This is officially the most mind-blowing TEDx talk I've ever seen. And I'm wondering why, even with many years of music instruction, I never heard that whole music IS frequency thing. Wow!
I love how he can narrate a story while playing relevant music that evokes certain emotions with his knowledge of modes(I assume he knows that). Just brilliant
I'm a teacher who love make music with high school student's band group in Koea. Thanks to invite me to that wonderful rabbit hole. I've never heard such a impressive music lecture like this. And it also a kind of great drama! I'm eager to attend your master class someday! :)
I literally only use theory when talking to people or watching a video to follow along lol. If you were to ask what I do when I play bass or guitar, I couldn’t tell ya. I just play by ear and have the fret board mapped out to what patterns sound good together. I dont think about what I’m doing though, idc what note I start on, what chord I play, I dont even pay attention. In a way I can kind of just see what I want to play or think of how I want it to sound and yeah..I just keep trying different things until I’m satisfied with what I’m hearing. Theory just makes things difficult in the sense that if I think about it, I become more focused on the theory than actually playing the instrument itself for fun. At least when you get down to the really technical stuff.
You just nailed it the deepest my Brother. You're one of the greatest Legends of my lifetime. There's som much to learn from you. Big Cheers Forever...
I wonder if after 7 years he got around to including microtones, all the stuff in between those 12 notes, and Eastern music theory. I’d love to hear an updated lecture!
Blown Away!!!! The video starts out slow, but that synthesizer part was radical on my interpretation/ music theory learning. It was always discussed that music relates to our heart beat, and I've studied somewhat the relationship between the notes and the octaves, but never came to mind to hear the these lower frequencies. It gives me questions now, can human life be reduced to twelve states of the heart, twelve beats, the twelve notes of music? Blown Away!!!!
Hi Dave! really great work! We need more people in this world that really understand the depth of what you are saying. This is all cutting edge stuff. I like that you are making it digestible for the average person out there. Its a good thing you are doing!
@@JonesJr876 Has anyone ever tried harmonizing the beat with the melody and what we generally understand as 'harmony' - or is that too subtle to make a difference? Perhaps a subliminal difference?
Sometimes too much information at once can overload, can leave stuff for the listener to later research after digestion. I studied physics for 9 years, and it never crossed my mind what low frequencies are, as this video explained. So they will pick up the meaning very soon, with this great of an introduction.
Dave: Every melody you've ever heard has been a combination of some or all of these 12 notes... King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard: We'd like to introduce ourselves
Frequency is a property of music. Rhythm uses any frequency. Melody must have rhythm that is either strict or free within the use of tempo. Western music is only part of the whole of "Music". There are more than only 12 notes.
Very true, but I believe that he was simplifying the concept down to later, western-influenced music, starting with classical music from the 1800s on up. There are infinite frequencies, and thus notes, hidden between the keys of a grand piano, but most western "ears" have not learned how to listen to them, let alone to enjoy the resultant tunes. I, for one, love almost all music, if not all songs, but the rest of the world, for the most part, does not.
That you can make a sound with a frequency (number of times per second air is being pushed to your ear) down slow enough to hear the oscillations of the air pressure as a pulse does not relate rhythm to melody in any meaningful way simply because the pitch of a note can be defined in frequency. Unless you want to believe houses are related to cars because they both have air in them, or unless you just smoked a big joint.
anyone know what bpm that E flat 1.215 frequency is? I tried to match the tempo in cubase. I got to about 75bpm (roughly) but i`m looking for Exactly, say 75.???. .. if anyone gets my meaning?
The frequency is in Hz, which is essentially beats per second. So I think you can just multiply by 60 to get your bpm. 1.215 beats per second x 60 seconds per minute = 72.9 bpm
Thank you for the reply. I have been trying to figure it out all week. I am assuming that, that 72.9 bpm E flat, would result in richer natural harmonics, when used as a set tempo in say Cubase.? That clicking sound almost sounds like a kick drum, or sub kick sound. which should compliment a kick drum at least. Very interesting. Thank you again.
be careful with leap years which actually reduce the duration of the minute by some .17628% in which case you could find yourself tearing ligaments trying to keep time properly.
