India Underestimating How Much It's a Global Player
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 сер 2024
- Strobe Talbott: India is underestimating the extent to which it is now a global player. It is not just a regional player. There will be a raft of opportunities if American statesmanship is handled properly going forward and if India steps up to the plate and thinks of itself as a major-league world power.
www.brookings.e...
On April 29th, the Asia Society Policy Institute, The India Project at Brookings and McKinsey & Company hosted a discussion examining India's election and the choices that will impact India's political, business, technology, social, cultural and foreign policy spheres and explored the challenges and opportunities facing India outlined in the publication, Reimagining India: Unlocking the Potential of Asia's Next Superpower.
We are not underestimating ourselves, we are geo-political introverts.
ve never heard someone put it this way haha
Nicely put... Ha ha...
your comment makes me feel proud, strangely :)
Thanks everyone :)
chocoboyc And POLITE.
Nobody is nobody's friend !!! Russia or America both have their interests, India should also have it's own.
India is the only country which has friendly relations with
America , russia , saudi , iran and israel
Actually we have friendly relations with every country except Pakistan
We do have our own interest.. We are not like UK for USA...
MrJeek2207 true
Yea brother You are right...
The most sensible comment in the section.
We don't want to be superpower
We don't want to intervene in others internal matters
We just want to give a good life style and security to our people as well as contribute in global betterment
No
It becomes inevitable to compete, super power or ultimate power is not a choice but consequence, no choice there.
Are u the official spokesperson of india?
India as a reluctant world power?
Without a doubt, India is a rising global power, whether or not it wants to be one. Historically, India was a leading naval, military, and economic global power. The superhighway that connected India to the rest of the world wasn't blatant military aggression, colonisation or economic piracy, but the softer, more venerable culture, trade, ethics and religion.
Since time immemorial, the roots of Indian civilization rested on ethics and spirituality. India should reclaim that ancient legacy and light the way forward.
Fair. India's treasure is her Dharma. When she makes 0.1% to represent Dharma internally and internationally, India will be paradise. Just 0.1%
Mohamed ne sahi bola..woh bhi hamara bhai hai
The first long comment that I read till the end. You made my day bro. We want more educated people like you.
@@salonichaudhary276 I want you to know he is not Indian.
Yeah thanks. Jai Shree Ram 🚩
This aged well 😂. Now India is not underestimating anything.
This person literally asking india to participate in dogfight for USA. what they did to pakistan, will never able to do with us. jai hind.
Very true
RAMGOVIND SINGH Pakistan is a prostitute they sleep with anyone who give them money,first time in world that a country become prostitute
@Merika Ramocan bcz that funding is not really to help Kerala...but to alienate it from India
He remembered Manmohan Singh as finance minister but not the prime minister PV Narasimha rao, this is what Congress does injustice to him.
Ehhh India never want to be world super power to begin with...Just trying to make the country n its citizens prospers...
Ehh meehh ahh blahhh
This was 6 years ago. India is now more powerful, bigger and better than ever.
Still the british will beat ur ass no matter how strong I get 🏴🏴🏴🏴
@@mohammedusmanmufti5311☪️ huslims
India must remain introvert for next 15-20 years. India cannot act globally right now. It must be on watch but not so actively involved.
True....once we reach 25-30 TRILLION DOLLAR GDP PPP......we will dominate the world everywhere
@@a.d.7888 yes.. good thing you pointed out 'PPP'
Oops we are getting dragged into geopolitics now... We are staying strong, hope we will continue to be strong 💪
I hope Mr Jayshankar made you realise that India can do it and in a better way than others
What he means: Be an US ally and fight wars with us
When the US falls, the whole world will rejoice. Such is their deadliness.
@@drd.n4695 YES... THIS IS TRUE US WILL FALL FROM SUPER POWER STATUS JUST LIKE UK, FRANCE , USSR AND IT'S TIME FOR NEW SUPER POWERS AS INDIA, CHINA AND BRAZIL
@@drd.n4695 it will be a disaster.
Ever strom leaves an untolled rebuilding growth opportiniuity
For us actually which we never will.
I m from the land of Kamasutra , we can screw in more number of ways than you actually count
i fell from my chair laughing like crazy. lol
eheheh
varun warrior ..and can DEPICT it in stone (KHAJURAHO) ..better than anyone can do with a camera !!
Rolf 😂😂😂😂 i ended up laughing in middle of my journey in a state transport bus 😂😂😂
Ha ha ha. U made my day. ..
i hope most educated indians like myself would understand americans are sefish we should praise their presense until our own needs are prioritised
just like america do it herself
india's lack of centralised power could lead to a easy exploit by americans
bhootpurv manusya yeah but America has proven to be a good ally in history south korea, japan, germany. They turned out to be very well.
lol the list of countries youlisted are just PUPPETS TO THE USA!
