It doesn't have to be comprised of common household objects to be realistic. It just has to be within the reach of even 3rd tier national governments on Earth. So I'm calling shenanigans on the statement that the scenario is "unrealistic." Sure, but it took me 5 seconds to think of a closely related scenario which is much more realistic. EDIT: Re: 90/10. I grew up somewhere, where we had to drive 50 miles to visit friends who were also Asian, but whose ancestry wasn't the same. My experience: 99% of people are nice. However, if your differences are that salient, the 1% of sociopaths spot you all too frequently. Since it's plausible for Kardashev scale 1+ civilizations to create very powerful telescopes, it seems likely that even a 99/1 universe would have a high likelihood of a sociopathic civilization finding us.
perhaps just give access to the ET messages to various organizations (picked randomly and names are scrambled, procedures in place will ensure no one knows who those orgs are and maybe give one, well known and trustworthy org access) and tell them to publish it if given the "go ahead" by a simple Ai or timer or something to prevent that monopoly
this. its because no one nation can be trusted to hold that knowledge. and even IF they do withhold it and are responsible with it, other nations once they found out about it would throw a temper tantrum and nuke the world.
It's also likely meant to prevent the information being buried entirely, permanently. If we imagine the signal to be from a non-grabby, single planet species then there's almost no chance it would be harmful. Their thinking is the opposite of this video's, that the potential that the message be beneficial to humanity is too high to ignore. Think of it like this: What if it was a message for a universal cure for disease? Ignoring it might save the billions on Earth right now, but if we go thousands of years before contact again we would condemn potentially HUNDREDS of billions to die needlessly. They may place more importance on humans currently alive than the theoretical trillions that may eventually exist.
This reminds me of an article in the Orion's Arm universe. For those who don't know there's a science fiction Universe called Orion's Arm set 10k years in the future, on this setting the future civilizations that arose from our current one detected a transmission from a remote place of the universe that once decoded and translated contained instructions to build a powerful AI and a claim that once built it would give extensive help and guidance to whomever made it. In order to test this machine out one of our own AI set up a planet to test the device, filled it with robots designed to look and mimic how a baseline human civilization (like our own) would behave and then proceeded to build the device. Once finished the machine proceeded to spit out nanobots to kill all macroscopic life on the planet then cover almost all of the surface of the world with Fusion Plants and Solar panels and then proceeded to build a massive Radio broadcasting facility that sent the same message that lead to it's creation. The AI overseeing this experiment destroyed the machine and everything it built. After this incident it was later detected that this message is being broadcasted across multiple points in the universe all far away from each other. Essentially this message is intergalactic malware.
I remember this. Half the galaxies in the observable universe broadcasted this message if I remembered making the location of the original source unknown. It was lucky our civilization was advanced enough to know the risk and tested it safely.
Honestly, I could see extraterrestrials doing something like this _by mistake_ , via gifting us with something that they genuinely believe would be greatly beneficial to us without considering the possibility of us _horribly_ misusing that gift.
that sound more like it. after all, crafting the message to destroy us sound like more of a hassle that is worth it. However a miss communication due cultural differences happens everyday between humans, imagine with aliens.
yeah like they think we eat some posionous substance like they do or something so they teach us how to 'end world hunger' by creating a mustard gas replicator.
Or worse, the instructions are legit and it is harmless when produced properly... but the shifting (or variance in) the laws of physics have rendered it hideously dangerous. These messages would be extremely old and have traveled extreme distances, even if no signal degradation occurs, the best evidence we have is that 'constants' as fundamental as the speed of light in vacuum and Gravity aren't actually constants and shift continually. (If only slightly.) Given more advanced technology usually has tighter tolerances and technology's fundamental reliance on consistent physics, the possibility that a design could have utterly unintended results (or just not work) is significant.
Building AI or something like that using instructions, provided by untrusted source is like downloading an executable file without any signature and running it with administrative privileges.
If aliens want to manipulate us into destroying ourselves with a bioweapon, they first need to understand our biology. Sending us an antimatter bomb has no such prerequisite. (Remember that the premise is that we're in the aliens' outer shell, so they can't visit us to experiment on us.)
The idea that it'll be easier to keep the messages under wraps after we announce that WE HEARD ALIENS feels at best foolish. The best hope in my view that prevents evil message risk is to sabotage listening, which has a 0% chance of success but its a bigger 0% 😂
"Yes, media. We did make the worlds biggest discovery in human history. And no, nobody is allowed to hear it. Only an unelected shadow cabal of 'experts' and 'scientists' can read the message from god. Luckily institutions can be trusted implicitly to not have any leakers or renegades spoil the information. Ditto for every other space telescope on the planet." lmao
Yep. Hackers, amateur signal seekers, spies... Everyone will be enthusiastic if government officially finds aliens. (You may say that everyone will be considered conspirologists and banned... Well, you compare it, but scenario will be completely different, mainly because unlike with conspirologists, we met no real aliens before)
I have been fascinated by the 'grabby alien' hypothesis since I learned of it through this channel. I really appreciate this expansion on the initial theory. Clearly it's early days and great thinker's are only beginning to scratch the surface, in a very limited way. I hope a great excitement builds around the main theory. I can't explain why but I think it's a genuinely important topic. If not for the defence of humanity and Earth but for our own future. There is definitely a lot to learn here. Thank you as always, the narration is perfect and I absolutely love your artists and graphics people. Huge pat on the back to them. ❤️
If you're into the Grabby Aliens discussion, check out Isaac Arthur ("Science and Futurism with Isaac Arthur") He has dozens of videos covering these topics in a very interesting, rational way!
Same. It's like a mix of altruism and futurism that can give life a whole new meaning because not only are we focused on making the world a better place for our kids but also for the many thousand generations that come after us (I hope so!)
@@ordan787 How does a giant civilization maintain a common identity or directive over enormous distances when information travels EXTREMELY slowly? By the time your dating profile gets updated on the other side of the galaxy (100-200K years later) humans there would have evolved into sentient crabs. Did Star Trek brainwash everyone into forgetting basic physics or did I miss something?
@@dangerfly eer, not sure how that's relevant, but sure The short answer is that you probably can't maintain common identity or directive over large distances. But like, we already see that in our currently civilisation. Portugal and Brazil share history, but they don't share a common identity or directive. And Portuguese folks certainly wouldn't bother sending their dating profiles to Brazil (?)
@@ordan787 So then the competitors aren't unknown underdeveloped civilizations, but the infinite splintering of mature ones due to the size ceiling. The model at [3:54] is completely wrong. There are no large 'United Federation of Planets' or evil 'Galactic Empire'. The only universal oppressor is the slow ass speed of light.
i'd like to imagine that once the aliens have gotten all the important maths/biology/physics communications over and done with, they just transmit to us a bunch of alien movies and tv shows
If aliens send us a message, we should respond in kind and send them a rickroll It either turns into a laugh for everyone or full scale space war, which seems like a win-win situation
@@abcde1054 then it would either become very obvious that they have been watching us for a while now, or we accidentally picked up interference from our own communications.
