I paid 5 Bakeries to make EXPENSIVE Edible Wedding Favors!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,4 тис.

  • @TheIcingArtist
    @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +3599

    What if I tried this again, but said ONE dessert only.. Like one SINGLE macaroon etc. and sent some inspo for my expectations??? Idk... what do you guys think??

    • @michelle-sophiehaas9824
      @michelle-sophiehaas9824 3 роки тому +52

      Yessss

    • @rynfiaryn
      @rynfiaryn 3 роки тому +119

      I think yes, you should try again and be much more specific about your expectations!

    • @veenamalhotra8687
      @veenamalhotra8687 3 роки тому +27

      Yes!! That is really a gr8 idea Laurie!! It's awesome..always waiting for a new vid of urs...lots of 💘

    • @Cubisum
      @Cubisum 3 роки тому +31

      And actually have them follow up with you to ensure it’s being made correctly.

    • @laurac2385
      @laurac2385 3 роки тому +28

      Yes! The pics you showed us were amazing! They all kinda blew it! I thought the mini cake was beautiful but when you showed the cupcakes that were inspo...so much better!

  • @martabrulinski6764
    @martabrulinski6764 3 роки тому +2528

    The mini wedding cake was the only one that felt like it fit the $30 price point. I can't speak to the pies or cupcakes, but as someone who has made a lot of macarons for fun, there is a lot more you can do to plus up even a simple macaron.

    • @carrie9716
      @carrie9716 3 роки тому +60

      Right? Like fillings, icing, painting, stacking multiple. Anything more than the same ones you get from behind the glass counter.

    • @damaskito
      @damaskito 3 роки тому +3

      Yeah but they don't survive transport.

    • @martabrulinski6764
      @martabrulinski6764 3 роки тому +33

      @@damaskito they do...as I've driven them to people in plastic Tupperware. You can take the filling a line it with edible pearls. On top you can do a much nicer things than clunky gold type, you can even creme brulee the top of the macaron

    • @damaskito
      @damaskito 3 роки тому +6

      @@martabrulinski6764 yes, you can.

    • @melbapeach162
      @melbapeach162 3 роки тому +18

      This is what happens when anything is for a wedding though 😅 price shoots up but doesn't mean it'll be any better quality!

  • @ashleyfwtx
    @ashleyfwtx 3 роки тому +3353

    I would be totally pumped if I went to a wedding and the favor was that mini cake 😍

  • @one_smol_duck
    @one_smol_duck 2 роки тому +150

    I love the bakery that gave you the cupcake you said you wanted, but also added in the mini cake they _knew_ you wanted.

  • @shiaras4675
    @shiaras4675 3 роки тому +2043

    The mini cake won this round. I feel like that was the "contender" that made the most effort to check all the boxes in the order.

    • @christinasanderford5849
      @christinasanderford5849 3 роки тому +20

      Whats ironic is she didn't even order a mini cake, that was the cupcake round, lol 😂.

    • @shiaras4675
      @shiaras4675 3 роки тому +6

      @@christinasanderford5849 But she did say they offered it and they did give cupcakes still. Either way, I am desperately wishing for Willie Wonka's TV so I could taste it hahahahaha

    • @cakerbaker9965
      @cakerbaker9965 3 роки тому +8

      The pies look so unappetizing vs the mini cake/cupcakes!

    • @aarenmarchi4667
      @aarenmarchi4667 3 роки тому +11

      I genuinely just commented about the mini cake lol "You're a lot nicer than I would be with that one bakery that basically forced your hand on the mini cake. Like they clearly wanted to impress you that way with it and intentionally put less time into the cupcake. Like that unprofessionalism to me is enough for me to pick another bakery"
      Like regardless if it looked nice, if it's my wedding and I've ordered something specific - it's not up to the person at the bakery to just ignore that....
      **To edit this: ALL the bakeries failed. They ignored the customer request completely. They honestly should be glad she doesn't link the bakeries because their customer service is horrid

    • @zoe8010
      @zoe8010 3 роки тому +14

      @@aarenmarchi4667 i’m not sure if they put less time into the cupcakes, the cupcakes are still very well done, but the bakery probably knew that they would be able to do something more exciting looking with a mini cake which is why they added it.
      they still delivered what she ordered

  • @tiffanylee3634
    @tiffanylee3634 3 роки тому +1894

    As a bride, I wouldn't want to spend that much money on an edible favor but hands down, that mini cake is amazing! I would love to give it and receive it.

    • @damaskito
      @damaskito 3 роки тому +28

      No one in their right mind would charge 30 dollars for a pastry, if you're planning on doing edible flavors the packaging is the most expensive part so just package yourself.

    • @ariana_208
      @ariana_208 3 роки тому +53

      @@damaskito mini doesn’t always mean less detailed.
      I would argue it’s harder to decorate 100 mini cakes than 100 small cakes.

    • @damaskito
      @damaskito 3 роки тому +8

      @@ariana_208 yeah, nobody is arguing.

    • @BettyAlexandriaPride
      @BettyAlexandriaPride 3 роки тому +9

      @@damaskito They didn't mean that literally. 😅 That being said, I get what you're saying about the favors.

    • @pbelle1971
      @pbelle1971 3 роки тому +3

      It is so pretty! Love the mini cake!

  • @amberpdavis
    @amberpdavis 3 роки тому +1148

    Laurie is always so full of joy even when she’s baffled and frustrated with things I’m always smiling watching her videos

    • @TheIcingArtist
      @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +183

      Maybe my shirt should have been "Happily unhappy." LOL

    • @shreeyachodankar2452
      @shreeyachodankar2452 3 роки тому +6

      @@TheIcingArtist yea lol

    • @girlmeetsuke2980
      @girlmeetsuke2980 3 роки тому +4

      Couldn’t agree more. She’s a ray of positivity and I’m here for it 😊

  • @paulaj7682
    @paulaj7682 3 роки тому +817

    I don't understand the lack of "wow" cupcake liners. A $30.00 cupcake demands a luxurious wrapper or even multiple layers. Lace cutouts and gold or something, anything besides a common wrapper you can get from any supermarket.

