Great vid but honestly using a pro controller in odyssey is just as good as joy cons. The only thing u can’t do is a mid air downward throw. Which um... boo f*ckin hoo XD
Ehh. I LOVE Paper Mario, but the only one that I'd actually say has a good story is Super Paper Mario, and even then I'd never suggest that someone should play it for the story. Ya, I think people will probably enjoy the story, but it's not so good that its enough reason to play it even if you're not a big fan of the gameplay and humor.
SelTar bro what about TTYD or 64. TTYD is my fav game and although story isn’t the first thing that comes to mind I feel like other paper Mario games have good stories. I heard amazing things about spm’s story tho so I wanna try it out either way
@@moose5958 I love both those games but I dont think their stories are all that great. Their humor and dialogue are amazing, but I dont think the story themselves are noteworthy. Some of the individual chapters in TTYD have decent story, but not the overall plot.
@@moose5958 I personally prefer 64 over TTYD because it's easier to replay. Less backtracking, and while chapter 3 and 6 are super cool, they're best the first time playing. 64 was always my favourite Paper Mario game, but if you havent heard of it, you should check out Bug Fables. It's an indie game meant to replicate the Paper Mario style and improve on it. It might be my favourite Paper Mario game now, even though it's not technically a Paper Mario game at all.
@@willhofheimer9998 We don't know what that entails yet. Remember when Super Mario Party was said to have online? But then it was just mini games online smh.
You know what? I’m not gonna put this channel on an alphabetical tier. I’m gonna give it its own tier: pretty freakin great and deserves more subscribers
Says Mario 64 is garbage: well it has its goods and bads Says Sunshine is good and bad: fair enough, haven’t played it Says Galaxy is “alright”: right that does it
@The_boyz452 !, yeah, Odyssey is way better. The Galaxy Games are brilliant and I love them but once I 100% them, I’m not going to play it for another couple of months. Odyssey has so much to do and even once you 100%, it’s so much fun to just explore the different kingdoms and do crazy jumps and tricks. Oh, and just saying, play Sunshine but if you suck at video games, well, you’re going to hate Sunshine. It’s really difficult in some areas
@@joeyjerry1586 Galaxy games had better level design and challenge. Odyssey rewards you for doing something as simple as a ground pound while the galaxy games made you work your ass to get a star. Odyssey has too many moons and too many repeating concepts.
Super mario galaxy is literally the best one here, also its not really that easy if u go 4 100% completion , trust me its no kiddie game at that point.
@@jadenpalmer5815 It doesn't really make it hard, just a bit tedious. The Luigi levels are technically harder, but the only direct difficulty increase that I remember is that the cosmic clones are faster.
I honestly have alot of nostalgia from super mario galaxy 1, but I later got really bored of it and when galaxy 2 came out, I completely ignored the existance of galaxy 1 due to my obsession on galaxy 2. I love how you're also so honest in these videos, you have earned a sub.
Galaxy 2 finally gets the respect it deserves. God teir game and I'm tired of all the people who think 64 is still amazing. Just play odyssey it's so so much better with the same design
When I was a kid my mom bought a Wii and a copy of Super Mario Galaxy. My dad went through the tutorial and got to Rosalina’s spaceship. I couldn’t get out of the spaceship for the life of me. I would literally boot it up, walk around, think about how to play, give up, cry. TLDR: I need my Gamer Card to be revoked.
How old were you lmao, and also yeah that other person is right Rosalina literally tells you to go to the Terrace while the camera zooms onto said Terrace
He’s right the swimming in Super w64 sounds like a cat vomiting. One time I was playing Dire Dire Docks and my Mom came down, thinking it was my cat Tommy about to vomit.
This was absolutely fantastic to watch. You gave fantastic reasons for why you thought a certain gamed deserved it's place. Humor was nonstop but not annoying. This was so good I want to rethink how I rank the games. You just got yourself a fan.
I mean I’ve 100% almost every 3D Mario but odyssey is just too much. The game is monotonous and a lot of the moons feel rushed. For me it’s just not that worth it to play and so even though I’ve 100% Mario 64 ds, 3D land, galaxy 1 and 2 back to back, I’m giving up on getting the last 100 or so moons In odyssey
As someone who just finished Mario 64 recently somehow even though I have been playing the game since I was a little child, game isn't bad or "aged poorly", but it isn't a masterpiece either, you can tell they didn't focus that much on the worlds, the later ones specially just don't fit Mario's movement and are plain frustrating to navigate. Good game, it just isn't the timeless masterpiece some people say it to be, also Mario's movement is sick
Some aspects aged poorly like camera, or things like Mario falling off if you walk a pixel off a ledge, or some bossfights, but the game is pretty enjoyable nonetheless. But it’s absolutely not “the pinnacle of 3D platforming that no game ever has surpassed” like I’ve heard people say, and I’m not even exaggerating, I’ve read people say exactly that.
this channel is super underrated some of the jokes are are decently funny and most give me a good laugh and i would love to see this channel grow and get the recognition it deserves.