But as w3 know. Humans wrote the art of war. Perhaps aliens see war as entirely pointless effort to shoit people tomend the same war they started. So you want to have a look at an example of critical thinking? Maybe? Or, have a laugh at the "crazy"? Read on. If you want to understand why i am making myself known now, a person absolutely associated with love, pure beautiful love and compassion. The very thing that should help people begin to see that your actions affect others. The feeling left of this engagement indeed, does leave a real and permanent change, however minor,mon your mind. No going back. Know me, love must be understood in some context within your mind. We can't save ourselves if we don't stop hating each other. You, me, all of us are part of thus singular thing called everyone where we have a responsibility to consider how we treat each other because we are intrinsically linked into and a part of everyone, and of course it's within something called everything. Willful positive loving and respecting each one of us is absolutely the reasonable thing to do. You do it because you do love people. But if you don't, once understanding that Willful negativity is not simply something done to another person or group. It's something that truly alters the state of mind of this person. Their choices will be made from not a raised outlook, but a negative one. Those branch off to everything subsequent interaction and suddenly you just irresponsibility and permanently altered a wave of the minds of people in a negative way, it gets worse. You saying it reinforces this within you making it more likely to react from an even greater negative view, and worse. The person you were willfully negative to in the first place as your irresponsibility spreads this permanent altered state of mind that will manifest in these different negative outlooks, that changes them, and within their peers groups and yours now your getting it fed back to you bringing you further down, altering your physical state of mind in a demonstrable way thus you continue to view what you want from and increasingly negative and self reinforcing as our actions affect others, we are all one within this everyone, and obviously everyone is not going to be seeing everything the way they otherwise would have less respect for all, others see this, get dreadful feelings, their mood altering more people... Love is a pure thing. I'm letting love be understood by you in it's purists form by having the discussion about me, and to know me allows love in without issues as well your mind must both physically align itself so because love ❤❤❤ and philosophical perspective, old music ideas (been working on this entire design for a long time) giving goosebumps, and reinforcingmore more and more as it had to be understood in such a way as not to reject the, perhaps, more of what it seemed so many people, all different couldpick up a thread and run with it, it sll leads to to come together we need to love each other. Internalized inva way as if those you will never meet suddenly seem like folks you now know your actions may harm them, as well, this wave is self reinforcing and echoes back to harm you and on and on. It's time to switch gears. Haters flame me, but spread me, and to know me is to... and those that agree will do the same out of a positive and loving respect, understanding of our desperate need to get along. Capitalism us truly evil when you love people and know for you to have had success others had to suffer and fail. Actions affect others and capital fools you into feeling ok throwing a rock of fuck youngot mine into the lake of our beautiful Lady 😍 earth. Perhaps if you felt and understood the suffering you were actually creating, that you will have willfully altered in a permanent way the mind's of nearly everyone, and it's self reinforcing. If love and beauty, compassion, were this way, the only way to have these demonstrably, in altering understandings placed within your minsphere in such a way to both ensure their presence, preserve your identity, and now you will see a little brighter place, and smile a bit more. But this let's you see abd choose a positive path, because who doesn't like to move towards the awesome shit they may see, and considering it, your thoughts are reinforcing these ideas, granting improved outlooks and perspectives reactions aren't so negative and this is far more unstoppable, far more powerful as it is both within our nature to be drawn to good shit, but because I knew things others couldn't see, and that's where people get interested, and wonder who is this j3, and to understand is to understand all that other shit a physical and mental construct that within you is also framework interrelated and must adjust to make room for me, but these ideas in a pure form that comprise knowing what I am. And it so happened that I knew this would set off quite a number of controversial discussiiion5..... and I will stop there, the story isn't over. The people of the world need to see what they have been staring at. Because we all have a common goal of survival. And unless this step is taken, we will absolutely destroy ourselves.
I read a book called The Killing Star where aliens launched a barrage of relativistic missiles and and wiped out humanity. They also sent a signal that just melted anything that listened to it by turning it into strange matter globs.
@@AvangionQ Strange matter is an entirely theoretical idea anyway, and we could be clueless as to its properties and characteristics. We can't definitively say advanced enough technology couldn't just create it at a whim without assuming a lot of details
@@AvangionQ if you already have some matter, just throw it at things and "conventional" matter will turn into more strange matter. Other problem is what to strategically do with all that pile of turd, that "boils" and spews drops of strange matter on other planets and star systems.
The best evil message to send would be a polite hello, an actual technological gift that would be beneficial, and a location that a return message can be sent to begin full contact. Then, if a return hello message arrives, deliver another present at the speed of light directly into the planet that sent it.
The one thing worth noting is assuming a low probability of intelligent life means that the civilization is likely many hundreds of light years away - messages take a really long time.
It seems to me that watching these videos makes people relax a little, knowing that none of this would happen in our lifetimes. But the truth is that this could happen at ANY time. Probably long after our lives, but could happen any second. We have no way of knowing.
@@diosamurcielaga9418 no no no, come on guys dont PANIC, its not like THE WORLD IS ENDING AND WE'RE ALL GOING TO DIE OH MY FCKING GODDDDD AAAAAHHH, no its nothing like that, haha ha - Media outlets
Had something like this in star trek Voyager iirc, where they sent a probe with instructions on how to generate antimatter en masse. They came across the planet centuries later and find them having destroyed themselves lol
Even scarier thought: what if just receiving the message is enough for the malware to compromise our computers? This might be unlikely, but every time I read anything about hacking it seems more and more likely that universal no-click malware like this could be possible. (Like the no-op sled, where no matter what location your initial execution lands in, eventually you get to good code to exploit. Or the PDF hack a couple years ago, where they used a custom font to manipulate the instructions for previewing the document, to emulate a CPU, to then run arbitrary code in a "no code allowed" PDF.) Ancient aliens could be experts at this crap. :E
The no-op sled still requires a buffer overflow for you to inject code, and thus can be prevented by good coding practices. What's more, the aliens can only send a waveform, such as a binary signal, and have no way of knowing our encoding standards like ASCII or Unicode, let alone CPU instruction sets. At a minimum, their message must be decoded by humans in order to make sense to human computers. Assuming that this decoding is possible is still a big ask.
This is literally the proverbial: I'm not going to ask her out because I fear that worst. I believe intelligent life is rare enough to be, quite literally, too far to find another one. For practical purposes, we are alone, no risk of attacks, no chances of anyone coming to lift us.