    • @TheIcingArtist
      @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +141

      Yes!!!! Right lol?!

    • @BettyAlexandriaPride
      @BettyAlexandriaPride 3 роки тому +13

      @@TheIcingArtist Omg if you do this again can you request a pretty liner?

    • @educatorally3875
      @educatorally3875 3 роки тому +47

      @@BettyAlexandriaPride since it's a wedding favor this should be a given in my opinion.

    • @tiffanylastinger3925
      @tiffanylastinger3925 3 роки тому +20

      Plus like its specifically a wedding cupcakes which obviously screams elegant

    • @lunabelletheinsane
      @lunabelletheinsane 3 роки тому +23

      These also weren't the final product. They were expecting her, if she chose them, to come back with feedback - and if it was doable, I'm sure they'd do it.

  • @KathrynDeSinaasappelen
    @KathrynDeSinaasappelen 3 роки тому +925

    So a little trick. NEVER tell a bakery you're doing something for a wedding. There is a tendency to add a "wedding tax"
    I wanted a simple wedding cake. 2 tier chocolate cake, chocolate filling, with no toppers, white icing and blue flowers on the side. Enough to feed about 50.
    My mom went to two bakeries and they quoted her 500$ at 1 and 650$ at the other.
    I went in saying it was going to be my Birthday. and that same cake was 75$. It was stunning, and delicious, and we only paid 75$.
    I think the issue is you said "wedding favor"

    • @TheIcingArtist
      @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +373

      Very ture honestly. The two bakeries I worked at did this. They had a birthday/celebration price sheet and a wedding cake price sheet.

    • @lovefromlila
      @lovefromlila 3 роки тому +117

      Can we stop with this 'wedding tax' crap please. Unscrupulous business owners will find any excuse to charge you more. Legitimate, professional business owners recognise that your wedding day is a big event, and requires a lot more attention and detail. So we charge accordingly. Find trustworthy suppliers, and they'll charge fairly for the work you're asking for. Find questionable suppliers and they'll shaft you.

    • @gimygaming8655
      @gimygaming8655 3 роки тому +102

      @@lovefromlila it honestly depends on what you are looking for. If you want a simple wedding cake then just saying it's for your birthday will turn out good. If you are looking for very very fancy and high end then it's understandable for the price. If though just by saying it's your birthday instead of wedding for the same exact cake is cheaper and it's a simple cake and what you want then I get what they are saying.

    • @lovefromlila
      @lovefromlila 3 роки тому +48

      @@gimygaming8655 but you're missing the point. If you have to lie to your cake designer to get a 'cheaper' price, then that designer is unscrupulous IMO. However, a professional designer will be costing in a lot of things for a wedding cake which makes it more expensive e.g. extra consultations and admin time, samples etc. If you don't want or need those then a respectable designer will price accordingly. It's only the unscrupulous ones who will have no reason to justify why you need to pay the higher price in that situation and you would need to lie to. In which case, the issue is that they're a shady business and you shouldn't be booking with them anyway.

    • @grandy2875
      @grandy2875 3 роки тому +100

      It's not just food prices that get jacked up, venue prices are another rort.
      We were looking for a simple basic hall, nothing fancy, just 4 walls, a roof and a kitchenette, something big enough to hold the party in. We rang around and got prices, then a week later mum rang the same venues and got prices for a 60th birthday party and the price for the wedding was 4 times higher than the price for the b/day party... same venues, same amount of guests, same everything, the only difference was what the venue owner was told the place would be used for... it's the biggest scam going...

  • @MichelleLSmith
    @MichelleLSmith 3 роки тому +525

    That mini-cake!!!! Maybe if they did the leaves in the darker green it would get your 10/10. Love your videos....they are like bursts of sunshine.

    • @lovebug8482
      @lovebug8482 3 роки тому +2

      do you think it was worth 30 bucks tho?im thinking more like 20,especially for 100 total favors

    • @elenpena42564
      @elenpena42564 3 роки тому +16

      @@lovebug8482 I'd say that's precisely why they are worth it. One of those I don't think I would pay 30 dollars for, but 100 of those for the same day definitely seem like an insane amount of work that's well worth he 3000 dollars

    • @thatssoari3533
      @thatssoari3533 3 роки тому +2

      @@lovebug8482 you clearly do not bake. for the price of the ingredients, skill, and labor, it is 100% worth 30 dollars.

    • @lovebug8482
      @lovebug8482 3 роки тому +1

      @@thatssoari3533 nope, youre right I dont! thats why I was curious and asked

    • @thatssoari3533
      @thatssoari3533 3 роки тому +1

      @@lovebug8482 sorry for being aggressive. i just feel like slot of people feel like baking isn’t hard work (at least on tiktok) so they always attack them when they hear their prices. like i’ve seen so many disgusting comments on cakes that prob took a baker days. (bakers freeze their cakes and decorate them one to two days before the delivery date, most have a specific days for baking, and then others for decorating). i do hear what your saying, you can get a whole cake at cold stone for 30 dollars, but they’re a corporate business. ive never seen commercial bakeries have those low prices, well because they can’t, they do not get hundreds of customers a day like cold stone. walmart makes the pressure of bakeries prices even worse because they’re cakes are like freaking ten bucks, but ive the taste of commercial bakeries are 100x better and i feel people do not know that unless they’ve ordered from one, and most haven’t because they can just get cakes from their local store.

  • @kitschydevil
    @kitschydevil 3 роки тому +422

    You were NOT too emotionally involved, especially if this was for your ACTUAL wedding! That is a very special day! Would love to see you go back to the bakeries with your critiques and give them a second chance to fix what you didn't like, and see what they come up with! Love this idea, so invested!

    • @educatorally3875
      @educatorally3875 3 роки тому +8

      Yes!! This is a fantastic idea!!

    • @kcanded
      @kcanded 3 роки тому +6

      I would love to see a follow-up to this video as you described!

  • @shreeya5167
    @shreeya5167 3 роки тому +225

    I love how she's so positive and kind towards the one she's dissapointed in too

    • @TheIcingArtist
      @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +70

      At the end of the day, everyone is trying their best! There's always room for improvement even with the best bakers in the world. But all of them honestly have their pros and cons.

