Architecture Competition Review: All 623 Entries - Episode 15

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 18

  • @markuswedlich2880
    @markuswedlich2880 Місяць тому +2

    cathal crumley: "I guess i don't like triangles"
    also cathal crumley 5 minutes later: "I like projects that look like origami" ;)

  • @54mm30
    @54mm30 Місяць тому +1

    Hello sir, at 7:11 u mention art galleries that can do both, being a work of art and is sensitive to the art inside. I'd like to ask if u can share any of those examples?

    • @cathalcrumley
      @cathalcrumley  Місяць тому

      Hi there! The Hepworth Wakefield by David Chipperfield comes to mind!

    • @54mm30
      @54mm30 Місяць тому

      @cathalcrumley Thank you!!! I had the same in mind but I was quite unsure. I am a huge fan of David Chipperfield's works as well.

  • @temporarydiscussion
    @temporarydiscussion Місяць тому +1

    My Top 3:
    1 - 207
    2 - 204
    3 - 202
    201 - I understand the idea, but I don’t think this project is very realistic. I’m not particularly excited about how it would look in reality.
    202 - The concept is nice. However, it feels like each page was made by a different team member, which weakens the overall presentation.
    203 - I don’t understand the concept of the big window and how it combines with the rest of the materials. Not my taste.
    204 - I really like the form-very nice! It feels somehow inspired by the sea.
    205 - The bird’s-eye render is appealing, but the design overall reminds me more of an opera house.
    206 - I’m not sure if the volumetric torsion benefits the building. The reception concept is cool, but the render feels lifeless.
    207 - I’m very impressed. I liked the bird’s-eye rendering; however, it was the interior that surprised me the most. One of the few projects from all the series I’ve seen where the concept and presentation are solid, and the building looks realistic at the same time.
    208 - Feels like a cheap imitation of Casa da Música.
    209 - The funky aerial view is interesting, but the interior looks very unrealistic.

    • @cathalcrumley
      @cathalcrumley  Місяць тому

      201 - I agree! The spirit is correct, technical execution? Im less convinced...

  • @alpagator1372
    @alpagator1372 Місяць тому +1

    Props to 201 for actually wanting to be materially ecological! Hooray!

  • @MONTOUTE-STUDIO
    @MONTOUTE-STUDIO Місяць тому +3

    208 - I like 208 - I don't think they understood what was special about their project and the magic.

    • @henryward-raatikainen2189
      @henryward-raatikainen2189 Місяць тому +1

      I agree, everything /apart from the exact very final form/ is very nice. The current skin makes it just a little too awkward and lumpy for the space

    • @cathalcrumley
      @cathalcrumley  Місяць тому

      @@henryward-raatikainen2189 its sort of ALMOST there in a way. I think its cool but as @MONTOUTE-STUDIO says, I dont think they sold it well in the 5 pages above!

  • @danielk3275
    @danielk3275 Місяць тому +2

    208 - casa da música

    • @cathalcrumley
      @cathalcrumley  Місяць тому

      formally yes, in a way......208 feels a bit more playful with the facade though....

  • @MONTOUTE-STUDIO
    @MONTOUTE-STUDIO Місяць тому

    Mic stand? Maybe?

  • @brianantoniohuman
    @brianantoniohuman Місяць тому +1

    These were fresh. But not as developed concepts.