Intelligent life is plenty abundant, even here on Earth from several orders life like ourselves and our Great Ape cousins, but also including Corvids and Octopodes for instance. What's exceptionally rare is intelligent life developing into civilizations that survive and thrive long enough to finally start colonizing the stars and becoming grabby. Space and Futurism with Isaac Arthur describes these hard steps as individual filters and to me, perfectly explains the Great Filter Hypothesis
I'm intelligent life, 😳 and so are all of you. We arrived here over a very long journey from the first single cell organism. That's a long time to get here. Intelligent beautiful life arrived here. And I'm going to counter your assertion about your outlook on the you know lifting us up part. 🌻
@@Texelectric I agree. That other life forms have already occured somewhere in the universe is much more likely than some advanced civilization that is already trying to conquer the whole thing.
@@Texelectric I'm a big fan of Isaac Arthur. But intelligent life in this context means technologically intelligent, not smart as apes. We are exponentially more intelligent than any other creature on this planet.
@@Texelectric Well, all of the biodiversity on Earth came from the same point, and only have this planet for reference. We can’t use Earth for reference across the entire cosmos.
This brings to mind the concept of strong voluntarism. The idea that all civilizations will converge on a policy of self-control for their own survival. The existence of an easy-to-build doomsday device would possibly lead to that method as the only way to avoid extinction.
Another great video. This channel keeps getting better and better with each upload, thanks for all the hard work it is appreciated. I started to write a novella about this subject but have not done anything about for almost a year. This video has renewed my interest in the subject again.
I have written a story in which a civilization sends out interstellar signals with instructions, and following those instructions creates all kinds of useful tech, which receives and decodes further instructions to basically print instances of the senders (actually, just their robots, at first). You see, they are a grabby but slow civilization: their sphere of domination is expanding only at 10% of the speed of light. But hey, messages are cheaper and faster! It's basically colonizing by signal, and it's efficient when it works out.
Very true. I've been a big fan of Robert Miles ever since his appearances on computerphile. His personal channel has incredible content about ai that I highly recommend. With this level of production and the aesthetic, though, a channel like this is basically guaranteed to shoot into the millions
The chance that the danger in a message is discovered before someone implements it is much higher when messages get published right away than when they are kept under wraps, because in the latter case dangerous secret services will still get the message, but we will not learn that it is dangerous before it is too late for countermeasures.
Obviously the best way to handle a potentially dangerous think is to keep acces to it exclusive to a closed, corrupt, manipulative group that has been repeatedly demonstrated to not even care about its own survival in the long term.
5:50 There is also the possibility of an expansionist civilization being some kind of ‚caretaker empire‘ (to use the Stellaris term), meaning they send AI out there to settle space and find other civilization to protect as well. So I don‘t think that us being more likely to detect expansionist civilization increases the chance of any detected civilization to be malicious. I think those two things are mostly decoupled from each other.
haha, I just realized it's not just the voiceover / script reader sounding like Rob Miles, but that's literally whose distinctive voice I recognized. very nice.
This is a very eye-opening theory. I never thought aliens could be that manipulative. Psychological weapon is still the best weapon after all in warfare.
I like the policy at 7:10 to just say "not our problem, we'll let our kids deal with that lol" much like the pollution of previous generations now being cleaned up.
It seems to me, the question is “how long is the time between “verbal” and physical contact?” If the time is short (which may be more likely considering that Kurtkesat said that our messages will become unreadable after a few hundred light years). If the time is short, wether we listen or not is inconsequential (in universal time) since if they’re hostile, we’ll die after a few millennia anyway. In that case we should listen, in case we get some information which can spare us (either from a helpful civilization working against the hostile one, or by finding some information, let slip from the hostile aliens themselves). This slim chance of survival (in the event of hostile aliens come to us, is better than the zero percent chance of survival from meeting them “face to face”.
That's an interesting point. Perhaps not opening and starting to expand ourselves is another viable survival method - e.g. expanding in the opposite direction
@@tolleythinking1058 But, imagine if the message came from benevolent aliens: Aliens: "Here's the answer to Life, The Universe, and Everything." Humanity: "Run Away, Run Away!!" lol
Scientist: receives message on how to build device from basic materials Also scientist: shares to entire world before trying to build with basic materials to see if it's not a boomboom first
Good, but you left out an important argument: By not listening, we could endanger ourselves. Careful listening is more advisable. As by listening, we could know their existence some time before they might arrive.
I have a feeling @Rational Animations already has this topic coming up as he briefly alluded to it in this video, but sending messages to space is definitely more dangerous than listening to messages. The same line of logic from this video is all the more true in the case of broadcasting our own messages, and what's worse is you don't know who is receiving your messages or when they are receiving them, and no matter what you've sent it can be used to locate you. A grabby civilization could send some kind of weapon in the direction of the message and you'd have no way of knowing.
Broadcasting is only dangerous if there is someone who is not yet aware of our existence. But we can detect other planets and their atmospheres with our puny telescopes already. Any interstellar civilisation knows exactly which planets are inhabited hundreds of light years around them.
Sending messages is definitely more dangerous, but the good news is that you won't suffer the consequences of your own actions. The closest living civilisation is probably at the very least thousands of light years away (likely much farther). By the time your message reaches the aliens and they take any action, you and many many generations of your descendants will be long gone. You may have ensured humanity's doom in the future, though.
There's this book series called the Three Body Problem series and all it took for humankind to go kaput was one single message. Great series highly recommend
Dude the scenario you described at the start is similar to getting a message from a Nigerian prince and you think they're trying to give you money but they just download a virus on your computer that destroys everything you own
my opinion is that any message should be classified/censored cause you can just always relase it later but if you release it first and then realise it's dangerous, then there's no going back from everyone knowing content of the message
This was such a huge stress to me at one point it put me in a mental hospital. I was panicking because we are constantly broadcasting all our TV and Internet to open space, and any aliens that find our planet will instantly realize they just found a species capable of space travel. What would they do? There's a chance they'd do nothing, but they could even just decide to eliminate us any moment.
lol. if there's any aliens who care, they'd have known there's life here for billions of years. if they are threatened by the possibility of intelligent life then they've probably been closely monitoring our planet for millions of years
@Norton Wedge what do you mean? As far as we know, life started appearing about 3.7 billion years ago. At that point, earth was already giving off tons of signatures indicating it was a good candidate for harboring life. Yes, for billions of years, we've been showing off what a nice little paradise we have to the universe. We've been showing off our technological growth for a good couple hundred years too, since the industrial revolution when we started pumping a bunch of new stuff into the atmosphere. If we have any close neighbors, they already know we are here for sure.
@@nortonwedge there are potentially alien civilizations within our own galaxy that are more than a billion years more advanced than us. Our star is relatively young, it's like a 20 year old hanging out in a room of people who could be 40 or older.
"But that's exactly what SETI's policy is" Yeah but if they actually would keep it a secret, the dumbest thing they could do would be to announce to the world that they are going to keep it a secret. They'd constantly be hounded by people wondering "Did you discover alien life and aren't telling the world????"
