Nirmala Sitharaman's Popcorn Tax: Why is GST Still Haunting India? | The Quint

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 118

  • @shabeer-r1z
    @shabeer-r1z 20 днів тому +72

    The interest on used cars and bank loans is taxed at 18%, while fuel is taxed at a significantly higher rate of 90%. It appears that the east india company was generous in its tax policies compared to our own.

    • @deepakgeorge5871
      @deepakgeorge5871 20 днів тому

      Has anyone noticed that all people who looted money from banks always run away to our previous colonial masters(London) and is safe from our id107$ in power in central government who does not try to extradite them.. purely coincidental..

    • @amols101
      @amols101 20 днів тому +8

      Fuel is taxed at 200%.

    • @shylendrasuvarna6003
      @shylendrasuvarna6003 19 днів тому +1

      Our representative, elected. Now can't blame.

    • @riddhimanna5679
      @riddhimanna5679 16 днів тому

      Nobody elected Nirmala Sitharaman. ​@@shylendrasuvarna6003

  • @turtlecreek6043
    @turtlecreek6043 20 днів тому +91

    Can this government reveal what percentage of total collected GST is coming from top 100 corporate

    • @anittaPapi
      @anittaPapi 19 днів тому +3

      Nothing. They don't pay mostly as GST has an ITC system for them,

    • @Nohandletofound
      @Nohandletofound 19 днів тому

      They don't pay taxes they provide funds to the government for corruption and buying mla

    • @sanjaymore221
      @sanjaymore221 19 днів тому +1

      Never

    • @Sumit_ss98
      @Sumit_ss98 19 днів тому +1

      They claim everything in deductions, anyway it’s their government why they would pay. 😅

    • @SanjuBaba-vv9rh
      @SanjuBaba-vv9rh 19 днів тому +1

      Zero! 😮😮😮

  • @anishbacal9366
    @anishbacal9366 19 днів тому +52

    This lady will not allow people to survive in India. There's nobody to question her ?

  • @niteesh.g
    @niteesh.g 20 днів тому +30

    I love my india. I am a proud lndian but due to these politicians my patriotism is buried now. I am jobless due to this system I am also trying to leave this country as soon as possible. I am done now. I bhakt of bhagat singh and fond of his ideology.

  • @barnalisarkar3248
    @barnalisarkar3248 20 днів тому +38

    TAX like European countries and Services like Somalia this is indian condition right now

    • @Truthislogical
      @Truthislogical 18 днів тому +3

      first change mindset of people. Railways spends Rs 12000 crore a year to clean 'gutkha' stains. How can they focus on better facilities when they are required to spend money on such acts?

    • @ARSHADIQBAL-u4k
      @ARSHADIQBAL-u4k 18 днів тому

      I don't eat Gutka and that is not my problem.😂​@@Truthislogical

    • @ARSHADIQBAL-u4k
      @ARSHADIQBAL-u4k 18 днів тому +1

      why didn't they stop making gutka.
      coz pehle us par tax.
      phr us ko saaf karne pe tax.
      par jab bande ko cancer pakad le to medicine par tax par tax tax par
      tab tak jab tak banda upar wale k pass Fax na ho😂

  • @livingdead233
    @livingdead233 20 днів тому +36

    Give India back to the British.

    • @ichbeen9954
      @ichbeen9954 19 днів тому +4

      Yeah, they ruled better then them!!!!

    • @gearedtorule
      @gearedtorule 18 днів тому +1

      Pre modi period was better

  • @masudsir3565
    @masudsir3565 20 днів тому +35

    India is not moving forward but going backward.
    Like in the old days where the Rich/ high class people lives in luxury.
    But the Poor people live in Poverty and get stomped by the rich people.

  • @AmandaFlorance-h8v
    @AmandaFlorance-h8v 9 днів тому +2

    Indian government:
    Income Tax : 🗿
    Services : 🤡🤡🤡...atleast Somalia mein air pollution kam hai

  • @Native_Guyy
    @Native_Guyy 20 днів тому +29

    Gabbar Tax for horse trading of MPs and MLAs and for lavish life of government ministers.

