Dr. Ali Ataie: Is God Allah?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 гру 2016
- Content Chapters:
0:0:0 Program Introduction (Safir Ahmed)
0:0:49 Quranic Recitation Surah Hashr- Asmal Husna (Ibraheem Naqeeb)
0:05:00 Dean of Faculty Introduction (Safir Ahmed)
0:07:14 Dr Ali Ataie Introduction (Dr. Mark Delp)
0:13:15 Dr Ali Ataie (Bismillah) Is God…Allah?
0:13:40 Linguistic Connections of Allah (Hebrew/Arabic)
0:15:41 History and Description of Allah
0:21:38 Allah Etymology 1(Hebrew/Arabic/Aramaic)
0:26:55 The God of the Semitic People (Is Allah a Moon God?)
0:42:30 Allah Etymology 2(Syriac/Greek)
0:50:25 Is Man God?
01:02:42 Is God our Father?
01:06:17 Allah: God of the Jews, Muslims and Polytheists
01:09:01 What is the Personality of Allah? (Closing Point)
Q/A
01:15:34
Dr. Ali Ataie examines the etymologies and meanings of some of the names of God found in the Hebrew Bible and the Qur'an. His talk attempts to answer: Who is Allah? Do Muslims and Jews (and Christians) worship the same God? What is the greatest name of God? What is the personality of the biblical and Qur’anic God?
Dr. Ali Ataie is a faculty member at Zaytuna College. He has been involved in interfaith activities for over fifteen years. He has been a guest lecturer and guest instructor at several colleges and universities, including Cal Poly State, UC Davis, UC Berkeley, UCLA, Cal State East Bay, and others.
Learn more about Zaytuna College: www.zaytuna.edu
Join our email list for updates on the college, our programs, and events: bit.ly/3aCyBxn
Follow us on social media:
Facebook: / zaytunacollege
Twitter: / zaytunacollege
Instagram: / zaytunacollege
Linkedin: / zaytuna-college
Read articles and papers from our journal, Renovatio: renovatio.zaytuna.edu
Listen to talks and lectures from our scholars: / zaytunacollege
Zaytuna College aims to educate and prepare morally committed professional, intellectual, and spiritual leaders who are grounded in the Islamic scholarly tradition and conversant with the cultural currents and critical ideas shaping modern society.
Give the gift of knowledge: zaytuna.edu/give
With gratitude for your support,
Zaytuna College - Фільми й анімація
Dr Ataie is a gem. He is very funny on top of being the best scholar in the world in his field. May Allah bless him, protect him and spread knowledge through him and his students.
What field.is that?
@@peaceful_warrior7627 comparative theology
Bart Ehrman blows this guy away.
@@busterbiloxi3833 Dr Bart Erhman is not a theologian. He is a philologist. He studies how ancient texts were put together. Dr Ataie knows in detail the knowledge that philologists produce but that's not what he specializes in. He is a comparative theologian. He knows the content of different theologies, their history and meaning. In that field, Dr Ataie is vastly superior to Erhman. Ataie knows ancient Greek, Hebrew, latin and arabic. The different interpretations, schools of thought and the intellectual history of the different religions. So you're comparing two different specialties but in the end Ataie is vastly more knowledgeable that Erhman. Erhman is more well known because he is an not a Muslim, he is an atheist debunking Christian myths. A Muslim comparative theologian cannot be more popular in the US than an atheist philologist that debunks Christian myths.
@@karimb972 Dr. Ataie, an effective polemicist, is a committed Muslim who seeks to prove what he has already concluded based on blind faith. His methods are unsound. The Muslim word needs an Ehrman-type de-bunker, but will never permit it. Instead, the Muslim world assassinates and silences all rational inquiry and legitimate mockery: Rushdie, Mahfuz, Charlie Hebdo. You Muslims threaten violence against unbelievers and your myths are just that: unverified myths.
I wish I have an opportunity to be a student of this great college to study comparative theology. I love Dr Ali
Watch Ali Ataie get proven wrong!
Dr Ataie needs help Isaiah 53
ua-cam.com/video/egSq7nKhaZQ/v-deo.html
Dr Ali Ataie FINDING Muhammad in the Bible
ua-cam.com/video/8TWsUPN6-Is/v-deo.html
Paul Williams Interviews Ali Ataie on Numbers 23:19 God is Not a Man
ua-cam.com/video/vglVtRV1SgM/v-deo.html
Dr Ali Ataie says Muhammad is in the Bible
ua-cam.com/video/8TWsUPN6-Is/v-deo.html
Dr Ali Ataie is wrong.
Dr Ali Ataie is 100% wrong about the Son of Man. Did you notice Dr Ataie jump over Daniel 7:14 clear worship of the Son of Man?
His erudition and eloquence is amazing. Mashallah !
It's a cermon.
This is absolutely awesome The History of Jihad from Mohammed to Isis reveals the truth about Quran Islam Muslims and Muhammad's genocide on civilizations
Allah is the Alias for Muhammad
Marshmallow!
@@busterbiloxi3833 With gelatin or without.
@@syedsalam3199 What?
