monuments, geology, oceanic, sea, rivers, topography, cosmology, space, physics, atom, Big bang, black hole stars, climate change and corruption of the planet earth by some of the rich who are excessive in their conducts, countless else to the degree we need thousands of books to explain what in the glory Quran, so that its enough for ordinary people to comprehend one or two verses to be reassured that Quran has been revealed to Muhammad from God (Allah) .
May Allah guide us all to the straight path
Excellent material!!!
Please bring Dr. Shabir Ally one day sir
An intelligent and articulate interviewee
What I expected was the Biblical incident of Jesus alaihisalaam being tempted by Satan to be discussed, also Abraham alaihisalaam being tempted by Satan when about to sacrifice his son Ismail alaihisalaam.
Satan challenging Prophets & Messengers and them overcoming these traps with Allah subhanawataala's support is a recurring theme both in Bible and Quran.
Mashaallah great 👍 May Almighty God bless you both
Paul is blessed by God and he is chosen by God to clear the wrongs and replace the truth to the man kind.He is doing a great 👍 job and God is guiding him. Love your Paul And have a great day 👍 keep on keeping on the truth.☝️😘
Any plan to speak about aya 48:29 from the quran with dr. Ali? Jazaakum Allahu Khayran for all ur work.
The people around the prophet Muhammad SAW weren't blind followers, they understood tawheed better than most men today. They also understood the distinction of the speech of the Quran to anything else they'd heard before. If this happened wouldn't they have noticed, and wouldn't their be hadith about this event from the pov of the companions since it's such a big departure from what was being taught earlier (tawheed). If someone wanted to hide this why would they let some weak hadith go and eradicate all others. If anyone from the people of the book thinks Satan or anything in existence can mimic God, they grossly underestimate the Lord they claim to worship.
Very good point from Dr Ali.wish you have a conversation with Dr Zaid.he was an atheist reverted to Islam.
I've been seeing Ali's lectures for years. Thank you brother Paul for having him as your guest. May the Almighty keep you all healthy and safe
This discussion is awesome
May Allah SWT bless two of you
May Allah bless both of you . Ameen.
Dr Ali Ataie is my new hero. Well done sir! and thank you, Paul.
Intellect at work
Hats off BT as always
May Allah bless you for defending the Quran
Masha Allah good discussion.
A Poem I wrote after watching a blind man on a bus I was on:
Ashamed am I at the sight of a blind man
The world he travels yet I complain about
minuscule issues
All is fine for him but problematic for me.
At least this man has bestowed me the vision of priority
Little are my woes
And so huge is his smile
I will never ever again complain about my life
❤️❤️😪👌🏾
Very informative
May Allah reward you
Great explanation, I never understood why Muslims kept this story alive. I knew the story was false and knew how and why it was wrong but this was really thorough.
جزاكم الله خير الجزاء وبارك الله فيكم وفي أهلكم واموالكم. اللهم امين يارب العالمين.
Ones some bad story is out it always lives among bad people. There no way to terminate them completely.
ما شاء الله محاضرة ممثازة إن شاء الله من ميزان حسناتكما.
Thank you for clearing fog. Lakum deenikum Waliya deen.
They prostrated at the verse of the prostration which is at the end of surah najm. Which says" And prostrate to Allah and worship Him"
Excellent explanation
Glad it was helpful!
Dear Paul Williams:
You are a noble man. The religion of Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ela Al-Islam needs people like yourself who love to explore and present the truth to the worlds.
May Allah bless you and your efforts.
Remember, when you remember Allah, He remembers you; when you walk to Allah, He runs to you.
Mahboob Khan
10:00 yes, this is the most compelling reason to refute the incident altogether, linguistically, it can't pass the " ear" test -
@bloggingtheology can you get in contact with Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl? I’m sure you would have an awesome conversation together.
so there is textual criticism writings. There is 0 external evidence and 0 internal evidence with respect to the story of the satanic verses. thanks Paul . Thank you Dr. Ali you are an outstanding source as Paul said.
Yip, all the evidence that Satan inserted verses into Muhammads' mouth are internal references from Islamic history!.
@@pietjstrydom4467 ha butthurt stickboy..
Clearly next level discussion - beats all those videos of the Park in London where you got these speakers blabbing away and so much nonsense
Excellent!
No one can even come close. The truth and the best sentence said about prophet Muhammad.
