I love your vlogs exactly as they are. I have had some hectic weeks lately due to life changes and struggles. Also, I have chronic pain, so anytime I see you have a new vlog up I can't wait to pick up a cup of coffee and enjoy the time with you. Although I do not read the same genre of books that you do, my granddaughters (in their 20's and 30's) are very much into this genre so I try to glean information for them, Your videos are visually delightful and so relaxing to watch. They put me in a good mood immediately. Thank you.
oh belinda! you are so kind. thank you so much for the sweetest comment! i’m so sorry to hear about your chronic pain, but it’s an honor to know that my videos can help you feel better in some way 🤍 it’s so thoughtful of you to try and gather information on books that your granddaughters read 🥰 i’m grateful for your presence on here!
I really had been in tough situations in the past few days, thats why i was very sad and anxious then i saw you upload a new video and i thought "finally, i can relax for a little bit" Thank you always for your videos and efforts❤ wish you a good day
I had a realy rough day at my new job. I’m a teacher and started teaching in a new school. And cried so hard during my break because my class did not go well. Your video instantly helps me to calm down and I feel more relaxed now. Thank you so much! 🤎
i am so sorry to hear that! 😢 i am aending you all the love and strength to get through the rest of the week 🤍 i’m so happy to hear that my videos can help in some way! 🥰
I've always loved your vlogs, they're so calming and cozy! 💗 You inspired me to start a reading journal becauseI realized that when I borrow books, I'll probably won't remember my favorite quotes 😅
I could watch you annotate your books for hours, it's so relaxing to annotate / journal along with you! 🙂 the idea with the live annotating video is so brave, I'm way too shy for live videos! 😅I love that your vlogs are longer now - more to enjoy!! The Sword of Kaigen is on my TBR, I will order a copy in winter! (In fall, the focus lies on Tolkien - The Hobbit and LOTR trilogy reread) 🥰 Thank you so much for putting so much effort into your content, next to work and everything!! Have a super cozy Sunday!! 🧡
ahh thank you so much, kat! 🥰 i love hearing that people annotate / journal along with me! 🥹 haha i’m wayyy too shy as well, but hopefully it can be done! it’d be so much fun to annotate together 🥰 your fall tbr sounds very fall indeed! such cozy and atmospheric books 🤍 i cannot wait for you to read The Sword of Kaigen! :) it’s my pleasure to create these videos knowing there are like-minded people like yourself who can enjoy them! 🥹🥹 i hope you have an amazing Sunday too 🤍
Such a cozy and autumn/winter vibes vlog Cath - thank you so much! Loved seeing all the reading and annotating throughout it was so relaxing to watch. Definitely up for an annotating livestream if you ever want to do so - no pressure! 🥰💖💖
Been waiting for this video my whole day and you didn't disappoint 🥰 Now I feel calm and relaxed and can go to sleep thanks to your immaculate cozy vibes 😇
I am finally starting my journey with annotating books😊.. I have never done it before, but watching your and other videos on annotating, I feel quite compelled 😅... the books look much more beautiful and become dearer ❤. Wish me luck and all the best for your house hunting . Hope you soon find what you are looking for💛.
oh that sounds amazing! 🥹 it’s a lot of fun, especially when you’re just starting out! enjoy annotating, it definitely adds more love and character to the book :) and thank you sooo much!! 🤍
I really enjoy watching your videos. I love reading and you inspire me to do something similar. I don’t know if I have time right now because I’m a first year teacher and have little free time. But this is lovely to watch!
I’m so grateful to you for introducing me to new things! Today I tried matcha, houjicha and a full matcha latte with oat milk which was my fave! My first two annotated books were in July by Matt Haig: The Midnight Library and How To Stop Time. I just finished reading The Night Circus which was so fantastic (I never read fantasy only mostly historical fiction) (and will try my hand at annotating it after now) and started The Starless Sea yesterday which is very intriguing only a few pages in! I started a reading journal I put my Goodreads reviews in and decorate it with journalsay products that I love! Thank you so much for your channel and bringing fun things into my life as I am a pre-k teacher and look for ways to give myself self-care to get through the teaching weeks. Thank you again!!!