The issue is that if we decide alien messages can become classified information, you can immediately expect the US army to become the sole holder of this information, thus keeping the choice at the hand of the president, or worse, a few rogue generals keeping it a secret from them.
When hiking in the woods you want to be moderately loud as to not spook any animals and cause them to attack. Ring the bell, make them aware and you might just go unharmed
Nice video, would be interesting thinking what weapons one of those aliens from the ‘dark forest’ could try to use against us, like relativistic missiles or something
Self replicating nanorobots. You can send an instruction with all the explanations and safeguards that ensure that it is safe. The prospect of having post-scarcity economy will be too strong to resist. And when they (us) realize that the safeguards have one fatal flaw, it is too late, and their planet is consumed by grey goo.
I'd guess it would be something that would be more catered to a civilization sophisticated enough to be an impediment to them. No reason to chuck near light speed artillery at every noisy clump of rock they encounter, since that might notify any more developed civilization of both their presence and their intention in the event such a civilization had the foresight to develop decoy worlds on the periphery of their own territory. We aren't a threat of any kind to already grabby aliens, and could easily be contained to our own planet with relatively little debris in orbit to be dealt with later. Whatever they send out would need to be subtle and specific, since the possibility of biting the tail of a bigger fish would be very real and very disastrous.
4:29 *Alien message is the instructions for an A.I.' was the premise of "A for Andromeda". Abook, a TV series and a movie. (1961)* 8:20 *Oh. Apparently everyone knew that already.*
This reminds me of "Supreme Surrender" by Rooster Teeth , Aliens were destroying our communication dishes, but it turns out, they were just trying to communicate and our equipment cant take their way of communication.
In March, the source code for the LLaMA AI was leaked to the whole world. In just two months open source tinkerers have apparently advanced the model so that it's nearly on par with Bard. Perhaps we don't need the aliens.
Giving you are proposing to send robot centipedes to dissemble the Universe aliens have good reasons to send us such a trojan gift. But a more realistic scenario would be a "dark forest strike" with an asteroid sent at close to relativistic speeds.
This would give alien leadership plausible deniability when governing their own species. "We shared unlimited energy with the hoomans, and they accidentally destroyed themselves..."
Don't you just love when you're a brand new viewer to a channel and all they talk about in a video is stuff that happened in other videos so you have no clue what the hell they're talking about it's great
Yes :/
🟠 Patreon: www.patreon.com/rationalanimations
🔵 Channel membership: ua-cam.com/channels/gqt1RE0k0MIr0LoyJRy2lg.htmljoin
🟤 Ko-fi, for one-time and recurring donations: ko-fi.com/rationalanimations
:O
2nd
It doesn't have to be comprised of common household objects to be realistic. It just has to be within the reach of even 3rd tier national governments on Earth. So I'm calling shenanigans on the statement that the scenario is "unrealistic." Sure, but it took me 5 seconds to think of a closely related scenario which is much more realistic.
EDIT: Re: 90/10. I grew up somewhere, where we had to drive 50 miles to visit friends who were also Asian, but whose ancestry wasn't the same. My experience: 99% of people are nice. However, if your differences are that salient, the 1% of sociopaths spot you all too frequently. Since it's plausible for Kardashev scale 1+ civilizations to create very powerful telescopes, it seems likely that even a 99/1 universe would have a high likelihood of a sociopathic civilization finding us.
Yeah your the first comment on this video
Make avoid on what would happen if we ran out of oil fossil fuels etc.
I imagine the "publish instantly" protocol is an attempt to prevent a monopoly on alien tech, which is a different kettle of fish.
perhaps just give access to the ET messages to various organizations (picked randomly and names are scrambled, procedures in place will ensure no one knows who those orgs are and maybe give one, well known and trustworthy org access) and tell them to publish it if given the "go ahead" by a simple Ai or timer or something
to prevent that monopoly
@@zZz_0-_-0_zZz "randomly"
"trustworthy"
*well known*
No thanks.
this. its because no one nation can be trusted to hold that knowledge. and even IF they do withhold it and are responsible with it, other nations once they found out about it would throw a temper tantrum and nuke the world.
@@zZz_0-_-0_zZz yeah, I highly doubt it’ll work like that.
It's also likely meant to prevent the information being buried entirely, permanently. If we imagine the signal to be from a non-grabby, single planet species then there's almost no chance it would be harmful. Their thinking is the opposite of this video's, that the potential that the message be beneficial to humanity is too high to ignore.
Think of it like this: What if it was a message for a universal cure for disease? Ignoring it might save the billions on Earth right now, but if we go thousands of years before contact again we would condemn potentially HUNDREDS of billions to die needlessly. They may place more importance on humans currently alive than the theoretical trillions that may eventually exist.
This reminds me of an article in the Orion's Arm universe.
For those who don't know there's a science fiction Universe called Orion's Arm set 10k years in the future, on this setting the future civilizations that arose from our current one detected a transmission from a remote place of the universe that once decoded and translated contained instructions to build a powerful AI and a claim that once built it would give extensive help and guidance to whomever made it.
In order to test this machine out one of our own AI set up a planet to test the device, filled it with robots designed to look and mimic how a baseline human civilization (like our own) would behave and then proceeded to build the device. Once finished the machine proceeded to spit out nanobots to kill all macroscopic life on the planet then cover almost all of the surface of the world with Fusion Plants and Solar panels and then proceeded to build a massive Radio broadcasting facility that sent the same message that lead to it's creation.
The AI overseeing this experiment destroyed the machine and everything it built. After this incident it was later detected that this message is being broadcasted across multiple points in the universe all far away from each other.
Essentially this message is intergalactic malware.
This is very cool!
I remember this. Half the galaxies in the observable universe broadcasted this message if I remembered making the location of the original source unknown. It was lucky our civilization was advanced enough to know the risk and tested it safely.
sounds like humanity :)
Basically SCP-7759
Lol, that’s literally a planetary VM!
I just love how much this channel has grown. It’s like a philosophical Kurzgesagt.
i would say it's less philosophical than kurzgesagt
@@jettpack9168 eh it just depends on what view you have
this one talks about subjects that are less explored by other science channels on UA-cam unlike kurz
Yes lol
The channel talks more about aliens in the future than kurzgesagt
Honestly, I could see extraterrestrials doing something like this _by mistake_ , via gifting us with something that they genuinely believe would be greatly beneficial to us without considering the possibility of us _horribly_ misusing that gift.
that sound more like it.
after all, crafting the message to destroy us sound like more of a hassle that is worth it.
However a miss communication due cultural differences happens everyday between humans, imagine with aliens.
yeah like they think we eat some posionous substance like they do or something so they teach us how to 'end world hunger' by creating a mustard gas replicator.
