I mean it was announced more than 2 month ago. It was just that it had both a nomination and a ranking phase both needed a timetable for people to do, also I failed to give a deadline for the second part, which created confusions and that the last couple I only received around like nov 5-10. The next one, 2024 Anime Opening Party Rank, will be done in a month. I am only waiting for 2 openings to come out officially as their episodes should've premiered yesterday.
...The person who nominated that super short song put it at 88th themself...~? What...~? ...I was prepared for DAYBREAK INTERLUDE to be the lowest of my picks but dammit what the hell literally _how_ could _anyone_ put it dead last when there's that crappy rap(?) one that's even worse than freakin' unlasting-? ...A lot of these lower ones look to be quite love-it-or-hate-it. Though maybe this feeling I get was caused by a slight bit of visual confusion with even rankings around 58-59 appearing in green...~ 84 was the first of five I placed at the same position they ended up... I must say so far it has been mostly ones I didn't care for much in general... with one obvious exception. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the ones like this are lower down... 83's so catchy how'd it get so low- ...Looking at the spread of rankings further cements my non surprise at that Lucky Star song being so controversial...~ Huh. Only like 2-3 people put Taiyou no Esperzanza fairly high up, one of whom being the very person who nominated it. That somewhat reduces my anger at how it somehow overshadowed DAYBREAK INTERLUDE. Somewhat. ...Why is the least bad of the Initial D ones so unpopular...? Yeahhhhhhhh seeing the spread of rankings really does just make it even less surprising what the most controversial songs are...~ ...Honestly looking at those rankings I'm a little surprised HOUSE CAT isn't in the top 3 most controversial songs here. Eh? Why's Rikaisha so low?! Why's it... so divisive...? ...The speech? Eh? But why's that the case for Last Inferno too? And... the Precure song...? Huh?! ...Okay stay calm... I'm counting on you Sing Alive please be somewhere good... ...How the *_hell_* did Love Live beat out a goddamn GYRO song *_what-?!_* Also I swear if next is like Kizuna Music... aww that would've been funny. ah only five places too high for the funniness Well, it's a decent placement~ ...How is this Persona song not in the top three most controversial it looks like it should... ...I still don't get it. Don't a lot of people hate on idol anime for the music being really generic pop? Yet the Oshi insert that's way more generic sounding pop than most idol anime songs actually are is still popular for some reason... well, it didn't get too high at least. ...Yeah seriously looking at the spread of rankings, the Persona one and probably some of the others I mentioned really feel like they're more controversial than Kyoukaisen's ranking spread... I guess the maths used for that are probably somewhat more complex than I thought...~ wait that Love Live one is the second of the five exact matches I got- ...How did And I'm home get such a high placement...? ...I guess I can probably chalk it up to whatever the hell makes unlasting so unreasonably popular, too... maybe. It is interesting how those ended up next to each other...~ Who the frick put a Claris song in dead last wha- ...Okay why have the songs that I ranked at the same place they ended up all been really random ones so far? A random one I don't like, Love Live, and now... I genuinely don't remember running into this, despite how I put it at 30. ...Two in a row what. Also yeah 4/5 of them are really random. Okay and yeah... Kuuhaku has a wide range of rankings it received too it appears... 87th through to 1st... I still don't get why it's the most popular song, aside from it's place in the show being the cool climax insert. Musically it really pales in comparison to the rest of the songs... 25th huh... that'll do. That'll do... wait we still haven't had Ave Mujica whaT- ...And the two songs that followed it... _shudders_ I am now no longer content with that ranking... okay make that the three that followed okay four but at least they're getting better Yup, Cinderella, definitely getting better~ Looks like the top 20 are mostly popular and non-random songs... on chAngE is the fifth one huh. And the only non-random one. ...four people put it at 6th, one 7th, one 8th, two 9th and one 4th... huh... it's still, ironically, Ave Mujica's least good song... Oh my gosh the songs at the top here though...~ Reimei, This Life, Stay With Me... the top songs sure are deserving~ ...Black Catcher is op10 and it got 10th pfft...~ ...Hadaka no Yuusha I think is a song ruined by the vocals for me. That said I'm not a big fan of RAISE A SUILEN's cover either but... it's definitely better. _♪"Shaaaaaaaa-naaaaaaa-aaaaaaaa, onore no soraa..."_ Miiro got a first, a second, a third, and a fifth, yes~ Three people put Magia at 5th and it ended up at 5th. Huh~ Wait did first place get to first place with no first place rankings? ...To start with I thought it would be easy to list off all the big "what the hell" moments but then it quickly proved to not be the case. It was only in the top 20 and bottom few that those moments numbered few. I also apologise for how difficult to follow this comment may have been.