Boo to who ever gave this or will give it a thumbs down...
Ma'shallah MAY Allah Keep blessing Zaytuna College with great professors and Keep giving Hamza Yusuf the energy to keep doing this beautiful Service to our Young and also too all the Professors at this College and May Allah Protect this College like he has protected His House the Ka'abah
Christian apologists and islamophobes
So after all the intro... the main speaker answers the question in the first five seconds.. class done!
I love Dr. Ali Altaie
I've seen one video of his.. and then became so interested in all his studies and the way he lectures them
May Allah bless him 🙏
Alhamdulillah, when you hear this beautiful knowledge of God, you can't help but have your faith increased, subhanallah!
Very informative lecture by my fave speaker Dr. Ali Al Taie may Allah bless u
I LOVE hearing The Blessed Quran recited in Arabic! Please, which Ayah is being recited?
With all due respect to Dr. Ataie, I don't think we should compromise when it comes to The Trinity. I know full well that it's a "3 in 1" vision of "God" but so are the various Trinitys in Hinduism! In both Christianity and Hinduism, it's putting a "mask" on GOD which should be unacceptable!
MuslimByChoice
Islam means "Peace-Making" and "Muslim means "Peace-Maker" in the Bible. Read the links below:
www.abarim-publications.com/Meaning/Islam.html#.WxwDMkgvyUk
www.abarim-publications.com/Meaning/Meshullam.html#.WxwEPEgvyUk
from reading the comments below - I am certainly unfit to engage in discussion on this - just wanted to say, this is the most intellectually engaging piece I have had the pleasure to watch (or read)... and I spend most of my waking hours for decades reading or watching. Thank you Doc and Zaytuna
This is like a true introduction to have a linguistic view of who GOD is in Greek, Hebrew, and Arabic. Really enjoyed Ali Atai's eye opening lecture. Thanks a million to everyone. Really didnt want comment like others who think they have certain knowledge and that is where they contradict and are ignorant.
Take a Hebrew and Koine Greek course. You will see that Islam is not from God.
Alif lam meem is gibberish and God does not send gibberish.
@@matthewpaulson6497
YOUR comment doesn't come as a surprise at all.
*BY THE FRUITS YE SHALL KNOW THEM*
Thanks to Saul aka Paul the Feroci0us W0LF in SHEEP'S clothing whom Jesus WARNED about, it's Christianity / Christians making a 🚩 *LIAR of Jesus of the Bible* till the end of times. The Bible testifies 🔥
1)
✔️ Jesus: THE FATHER IS THE ONLY TRUE GOD.
✖️ Christians: NO. The Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit (The Trinity) is the true God.
2)
✔️Jesus: NO payment needed, NO Jesus died for us. Just repent sincerely and the Merciful God (THE ONLY TRUE GOD - THE FATHER) forgives.
✖️ Christians: NO. Salvation comes by the blood of Jesus and his dying on the cross
3)
✔️ Jesus: Keep the Laws and the commandments if you want eternal life
✖️ Christians: NO. Eternal life comes by faith in the sacrifice of Jesus
4)
✔️ Jesus: Do NOT neglect even the smallest laws
✖️ Christians: NO. Those laws are unimportant
5)
✔️ Jesus: I was sent ONLY for the lost sheep of Israel
✖️ Christians: NO. Jesus came for us all, Jesus came for all of mankind
*********************
THE ONLY TRUE GOD - THE FATHER, has left the previous scriptures in such a state to expose and destroy EACH and EVERY fundamental doctrine of Christianity or whatever YOU wanna call YOUR faith. Each and every fundamental doctrine of Christianity UNFORTUNATELY is an ABOMINATION to both Jesus as well as THE ONLY TRUE GOD - THE FATHER. The Bible testifies 🔥
*THE ONLY TRUE GOD - THE FATHER has left the previous scriptures in such a state to back up HIS true believers - The Muslim - the TRUE defenders of the true honor and status and doctrine of Jesus AGAINST the falsehoods which UNFORTUNATELY, misguided by false teachers, Christians attribute to Jesus*
THE ONLY TRUE GOD - THE FATHER REVIVED HIS message by sending His Prophet of Deuteronomy 18 V 18-19 Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) - bringing up a nation 1.5 BILLION+ to DEFEND the true honor and status and doctrine of Jesus the Messiah (peace be upon him) against the falsehoods which the Jews as well as the Christians attribute to Jesus.
It's the Brotherhood of Prophethood which the scriptures honor and protect against the lies of the transgressors.
And on the Brotherhood of Prophethood, the chain of Prophethood:
EVEN as per the NT, Jews awaited the arrival of three distinct luminaries. NO WONDER they inquired of John the Baptist:
👉 Are you Elijah?
👉 Are you Christ?
👉 Are you the Prophet?
1) Elijah 👉 John the Baptist (peace be upon him), NOT an incarnation of Prophet Elijah (peace be upon him) BUT in the spirit and authority of Prophet Elijah (peace be upon him)
2) Christ 👉 Jesus (peace be upon him)
3) The Prophet 👉 The Prophet of Deuteronomy 18 V 18-19 Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)
THE ONLY TRUE GOD - THE FATHER has left the previous scriptures with an inbuilt system for course correction or destruction depending upon what someone chooses. Of course the scriptures admonish the deniers who see it right in front but yet deny.
