Case IH vs Versatile | Big agricultural tractors with rubber tracks

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 66

  • @chasefreedom5178
    @chasefreedom5178 3 роки тому +6

    Overcoming a 150 hp difference must feel good for all Case fans. Comparison racing generally is done with like machines. No dog in the hunt here. But come on man!

  • @joyceandkeithfox4499
    @joyceandkeithfox4499 5 років тому +10

    If both were 550 or 620 would be a more fair comparison.

  • @PaulieFetz
    @PaulieFetz 7 років тому +22

    I don't know about other farmers, but I'm not really concerned with a tractor's drag racing abilities. More important:
    1. Reliability - which tractor is gonna be able to pull that silage wagon for 14-16 hrs/day for a couple weeks with minimal breakdowns?
    2. Cost & Cost of operation - which tractor is best value for money, and which is more efficient in fuel use and operator comfort?

    • @jfdb59
      @jfdb59 7 років тому +3

      Exactly.

    • @EZ570
      @EZ570 6 років тому +8

      Add in : Which dealer is local and actually stocks some parts, and has mechanics that can know where to begin fixing the equipment, and which manufacture is going to be in business a few years from now.

    • @jamesfl1968
      @jamesfl1968 5 років тому +1

      @@EZ570 Great Point.

    • @goodmorning1476
      @goodmorning1476 2 роки тому

      👏👏👍👍✌

  • @flushmammadrama
    @flushmammadrama 3 роки тому +4

    Case 620 vs... versatile 550? That’s a bit like comparing apples to oranges

  • @jameslivingston8301
    @jameslivingston8301 6 років тому +4

    I'm watching racing Turtles now! Lol! I need to sleep...liked it anyway.

  • @apuuvah
    @apuuvah 4 роки тому +4

    Yeah, from what I know I'ma take Versatile.

  • @kubatomczak8036
    @kubatomczak8036 6 років тому +14

    Realy 700 hp vs 550 hp ??

    • @henthust9784
      @henthust9784 Рік тому

      Which one is 700hp? That's an exaggeration. The Case is 620, and Versatile is 550

  • @alex.w.kimani6921
    @alex.w.kimani6921 4 роки тому +3

    You cannot compare Tractors with over 100BHP power difference

  • @farmerjoe8144
    @farmerjoe8144 7 років тому +10

    Doesn't seem very fair seeing as the versatile is 550 hp whereas the quadtrac is 690 hp

    • @rancidreducer584
      @rancidreducer584 7 років тому +3

      It only has 690 PEAK horsepower. Plus, it doesn't take all of 550HP to pull that trailer - the case is just a better tractor for this. Isn't that what the comparison is about?

    • @farmerjoe8144
      @farmerjoe8144 7 років тому +5

      Rancid Reducer When pulling up that hill trying to be the fastest they will be using all the horsepower and torque available, however when cruising on flat ground they wouldn't be using all of their power.

    • @chevysilver-ray-dough6328
      @chevysilver-ray-dough6328 6 років тому +1

      Another jd boy crying not fair. Somethings will never change

    • @jhonkenthdelfin6146
      @jhonkenthdelfin6146 6 років тому +1

      It is not JD boy crying the human crys for his vote. If something's happen wrong. Haha. I am a JD fan. Hehe. I just felt sad when John Deere get worst. But that's okey I know that it is a Machine and I'm not the worker of every JD I see. Okey.

  • @henthust9784
    @henthust9784 Рік тому

    It's not always about higher horse power, it's m8re about how much of tge horse power is converted into torque. Years back there was a video of a Scania R500hp drag racing a Volvo which had superior horsepower, sometimes above 600hp ( I forgot the exact number) The Scania left the Volvo for dead, made a doughnut spin and was out of sight before the Volvo could arrive at the doughnut spot for its turn.
    I believe the CaseIH with even slightly lower horses would still have won.

  • @vortexrace
    @vortexrace 5 років тому +2

    the trackor with the most horsepower wins. In other news, water is wet

    • @beaviccoon470
      @beaviccoon470 3 роки тому

      But is water actually wet or does it just make things wet 🤔🤣

  • @JamesJones-lu2kx
    @JamesJones-lu2kx 7 років тому

    that's a real fair comparison

  • @jaegerbomb4142
    @jaegerbomb4142 4 роки тому +3

    This is bollocks. We run 3 delta tracks and 3 qaudtracs and the versatiles pull so much better. And they don’t shit the gearbox our whilst they are doing it.