dude literally only focuses on gameplay and nothing else, anything minorly inconvenient makes it apparently shit and he doesnt value anything else. and i dont get the hate with innovative controls, they arent even bad people just dont like new stuff. and the biggest sin with this joke of a review is that he called galaxy 2's soundtrack better than the first, like, are you fucking kidding? in summary this review is a joke, especially if he cant take it seriously to give them actual tiers and each one gets an exclusive tier. and the dude didnt even care enough to rant on about the flaws of the "better" games. he just shit on the older games and praised the newer games while giving not even a half-hearted counter arguement. id say this video gets a tier list of its own: the one friend in you social group who never takes anything seriously and aggressively tries to make everything funny
@@ivegonesickomode1610 You could write the entirety of all 3D Mario games story in a paragraph man. It’s a gameplay focused series, so he focused on the gameplay.
@@ivegonesickomode1610 the sound tracks in both galaxy games are very close in quality. I don’t think it’s at all outlandish to prefer the second. The second game has some severely overlooked masterful tracks. The world map themes, starship mario and puzzle plank to name a few. And of course I can’t forget cloudy court galaxy.
Honestly 3d land was really good. It get’s over BS 3d controls controls with the 3D slider.However I basically remember nothing, because that game is the easiest Mario game except for maybe new super mario bros 2. The game has 16 worlds so there’s a lot of content in that game for $20
Yeah, 3D Land is a great low-stakes handheld title. It just doesn’t compare with the juggernauts on this list. Just like how Super Mario Land pales in comparison to SMB1, 2, 3, and World.
Galaxy 2 don't really deserve nothing. It's a game with no soul. Horrible hub, horrible world map, lazy story and ost compared to the first one. Level design is just the same as the first one.
I really like ur level-headded review of 3D All-Stars as a compilation. A lot of other people, like you said, make themselves sound self-entitled when it comes to this comp of games.
Yeah, I heard some guy comparing Mario 3D All Stars to the retroactive microtransactions in Crash Team Racing and I'm like... Are you high? Like, say what you want about this collection, but they're selling you exactly what's advertised: a collection of 3 old Mario games. They're not taking your money first and ruining stuff later.
Super Mario Sunshine will always be my personal favorite. I was 6 years old when it first came out and I still remember my mom buying it for me and playing it for the first time. 2002 was a great year for video games. You had sunshine, wind waker, time splitters 2, spider man, vice city, resident evil, mario party 4, etc….
Our kids 20 years later: "Why is yahoo so important?" "Let me tell you a story, son." *shows SimpleFlips, People who played it in childhood, Pannenkoek, and SMG4* aka who I think are the four horsemen of the SM64 fandom
Actually the reason Mario can breath in space is because of Luna's magic... I think... Because Mario doesn't even meet luma until after he's already in space.
That’s not the case as in Galaxy 1 Luma doesn’t join you until your already in space and in Galaxy 2 Luma leaves Mario at the end. Also, if we look at Odyssey Mario can breath in space on his own. So yeah definitely not because of Luma’s magic.
@@inaki8014 yeah who thinks the first 3 of them are better than Wii. I don't mind people who think that double dash and ds are better but I think the newer ones are too restrictive with its movements with hardly any unintended shortcuts that require skill with also there aren't as many cool strategies sure original 8 has fire hopping and demonslidng but Wii is soooo much cooler
You are definitely right about the annoying amount of swimming levels in this game. And yes it is ironic that in spite of being the tropical island theme, Super Mario Sunshine has the least amount of swimming of all 3D Mario entries. I know for sure that the Galaxy games and Odyssey also have more swimming in it than Super Mario Sunshine.
Galaxy and Odyssey are the best. Galaxy mainly in its mood and tone, plus the level design is great. Odyssey in its ability to make moving Mario around fun, plus it’s so fun to look around every corner for moons
Finally someone who acknowledges flaws of Sunshine AND 64. Really good tierlist that has a perfect balance between objective and subjective points, hard agree with the spots.
People who say mario64 holds up are blind. It absolutely does not. It’s nauseating to look at and difficult to control. Anyone born after the nineties will tell you this
I love this video! My god, what a brutally honest review of each game. It pained me a little to hear some of the criticism of the games that raised me as a child, of course, but you were pretty spot on with your critiques. Excellent work.
I’ve made the same point about Odyssey being the true successor to Sunshine before, so I was happy to hear you mention it. I feel like they had the blue coins from Sunshine in mind when they decided on how to implement moons in Odyssey- a larger number of collectibles that require creative exploration of the worlds.
My list: S - Super Mario Odyssey A - Super Mario 64 DS B - Super Mario 64 C - Super Mario 3D World, Super Mario Galaxy 2 D - Super Mario Galaxy E - Super Mario Sunshine F - Super Mario 3D Land
He’s mostly right though. Galaxy’s story isn’t really all that special when you compare it to most games out there. Galaxy’s level design is its strongest aspect imo.