We think of the tonal note as being the basis of the whole edifice but what really constitutes the foundation and what all other frequencies (notes) must abide by is the rhythm! Ideally, a masterpiece would build upon the rhythm and extend to higher pitches using the Fibonacci sequence all the way up to the highest note, would it not? That would be a TRULY harmonious piece in the Pythagorean sense, yes/no?
Fibonacci won't generate you much, I'm afraid. Take 1,1,2,3,5,8,13,22. The actual musical scale is generated by using whole number ratios, so: 2:1 = an octave; 3:2 = a fifth, 4:3 = a fourth, 5:4 = a major third and so on. The first couple are 'found' in the Fibonacci series, but the rest - 8:5, 13:8 22:8, will generated pretty unpleasant intervals not found in the western tuning system. Lots of inaccurate stuff is written about this mathematical series. I guess the principle is easy to understand and the temptation is to apply it to EVERYTHING. My advice...don't!
Fibonacci numbers are relevant exactly because they define the ratios between integers. So they are key to every temperament, like pi, phi and e are. This doesn't mean that one has to generate the ratios of values already on the fibonacci scale, like "22/8"... what would that mean in any case?
while its an amazing talk, felt he slightly mixed frequency of sound, with frequency of generating a note, when he was explaining Rhythm. Yes, everything in the world is a cycle or wave. but just because they are measure in cycles does not mean they have the same be compared in same way. Life n Death cycle is different from the number of cycles you visit your office. he making 1.215 Hz at 10.25 mins, and saying that we are hearing it not the right argument. He was make a sound note that was played at an interval of 1.215 Hz. thats it !! feel free to update me so that i can further my learning. Btw, am in no way demeaning the talk., its really amazing and learnt a lot. only wanted to get the few seemingly rough edges smoothened 🙂
let me just say it with all humiliation only on me, Beautiful night sounds like, been here all night been here all day, and I-i-i-i-i'm swinging here from side to side.
The problem with music theory, is that it breaks down something magical, and turns it into something mathematical; in order to produce cliched formula. If you want to be a magical musician, then it's a good idea to break down the cliched formula; thus turning something mathematical into something magical. After all, the best music is spontaneously magical, not strictly mathematical.
Farmer Freakeasy That’s your perspective. For me, studying and understanding the underlying processes which define musical sound, provides a deeper appreciation for the intricate complexities that constitute musical magic. Theory is not a prescriptive template like a mathematical formula, but a descriptive process of how musical structures unfold and why they function the way they do.
...except there are absolutely more than 12 "notes". Well-tempering excludes some intervals that occur earlier in the overtone series, plus some others. This is demonstrably untrue.
it'z odd but when people ztart talking ''the rabbit hole'' like they were the firzt wee genius on the planet to think of uzing that clever wee analogy i go ztraight off to zlee .. z z.. ..zz
Not much on theory at all mostly just point that it's all from just 12 notes.... then a lame song, I guess that he wrote...Not to demo anything in a specific way.... any song could have been used but what was point of song? annoying... This person could have done so much more - you can tell he's a gifted teacher but his song ate up too much of the talk with little purpose for supporting the main topic? Song is great for what it is, but putting it in this topic diminished song, and didn't serve purpose of talk. Any song w several instruments could have been put in....
Great lecture however, in this global information age your talk would be more complete if you preceeded it with a "Western Music Perspective" disclaimer. Our music is only a fraction of the other types of beautiful music around the world...e.g. the note A and harmony means nothing in Chinese music. Good talk though.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This is officially the most mind-blowing TEDx talk I've ever seen. And I'm wondering why, even with many years of music instruction, I never heard that whole music IS frequency thing. Wow!
Same!
It begins with the heartbeat in our mother’s womb...
I love how he can narrate a story while playing relevant music that evokes certain emotions with his knowledge of modes(I assume he knows that). Just brilliant
I'm a teacher who love make music with high school student's band group in Koea.