It was illuminating though to believe that the Prophet SAWW could have prostrated to the idols is like rejecting everthing Islam stands for and therefore it is absurd. And this Surah, Surah Najam begins with rejecting the possibility of Prophet uttering any thing that is not revealed unto him by the Almighty. Therefore to ascribe insertions by Devil in the same Surah is another oddity. This is not a serious issue but a weapon in the hands of enemies of Islam; albeit a weak weapon. Thank you Paul⚘⚘♥️
MashaAlaah, indeed an outstanding refutation of the reason why prophet Muhammad is the one talked about in the bible. Jazakum Alaahou Khairan brother Paul for bring on Dr Ataie who is extremely knowledgeable about always brings so much more detail to the topic of discussion with an exquisite style of delivery, easy but the same time exciting. May Allah increase you bot in knowledge and grant you the best of this world and the best of the aakhira. I will be watching this video again so as to better appreciate the information.
great great discussion.
Hello, Paul, how can one contact Dr.Ataie. Can you give me his email, please? Thank you.
Ali is way too smart, he owns the Christian faith
anyone have a link for his next vid
Thanks!
Many thanks tash!
Thank you for this very informative interview.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Ali atai is a scholar par excellence....
نربد ترجمة عربية لكل فيديوهاتكم إذا تكرمتم..الترجمة الفورية ليوتيوب ليست متاحة دائما وعادة ماتكون ترجمة سيئة..جزاكم الله خيرا😊
where are the subtitles? :-(
Excellent debate.
BTW, the title used by S.Rushdie has nothing to do with this subject.
You see, the lamp behind Dr. Ali's head (in the mirror) made him look as if his head is shining light like an angel :P
I like the way Br Paul mentions non Muslims with respect .
Thanks Br. Paul .
Loved the reasoning made by Dr Ali athalle to disprove the satanic verses in Quran and also prove the prophecy in Deuteronomy 20 :.18 about Mohamed PUB
Very crafty......you were the first to enslave Africans
Dear paul..
Would u plz explain more about thr history clash between catholic roma n anglican england from the era of Henry VIII?!?! also the massacre of St. Bartolomeus between catholics n huegenots during the wedding of Henry de Bourbon n Marguerite de Valois?!?!
Thx b4.... jazzakallah.. 🙂🙏
الدكتور علي عطية منور والله.
8:57 Didn't they actually prostrated at the last verse saying:
فاسجدو لله واعبدوه
???
And this verse is actually a point of Prostration in tilawah!
yes.
@@syedsaad1594 this Surah is really powerful, especially how it starts and how it ends, they all prostrated, no doubt, they were Arabs and eloquent, if I can feel so much power in those verses, why can't they. SubhanALLAH
Brother Paul have you heard of Sheikh Imran Hosein? I hope one day you get to interview him.
This is unrelated to the topic of the video, but brother Paul, why is your profile picture of Thomas Aquinas? Wasn’t he vile against Islam?
ua-cam.com/channels/_SLXSHcCwK2RSZTXVL26SA.htmlabout
The answer is in the channel description
@@BloggingTheology Thank you my respected teacher. I really appreciate your channel
@@faisal35i92 Thank you for the clarification brother
Surah69 (Al-Haqqa)
[it is] a revelation from the Sustainer of all the worlds. (43) Now if he [whom We have entrusted with it] had dared to attribute some [of his own] sayings unto Us, (44) We would indeed have seized him by his right hand, (45) and would indeed have cut his life-vein. (46) and none of you could have saved him! (47) And, verily, this [Qur’an] is a reminder to all the God-conscious!
I don't know what to write but give me a heart please 😀
Brother want to know about Roman Emperor Heraclius and his notion about prophet Muhammad.
Thankyou
Welcome
Super.
We are maybe missing a very very crucial point here. The chapter called The Star was being revealed, to an audience with makkan pagans. The mentioned star here is SIRIUS. Which has some serious, weighty impact on civilizations in the ancient world from the Egyptians, Dogans in Mali, the far east,, literally everywhere. The star was deified, as a celestial body with supernatural powers that can transcend between realms of men and god. This is one key ingredient to add to the context.
Next,
The chapter mentions the 3 pagan idols and God says that the names are just made up, but acknowledges that people take them to be intercessors and warns against this.
So the context HERE is clearly - addressing polytheism and collectively calling out worshipping of celestial bodies and idolatry but also acknowledging that these supernatural "jinns" do infact exist, and have infact been making an impact on civilizations throughout but now with this guidance this must stop.
One version where Satan adds his own words to the revelation but heard only by the pagans - makes some sense because he wants to have them misunderstand the acknowledgement to be, an acceptance of the deities* and this intentional misleading is something that has happened repeatedly. But not in the sense of putting words in the prophets mouth* because the chapter initially states "the companion speaks only what is revealed to him" and attests to "the prophet witnessed and saw the lords highest signs, will ye not believe him" - therefore it would be a contradiction to say that satan eventually managed to put words in his mouth at the very end of the revelation. Defies logic.
Its very interesting stuff.