Mario Sunshine is such a good game, it’s underrated and deserves better because it does have a lot of hate. I know it has a lot of love too though thankfully. It was always my favourite childhood game and I grew up with it. I still think galaxy and Mario 64 are fun and good as well, especially galaxy 2 omg so good. But there is something about sunshine, that game is a beautiful fun masterpiece that doesn’t deserve the hate in my opinion
I absolutely LOVE 64 and I've been playing it about 15 years. I agree with you on the last levels being super punishing. Tick tock clock could've been the best level in the game if they got rid of the 100 coin star in that level.
@@Benjawin6671 it didn’t age well, some mechanics like the wall jump and the camera are shit. Some levels look terrible(rainbow ride, most of the secret star levels). Stop being nostalgic about this game it didn’t age well
@@Benjawin6671 That wasn't my argument, mine was it is worse than every other 3D Mario game. All opinions aside, people can like it, but it doesn't have much going for it now
I clicked on this to have something to watch before bed, not thinking I’d finish it, but you surprised me! Definitely got a wrap on how to be entertaining throughout the video with the same style but different jokes, which most people can’t pull off. Definitely have some different opinions which is great because it’s awesome to hear why people like the other ones. I love Galaxy and honestly you might’ve convinced me to pick up Galaxy 2. All in all 11/10, well deserved sub my man
Bourne Ultimatum: Galaxy 2 A New Hope: Galaxy 2000s action movies: 64 Sonic Generations: Odyssey Sonic Unleashed: Sunshine, 3D World Sonic Unleashed on Wii: 3D Land
Mood! I think the production value of Odyssey alone makes it 'objectively' the best (the same way I think BotW is arguably the best Zelda game) But just with BotW I don't really like sandbox games. I enjoyed the simple premise of Galaxy 1 and Galaxy 2 just had the best gameplay and depth. I don't mind overly linear levels, but I don't like the 2.5D formula of "platform but don't get hit" nor do I care for Odyssey's "if you want to 100% you need to use random hints and rumble features"
Honestly I’m not sure if odyssey is even objectively the best. I feel like people are way too quick to say that big equals better. I respect odyssey’s ambition, but for a 3D platformer there really wasn’t much...platforming. Especially compared to the galaxy games. Galaxy 2 had some of the best platforming in the industry and odyssey is just mostly traversal with how it plays. Like I seriously don’t think odyssey is as replayable as galaxy 1 and 2 since most of the challenge comes from finding the moons, which is fun the first time round but would you rather REVISIT scavenger hunts ground pounding things or doing silly mini games like trace walking or using a dog to dig stuff up or would you say running up walls with a dash pepper and skipping across a lava lake with a cloud power up would be more fun to relive? I’m going to go with the latter, though I guess I can still see the appeal of a more relaxed and set back experience. Not trying to undersell odyssey’s best moons. The best moons are the ones that involve platform challenges but a lot of them just felt so disconnected from the rest of the worlds, like they were scrapped galaxy levels or something. It’s a shame too, since mario’s move set is easily the best it’s ever been in odyssey and yet it isn’t really put to the test enough imo.
People's anger towards 3D All-Stars is completely justified. They're not even remakes, it's the exact same thing. The fact that they cost money at all is offensive. When it comes to old games, people should just pirate. The people who actually made these games so great aren't making money off them anymore.
Hey uhh, there's this game I just found. Super underground stuff. I found it when looking at a bunch of old japanese nes games. It has a pretty weird title, but I'm pretty sure it's called mario? Not many people have heard of him though.
My top tiers have to go to the galaxy games. Both of em. Then I'd slap 3D World because its probably the best designed game on 3ds. Seriously, the graphics are phenomenal. I spent a lot of time playing it.
Super 64: I don't like the controls. Some stars come off as a little too cryptic like the Bomb field one where you gotta use the wing cap to fly through some coins up above where you can't see them.
My rankings (will be edited when 3D World + Bowser's Fury is released): C Tier=3D Land B Tier=3D World A Tier=64 S Tier=64DS, Sunshine SSS Tier=Galaxy, Galaxy 2, Odyssey
16:00 This, sir, is where you earned my like. Granted, Mario Bike Wii isn't *quite* as bad as 64, but suffice it to say it was no Double Dash, never mind the OG Super legit the best Mario Kart they ever made until friggin *8.*
If you were wondering which let’s be honest you were not, my ranking is 1. Super Mario Galaxy 2. Super Mario Galaxy 2 3. Super Mario 3D world 4. Super Mario 64 5. Super Mario Odyssey 6. Super Mario 3D land 7. Super Mario Sunshine
@@bihn atmosphere, story, and generally more memorable galaxy’s, even tho I feel Galaxy 2 has better galaxy design by a little bit. (Played galaxy 2 before 1 so don’t say it’s nostalgia)
Thank You for Watching! And Remember to Subscribe!!
And follow me on Twitter for more I dunno memes and such: twitter.com/CptAstro
Great vid but honestly using a pro controller in odyssey is just as good as joy cons. The only thing u can’t do is a mid air downward throw. Which um...
boo f*ckin hoo XD
Dog boy knows best games
Captain astronauts review power is infinite
don’t ask... i thought you said Thank me for watching and subscribe to you
Quick question- why is this video only avalibe at 480p max?