Thanks to invite me to that wonderful rabbit hole.
I've never heard such a impressive music lecture like this. And it also a kind of great drama!
I'm eager to attend your master class someday! :)
When your heart beat syncs with the frequency before the piece of magic begins just makes this ted talk so pure...
I understand ... why I not only love music, but am in love with music.
Preaching the gospel of music theory and finding music at the bottom of the rabbit hole! Artful, interesting, and good!
I literally only use theory when talking to people or watching a video to follow along lol. If you were to ask what I do when I play bass or guitar, I couldn’t tell ya. I just play by ear and have the fret board mapped out to what patterns sound good together. I dont think about what I’m doing though, idc what note I start on, what chord I play, I dont even pay attention. In a way I can kind of just see what I want to play or think of how I want it to sound and yeah..I just keep trying different things until I’m satisfied with what I’m hearing. Theory just makes things difficult in the sense that if I think about it, I become more focused on the theory than actually playing the instrument itself for fun. At least when you get down to the really technical stuff.
Awesome so much depth to his presentation. He didnt spell it out that the most lowest note was the same rhythm as the heart beat :) Great going :)
Nice work Dave! Glad to see that your love of music is still taking you new places.
You just nailed it the deepest my Brother.
You're one of the greatest Legends of my lifetime. There's som much to learn from you. Big Cheers Forever...
I wonder if after 7 years he got around to including microtones, all the stuff in between those 12 notes, and Eastern music theory. I’d love to hear an updated lecture!
"What tempo are you playing in?" "E flat"
It's roughly 75 bpm at quarter notes
but i can´t play it on that guitar, it´s too red...
Best TEDX presentation for sure. Mind blowing.
Blown Away!!!! The video starts out slow, but that synthesizer part was radical on my interpretation/ music theory learning. It was always discussed that music relates to our heart beat, and I've studied somewhat the relationship between the notes and the octaves, but never came to mind to hear the these lower frequencies. It gives me questions now, can human life be reduced to twelve states of the heart, twelve beats, the twelve notes of music? Blown Away!!!!
What a beautiful song A Beautiful Night is.
I am a singer-songwriter and you have just give me the passion I need to start learning music theory thank you!!!
Absolutely beautiful presentation.
Hi Dave! really great work! We need more people in this world that really understand the depth of what you are saying. This is all cutting edge stuff. I like that you are making it digestible for the average person out there. Its a good thing you are doing!
That song as an instrumental only would be great!
And so we should think of harmony as including rhythm...
It's a continuum of sorts.
This is blowing my mind!
Exactly!
@@JonesJr876 Has anyone ever tried harmonizing the beat with the melody and what we generally understand as 'harmony' - or is that too subtle to make a difference? Perhaps a subliminal difference?
"beautiful night" made my night beautiful.. and i like your theory
Inspiring metaphor. That E frequency though, never thought it sounded like that, like rhythm =]
Thanks for sharing!
Excellent way to demonstrate the connectivity and beauty of music and math.
A quick definition of hertz as 'number of cycles (or repeats) per second' wouldn't have gone amiss.
Sometimes too much information at once can overload, can leave stuff for the listener to later research after digestion. I studied physics for 9 years, and it never crossed my mind what low frequencies are, as this video explained. So they will pick up the meaning very soon, with this great of an introduction.
Nice. Good to hear a musician explain his passion.
This woke up the concept of rhythm to me. Thanks on to the next lesson.
Exactly! Maybe now I can find rhythm. Has me remembering how each key has it's own feel, now i get it - the keys come from a certain rhythm. wild!
6:50 is beautiful
What a beautiful song, and such wonderful message behind this talk. Thank you
3:53 incorrect. there are different tonal equal temperaments.
Dave: Every melody you've ever heard has been a combination of some or all of these 12 notes...
King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard: We'd like to introduce ourselves
beautifully done Dave!
That was freak'in beautiful !
It would've been cool if the Eb note kept playing
@1:04 Anyone, where can I find this bad-a*s "cheat sheet" to music theory?
Absolutely awesome!
Nice touch thankyou
Wonderfully presented. Thank you.
