Hey, I'm a Home Fry and I would NEVER argue with you about your heartfelt opinion. I seem to recall that Mark Lowry wrote this song so, obviously, he would sing it with feeling. And Voctave is a group of excellent singers and have a great arranger. To tell a secret, I think this is the best of the three as well, don't let the others know. How great it was is obvious from its ability to render Mortius speechless, that's a true Christmas miracle. Now, as a Home Fry and considering the season, I would be remiss if I didn't suggest you do their rendition of Auld Lang Syne. Just for the harmonies. Here's wishing everyone a better New Year that the last two.
What makes this even more special is that Mark was not able to stand for this performance. Mark was diagnosed with MS a few years ago and it has progressively gotten worse. To the point where he is unable to stand and sing very long. In advanced stages of MS diapragmatic weakness occurs along with speech difficulties. It is truly amazing how long Mark can still hold his notes given his advanced condition and not being able to stand while performing.
I was just going to say that! I was SO emotional hearing this version my first time (still do). My mom was diagnosed with MS the year after he was, and she sang too. Unfortunately, hers affected her singing, and that was her passion. This was her absolute favorite song. She passed away just before Christmas several years ago. My sisters, brother-in-law, daughters, and I sang this at her funeral and now every Christmas as a dedication to her.
I've watched a lot of reaction videos of this song... yours is the best... made me laugh out loud. Did you notice that when Kate goes up high, the basses go down low at the same time?! Hard to hear if you're not wearing headphones. Each member of Voctave is a talented singer in their own right... and together, they are just fabulous!! Jamie can certainly arrange for them... he is a true master arranger! Keep up the great work!!!
This song was my first Voctave experience and it gets me every time! As a soprano, I am so amazed at how she can soar in the clouds so lightly without blasting out everyone with the breath support it must take to sustain her melody. As a Home Fry, I loved hearing the guys with a new arrangement, but this is the best performance.
Mark Lowery wrote the words to this song. I once heard him say that he started thinking about what he would ask Mary if he had gotten a chance to meet her. He said the words just poured out naturally from there! Beautiful! 💖
I just saw your reaction to Home Free's cover, and I went looking through your channel in the hope that you had done a reaction to this version as well. Was not disappointed. Appreciate your analysis, and I'd like to add a bit. That high soprano is Kate Lott, and she is incredible. Her top note in this performance is a beautiful, /background/, G6. I mean sure it's just one moment within the much larger cohesive glory of this performance, but I've never heard of any other singer who could sing that note. Modest number who can legitimately perform a G6, a handful of those who can make it beautiful, but to place it in the background behind a melody that's like two octaves down? Forget about it. And yeah that bell-like resonance is all her - she really is /that/ good. More than half a decade since I first saw/heard this performance, and it still literally takes my breath away. A handful of individually incredible moments within it (eg. Kate's G6 and Mark's long note), but also the overall performance itself. Truly sublime.
I am both a home fry and a pentaholic and this version with Voctave and Mark Lowry has to be the best ever in the world.Also, please check out David Phelps singing oh holy night. Phelps and Lowry used to sing together with the gaither vocal band
Mortius, you can't argue with perfection. The man wrote the lyrics to this song & believes with all his heart & soul. How can anyone compete with that? Mark suffers from MS which is why he's sitting for this performance but you can tell that he feels so truly blessed to be able to sing this for us. To me, it's perfection.
I have found that when the stars are aligned and the performers are of one mind and perfectly attuned to each other, it is a full body experience. No part of your physical or emotional being is left unaffected. I think your looking for the words awe struck! I know I am.
I’ve listened to this probably a hundred times and almost as many reactions. At first, I thought you stopped too much. But after patiently watching your whole video without skipping through your commentary, you have given me a new appreciation for this performance and I hear it in ways I never did before (and I’m a musician). Absolutely phenomenal performance!!! Mark is amazing! Btw, can you believe a fairly popular reactor watched this and actually was like, “meh.” Needless to say, the comments section was blown up lol
Mark Lowry wrote this song believing every word he put to paper. The first time I saw this video I played it over and over and over. I couldn't get enough of the beautiful words and, of course the incredible Voctave.
I turned 70 in May of 2021. I began singing Acapella harmony at about age 4 when my dad taught me both melody and harmony to many of his old Glee club songs. I also sang 5 years in the children’s choir at church and in the Freshmen Choir in High School. When I was 14, Dad started bringing me to his Barbershop chorus shows and District contests. And at 16, I joined his chorus. Today I’m no longer active but a 55-year Life Member, and 1987 International Chorus Champion [as a Tenor with the West Towns Chorus] of the Barbershop Harmony Society [BHS]. I also spent time in the BHS contest judging program. And, I sang in over 60 Barbershop choruses and quartets District contests for over 20 years with one of my quartets finishing as high as 3rd Place. Needless to say, I’m a huge fan of Barbershop Quartets & Choruses. But, I also love of most forms of Acapella - from; the present day Big 3 of Acapella; Pentatonix, Home Free and VoicePlay. To college groups like BYU’s Vocal Point, Noteworthy and the Yale Whiffenpoofs. To Multi-trackers like Sam Robson and Danny Fong. Plus, groups like; Take 6, The Real Group, Singers Unlimited, and so many others including what in my humble opinion is currently THE Greatest Acapella Group on the Planet today - VOCTAVE. That said, here you have just reacted to Voctave’s version of “Mary Did You Know” comparing it with Home Free’s version and found out how good Voctave is. So now I’d like to see your reaction comparing to Voctave’s “O Holy Night” featuring Voctave’s own Tiffany Coburn ua-cam.com/video/2whYdPtH5Ac/v-deo.html . And then check out Voctave’s O Come All ye Faithful featuring Voctave’s own E.J. Cardona ua-cam.com/video/CljN1YIxHiI/v-deo.html
Your reaction was pretty much my reaction the first time I heard this song. Blown away, speechless, repeating certain parts, did I mention speechless? It was incredible! It became my ringtone on my phone for about a year! Lol I didn't care that Christmas had passed, it was that good. Two years later and I'm still crying listening to it. Yep, perfection. ❤
Mark Lowry is a gifted singer, who for many years was the baritone in The Gaither Vocal Band, and in those performances clowning it up with a sternly serious (tongue-in-cheek, of course) Bill Gaither who sang bass. He's got an old-school _legato_ type delivery, very heartfelt quality, musically. He wrote the words to this song, teaming up with Buddy Greene (also a Gaither alum, known affectionately as 'that harmonica guy') on the music. A YT search for videos of both men doing various performances is a rabbit hole well worth the time, plus it gives one a bit of context for where Mark's coming from stylistically here.