God is an additional and important level of control for gouvernement wno need a additional po psyhological control mechanism to aid mediocracy. Connerie and mediocracy is the hallmark of theology, however much scholarship is utilised!
@@matthewpaulson6497 I recommend that you should watch the video again ..
zaytuna is my favorite college, they teach traditional, classic islam.
Dr. Ali Ataie, Thank you so very much for your excellent and enlightening lecture.
Ali is an asset to Islam. Learnt so much from him over the years
Wow, fantastic discourse!
ما شاء الله
SubhanAllah
Wal hamdulillah
Wa la ilaha illallah
Wallahu akhbar
May Allah SWT guide those who reverted to Islam, to the true teaching of Islam and being obedient Muslims, will grant them and all the Ummah with a place in Jannah.
Aamiin🌙🕌💕
He is reciting powerful verses of the Quran here are the English translation of the verses .
'' If We had sent down this Qur'an upon a mountain, you would have seen it humbled and
coming apart from fear of Allah . And these examples We present to the people that perhaps
they will give thought . He is Allah, other than whom there is no deity, Knower of the unseen
and the witnessed. He is the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful. He is Allah, other than
whom there is no deity, the Sovereign, the Pure, the Perfection, the Bestower of Faith, the
Overseer, the Exalted in Might, the Compeller, the Superior. Exalted is Allah above whatever
they associate with Him. He is Allah, the Creator, the Inventor, the Fashioner; to Him belong
the best names. Whatever is in the heavens and earth is exalting Him. And He is the Exalted in Might, the Wise.''
And surely Allah is our Lord and creator. May Allah guide us all to the right path.
@@ahmedmohamed5146 This Arabic word Allah, is it a proper noun the personal name of the God?
Is the word Allah derived from a root word Alilah?
@@jackjill3205 Tabari Qur'an commentary Volume 1 about Allah, he explains Allah comes from al ilah and the i is dropped and the rest is conjoined to dorm Allah and that ilah comes from alaha meaning God.
@@lakerstekkenn Tabari Qur'an commentary Volume 1, which page and what is the exact wording of his comment?
@@jackjill3205 Just because Allah has it's roots in alaha in Aramaic doesn't prove Muhammad was a true prophet from Yahweh, this is the nice Islamic missionary way to show a connection with the Jewish scriptures and Allahwith Elah but this means nothing at all because they are from the same tribal families, so their languages are similar, Muslims have to actually prove that Muhammad wasn't making stuff up by borrowing from Jewish legends, legends he thought were the true Biblical stories until he found out they weren't that he was told only Jewish legends, then Muhammad started accusing the Jews of deception and writing the scriptures with their own hands.
Muhammad actually failed the Jewish test he was given by the Jews, they wanted to see if he was truthful and asked him certain hidden questions but the answers was in their minds, so if Muhammad was a true prophet receiving divine revelation then Allah would've told Muhammad their secret thoughts answering their questions.
Muhammad answer to the first question, about what the ruach, spirit was revealed in this Quran verse as his answer.
"The spirit," its knowledge is with my Lord; and of knowledge you (mankind) have been given only a Little." (Qur'an 17.85) If We pleased We could take away what We have revealed to you. Then you will not find any one to plead for it with Us, (17.86)
quranx.com/tafsirs/17.85
Strange answer, basically Muhammad said, I don't know, only God knows, then comes the strange threat, instead of answering the question Muhammad answers it with, well I don't know only Allah knows then we could just take away your revelation.
So like any other person who's questioned after making incredible statements, like Gods speaking through me, if they are lying they then can't answer then reply with their mind games plus with threats coming supposedly from God.
Example: I ask someone who's claiming to be in contact with God about Nuclear Physics and they say only God knows then say you try and test God, he will destroy you, these are simple mind games false people play.
The Jews then asked him, who told you this ? Muhammad said Gabriel brought it to me from Allah, then the Jews said this to Muhammad.
They said, `By Allah, no one has told you that except our enemy.
So the Jews said by Allah, whoever told you this is our enemy, so his answer to them was a lie, he didn't have the knowledge to answer a simple hidden question , so they said, whoever brought this answer doesn't know & can't even answer a simple question about the ruach.
This isn't an answer it's a admittance that I have no clue what your talking about because the Jews didn't give him the context of what they were referring to, so Muhammad failed the first question & test, Allah should've known their thoughts, & according to the answer, it was a Qur'an revelation from God but God supposedly says the knowledge is only with my Lord alone.
It's like someone says God's speaking to me giving me revelation and I ask what am I thinking ? and his response is, only God knows what your thinking he's already failed this simple test.