Frequency is a property of music. Rhythm uses any frequency. Melody must have rhythm that is either strict or free within the use of tempo.
Western music is only part of the whole of "Music". There are more than only 12 notes.
Very true, but I believe that he was simplifying the concept down to later, western-influenced music, starting with classical music from the 1800s on up. There are infinite frequencies, and thus notes, hidden between the keys of a grand piano, but most western "ears" have not learned how to listen to them, let alone to enjoy the resultant tunes. I, for one, love almost all music, if not all songs, but the rest of the world, for the most part, does not.
Very well presented. Admirable!
That you can make a sound with a frequency (number of times per second air is being pushed to your ear) down slow enough to hear the oscillations of the air pressure as a pulse does not relate rhythm to melody in any meaningful way simply because the pitch of a note can be defined in frequency. Unless you want to believe houses are related to cars because they both have air in them, or unless you just smoked a big joint.
Drums always win. God is a drummer.
God is a DJ
Cool little 7/4 idea at the end there
Thanks!
Actually, rhythm is everything - which is something any good hypnotist would agree to.
educational and spaceball reference. you have my axe.
I enjoyed it. Thank you
Dave Madden?
More like *Dave Madman*
anyone know what bpm that E flat 1.215 frequency is? I tried to match the tempo in cubase. I got to about 75bpm (roughly) but i`m looking for Exactly, say 75.???. .. if anyone gets my meaning?
The frequency is in Hz, which is essentially beats per second. So I think you can just multiply by 60 to get your bpm. 1.215 beats per second x 60 seconds per minute = 72.9 bpm
Thank you for the reply. I have been trying to figure it out all week. I am assuming that, that 72.9 bpm E flat, would result in richer natural harmonics, when used as a set tempo in say Cubase.? That clicking sound almost sounds like a kick drum, or sub kick sound. which should compliment a kick drum at least. Very interesting. Thank you again.
1.215 Hz = 60 x1.215 bpm = 72.9 bpm
be careful with leap years which actually reduce the duration of the minute by some .17628% in which case you could find yourself tearing ligaments trying to keep time properly.
THERE ARE MORE THAN 12 NOTES!!! Pianists are stuck in a 12 note system - not string instruments!
(see question below) or even how to work out the precise bpm. Thanks all.
What happens if you play a "G" repeatedly at the speed of "B"?
Great lecture!
There are notes between the notes.
There are frequencies between the notes.
Bruce Ruttan no... those would be the same thing if you made the notation for it
If you didn’t need that, it is already
Call it what you like ...
Very well done. Nice.
I loved it!
musicinmyopinion willbe universe to understand everyonebinuniverse
We think of the tonal note as being the basis of the whole edifice but what really constitutes the foundation and what all other frequencies (notes) must abide by is the rhythm!
Ideally, a masterpiece would build upon the rhythm and extend to higher pitches using the Fibonacci sequence all the way up to the highest note, would it not?
That would be a TRULY harmonious piece in the Pythagorean sense, yes/no?
I don't know what Timothy is talking about, but I like it. And Fibonacci's "sequence" is a new-age-spirituality lie _-sorry about that-_
How is the Fibonacci sequence "a new-age-spirituality lie" it's a mathematical sequence that uses feedback to generate exponential values!?
You're looking for spectral music. Check Grisey's "Vortex Temporum", for example.
Fibonacci won't generate you much, I'm afraid. Take 1,1,2,3,5,8,13,22. The actual musical scale is generated by using whole number ratios, so: 2:1 = an octave; 3:2 = a fifth, 4:3 = a fourth, 5:4 = a major third and so on.
The first couple are 'found' in the Fibonacci series, but the rest - 8:5, 13:8 22:8, will generated pretty unpleasant intervals not found in the western tuning system. Lots of inaccurate stuff is written about this mathematical series. I guess the principle is easy to understand and the temptation is to apply it to EVERYTHING. My advice...don't!