0/10 the tier list wasn't in 3d it was a 2d image disliked unsubbed I feel clickbaited
`m`
@Red Cyndaquil its not creepy... Its stupid
@@itsyako9752 yes
@Welp Stay at home *that's the joke*
@Red Cyndaquil shut up
...
"no one plays Mario for the story"
*Paper mario veterans joined the chat*
Ehh. I LOVE Paper Mario, but the only one that I'd actually say has a good story is Super Paper Mario, and even then I'd never suggest that someone should play it for the story. Ya, I think people will probably enjoy the story, but it's not so good that its enough reason to play it even if you're not a big fan of the gameplay and humor.
SelTar bro what about TTYD or 64. TTYD is my fav game and although story isn’t the first thing that comes to mind I feel like other paper Mario games have good stories. I heard amazing things about spm’s story tho so I wanna try it out either way
@@moose5958 I love both those games but I dont think their stories are all that great. Their humor and dialogue are amazing, but I dont think the story themselves are noteworthy. Some of the individual chapters in TTYD have decent story, but not the overall plot.
SelTar it’ll always be my fav but I see what u mean. I respect ur opinion :)
@@moose5958 I personally prefer 64 over TTYD because it's easier to replay. Less backtracking, and while chapter 3 and 6 are super cool, they're best the first time playing.
64 was always my favourite Paper Mario game, but if you havent heard of it, you should check out Bug Fables. It's an indie game meant to replicate the Paper Mario style and improve on it. It might be my favourite Paper Mario game now, even though it's not technically a Paper Mario game at all.
"Mario kart wii is the worst one"
You have provoked a gang war
Mandatory motion controls aren’t fun.
@Holden The Gamer @Aequitad then use the pro controller or GameCube controller, they don’t have motion controls. You press a button to trick
They hated Jesus for he told them the truth
@@aequitad4411 use the nunchuk or the pro controller or the gamecube controller
@@glctcthnkr8059 but the game is good its very competitive like melee and it have funky kong
I’m so glad I’m not the only one who doesn’t act like Mario 64 is automatically the best.
Vouch
it has place in history and stuff but aged poorly
Its still a good game now just didnt age too well and isnt the best out of all mario games*
Yeah Honestly. It was a big game at the time, but has barely aged well.
Sunshine aged a bit better but it still has some issues in some cases but its still tolerable and fun
3D world: "I wish 3D world had online multiplayer."
Yeah... It did until miiverse perished...
*sad face *
Feelsbadman
not really multiplayer. more like "watch this guy play this level and race him maybe"
The switch port has online multiplayer
@@willhofheimer9998 We don't know what that entails yet. Remember when Super Mario Party was said to have online? But then it was just mini games online smh.
No it didn’t. You could see other people’s ghosts, but you couldn’t play with someone else at the same time
You know what? I’m not gonna put this channel on an alphabetical tier. I’m gonna give it its own tier: pretty freakin great and deserves more subscribers
P Tier
Cap
I'd rather put him in his own little tier of "decent, but kills the purpose of using an actual tier list"
@@nm5329 fax
I'd say "repeats unfunny jokes to often, but has a good amount of funny ones too. Also the disrespect towards MKWii is intolerable."
Says Mario 64 is garbage: well it has its goods and bads
Says Sunshine is good and bad: fair enough, haven’t played it
Says Galaxy is “alright”: right that does it
I don’t trust a man who prefers 3D world to Galaxy
You saying you haven't played sunshine says enough for me.
@The_boyz452 !, yeah, Odyssey is way better. The Galaxy Games are brilliant and I love them but once I 100% them, I’m not going to play it for another couple of months. Odyssey has so much to do and even once you 100%, it’s so much fun to just explore the different kingdoms and do crazy jumps and tricks. Oh, and just saying, play Sunshine but if you suck at video games, well, you’re going to hate Sunshine. It’s really difficult in some areas
@@safiyysreactionvideosnumbe2784 I do.
@@joeyjerry1586 Galaxy games had better level design and challenge. Odyssey rewards you for doing something as simple as a ground pound while the galaxy games made you work your ass to get a star. Odyssey has too many moons and too many repeating concepts.
"It's the best game here, but I still like -galaxy 2- galaxy more"
Basically sums up my thoughts on 3d Mario as a whole.
Super mario galaxy is literally the best one here, also its not really that easy if u go 4 100% completion , trust me its no kiddie game at that point.
@@jadenpalmer5815 It doesn't really make it hard, just a bit tedious. The Luigi levels are technically harder, but the only direct difficulty increase that I remember is that the cosmic clones are faster.
@@Moss_Dude bruh i don't think you completed the game 100% then
@@marx3447 What else gets harder then? Luigi's controls are not that different. Are the purple coin time limits shorter?
@@jadenpalmer5815 As someone who really likes galaxy one and has completed it four times the game is super easy.