ahhh yay!! 🥰 i’m so glad you enjoyed the matcha and houjicha latte 🤍 those sound like amazing reads! i read The Midnight Library a couple years ago and really enjoyed it too! I’m so glad you liked The Night Circus :) I can’t wait for you to finish The Starless Sea! and i’m sooo happy you’ve started a reading journal too! it’s so amazing being able to document the books you’ve read in a creative manner ✨ thank you so much for sharing with me! 🥹🤍
I really enjoy your vlogs, it’s so nice and inspiring seeing how you annotate and journal. 😊 I also enjoy chocolate digestives with my tea or coffee while reading. 😀
Lovely vlog as always! I last read The People of Paper more than 15 years ago, and it's still stayed with me! I've been meaning to re-read it as an adult, but it was the first book I ever read (and maybe even piece of media in general) that took the form of the book and used it to also tell the story. Teenage me was blown away!!
"The Starless Sea" is one of my favorite books as well (along with "The Night Circus") so it was fun to see what you had to say about this book. The other books that made me feel as excited about them were "Shadow of the Wind", "Strange the Dreamer", and "The Ten Thousand Doors of January".
i’m so happy to hear that! 🥰 oh yes, Strange the Dreamer was so beautiful and dreamy! i need to pick up The Ten Thouand Doors of January seeing as you enjoyed all the books I enjoyed too 😍😍
Looove your vlogs i usually watch them on a Sunday morning with my coffee for ultimate cozy vibes 😅. Some ideas if you end of reopening your shop; stickers as always like before, post it notes, mini notebooks, bookmarks all with a Cath spin on them stuff for annotating etc.
Please make "read with me" videos. These types of videos really help me to read and sometimes I feel like leaving your video running while I read, but I end up paying attention to the video instead of concentrating on the book
Thank you so much for another gorgeous cosy video, they are such a happy place for me. Thank you for all the time and effort you put into them! I only discovered you after your shop had already closed, so goodness I'm a little bit excited to think it might open again! But of course please only do what is right for you! Also, where did you get that AMAZING Kaz/Inej bookmark! I literally gasped when you showed it haha!
it is my pleasure!! i’m so thankful for your amazing support 🥰🥰 hehe i’m happy for your excitement!! i hope it open up my online shop again very soon 🤍 i’ll need to scour the web for the artist! it’s been a while, but i’ll let you know when i find them 🥰
Hi! I live in Poland and you should totally see our edition of The sword of Kaigen. I am not sure if it is the other special edition as you said but it looks just so beautiful.
omg i just subbed last week and am so excited that you posted a new video!! i’ve been following you on ig for a long time and find your content so inspiring
Hi Cath, I'm from Brazil. and I love your videos. I've seen them all 😅 You could make a video about your favorite books. I would love to see it. hugs ! ❤
I would say that if you’re already experiencing burn out and being anxious about your shop then ease into it and start out just doing what you know. Once you have a reliable supplier and feel it’s going smoothly without adding stress to you, then maybe expand into other areas. Just my feedback.🥰
this is the loveliest feedback 🤍🤍 thank you so much!! i will totally try and ease into this and not go full force all at once. i appreciate your support! 🥹🥹
LOVE, LOVE< LOVEEEE!!! I've been reading lot of Nora Roberts works lately... I'm on to The Circle Trilogy: Morrigan's Cross. I just finished Blue Dahlia the first of the In The Garden trilogy and i really liked it :) Thank you for your beautiful, peaceful videos to add to my Saturday morning. xo (Bookmarks from you would be such a dream!!!!, but obv at your own pace!!) much love
I am getting more into Japanese fiction and excited to see Dead-End Memories! Do you have any suggestions of Japanese fiction you think I should read?? Love your video like always ❤
Hi im a 13 yearl old Honduran who loves your vlogs English is my second lenguage and Spanish is my Native one i dont have lots of books like you but my parents promised to buy me some books from the supermarket (which are on Spanish) Greetings From Cortés,Honduras.
Does anyone know where I can find this copy of The Starless Sea?? 🐝🌊🍯I haven't found this size, and paperback with this cover. I would love a bigger paperback version! 😭
Enjoyed your video very much. Thank you. Love your channel as well. Inspires me to journal and read more often. So thank you dear. Would love stickers from you to add in my journal and bookmarks. 😊 Thanks for a lovely video. 🤎🤎🤎
A nice treat to go with my coffee on a Saturday morning! Fun trivia: ML Wang is about my son's age, and I think she studied at a rival taekwondo school in Madison when my son and I studied and competed. I wonder if they ever fought each other in an open tournament!?