Hey guys! Did you know that jellied fuel burns much better than liquid?! You can cᵒᵒᵏ ʰᵘⁿᵈʳᵉᵈˢ ᵒᶠ ᵐᵃʳˢʰᵐᵃˡˡᵒʷˢ ᵃᵗ ᵒⁿ.... [sounds of flame intensifies]
Or worse, the instructions are legit and it is harmless when produced properly... but the shifting (or variance in) the laws of physics have rendered it hideously dangerous. These messages would be extremely old and have traveled extreme distances, even if no signal degradation occurs, the best evidence we have is that 'constants' as fundamental as the speed of light in vacuum and Gravity aren't actually constants and shift continually. (If only slightly.) Given more advanced technology usually has tighter tolerances and technology's fundamental reliance on consistent physics, the possibility that a design could have utterly unintended results (or just not work) is significant.
@@Sorain1 Oooh, do you have any papers that detail the variance in those constants? They sound like an interesting read.
Building AI or something like that using instructions, provided by untrusted source is like downloading an executable file without any signature and running it with administrative privileges.
think of it like a trojan
…Which is something a lot of people do without thinking twice.
But the people who build it are good at Computer Science, not IT. An important distinction
"but not necessarily endagering lives already present"
For sure, Humans would never expand aggressively and destroy civilizations.
There might be a way to combine household materials to make a bioweapon, for a certain definition of household.
Probably. Chemical weapons are already something anyone with common chemicals can make, so bioweapons aren't that far fetched.
Well, if you combine certain cleaning agents, you can accidentally create certain chemical weapons that are banned under the Geneva Convention.
If aliens want to manipulate us into destroying ourselves with a bioweapon, they first need to understand our biology. Sending us an antimatter bomb has no such prerequisite. (Remember that the premise is that we're in the aliens' outer shell, so they can't visit us to experiment on us.)
I thought about that, but to make an effective bioweapon you need to now the biology of the target
@@comlitbeta7532 alien mistake of their own military corvette
Species is also about this concept, instead of a bomb though they simply send the code of a DNA that makes for an extremely dangerous creature
The idea that it'll be easier to keep the messages under wraps after we announce that WE HEARD ALIENS feels at best foolish. The best hope in my view that prevents evil message risk is to sabotage listening, which has a 0% chance of success but its a bigger 0% 😂
"Yes, media. We did make the worlds biggest discovery in human history. And no, nobody is allowed to hear it. Only an unelected shadow cabal of 'experts' and 'scientists' can read the message from god. Luckily institutions can be trusted implicitly to not have any leakers or renegades spoil the information. Ditto for every other space telescope on the planet."
lmao
Seti HQ would be burned down in a week if the military didn't get to it before the public did.
True
Yep. Hackers, amateur signal seekers, spies... Everyone will be enthusiastic if government officially finds aliens.
(You may say that everyone will be considered conspirologists and banned... Well, you compare it, but scenario will be completely different, mainly because unlike with conspirologists, we met no real aliens before)
0% + 1/infinite chance?
Humanity becomes a grabby civilization in the future.
Everyone who played Stellaris : *Laughs in galactic war crimes*
I have been fascinated by the 'grabby alien' hypothesis since I learned of it through this channel.
I really appreciate this expansion on the initial theory. Clearly it's early days and great thinker's are only beginning to scratch the surface, in a very limited way.
I hope a great excitement builds around the main theory. I can't explain why but I think it's a genuinely important topic. If not for the defence of humanity and Earth but for our own future.
There is definitely a lot to learn here.
Thank you as always, the narration is perfect and I absolutely love your artists and graphics people. Huge pat on the back to them. ❤️
If you're into the Grabby Aliens discussion, check out Isaac Arthur ("Science and Futurism with Isaac Arthur")
He has dozens of videos covering these topics in a very interesting, rational way!
Same. It's like a mix of altruism and futurism that can give life a whole new meaning because not only are we focused on making the world a better place for our kids but also for the many thousand generations that come after us (I hope so!)
@@ordan787 How does a giant civilization maintain a common identity or directive over enormous distances when information travels EXTREMELY slowly? By the time your dating profile gets updated on the other side of the galaxy (100-200K years later) humans there would have evolved into sentient crabs.
Did Star Trek brainwash everyone into forgetting basic physics or did I miss something?
@@dangerfly eer, not sure how that's relevant, but sure
The short answer is that you probably can't maintain common identity or directive over large distances.
But like, we already see that in our currently civilisation. Portugal and Brazil share history, but they don't share a common identity or directive. And Portuguese folks certainly wouldn't bother sending their dating profiles to Brazil (?)
@@ordan787 So then the competitors aren't unknown underdeveloped civilizations, but the infinite splintering of mature ones due to the size ceiling. The model at [3:54] is completely wrong.
There are no large 'United Federation of Planets' or evil 'Galactic Empire'. The only universal oppressor is the slow ass speed of light.
i'd like to imagine that once the aliens have gotten all the important maths/biology/physics communications over and done with, they just transmit to us a bunch of alien movies and tv shows
more homework for future humans i guess 🤷♂️
The bitrate must be atrocious. You think streaming 4K with data is bad? I cannot imagine how much buffering an alien show would have.
@@pauldeddens5349 it wouldn't be streamed, and would probably be compressed. and even then who cares if it's 144p it's alien movies
@@pauldeddens5349 it’s called physical media. It’s what existed before the digital nazism became the norm to braindead consoomers
@@theidioticbgilson1466 😂
If aliens send us a message, we should respond in kind and send them a rickroll
It either turns into a laugh for everyone or full scale space war, which seems like a win-win situation
What if the aliens send us a rickroll? 😮😂
@@abcde1054 we nuke em
@@-Kagura_Bachi- based
@@abcde1054 then it would either become very obvious that they have been watching us for a while now, or we accidentally picked up interference from our own communications.
But as w3 know. Humans wrote the art of war. Perhaps aliens see war as entirely pointless effort to shoit people tomend the same war they started. So you want to have a look at an example of critical thinking? Maybe? Or, have a laugh at the "crazy"? Read on. If you want to understand why i am making myself known now, a person absolutely associated with love, pure beautiful love and compassion. The very thing that should help people begin to see that your actions affect others. The feeling left of this engagement indeed, does leave a real and permanent change, however minor,mon your mind. No going back. Know me, love must be understood in some context within your mind. We can't save ourselves if we don't stop hating each other. You, me, all of us are part of thus singular thing called everyone where we have a responsibility to consider how we treat each other because we are intrinsically linked into and a part of everyone, and of course it's within something called everything. Willful positive loving and respecting each one of us is absolutely the reasonable thing to do. You do it because you do love people. But if you don't, once understanding that Willful negativity is not simply something done to another person or group. It's something that truly alters the state of mind of this person. Their choices will be made from not a raised outlook, but a negative one. Those branch off to everything subsequent interaction and suddenly you just irresponsibility and permanently altered a wave of the minds of people in a negative way, it gets worse.