#89 I mean the fact that it was nominated by him/her does not mean that he/she thinks it is a good song :P I am more dissappointed by teh two 1s #87 wait we had a crappy rap one? ohh the (red and green) colours mean that the person's ranking differ from the songs final ranking #79 tbf I do think taht the oprder kinda resembles their objective ranking so ... -\_/- #71 ohh yeah Bannou Bunka got robbed #70 I think it just sounds like a basic singer group song, the rhythm is really basic, no outstanding instrumental or base either, and I would not call the singing performance outstanding either, it is good for a wanna listen to music, but not a lets listen to somwthing super awesome (= mid in the literal sense) #68 well some of the criticisms still apply :P #61 well it is around the similar type of songs, I'm more suprised how last resort got that low, it is a genuinely nice song #55 tbf there are a couple people who would rate any love live bang dream etc high no matter what so it kinda contributed them getting bunched up #51 ohh there are way more controversials #43 from the songs in this sample sign wa has a far more tight and intricate beat, it is composed that the baseline is not a faltish line, but mroe like a mountainline with valleys, I overvalue drums but if you listen to the drums just themselves you can hear how it changes with the song, plus the singing has a wider amplitude as well #38 ohh no if you look at the numbers Kyökaisen is really controversial, for reasons I dont know, I literally lsitened to it dozens of times to try to determine how people gauge it one of the worst song of the lot, I went throught everything, beat, rhythm, instrumentals, instrumentals individually, amplitude, singing, the only thing I found is that the baseline is somewhat oscillating too much to a 1..2..3..1..2..3..1..2..3 pattern which can become boring after a lot of listening, for the deviation I can go into it at the end #36 certain people seem to like it, since I'm on literally the same opinion about it as you, couldn't say why #35 I think it is just carried by it's wave and LiSA's tremendous singing talent #31 ohh this I can answer without any doubt, the person who put it last hates that the nominator likes this song so it was mostly out of beef, I would like if everyone would just rank the songs on how good of they are songs, but sadly not something I can police in any way, even though it grieves me deeply. #28 tbf I think this is the most bland of them all, so flat and meh... but hey '... anime with rock song instead of pop so put it high' (at least how I interpreted it) genuinely how hard I tried to find flaws in Kyökaisen I tried almost as hard to find virutes in this, I was unsuccesful #17 my fav song is just 17th :'( #14 nah Ave Mujica is veritably awesome, if all of their other songs are higher quality even better, but out of the music anime ones this one deserves best placement imo #13-11 yeah really good songs, Im really happy for finding Deltora Quest #10 deserved better, I cannot see in objectively outside of top3 of this lot #5 ohh yep, deserved aw imo #1 yep, basically because noone placed it really low unlike all the others ohh no problem I just had the video on one window, the comment on another and writing the answer in a notepad :P also yeah I do plan my revenge on people that ranks based on funnies and ohh I like/dislike the person who nominated it so I'll put it in first/last ten (dont worry nothing nefarious) for the deviation I will jsut copy from my message to drasta it is standard deviation, ou find the mean, sub the mean from all numbers, get their absolute value, square them individually, add them together, divide it by (number of numbers-1), then root it [for me it was to just put STDEV [range] into the spreadsheet]
I do agree with this ranking. I probably have issues accepting with re:Hamatora OP but I guess the visuals is cool enough.
I think the Re:Hamatora opening is a good song, did not expect it to end up so high though.
@@Franktamas It's in general a very popular opening, especially amongst anirankers
How good was this PR
I was surprised that it was done very quickly haha, one of the fastest editions I've seen
PS. I won with my Hanna ni Natte
I mean it was announced more than 2 month ago. It was just that it had both a nomination and a ranking phase both needed a timetable for people to do, also I failed to give a deadline for the second part, which created confusions and that the last couple I only received around like nov 5-10.