  • @DarkLadyPhoenix
    @DarkLadyPhoenix 3 роки тому +200

    Damn, that mini cake!!! I love how that bakery is all like, "Here's what you ordered but here's what you could have instead!" We'll show you! ;)

  • @mamabear7605
    @mamabear7605 3 роки тому +306

    The mini cake would be perfect as a replacement for one large one, especially for smaller weddings!

    • @skeletonkeybooks
      @skeletonkeybooks 3 роки тому +32

      When one of my close friends got married, she had the bakery do a few different medium-sized cakes instead of one big one, and then for people like my husband with all sorts of crazy dietary issues, she had them do fancy mini cakes like that one. It was really special.

    • @martah5369
      @martah5369 3 роки тому +7

      @@skeletonkeybooks that's what I was thinking, great for guests with allergies.

  • @erinf245
    @erinf245 3 роки тому +39

    This is kind of a specific thing to mention, but I really like that you don’t have a formal intro. Feels natural that way, like you’re having a conversation with a friend.

  • @danielleoliver1734
    @danielleoliver1734 3 роки тому +93

    Remember, these were all samples. If it was for your wedding you could go back with feedback and confirm a few changes before the actual order for the wedding, so a few colours/ details could easily be tweaked

    • @sarasamaletdin4574
      @sarasamaletdin4574 3 роки тому +18

      Tweaks like colors sure. But some just lacked effort or were completely different than what was asked.

    • @krisdiane
      @krisdiane 3 роки тому +7

      @@sarasamaletdin4574 yeah, I don't think any of them were up to the task aside from the mini cake bakery. And they should have put that effort in to what she asked for instead of what they wanted her to order.

  • @theothermrs.weasley4984
    @theothermrs.weasley4984 3 роки тому +39

    I'm kinda in love with the pies. Oddly enough I love the green. It's very earthy feeling. I also love that they look super handmade which gives them a more intimate feel.

    • @GypsyxDarling
      @GypsyxDarling 3 роки тому +5

      I felt the same way! They matched the vibe of the moodboard even if the colors weren't all there!

  • @lilnoodle4924
    @lilnoodle4924 3 роки тому +178

    I’ve never heard of cake truffles so I thought chocolate truffles were just fancy chocolates. The blue was wrong but it seems like they got the other colors closer. Maybe Laurie could make a video creating the exact wedding favors she was hoping for herself so we can really see what her vision was for this because she seems to have been really inspired & excited about the idea.

    • @bethd.6670
      @bethd.6670 3 роки тому +26

      Yeah, when I hear truffle, I think of fancy chocolates. I hadn't heard of a cake truffles until recently.

    • @jendubay3782
      @jendubay3782 3 роки тому +11

      They’re just renaming cake pops. Which are gross.

    • @jendubay3782
      @jendubay3782 3 роки тому +2

      They’re just renaming cake pops. Which are gross.

    • @GoddessNeith
      @GoddessNeith 3 роки тому +11

      "cake truffles" are cake pops only larger.

    • @lunabelletheinsane
      @lunabelletheinsane 3 роки тому +6

      Cake truffles are really just cake pops, but fancier. I'm not huge on cake pops, so I would probably not enjoy a cake truffle favor. My best friend had DIVINE cookies as her favor - and I wanted to eat the whole basket. It was just a simple cookie though with their names piped on it.

  • @Kizzmycntryazz
    @Kizzmycntryazz 3 роки тому +78

    I helped my friend make autumn scented candles for her wedding favors it was amazing they smelt Heavenly. since her wedding was it's the beginning of October and totally autumn themed. She used 1 or 1 1/2 ounce Mason jars they were so cute.

    • @ShastaAnn
      @ShastaAnn 3 роки тому +10

      Kizzmycntryazz, I love the candle idea!! I'm kind of tired of getting tiny plants that I never end up planting...or seed packets.

    • @bonniehowell9206
      @bonniehowell9206 3 роки тому +4

      What a perfect idea for an autumn wedding !

    • @Kizzmycntryazz
      @Kizzmycntryazz 3 роки тому +2

      @@ShastaAnn I got a seed packet from one went home to plant the seeds and they were all dead LOL nothing grew

  • @archiecat4182
    @archiecat4182 3 роки тому +71

    I’d run with this idea again. Try other places. Love your purple hair with your green tee shirt. Your personality is a joy. ❤️

    • @TheIcingArtist
      @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +47

      Anyone agree???? I would LOVE to and change up a few things to see if that yeilds better results, like saying ONE SINGLE macaroon or cookie etc.

    • @diyak3069
      @diyak3069 3 роки тому +4

      Months of planning deserves a second chance!!!

    • @lillieemery
      @lillieemery 3 роки тому +7

      @@TheIcingArtist Yes! Do another one. But I think it would help to give them 2 inspiration boards. One for the wedding and one of examples of the item you chose them for. I think it was just a new concept for the bakeries and they didn’t even have a clue how to rise to the challenge (but really wanted to…except for the last one…I dont know what happened there!)

    • @cherylcolby5539
      @cherylcolby5539 3 роки тому +1

      I agree... skip the cake and cupcakes this time and see what else they can do. Obviously it was a challenge for them to do the chocolates and macaroons, so it would cool to see if anyone else can step and deliver a better product.

    • @lucinda2329
      @lucinda2329 2 роки тому

      @@TheIcingArtist Absolutely! And def ask for one single favor to clarify things. I LOVED your idea and they didnt get close to executing it!

  • @TheIcingArtist
    @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +219

    I was SO excited for this video!! But how do you think they all did with the challenge??

    • @siennascott9751
      @siennascott9751 3 роки тому

      PLEASE NOTICE ME

    • @laurenschenck5355
      @laurenschenck5355 3 роки тому +3

      Some of them did great some did okay honestly ❤️

    • @linseylinsey
      @linseylinsey 3 роки тому +18

      Eh, just okay. The mini cake was probably my favorite and the most WOW factor to get at a wedding. I wonder if some of them would have been more excited to do this if they knew it wasn't going to result in an order of HUNDREDS of them later. They probably took into consideration the labor if they landed the job.