Dude... I was COMPLETELY with you... until 18:48!!! As a musician, harmony and ensemble lover.. which arrangement have you heard that comes anywhere NEAR this?! Jamey Rey absolutely nailed this to the CROSS!!!
I was lucky enough to get to perform with Voctave recently at a holiday concert and honestly it is crazy to be able to actually perform with groups like this. They honestly sound just as good live as in recording, including the one piece they did off mic at the very end. It was definitely great to perform with a group like them. They were so professional when working with college and high school musicians that it honestly blew my mind.
Also, Mark Lowry, who has MS, was SEATED for the entire performance. Almost unbelievable task to achieve that sound, volume, & pitch control in a seated position!
I know this reaction is a year old, BUT, you have just become my favorite reactor. I happened upon your channel tonight and I love your enthusiasm, emotions and you are as funny as heck! Mahalo for the clean language...I also get annoyed with pauses and I will stop and go on to something else, but I learned a lot about a capella levels that I never knew before. You have my like and definitely subscribing. Keep up the fantastic work!!!
All 3 are "the best," really. I'm a Pentaholic, enjoy Home Free, love Voiceplay (recent addiction) and had never heard Voctave before, nor Mark Lowry. When I hear the PTX version, I'm blown away by the MUSIC - the harmonies, voices, percussion, perfection. Not to mention the video itself, which is beautifully framed. Home Free is equally good harmonically and musically. I'm not a big fan of country music so I rank them a little behind Pentatonix. But both groups seem to be focusing on making the music as good as they can get it. This version is musically excellent, I'm willing to grant - but it's the FEELING that makes it rank higher than the other two. Like you said, it's got the emotional tug of a real conversation. Mark's voice is interesting, and well suited to bringing in the feels, and that note.... wow. It's not just because he's the author that he owns it (I've heard plenty of originals that either PTX or Home Free has made 100 times better), it's that he means it.
There is always something special when the writer sings a song. I'm glad you caught the conversation tone of the lyrics. Mark wrote it after thinking what if he was sitting with Mary over a cup of coffee. And I don't know if you noticed something. On the line "calm the storm with his hand", most singers emphasize "his" while Mark emphasizes "hand".
Yes! Loved your reaction to this! My brother is a Pentaholic and will always tell me his favorite is their version of this. There is no denying the greatness of their version but this one is just magical and angelic. I love how you mentioned that Voctave knows how and when to shine. There have only been a few reactors to Voctave that I have heard mention their musicianship and professionalism when a soloist is singing. Thank you for mentioning that. Also, near the end of your video you mentioned when you sing what you believe in, people notice and that is part of what makes good music great. I was listening to the Matthew West podcast (who is also a very talented singer and songwriter) and he interviewed Jody McBrayer (who sang with Voctave on Someone Like me from Jekyll and Hyde....this needs your reaction too). They both mentioned that this something that they have noticed throughout the years is that when they really take the words they are singing to heart and truly mean them and believe in them, that's when their listeners notice.
Agree, this is the best version I have heard. Original singer backed by Voctave ... does not get better than this. With Lowry (and Voctave) you really feel the songs emotional element. Lowry, even at this age and stage of life, has a set of lungs to be envied ... that note hold ... wow! Just goes to show that accapella does not always need fireworks ... I get far more from the emotional side of the performance. Voctave are really a slick outfit ... the way they turn towards the soloist (see O'Holy Night and O Come All Ye Faithful). They do all the little things well...
Some of the more impressive is that he also has MS when he sung this and that is why he is sitting. He wrote the words but can’t read music so he had someone else do the original music for it. Now the weird thing with him is that now only is he a great singer but also a comedian. If you ever need a laugh look up some of his stuff with the gaither vocal band not for your channel but personal viewing
I watched several reaction videos to this performance, and yours is one of my favorites. You pointed out things that none of the others did. Thank you for this AND your genuine, speechless reaction to it!
As we hear the last chord the two prominent voices are the mezzo soprano singing the 5th to the tonic key versus the coloratura sound on the 9th to the tonic key. This creates a hollow combination which does, indeed, sound like a glass ringing. Normally we would hear that chord resolve to the tonic in most arrangements of music so we would hardly notice, but this chord is left unresolved and creates so much mystery along with several overtones.
Mortius has malfunctioned !! Greatest reaction yet to this song! Mark wrote this in 1984 and Buddy Greene did the music to it. I 1st heard this song when Mark was in the Gaither vocal band. I've loved the song ever since. Now this version was the best. Voctave sounds like angels singing behind Mark. I saw Mark in concert once, and yes he sang this song. Mark is not only a great singer, but a comedian, minister and songwriter. He wrote this when asked to write a script for a church Christmas play.
And I once heard Buddy Greene say that when he first heard the words, before he wrote the music, and thought, "You say Mark wrote this? This must be stolen!" Which got a huge laugh from the audience
Marks held note is amazing. But after watching several different reactions I am surprised that Kates G 6 near the end of that sustained note seems to be missed. The whole rendition of this is absolutely amazing and I love your reaction. Please keep up the great work!
