Amit Shah on Manipur Violence: Why it happened and what actions government took
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 сер 2023
- While addressing the Parliament during the no-confidence debate, Home Minister Amit Shah said that 'Whatever happening in Manipur is ethnic violence triggered by circumstances, it should not be turned into a political issue,'
► Subscribe to The Economic Times for the latest video updates. It's free! - ua-cam.com/users/TheEconomicTi...
► More Videos @ ETTV - economictimes.indiatimes.com/TV
► EconomicTimes.com
► For business news on the go, download ET app:
etapp.onelink.me/tOvY/Economi...
Follow ET on:
► Facebook - / economictimes
► Twitter - / economictimes
► LinkedIn - / economictimes
► Instagram - / the_economic_times
► Flipboard - flipboard.com/@economictimes
#news #latestnews #economictimes #ET #TheEconomicTimes #businessnews
What I learnt is that Meithei's are Ethnic Group of Manipur and due to Illegal Migrants from Myanmar coming to India in Large Numbers caused disturbance in the Region.
Its Meitei.
The Meiteis are the ones who are illegal immigrants who came into Manipur in the thousands after the Myanmar Junta takeover of power in Myanmar since 1st February 2021, but the Meiteis blamed the Kukis as illegal immigrants which is wrong. Also, the Meiteis are the real narco-terrorists, as they are the druglords and kingpins of the drug cartels operating in three countries called the Golden Triangle - Myanmar, Thailand, Loas, Cambodia included. The Meiteis are the land grabbers as they realized the legislature is theirs but tribals seemed to occupy more land - those lands that are non arable, while they exhausted the fertile plain valley areas for buildings and other recreational activities! Yet, despite enjoying all kinds of government jobs and benefits through SC & OBC categories, the Meiteis still wanted to become Scheduled Tribes for grabbing Tribal lands in the foothills of Manipur and pushed the Kuki tribals to the unhabitable mountain areas.
Yup and since these illegal migrants enjoy the status of ST. The meitei are at the risk of becoming minority and landless in their own home state.
Foreigner came and try to took our land its whole nation concern
The state that brings pride for the nation is being burned before your very eyes
Finally truth revealed . Thank you Amit Shah ji .
what truth is revealed by the murderer?
@@MargaretTCGangteManashedumb idiotic tribes like you fight for inclusions for reservations, jealous of other tribes, inspite of sharing land, culture, history, Instead of being United ppl like you demean such eminent leaders, shame on you!
@@MargaretTCGangteManashestill u don't realize ur self refugees is refugees...
For the very first time, Mr Shah said FACTS without fabricating a single word. Even though some of his words (Hindi) went above my head but I know what happened back then cause that's where I come from.
This is very first time, you listened him with brain along with your ears, just go and search his media and other discussions
Dude just put on your headphones and listen to all his speech and than talk nonsence... He is one of the most intelligent ministers in the cabinet....Kuch bhi🤦🤦
@@abjarupbanerjee8165 You follow your leader you fool...Did he talk facts even after coming to the session after a long time...Yahi toh trailer hai picture abhi Baki hai Bhai...You should spare with him till 2029...Love him or hate him but you can't ignore him beta
@@abjarupbanerjee8165 Agar BJP Hoga toh apka Kacha Bacha hai Varna Woh bhi Nahi
@@abjarupbanerjee8165 There muh kutta jaisa dikh Raha hai isliye aap sirf bhonktha hai
clear, factual and to the point.
This is not just the failure of the Government but is it the failure of our country how can we figth our enemy when we are not united and can't understand each other the Government should take a very serious action to bring peace in Manipur
Biren took personal on kuki that's the problem n lead to community clash.
@@isaacpameih4863if it is his personal then why did all the kukis started war against the innocence meitei n when the meitei reacted back all the community victimized the kuki-zo community!