You saying it reinforces this within you making it more likely to react from an even greater negative view, and worse. The person you were willfully negative to in the first place as your irresponsibility spreads this permanent altered state of mind that will manifest in these different negative outlooks, that changes them, and within their peers groups and yours now your getting it fed back to you bringing you further down, altering your physical state of mind in a demonstrable way thus you continue to view what you want from and increasingly negative and self reinforcing as our actions affect others, we are all one within this everyone, and obviously everyone is not going to be seeing everything the way they otherwise would have less respect for all, others see this, get dreadful feelings, their mood altering more people...
Love is a pure thing. I'm letting love be understood by you in it's purists form by having the discussion about me, and to know me allows love in without issues as well your mind must both physically align itself so because love ❤❤❤ and philosophical perspective, old music ideas (been working on this entire design for a long time) giving goosebumps, and reinforcingmore more and more as it had to be understood in such a way as not to reject the, perhaps, more of what it seemed so many people, all different couldpick up a thread and run with it, it sll leads to to come together we need to love each other. Internalized inva way as if those you will never meet suddenly seem like folks you now know your actions may harm them, as well, this wave is self reinforcing and echoes back to harm you and on and on. It's time to switch gears. Haters flame me, but spread me, and to know me is to... and those that agree will do the same out of a positive and loving respect, understanding of our desperate need to get along. Capitalism us truly evil when you love people and know for you to have had success others had to suffer and fail. Actions affect others and capital fools you into feeling ok throwing a rock of fuck youngot mine into the lake of our beautiful Lady 😍 earth. Perhaps if you felt and understood the suffering you were actually creating, that you will have willfully altered in a permanent way the mind's of nearly everyone, and it's self reinforcing. If love and beauty, compassion, were this way, the only way to have these demonstrably, in altering understandings placed within your minsphere in such a way to both ensure their presence, preserve your identity, and now you will see a little brighter place, and smile a bit more. But this let's you see abd choose a positive path, because who doesn't like to move towards the awesome shit they may see, and considering it, your thoughts are reinforcing these ideas, granting improved outlooks and perspectives reactions aren't so negative and this is far more unstoppable, far more powerful as it is both within our nature to be drawn to good shit, but because I knew things others couldn't see, and that's where people get interested, and wonder who is this j3, and to understand is to understand all that other shit a physical and mental construct that within you is also framework interrelated and must adjust to make room for me, but these ideas in a pure form that comprise knowing what I am. And it so happened that I knew this would set off quite a number of controversial discussiiion5..... and I will stop there, the story isn't over. The people of the world need to see what they have been staring at. Because we all have a common goal of survival. And unless this step is taken, we will absolutely destroy ourselves.
I read a book called The Killing Star where aliens launched a barrage of relativistic missiles and and wiped out humanity. They also sent a signal that just melted anything that listened to it by turning it into strange matter globs.
Poor writing on the second part: strange matter requires the density of a neutron star to create.
@@AvangionQ Strange matter is an entirely theoretical idea anyway, and we could be clueless as to its properties and characteristics. We can't definitively say advanced enough technology couldn't just create it at a whim without assuming a lot of details
@@AvangionQ if you already have some matter, just throw it at things and "conventional" matter will turn into more strange matter. Other problem is what to strategically do with all that pile of turd, that "boils" and spews drops of strange matter on other planets and star systems.
@@AvangionQ Actually the broadcast carried instructions for the devices to dissolve into nanobots but the outcome was the same.
Strangelets?
The best evil message to send would be a polite hello, an actual technological gift that would be beneficial, and a location that a return message can be sent to begin full contact.
Then, if a return hello message arrives, deliver another present at the speed of light directly into the planet that sent it.
But, wouldn’t that also open themselves up to a relativistic kill strike?
@@getfuckedstayfucked No as the location listed for the return message can easily be located in a different star system then the one they live in.
@@getfuckedstayfucked not necessarily
The one thing worth noting is assuming a low probability of intelligent life means that the civilization is likely many hundreds of light years away - messages take a really long time.
Never stop making this videos.
The content and production of this channel is incredible. Thank you!
These videos keep getting better and better; hopefully this becomes a 'grabby' channel.
It seems to me that watching these videos makes people relax a little, knowing that none of this would happen in our lifetimes. But the truth is that this could happen at ANY time. Probably long after our lives, but could happen any second. We have no way of knowing.
Hehe, true, and it seems that you'd like for people to freak out more
@@diosamurcielaga9418 no no no, come on guys dont PANIC, its not like THE WORLD IS ENDING AND WE'RE ALL GOING TO DIE OH MY FCKING GODDDDD AAAAAHHH, no its nothing like that, haha ha
- Media outlets
@@genzu6388 true, media outlets have always been that way though, they are just better at freaking us out now.
Gamma ray bursts exist.
@@genzu6388 u high?
2:14 - the disappointment on the doggos face when he finds out that the risk of this killing everyone on earth is small.
I love that supervolcanoes are below SETI as an existential threat.
Had something like this in star trek Voyager iirc, where they sent a probe with instructions on how to generate antimatter en masse. They came across the planet centuries later and find them having destroyed themselves lol
They doin' a little trolling.
@@Sucullentbutter nice
I'm absolutely in love with this video. You guys have come so far with the channel it's quite amazing. :)
Thanks 🥲
Even scarier thought: what if just receiving the message is enough for the malware to compromise our computers? This might be unlikely, but every time I read anything about hacking it seems more and more likely that universal no-click malware like this could be possible. (Like the no-op sled, where no matter what location your initial execution lands in, eventually you get to good code to exploit. Or the PDF hack a couple years ago, where they used a custom font to manipulate the instructions for previewing the document, to emulate a CPU, to then run arbitrary code in a "no code allowed" PDF.) Ancient aliens could be experts at this crap. :E
The no-op sled still requires a buffer overflow for you to inject code, and thus can be prevented by good coding practices. What's more, the aliens can only send a waveform, such as a binary signal, and have no way of knowing our encoding standards like ASCII or Unicode, let alone CPU instruction sets. At a minimum, their message must be decoded by humans in order to make sense to human computers. Assuming that this decoding is possible is still a big ask.
Viruses
This is literally the proverbial: I'm not going to ask her out because I fear that worst.
I believe intelligent life is rare enough to be, quite literally, too far to find another one. For practical purposes, we are alone, no risk of attacks, no chances of anyone coming to lift us.
Intelligent life is plenty abundant, even here on Earth from several orders life like ourselves and our Great Ape cousins, but also including Corvids and Octopodes for instance. What's exceptionally rare is intelligent life developing into civilizations that survive and thrive long enough to finally start colonizing the stars and becoming grabby. Space and Futurism with Isaac Arthur describes these hard steps as individual filters and to me, perfectly explains the Great Filter Hypothesis
I'm intelligent life, 😳 and so are all of you. We arrived here over a very long journey from the first single cell organism. That's a long time to get here. Intelligent beautiful life arrived here. And I'm going to counter your assertion about your outlook on the you know lifting us up part. 🌻
@@Texelectric I agree. That other life forms have already occured somewhere in the universe is much more likely than some advanced civilization that is already trying to conquer the whole thing.