  • @jayaramprabhu5595
    @jayaramprabhu5595 20 днів тому +7

    Gap between HAVES & HAVE NOTS is increasing day by day & it's very dangerous trend.

  • @INR1920
    @INR1920 19 днів тому +11

    Brtish Raj in Desi Version 😂😂

  • @swathitnswathi7603
    @swathitnswathi7603 17 днів тому +2

    As a gst student I have learnt that Salt is exempted goods under gst how come salted popcorn can be taxed at 12 percentage.

    • @navjyotraut5829
      @navjyotraut5829 14 днів тому

      They think people should not even afford luxary bro air filter car waterfilter insurance doodh chini chhanch

  • @sdsameer-zm2il
    @sdsameer-zm2il 19 днів тому +8

    GST failure project ,they brought one nation one tax, every state adding additional taxes by
    saying user charges, service charges, true up charges ,fuel charges they dont say it is tax they say charges, where is the point of one nation one tax ,whether it is tax or charges pulling money from public. Now ingredient based tax interduced

  • @xraydog2011
    @xraydog2011 20 днів тому +11

    Taxes at every step , one fine day they will even tax air!
    But when it comes to responsibility from the Govt ,they don't do their part.
    Roads have pot holes ,what is the point in road tax
    Govt Schools and Hospitals are not upto mark.
    Remove reservation

  • @somnathhaldar1597
    @somnathhaldar1597 20 днів тому +34

    Sitaraman has no humanity

    • @Native_Guyy
      @Native_Guyy 20 днів тому +1

      She knows lazy people won't talk/protest about this for a long time

    • @lg7631
      @lg7631 20 днів тому +4

      Modi has appointed her.. why to blame her?

    • @hotlemonade6643
      @hotlemonade6643 19 днів тому

      BJP*

  • @DpnDebBarma
    @DpnDebBarma 20 днів тому +11

    Minister ka pocket mai sab kuch

  • @jec_ecart
    @jec_ecart 19 днів тому +4

    There is no need to explain it. Because even the goberment ministers don't know what they're saying. 😡

  • @vidyanandbapat8032
    @vidyanandbapat8032 19 днів тому +4

    What's wrong with taxing Popcorn bucket of 300 rupees in Multiplex which only ultra-rich can afford? Although its an indirect tax, its being levied on things which only ultra-rich can afford. So in practise, its a progressive way of taxation because it taxes rich people and not poor people.

    • @VarunTomee-kr6nf
      @VarunTomee-kr6nf 19 днів тому

      Middle class and poor people also eat popcorn on thela so it is not progressive andhbhakt

    • @Suiiii12_7
      @Suiiii12_7 8 днів тому +1

      Abe tuje kis ne bola comment karne ko insurance par bhi tax liya
      popcorn agar ultra rich ka lia ha muje aagya samj tu kitna samjdaar aur Ameer ha

  • @chandankumardas1103
    @chandankumardas1103 20 днів тому +10

    Impose GST on Pay & Use Toilet

    • @Sahilkhan-jd5fz
      @Sahilkhan-jd5fz 19 днів тому +2

      It's already taxed on cleaning reagents, handwash water and tissue

    • @anittaPapi
      @anittaPapi 19 днів тому

      😂

  • @Barathindbjp
    @Barathindbjp 20 днів тому +5

    Coconut water is sweet. will nirmala charge 18 % gst in upcoming days? 🤔

    • @Toxicboomah
      @Toxicboomah 19 днів тому +1

      Are bhaiya naya idea de diya 😂 coconut water tax coming soom 😂

    • @rpaul8497
      @rpaul8497 День тому

      She will print gst on cocunut

  • @DepthGamer-fe4wp
    @DepthGamer-fe4wp 18 днів тому +1

    Even if we give these taxes we never get the resultant development from these taxes in service like road, electricity etc

  • @slybombgaming3086
    @slybombgaming3086 20 днів тому +6

    Tax badega in india,tabhi tho ghatega india

  • @1983volunteer
    @1983volunteer 19 днів тому +2

    It’s a shame and unfortunate people love their country but due to the infrastructure and policies are always in thoughts of settling in western countries. Even Indian corporates work with mentality of sucking blood of employees ignoring work life balance with much lower pay scale. Where are we going with all this 😢

  • @chitturkannan
    @chitturkannan 17 днів тому

    Nothing.. Now Most off the Essential Items Price Going high. But Centre Government not Care about it. Only Middle class people's suffering.