@@isaacpameih4863..personal...r u kidding..saving forests, distroying poppy plants, taking action against the immigrant who r entering the country without proper paper ....u say it is personal..plz stop ur unmature mind..we meitei,Naga r peace loving people..go back kuki territories to Burma..
Now a days… Amit shah ji speech always clear and sound
Hat's off to our government for dealing with such patience and reaching it to it's root cause.. jai hind jai bharat ❤❤❤❤❤
Thanks Amit Shah ji for exposing the truth. 🙏
He got wrong information from the liar,communal cm.
@@laltinkhuminbuon1147 Don't underestimate Indian government intelligence. It's the truth that has come out.
It's a situations jumla.... By jumla party
1st their will right a story, then their will creat character from opposition parties, then their make a link as if their were present in that place.... 1st peace has to be restored..... Then talk's
@@laltinkhuminbuon1147 So who has the right information your favourite leader Rahul Gandhi who is more concerned about his leg than the real issue
@@laltinkhuminbuon1147 every truth is ur problem !
For first time I liked mota bhais speech ...it was detailed , point to point
What a speech.Finally cleared all the doubts. so detailed how fully prepared he is. This shows how serious he is about the issue
Wish there were subtitles. Non hindi speakers are missing out on the essence of this content.
Amit Shah is telling congress is worthless for country.congress is anti Hindu but doing appeasement of Islam and Christianity people for only vote banks
Dear Amit Shah ji the main issue of Manipur was not for ST status consideration for MEITEI people. It's about the illegal immigrants residing, poppy cultivation reserved forest land encroachment
Go to the ground you will understand who are the illigal migration.. don't just listen to BJP led govt over ther they fool the country like hell... See now it's been 3 to 4 months but nothing done ..... See yourself brother take root and talk plz
Yes bro
And all the drug lords from the valleys including the chief minister too
Yea u shud all stop exporting popies in Mizoram too.. ther r lots of poppy addiction because of meitei suppliers
Rapist terrorist and naked weapons attack Kuki villages
Your CM crime minister will be the first to go to prison for that drugs story...if you agree....bring it on...meiteis
Whatever happened in Manipur should not be politicise but ruling should not afraid of losing power on their way in controlling and descalating the situation in Manipur
Reality and truth facts by Amit ji. Excellent action appreciated. Opposition must cooperate not to create further problems by doing politics. We are one nation. All issues can be debated like today. Not like walk out by opposition only for blaming and votes tustikaran..Jay hind!
Really appreciate Amit Shah ji for exposing the truth …
Weakest hm in india history...😤😤😤
The earlier NRC is done , the earlier this problem is solved.
This why Amit Shah ji is called Chanakya... Great answers.
Lovely and powerful speech from our Home Minister, thanks for letting the whole country understand the root cause of the violence.Illegal immigrants infiltration should be stopped, narco terrorism activities should be squashed , illegal settlement in the reserved forest area should be removed.Please expedite the fencing of the border area with Myanmar, if infiltration is not stopped, its Manipur now but few years later it will be spread to others parts of our nation India.🙏
Weakest hm in india history...🤮😤🤮😤
Illegal immigration?!
Why not take concrete steps to actually prevent that if it is in fact happening?
You don't even have any proof to back up any of these wild claims.
Narco terrorism?!
Your meitei CM is the ultimate Drug Lord as is clear from the interview by Brinda.
Reserve Forests?!
You mean the forests where we've been roaming freely for many millennia?
We ARE the owners of the Forests!
The govt did not follow proper procedure when declaring such areas as reserve forests(we have protested on this so many times)
How convenient to kill so many innocent unarmed young and old kuki tribals in imphal and blame it on illegal immigrants and poppy cultivation. You can tell all the lies you want both at the state and centre but please be assured that the universe and karma is waiting to repay all the lies. The community that indulges in injustice will be in trouble, if not now, your time will come.
