I hope David doesn't mind, but I took a stab at transcribing his wonderful arrangement: swartzcr.the-nsa.org/cardiacs/Wind_and_Rain_is_Cold_piano.pdf (apologies for any errors, I don't play piano and I've never transcribed a full song before - but I think it's pretty accurate)
@@noahswartz5467 Good job, I was really hyped about learning to play this but a few thing really bothered me when I tried it. Some of the notes in the bassline are written an octave higher than they actually are (for example bars 6, 17 and 18). In some cases it's even unplayable because right hand is playing tha same note. I've also noticed some chord shapes aren't right, the pitches are correct but they should be (at least in my opinion) written so they make sense in terms of harmony. For example in bar 4 the first beat in treble clef looks like b flat major first inversion and you wrote it like d minor with augmented fifth, which is kinda confusing for anyone who tries to play that.
Flippin heck. Didn't know you were fluent on piano. That was marvelous.
Superb again !!!! I hope Timmy is seeing these
Brilliant cover of a brilliant song, by a brilliant band!
Just had a wee jig to this. Bloody BRILLIANT!
Worthy of laudation
Worthy of laudation ❤
Absolutely speechless. Amazing
You make it look so effortless. Another great repro David! ;-)
This is just bloody cheeky. Cracking cover!
Perfect song for the piano. Beautiful.
Udderly awesome
worthy of laudation
yeah but tune the damn thing. :)
Wow cardiacs wind and rain is cold sounds so cool in piano keep it up, I wanna play this song so bad)
Think this is one of the best Cardiacs covers out there, excellent!
Amazing
Splendid!
Beauty on an arrow... Thank you!
Awesome - great work - hard to find anyone in the US that knows Cardiacs!
Far out and groovy!
Fantastic!
I love this
Wow this sounds pretty damn good.
Incredible
❤❤❤
I hope David doesn't mind, but I took a stab at transcribing his wonderful arrangement: swartzcr.the-nsa.org/cardiacs/Wind_and_Rain_is_Cold_piano.pdf
(apologies for any errors, I don't play piano and I've never transcribed a full song before - but I think it's pretty accurate)
Thanks Noah!
I just had a minute to look but it looks pretty close! Very cool!!!
If you spot any errors, let me know and I can amend it!
@Randy Warhol Try copy pasting it? Also here is a google link for it drive.google.com/file/d/1-KGv_XcVD5s0OFihsSpL1XtLkEwJvtsW/view?usp=sharing
Cheers! My piano playing is atrocious and this sort of thing always encourages me to try and improve
@@noahswartz5467 Good job, I was really hyped about learning to play this but a few thing really bothered me when I tried it. Some of the notes in the bassline are written an octave higher than they actually are (for example bars 6, 17 and 18). In some cases it's even unplayable because right hand is playing tha same note. I've also noticed some chord shapes aren't right, the pitches are correct but they should be (at least in my opinion) written so they make sense in terms of harmony. For example in bar 4 the first beat in treble clef looks like b flat major first inversion and you wrote it like d minor with augmented fifth, which is kinda confusing for anyone who tries to play that.
Tune that damn piano.
Cool interpretation though
*Tips hat*
Score, maybe?
Hi!
I’m sorry but I didn’t make a score for this.
laudy of worthation.
This is great 👍
Superb!
Amazing