@@Texelectric I'm a big fan of Isaac Arthur. But intelligent life in this context means technologically intelligent, not smart as apes. We are exponentially more intelligent than any other creature on this planet.
@@Texelectric Well, all of the biodiversity on Earth came from the same point, and only have this planet for reference. We can’t use Earth for reference across the entire cosmos.
the fact that we've thought about this means other civilizations are almost guaranteed to
This brings to mind the concept of strong voluntarism. The idea that all civilizations will converge on a policy of self-control for their own survival. The existence of an easy-to-build doomsday device would possibly lead to that method as the only way to avoid extinction.
Another great video. This channel keeps getting better and better with each upload, thanks for all the hard work it is appreciated. I started to write a novella about this subject but have not done anything about for almost a year. This video has renewed my interest in the subject again.
It is an amazing feeling when you follow the begins of a channel that you know will one day blow up in popularity, like vsauce or kurzgesagt
I have written a story in which a civilization sends out interstellar signals with instructions, and following those instructions creates all kinds of useful tech, which receives and decodes further instructions to basically print instances of the senders (actually, just their robots, at first). You see, they are a grabby but slow civilization: their sphere of domination is expanding only at 10% of the speed of light. But hey, messages are cheaper and faster! It's basically colonizing by signal, and it's efficient when it works out.
Interesting approach to a "Dark Forest" scenario.
Read “the killing star”
@@hehexd4557 Signal to Noise
Ah yes, Cixil Liu and his goddam Dark Forrest, terrifying everyone previously optimistic about SETI/METI.
can't believe i get to watch this wonderful channel in its infacncy before it becomes big
Very true. I've been a big fan of Robert Miles ever since his appearances on computerphile. His personal channel has incredible content about ai that I highly recommend.
With this level of production and the aesthetic, though, a channel like this is basically guaranteed to shoot into the millions
Same
indeed
Ah yes, common household items.
"What do you mean you don't have an electron depolarizer at home? How do you do anything without", Aliens probably.
what the fuck electron depolarizer? mfs gonna make neu..tron....
1:48
Words can’t stop me
The chance that the danger in a message is discovered before someone implements it is much higher when messages get published right away than when they are kept under wraps, because in the latter case dangerous secret services will still get the message, but we will not learn that it is dangerous before it is too late for countermeasures.
Obviously the best way to handle a potentially dangerous think is to keep acces to it exclusive to a closed, corrupt, manipulative group that has been repeatedly demonstrated to not even care about its own survival in the long term.
5:50 There is also the possibility of an expansionist civilization being some kind of ‚caretaker empire‘ (to use the Stellaris term), meaning they send AI out there to settle space and find other civilization to protect as well.
So I don‘t think that us being more likely to detect expansionist civilization increases the chance of any detected civilization to be malicious. I think those two things are mostly decoupled from each other.
That cat just chilling with the space dog was amazing.
Keep up the good work
Wow your 2nd
This could make a good punchline for a joke in a sci-fi comedy.
These are the channels I love!! Glad this popped in my feed! Subscribed!
"This story is unrealistic"
*_sweats nervously in At-Home CRISPR_*
Loving the animation in this one. So smooth and cool!
haha, I just realized it's not just the voiceover / script reader sounding like Rob Miles, but that's literally whose distinctive voice I recognized. very nice.
This is a very eye-opening theory. I never thought aliens could be that manipulative. Psychological weapon is still the best weapon after all in warfare.
"according to the transmission the aliens will not give us up or let us down"
Exciting to see this series continue - fascinating exploration of SETI related concepts along with a great graphical theme and outstanding narration.
"Oh, hi."
Honestly, there is no dangerous knowledge that can be more dangerous than the absence of knowledge
I like the policy at 7:10 to just say "not our problem, we'll let our kids deal with that lol" much like the pollution of previous generations now being cleaned up.
It seems to me, the question is “how long is the time between “verbal” and physical contact?” If the time is short (which may be more likely considering that Kurtkesat said that our messages will become unreadable after a few hundred light years). If the time is short, wether we listen or not is inconsequential (in universal time) since if they’re hostile, we’ll die after a few millennia anyway. In that case we should listen, in case we get some information which can spare us (either from a helpful civilization working against the hostile one, or by finding some information, let slip from the hostile aliens themselves). This slim chance of survival (in the event of hostile aliens come to us, is better than the zero percent chance of survival from meeting them “face to face”.
That's an interesting point. Perhaps not opening and starting to expand ourselves is another viable survival method - e.g. expanding in the opposite direction
@@tolleythinking1058 "Run Away, Run Away!"(Monty Python: King Arthur and the Holy Grail)
@@tolleythinking1058 But, imagine if the message came from benevolent aliens:
Aliens: "Here's the answer to Life, The Universe, and Everything."
Humanity: "Run Away, Run Away!!"
lol
Scientist: receives message on how to build device from basic materials
Also scientist: shares to entire world before trying to build with basic materials to see if it's not a boomboom first
I'm enjoying the fun little Robert Miles (narrator) easter eggs, like "unaligned AI" at the top of the Existential Threats list!
I love the scientists in this hypothetical event:
"We found weird alien technology stuff"
"Cool, let's tell the entire earth how to make it!"
9:11 because we have a great historical track record of doing that here...
@Iggy Madness Me too, Iggy
Good, but you left out an important argument: By not listening, we could endanger ourselves.
Careful listening is more advisable. As by listening, we could know their existence some time before they might arrive.
The animation is absolutely stunning! So underated!
Third option: the richest and most powerful people of the planet classify information in order to be collaborate with alien invaders.
Such an underrated channel!
I love how this channel started growing. Quality increases from video to video.
Everyone, Please turn off your virtual headsets for an hour or 2, we are being attacked by alien computer virus.
This is also the plot of „Signal to Noise“ by Eric Nylund. Definitely recommend.
These videos are so crazy, entertaining, thought provoking and fired up my imagination and terror of the universe
These videos are criminally underrated. I absolutely love it!!!!!
The most malicious thing that can happen is them simply telling us they exist, they surround us, and we cannot leave our Oort Cloud.
"SENT, LOL"
"Fleebleglorb you are a genius that was such a funny troll"
2:08 "no more doggos" I see you there mister ;)
How about a multi vector disease that kills dogs AND cats....
I have a feeling @Rational Animations already has this topic coming up as he briefly alluded to it in this video, but sending messages to space is definitely more dangerous than listening to messages. The same line of logic from this video is all the more true in the case of broadcasting our own messages, and what's worse is you don't know who is receiving your messages or when they are receiving them, and no matter what you've sent it can be used to locate you. A grabby civilization could send some kind of weapon in the direction of the message and you'd have no way of knowing.