Funny for ur brilliant acting skills n lies ... The Meiteis who have burned the Indian flag, banned Hindi movies n language n even books in schools in Manipur n who hates Indian Army is now trying to play patriotism... Do u hv the guts to tell the country the truth ??? illigal immigrants ??do u evn know the meaning ?? Go bck n study some Indian history when ur father was not evn born ...the kuki's had fight the Anglo war against the British ...get ur self educated first instead of blindly lying
@@ardyfelkimAnd Kukis are saints. Kukis didn't kill Meiteis, didn't behead or burn alive any Meitei.. Kukis also didn't burn Meitei homes in CCpur and Moreh. Meitei only burn their houses, burn themselves and shit at themselves with sniper guns
how much the kuki will play victim card and hide all the illigal thing . misleading the people of India but the truth prevail atlast. we respect you HM . thanks u very much BJP government for telling the truth and kuki have said Manipur government democracy is anti kuki now they say will whole india government democracy is anti kuki. U can't live upon lie tho. let make peace and talk with eachother together. let solve the conflict.
Government knows that it's not only ethnic clash , it's a narcoterrorism war and for seperate administration or seperate country of kukiland.
Government is recognizing the presence of narcoterrorism militants which is unacceptable and calling for talks .
It's not time for words and agreement , it's time for action and make freedom of manipur from narcoterrorism and illegal immigrants.
And lastly I request , Prime minister should atleast give a supportive speech for citizens of India , Manipur
Ok show us the proof.........
Another meitei lies🤣
Seperate Administration will be given only by God not by PM,HM and Meiteis.Only God knows the truth not PM,HM and Meiteis (who born to speak only LIES)
True 👍
Full support from Tripura Jay Hind 🇮🇳
best dabate by HM in parliament. all doubts are clear.
Great, Then why he is unable to solve the issue? It is excellent that he explained the history. But Why he is unable to put in place a proper administration?
@@user-dq9sq9jl3iYou want want 75 year old legacy issue to be solved over night? Wow!
At best he can bring the Status quo that was before May 2023. That should be the starting point.
Don't have unrealistic expectations.
Did you even watch the video?
So many admistrative changes have been made.
@@user-dq9sq9jl3i Bro he is not a God to predict what is happening in the future...All the necessary actions are taken but still people are finding loopholes....It shares borders with few countries also So things can be even worse
😊@@shashikirandhabole
Amitji has Xero knowledge of Indian constitution
After india got freedom wonderful and sensible home minister we have in parliyament amit shah you are really a brave man who told every thing on manipur incident line by line to the nation such responsible person we have. I appreciate amit shah.
He is the strongest HM we ever had. What a bold and honest speech it was. Hats off
Do you know the truth of Manipur now?
Lol, he made a promise while he was in Manipur ### ( 2023 May ) that I would return after 15 days while examining all the information that I collected from the resource person and resolve this matter as soon as possible..... Ha ha ha ( 2024 Feb still collecting )
MANIPUR MEITEI. NRC COMPULSORY IN INDIA MANIPUR
WE WANT PEACE JUSTICE NRC
IMPLEMENT KARNA THI HOGYA
NRC 35 TRIBE CHATTAHY .KUKI DON'T WANT. WHY SEPARATE KARKY .POPPY PLANTATION KARNA CHATAHY .
Meitei and Naga have a history of about 2000+ years and Kuki about 150 years old. I will not say who is indeginous or not, let people decide who is indeginous or not
😂😂😂😂😂
Talking with facts shows he is doing real work to control manipur violence.
Abey jaaa....
@@paochongloi596 kuki refugees bhag
😂😂doing his real work so violence still continue.
@@paochongloi596 bloody illegal Myanmar immigrant.
@@creativemaster733no one gives dam abt ur opinion.. ..illegal Myanmar immigrant
most important ...we should build our borders strong ...