I honestly have alot of nostalgia from super mario galaxy 1, but I later got really bored of it and when galaxy 2 came out, I completely ignored the existance of galaxy 1 due to my obsession on galaxy 2. I love how you're also so honest in these videos, you have earned a sub.
Galaxy 2 finally gets the respect it deserves. God teir game and I'm tired of all the people who think 64 is still amazing. Just play odyssey it's so so much better with the same design
I grew up with galaxy, but I enjoyed odyssey, I just didn’t like how easy it was.
@@zetsubou619, Odyssey is easy but I also find Galaxy really easy as well
@@joeyjerry1586 Yeah, it is pretty easy, unless you add the purple coin comets into it.
I don't really like odyssey, but Mario 64 best mario game for me
@@zetsubou619, oh, yeah, and some of the Daredevil ones are really hard as well
When I was a kid my mom bought a Wii and a copy of Super Mario Galaxy. My dad went through the tutorial and got to Rosalina’s spaceship. I couldn’t get out of the spaceship for the life of me. I would literally boot it up, walk around, think about how to play, give up, cry.
TLDR: I need my Gamer Card to be revoked.
As kids we often neglect one of the most critical yet basic skills in life. The ability to read.
... I haven't played it I couldn't get it but I would have the same problem now
How old were you lmao, and also yeah that other person is right Rosalina literally tells you to go to the Terrace while the camera zooms onto said Terrace
@@finixmoon127 bro, I was 3. I’m 19 now
@@Cchase Oh wow yeah no wonder you had no idea what to do (why tf did your parents think it would be a good idea to let a 3 year old on a Wii 😭)
He’s right the swimming in Super w64 sounds like a cat vomiting. One time I was playing Dire Dire Docks and my Mom came down, thinking it was my cat Tommy about to vomit.
This was absolutely fantastic to watch. You gave fantastic reasons for why you thought a certain gamed deserved it's place. Humor was nonstop but not annoying. This was so good I want to rethink how I rank the games. You just got yourself a fan.
Glad you enjoyed it :)
I recently 100% Mario 64 and Goddamn I never wanna touch this game ever again
Just don't 100% the game. You'll have a lot more fun.
I mean I’ve 100% almost every 3D Mario but odyssey is just too much.
The game is monotonous and a lot of the moons feel rushed.
For me it’s just not that worth it to play and so even though I’ve 100% Mario 64 ds, 3D land, galaxy 1 and 2 back to back, I’m giving up on getting the last 100 or so moons In odyssey
@@kasrakazemi5077 Weak fool. I grabbed every moon AND I bought 99 in each Kingdom after Balloon World came out.
As someone who just finished Mario 64 recently somehow even though I have been playing the game since I was a little child, game isn't bad or "aged poorly", but it isn't a masterpiece either, you can tell they didn't focus that much on the worlds, the later ones specially just don't fit Mario's movement and are plain frustrating to navigate. Good game, it just isn't the timeless masterpiece some people say it to be, also Mario's movement is sick
Some aspects aged poorly like camera, or things like Mario falling off if you walk a pixel off a ledge, or some bossfights, but the game is pretty enjoyable nonetheless. But it’s absolutely not “the pinnacle of 3D platforming that no game ever has surpassed” like I’ve heard people say, and I’m not even exaggerating, I’ve read people say exactly that.
this channel is super underrated some of the jokes are are decently funny and most give me a good laugh and i would love to see this channel grow and get the recognition it deserves.
Right. Had me laughing lol. The cat about to vomit XD
It hurt me when he said Galaxy is just ok because that not only my favorite Mario game, I am emotional attached to it
dude literally only focuses on gameplay and nothing else, anything minorly inconvenient makes it apparently shit and he doesnt value anything else. and i dont get the hate with innovative controls, they arent even bad people just dont like new stuff. and the biggest sin with this joke of a review is that he called galaxy 2's soundtrack better than the first, like, are you fucking kidding?
in summary this review is a joke, especially if he cant take it seriously to give them actual tiers and each one gets an exclusive tier. and the dude didnt even care enough to rant on about the flaws of the "better" games. he just shit on the older games and praised the newer games while giving not even a half-hearted counter arguement.
id say this video gets a tier list of its own: the one friend in you social group who never takes anything seriously and aggressively tries to make everything funny
@@ivegonesickomode1610 and that's an enormous fact.
@@ivegonesickomode1610 You could write the entirety of all 3D Mario games story in a paragraph man. It’s a gameplay focused series, so he focused on the gameplay.
@@ivegonesickomode1610 the sound tracks in both galaxy games are very close in quality. I don’t think it’s at all outlandish to prefer the second. The second game has some severely overlooked masterful tracks. The world map themes, starship mario and puzzle plank to name a few. And of course I can’t forget cloudy court galaxy.
It hurt me also, but I can't deny its flaws.
Honestly 3d land was really good. It get’s over BS 3d controls controls with the 3D slider.However I basically remember nothing, because that game is the easiest Mario game except for maybe new super mario bros 2. The game has 16 worlds so there’s a lot of content in that game for $20
Yeah, 3D Land is a great low-stakes handheld title. It just doesn’t compare with the juggernauts on this list. Just like how Super Mario Land pales in comparison to SMB1, 2, 3, and World.