The story goes deeper with the other questions that Muhammad failed to answer even telling them I will tell you tomorrow, then taking 15 days and giving the Jews who asked about Jewish history, Muhammad gives an answer about Christian history or stories from the past Christians were telling about their religion, the people in the cave & the dog but the Jews were not asking a question about Christianity & Christian history but they were asking about the 3 lads in Jewish history their stories but since Muhammad had no clue what he's doing, he's giving Jews Christian stories as his answer.
But you can study it for yourself.
Reason why this Surah was revealed
quran.worldofislam.info/tafsir/ibnkathir_web/18.29908.html?__cf_chl_jschl_tk__=pmd_GBMPnGTMXTP7ndhSP4Pekt2KO96ttFQ9VcJKG1vDQTA-1630096857-0-gqNtZGzNApCjcnBszQiR
May Allah bless Dr. Ali, I'm really impressed & proud. Thank you
Amin
That was an impressive theological und linguistics lesson. Dr Ataie has truly accomplished a masterpiece here.
May Allah SWT increase your knowledge and bless you. Thank for sharing you knowledge.
I can put these talks on while i’m working and get through anything without being bored
You never disappoint! God bless you always 🙏
Ma'shallah Dr. Ali logical explanation through the use of original diction is very impressive. May Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala bless him and extend his knowledge further. Thank you Zaytuna College for introducing such Gems.
Soo impressed by Dr. Ali’s knowledge of divine languages. Languages in which God has communicated with the people through his chosen messengers Moses, Jesus and Mohammad .
I love you because of Allah.
Thanks
Absolutely fascinating ❤️❤️❤️
I thought this was a fair and balanced presentation of a difficult subject for the three great Abrahamic faiths to agree upon - the Q & A session gave the whole thing a nice coda too. Enjoyed the upload, thanks.
Assalamo Alaikum Brother. Love you from India.
REQUESTING you all to do Dawah works continue world wide and Build Islamic Schools to create more and more Zakir Naik and Ahmed Deedats like Islamic preachers to explain Islam betters to non muslims and muslims as well. May Allah Bless and protect you and make Dawah works easy for all Ameen
Mashallah, learned a lot. Certainly Dr Ali is one of those praised by the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh): Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: "If the din were at the Pleiades, even then a person from Persia would have taken hold of it, or one amongst the Persian descent would have surely found it"
Excellent 👍أكرمك الله
Haahahha some Jehovas witness was trying to do the same to me and i used this exact argument and she just wished me a blessed day 😭😭😭
@@heretostay-nv4yw What do you mean by "the same to me" ??
Mashallah great knowledge on the subject.
Amazing I wish I could of attended in person
This is a very beautiful and eloquent explanation, this can destroy anyone's false claims, specially the trinitarian Christians and can be an eye opener to the Jews who are totally oblivious about the truth of the confirmation of the Qu'ran.
Do you know the truth in the Torah in Hebrew not English. Why do we need the Qur'an? What is missing in our scriptures??
Neil Castro *Muslims is this true, if any of it is wrong speak up?*
The word Allah is basic transliteration of the Arabic al-Ilāh, “the God.” Allah is the standard Arabic word for God and is used by Arabic-speaking Christians and Jews as well as by Muslims. The name’s origin can be traced back to the early Semitic writings in which the word for God was il or el, which is also used in the Old Testament.
@@jackjill3205 yes, and you can ask Christians in the Middle East and they say Allah
@@lordrisen3696 " Christians in the Middle East say Allah" do the Jews in the Middle East say Allah?
@@jackjill3205 yes, although they also us their Hebrew name “hashem” but in Arabic they say Allah, the great Maimonides who was a rabbinical Jewish scholar and theologian who praised Muslims and (his creed)was praised by some Muslims like ibn taimiyah and others is actually written in Arabic (his creed) and he was a orthodox jew
I really like sheikh Ali Ataie so much, but his lectures are hardly found.
Knowledge is power ma sha allaah
Ask to answer:
"Knowledge" of this Arabic word Allah, is it Jamid or Mushtaq derived)?
Very wise man ,Mashallah
Wow! Masha Allah. Such a wealth of knowledge. Only if most of these scholars take this route of Dr. Ali, to share the knowledge across instead of being a polemicist, we’d fare much better imo!
Mash Allah his good . May Allah bless him
Beautiful 🥰🥰🥰
Some christian guy was telling me that Elohim is plural which points to the trinity... This video clarifies the royal plural. Pluralis magistatus
Ask them the reason why they don’t translate Elohim into English as Gods since Elohim is in plural.
@@alfapaul5593 no Elohim is singular and it’s Allah / yhw/God of Abraham
keep the good work, you are an asset to all the musilms.
Beshak : Allah is true one god
@13:00 is about where dr.ali begins
Mashallah 💚💚💚
Thank you for sharing your understanding Ali Son of my Lord Jehovah.
Pls do not spell it Jehovah it not Jehovah no one know how to pronounce that just Say God .
We are still educating increasing knowledge , struggling to maintain society in this world of ours.
I would Love to see a respectable debate between Ali and Dr. James White. Jazakh Allahu Khayran
Why? Its obvious trinity is fake...Christians have no right to debate Muslims when Jewish scholars n rabbis have clearly proven how false Christianity is n how badly they translated tanahk
@@kingofdetroit358 What? What DO you mean why? You do not need to answer, I was not talking to you!