Dear Cath, if your online shop is able to open it'd be amazing (and yes I will take the idea with a grain of salt! :P) Products I'd love are: Bookmarks, Keychains, and maybe tote bags with pockets! and obviously stickers :) Perhaps grid note pads tooo P.S watching this before starting a new work week and flying to Melbourne during mid week which is excitinggg!
hahaha you are always so supportive of my online shop! i appreciate it so much 🥹🤍 ahh such lovely ideas!! thank you so much, i will definitely look into these 🥰 wow that’s so exciting! i hope you have a great time at melb 🫶🏼
Why do you deface your books that way? Books are precious and should be treated as object of respect. Would you buy a book that has been defaced that way?
I love your vlogs exactly as they are. I have had some hectic weeks lately due to life changes and struggles. Also, I have chronic pain, so anytime I see you have a new vlog up I can't wait to pick up a cup of coffee and enjoy the time with you. Although I do not read the same genre of books that you do, my granddaughters (in their 20's and 30's) are very much into this genre so I try to glean information for them, Your videos are visually delightful and so relaxing to watch. They put me in a good mood immediately. Thank you.
oh belinda! you are so kind. thank you so much for the sweetest comment! i’m so sorry to hear about your chronic pain, but it’s an honor to know that my videos can help you feel better in some way 🤍 it’s so thoughtful of you to try and gather information on books that your granddaughters read 🥰 i’m grateful for your presence on here!
Whenever I feel down or unmotivated, I always come to your channel. Thank you for motivating me and make me grateful for little things in life ❤
i’m so happy to hear that! you are very welcome 🥰 sending you lots of love 🤍
I really had been in tough situations in the past few days, thats why i was very sad and anxious
then i saw you upload a new video and i thought "finally, i can relax for a little bit"
Thank you always for your videos and efforts❤ wish you a good day
oh no! i’m sending you lots of love and hugs 🤍 i’m glad my video can help you relax a little bit :) i hope you feel better soon!
❤❤❤❤It's absolutely amazing i am blown away by this video ❤🎉
Your vlogs really help me to calm down after a stressful day
i’m so happy to hear that! 🥰✨
i would loveee it if you made a video on how you annotate your books!!
i’m slowly making a guide for it!! 🥰
I had a realy rough day at my new job. I’m a teacher and started teaching in a new school. And cried so hard during my break because my class did not go well. Your video instantly helps me to calm down and I feel more relaxed now. Thank you so much! 🤎
i am so sorry to hear that! 😢 i am aending you all the love and strength to get through the rest of the week 🤍 i’m so happy to hear that my videos can help in some way! 🥰
Thank you for uploading again. Your videos are part of my glimmers🥰
you’re so kind!! 🥰 it’s my absolute pleasure to make these videos 🤍
I've always loved your vlogs, they're so calming and cozy! 💗
You inspired me to start a reading journal becauseI realized that when I borrow books, I'll probably won't remember my favorite quotes 😅
thank you sooo much!! 🥹 haha i love that for you! reading journals are such a lovely way to document your favorite quotes and themes from a book 🤍
@@cupsandthoughts I hope mine turns out as beautiful as yours! ❤
Literally saved this to watch while I'm cosy in bed❤😂.p.s don't forget to take care of yourself!
haha that sounds super cozy indeed 🥰 definitely! thanks for the reminder 🤍
I could watch you annotate your books for hours, it's so relaxing to annotate / journal along with you! 🙂 the idea with the live annotating video is so brave, I'm way too shy for live videos! 😅I love that your vlogs are longer now - more to enjoy!! The Sword of Kaigen is on my TBR, I will order a copy in winter! (In fall, the focus lies on Tolkien - The Hobbit and LOTR trilogy reread) 🥰 Thank you so much for putting so much effort into your content, next to work and everything!! Have a super cozy Sunday!! 🧡
ahh thank you so much, kat! 🥰 i love hearing that people annotate / journal along with me! 🥹 haha i’m wayyy too shy as well, but hopefully it can be done! it’d be so much fun to annotate together 🥰
your fall tbr sounds very fall indeed! such cozy and atmospheric books 🤍 i cannot wait for you to read The Sword of Kaigen! :) it’s my pleasure to create these videos knowing there are like-minded people like yourself who can enjoy them! 🥹🥹 i hope you have an amazing Sunday too 🤍
I have been waiting for this one to come out... I love your vlogs. I love how calm and cozy they are.