I'm commenting more to just say... something. But, yeah, the first time I heard this, I was like you: Unable to really experience the music for what they were doing and just experiencing the emotion conveyed; which is impressive for me, as someone who struggles to connect with emotion generally - and I still get chills every time i hear it, although I can now focus more on their technique. I'm so glad you had the same reaction to it as me because I've had this playing whilst friends and family have been in ear shot and they just didn't seem to care about it like we do and i thought i was being stupid or something, like, in my heart, i knew i wasn't, but there's always that doubt, ya know? ... omg... My own choir has done a different arrangement of this, and - without sounding too braggy, we're pretty good - we can't even hold a flickering candle to these guys. My awe is true.
Mortius great reaction. Good to see you so impressed and moved that you have no words. That is a true reaction ! Please Please Please react to their Prince of egypt medley. No video only audio but you will go on an amazing emotional ride, Being alive with David Phelps is also amazing along with someone like you with Jody Mcbrayer. Thank you again for this reaction and Merry Christmas.
@Mortius I have been subscribed to you for several months now. I have to say this is my absolute FAVORITE reaction of yours so far. I agree with you. I cannot think of another performance of this song that comes close to this one. Kudos, man.
This beginning is actually closer to that done by one of the earliest releases, the one by Mark's fellow Gaither Vocal Band alum, Michael English. Way back in the day. Also, those long sustained notes -- they're a big thing in both Southern Gospel (Mark's genre) and barbershop. I've heard some in live performance that make you wonder if they have an extra set of lungs in there somewhere.
Really appreciated the reaction, and your observation this is one where the soloist really directs the message of the song, as appropriate being the writer.
This was something special! We are not angry about your reaction! Each version has it’s special “call” to our soul. I refuse to say one is “better” than the other, they were all great! Thank you for a genuine reaction!
That vocal fumble highlighted at the start of the video, the one he has to replay, I'm pretty sure he was tying to say "emotionally overwhelmed", but mashed the two words together because he was just THAT overwhelmed in the moment. Valid reaction, it's a heart-stirring performance after all, and makes my heart swell every time I listen.
I’ve been watching reaction videos to this performance and your video is the best analysis. You touch on nuances of the arrangement and acknowledge the emotion Mark shows through this performance. Nobody sings the song like Mark does here. You’re right, he really believes what he’s singing and he unabashedly shows it. This is by far my favorite rendition of the song.
great reaction, I waited with anticipation for when Mark held that note! The only reason he is sitting down is because he is ill (MS maybe?) and needs to sit a while. x
🤯🤯🤯 Mortius, you definitely did save the BEST take for last! The Home Free and Pentatonix versions (which I adore equally) take you to Church, but Voctave's rendition with Mark Lowry transport your heart & soul beyond the stratosphere straight to Heaven and the angelic chorus! 🙏😇😇😇🎵🎶💕✨ You absolutely hear and feel it in your gut in Mark's performance that he truly believes and feels every. single. word. Meanwhile, Voctave's backup is so incredibly nuanced yet powerful... Leaves me shaken AND stirred! 🥰😇
So glad you did this cover Mortius! I am a huge Mark Lowry fan and this version gives me chills every time. I love PTX and Home Frees covers too, but I agree Voctave singing with the song’s creator, Mark Lowry, is just perfect. Happy New Years! I so look forward to your 2022 content. ❤️🎶👍
I often struggle putting words, facial expressions, and even sounds to how I feel, even when I listen to this version of this song. You, sir, have given me all of them in this video. I profoundly appreciate and thank you so much for your honesty, vulnerability, and expertise all displayed in this video. Again, thank you.
This is in another dimension! - We are super lucky, proud and humble to be able to listen to the actual co-Author expressing his feeling and emotions the way he intended for us to feel it, surrounded by no other than a chorus of super skilled angels from Voctave! - Enjoy this multiple times and share it! God Bless All....
This performance is a special and unique experience. There is no argument to be had. The ringing at the end was likely a consequence of the over tone series of the lower female parts interacting with the high soprano. Some of the phrasing that Mark uses in this are interesting and different than the basic phrasing that i often hear. A specific example would be 10:41 "will calm the storm, with his hand."
Exactly. Most singers emphasize "his" but Mark always emphasizes "hand". I don't believe in the message, but there is no denying when beautiful music is performed wonderfully.
The song provides a glimpse of Heaven both spiritually & musically. I look forward to singing along with the angels one day! How glorious will that day be? Thanks for the wonderul reaction video, my friend!
Since Mark Lowry is the original lyricist for the song, it's technically not a cover so you don't have to feel bad about ranking it higher than the covers.
Well I found your channel with Bass Gang reactions and have been randomly going back and watching your other videos. This was my favorite reaction of yours by far!!! Thank you for recognizing how it affects music to believe what you are singing.
Ok, I am late to the game on the reaction on this channel. Not one person is commenting that Mark Lowry sat on a G4 for 16 seconds… Before popping up to the Ab4 for a quick second. No one has ever heard Mark sing this high. He normally sings this song a 1/3 lower. I encourage everyone to listen again, but this time instead of the high notes - listen to the bass singers. The foundation they lay, allows all the movement to happen. The basses were intensely incredible.
There are things you can do with an 11 member group that a 5 member group can't compete with. Extra long notes by working in pairs. Half the group supporting a chord and the other half providing movement and many other things. And this group has the chops to do it all very well. I'm a pentaholic, but this group provided a much fuller experience on this song.
At the same time, I don't know how often they'd need to trade off to sustain long notes. There are a number of examples of several of their singers holding notes for a very impressive time. But, if anyone where to be able to trade off on a note without really being noticeable, it would be Voctave, too. :)
Thank you for another great reaction! I don't know if you do reactions to non acapella stuff that is still theater-related, but if you do I would highly recommend "Tough Love" form PattyCake Productions - Written by Voiceplay's percussionist Layne Stein and their former baritone (and current co-owner of the studio) Tony Wakim! It's an original song written for disney villains, and it's incredibly catchy! On the acapella side, I would recommend "Bang!" or "Attention" by VoicePlay - Not enough love out there for the two of them I feel, and while it is pop-music I would be highly interested in your insights of them! Thanks again for amazing reactions and videos this entire year, I've learned a lot from you, laughed a lot with you and smiled a bunch thanks to you! Hope the new year will be good to you!