@@kingofdetroit358 And who are you to tell who has or has not the right to debate what?..
@@imranlodhi90 Christianity is obviously false...a jew n Muslim debate is better....u probably associate partners to Allah if u think Christianity is ok.
@@imranlodhi90 Allah advised NOT to argue with people of the books ...but to politic in most beautiful way. Truth has been distinguish from falsehood so let people take heed who will ⁉️ WE/Muslims are not even allowed to make fun of or curse pagan gods that we KNOW are false... Why do you think 🤔🤌 that IS ⁉️
As salaamulikum can someone help me with the surah that he recited in the beginning?
end of surh ahasyr
[ Indeed Iam Allah there is no god except me so worship me and establish prayer for my remembrance ] The Holy Quran Chapter 20:14
Slmz tp the organizers of zaytuna college please do a lecture on "how muslims can prove that Allah exist" jzks Muhammed c
Beauty manifests in real Knowledge
At about time 13:02 the Speaker fulfil the truth of we being Children of the One Allah/God and then motivate the truth of his culture by fulfilling the request of the Prophet Muhammed whom wrote the Quran and shared time with Angel Gabriel and asked what they ask us to do before we proceed with the reading of the Quarn. I salute you just for that even if I do not get to watch finish.
At about time 29:50 I do not agree with the comment because I cannot pronounce that because it does not matter to me what matter is what was shared as to how we must live to live with Allah as a one. I am thankful to have found the Prophet Muhammed' writings.
Pls up volume
they definitely got a wireless microphone after this lecture seeing Dr. Ali struggling the whole time 🤣
At time 1: 22:20 The Creator shared himself to us. That which the Creator is we his Creation received or we would have been empty vessel.
At time 34:02 I came across a Bible of around 1962/1952 but it speaks of we must not mistake Sin as a sinful it also speak of Way and Fate that which God is, so I agree Sin is my God when he choose to live with him physical as the ruler with his Children the people.
*Is it correct, that the Arabic عبدالله is vocalized as abdul -llah and not as, abduAllah or AbdAllah, because the word عبد Abd, is followed by a word that has the definite article... الله Allah?*
Etymology
Borrowed from Arabic عَبْدُ ٱللّٰه (ʿabdu llāh, “servant of God”), from عَبْد (ʿabd, “servant”) + اللّٰه (allāh, “God”).
Pronunciation
(US) IPA(key): /æbˈdʌlə/, /ˌɑb.dʊlˈɑ/
Rhymes: -ʊlə
Proper noun
Abdullah
A male given name from Arabic.
A surname, from Arabic.
Usage notes
A common Islamic name that is favored because it indicates servitude and humility before God. According to a hadith, "The most beloved of your names to Allah, the Mighty and Magnificent, are ‘Abdullah’ and ‘Abdur-Rahman’ (servant of the Most Merciful)". The name was also a favorite of the prophet Muhammad.
Not the same name as Abdul.
Abdullah is the primary transliteration of the Arabic given name, Arabic: عبد الله, built from the Arabic words ʿAbd and Allah. The first letter a in Allah in its native pronunciation is unstressed, and is elided following another vowel; in the case of Abdu-llah this is the -u of the Classical Arabic nominative case. It is one of many Arabic theophoric names, meaning servant of God. God's Follower is also a meaning of this name
This is correct, to the best of my knowledge.
@@jackjill3205 I see you have posted many many posts on this thread.
Please post a SEPARATE thread for me and let's discuss this thoroughly with evidences.
Let's see if the Bible really does claim what you say it does.
I'll be waiting :)
At time 1 11 27 balance of truth in Leviticus writing it is found wound for a wound.
[[ HE had a name written that no one knew exept Himself. Who shall not fear You, O LORD, and glorify Your Name ? For YOU Alone Are Holy.]]
The Song of Moses and the Lamb
…2And I saw something like a sea of glass mixed with fire, beside which stood those who had conquered the beast and its image and the number of its name. They were holding harps from God, 3and they sang the song of God’s servant Moses and of the Lamb: “Great and wonderful are Your works, O Lord God Almighty! Just and true are Your ways, O King of the nations! 4Who will not fear You, O Lord, and *glorify Your name?* For You alone are holy. All nations will come and worship before You, for Your righteous acts have been revealed.”… *What is His name?*
@@TruthIsSalvation How do u know this is authentic, plz verify, thx!
Dr Ali is clearly stating that the Tetragrammaton is in the Qur'ān-in Arabic form!
👏
I am sorry here to correct DR Ataie ,,, In Greek you do pronounce ( not Kurios ) but Kirios ,,, For God they say Theos ,, or O Theos , Or gia afton ton Theo ,, But Kirie is for example Sir , Or Gentleman,, , or ( Kirie Matzonakis = Mister Matzonakis ). but in some cases also for God !!! Esselamu aleikum!!!