Broadcasting is only dangerous if there is someone who is not yet aware of our existence. But we can detect other planets and their atmospheres with our puny telescopes already. Any interstellar civilisation knows exactly which planets are inhabited hundreds of light years around them.
Sending messages is definitely more dangerous, but the good news is that you won't suffer the consequences of your own actions. The closest living civilisation is probably at the very least thousands of light years away (likely much farther). By the time your message reaches the aliens and they take any action, you and many many generations of your descendants will be long gone. You may have ensured humanity's doom in the future, though.
I'm sorry but
I would be the guy who would build an antimatter bomb out of raw curiosity
Amazing animation. Great voicework. Peak UA-cam!
You're meaning to tell me aliens are going to tell me to press alt+F4 on life?
"Yo, dudes, have you heard of ammonia and bleach?"
Sorry that was me, beware they have seen us! 😶🌫
There's this book series called the Three Body Problem series and all it took for humankind to go kaput was one single message. Great series highly recommend
When the alien message contains: How build an atomic bomb
Humans: 😅 We are all gonna kill ourselves aren’t we?
Dude the scenario you described at the start is similar to getting a message from a Nigerian prince and you think they're trying to give you money but they just download a virus on your computer that destroys everything you own
my opinion is that any message should be classified/censored
cause you can just always relase it later
but if you release it first and then realise it's dangerous, then there's no going back from everyone knowing content of the message
In addition to that, they should classify it at minimum TOP SECRET and not ever disclose that the information was received.
This was such a huge stress to me at one point it put me in a mental hospital. I was panicking because we are constantly broadcasting all our TV and Internet to open space, and any aliens that find our planet will instantly realize they just found a species capable of space travel. What would they do? There's a chance they'd do nothing, but they could even just decide to eliminate us any moment.
There is also a non trivial chance that they will domesticate us.
lol. if there's any aliens who care, they'd have known there's life here for billions of years. if they are threatened by the possibility of intelligent life then they've probably been closely monitoring our planet for millions of years
@@DevinDTV Billions of years? I can see you're not very versed on this topic....
@Norton Wedge what do you mean? As far as we know, life started appearing about 3.7 billion years ago. At that point, earth was already giving off tons of signatures indicating it was a good candidate for harboring life. Yes, for billions of years, we've been showing off what a nice little paradise we have to the universe. We've been showing off our technological growth for a good couple hundred years too, since the industrial revolution when we started pumping a bunch of new stuff into the atmosphere. If we have any close neighbors, they already know we are here for sure.
@@nortonwedge there are potentially alien civilizations within our own galaxy that are more than a billion years more advanced than us. Our star is relatively young, it's like a 20 year old hanging out in a room of people who could be 40 or older.
"But that's exactly what SETI's policy is" Yeah but if they actually would keep it a secret, the dumbest thing they could do would be to announce to the world that they are going to keep it a secret. They'd constantly be hounded by people wondering "Did you discover alien life and aren't telling the world????"
The issue is that if we decide alien messages can become classified information, you can immediately expect the US army to become the sole holder of this information, thus keeping the choice at the hand of the president, or worse, a few rogue generals keeping it a secret from them.
Who said anything about handing over the information to the US government? SETI researchers should hand it over to the UN.
When hiking in the woods you want to be moderately loud as to not spook any animals and cause them to attack. Ring the bell, make them aware and you might just go unharmed
Incredible animations and captivating story as always.
The theory is fascinanting, but at the same time the doomsdaymongering feels so petty and insignificant that the video ends up more as a joke
Ay! I really like the voice over guy. Miles better than most.
nice
"You now breathe manually."
Nice video, would be interesting thinking what weapons one of those aliens from the ‘dark forest’ could try to use against us, like relativistic missiles or something
Self replicating nanorobots. You can send an instruction with all the explanations and safeguards that ensure that it is safe. The prospect of having post-scarcity economy will be too strong to resist.
And when they (us) realize that the safeguards have one fatal flaw, it is too late, and their planet is consumed by grey goo.
Highly recommend the remembrance of earth past trilogy. Best sci fi ive read last decade
I'd guess it would be something that would be more catered to a civilization sophisticated enough to be an impediment to them. No reason to chuck near light speed artillery at every noisy clump of rock they encounter, since that might notify any more developed civilization of both their presence and their intention in the event such a civilization had the foresight to develop decoy worlds on the periphery of their own territory.
We aren't a threat of any kind to already grabby aliens, and could easily be contained to our own planet with relatively little debris in orbit to be dealt with later. Whatever they send out would need to be subtle and specific, since the possibility of biting the tail of a bigger fish would be very real and very disastrous.
@@microwave221 extermely well thought the idea of decoy worlds for more advanced civilizations to catch agitators on its border
4:29 *Alien message is the instructions for an A.I.' was the premise of "A for Andromeda". Abook, a TV series and a movie. (1961)*
8:20 *Oh. Apparently everyone knew that already.*
Exact reason I came to the comments to mention "A for Andromeda". Great book, I also recommend. Feels good to be reminded of it!
So now the question is should we send dangerous messages into outer space in the future?
This reminds me of "Supreme Surrender" by Rooster Teeth , Aliens were destroying our communication dishes, but it turns out, they were just trying to communicate and our equipment cant take their way of communication.
Me at my job in the supermarket watching a teenager buy a water bottle, plant pot, stick of gum, and whatever that 4th thing is
As a human I fear more for the aliens than us 😂
An alien sending me malware and stealing my credit card info is my worst fear
interestingly horrifying
In March, the source code for the LLaMA AI was leaked to the whole world. In just two months open source tinkerers have apparently advanced the model so that it's nearly on par with Bard. Perhaps we don't need the aliens.
5:21 for a moment i thought that said ‘British’ which does make sense in this context
Same lol
8:30 i swear im not dirty minded but that caught in my eye, why jiggle physics 💀💀
2:04 PFF-
Aliens be like: we do a little bit of trolling
Giving you are proposing to send robot centipedes to dissemble the Universe aliens have good reasons to send us such a trojan gift. But a more realistic scenario would be a "dark forest strike" with an asteroid sent at close to relativistic speeds.
This would give alien leadership plausible deniability when governing their own species. "We shared unlimited energy with the hoomans, and they accidentally destroyed themselves..."
Only if they're close enough. A message would just be the first tactic, before they've reached an alien physically. Realistically, they'd do both.
Don't you just love when you're a brand new viewer to a channel and all they talk about in a video is stuff that happened in other videos so you have no clue what the hell they're talking about it's great
Lol
Why would they send a risky message when they can just send a rock at a non-negligible fraction of the speed of light.
message arrive faster
"Hey boys, we found us some Scooby Snacks!"
Earth 🌎- "Uh-oh!"