Is it actually a Cover when the author of the song sings the lead? I dont know. But I have been in the building when Mark sings this song and its is not only special, it us powerful! First time I saw the Gaither Vocal Band with Mark, David Phelps and Guy Penrod, they sang this song and with "Praises of the Lamb" dust shook from the rafters of the coliseum and snowed down on the audience! It was so powerful it rattled the building literally. You dont have to react to it if you dont want to but there is a version of this song with those three that they did outside around a Bonfire and it is oh so powerful!! It is the version from the Video Bill and Gloria Gaither Hawaiian Homecoming. Check it out. But I also agree that this version is one of the Best I've heard! Mark was it his top voice and Voctave was awesome as always! Great job with the reaction. By the way, you expressed the type of afterglow so many others have felt before when Mark sings this song. Not to take away from the others because both Home Free and PTX did great jobs, but there is a difference between singing a song and actually Believing, Feeling, Living the song in your life! Mark above all others delivers that. When he wrote the lyrics he thinking about questions he would ask Mary if she were sitting and talking to him. What was it like to know that the baby in her arms was the living God in flesh? What did she know about what his life would entail? Funny enough, what kind of kid was he? Its an amazing story and hes told at a few times. Thanks again for this reaction.
I’ve loved Mark Lowry since I was like 8 or 9, and this song has been my favorite forever. I actually recorded it for my Granny last year for Christmas and she played it for his mom, who is her friend. This was beautiful
I have had the pleasure of hearing Mark Lowry in person sing his song. Mark has been a member of Bill Gaither's singers twice. He is also a Christian Comedian.
My favorite Christmas video this year, was Home Free: Christmas Ain’t For the Lonely co-written by Tim Foust, for this same reason. There is something so special when songwriters sing their own songs from the heart. Home Free: Warmest Winter (co-written by Austin) had me crying myself to sleep after watching it. 😭. I hope you have seen Warmest Winter, its so special. My favorite video that makes me cry is Chris Rupp featuring Home Free: Movin On. After I saw the Movin On video I immediately became Chris Rupp fan and a Home Fry.
I love the versions by both PTX and Home Free, but this is on a whole nother level. The difference when the soloist believes the words with his whole heart and soul. And of course, Voctave has unmatched vocal qualities.
If you haven't listened to their version of Oh Come All Ye Faithful, don't wait till Christmas. Do it soon. It's amazing. One of the best renditions I have ever heard. EJ Cardona is one of the best voices in acapella music. Easily top five. And he shines in it. It's a must listen to.
Does it really count as a cover when it's Mark Lowrey at the lead? Definitely agree that this one is the best performance wise of the a capella renditions.
As a happy home fry, I enjoy the versions provided by both Home Free and Pentatonix, but neither hold a candle to this performance. This is the version I look forward to each year.
Mortius, I hope you don't take this the wrong way... You are my autistic spirit animal and I love what you do. Keep it up with the reactions, I love the content you put out.
The best version I have heard was performed by Mark Lowry at his concert. This is a great version, but to hear him sing it in person is like nothing else!
I couldn't agree with you less about one statement. This arrangement by Jamie Ray is one of the best choral arrangements ever conceived and written. That, coupled with Voctave, and led by Mr. Lowry, gave us a truly magnificent gift. Comparing Voctave to PTX or VoicePlay or HomeFree is comparing apples to oranges. The amazing beat boxing of the other three is never missed with Voctave - in fact, it would take away from their performance. We're all fortunate to be able to hear all four of these groups in their prime and enjoy their musical talents.
You were hearing DISSONANCE when you talked about the sound glass makes. It's the specific chords they were singing causing it. It's prevalent in most of their music. It's beautifully done and when it resolves...it's like melted butter. 🧈 Drum Corps music is very similar to their style.
Angels singing "The praises of the Lamb" then silence and Mark's soft "Mary did you know" = me reduced to a sobbing puddle. They won Christmas
Hey, I'm a Home Fry and I would NEVER argue with you about your heartfelt opinion. I seem to recall that Mark Lowry wrote this song so, obviously, he would sing it with feeling. And Voctave is a group of excellent singers and have a great arranger. To tell a secret, I think this is the best of the three as well, don't let the others know. How great it was is obvious from its ability to render Mortius speechless, that's a true Christmas miracle.
Now, as a Home Fry and considering the season, I would be remiss if I didn't suggest you do their rendition of Auld Lang Syne. Just for the harmonies.
Here's wishing everyone a better New Year that the last two.
I love HF too, but this is definitely my very favorite!!
What makes this even more special is that Mark was not able to stand for this performance. Mark was diagnosed with MS a few years ago and it has progressively gotten worse. To the point where he is unable to stand and sing very long. In advanced stages of MS diapragmatic weakness occurs along with speech difficulties. It is truly amazing how long Mark can still hold his notes given his advanced condition and not being able to stand while performing.
I was just going to say that! I was SO emotional hearing this version my first time (still do). My mom was diagnosed with MS the year after he was, and she sang too. Unfortunately, hers affected her singing, and that was her passion. This was her absolute favorite song. She passed away just before Christmas several years ago. My sisters, brother-in-law, daughters, and I sang this at her funeral and now every Christmas as a dedication to her.
I just read that his test was negative.
Mark Lowry conceived the song imagining he was sitting down at a table for tea with Mary, and thinking 'what would I ask her?'
I love mark. He was Christians weird al for years.
Not bad for a comedian. Of course, he was also part of the Gaither Vocal Group for many years too. He's extremely talented.
I've watched a lot of reaction videos of this song... yours is the best... made me laugh out loud. Did you notice that when Kate goes up high, the basses go down low at the same time?! Hard to hear if you're not wearing headphones. Each member of Voctave is a talented singer in their own right... and together, they are just fabulous!! Jamie can certainly arrange for them... he is a true master arranger! Keep up the great work!!!