Bring word-i martyrdom to enter Islam (Allahu ekber ashedü enne ilahe illah and muhammadin rasulural)
15:37 The word in Arabic for God in capital G is الله *Allah*
You can spot an salty evangelical with no qualification yet bent on describing what they can't articulate, this is a sad reality of Christianity and whole of Christianty and this is why churches are empty.
@@codingblues3181 ?
@@jackjill3205 I CHALLENGE YOU TO A DEBATE ON YOUR CLAIMS.
YOU NAME THE FORUM OR PLACE OF DEBATE.
WE CAN POST THE LINK HERE FOR VIEWERS TO WITNESS
@Jack Jill you've spammed this thread with your constant messages.
Let's debate. Any forum.
Full evidences.
Organised and structured.
Let me know.
Thanks.
We can post the link on here.
I'll be waiting....
👍👍👍
Exodus 21:23, “But if any harm follows, then you shall give life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand for hand, foot for foot…if a man strikes the eye of his male or female servant, and destroys it, he shall let him go free for the sake of his eye?”
(I must be rather dumb to think that God would say such a thing about doing revenge)?
For those who do not believe and instead, insult Islam, without studying anything.
Sura 8:61, “But if the enemy incline towards PEACE/Shalom/Salaam, and trust in Allah: for He is the One that hears and knows all things.”
Sura 5:45, The Table Spread: “We ordained for THEM, “Life for life, eye for eye, nose for nose…and wounds equal for equal.” BUT if any one remits the retaliation by way of Charity, it is an act of atonement for himself.”
All traditions do have values to teach us--Quran has complete values and wisdom without pornography or devaluing womanhood or servant hood.
Tough discussion to listen to again and again, MashaAllah. Global peace is as important now than ever before. Do our prospective books and values teach us revenge or mercy, that’s the question. True-that all texts have some degree of violence, even more ancient texts have violence; what is the context? That thought was presented towards the middle half, Alhumdullilah.
JazakAllah Khair, for this discourse.
take what you find good in tradition and leave what you think is misfit. debates end.
The problem is; who determines what is "good" and what is "misfit"? If each and every person was capable of doing that, there would be no need for religions and prophets.
Dr Ali - the Persian - Ataie
I thought he was Arab!
@@fanzy1338 there is 8 million ethnic arabs living in iran
@@Astro-kb7zn Are you sure it’s not 80 million!
@@fanzy1338 i meant ali ataie is an arab
VELIK E
At time 1 14 38for myself I made it easy I take Neighbor as God living in Eden , because Allah separated us by Word according to history of the Holy Bible.
*_26:00_* WOW!
At time 1 16 15 It is unfair for one to loose ones job for such a living truth of our God.
Dr. Michael Heiser is proficient in several ancient Semitic languages. He talks, blogs and lectures about how ancient people used words like "elohim" as their author. One of which I'm reminded of is available on UA-cam: ua-cam.com/video/CDMjxXzCRvw/v-deo.html His views are mainstream scholarship imo.
"He gets gasps from the audience" at 30:46 🤣
At time 49:34 I disagree because it written for us to use the name of God in order to receive God. According to my understanding of our history we each have our own God by name of free choice but we must keep to that name for God as the individual. It is the Way, My God is Kareem for my Lord Jehovah is merciful, gracious and loving to me.
Would like anyone opinion Psalm 22 verses 1 to 26 .Who is speaking ?? Who is writing ? The year it was written ? The year it came to past ? The reason it came to past Isaiah 53 all verses ..There is no religion in this . There is good people in any religion any class of people . All those verses are for all of us no one is good enough .
I’ve been listening to this Brother Dr. Ataie, and I like his exegete. When the sister ask about hip-hop and us calling ourselves god, it’s absolutely true and actual fact. The Black Man is God and Allah Himself is a black man. He was, is and always will be A Man. The Most High God. Can’t go into on this forum but it does warrant discussion
At time 1:18:18 I Abdon Errol agree with you because I Abdon self Worship the Father/God/Allah. Christianity still practice within the church praying to the Son and not the Father as the Son instructed in the Holy Bible text within the New Testament.
Dr Alie i suggest you call CHRISRIAN PRICE for a debate if QURAN is a TRUE BOOK from G-d
Quran is from god
CP has not reached his level yet.
Check my playlist dude
This man is gonna destroy cp
That's the most humiliating thing that profesor Ali can ever do, and I hope he never does it, bcs I am yet to see a man so double faced, double standard, lying and arrogant as Christian Prince on UA-cam . People like him really do not deserve to debate erudites and scholars like doctor Ali. CP should go and debate idk ,,, Mohammed Hijab or smth ,, that's more on his level of insulting people and calling them racist names and what not. But leave profesor Ali out of this "UA-cam missionaries"
So you follow alRazi and Ibn Arabi?
*Muslims is this true, if any of it is wrong speak up?*
The word Allah is basic transliteration of the Arabic al-Ilāh, “the God.” Allah is the standard Arabic word for God and is used by Arabic-speaking Christians and Jews as well as by Muslims. The name’s origin can be traced back to the early Semitic writings in which the word for God was il or el, which is also used in the Old Testament.