Fibonacci numbers are relevant exactly because they define the ratios between integers. So they are key to every temperament, like pi, phi and e are. This doesn't mean that one has to generate the ratios of values already on the fibonacci scale, like "22/8"... what would that mean in any case?
while its an amazing talk, felt he slightly mixed frequency of sound, with frequency of generating a note, when he was explaining Rhythm. Yes, everything in the world is a cycle or wave. but just because they are measure in cycles does not mean they have the same be compared in same way. Life n Death cycle is different from the number of cycles you visit your office. he making 1.215 Hz at 10.25 mins, and saying that we are hearing it not the right argument. He was make a sound note that was played at an interval of 1.215 Hz. thats it !! feel free to update me so that i can further my learning. Btw, am in no way demeaning the talk., its really amazing and learnt a lot. only wanted to get the few seemingly rough edges smoothened 🙂
That was great - thank you.
Well, Mridangam - a Carnatic percussion instrument is tuned to a pitch.
fantastic work
Does anyone know which piano that is? It sounds amazing.
That is a Steinway..
Dave, is there a way to get the slides that you presented at this event?
Does the guy not know that most other instruments also play the expanse in between those twelve notes? Including the human voice??!?
Brilliant 🤘
Thought he was going to mention triads.
In other words, all tonal notes are not equally well-fitted to the underlying rhythm, right?
superapex21 what i was wondering too
rhythm is the basic element of music. Pitch is extra. For example: dat dat dah, dat dat dah, dat dat da du daaah. This is the beginning of what song?
Jingle Bells!
It's all about rhythm!
let me just say it with all humiliation only on me, Beautiful night sounds like, been here all night been here all day, and I-i-i-i-i'm swinging here from side to side.
Famous marches
Change to famous march music
T
SPOILER: There are 12 notes.
lol, yeah that was technically the ONLY educational aspect. It was still inspirational and entertaining though.
Great
feed your head :-)
The problem with music theory, is that it breaks down something magical, and turns it into something mathematical; in order to produce cliched formula.
If you want to be a magical musician, then it's a good idea to break down the cliched formula; thus turning something mathematical into something magical.
After all, the best music is spontaneously magical, not strictly mathematical.
Farmer Freakeasy That’s your perspective. For me, studying and understanding the underlying processes which define musical sound, provides a deeper appreciation for the intricate complexities that constitute musical magic. Theory is not a prescriptive template like a mathematical formula, but a descriptive process of how musical structures unfold and why they function the way they do.
...except there are absolutely more than 12 "notes". Well-tempering excludes some intervals that occur earlier in the overtone series, plus some others. This is demonstrably untrue.
:) You went plaid.
it'z odd but when people ztart talking ''the rabbit hole'' like they were the firzt wee genius on the planet to think of uzing that clever wee analogy i go ztraight off to zlee .. z z.. ..zz
👍🎼💛
Well...we're not together, but we're suuuure out of tune!
Ode to Joy has a portion that's played in Eflat rhythm. You know what's creepy, there are no vowels in the English word rhythm.
except Y, Do'h xD
WHY??!!
Y-y-y-y-yeah!
..sometimes "Y." That letter has a interesting role in this all
Not much on theory at all mostly just point that it's all from just 12 notes.... then a lame song, I guess that he wrote...Not to demo anything in a specific way.... any song could have been used but what was point of song? annoying...
This person could have done so much more - you can tell he's a gifted teacher but his song ate up too much of the talk with little purpose for supporting the main topic? Song is great for what it is, but putting it in this topic diminished song, and didn't serve purpose of talk. Any song w several instruments could have been put in....
A banal message used as a pretense by a singer-songwriter desperate for any audience for his music. :))
If you’re jealous just say that lol 😂
jesus . it's like listening to beatnik jargon.
that was weird
He should take singing lessons.
Great lecture however, in this global information age your talk would be more complete if you preceeded it with a "Western Music Perspective" disclaimer. Our music is only a fraction of the other types of beautiful music around the world...e.g. the note A and harmony means nothing in Chinese music. Good talk though.
if only that song wasn't so horrible...
Yea the lyrics killed it for me.
No.
bla-blah... gibberish