This song was my first Voctave experience and it gets me every time! As a soprano, I am so amazed at how she can soar in the clouds so lightly without blasting out everyone with the breath support it must take to sustain her melody.
As a Home Fry, I loved hearing the guys with a new arrangement, but this is the best performance.
Mark Lowery wrote the words to this song. I once heard him say that he started thinking about what he would ask Mary if he had gotten a chance to meet her. He said the words just poured out naturally from there! Beautiful! 💖
I just saw your reaction to Home Free's cover, and I went looking through your channel in the hope that you had done a reaction to this version as well. Was not disappointed.
Appreciate your analysis, and I'd like to add a bit.
That high soprano is Kate Lott, and she is incredible. Her top note in this performance is a beautiful, /background/, G6. I mean sure it's just one moment within the much larger cohesive glory of this performance, but I've never heard of any other singer who could sing that note. Modest number who can legitimately perform a G6, a handful of those who can make it beautiful, but to place it in the background behind a melody that's like two octaves down? Forget about it. And yeah that bell-like resonance is all her - she really is /that/ good.
More than half a decade since I first saw/heard this performance, and it still literally takes my breath away. A handful of individually incredible moments within it (eg. Kate's G6 and Mark's long note), but also the overall performance itself. Truly sublime.
I am both a home fry and a pentaholic and this version with Voctave and Mark Lowry has to be the best ever in the world.Also, please check out David Phelps singing oh holy night. Phelps and Lowry used to sing together with the gaither vocal band
Mortius, you can't argue with perfection. The man wrote the lyrics to this song & believes with all his heart & soul. How can anyone compete with that? Mark suffers from MS which is why he's sitting for this performance but you can tell that he feels so truly blessed to be able to sing this for us. To me, it's perfection.
I just read the tests were negative. I'm just going to ask him
The high soprano sings the highest note I've heard in any of their videos, a G6 at the climax. Kate Lott is a boss
I have found that when the stars are aligned and the performers are of one mind and perfectly attuned to each other, it is a full body experience. No part of your physical or emotional being is left unaffected. I think your looking for the words awe struck! I know I am.
I’ve listened to this probably a hundred times and almost as many reactions. At first, I thought you stopped too much. But after patiently watching your whole video without skipping through your commentary, you have given me a new appreciation for this performance and I hear it in ways I never did before (and I’m a musician). Absolutely phenomenal performance!!! Mark is amazing!
Btw, can you believe a fairly popular reactor watched this and actually was like, “meh.” Needless to say, the comments section was blown up lol
Mark Lowry wrote this song believing every word he put to paper. The first time I saw this video I played it over and over and over. I couldn't get enough of the beautiful words and, of course the incredible Voctave.
I turned 70 in May of 2021. I began singing Acapella harmony at about age 4 when my dad taught me both melody and harmony to many of his old Glee club songs. I also sang 5 years in the children’s choir at church and in the Freshmen Choir in High School. When I was 14, Dad started bringing me to his Barbershop chorus shows and District contests. And at 16, I joined his chorus.
Today I’m no longer active but a 55-year Life Member, and 1987 International Chorus Champion [as a Tenor with the West Towns Chorus] of the Barbershop Harmony Society [BHS]. I also spent time in the BHS contest judging program. And, I sang in over 60 Barbershop choruses and quartets District contests for over 20 years with one of my quartets finishing as high as 3rd Place.
Needless to say, I’m a huge fan of Barbershop Quartets & Choruses. But, I also love of most forms of Acapella - from; the present day Big 3 of Acapella; Pentatonix, Home Free and VoicePlay. To college groups like BYU’s Vocal Point, Noteworthy and the Yale Whiffenpoofs. To Multi-trackers like Sam Robson and Danny Fong. Plus, groups like; Take 6, The Real Group, Singers Unlimited, and so many others including what in my humble opinion is currently THE Greatest Acapella Group on the Planet today - VOCTAVE.
That said, here you have just reacted to Voctave’s version of “Mary Did You Know” comparing it with Home Free’s version and found out how good Voctave is. So now I’d like to see your reaction comparing to Voctave’s “O Holy Night” featuring Voctave’s own Tiffany Coburn ua-cam.com/video/2whYdPtH5Ac/v-deo.html .
And then check out Voctave’s O Come All ye Faithful featuring Voctave’s own E.J. Cardona ua-cam.com/video/CljN1YIxHiI/v-deo.html
I am a huge Home Fry, and I do love their rendition, but I agree that this is the ultimate version of this song. Mark’s emotion is heart-wrenching.
I sat here and stared waiting for THE NOTE and your reaction to it and your face did not disappoint! Thank you for this amazing reaction!
Your reaction was pretty much my reaction the first time I heard this song. Blown away, speechless, repeating certain parts, did I mention speechless? It was incredible! It became my ringtone on my phone for about a year! Lol I didn't care that Christmas had passed, it was that good. Two years later and I'm still crying listening to it. Yep, perfection. ❤
Mark Lowry is a gifted singer, who for many years was the baritone in The Gaither Vocal Band, and in those performances clowning it up with a sternly serious (tongue-in-cheek, of course) Bill Gaither who sang bass. He's got an old-school _legato_ type delivery, very heartfelt quality, musically. He wrote the words to this song, teaming up with Buddy Greene (also a Gaither alum, known affectionately as 'that harmonica guy') on the music. A YT search for videos of both men doing various performances is a rabbit hole well worth the time, plus it gives one a bit of context for where Mark's coming from stylistically here.
Dude... I was COMPLETELY with you... until 18:48!!! As a musician, harmony and ensemble lover.. which arrangement have you heard that comes anywhere NEAR this?! Jamey Rey absolutely nailed this to the CROSS!!!
I was lucky enough to get to perform with Voctave recently at a holiday concert and honestly it is crazy to be able to actually perform with groups like this. They honestly sound just as good live as in recording, including the one piece they did off mic at the very end. It was definitely great to perform with a group like them. They were so professional when working with college and high school musicians that it honestly blew my mind.