I dont know why people watch dhruv rathee deshbhakt and youtuber not these debates these are the realities shown by gov knows the government
Government is not stupid so it will let youtubers know single truth truth in sansad
Dont get emotional by watching youtube videos see facts listen some law student and officers
Thank you amit shah ji
Truth be told. ST is not the root cause of the ethnic clash. The chin kukis felt let down by Biren govt when their dreams of poppy cultivation and narcotic trades were destroyed. But they couldn't protest on this matter as these are illegal trades and no one will support them in this cause. So they have been waiting for an opportunity and... kaboom the meiteis demand for ST then serves as their Golden opportunity.
Amit Shah is also aware of that ! .....as per an internal infos from someone who is a close aid to a politician.
I got the privilege of seeing this rule of BJP in my life, I am blessed that I was born in this country of India. *Jay Hind*
Long live amit shah… may god be always with you. As a manipuri whatever amit shah said is right. Go back illigal kukis to your place Myanmar. At least we want. Go back illigal kukis go back to your place. Don’t further create war here india .
All congress party members clothes has been torn.... By home ministers teply.. Hats off to home minister... Congress n pappu only wants drama n politics😂
Modi is RSS Papu....😂🤣🤓🤣😂
@@peterneil6859kuch sense hai iss baat ka
@@narenderreddy9425first I thought you didn't watch/listen his entire speech but then I realised you don't understand Hindi ,you are like ,"ayyo thoda thoda Hindi aata isiliye sab mereko manipulate krta " 😅
❤❤❤❤❤❤ Amitasha Good work
❤❤❤❤❤❤ Amitasha Good work
Dhanyavaad Amitbhai understood Manipur violence and your efforts
The high court noted that the Meiteis had submitted several requests for ST status to the Centre from 2013 onwards - a request that was forwarded to the state government for a formal recommendation.
The Manipur High Court has admitted a review petition seeking to modify its March 27 order that directed the state government to recommend inclusion of the Meitei community in the Scheduled Tribes (ST) list.
Based on the petition, the court on Monday issued notices to the Centre and the state government, seeking their response.
The review petition by the Meitei Tribes Union (MTU) was admitted for hearing by a bench of Acting Chief Justice MV Muralidharan, who had also authored the March 27 order.
In the order, Justice Muralidharan had directed the Manipur government to reply to the Union Tribal Affairs Ministry on a file related to the request for inclusion of the Meiteis on the ST list.
The high court noted that the Meiteis had submitted several requests for ST status to the Centre from 2013 onwards - a request that was forwarded to the state government for a formal recommendation.
But the state government never acted on it, the high court said before directing it to respond to the Union government.
In addition to this direction, the HC had also said, “The first respondent shall consider the case of the petitioners for inclusion of the Meetei/Meitei community in the Scheduled Tribe list, expeditiously, preferably within a period four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order…”
Kuki narco terrorist wants to do poppy cultivation freely after getting seperate state and later they will fund Myanmar in their secession war
Do you know the truth about kuki in manipur. If don't know please change your hate speech I know how meitei were planing on kuki people's cuz it's my hometown
@@lenkhohaosingson445 yes we know ,kuki want to cultivation with Amith shah freely popy cultivation it is right .
Truth always triumphs...
I started believing bjb government ❤
Nice comedy😂
@@muhammedyazeen145 If you want more please watch Rahul Gandhis speech
Abhi Tak kya kar hai the😅
What a man for India🇮🇳
Failed to make borders since our independence usually states the source of conflict...
I feel that the video was upheld for 2 months post incident hints some sort of evil plan...