True bro
Tanmoy Saikia what about Philippines.
@@alexmercer866 but you know all these countries have American military bases there, which you know... doesn't sound good (・-・;)
With the new leadership in power, india will be relevant to much of the world.
well well here I am afte 8 years..that you were absolutely fn correct
You were absolutely correct bro
This man is a visionary..... After this video was published and the very next month Modi was elected as PM of India.....And whatever he predicted happening exactly the same way today....
After 9 years in 2023 what he said all came true.
There r so much butt hurts...wait for this century end...u will know what is INDIA
Century end is much too much maybe after 10 years India will be superpower.
But before that we need to be careful
@thecrazykdramaaddict carefull in the sense with our economy, naxal people and all othet unnecessary burden
We are " Live happy n let others live happy"
India Would always Remain Neutral. Even if world goes in 3rd and last war.
Yeah, because Pakistan has contained India.
@@saadkhanzada9962 It would be better for Pakistan to not go to any war with India and I definitely know if ww3 begins China will definitely tell Pakistan to somehow drag itself and India into WW.
We will not fight afghans or kill syrian's.
We indian's just want to grow our economy and keep our citizen educated and safe.
To hell with US, we'll never fight US meaningless wars. leave us alone!
This is exactly where you must apply the gentleman's words.
Afghanis are realizing their Hindu heritage: this happened because India is their patron. Use it.
Yes, don't support Syria's destruction. Help Iraq and Syria rebuild their state and see how the entire Middle-East will be eternally grateful to India. The pre-Islamic past will certainly get a boost: this will ground Islam in the Middle-East largely.
Indians, particularly Hindus, never connect the dots.
@@drd.n4695 want to know more in details. Please continue
if the defination of superpower is exploitation. india will become the superpower and change the defination to mutual growth , harmony and mutual welfare of under developed countries, because indian hearts are not just limited to there own welfare , we see every human being as equal irrespective of their colour, beliefs, or economic status.
It took us 8 yrs to realise this
it took right leader we have to make sure that it says the same
US had a peaceful period of over 100 years to mature it's economy and improve the lives of it's people, secluded from the rest of the world and protected by nature with no immediate threat unlike War ravaged European nations, easily accessible Africa, Asian countries... etc
But India does not have that Luxury, so we are purposely playing it down to keep things peaceful.. not yet , not yet. :)
@subhashishbanerjee yep that's right
I am not being an overcompensation,ignorant jackass or anything even close to that,one thing is pretty sure is that if the US wants to stay relevant in its stance as a global superpower it will have to align with India some time in the future,Its not a question of how,but a question of when.
India is a soft power not hard power
I m so eager to hear his views on this topic now....after 5 years ..!
especially now after Russia-Ukraine war
India is county who consistently disappointed to optimists and pessimists.....
India should develop more relations with Russia and Israel.. Americans policy has always been anti India
I think India should focus on domestic issues first. We got mountains of problems here poverty , population, polution, illeteracy,no sport ,poor infrastructure etc etc.
no sport?
Americans are very transactional in their outlook. We will not be able to depend on them despite our shared values of democracy.
Indian cultures teach to be humble and kind so we dont
I hope Mr. Jayshankar will make you satisfied
Why would you attribute a decision like liberalizing an economy exclusively to a finance minister and leave out the Prime Minister? Small detail but gets at the larger American sentiment/psyche vis-a-vis India and Indians.
🇮🇳 ❤️ 🌍
This man like many Americans doesn't know the country he talks about! He described India is a 'developed' country!
I have great respect for India where I visited twice and travelled broadly from south to north. No doubt India has made great stride since ridding of the British Colonialist! But much more hard works still needing attention like poverty, improving the infrastructures and education to the many illiterates. Religion divides between Hindu and Muslim etc etc.
India is a developing country. And yes we have certain issues but we are already working on them since decades, issues like poverty reduction through social welfare, education reforms and various other measures. And there is a lot to catch up as India is too big in terms of population. It’s a continent rather than a country
India is not an Elephant in the world Chess. It's the player itself.
And now India leading G20
Whether we want it or not we will have to play a key role in world politics soon
Every citizens are my brothers and sisters....keep in ur mind and make peaceful and lovable world.this world need that only....
@1:49 so much of india counts as developed world??? even the largest urban centers like Mumbai has 62 % of its population living in slums, name me another major city of a developed country that has 62% of its population living slums. the level of this indian apologist is amazing.