I was front row at one of their concerts and their off mic performance at the end was my favorite!
Also, Mark Lowry, who has MS, was SEATED for the entire performance. Almost unbelievable task to achieve that sound, volume, & pitch control in a seated position!
I know this reaction is a year old, BUT, you have just become my favorite reactor. I happened upon your channel tonight and I love your enthusiasm, emotions and you are as funny as heck! Mahalo for the clean language...I also get annoyed with pauses and I will stop and go on to something else, but I learned a lot about a capella levels that I never knew before. You have my like and definitely subscribing. Keep up the fantastic work!!!
All 3 are "the best," really. I'm a Pentaholic, enjoy Home Free, love Voiceplay (recent addiction) and had never heard Voctave before, nor Mark Lowry. When I hear the PTX version, I'm blown away by the MUSIC - the harmonies, voices, percussion, perfection. Not to mention the video itself, which is beautifully framed. Home Free is equally good harmonically and musically. I'm not a big fan of country music so I rank them a little behind Pentatonix. But both groups seem to be focusing on making the music as good as they can get it.
This version is musically excellent, I'm willing to grant - but it's the FEELING that makes it rank higher than the other two. Like you said, it's got the emotional tug of a real conversation. Mark's voice is interesting, and well suited to bringing in the feels, and that note.... wow. It's not just because he's the author that he owns it (I've heard plenty of originals that either PTX or Home Free has made 100 times better), it's that he means it.
There is always something special when the writer sings a song. I'm glad you caught the conversation tone of the lyrics. Mark wrote it after thinking what if he was sitting with Mary over a cup of coffee.
And I don't know if you noticed something. On the line "calm the storm with his hand", most singers emphasize "his" while Mark emphasizes "hand".
I noticed that. Interesting.
You're unfettered enthusiasm and sheer delight ecstasy was exquisite to watch! Thoroughly and rapturing and enjoyable! I needed this Thank you!😊😂❤
you know its a good cover when you are rendered dumfounded and speachless and close to crying (or in my case crying like a baby XD)
Yes! Loved your reaction to this! My brother is a Pentaholic and will always tell me his favorite is their version of this. There is no denying the greatness of their version but this one is just magical and angelic.
I love how you mentioned that Voctave knows how and when to shine. There have only been a few reactors to Voctave that I have heard mention their musicianship and professionalism when a soloist is singing. Thank you for mentioning that.
Also, near the end of your video you mentioned when you sing what you believe in, people notice and that is part of what makes good music great. I was listening to the Matthew West podcast (who is also a very talented singer and songwriter) and he interviewed Jody McBrayer (who sang with Voctave on Someone Like me from Jekyll and Hyde....this needs your reaction too). They both mentioned that this something that they have noticed throughout the years is that when they really take the words they are singing to heart and truly mean them and believe in them, that's when their listeners notice.
Agree, this is the best version I have heard. Original singer backed by Voctave ... does not get better than this. With Lowry (and Voctave) you really feel the songs emotional element. Lowry, even at this age and stage of life, has a set of lungs to be envied ... that note hold ... wow! Just goes to show that accapella does not always need fireworks ... I get far more from the emotional side of the performance. Voctave are really a slick outfit ... the way they turn towards the soloist (see O'Holy Night and O Come All Ye Faithful). They do all the little things well...
Some of the more impressive is that he also has MS when he sung this and that is why he is sitting. He wrote the words but can’t read music so he had someone else do the original music for it. Now the weird thing with him is that now only is he a great singer but also a comedian. If you ever need a laugh look up some of his stuff with the gaither vocal band not for your channel but personal viewing
my favorite is Heart Surgery 🤣🤣🤣
I watched several reaction videos to this performance, and yours is one of my favorites. You pointed out things that none of the others did. Thank you for this AND your genuine, speechless reaction to it!
As we hear the last chord the two prominent voices are the mezzo soprano singing the 5th to the tonic key versus the coloratura sound on the 9th to the tonic key. This creates a hollow combination which does, indeed, sound like a glass ringing. Normally we would hear that chord resolve to the tonic in most arrangements of music so we would hardly notice, but this chord is left unresolved and creates so much mystery along with several overtones.
I have been singing for over 50 years, with some truly wonderful conductors, and never heard anyone discuss a chord like you did. Awesome. Thank you.
That final soprano crystalline note was provided by Kate Lott.
Home fry here: I totally agree, this was the BEST performance.
This is beyond what words could hope to describe. Hands down probably my favorite acapella performance that I have seen thus far.
Your excitement to this video is exactly what I feel everytime I hear this song.
Mortius has malfunctioned !! Greatest reaction yet to this song! Mark wrote this in 1984 and Buddy Greene did the music to it. I 1st heard this song when Mark was in the Gaither vocal band. I've loved the song ever since. Now this version was the best. Voctave sounds like angels singing behind Mark. I saw Mark in concert once, and yes he sang this song. Mark is not only a great singer, but a comedian, minister and songwriter. He wrote this when asked to write a script for a church Christmas play.
And I once heard Buddy Greene say that when he first heard the words, before he wrote the music, and thought, "You say Mark wrote this? This must be stolen!" Which got a huge laugh from the audience
Marks held note is amazing. But after watching several different reactions I am surprised that Kates G 6 near the end of that sustained note seems to be missed. The whole rendition of this is absolutely amazing and I love your reaction. Please keep up the great work!
One of the most articulate & genuine Voctave reactions out there. Great video! 🙏
The best React/Analysis!!! Learned so much, Thank you.