thank you so much!!! i’m glad you’re enjoying the vlogs 🥹🤍
@@cupsandthoughts I always enjoy your vlogs. Also you are very welcome
Such a cozy and autumn/winter vibes vlog Cath - thank you so much! Loved seeing all the reading and annotating throughout it was so relaxing to watch. Definitely up for an annotating livestream if you ever want to do so - no pressure! 🥰💖💖
aww it’s my pleasure! i’m glad you enjoyed it 🥰🤍 i’m happy to hear that!! i’ll need to think about logistics but definitely am up for it too 😍
THE Little Prince and Lovie , Rosie. My favorites books !!!!! ❤❤❤
Been waiting for this video my whole day and you didn't disappoint 🥰 Now I feel calm and relaxed and can go to sleep thanks to your immaculate cozy vibes 😇
aww i’m sooo glad you enjoyed it!! 🥰🥰
I love your vlogs, sooo cozy! I would love to see a bookshelf tour soon ❤
thank you sooo much!! i’ll definitely be filming one soon 🥰
I am finally starting my journey with annotating books😊.. I have never done it before, but watching your and other videos on annotating, I feel quite compelled 😅... the books look much more beautiful and become dearer ❤. Wish me luck and all the best for your house hunting . Hope you soon find what you are looking for💛.
oh that sounds amazing! 🥹 it’s a lot of fun, especially when you’re just starting out! enjoy annotating, it definitely adds more love and character to the book :) and thank you sooo much!! 🤍
Was having a meh day, with things that brought my mood down but your vlogs always help me relax and feel cozy somehow so thank you
i’m sending you lots of love! i hope you’re feeling better 🤍 i’m glad this vlog helped in some way 🥰
I really enjoy watching your videos. I love reading and you inspire me to do something similar. I don’t know if I have time right now because I’m a first year teacher and have little free time. But this is lovely to watch!
thank you so very much! i’m glad you hear that 🥰 i hope you get some free time during school holidays to get some reading done! 🤍🤍
Ohhh the long-awaited Vlog is heree! 🥰♥️ Loved it as always Cath! 🎉
ahhh thank you so so much!! 🥰🤍🤍
I’m so grateful to you for introducing me to new things! Today I tried matcha, houjicha and a full matcha latte with oat milk which was my fave! My first two annotated books were in July by Matt Haig: The Midnight Library and How To Stop Time. I just finished reading The Night Circus which was so fantastic (I never read fantasy only mostly historical fiction) (and will try my hand at annotating it after now) and started The Starless Sea yesterday which is very intriguing only a few pages in! I started a reading journal I put my Goodreads reviews in and decorate it with journalsay products that I love! Thank you so much for your channel and bringing fun things into my life as I am a pre-k teacher and look for ways to give myself self-care to get through the teaching weeks. Thank you again!!!
ahhh yay!! 🥰 i’m so glad you enjoyed the matcha and houjicha latte 🤍 those sound like amazing reads! i read The Midnight Library a couple years ago and really enjoyed it too! I’m so glad you liked The Night Circus :) I can’t wait for you to finish The Starless Sea! and i’m sooo happy you’ve started a reading journal too! it’s so amazing being able to document the books you’ve read in a creative manner ✨ thank you so much for sharing with me! 🥹🤍
All the best who all are giving exams and who re examine never give up keep going keep study hard 📚📄 #study #calm #study hard
I really enjoy your vlogs, it’s so nice and inspiring seeing how you annotate and journal. 😊 I also enjoy chocolate digestives with my tea or coffee while reading. 😀
aww i’m glad you enjoy them 🥰 haha they are my new favorites! 🤍🤍
found my new comfort channel
ahhh thank you 🥹🥹
it's crazy how nobody is talking about the banned ebook Magnetic Aura from Borlest
Why is it banned?