Well, I think the India I live qualifies for the developed world. I dont know about you though
62% in indian tone ( hainggg) dude where have you got your facts :s and btw a house in that slum also cost around a 1CR so bitch plzzz 😏
+prashanth andugulapati kim hong un and his ruling elite lives in North Korea, and their lives qualifies as developed world, thus using your logic North korea must be a developed country
+obsidianstatue 62% ?! That's one out of the 92.5% of all statistics which people just make up ! LOL
obsidianstatue dear, in many developed countries there are slums, most probably of NRI s live in slums and bark at their Indian brethren . yes condition of slums are different at macro levels due to higher participation of govt machinery to push the general civic level. At the micro level they are slum dwellers. Thousands of people live in small cramped rooms, with dirty, bug infested, mattresses and linen, wearing unwashed clothes for days, and cutting each others hair , just because they cannot afford to go to barbers, however walking up nice and clean roads maintained by govt. such a large country yet have so many homeless people, even living in vehicles. social media has opened the pandoras box, please see you tube videos of ' hoarders' and you will se how average people live in western civilisations eg usa
I suppose he would have a different answer now, after seeing 7 years of NDA-II in India as well as the pandemic
Russia Ukraine war
India không nên coi thường, bởi vì ơ thế kỷ này chúng ta phải có tinh thần hợp tác để phát triển
Ấn Độ sẽ được luôn luôn với Việt Nam , trong những ngày tồi tệ , và cũng trong ngày tốt ... :)
We Indians have our own issue of poverty, illiteracy and jobs creation. For example, if we outsource job to every existing European job, we will still need more jobs. We should not start taking sides of powers like USA, Russia which are not reliable allies.
Russia and USA have both been in opposition of One Belt One Road and have changed their stance, undermining Indian interest. Similarly, they forced us to buy less oil from Iran to stop nuclear proliferation, while they have big stocks of weapons to bully the rest.
So, we should focus on creating more jobs in India, making urbanization asap, raising Indian standards. We will face racism, others will say 1/4 or 1/3 Indians are not literate. The Goldman Sachs will not be there to defend us at that time saying a lot of Indians are becoming rich. It's not a lot. Maybe 1/100th are rich enough to even compete with the west. Pool the resources for the betterment of India and its neighbors.
This guy is funny hahaha! Even the blind can see through this man's motive.
Pre 2014 era
absolutely spot on!
we a peaceful country dont want to become a superpower
But now we already are.
+Sanjib Ghosh You said it!!!!!!!! this has been the stance of India from times immemorial
Never, use 1st time last month 2019
Don't mind please
How does one rate India?
I heard & read this in Astronomy. At the event hirizon of a black hole, a person's body gets stretched (to infinity, even) so the feet stretch towards the ground or black body, while the head remains high above in the sky.
India is somewhat in that state. On per capita GDP basis it is a poor country (where a $ goes a long way to feed a poor person in a poorer area for the day), with its statistics aspiring to be a middle income country. India's detractors love to display this part of India's statistics. It is so while India's GDP-PPP (PPP alone matters) is in third place. India ìs a land of extreme contrasts, unlike other country - with both extremes lying side by side. Añy other country can be categorised as rich or poor, intelligent or dumb, peaceful or violent, law abiding or not. India isn't a Commumist country where the population can be steamrolled to fit into one category. Communists in India do participate & get elected in two states to form governments and next time yielding place to extreme right kind of capitalism. In a couple of years India is going to be world's most populous (No.1) country, with 17% of global population. South Asia (India+ Pakistan+ Bangladesh of the erstwhile British-Indian empire) has now about 1.8 billion people as against 1.4 billion in PRC.
Decide !
well-said-sir
US is one country always to be kept at arms length
India has always been a major power. Afghanistan, Pakistan and parts of Iran was India and it was Buddhist India that ruled. This area was also known as Asia Minor. Under India this area was beautiful, rich and peaceful. It was the Indian Prince "Buddha" who colonized the Orient and also the Indo Pacific. India was a non-violent empire. All the teachers of all the faiths are from Asia and it is India that is related to all. The primitive thinking British came in as friends and left India broke, uneducated, and her lands, power divided before India claimed her independence and the "Sun was Set" . If Britain had come in as "true" friends they would still be ruling the world. India has never been conquered. Egotistic primitive invaders and African slaves brought into Asia as hurt but India is still strong. The outside major powers are all about "Power and Greed" that is not India and never should be. India's strength in relations should be inventions, mathematics, sciences. Internally India needs to controlling it's population and getting everyone in India educated. Learn the good things from all the other major power to improve life for the average citizen. India needs to concentrate on it's space program and finding ways to get rid of oil, change ocean water into drinking water and be more business savvy in her inventions. Internally India needs to make India beautiful again, beautiful, clean cities that inspire, make the oceans, skies blue again. India needs to love her children, women with Law and Order. China, Russia have the death penalty for anyone dealing in drugs, India should do the same. 90% of Chinese women know how to play classical piano, India should do the same because it would give something in common with the 50+ European countries that as a global country India needs to do business with. The civilization that understands India will be the first empire since 5000+ years ago to take mankind into the next step in human evolution.