I'm commenting more to just say... something. But, yeah, the first time I heard this, I was like you: Unable to really experience the music for what they were doing and just experiencing the emotion conveyed; which is impressive for me, as someone who struggles to connect with emotion generally - and I still get chills every time i hear it, although I can now focus more on their technique. I'm so glad you had the same reaction to it as me because I've had this playing whilst friends and family have been in ear shot and they just didn't seem to care about it like we do and i thought i was being stupid or something, like, in my heart, i knew i wasn't, but there's always that doubt, ya know? ... omg... My own choir has done a different arrangement of this, and - without sounding too braggy, we're pretty good - we can't even hold a flickering candle to these guys. My awe is true.
Mortius great reaction. Good to see you so impressed and moved that you have no words. That is a true reaction ! Please Please Please react to their Prince of egypt medley. No video only audio but you will go on an amazing emotional ride, Being alive with David Phelps is also amazing along with someone like you with Jody Mcbrayer. Thank you again for this reaction and Merry Christmas.
@Mortius I have been subscribed to you for several months now. I have to say this is my absolute FAVORITE reaction of yours so far. I agree with you. I cannot think of another performance of this song that comes close to this one. Kudos, man.
This beginning is actually closer to that done by one of the earliest releases, the one by Mark's fellow Gaither Vocal Band alum, Michael English. Way back in the day. Also, those long sustained notes -- they're a big thing in both Southern Gospel (Mark's genre) and barbershop. I've heard some in live performance that make you wonder if they have an extra set of lungs in there somewhere.
Really appreciated the reaction, and your observation this is one where the soloist really directs the message of the song, as appropriate being the writer.
They are all great renditions in their own right. Sometimes there is no better, just equal. All three of these acapella groups blow me away.
Great reaction sir! About the same as my own the first time I heard this. It really does take you on an emotional journey whether you will or not.
This was something special! We are not angry about your reaction! Each version has it’s special “call” to our soul. I refuse to say one is “better” than the other, they were all great! Thank you for a genuine reaction!
That vocal fumble highlighted at the start of the video, the one he has to replay, I'm pretty sure he was tying to say "emotionally overwhelmed", but mashed the two words together because he was just THAT overwhelmed in the moment. Valid reaction, it's a heart-stirring performance after all, and makes my heart swell every time I listen.
I’ve been watching reaction videos to this performance and your video is the best analysis. You touch on nuances of the arrangement and acknowledge the emotion Mark shows through this performance. Nobody sings the song like Mark does here. You’re right, he really believes what he’s singing and he unabashedly shows it. This is by far my favorite rendition of the song.
This rendition gave me goosebumps. Ty Mortius, you are such an amazing analyst, I love you!
great reaction, I waited with anticipation for when Mark held that note! The only reason he is sitting down is because he is ill (MS maybe?) and needs to sit a while. x
Yeah he has MS
🤯🤯🤯 Mortius, you definitely did save the BEST take for last! The Home Free and Pentatonix versions (which I adore equally) take you to Church, but Voctave's rendition with Mark Lowry transport your heart & soul beyond the stratosphere straight to Heaven and the angelic chorus! 🙏😇😇😇🎵🎶💕✨ You absolutely hear and feel it in your gut in Mark's performance that he truly believes and feels every. single. word. Meanwhile, Voctave's backup is so incredibly nuanced yet powerful... Leaves me shaken AND stirred! 🥰😇
So glad you did this cover Mortius! I am a huge Mark Lowry fan and this version gives me chills every time. I love PTX and Home Frees covers too, but I agree Voctave singing with the song’s creator, Mark Lowry, is just perfect. Happy New Years! I so look forward to your 2022 content. ❤️🎶👍
If you looked at the sheet music of the complex harmonies you’d be impressed! Voctave are truly master singers!❤️
I often struggle putting words, facial expressions, and even sounds to how I feel, even when I listen to this version of this song. You, sir, have given me all of them in this video. I profoundly appreciate and thank you so much for your honesty, vulnerability, and expertise all displayed in this video. Again, thank you.
You can see why this is my favorite! But I think you should look at the composition. I think it is the best arrangement as well.
This is in another dimension! - We are super lucky, proud and humble to be able to listen to the actual co-Author expressing his feeling and emotions the way he intended for us to feel it, surrounded by no other than a chorus of super skilled angels from Voctave! - Enjoy this multiple times and share it! God Bless All....
This is my favorite version of Mary Did you know
I don't know how I missed this one two years ago! Glad I circled back around to this. I love that sound of ringing glass at the end.
This performance is a special and unique experience. There is no argument to be had.
The ringing at the end was likely a consequence of the over tone series of the lower female parts interacting with the high soprano.
Some of the phrasing that Mark uses in this are interesting and different than the basic phrasing that i often hear. A specific example would be 10:41 "will calm the storm, with his hand."
Exactly. Most singers emphasize "his" but Mark always emphasizes "hand".
I don't believe in the message, but there is no denying when beautiful music is performed wonderfully.
The song provides a glimpse of Heaven both spiritually & musically. I look forward to singing along with the angels one day! How glorious will that day be? Thanks for the wonderul reaction video, my friend!
I truly don't hear the things you point out until you do so. You are amazing.
As the lyricist, Mark knew not to enunciate the ‘his’ before ‘hand’ in the first verse. His delivery was so very personal.
Since Mark Lowry is the original lyricist for the song, it's technically not a cover so you don't have to feel bad about ranking it higher than the covers.
I'm a huge Home Free fan and I absolutely agree THIS arrangement and overall musicality is better hands down. It's shear perfection.
So right! Voctave is the best out of all of them tbh
Well I found your channel with Bass Gang reactions and have been randomly going back and watching your other videos. This was my favorite reaction of yours by far!!! Thank you for recognizing how it affects music to believe what you are singing.
Ok, I am late to the game on the reaction on this channel. Not one person is commenting that Mark Lowry sat on a G4 for 16 seconds… Before popping up to the Ab4 for a quick second. No one has ever heard Mark sing this high. He normally sings this song a 1/3 lower. I encourage everyone to listen again, but this time instead of the high notes - listen to the bass singers. The foundation they lay, allows all the movement to happen. The basses were intensely incredible.