Lovely vlog as always! I last read The People of Paper more than 15 years ago, and it's still stayed with me! I've been meaning to re-read it as an adult, but it was the first book I ever read (and maybe even piece of media in general) that took the form of the book and used it to also tell the story. Teenage me was blown away!!
thank you so much!! 🥰🥰 oh that sounds like an amazing book! u gope it remains special to you even as an adult 🤍🤍
"The Starless Sea" is one of my favorite books as well (along with "The Night Circus") so it was fun to see what you had to say about this book. The other books that made me feel as excited about them were "Shadow of the Wind", "Strange the Dreamer", and "The Ten Thousand Doors of January".
i’m so happy to hear that! 🥰 oh yes, Strange the Dreamer was so beautiful and dreamy! i need to pick up The Ten Thouand Doors of January seeing as you enjoyed all the books I enjoyed too 😍😍
Just the thing I need to wind down after stressing over exams 🫶🍁
hehe glad my videos could help! 🥰🥰
Looove your vlogs i usually watch them on a Sunday morning with my coffee for ultimate cozy vibes 😅. Some ideas if you end of reopening your shop; stickers as always like before, post it notes, mini notebooks, bookmarks all with a Cath spin on them stuff for annotating etc.
ahh thank you so much for watching them 🥰🤍 ooh such great ideas!! thank you for the suggestions ✨
This is so relaxing, I am loving this ☺☺
aww i’m glad you like it! 🥰
Love the teapot!
hehe thanks! ☕️
Hurray! I checked my Phone before getting out of bed, something I rarely do, I saw yourvideo and sprung up to wash my face and make my matcha 😄
hahaha you’re so kind! thank you for the support 🥹🤍🤍
This is just what i needed today… thankyou❤❤
you are very welcome! 🥰🥰
오랜만에 영상보면서 힐링하러왔어요, 여전히 감성적인 영상감사해요💗
thank you for the support! 🥰🥰🥰
i'm sooooo envious of your copy of Dead End Memories by Banana Yoshimoto! I didn't realize she had something new coming out in translation!
i’m sooo grateful and excited!!! i’ve been meaning to read her book 😍
Can we please get a tour of your special edition books 🥺
yes definitely!! once i get it sorted out i’ll have a tour of it 🥰
The perfect thing to wake up to 😌
you’re so kind hehe 🥹🤍
your videos always feel like i'm sitting with a friend.
that’s so sweet!! i’m glad the videos can be of great company 🥰🤍
So relaxing
ahh thank you! :))
@@cupsandthoughts you're welcome
Playing catch up with my UA-cam videos and had to stop and watch your video. Have a great day 😊🪡🧵🤗🤩
Please make "read with me" videos. These types of videos really help me to read and sometimes I feel like leaving your video running while I read, but I end up paying attention to the video instead of concentrating on the book
Thank you so much for another gorgeous cosy video, they are such a happy place for me. Thank you for all the time and effort you put into them! I only discovered you after your shop had already closed, so goodness I'm a little bit excited to think it might open again! But of course please only do what is right for you!
Also, where did you get that AMAZING Kaz/Inej bookmark! I literally gasped when you showed it haha!
it is my pleasure!! i’m so thankful for your amazing support 🥰🥰 hehe i’m happy for your excitement!! i hope it open up my online shop again very soon 🤍 i’ll need to scour the web for the artist! it’s been a while, but i’ll let you know when i find them 🥰
Hi! I live in Poland and you should totally see our edition of The sword of Kaigen. I am not sure if it is the other special edition as you said but it looks just so beautiful.
omg i just subbed last week and am so excited that you posted a new video!! i’ve been following you on ig for a long time and find your content so inspiring
ahh thank you so much!! 🥹🥹
We want a tour of your bookshelves. Pleeeaaaasssseeeee
it is in the works!! 🥰🥰
Hi Cath, I'm from Brazil. and I love your videos. I've seen them all 😅 You could make a video about your favorite books. I would love to see it. hugs ! ❤
I enjoyed watching.❤️😀
Hi Cath 🦋 Your Sword of Kaigen SE is GORGEOUS. 🥰♥️
hello amy! 🥰 ahh it’s a stunning copy indeed!! 🤍
Every relationship needs a person who hates tomatoes and one who eats it for them (my bf if the tomato eater 😂)
it’s a balanced relationship for sure 😂🤍
I would say that if you’re already experiencing burn out and being anxious about your shop then ease into it and start out just doing what you know. Once you have a reliable supplier and feel it’s going smoothly without adding stress to you, then maybe expand into other areas. Just my feedback.🥰
this is the loveliest feedback 🤍🤍 thank you so much!! i will totally try and ease into this and not go full force all at once. i appreciate your support! 🥹🥹
Can you pls make a video how so you film your vlogs? Want to start a UA-cam channel too but don't know how 🥹
Please do a "how to annotate books" ❤
what is that cosy brown fluffy thing you are wearing! It looks so warm!
it’s an Oodie!! 🥰 it’s sooo cozy and warm!
