Leehom wrote and sang this song beautifully, the interpretation has a feel and essence of a western-educated person. With 20 years experience, Lin's vocal is now perfect. He sang so freely, like he is relating a poetry. Aska sang this song (in a class meeting with other star-avenue competitors) in front of Leehom when the song first came out. His interpretation had a deeper feeling that moved me more. Even Leehom seemed unsettled and affirmed that it became Aska's song when he sang it.
That was what I thought in the beginning. Then while watching the video of Star Avenue class reunion with Leehom 20070808, Aska sang this song with the sreen showing the writer as "Kuang Y M ". Leehom's debut MV of this song also showed the Lyricist as Kuang Y M.
我最鐘意王力宏這首歌，無論唱作寫都係很棒！但當我聽完林志炫唱後，我更喜歡林志炫的版本。力宏已唱得很入心，但志炫唱到係入心入肺。
千尘不染的悠远，穿越时空的嘹亮，志炫的音质纯净得像是不属于这人间一般
林志炫唱出了淡淡的愁緒 ..... 功力深厚
他这首歌唱的太好了 但是听这首歌的时候 成赶上头一回出国 泪流满面
Leehom wrote and sang this song beautifully, the interpretation has a feel and essence of a western-educated person.
With 20 years experience, Lin's vocal is now perfect. He sang so freely, like he is relating a poetry.
Aska sang this song (in a class meeting with other star-avenue competitors) in front of Leehom when the song first came out. His interpretation had a deeper feeling that moved me more. Even Leehom seemed unsettled and affirmed that it became Aska's song when he sang it.
太........棒了~
太好听了！二胡找对了歌，歌碰到更适合它的歌者。
王力宏的版本我也聽過,和林志炫老師的版本比起來,志炫老師唱得比較有古典的味道
很適合,如果在兩者之間做個選擇 我會毫不猶豫選擇志炫老師的版本
也因此讓更多實力歌手多出去到各地發展，讓更多人發現也不錯。台灣
太小了。
演奏樂器的人都好有氣質! 好漂亮喔!
不曉得都是從哪找來的
也許是仙女下凡吧~
他唱得很美...可說是perfect
但..給我感覺總是欠缺了 那份感情
志炫老師的歌唱技巧可說是在國內外都無懈可擊,
可惜在台灣如此變質只重包裝的音樂文化下無法勝過當今藝人(嘆!
許多實力派歌手(ex:志炫老師,動力火車...)都在此情形下前往星馬及內陸,
台灣人真是不知珍惜啊~明明這麼多歌唱人才......
That was what I thought in the beginning. Then while watching the video of Star Avenue class reunion with Leehom 20070808, Aska sang this song with the sreen showing the writer as "Kuang Y M ". Leehom's debut MV of this song also showed the Lyricist as Kuang Y M.
很喜歡中西樂器合奏.
王力宏跟炫都是我很愛的歌手!
神！
志炫老師唱這首不錯ㄟ，蠻有感覺的
实力强，唱什么歌都游刃有余...
真的~~真假音混的超強的
epic voice
用靈魂演奏的上乘音樂。
My apology to the song writer.
Leehom directed and sang in his MV.
唱的不錯， 是個超級實力派。 但是我還是比較喜歡 力宏版的~。
why？？？？
leehom is the song writer。
both melody and lyrics
太瘦了,吃多一點會更好看
台灣人真是不知珍惜啊可惜變質台灣人真是人才
能有哪首老師是唱不好的嗎
一樣唱的超有水準…只是伴奏搶主、二胡在2:01走音，是怎樣？
這位音樂專家 那是泛音吧
其實這首歌還有平井堅的版本不過忘記歌名ㄌ
聽起來好像略高了一點 汎音是高八度 不會有out of tone的感覺
鄺裕民的歌
最攪笑係佢唱xi 音, 往往變了 si 音... :P
好聽 但是第一個，「遵守自然的邏輯」
守字沒有捲舌 聽起來突然就 阿，破壞了美感
不是什麼樣的走音都可以假裝成近似音呼嚨過去的
完全沒有氣音
唱歌冇感情 係佢一世唔紅既原因 學人唱人地D歌 又唔夠原唱好聽 咁米廢lo