    • @quietkid-zj7mr
      @quietkid-zj7mr 3 роки тому +1

      6th reply hiiiii please reply me 😊😊😊😊🤗🤗❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ i love your videos i am your biggest fan. You inspire me a lot

    • @hetalsheth3210
      @hetalsheth3210 3 роки тому

      Only use one colour for a cake

  • @rossjones1530
    @rossjones1530 3 роки тому +136

    That last baker just didn’t read the brief properly, that’s all I can think!
    Absolute standout was the mini cake, if I got that as a favour I’d be counting down the days until the couple renewed their vows. 😆

    • @GoddessNeith
      @GoddessNeith 3 роки тому

      but sadly THAT'S THERE J.O.B. to make the customer happy and do what THEY want. and they failed miserably.

    • @rossjones1530
      @rossjones1530 3 роки тому +6

      @@GoddessNeith oh I agree! It wasn’t an excuse, more an explanation. 😆
      I’d have asked for at least a 50% refund on that order, seeing as at least half of the order was… y’know… not what was ordered…

    • @paigek9923
      @paigek9923 2 роки тому +2

      One of my teachers had an expensive $30,000 wedding and after she brought in these extremely cute cupcakes and they were so good. As favors she had hand sanitizer bottles that said “spead love not germs” with her and her husband’s name on them because she had her wedding last year when Covid wasn’t still kinda a thing.

  • @kimberleyandaj
    @kimberleyandaj 3 роки тому +70

    I am a frequent viewer and an infrequent commenter BUT I had to let you know how much I enjoyed this video! How creative to do edible favors, this is not something I’d ever thought of before. That mini cake was perfection! Love all of the work and planning put into your content!

    • @TheIcingArtist
      @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +12

      I was SO exicted for this one. Out all all the videos we planned for months, this was the one I couldn't wait to film! I feel like everyone just threw in the towel a bit for it but also mainly got wrapped up in giving me MULTIPLE desserts to make it worth it since I said it could be one or it could be multiple. If I could go back, I would 100% say ONE. ONE SINGLE macaroon etc. Give me one $30 macaroon.

    • @Cannonball62000
      @Cannonball62000 3 роки тому

      @@TheIcingArtist I really think you should go again and see with you being even more specific what the result may be...
      Also, do you privately share your videos with the bakers you dealt with? It may be good for them to see where they are going wrong for future client bookings (or they may just be nasty! Not everyone takes constructive criticism very well!).

  • @MLB021285
    @MLB021285 Рік тому +3

    At first I thought the pies were quiches. Like green asparagus quiches, which would have fit perfectly with the vibe of the mood board. Now I want quiches as wedding favors. Too bad I’m already married 😄

  • @hibanizami
    @hibanizami 3 роки тому +158

    That’s what we did for my uncles wedding this past July, my aunt order a ton of cute packages and we filled them with candy and stuff which matched the wedding colours

  • @mochibear8933
    @mochibear8933 3 роки тому +54

    If I'm spending $30 dollars per favour, I don't want to see crappy cake cases. The mini cake won hands down, despite the lack of dark green.

    • @rebekah969
      @rebekah969 2 роки тому +1

      888999ttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt

  • @shinynickel05
    @shinynickel05 3 роки тому +20

    My wedding (three years ago) was a mix of art deco and Halloween. I did edible favors in the form of a trick-or-treat spread where people got to fill up their bags with goodies. It's absolutely delightful how everyone instantly turns into a kid again in the face of a trick-or-treat bar (including my husband's grandma).

  • @esalmond2286
    @esalmond2286 3 роки тому +33

    I feel like Kevin needs to have a microphone too. Love his commentary. You guys are a fun team.

  • @aimz54
    @aimz54 3 роки тому +149

    Not sure if it’s an Australian thing but we call the round balls truffles, so maybe it was a miscommunication?
    But the colours being totally wrong doesn’t give me much hope that it was

    • @irminafatima333
      @irminafatima333 3 роки тому +30

      even in the uk we call the round balls truffles too

    • @BiterAvid
      @BiterAvid 3 роки тому +16

      In the US, a truffle can be any shape. It is what is inside that makes it a truffle. That is very interesting. Very few of them in the US are round balls. Usually other shapes.

    • @karolinapupi19977
      @karolinapupi19977 3 роки тому +6

      @@BiterAvid truffles in the UK are soft

    • @jendubay3782
      @jendubay3782 3 роки тому +8

      Yeah, that’s what truffles are. She wanted cake pops. Which are gross.

    • @brittneyburton5365
      @brittneyburton5365 3 роки тому +6

      We call them truffles here in Alabama, USA too! A "cake truffle" or "cake pop" are the round balls--not the chocolate candies. But I def think had she provided him pics of the actual desserts she wanted it would've helped them.

  • @anabee6545
    @anabee6545 3 роки тому +10

    Edible wedding favors has always been a thing here in Brazil 😍 we have this thing called "bem casado" that is kind of a soft alfajor with Dulce de Leche in the middle. It's traditionally used as wedding favor. The couple just attach a tag with their name and day of the wedding in it. It's delicious and a must have in every Brazilian wedding 😍

  • @matthewhines9787
    @matthewhines9787 3 роки тому +15

    My first reaction when I heard the challenge was something like "Making a sample of what you would do is not applicable in this situation because design, purchasing of supplies, and other factors are very up-in-the-air until an actual order for 200 is made."
    For example, there may be something that they really want to do to make it ornate/fancy, but doing that for 1 sample may not be possible because the supplies can only be bought in bulk. Or perhaps they are unsure of the logistics of preparing 200 of something, and keeping all of them fresh and presentable and don't want to show you that sample because the plan needs to be explored and worked out.
    I mean...is one note of a song completely representative of the whole song?

    • @allisonjustice678
      @allisonjustice678 3 роки тому +1

      Such a good point !!!