The next one, 2024 Anime Opening Party Rank, will be done in a month. I am only waiting for 2 openings to come out officially as their episodes should've premiered yesterday.
Also well dont with Hana ni Natte, it does deserve it.
Top 10s are great
yeah, for me they were all in my top20 so I do generally agree :)
surely lucky star is #1 right guys. It has the voice of an angel.
no
@@zanedimensions3834 :D
If you want to join the next PR, the full 2024 Anime Opening one, join the otaclub discord
discord.gg/otaclub
...The person who nominated that super short song put it at 88th themself...~? What...~?
...I was prepared for DAYBREAK INTERLUDE to be the lowest of my picks but dammit what the hell literally _how_ could _anyone_ put it dead last when there's that crappy rap(?) one that's even worse than freakin' unlasting-?
...A lot of these lower ones look to be quite love-it-or-hate-it. Though maybe this feeling I get was caused by a slight bit of visual confusion with even rankings around 58-59 appearing in green...~
84 was the first of five I placed at the same position they ended up... I must say so far it has been mostly ones I didn't care for much in general... with one obvious exception. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the ones like this are lower down...
83's so catchy how'd it get so low-
...Looking at the spread of rankings further cements my non surprise at that Lucky Star song being so controversial...~
Huh. Only like 2-3 people put Taiyou no Esperzanza fairly high up, one of whom being the very person who nominated it. That somewhat reduces my anger at how it somehow overshadowed DAYBREAK INTERLUDE. Somewhat.
...Why is the least bad of the Initial D ones so unpopular...?
Yeahhhhhhhh seeing the spread of rankings really does just make it even less surprising what the most controversial songs are...~
...Honestly looking at those rankings I'm a little surprised HOUSE CAT isn't in the top 3 most controversial songs here.
Eh? Why's Rikaisha so low?! Why's it... so divisive...? ...The speech?
Eh? But why's that the case for Last Inferno too?
And... the Precure song...? Huh?!
...Okay stay calm... I'm counting on you Sing Alive please be somewhere good...
...How the *_hell_* did Love Live beat out a goddamn GYRO song *_what-?!_*
Also I swear if next is like Kizuna Music... aww that would've been funny.
ah only five places too high for the funniness
Well, it's a decent placement~
...How is this Persona song not in the top three most controversial it looks like it should...
...I still don't get it. Don't a lot of people hate on idol anime for the music being really generic pop? Yet the Oshi insert that's way more generic sounding pop than most idol anime songs actually are is still popular for some reason... well, it didn't get too high at least.
...Yeah seriously looking at the spread of rankings, the Persona one and probably some of the others I mentioned really feel like they're more controversial than Kyoukaisen's ranking spread... I guess the maths used for that are probably somewhat more complex than I thought...~
wait that Love Live one is the second of the five exact matches I got-
...How did And I'm home get such a high placement...?
...I guess I can probably chalk it up to whatever the hell makes unlasting so unreasonably popular, too... maybe. It is interesting how those ended up next to each other...~
Who the frick put a Claris song in dead last wha-
...Okay why have the songs that I ranked at the same place they ended up all been really random ones so far? A random one I don't like, Love Live, and now... I genuinely don't remember running into this, despite how I put it at 30.
...Two in a row what. Also yeah 4/5 of them are really random.
Okay and yeah... Kuuhaku has a wide range of rankings it received too it appears... 87th through to 1st... I still don't get why it's the most popular song, aside from it's place in the show being the cool climax insert. Musically it really pales in comparison to the rest of the songs...
25th huh... that'll do. That'll do... wait we still haven't had Ave Mujica whaT-
...And the two songs that followed it... _shudders_ I am now no longer content with that ranking...
okay make that the three that followed
okay four but at least they're getting better
Yup, Cinderella, definitely getting better~
Looks like the top 20 are mostly popular and non-random songs... on chAngE is the fifth one huh. And the only non-random one.
...four people put it at 6th, one 7th, one 8th, two 9th and one 4th... huh... it's still, ironically, Ave Mujica's least good song...