  • @ichbeen9954
    @ichbeen9954 19 днів тому +2

    Now, will they even put GST on breathing?

  • @yasin3834
    @yasin3834 15 днів тому

    Abse Gud vale Murmure ke laddu par bhi 18% GST
    Caramelized puffed rise Laddu😅😂

  • @YLaibaklai
    @YLaibaklai 19 днів тому +2

    This is inhuman tax

  • @Jaspreetsingh26012
    @Jaspreetsingh26012 19 днів тому +1

    Is gst on popcorn applicable in kirana store as well please tell

    • @navjyotraut5829
      @navjyotraut5829 14 днів тому

      Yes kirana dukaan me act 2 kharido to 18% gst ke saath aata hai

  • @rudraparapuranjaya2393
    @rudraparapuranjaya2393 17 днів тому

    We cant win tax payers are less and we cant fight this greedy power hungry govt, this fm is the worst.

  • @kmk1508
    @kmk1508 13 днів тому

    कलयुग है जी। ये दुनिया ऐसे ही चलती आई है और ऐसे ही चलेगी

  • @gopalacharya7737
    @gopalacharya7737 19 днів тому +2

    दुकानदार ने चीनी खरीदी Tax दिया बंटर खरीदा टैक्स दिया पोपकोर्न मे मिक्स कर के ग्राहक को बेचा तो ग्राहक ने भी टैक्स दिया लुटेरी कही तो रूक जा

  • @agxec2932
    @agxec2932 14 днів тому

    So she wants cinema goers to now eat vada pav, rayvdi, idli sambar, poha etc in movie theatres 😂😂😂😂😂
    Nachos, chips and ice cream GST tax soon coming 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @maharghabar
    @maharghabar 18 днів тому +1

    Mere popcorn me gst hai 😂

  • @amishasahoo7376
    @amishasahoo7376 18 днів тому

    Sir gst ka matalab ye nhi ki desh me peda ya utpann hue goods and services se h baki gdp me d ka mtlb domestic h iska mtlb desh ka goods ya services agr india ki territory ke bhr v indians deliver kr rhe honge use v calvulate kiya jata h jese agr koi indian company usa me apni airline sewaye de rhi h to wo v gdp hoga 🙏

  • @Tech-lq1kc
    @Tech-lq1kc 20 днів тому +3

    Tai apne liye nahi apne mantri santri ke liye itni burai uthati hai kisi ne socha hai unke chote chote kharche kaise chalege❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @himonchakraborty8527
    @himonchakraborty8527 20 днів тому +4

    Kai main jaan sakta hoon ki cheese popcorn main kitna gst hain!!

    • @anittaPapi
      @anittaPapi 19 днів тому

      😂

    • @zuberkgolechha
      @zuberkgolechha 19 днів тому

      Vote bhi to aap logo ne hi to diya hai !!
      Sirf ek minister ko gaali dene se kya hogaa !!
      Use janta ne elect nahi kiya hai !!
      Use minister kisne banaya hai wo dekho

  • @sanjeevmodi5524
    @sanjeevmodi5524 20 днів тому +5

    Come back East India Company

  • @varpithaa
    @varpithaa 19 днів тому +3

    Remove freebees for votes

  • @abhi_0915
    @abhi_0915 18 днів тому

    But money given to these parties from someone is not taxed.😅

  • @mrme-m
    @mrme-m 19 днів тому

    You have to understand they will make India the richest countries..hum saare aam Aadmi rahenge hi nahi toh sirf aamir log rahenge toh ban gaya bharat aamir😊😊😊