    • @BrittanyArtPoetry
      @BrittanyArtPoetry 3 роки тому +6

      Interesting point, though based on the beginning of the video I’m assuming she went to bakeries that specifically offer this type of wedding service, in which case they may already have the supplies on hand, or arguably be expected to provide the service in someway

  • @inspired2createl.l.c563
    @inspired2createl.l.c563 3 роки тому +42

    I’m so shock! 👎 I thought I was going to see the WOW factors! I sent this video as inspiration to my business partner in hopes she’ll charge more for her work. My business partner does detail work on her cakes and treats that take her days to complete. Thank You for this video!

    • @gimygaming8655
      @gimygaming8655 3 роки тому +3

      Hopefully she raises her prices if she is good. Cause a lot of time places that are well known charge high prices for this crap while small bakers do an amazing job yet charge very little for their work.
      Yes, it makes them desirable but they still need money

    • @melbapeach162
      @melbapeach162 3 роки тому +1

      Definitely show her this, people will always be out there charging more for less!

  • @amyspeers8012
    @amyspeers8012 3 роки тому +8

    I made wedding favors for my friends. I thought they were going to ask me to make their wedding cake, so I immediately said yes to the favors. They had a garden wedding. The tables were long and they had small metal buckets with flowers all along the table. For their favors, they wanted 4 small cookies in a small metal bucket…plain butter cookie with American lemon buttercream. Instead of 4 cookies, it became 8 because they wanted 4 sandwich cookies. Oh…and there were 100 guests. They turned out super cute but OMG they were a ton of work!

  • @ticketyboo2456
    @ticketyboo2456 3 роки тому +14

    In the UK edible favours have been a thing for many, many years. Most traditionally they're sugared almonds ( pastel sugar-coated almonds ) in tiny little bags or boxes. The number supplied is significant to something like bringing good fortune etc etc.

    • @zoerobinson9897
      @zoerobinson9897 3 роки тому +1

      Came here to say the same!

    • @nancyhgardneryoutube8494
      @nancyhgardneryoutube8494 3 роки тому

      Thats italian

    • @ticketyboo2456
      @ticketyboo2456 3 роки тому

      @@nancyhgardneryoutube8494 No I don't think so lol. It may have been adopted by the Italians or coincided but it's very much a British tradition lol.

    • @AnnabellaRedwood
      @AnnabellaRedwood 2 роки тому

      We also do it in Australia. 😊

    • @azuraathena
      @azuraathena 2 роки тому

      What you are talking about is a Bomboniere, the favour originated in Italy, but the name is french origin (Bonbonniére - Bonbon meaning candy). The tradition has spread around Europe, but it definitely didn’t start in the uk. My parents had them at their wedding, as well as my baptism and first holy communion.

  • @jaimew1539
    @jaimew1539 3 роки тому +110

    Maybe you could get “bake-able” pies so they can bake them at home and tie a little instruction sheet to the pie. There is cake and food at the wedding, so they don’t need to eat it there and they would look better.

    • @sierraroseprzybyla3333
      @sierraroseprzybyla3333 3 роки тому +17

      They’re not for eating there… it’s a little sweet something for the guests to eat when they get home (like a midnight snack). It stems from the tradition of sending guests home with a slice of wedding cake.

    • @tiffanylastinger3925
      @tiffanylastinger3925 3 роки тому +15

      Thats so cute but idk how you would keep them fresh and safe because they would need to be refrigerated

    • @lunabelletheinsane
      @lunabelletheinsane 3 роки тому +7

      @@tiffanylastinger3925 The would probably keep them refrigerated at the venue - most venues provide refrigeration of some sort - even outdoor ones have a kitchen of some sort if it's an actual wedding venue - and not a place being used a wedding venue. In which case - caterers will bring their own if they need to - and if that's case, you could probably pack your favors in a container with dry ice to keep them cold for the duration of the wedding and bring them out near the end. If you leave early - you can usually ask for it or just do without if the bride or groom doesn't offer it to you (they usually do).

    • @alliemosley3133
      @alliemosley3133 3 роки тому +3

      Or putting dry ingredients for a secret family cookie recipe into a mason jar with a ribbon and instruction sheet.

    • @TheMotherofTacos
      @TheMotherofTacos 2 роки тому +2

      Mine are getting drunkenly eaten in the cab on the way home raw or not, so

  • @racheloverton3061
    @racheloverton3061 3 роки тому +2

    I do custom decorated sugar cookies! I think you should do a video about decorated sugar cookies! Everything is so detailed I think it would be a great to see how different artists go off same mood board!

  • @anayah8521
    @anayah8521 3 роки тому +4

    The mini cake was beautiful! I would have liked to see detailed cookies…cookies can pretty much be transformed into anything! Imagine the cookie you could have gotten with a $30 budget? I know some people will say cookies have already been done, but the versatility of a sugar cookie is pretty much limitless! I loved this video!

  • @GuineaPigLover130
    @GuineaPigLover130 3 роки тому +19

    I love how that bakery fought you on that mini cake, and they won😂💖It’s gorgeous!!

  • @nicolcacola
    @nicolcacola 3 роки тому +174

    The first box, even though I'm not a baker, I would never find that acceptable to give to a customer.

    • @nicoleavedisian242
      @nicoleavedisian242 3 роки тому

      @@EllaFox you know they’re not real leaves right??

    • @jaclynholbrooks3338
      @jaclynholbrooks3338 3 роки тому +24

      @@nicoleavedisian242 hey florist here those were real there was eal leather leaf and alstromeria in the box with the food. Unless they washed it, I agree that's pretty gross

  • @deepthoughtswithjessica
    @deepthoughtswithjessica 3 роки тому +21

    They should have streaked dark green in that white icing on the mini cake. It’s gorgeous!

  • @purepunk18
    @purepunk18 3 роки тому +10

    Lol girl. You were confusing me at the start! They made macarons (mack-a -rons). Macaroons are very tasty though! Still love your videos. The ideas you get are amazing.