There are things you can do with an 11 member group that a 5 member group can't compete with. Extra long notes by working in pairs. Half the group supporting a chord and the other half providing movement and many other things. And this group has the chops to do it all very well.
I'm a pentaholic, but this group provided a much fuller experience on this song.
At the same time, I don't know how often they'd need to trade off to sustain long notes. There are a number of examples of several of their singers holding notes for a very impressive time. But, if anyone where to be able to trade off on a note without really being noticeable, it would be Voctave, too. :)
Thank you for another great reaction! I don't know if you do reactions to non acapella stuff that is still theater-related, but if you do I would highly recommend "Tough Love" form PattyCake Productions - Written by Voiceplay's percussionist Layne Stein and their former baritone (and current co-owner of the studio) Tony Wakim! It's an original song written for disney villains, and it's incredibly catchy!
On the acapella side, I would recommend "Bang!" or "Attention" by VoicePlay - Not enough love out there for the two of them I feel, and while it is pop-music I would be highly interested in your insights of them!
Thanks again for amazing reactions and videos this entire year, I've learned a lot from you, laughed a lot with you and smiled a bunch thanks to you! Hope the new year will be good to you!
It's ok to just feel. We want to experience this performance with someone who gets it.
This is 100% the best. The emotion behind this.
One milion of thumbs upe to this reaction, i love Voctave, and now, your job here on youtube, keep doing this great job.
What a glorious reaction 👍😃. From another necktie lover in UK. 🇬🇧
Mark Lowry is unbelievable & the saprano took it to heaven.
Is it actually a Cover when the author of the song sings the lead? I dont know. But I have been in the building when Mark sings this song and its is not only special, it us powerful! First time I saw the Gaither Vocal Band with Mark, David Phelps and Guy Penrod, they sang this song and with "Praises of the Lamb" dust shook from the rafters of the coliseum and snowed down on the audience! It was so powerful it rattled the building literally. You dont have to react to it if you dont want to but there is a version of this song with those three that they did outside around a Bonfire and it is oh so powerful!! It is the version from the Video Bill and Gloria Gaither Hawaiian Homecoming. Check it out. But I also agree that this version is one of the Best I've heard! Mark was it his top voice and Voctave was awesome as always! Great job with the reaction. By the way, you expressed the type of afterglow so many others have felt before when Mark sings this song. Not to take away from the others because both Home Free and PTX did great jobs, but there is a difference between singing a song and actually Believing, Feeling, Living the song in your life! Mark above all others delivers that. When he wrote the lyrics he thinking about questions he would ask Mary if she were sitting and talking to him. What was it like to know that the baby in her arms was the living God in flesh? What did she know about what his life would entail? Funny enough, what kind of kid was he? Its an amazing story and hes told at a few times. Thanks again for this reaction.
I loved watching you react to this incredible performance, God Bless You. This is the first time I ever watched you and it will not be the last!!!
Another reactor timed that note, it’s just shy of 25 seconds. Amazing
I’ve loved Mark Lowry since I was like 8 or 9, and this song has been my favorite forever. I actually recorded it for my Granny last year for Christmas and she played it for his mom, who is her friend. This was beautiful
I totally agree with your analysis...truly made me cry! Thank you. Twin Dragon ^_^
This version of this song is just plain magic.
I have had the pleasure of hearing Mark Lowry in person sing his song. Mark has been a member of Bill Gaither's singers twice. He is also a Christian Comedian.
My favorite Christmas video this year, was Home Free: Christmas Ain’t For the Lonely co-written by Tim Foust, for this same reason. There is something so special when songwriters sing their own songs from the heart. Home Free: Warmest Winter (co-written by Austin) had me crying myself to sleep after watching it. 😭. I hope you have seen Warmest Winter, its so special. My favorite video that makes me cry is Chris Rupp featuring Home Free: Movin On. After I saw the Movin On video I immediately became Chris Rupp fan and a Home Fry.
We are not worthy of this cover. Nuff said! Thanks for the reaction 😊
Had to watch this again. Love your enthusiasm!
I love the versions by both PTX and Home Free, but this is on a whole nother level. The difference when the soloist believes the words with his whole heart and soul. And of course, Voctave has unmatched vocal qualities.
If you haven't listened to their version of Oh Come All Ye Faithful, don't wait till Christmas. Do it soon. It's amazing. One of the best renditions I have ever heard. EJ Cardona is one of the best voices in acapella music. Easily top five. And he shines in it. It's a must listen to.
Does it really count as a cover when it's Mark Lowrey at the lead? Definitely agree that this one is the best performance wise of the a capella renditions.
I can‘t wait for your reaction to „O Come, All Ye Faithful“. 😂
As a happy home fry, I enjoy the versions provided by both Home Free and Pentatonix, but neither hold a candle to this performance. This is the version I look forward to each year.
Spot on! Well done!
It is truly the most beautiful song of mother and child.
U had the exact same reaction I had 2 this it's just beautiful
Mortius, I hope you don't take this the wrong way... You are my autistic spirit animal and I love what you do. Keep it up with the reactions, I love the content you put out.
The best version I have heard was performed by Mark Lowry at his concert. This is a great version, but to hear him sing it in person is like nothing else!
This is what you call "Anointed"
I couldn't agree with you less about one statement. This arrangement by Jamie Ray is one of the best choral arrangements ever conceived and written. That, coupled with Voctave, and led by Mr. Lowry, gave us a truly magnificent gift. Comparing Voctave to PTX or VoicePlay or HomeFree is comparing apples to oranges. The amazing beat boxing of the other three is never missed with Voctave - in fact, it would take away from their performance. We're all fortunate to be able to hear all four of these groups in their prime
and enjoy their musical talents.
You were hearing DISSONANCE when you talked about the sound glass makes. It's the specific chords they were singing causing it. It's prevalent in most of their music. It's beautifully done and when it resolves...it's like melted butter. 🧈 Drum Corps music is very similar to their style.
You sing what you feel....This I've been doing singing in a barbershop chorus for the last 42 years.