🙏🙏🙏
👏👏👏👏 I Thought only Modi ji can deliver this level of Speech but Wow Amit Sir Wow you opened our eyes we were also doubtfull why Bjp Was silent these many days but your one speech we learned facts Thankyou sir And Also So Thankfull to Rahul Gandhi sir with todays Speech He Made Bjp Win more seats in 2024 and form government
My foot 👣👣👣👣
@@peterneil6859 😆😆😆😆😆😆 Go take Eno can understand your gastric pain and Sleeping Disorder For Your Disease Best Medicine is hear this speech again and again 😆😆😆
@@peterneil6859 You know it is very ugly
Today i came to know this congress n pappu r most expert dramebaz😅
Modi is RSS Papu 🤣🤣😂🤣
Ye BJP govt. bahut sensitive hai ese muddo par ... Dango ka itihaas dekhkar smjha ja sakta hai
Now mereh is burning means manipur is burning ,manipur is burning lndia is burning plz be
Consider
Pm and Amit shah are not thinking for Manipur peoples,it's not fair ,
This mans actions speaks louder than his vetbosity ever can
Kuki people are refugees we always said but kuki denied it always, they're vote bank of lndian Government we always said that also but kuki denied but unfortunately indian government exporting shame on Indian government and kuki refugees illegal migrant i will say core time its truthful
Why don't you people sit peacefully rather than tagging each other as immigrants. This whole racist war is killing innocent people. Doing rapes and harrasment of women. Stop these stupid racist war
Well said... good explanation.... Vasudeva kudumbakam
ET, please don't add music to such videos that are mostly speech, it is highly distracting.
Amit ji just respond everything very good 👍
It’s very sensitive matter..
n bjp government understand 😊
I’m so proud of bjb❤
it’s BJP* Chutiye
Satyameva Jayate! Long live Manipur! Long live India!!!
Thank you Amit shah 🙏 exploring the truth 🙏
Music in background is not at all needed. It's just a disturbance here.
Please let him speak fully , he is right in explaining events . I support you sir
Little learning is dangerous thing
Shri Amit shah ki jaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii…………….. the greatest home minister of all time long live bjp for telling the truth it’s a very sensitive thing for our state and he narrates it point to point long live bjp long live bjp truth always trumpth🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Why he is not mentioned poppy plantation and elegal deforestation. Ih he blind or what? 😮😮😮
Excellent 👌
I was real time supporter for bjp but now it deepen my spirit😮
Yes they're pretty good compare this 2hr factual speech of Amit Shah with 30min stupidity of prince
Meiteis we’re telling that since day 1 but we were made to look bad
Keep the trick with you. you are/were never a BJP supporter.. Keep supporting Pappu
@@Bharathfirst-ou6os thank you for your fore knowledge and advice
Thank so much Amit Shah ji for exposing the truth.
Thank god.. finally..
Don't create to make the story longer, just take action and stop the violence ....
It is easy to ask someone to do something sitting on your couch
Why is there background music in the video
But Sir the main cause of the crises is not the ST demand. you are twisting it deliberately to the state HC. It was implanted to coincide 2ith the rally against ST. As HM more information needs to be gathered before saying so bluntly
We want peace in Manipur immediately .
No more violence
Amit ji speech is great but the violence was happened due to the negligence of BJP govt. They want to win elections by any means. They wanted some votes from Kuki people so they finance to the kuki militants and then Kukis strated this war... ITs all their plan or negligence or Is this the Indian modern Democracy.
17:01 is very much important. Names must come out .
Why after his visit to Manipur and departure, the situation became worsed?..?
He visited in May when already people were killed & incursion from Myanmar was thr biggest issue
Because the kukis want to create violence and eventually wants to get seperate state
Because kuki idea is to spread violence and keep demanding
yes during his visit was the bloodiest..
That attack on Serou and Sugnu area will be the darkest (bloodiest) days.
And interestingly that was also the first incident that exposed the involvement of Myanmar militants on attacking and killing Meitei civilians with sophisticated weapons like Snipers, M16, etc.
Come on India wake up don't let the low class/wrong propagandas of separatist fool you anymore.
Because kukis are wild.. Kukis keep on shooting meitei people
Seek the truth, hear out the truth, let the truth prevail !
Manipur is a nation.Manipuri fighting for our nation. 1.Chahi taret khundakpa 2.British period. 3.kukis nomadic /illegal immigrants people's coming from Myanmar and Bangladesh etc
.