  • @stephanieromines4934
    @stephanieromines4934 3 роки тому +2

    My favorite was the mini cake and in my opinion that bakery did the best out of all of them. The last one i think they were confused or something because it wasn’t anything like you asked ( except the heart shape ) Now, if I wasn’t sure or had any doubts about what the customer wanted I would take 5 minutes & call to be sure. I absolutely love your facial expressions everytime you get to see whatever you’ve ordered for the 1st time or when you take the 1st bite.. especially in the tasting your face gives it away & I love it!! Thanks for another awesome video!!

  • @CarboneCat
    @CarboneCat 3 роки тому +14

    The mini wedding cake wins hands down. At my wedding, we had a candy bar filled with candies that were of our wedding colors and our guests can filled paper bags at their hearts content. So in the end, that also served as wedding favors.

    • @loading1345
      @loading1345 3 роки тому

      Omg I'd be soon happy if there were m and Ms haha

  • @cadensandstrom
    @cadensandstrom 3 роки тому +27

    I loved the look of that mini-cake! That would completely blow me away if I got that as a wedding favor!

  • @taylor6528
    @taylor6528 2 роки тому +4

    obviously, the mini cake is stunning, but i think the pies are also pretty cool! its hard to get detail with pastry, and even if the coloring's a bit off, i feel like the flavors really match the color and vibes of the moodboard SUPER well.

  • @cherylcolby5539
    @cherylcolby5539 3 роки тому +42

    I thought the pies were super disappointing but those truffles failed miserably. I would get my money back. The first two were great. I LOVED the mini cake. What great ideas!

  • @geelizz
    @geelizz 3 роки тому +17

    Aww that was disappointing! I loved the mini cake! So beautiful! I have to say though, my absolute favorite wedding party favor was a cookie and candy box that guests got to choose from. They had it all laid out on the table and there were little takeout boxes (think like a chinese paper takeout box) that the guests got to stuff full for later eating. It was great!

  • @educatorally3875
    @educatorally3875 3 роки тому +1

    This is so crazy....the incompetency of people and inability to do what the customer ASKS for is just astonishing to me. The mini cake was the STAR of this episode. I don't have an issue with the fact that this bakery gave you a mini cake even though you specifically wanted it to be a cupcake because the mini cake was in addition to what you asked for. They knew you'd like it based on the detail you were asking for. First time viewer here and definitely subscribing. Great video!

  • @judymckerrow6720
    @judymckerrow6720 3 роки тому +51

    The cake was beautiful, it would be extra special if it were a mini version of the wedding cake. I would love to receive a favor like that🌺💚🙃

  • @trueinthekitchen
    @trueinthekitchen 3 роки тому

    I respect that the cupcake/mini-cake place heard that you wanted cupcakes but still recommended the mini-cakes, for the same price they knew you could get more! Super nice of them.

  • @roche320
    @roche320 3 роки тому +12

    We had meringue pops at our wedding. They looked so good and I was so glad we didn't go with a glass or something like that. Our extended family frown upon edible favours, but there's a reason why they're extended and not immediate.

    • @shefalikar
      @shefalikar 3 роки тому +5

      The last sentence made me laugh, even I think the same of my relatives.

  • @natashawren4456
    @natashawren4456 3 роки тому +27

    The mini cake is adorable, the rest were a bit underwhelming. I'm just as confused as you with the truffles, how did they decide on those colours 😅.
    I'd love to see you do another one of these videos with other bakeries. Loving your positivity as always.

  • @colesmith7509
    @colesmith7509 3 роки тому +14

    What I’ve really learned from this channel is if I ever order from a professional bakery, I will be disappointed 😭

  • @adriennetochter6873
    @adriennetochter6873 3 роки тому +2

    That mini cake was gorgeous! I think that bakery won. They gave you what you asked for, and also what is clearly their expertise for your consideration. That last one with the truffles... Something I always admire about you is your determination to say positive things. And I could see what a struggle that was with the truffles. Looks like they really didn’t want your business, though it would have been more honest and less frustrating to just say so. If it were me and I ever wanted to order fancy truffles, I sure wouldn’t order from them. Thanks for another fun video. I love your comparisons and this-into-that. ♥️

  • @Clarky1951
    @Clarky1951 3 роки тому +233

    Was excited to see this challenge. A very interesting one indeed. Macrons we’re blah..a few brush strokes aren’t really decorations. As you showed, there are many ways to decorate a macron, and a few gold brush strokes didn’t cut it. The decorations were basically the bed of flowers. I really liked the mini cake. Well executed and delicately pretty. Cupcake/cupcakes were pretty, but wasn’t impressed with the decorations. Pies…no. A fail. Couldn’t see any of the decorations you asked for. Very little to no colour. But unless you used someone like The Pieous..well you know. She’s amazing. And the chocolates..Total Epic Fail. Firstly they didn’t even make what you asked them to. Secondly, they were just chocolates in a box. And zero, zip decorations. If I had the $$, I would go with the individual cakes. That being said. A good many of the cakes would either be left behind at the venue. Or taken home and thrown away. I was at a wedding where cupcakes were being given away. Only half were taken. But I guess if you gots the dough, it’s about impressing, not the waste.

    • @kimitsukouseki9872
      @kimitsukouseki9872 3 роки тому +5

      I agree with everything you said.

    • @tiffanylastinger3925
      @tiffanylastinger3925 3 роки тому +10

      You could literally make shapes with macaroons like they could've made them into the initials or something

    • @michealpersicko9531
      @michealpersicko9531 3 роки тому +16

      i feel like the mini cake would bea replacement for a single large wedding cake since 30 dollars per person can more or less equal the price of an average wedding cake depending on how many people they are. Plus i don't think many people would waste the time to get a giant wedding cake when you can just give them an individual cake for the same price and it would be more cake than a pinky size serving of wedding cake that you'd normally get; the mini cakes to me if i were to plan a wedding makes more sense to me .

    • @disneydiscoverychannel8838
      @disneydiscoverychannel8838 3 роки тому

      @@tiffanylastinger3925 macarons*

    • @julianokleby1448
      @julianokleby1448 2 роки тому

      @@michealpersicko9531 I saw a wedding on UA-cam where the couple was paying for everything themselves with no help. Because the bride was in a car accident and totaled the only car, they had to cut corners everywhere possible in order to get a new car. They ordered mini cakes at one per couple, or if the guest was single, one for them as well. The mini cakes were all iced differently in the same color scheme, and were stacked in the centers of the tables as centerpieces, then taken home by the guests to enjoy at their leisure. It was way cheaper to do them than it would be to have a huge single cake. The bakery even threw in a single small cake decorated nicely for them to couple to cut at no extra charge. Very classy!!

