Understanding John Coltrane - Live vs Studio Recordings | Vinyl Rewind

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 19

  • @ernestaguirre4300
    @ernestaguirre4300 Рік тому +5

    Talking about John Coltrane without playing so much as a single note is like sitting down to eat and being handed an empty plate

  • @wilberteric
    @wilberteric Рік тому +3

    It can be challenging to match the intensity of Coltrane's music. However, I am pleased that you have brought along some knowledgeable guests. Well done!

  • @Cooperthecatful
    @Cooperthecatful Рік тому +3

    This is a very good discussion and captures several of the joys of jazz. Thank you.

  • @jazzkatt7083
    @jazzkatt7083 Рік тому +1

    I was literally looking at this record in store today but didn’t know anything about it. Thanks guys. 👍

  • @DaveZula
    @DaveZula Рік тому +1

    Thumbs up for doing a whole episode exploring Coltrane!

  • @Amadeusthegreat100
    @Amadeusthegreat100 Рік тому

    Very interesting. Actually induced me to buy the Damm thing. I don't have anymore room for records so,,,,stop showing me interesting things to buy.☺

  • @klep2859
    @klep2859 Рік тому

    Apparently, the individual who did the mix for this thought Elvin was the leader when one considers how high up (to the detriment of the music as a whole) he is in the mix. Next up is Workman. Then, buried underneath are Coltrane, Dolphy & Tyner. I have many, many hours of the Coltrane-Dolphy era & I get the feeling from this recording that Coltrane couldn't wait to get on with his next project & get these last few contractual obligation dates out of the way. Don't get me wrong, I'm happy to have more of this group, but there are some real cringe-inducing moments, highlighted by an unbelievably excruciating bass solo in 'Africa". I edited it out & it sounds much better. This is a sub-par performance by the group when compared to the Vanguard recordings & the many, many others that have been officially released or available to torrent.

  • @sidaisdad
    @sidaisdad Рік тому +4

    Understanding Coltrane with 3 white guys... Interesting

    • @michaelmoraga2926
      @michaelmoraga2926 Рік тому +7

      I think you mean one music lover and two musicians.
      'Jazz is the most democratic music in the world' 💜💪✌

    • @sidaisdad
      @sidaisdad Рік тому +1

      @@michaelmoraga2926 I see no fallacy in either statement.

    • @michaelmoraga2926
      @michaelmoraga2926 Рік тому +2

      @@sidaisdad Perhaps

    • @sugadelicsavagesoul8623
      @sugadelicsavagesoul8623 Рік тому +3

      Music has no color. It's universal.

    • @sidaisdad
      @sidaisdad Рік тому +2

      @@sugadelicsavagesoul8623 Art. The Arts are UNIVERSAL.

  • @rocdocs
    @rocdocs Рік тому

    Cool topic! I am excited for this one!!!

  • @herbtube7824
    @herbtube7824 10 місяців тому

    Great episode. Love to see more like that!

  • @joechiocca8429
    @joechiocca8429 Рік тому

    Agree with poster below 100%- what a tease!- let's hear some music! Will get this recording asap.
    Long live John Coltrane and his amazing group!

  • @michaelmoraga2926
    @michaelmoraga2926 Рік тому

    Hats off to the guests. For Coltrane fans, this album is pretty amazing (Elvin Jones!), especially for those of us whose all-time favorite song is Coltrane's "My Favorite Things" 💜
    Cheers from Kobe.

  • @thatwastheplan6851
    @thatwastheplan6851 Рік тому

    Cool discussion, would've been really interesting to hear Tim and Richard explain the music theory with their own instruments as well as through words.

  • @iloveweezer69
    @iloveweezer69 Рік тому

    second