@@MAX-tw3qz on your bike *EXIT--->*
@@jackjill3205 if you have arabic to English translation I can answer your questions, reason why I’ll do in arabic I don’t have academic English wish I’m afraid miss the point and I master arabic
Dr. Ali is amazing
At time 30:12 could the Scholar consider this due to Bible text of how God speak of ownership of His possessions he entrust to us. 600 60 6 ( the 60 is a 10% of 600, 6 is 10% of 60 and 600 the beginning.) Our God says everything is His and he gave it to us and just require a 10% return forever from us, and he does not even need it because by degree unto us via The Bible God keeps ten percent of Earth which is the only Heaven for Himself to do with as He left us with the rest to cultivate for our food and home use.
1:17:40 ...open the Qur'an, it's very clear that Muslims worship the God of Abraham. Yes there're differences in the theology. 1:18:06 If by God you mean the Father, Hatheos, the God, Rabb, Rabbul Alamin, yes. But if by God you mean Jesus, then no, we don't worship Jesus.
@Aslan do you, as a Muslim, profess to worship YHWH the one true God worshipped by the Chosen People of the Book?
Aslan do you, as a Muslim, profess to worship YHWH the one true God worshipped by the Chosen People of the Book?
@@jackjill3205
Who is yahweh
Is that another name for god
Where is the evidence for this assertion made by Ali Atai:
15:46 The earliest attestation of the word Allah is in an inscription at Qariyat a FOW in the first century CE.
The way the guy sings in the beginning is just like how Jews read the Torah. It's at least a similar style - granted the notes etc are different. You jacked that from us - no cap
Woah and Apostolic Christians also chant the Psalter and all the other Scriptures 🤯 it's almost as if they share some common traditions
Al ilahu ? Who is ilahu ?
1)Allah 2)Rahman 3)Raheem....
(Bishmillah-ir-Rahaman-ir-Raheem)...
yes or no?
Elohim =GOD and his Angel's
Allahuma =GOD and his community(angels)
Yes or no?
*QUESTION:* The Pagan's lord of the Kāba rebranded by Mohammad as his dreamt up wannabe god coined the name *Allah, what god is that ignorant of* #YHWH, the revealed name of God Almighty revealed to and worshipped by His Chosen People of the Book Bani Israel preferred over the worlds?
You can call God blablubleebloo and if you’re referring to that same one Supreme Being, then you believe in the same God. The words in various languages which are used to refer to Him is irrelevant and meaningless. It’s silly to assume there are separate beings because the words sound different. My daughter can call me ZazaZaxa and I’ll still be her father and she’ll still be my daughter.
Is Elohim, Yahweh, Allah, God, Dios, Shangdi all the same God? It matters what you _mean_ and _who_ you are intending to refer to. The rest is semantics.
Jehovah’s Witnesses play this word game, that if you don’t pronounce “God’s name” accurate you’re actually worshiping another God. As if you turn to God in humility and use the wrong name and wrong phonemes he’ll reject you. Child’s play!
At time 1 00 32 thank you for quote of God' desire spoken through Isaiah. He not want us murdering the animals it is why he need not the blood sacrifice of animal but the sacrifice of us Children that we do keep us from bad deeds.
1:01:10 in my knowledge Jesus is not the only one who was sentenced to death penalty for blasphemy of claiming to be God. Unification with God were also the case with Al Hallaj and Syaikh Siti Jenar. So why this phenomenon happened? AH and SSJ were practicing sufism, and I think it has something to do with it. It is because they already at the awareness that they actually do not exist. The only existence is the existence of God. And it's interesting to know that the word sufi came from the wool garment that Jesus wore; I don't know if this is relevant, but just nice to know.
Read that yes they are the poor ppl who wore wool garments...but rather they were the ones who sat outside the Prophet (saw) house to listen to his lectures/talks..Pls research.
At time 41:02 amen for the truth of our God and our Brother Jesus Christ the Son of Mary, Joseph and God.
A "doctor" in theology said that the Kaaba was built by Abraham and Ismael????😅😅😅
Then u tell me , who build it ?
Muslims say its Abraham, you say its not Abaraham,, so give us a better option ,,, who built it then
And he is right
@@heretostay-nv4yw Abraham never build anything. He lived and was buried in Hebron, which is close to Jerusalem. From Jerusalem to the Kaaba is 1385 kilometers. Ismael was born when he was 87 and he was 100 when Isaac was born.
If Abraham and Ismael build the Kaaba then he was over 100 old !!
Now use your logic:
Why would an old Abraham travelled 1385 km to the land he never been to build the house for God just to leave it there for the pagans and to return back to Hebron to die there??
Abraham is the Father of Jews, then ask yourself, why Jews NEVER go to visit the "house of God " in Mecca built by their grandfather ???
Abraham never built anything. He lived and died in Hebron which is near Jerusalem and is 1385 km away from the Kaaba. He was 87 when Ismael was born and 100 when isaac was born. If Abraham built the Kaaba with Ismael then he was over 100 years old.
Now use your logic:
Why would Abraham traveled 1385 km to the land he never been to build the house for God just to leave it to the pagans and to return back to Hebron???