  • @kellygibbs7552
    @kellygibbs7552 3 роки тому +9

    I agree that they didn't really match your guidelines, except the cupcake/mini cake one. But I would LOVE to see the DIY version of your vision!

  • @marshmallowsweetie1056
    @marshmallowsweetie1056 3 роки тому +55

    Do you ever contact some of these places back and be like "Uhh...this isn't what I ordered.. like...at all!" I would LOVE to get a video of that phone call. Lol.

    • @TheIcingArtist
      @TheIcingArtist  3 роки тому +23

      hahaha no lol. I've been tempted, especially when the cakes fall apart and become a cumble mess. But I have never called a single bakery to complain or get my money back.

    • @anaandujar3367
      @anaandujar3367 3 роки тому +17

      I agree on holding back on calling the bakeries as you aren't really mentioning them and all but that last one... well ma'am needed a call for clarification...lol "hello good day, yes my husband picked up my order but i think the wrong package was given...lmao"

  • @calliemaddiecats5457
    @calliemaddiecats5457 3 роки тому +18

    Wow, I think these all were a fail except for the mini cake that was absolutely stunning. I loved the concept of your challenge, and would like to see you try it again with some other bakers!

  • @kippy7883
    @kippy7883 2 роки тому +4

    I actually really liked the pies! They have a kind of rustic, magical vibe. I think they’d be perfect at a woodland wedding.

  • @maegankaz4943
    @maegankaz4943 2 роки тому +2

    Please do this again! I think you should specifically order just *one* item from each place. Alternatively tell them you have a party and need (whatever number) favors for 30$ each but you want a sample before the day of! This is what I did for my wedding because I didn't want to be disappointed on my wedding day with cheap/corny looking favors!
    Also, that color palette is everything! 😍😍

  • @clairemarz6273
    @clairemarz6273 3 роки тому +9

    The macarons are super cute but I was expecting actual macaroons and now I’m wondering if someone COULD dress up a macaroon… coconut macaroon birds nest for Easter maybe?? I bet Laurie could do it 😍

    • @vjhreeves
      @vjhreeves 2 роки тому +3

      Weird that a professional baker would not know the difference between macarons and macaroons.

    • @clairemarz6273
      @clairemarz6273 2 роки тому +1

      @@vjhreeves Is she? I thought she was a home baker but I don't know for sure. Honestly though a loooooot of people don't know that they're two distinct things. One of my friends is allergic to almond and it's always a huge thing when she tries to get "macaroons" and ends up with "macarons"

  • @Vanz8397
    @Vanz8397 3 роки тому +4

    would love to see you making the wedding favors you wanted! it'll be super amazing see you do a trial and error and as you always do, eventually succeed in creating something awesome.

  • @shreeyarani
    @shreeyarani 3 роки тому +55

    "Once we cut it we can't uncut it"
    -Laurie Shanon, 2021

  • @JoMarieHartup
    @JoMarieHartup 3 роки тому +2

    I literally bought a box of individual wrapped truffles from the supermarket and each guest had one on their place at the wedding breakfast. It cost me max £20 for 80 people (25 pence each). A tip for people that need to cut cost.

  • @jlynn4187
    @jlynn4187 3 роки тому +5

    Laurie with the Cupcakes and Mini Cake: Well I wish they used a darker green like I had on my palette
    The Pies: Why hello, boy do I have a treat for you

  • @carrie9716
    @carrie9716 3 роки тому +2

    For the pie, maybe the baker isn’t used to working small. Pies are easier the bigger you go so it doesn’t lose as much shape. That being said, I’d just make a small plain pie, bake it, then decorate with frosting/ luster dust and/or place small sprinkles in the matching colors. Trying to make the details on a small pie stay intact is really hard. (A second way would be to cook the details on a cookie sheet separate and place them on after baking… that way they can go at a lower temperature and not loose shape.)

  • @TrinaPorter
    @TrinaPorter 3 роки тому +32

    I'm here so early I haven't drank my coffee yet. Luckily you're so full of positivity, the coffee can wait. Humph.

  • @GypsyxDarling
    @GypsyxDarling 3 роки тому

    The mini cake was the total winner, but I am OBSESSED with those pies!!! Such a cute idea and I feel like they go with the theme with the wedding, even if the colors aren't all present.

  • @217geol
    @217geol 3 роки тому +20

    These are so cute! I would love to see what you would make as an edible wedding favour!

    • @DancesWithBeauty
      @DancesWithBeauty 3 роки тому +2

      Yes!!!!

    • @dietotaku
      @dietotaku 3 роки тому +2

      YES! i'm a little tired of seeing what other bakeries can do, i want to see what LAURIE can do!

  • @southurnstar
    @southurnstar 3 роки тому +1

    That mini cake was gorgeous and would be an awesome alternative to a traditional cake that you'd cut and serve. Particularly if you were having a micro wedding with less than 10 people.

  • @M33PSTER
    @M33PSTER 3 роки тому +4

    You should do this video again but you make the different kinds of favors! I love watching you make the cakes, you’re so creative 💕

  • @matrix4003
    @matrix4003 3 роки тому

    I wouldn’t shorts. It is your personality that attracts me to watch your videos. I enjoy you creating and figuring out how to do your designs. It encourages me to try out new ideas.

  • @danielah.hafeitz4046
    @danielah.hafeitz4046 3 роки тому +8

    I think you should make a video trying to do cakes (or any type of dessert) in different times, for ex: decorate a cupcake in 10min, 1 min and 10 seconds.