India should not deteriorate her relations with any country just because the west wants her to do so.
Now india is one of the major global player
We r not superpower
On hindsight India overestimates its power and capability.
No buddy we still have many many issues , but we have to show our military power to our neighbors too
Look like he his giving massage on that head 😂😂😂
Seeing it in 2019 oct
not yet India
Revised conditions
01:49 developed
Not anymore
Well, with a 72% literacy rate, I don't think India can be a significant global player.
Well you should litrate yourself . 87.7% indians are highly educated
2011*
well it is 72% of 1.3 billion.
Yeah i think its called '' being a good boy ''syndrome.
Yeah India is a global player in exporting poor labourers. India don't export much of anything else.
Diaspora of Europe, i.e. the Americans are much richer than Indians. Indians are poor.
I agree with Talbott. India does not realise it now but things would change in near future if one whould remember the time during ex-PM Nehru how he would interact with world leaders..
mera Bharat mahan
jai hind
How about classifying us as global servants of humanity
USA has been world police to large extent but they had vested home interest. What is wrong if india's too concentrates on issues of food, clothing, shelter, education and health care for its citizen than international politics. Is it not the duty of a country to target this issues than be major player in the world.
No matter what shi indexes US release, India always top the table in democracy if someone learn to listen to their heart. Skewed biases by those who want to control the world cannot deter this belief of Indians.
Gore matlabi hote hain
Do praise whatever to India but India will never engage itself in the mess created by the US. ...
India knows how to play .....
In diplomacy no country is permanent friend or enemy
It's the country's intrest that's matters the most. ....
What? Did he say India is developed? I heavily disagree on that.
India though very strong today if attacked, still has a subservient mentality and therefore culturally too timid to be a world leader underestimating its own ability and always "bowing " when it comes to eminent confrontation militarily or economically. A sleeping giant that prefers sleeping a bit like the giant sleeping Buddha statues you see in Asia.
Hahaha India has now become a self-claimed super power and developed country. Congrats!
Indian's really underestimate themselves but here America is underestimating india in thinking we will trust them more than china... our relations is all interest based unlike Russia...
Missing Manmohan sir
If that includes attacking Pakistan, I think we are very aligned to the US policy of making war.
Modi is not Lee Kuan Yew , unfortunately.
Yes, because he is Modi.
Indian foreign policy #NAM
India with deal with the world on its own terms, Yes we have enough problem at home and abroad including china challenge.
We need to work with USA.
But USA should be clear that India is not Britain that will follow your policy blindly
Congress was not interested in that we keep an International fora as it wanted to give Kashmir to Pakistan.
Population is the only problem of India
@G Joeye I always think India as one ....north south are just direction... problem is ours we have to solve it
71 bomb huggers disliked this video.
A weak voice from crowd calls out" u can step up to crease heh heh"
Backing fascism not secular india now, usa and ironically israel.
What do u mean? I think you misunderstood crease here is cricket term analogous to plates in baseball.🤨🤔
LMFAO, this guy probably eating his own words today
I would say he would probably feel good on how Modi is realizing his words and Playing the bigger role in India and world.
BBC ' s Ambition to become new Aljazeera
Indousa will be boss upcoming world
Many more a coming required & many more deductions from here & there both
It is a nice way to tell you India is NOT a global player. 🤣
Still Indians compare themselfs with pakisthan. India should works on their poverty and very very poor infrastructure,so it could compare with china in nearby future! Goodluck india.
Edwin we like criticism thanks We are working on infrastructure and education. Yes we should compare our self from china and developed country and thanks for positive criticism.
CHINA ,a major superpower be it economy Militarily terms of everything,yet it says its a developing country.
Its all about politics,India keeps it status like regional power cuz it trades with both Russia and USA.
America can help India in fields of science and technology..We have enough problems with Pakistan itself.If possible stop your funding to radical Christian NGO'S..they are doing enough harm to country
Typical western style of grooming.
GDP IN 2030 - China, 50 trillion, USA, 38 trillion, India, 9 trillion dollars.
Chris D'cruz we are 8+ trillion already if you are counting on PPP terms
+dranzer gigs pagal hai kya kuchh pata bhi hai economics ke bare me ya aise hi like ja rha hai. présent condition pata hai bharat ki
Chris D'cruz maybe you should research well China 50tn in 2030???
hahaha wtf yu'r extremely optimistic now us economy is around 15 trillion $ chinas economy is 6.5 trillion Indias is 2.97 trillion hw can yu aspect to reach to that level in 11 years its copletely paradoxical
We need to choose some side. Capitalism or socialism. Capitalism wins.
great American Dream!! I love America and its culture.