Now what should will done for manipur
One thing is clear.. either he does not know anything about manipur's ground situation (he is being led) or he is not at all interested in manipur (too small an issue for him).
Why don't you enlighten us instead of just saying this. He covered it quite extensively.
Please fench the boarder area. of North East very tall and strong. If not the same situation may happen to other states also..✊
Long Live Manipur...
1.implement NRC
2.Destroyed narco terrorism
3.aborgate KUKi SOO agreement
4.Sent back kuki refugees to Myanmar
5.Booked all the culprits of this kuki war
Catch the main leader of drugs@the CM of Manipur...........and kick out all the meitei illegal immigrants in myanmar
Subtitle would have been appreciated
Amit shah salute for speaking facts
Why before amit shah sir want giving reply other political parties make noise this is not good manners
unki jal jati haiiii
Excellent analysis
Proud of you Amit Shah jii sir😊😊
Truly said ...Jai Hind
Thank you Amrit sah ji ❤❤
North East needs NRC to identify outside
What was Amit Shah committed to nation particularly Manipur on 2nd June 2023, Liar Liar
SoO ???
Return to Manipur again within 15 days ????
jesus ki cheli jbh story pta na ho toh gyan na pele
@@ananyasingh1158Ram, sita Krishna shankar snake ka bidrawala beta tu bhi kuch nhi janta
@@natung9048 teri tarah gwar nhi hu pol science ki student hu
@@ananyasingh1158 🤣🤣🤣☕☕☕
Hon'ble Union Minister Shri. Amin Shahji came to Manipur before Lok Sabha election, but BJP got defeated.let's see what he speak on the first parliament assembly 2024 regarding Manipur issue.
Hopeless Bjp government. Till now no sign of normalcy still with no shame Hm is defending Meitai CM
You being a kuki with your surname Hangshing,you kuki just want to create Havoc and get your seperate state
Lol
Kuki separatist spotted illegal immigrants 🤣🤣
The government of india is not blind...this is all I can say to all the infiltrators
It is his responsibility to ensure safety in the state from outsiders , nothing to do with biren. He meant no offence to anyone... Unless of course you are the outsider.😂😂😂
MR Amit shah I though I should respect you but I don find the worth wen u can still stand with the CM of Manipur wen u know his wrong doings...Let this be the last reign for u n Ur BJP....pissed off!!!
We the pure Manipuris do not want lam excuse. Immediate action, free movement and peace, is required for recover the economy and education of the Manipuri people and the children of Manipur state.
If Amitsahji is a real politician he can now solve all the matter
If he doesn't want to disclose he with meitei why don't he directly say to clear kuki living in manipur.
You don't deserve to speak about Manipur issues.Sorry unfortunate first ever Home Minister of india.
The dusts which were left in the past has to be cleared by BJP government.
WHERE IS THENALI
Then why pm is not talking even a single word about Manipur.
Why are there music in the background? Please remove music on this speeches.
Manyavar’s stock value meanwhile- 📈📈
Myanmar logo ko apka bhasan samaj meh nahi aah rahi. Tabhi to kuki chin ka comment nahi hai yahape.
🌿🌻 What's the earthly use of talking now when Manipur was burning and suffering so much ?
Amit shah ji speak truth but you leave the cause of manipur violence sirji
अमित शाह जी अगर सिएम सहयोग कर रहा है तो कुकी विरोधी बयान कौन दे रहा है और ट्विट कौन कर रहा है? शासन सचिव और डीजीपी से पहले सिएम को बदलने चाहिए थे। और मिजोरम से जो मैतैयों को खदेड़ा जा रहा है उसको रोकने के लिए सरकार क्या कर रही है? सिर्फ बफर जोन बनाना काफी नहीं सभी लोगों में सद्भावना कैसे आएगी उसका भी प्रयास किया जाना चाहिए। यही सबसे बड़ी बात है।
ये हैं जवाब 👍