The soundtrack is why i love the game and feel nostalgia for it
i like the game but the movement options and lack of power ups kills it for me its too basic imo
He just be thrashing on my favorite games of all time, Galaxy and Skyward Sword.
Skyward sword is overhated
im mad too
That’s and Sonic Adventure 2
Finally glad to see galaxy 2 getting the respect it fucking deserves
Galaxy 2 don't really deserve nothing. It's a game with no soul. Horrible hub, horrible world map, lazy story and ost compared to the first one. Level design is just the same as the first one.
@@riot9179 tf? galaxy 2 is a classic
I really like ur level-headded review of 3D All-Stars as a compilation. A lot of other people, like you said, make themselves sound self-entitled when it comes to this comp of games.
Yeah, I heard some guy comparing Mario 3D All Stars to the retroactive microtransactions in Crash Team Racing and I'm like... Are you high? Like, say what you want about this collection, but they're selling you exactly what's advertised: a collection of 3 old Mario games. They're not taking your money first and ruining stuff later.
mareo is my fave nintendo character :3
Lueegee is my 2nd favorite Nintendo Character
@@zeroddor2665 peechee is my real first favorite mareo character 🤭😔 lueegee pretty pog tho
*ness*
You mean sans deltarune
my fav caractr is zleda i love playing as him in brath of te wold!!!111!
Super Mario Sunshine will always be my personal favorite. I was 6 years old when it first came out and I still remember my mom buying it for me and playing it for the first time. 2002 was a great year for video games. You had sunshine, wind waker, time splitters 2, spider man, vice city, resident evil, mario party 4, etc….
Every time I click on a Mario tier list video I expect the obvious and get genuinely surprised. Nice video!
Ok so this was a pretty good vid even if I disagree with 85% of the takes here. But WHERE'S THE XENOBLADE 2 VIDEO!!!?
Our kids 20 years later:
"Why is yahoo so important?"
"Let me tell you a story, son."
*shows SimpleFlips, People who played it in childhood, Pannenkoek, and SMG4*
aka who I think are the four horsemen of the SM64 fandom
Can't forget nathaniel "scuttlebug" bandy
Pannenkoek are you Dutch? Like me?
Who is pannenkoek? Ive heard of the other two but not him
Actually the reason Mario can breath in space is because of Luna's magic... I think... Because Mario doesn't even meet luma until after he's already in space.
That’s not the case as in Galaxy 1 Luma doesn’t join you until your already in space and in Galaxy 2 Luma leaves Mario at the end. Also, if we look at Odyssey Mario can breath in space on his own. So yeah definitely not because of Luma’s magic.
Finally, someone who doesnt just put sm64 in the s tier cuz "nostalgia" or whatever
Nah instead he ranked it very low because he sucks at the game lmao
@@Benjawin6671 nostalgia blinded man.
@@andresreynoso7254 no I like the game because it's fun *facepalm*
@@andresreynoso7254 he just sucks
@@Benjawin6671 no it’s because he has something called an opinion, ever heard of it
Mário Kart Wii is the second best one. Go home, Captain
It has funky Kong, 10/10
Yes, it is really good, it is of my favorites xd, who thinks that super circuit is better than wii?
@@inaki8014 yeah who thinks the first 3 of them are better than Wii. I don't mind people who think that double dash and ds are better but I think the newer ones are too restrictive with its movements with hardly any unintended shortcuts that require skill with also there aren't as many cool strategies sure original 8 has fire hopping and demonslidng but Wii is soooo much cooler
I think you mean the wii u, the wii doesn't have splatoon also I can name atleast 20 amazing games on the wii to easily contradict that statement
you mean the best one
You are definitely right about the annoying amount of swimming levels in this game. And yes it is ironic that in spite of being the tropical island theme, Super Mario Sunshine has the least amount of swimming of all 3D Mario entries. I know for sure that the Galaxy games and Odyssey also have more swimming in it than Super Mario Sunshine.
I agree with this. I think the galaxy games are better then 64, just cuz 64 came out first doesn't mean it's the best.
Galaxy and Odyssey are the best. Galaxy mainly in its mood and tone, plus the level design is great. Odyssey in its ability to make moving Mario around fun, plus it’s so fun to look around every corner for moons
Finally someone that puts Galaxy 2 on S tier and knows that 64 didn’t age well.
Good job Astro, I disagreed with every possible position!
#mareo
Finally someone who acknowledges flaws of Sunshine AND 64. Really good tierlist that has a perfect balance between objective and subjective points, hard agree with the spots.
Fastest click in the west
People who say mario64 holds up are blind. It absolutely does not. It’s nauseating to look at and difficult to control. Anyone born after the nineties will tell you this
I love this video! My god, what a brutally honest review of each game. It pained me a little to hear some of the criticism of the games that raised me as a child, of course, but you were pretty spot on with your critiques. Excellent work.