  • @crazyhass84
    @crazyhass84 7 років тому +4

    Has nothing to do with max hp. It doesn't take 600hp to move those 30k lb trailers! Look how much faster the case transmission shifts. They also have skip shift so it can jump 2 gears at a time.
    It's not always about max power. It's how u use it. I bet a 540 model case would beat the 550 versatile.

    • @Ethan-ck6iz
      @Ethan-ck6iz 6 років тому

      The case driver starts out way faster and that's what makes him win

    • @chasefreedom5178
      @chasefreedom5178 3 роки тому +1

      Ok so you declare HP has nothing to do with pulling? Torque has a large part in it. What are the torque numbers? Thats right the Case has the advantage and Hp does allow a speedier time to speed. Bold claiming a underpowered tractor be compared with a machine 100+ hp more powerful. Mismatch implements then! Spend that cash on your explanation of power.

    • @goodmorning1476
      @goodmorning1476 Рік тому +1

      👍👍👍

  • @jhondeere7530
    @jhondeere7530 7 років тому +19

    620hp vs 550hp ???

    • @tanguybertin8749
      @tanguybertin8749 7 років тому +7

      in fact the ih 620 is almost 700hp so...

    • @matthyslouw440
      @matthyslouw440 7 років тому

      Jens Harder its kw not hp

    • @jhondeere7530
      @jhondeere7530 7 років тому +1

      Matthys Louw what, do the case have 620hp, and the versatile 550kw, ??? Explain!

    • @matthyslouw440
      @matthyslouw440 7 років тому

      Jens Harder no both are kw i may be wrong it can be hp

    • @jhondeere7530
      @jhondeere7530 7 років тому

      Matthys Louw never mind

  • @frikkies333
    @frikkies333 7 років тому +8

    Anyhow CASEIH is the best ever

    • @unclerico2531
      @unclerico2531 7 років тому

      frikkies333 that might be your opinion and I respect it but this test honestly proves nothing about how well the tractors are versatile is great and anyways the case has 70 hp on the versatile

    • @jakubjakubec6535
      @jakubjakubec6535 7 років тому +1

      frikkies333 big bud is Best ever

    • @unclerico2531
      @unclerico2531 7 років тому

      Jakub Jakubec no big roy is better

    • @GOAT_GOATERSON
      @GOAT_GOATERSON 4 роки тому

      @@unclerico2531 no big bud is god of tractors

  • @loiclenoir491
    @loiclenoir491 4 роки тому +1

    Case ih 620 hp+ 50hp boost 670ch
    Versatiles 550 hp
    Case ih+ 120ch.... 🙄🙄

  • @erkankomit8535
    @erkankomit8535 5 років тому +2

    Case=TANK

  • @vuluu5782
    @vuluu5782 7 років тому

    Super traktor

  • @jesusonecstasy7863
    @jesusonecstasy7863 4 роки тому

    Case looks way sexier

  •  7 років тому +2

    It's the dumbest tracked tractor test I have ever seen! How can you test heavy, pulling optimized tractor for speed performance.... It's like attaching Bugatti and Ferrari to the plow and see which is faster... It's idiot. Delta track is more than 3 tons heavier than Quad... Idiot once again.
    Głupszego testu ciągników gąsienicowych nie można sobie wyobrazić! To tak, jak zapiąć Bugatti i Ferrari do pługa i sprawdzać do ilu się bujną... Delta Track sam w sobie jest ponad 3 tony cięższy od Quadtracka. Te maszyny są optymalizowane do ciągnięcia, nie do ścigania się. Pomysł kompletnie idiotyczny. Pozdrawiam.

  • @cb7815
    @cb7815 7 років тому

    Add in a dry track fer the close pullers on the first race. Then they reverse and wet the close track when outer is dry. Dry pulling track won every time. Dumb

  • @olijsc2769
    @olijsc2769 7 років тому

    18T TRAILER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Raulillo406
    @Raulillo406 7 років тому +1

    Menuda chatarra el versatile

  • @laurynasd3016
    @laurynasd3016 7 років тому

    umega 💪

  • @anushchinu2321
    @anushchinu2321 6 років тому

    Song

  • @corycoulter5140
    @corycoulter5140 7 років тому

    Versatile trying to look like the caseih quadtrac.lol

  • @phalanx3803
    @phalanx3803 5 років тому

    if the Versatile had a CVT like a Vario drive and not an outdated power shift it may have won well its still better then a New Holland hahahahaha. i want to fucking burn our NH the old Steiger does better then the NH.

  • @phalanx3803
    @phalanx3803 5 років тому +1

    if the Versatile had a CVT like a Vario drive and not an outdated power shift it may have won well its still better then a New Holland hahahahaha. i want to fucking burn our NH the old Steiger does better then the NH.