Oh my gosh the songs at the top here though...~ Reimei, This Life, Stay With Me... the top songs sure are deserving~
...Black Catcher is op10 and it got 10th pfft...~
...Hadaka no Yuusha I think is a song ruined by the vocals for me. That said I'm not a big fan of RAISE A SUILEN's cover either but... it's definitely better.
_♪"Shaaaaaaaa-naaaaaaa-aaaaaaaa, onore no soraa..."_
Miiro got a first, a second, a third, and a fifth, yes~
Three people put Magia at 5th and it ended up at 5th. Huh~
Wait did first place get to first place with no first place rankings?
...To start with I thought it would be easy to list off all the big "what the hell" moments but then it quickly proved to not be the case.
It was only in the top 20 and bottom few that those moments numbered few.
I also apologise for how difficult to follow this comment may have been.
#89 I mean the fact that it was nominated by him/her does not mean that he/she thinks it is a good song :P I am more dissappointed by teh two 1s
#87 wait we had a crappy rap one? ohh the (red and green) colours mean that the person's ranking differ from the songs final ranking
#79 tbf I do think taht the oprder kinda resembles their objective ranking so ... -\_/-
#71 ohh yeah Bannou Bunka got robbed
#70 I think it just sounds like a basic singer group song, the rhythm is really basic, no outstanding instrumental or base either, and I would not call the singing performance outstanding either, it is good for a wanna listen to music, but not a lets listen to somwthing super awesome (= mid in the literal sense)
#68 well some of the criticisms still apply :P
#61 well it is around the similar type of songs, I'm more suprised how last resort got that low, it is a genuinely nice song
#55 tbf there are a couple people who would rate any love live bang dream etc high no matter what so it kinda contributed them getting bunched up
#51 ohh there are way more controversials
#43 from the songs in this sample sign wa has a far more tight and intricate beat, it is composed that the baseline is not a faltish line, but mroe like a mountainline with valleys, I overvalue drums but if you listen to the drums just themselves you can hear how it changes with the song, plus the singing has a wider amplitude as well
#38 ohh no if you look at the numbers Kyökaisen is really controversial, for reasons I dont know, I literally lsitened to it dozens of times to try to determine how people gauge it one of the worst song of the lot, I went throught everything, beat, rhythm, instrumentals, instrumentals individually, amplitude, singing, the only thing I found is that the baseline is somewhat oscillating too much to a 1..2..3..1..2..3..1..2..3 pattern which can become boring after a lot of listening, for the deviation I can go into it at the end
#36 certain people seem to like it, since I'm on literally the same opinion about it as you, couldn't say why
#35 I think it is just carried by it's wave and LiSA's tremendous singing talent
#31 ohh this I can answer without any doubt, the person who put it last hates that the nominator likes this song so it was mostly out of beef, I would like if everyone would just rank the songs on how good of they are songs, but sadly not something I can police in any way, even though it grieves me deeply.
#28 tbf I think this is the most bland of them all, so flat and meh... but hey '... anime with rock song instead of pop so put it high' (at least how I interpreted it) genuinely how hard I tried to find flaws in Kyökaisen I tried almost as hard to find virutes in this, I was unsuccesful
#17 my fav song is just 17th :'(
#14 nah Ave Mujica is veritably awesome, if all of their other songs are higher quality even better, but out of the music anime ones this one deserves best placement imo
#13-11 yeah really good songs, Im really happy for finding Deltora Quest
#10 deserved better, I cannot see in objectively outside of top3 of this lot
#5 ohh yep, deserved aw imo
#1 yep, basically because noone placed it really low unlike all the others
ohh no problem I just had the video on one window, the comment on another and writing the answer in a notepad :P
also yeah I do plan my revenge on people that ranks based on funnies and ohh I like/dislike the person who nominated it so I'll put it in first/last ten (dont worry nothing nefarious)
for the deviation I will jsut copy from my message to drasta
it is standard deviation, ou find the mean, sub the mean from all numbers, get their absolute value, square them individually, add them together, divide it by (number of numbers-1), then root it
[for me it was to just put STDEV [range] into the spreadsheet]