  • @dawnchesbro4189
    @dawnchesbro4189 2 роки тому +1

    The pies that the pieous makes are fully baked on her IG. Maybe a few are pre-bake, but even the portrait you showed was after baking. And, like all the other have stated, they are sending you options so you could choose what you liked best. I think they all did a great job at showcasing their specialties

  • @stephaniemcfarlane4434
    @stephaniemcfarlane4434 3 роки тому +11

    The chocolate heart truffles, I think they used their own colors so you can know the different tastes. It shows you their texture and technique and flavors. And you would have to trust that they would do your colors properly when you order it I guess?

    • @dietotaku
      @dietotaku 3 роки тому +1

      i feel like the truffle people just completely phoned it in. like "you want heart truffles, this is what we do."

  • @jojobee42
    @jojobee42 2 роки тому +2

    My favourite is number 2 !! Easy pick, amazing! 🥰 The cupcake is beautiful, but omg the mini cake! If I left a wedding with a mini cake like that I'd be BEYOND happy and excited! Though also the cupcakes would give that same feeling, they're amazing too.... LOVE!!! 😍 (Ps. They could use a dark green ribbon to bring in that colour) 😉

  • @ashleyguerrero8081
    @ashleyguerrero8081 2 роки тому +3

    I honestly love the mini wedding cake it was the best and most detailed beautiful 😍

  • @samanthadean1083
    @samanthadean1083 3 роки тому +1

    My cousin made her own edible favours for her wedding!!! Her dad is of Portuguese 🇵🇹 decent and her mom (and her fiancé) are of Scottish 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 decent so she made Scottish Shortbread Fingers, but she added brandy to the fingers!!! They were delish! And the gauze bags were adorable!!!

  • @tofuhearts
    @tofuhearts 3 роки тому +8

    The pies would be an amazing idea to give to the wedding party while you're getting ready!

  • @mjb7015
    @mjb7015 3 роки тому +1

    That first mini-cake is amazing. If I were having a wedding, I'd totally want to give my guests a tiny miniature recreation of the big wedding cake each to take home. It's such a good idea.

  • @nabihajunaid
    @nabihajunaid 3 роки тому +6

    Literally the mini cake was like heavenn!!!!

  • @jdrew5367
    @jdrew5367 3 роки тому

    You can’t always get what you want.
    No matter how hard you try, you get what you need!
    The Rolling Stones had your number !
    The decorative cake was the nicest even if the frosting green part should’ve been a little darker.
    Thank you, I enjoyed your vlog!

  • @gracefuldeals
    @gracefuldeals 3 роки тому +8

    I adore the mini cake! I need to learn how to make those ASAP!

  • @juliechildress8905
    @juliechildress8905 2 роки тому +1

    I love edible wedding favors. Many years ago, I went to a wedding where the favors were a small box with a variety of Hershey kisses. So cute.

  • @jbauntie
    @jbauntie 3 роки тому +3

    I love the idea of the little pies,they’re adorable and unique and perfect for a fall wedding but they weren’t as pretty as I would want for a wedding.However the mini cake was beautiful and I’d love to give or receive it as a wedding favour. Though if the pies were prettier I’d probably choose them over cake.The chocolates were just kinda sad. Now I’m craving cake&pie😋😋😋

  • @mrscb5303
    @mrscb5303 3 роки тому +1

    First of all, totally interesting video!! I think one thing you are helping future brides and grooms realize just how detailed of communication they have to have and to get a test run!! Now #2 that mini cake was spectacular as a favor. How fun to get home that night or maybe with coffee in the morning to have a little cake and think about the couple you were so happy to see married. #3 Yes there is a good way to eat a cupcake 🧁.... split it horizontally, put the bottom on top and wa-la Sandwich cupcake 😉😉 I love cupcakes. Thanks for a happy morning watching your video 💚

  • @barghast
    @barghast 3 роки тому +5

    Loved this video. It was so cool to see the results even if it's not what you expected. I'd love another video like this in future with some different bakeries/bakers.

  • @wandawatkins1501
    @wandawatkins1501 3 роки тому +2

    I like the little cake

  • @courtneymichelle5276
    @courtneymichelle5276 3 роки тому +3

    That mini cake is definitely the vibe! I love it!

  • @maedlaglasser7041
    @maedlaglasser7041 3 роки тому +1

    The second bakery I've been too is amazing! Recognized their boxes lol. Though creativity wise they do that design on cupcakes and mini cakes all the time.

  • @MissHolly60
    @MissHolly60 3 роки тому +4

    Wow! The Mini Wedding cake and the cupcake stand out the more. So pretty! Who ever make the cake. I would go back to the barkey give them a tip.👍🙂

  • @mariea.carreras2761
    @mariea.carreras2761 2 роки тому +1

    Love the tiny cake ! Approximated more to what you were looking for....agree the others did not make items as requested.

  • @michellecrowder6374
    @michellecrowder6374 3 роки тому +4

    i love how real you are when youre eatting the cupcake, no matter how u try eating a cup cake never we can never be cute lol

  • @angelinacrafts5385
    @angelinacrafts5385 3 роки тому +2

    Mini cake for the win.

  • @allye9865
    @allye9865 3 роки тому +4

    No huge winners in this one. Great video!

  • @thecenturyjourney
    @thecenturyjourney 3 роки тому +1

    The mini cake seemed like the only one that gave you what you asked and paid for

  • @bsjwiwiqkqlpwlskskdkd421
    @bsjwiwiqkqlpwlskskdkd421 3 роки тому +16

    When you and ann reardon post the same day
    "That's weird, that suspicious ":===

  • @consultingdetective6310
    @consultingdetective6310 3 роки тому

    The 2nd bakery's mini cake was so beautiful. The colors and flowers are fabulous. Edible favors are definitely the way to go!

  • @christystamps9090
    @christystamps9090 3 роки тому +7

    I loved the mini cake also that was my favorite! I have been waiting and waiting for you to post! I love you and Kev! I absolutely love how happy and excited you are!
    I’m going to try your elephant cake this weekend! I’m baking cakes for it today! I can’t wait I’ve never covered with fondant.

  • @courtneyoconnor8526
    @courtneyoconnor8526 3 роки тому

    Second shop was definitely the most impressive! Mini cake was the winner of them all! I’m honestly impressed they would do that many mini cakes for only $30/each