Also Abraham is the Father of Jews!:Now ask yourself, why Jews NEVER go to Mecca to visit the "house of God " built by their grandfather??
15:37 The word in Arabic for God in capital G is الله Allah
15:46 The earliest attestation of the word Allah is in an inscription at Qariyat a FOW in the first century CE.
18:00 definition of the word Allah
@ Imam Fakhirudeen AlRazi exegesis and philosophers Islamic scholar says the Greatest name of God is HW Huwa
1:26:11 important to make the linguisti connection te ancient Canaanites called god Ayel and they did not worship the Abrahamic God
1:35:40 Human names called the word God
You a Muslim commanded to do Dawah going to the People of the Book and asserting that,
‘The God of their forefathers has sent you to them,’ and they ask you, *‘What is his name?’*
What would you say to them?
Here, reflect on what God said to Moses:
What is the Divine name given to Moses and instructing him to reiterate to the Israelites?
*YHWH or Allah?*
is the God of their forefathers,
the God of Abraham,
the God of Isaac,
and the God of Jacob,
What is the name of the God, who gave you authority to do Dawah to the Israelites, the Chosen People of the Book, bani Israel, preferred over the worldS.
*What is God's own revealed name that is forever, YHWH or Allah?*
*the name God is to be remembered from generation to generation YHWH or Allah?*
which generations are we talking about here? generations of the Israelites or generations of humanity? if of humanity then why didn't he say forever instead? why from generation to generation?
In Quran that is لھُو آسما ال حسنی۔ all the good names are his. people are mistaken in understanding these names as how they have been universalised . each and every name of God is its historical background there is no need for the english people to define God as you would say God every one understands such is الہ for arabs , khuda khudey those words need not be defined In where the word الہ has been used with historical context in such instances the word اللہ has been used in the universal context while those narratives of the extinct people so to know that whatever name they were using for God الہ in arabic and with it Allahاللہ as for the all .
31:17😂😂😂😂😂
What is the original meaning of Allah. even the so called Muslim scholars has no idea of the meaning of Allah , because is not an Arabic language.
that's kind of a stupid question ! no disrespect. Allah is a name, THE name for God. Asking for a definition of that word is the same as asking the definition of God, or what is God, which is something you cannot ever reach a full of understanding of. Watch the video again around 17:00 and reflect on it.
@@n_adoui Allah is not the Name of God, But a title and not an Arabic language. The Muslim scholars has no idea the meaning of Allah, it language and how to pronounced it properly. Incase you don't know the word God has a definition, but because what you don't know is bigger than you and lack of reasoning made you thinks that Question is a kind of stupid. All languages are all originated from Igbo language, written in Igbo consonants, but was vowelized. The Bible was written in original Igbo language, which the first Quran was copied from.
@@gregonwum8813 i told your question is stupid, and you decide to top that !! good job. you proved you did not watch the video, and you know nothing about languages, let's educate you :
- Allah is the name, not a title , stop copying moronic statements from youtube. as an arabic speaker, you would think i know more ! even arab christian and arab jew call God by the name Allah. the translated arabic bible, He is called Allah.
- You do not know the definition of God beyond what he told you about Himself. that's it ! there is no reasoning, or thoughts or conclusions, whatever He told us through his messages that we confirm, anything else is beyond us.
- all languages are definitely NOT from igbo. that stupidest part of your rant. Arabic, like hebrew and aramic (jesus's language) are from the proto semetic, which are from proto-afroasiatic language. The same way, English is from old german which is from proto-indo-european.
- the oldest script from the bible is in greek, and it's probbaly just a translation. we do not know the writers of the bible, nor which language they use, which ironic if you think about it !!!
- and finally, the quran is not copied from the bible. Mohammed was illitrate, and did not speak greek or hebrew, so would need to explain how he got his hands on a bible in the middle of the desert, and how he translated it. also all of things in the quran differs from the bible, and other parts you can find in apocryphal texts, Tanakh, talmud, and many more. so you have a LOT of explaining to do !
educate yourself.
1:06:45 Imam Fakhirudeen AlRazi exegesis and philosophers Islamic scholar says the Greatest name of God is HW Huwa
@@agadirand4four347 child! you dare question your teacher
@@agadirand4four347arguing with yourself about being "dumb" is not going to help you. You are doubting the words of the esteemed Dr. Ali Ataie?
@@agadirand4four347 ask him
off topic but needs attention: Dr. Ali Ataie is a great scholar of Islam and comparative religions: But The Story about Masjid e Aqsa is a made up story by converting the Muslims from within Jews and Christians: to give Jerusalem importance on the same footing as Mecca/Medina representing Toheed. If the Night Journey was relevant to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) then we would have been given clearer understanding of it by the Quran. If the Quran is silent on something then we must take it as wisdom and follow made haidiths: contradicting the Quranic Message.
Not convinced about the night Journey to Jerusalem. The Night Journey mentioned in the Quran means the Hijarat. The Prophet hood of Muhammad (PBUH) was not about Jerusalem: but about Toheed. Moving the Believers away from Jerusalem & its Temples