This was the best tier list video I’ve ever seen, not only did you have good reasons on why you like the games, but the video was also so funny
I love super Mario Galaxy
I’ve made the same point about Odyssey being the true successor to Sunshine before, so I was happy to hear you mention it. I feel like they had the blue coins from Sunshine in mind when they decided on how to implement moons in Odyssey- a larger number of collectibles that require creative exploration of the worlds.
My list:
1 (best). Galaxy 2
2. Galaxy
3. Odyssey
4. 3D World
5. Sunshine
6. 3D Land
7. 64 DS
8. 64
Wow, what a great tier list. This acutally represents my own opinion, didn't know there's another human being who shares it.
If this blows up there will be a hate mob because of 64's placement.
I do respect your opinion tho.
I apologise in advance.
Hate Mob = More Engagement = More Views. I'm ready for it haha
@@CaptainAstronaut big brain.
My list:
S - Super Mario Odyssey
A - Super Mario 64 DS
B - Super Mario 64
C - Super Mario 3D World, Super Mario Galaxy 2
D - Super Mario Galaxy
E - Super Mario Sunshine
F - Super Mario 3D Land
Captain astronaut: no one plays Mario for the story
Me, a Mario galaxy fan: * deep breathe * i respectfully disagree with your disision
yea Mario galaxy isn't moldy cheese
He’s mostly right though. Galaxy’s story isn’t really all that special when you compare it to most games out there. Galaxy’s level design is its strongest aspect imo.
" I'm probably not gonna buy the 3d world re-release" Streams it 3 times with Vic, Squidmin, and Mijou
I am SO HERE for all these hot takes 🔥 🔥 🔥
3:43 THANK YOU I have been waiting for so long for someone to say that. You've made my day
As a 64 speedrunner my feelings are hurt xD
Not even halfway through the video, and I already know I'm gonna enjoy screaming at it
Mario Sunshine is such a good game, it’s underrated and deserves better because it does have a lot of hate. I know it has a lot of love too though thankfully. It was always my favourite childhood game and I grew up with it. I still think galaxy and Mario 64 are fun and good as well, especially galaxy 2 omg so good. But there is something about sunshine, that game is a beautiful fun masterpiece that doesn’t deserve the hate in my opinion
I absolutely LOVE 64 and I've been playing it about 15 years. I agree with you on the last levels being super punishing. Tick tock clock could've been the best level in the game if they got rid of the 100 coin star in that level.
Im sensing a rising youtuber. Just found this channel. Criminally underrated IMO
26:04 🤣
I mean Rosalina is best girl in the Mario franchise and ur not wrong but...
How dare you offend Mario Kart Wii like that?
(You're right about 64, though)
These fuckers complain about sm64 too much the controls are fine and the levels are very unique and (most importantly) it's FUN
@@Benjawin6671 it didn’t age well, some mechanics like the wall jump and the camera are shit. Some levels look terrible(rainbow ride, most of the secret star levels). Stop being nostalgic about this game it didn’t age well
@@Benjawin6671 Even if all of that was true (it somewhat is), it's the worst out of all of them
@@FullyArmedNightOwl since when? How come people can't just praise this game like people used to?
@@Benjawin6671 That wasn't my argument, mine was it is worse than every other 3D Mario game. All opinions aside, people can like it, but it doesn't have much going for it now
Preferring Sunshine over 64 and *Galaxy* is one thing, trashing on Mario Kart Wii is another thing entirely, bro
I was willing to watch this instead of sleeping.
The most annoying thing for me for Super Mario Galaxy was the swimming levels. I would spend forever because the camera angles kept changing.
I need you to review every nintendo franchise now omg seriously loved this tier list! Was really fun
10 minutes in and this vid is already a gem
I clicked on this to have something to watch before bed, not thinking I’d finish it, but you surprised me! Definitely got a wrap on how to be entertaining throughout the video with the same style but different jokes, which most people can’t pull off. Definitely have some different opinions which is great because it’s awesome to hear why people like the other ones. I love Galaxy and honestly you might’ve convinced me to pick up Galaxy 2. All in all 11/10, well deserved sub my man
*you know what, I'm not gonna give this one an alphabetical tier*
Sunshine and 64 are my 2 favourites no other 3d platform comes even close to the amazing movement in those games
Finally, someone who likes Super Mario Sunshine
Bourne Ultimatum: Galaxy 2
A New Hope: Galaxy
2000s action movies: 64
Sonic Generations: Odyssey
Sonic Unleashed: Sunshine, 3D World
Sonic Unleashed on Wii: 3D Land
For me the best ones are the Galaxy games and Odyessy. I would put 3D World and 64 next to each other, then Sunshine, then 3D Land.
Super Mario Sunshine is criminally underrated
Honestly I’m not gonna give this video an alphabetical tier, instead, I’m gonna give it a 3D tier.
That was a highly entertaining video. Good work.