  • @shylendrasuvarna6003
    @shylendrasuvarna6003 19 днів тому +1

    Middle class loose, Madame always win

  • @afsanashaikh4368
    @afsanashaikh4368 20 днів тому +1

    Jai popcorn

  • @traderbestc2099
    @traderbestc2099 18 днів тому

    China’s experience with population control highlights how a balanced demographic structure can drive economic growth and improve living standards, offering lessons for India, where unchecked population growth in economically weaker sections strains resources and governance.
    Unlike China, India has not implemented strict population policies, leading to a high birth rate in poorer sections that places disproportionate pressure on the middle class to shoulder the tax burden.
    Policies under Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, often criticized as "tax terrorism," attempt to extract more from the middle class through increased taxes, ostensibly to fund welfare schemes and freebies for the poorer sections. This approach risks stifling the middle class-the engine of economic growth-by reducing their disposable income and investment potential.
    Addressing population growth through targeted control measures, improved education, and awareness in high-birth-rate areas could alleviate this imbalance, reduce reliance on heavy taxation,, ensuring sustainable economic progress without overburdening taxpayers.

  • @whos_hansi
    @whos_hansi 7 днів тому

    Better to leave and silently settle some where other than india

  • @parasmaloo8182
    @parasmaloo8182 18 днів тому

    जब.विपक्षी सरकार आयेगी तब GST स्केम world आ सबसे बड़ा स्केम होगा

  • @ਪੰਜਾਬਦੇਰੰਗ-ਦ4ਸ

    Bhai ab insaan khana nahi GST kha rahe hai।G,Gobar -S,shit -T, tobacco। rajnigandha matlab zubaan kesri 😂😂

  • @sangitadharvlog
    @sangitadharvlog 14 днів тому

    Hamara minister etna garib hai Jo public ko etna loot raha hai

  • @amoldeshmukh6100
    @amoldeshmukh6100 10 днів тому

    First time i have liked your video nhito har video main hindu muslim hota hain

  • @reachmaximum
    @reachmaximum 18 днів тому

    Gst on beggars also upcoming congratulations

  • @RohitDas-rt9cf
    @RohitDas-rt9cf 17 днів тому

    Saans lene pe tax soon

  • @prashantsrivastava8780
    @prashantsrivastava8780 17 днів тому

    Gandhi ji ka नमक कानून याद कीजिए

  • @storyextract7742
    @storyextract7742 18 днів тому

    British ka tax or Nirmala ji's tax kon besbse vanyankr tha

  • @Siddhant3823
    @Siddhant3823 19 днів тому

    sarkar mp aur mla ka free bee's bandh kr de.

  • @zuberkgolechha
    @zuberkgolechha 19 днів тому

    Vote bhi to aap logo ne hi to diya hai !!
    Sirf ek minister ko gaali dene se kya hogaa !!
    Use janta ne elect nahi kiya hai !!
    Use minister kisne banaya hai wo dekho

  • @Siddhant3823
    @Siddhant3823 19 днів тому +1

    bhai sb k sb chor hai.

  • @ਪੰਜਾਬਦੇਰੰਗ-ਦ4ਸ

    Desh uganda,barundi,syria,iraq,ukrain,or north koria ki or badh raha hai।jalad hi apko ghar khali karne par bhi tax dena hoga।india homeless, homeless logo ki or badh raha hai।khao GST।

  • @sammyjohn.production4783
    @sammyjohn.production4783 18 днів тому

    S she even educTed does she knws about tax

  • @vodindia7834
    @vodindia7834 7 днів тому

    Modi ko hatawo yar...sala manmohan se bhi jyada chup rhta h

  • @pratikmere4226
    @pratikmere4226 19 днів тому

    Sir: इंडिया को no. 1 economi country banana bjp ko

  • @starhaven4944
    @starhaven4944 19 днів тому

    Achay din

  • @zarrarbadshah9292
    @zarrarbadshah9292 19 днів тому +1

    Ye pgla gye h

  • @maryterhase5712
    @maryterhase5712 18 днів тому

    Keep voting for bjp

  • @user-de4rl5bf9r
    @user-de4rl5bf9r 19 днів тому

    Par ham to Hindu hai na kyu kuch bolenge

    • @ruqaiyaq9377
      @ruqaiyaq9377 6 днів тому

      To kya aise hi tax de te rahoge

  • @sanjeevmodi5524
    @sanjeevmodi5524 20 днів тому +2

    Abki baar 100 ke uss par, sudhar joo ...