@@cupsandthoughts ooohhhh thanks!!!
LOVE, LOVE< LOVEEEE!!! I've been reading lot of Nora Roberts works lately... I'm on to The Circle Trilogy: Morrigan's Cross. I just finished Blue Dahlia the first of the In The Garden trilogy and i really liked it :) Thank you for your beautiful, peaceful videos to add to my Saturday morning. xo (Bookmarks from you would be such a dream!!!!, but obv at your own pace!!) much love
ps-- Ive been here since you were at 14K subs and its amazing how you're growing!!
I am getting more into Japanese fiction and excited to see Dead-End Memories! Do you have any suggestions of Japanese fiction you think I should read?? Love your video like always ❤
What wallpaper do u use on your desktop? I love it
it’s from Wallpaper Engine on Steam! :) i just search up “pokemon” and this is one of many that came up!
the sword of kaigen broke me
the best books always do 😭😭
Hi im a 13 yearl old Honduran who loves your vlogs English is my second lenguage and Spanish is my Native one i dont have lots of books like you but my parents promised to buy me some books from the supermarket (which are on Spanish) Greetings From Cortés,Honduras.
hi! thank you for watching my vlogs 🥰 that’s so lovely of your parents to do! i hope you enjoy reading them 🤍
Sword of kaigen was a 4 out of 5 for me it’s a good book.
I sooo badly want to read the sword of kaigen !! 📖 📚
oh you shoulddd!! it’s one of my favorite books ever 🥹
I def think you should try live streaming!
Does anyone know where I can find this copy of The Starless Sea?? 🐝🌊🍯I haven't found this size, and paperback with this cover. I would love a bigger paperback version! 😭
I love your volgs! I had a question who is the Author of "No Soul Can Enter Without an Invitation?" I tried to find it online and couldn't. Thank you!
thank you so much! i completely forgot to clarify that in the video 😭 the book is Immortal Dark by Tigest Girma! 🥰
@@cupsandthoughts Thank you! I am excited to read it!
Enjoyed your video very much. Thank you. Love your channel as well. Inspires me to journal and read more often. So thank you dear. Would love stickers from you to add in my journal and bookmarks. 😊 Thanks for a lovely video.
🤎🤎🤎
i’m so glad you enjoyed it!! thank you sooo much for the incredible support 🥹🤍
🌼🧡
💚🖤
A nice treat to go with my coffee on a Saturday morning! Fun trivia: ML Wang is about my son's age, and I think she studied at a rival taekwondo school in Madison when my son and I studied and competed. I wonder if they ever fought each other in an open tournament!?
that sounds lovely indeed! ☕️ and that is such a cool fact!! the combat scenes in her book were very detailed, maybe she’s super experienced herself!
📚🖋️🖊️
😊
What’s that No Soul Can Enter book to the right? I looked it up but it’s nowhere!
sorry! i should have mentioned the title of the book 😅 it’s Immortal Dark by Tigest Girma!
Which mobile phone you use while vlogging ¿
❤🐞❤
What's the title of the book coming out 3rd September?
Immortal Dark by Tigest Girma! 🥰
Dear Cath, if your online shop is able to open it'd be amazing (and yes I will take the idea with a grain of salt! :P)
Products I'd love are: Bookmarks, Keychains, and maybe tote bags with pockets! and obviously stickers :) Perhaps grid note pads tooo
P.S watching this before starting a new work week and flying to Melbourne during mid week which is excitinggg!
hahaha you are always so supportive of my online shop! i appreciate it so much 🥹🤍
ahh such lovely ideas!! thank you so much, i will definitely look into these 🥰
wow that’s so exciting! i hope you have a great time at melb 🫶🏼
I’m a man with lots of testosterone. This is cozy.
haha i’m glad you enjoyed it! 🕯️✨
Please CC😢
Why do you deface your books that way? Books are precious and should be treated as object of respect. Would you buy a book that has been defaced that way?
It’s her book to do what she likes with
You are correct. My apologies to her.