Mood! I think the production value of Odyssey alone makes it 'objectively' the best (the same way I think BotW is arguably the best Zelda game) But just with BotW I don't really like sandbox games. I enjoyed the simple premise of Galaxy 1 and Galaxy 2 just had the best gameplay and depth. I don't mind overly linear levels, but I don't like the 2.5D formula of "platform but don't get hit" nor do I care for Odyssey's "if you want to 100% you need to use random hints and rumble features"
Honestly I’m not sure if odyssey is even objectively the best. I feel like people are way too quick to say that big equals better. I respect odyssey’s ambition, but for a 3D platformer there really wasn’t much...platforming. Especially compared to the galaxy games. Galaxy 2 had some of the best platforming in the industry and odyssey is just mostly traversal with how it plays. Like I seriously don’t think odyssey is as replayable as galaxy 1 and 2 since most of the challenge comes from finding the moons, which is fun the first time round but would you rather REVISIT scavenger hunts ground pounding things or doing silly mini games like trace walking or using a dog to dig stuff up or would you say running up walls with a dash pepper and skipping across a lava lake with a cloud power up would be more fun to relive? I’m going to go with the latter, though I guess I can still see the appeal of a more relaxed and set back experience.
Not trying to undersell odyssey’s best moons. The best moons are the ones that involve platform challenges but a lot of them just felt so disconnected from the rest of the worlds, like they were scrapped galaxy levels or something.
It’s a shame too, since mario’s move set is easily the best it’s ever been in odyssey and yet it isn’t really put to the test enough imo.
People's anger towards 3D All-Stars is completely justified. They're not even remakes, it's the exact same thing. The fact that they cost money at all is offensive. When it comes to old games, people should just pirate. The people who actually made these games so great aren't making money off them anymore.
6:47 thanks, i.cant unhere that.
This was a very nice video. Much more detailed and in-depth compared to other tier list videos!
Hey uhh, there's this game I just found. Super underground stuff. I found it when looking at a bunch of old japanese nes games. It has a pretty weird title, but I'm pretty sure it's called mario? Not many people have heard of him though.
Also I like the fact that you gave sunshine some respect!
My top tiers have to go to the galaxy games. Both of em. Then I'd slap 3D World because its probably the best designed game on 3ds. Seriously, the graphics are phenomenal. I spent a lot of time playing it.
I couldn’t agree more
i really enjoyed your tier-d super 3 list mareo
4:16
“go to top and fight a boss”
but how exactly do you get on top of whomps head
Super 64:
I don't like the controls.
Some stars come off as a little too cryptic like the Bomb field one where you gotta use the wing cap to fly through some coins up above where you can't see them.
My rankings (will be edited when 3D World + Bowser's Fury is released):
C Tier=3D Land
B Tier=3D World
A Tier=64
S Tier=64DS, Sunshine
SSS Tier=Galaxy, Galaxy 2, Odyssey
Best to worst
1- Galaxy 2
2- Galaxy
3- 3D World
4- Odyssey
5- 64
6- Sunshine
7- 3D Land
Is it just me or is some wrong with some of the Odyssey visuals? But I loved the video Cap nonetheless
Don't worry, Sonic was my pre teen years.
When Mario 64 came out, I was playing Doom, Dark Forces, Tomb Raider and Unreal
I loved 64 and had so much fun playing it in all stars but rainbow ride triggered me bc it was so repetitive.
"3ds is reserved for RPG's and monster hunter" truer words have never been spoken
Slider Jam is in my top ten remixes. Can I stream it on Spotify?
Thank you good sir.
I do appreciate you for Galaxy 2, but still
16:00
This, sir, is where you earned my like.
Granted, Mario Bike Wii isn't *quite* as bad as 64, but suffice it to say it was no Double Dash, never mind the OG Super legit the best Mario Kart they ever made until friggin *8.*
Nice intro
Damn mans shit on 64 lol. It ain’t the best but it’s still fun
God I disagree so much with this list, it’s like we have complete opposite tastes in gaming, but it’s your opinion
If you were wondering which let’s be honest you were not, my ranking is
1. Super Mario Galaxy
2. Super Mario Galaxy 2
3. Super Mario 3D world
4. Super Mario 64
5. Super Mario Odyssey
6. Super Mario 3D land
7. Super Mario Sunshine
@@yellowluma101 I will never understand the argument for how galaxy is better than 2
Nostalgia maybe?
@@bihn atmosphere, story, and generally more memorable galaxy’s, even tho I feel Galaxy 2 has better galaxy design by a little bit. (Played galaxy 2 before 1 so don’t say it’s nostalgia)
@@bihn recommend watching Scott the Woz video on galaxy 2, he pretty much sums up my entire opinion on galaxy 2
@@yellowluma101 Galaxy 2 has yoshi
Nuff said
im happy that this guy doesnt place mario 64 at first, cuz ppl act like it was the best game ever, bcuz it was "nostalgic"
Ok I like your placement for 64 and I can understand sunshine because nostalgia however how dare you do that to galaxy
yea 3d land also had the "oops you gotta collect old stars to continue"
18:32 my favorite part 🤣
Captain Astronaut videos are genuinely very funny
“His movement is really *FLUID*
-Talking about Super Mario Sunshine