Taiwan Becoming History

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 118

  • @brendonzhan6633
    @brendonzhan6633 Рік тому +66

    Homegrown Taiwanese here,
    Well done here, as it is surprisingly elaborate!!!!😁😁😁
    However, I would like to give some suggestions for the historical part if you don't mind (for the sake of historical accuracy).
    The migration of the Chinese people to Taiwan during the Sui dynasty is just some speculation, as Taiwan as an official name in the Chinese document did not exist until the 1600s.
    The Chinese used the name liuqiu to identify several islands including the Ryukyu islands (modern day-Okinawa), Penghu (an outskirt island that was colonised much earlier), and Taiwan. Unfortunately, nobody could really identify the name was really referring to til this day. (so whether the migration really happened it's subjected to debates.)
    Also, the Austronesian people were pretty widespread on the western plains before colonisation. (many plain indigenous people kept their identity to this day, practicing/reviving their religion, and the elders also strive to keep the language. e.g. papora and pazeh people )
    One of them (Siraya) even had a codified language (introduced by the Dutch)
    The kingdom of Tungning was much bigger, stretching all the way to central Taiwan (including tributaries) bordering the tribal confederation of Middag.
    Please feel free to ask any questions regarding the political climate and the history of Taiwan :)
    Once again, great work !!!

    • @yothitweeling9691
      @yothitweeling9691 Рік тому +1

      Not really a question, but perhaps do you have a book recommendation about the history?

    • @brendonzhan6633
      @brendonzhan6633 Рік тому +2

      @@yothitweeling9691 Unfortunately I cannot think of any that is written in English....unless you speak Mandarin.
      You could dig up academic journals regarding Taiwanese pre-historic era or Formosan tribes, they are pretty hardcore ofc...but they are definitely the most accurate source. (Many western universities have Taiwanese studies)

    • @matteogibbone8917
      @matteogibbone8917 Рік тому +2

      I wanted to ask, was the culture of Taiwan influenced by Polynesian tribes and Spanish and Japanese rule?
      I also wanted to ask if the Chinese spoken in Taiwan is classical Mandarin and if it is dialectal?
      P.S. Taiwan is one of my favorite countries in asia.

    • @brendonzhan6633
      @brendonzhan6633 Рік тому +3

      @@matteogibbone8917
      Yes but the extent varies
      Indigenous influences:
      1.most of the religious Taiwanese believes in Taoism and Buddhism, since Taoism is a polytheistic religion, indigenous gods and goddesses are often incorporated into local pantheons.
      2. Some Hakka people/other Hans ethnicities that lives on the mountain have Indigenous surnames (vice versa) due to frequent intermarriages.
      Japanese influences:
      1. the prosperity of Taipei is basically the product of Japanese colonisation, the old capital would be Tainan (in the south)
      Pretty much every cities went through japanisation, back then Shinto shrines were erected in every townships, most of them were torn down during KMT's dictatorship but there are still a couple around.
      2. My grandparents along with many others in their generation speaks Japanese (colonisation duh), Japanese also remains the second most popular foreign languages after English (sometimes I would say Japanese is even more influential)
      3. Japanese loan words are extremely common in Taiwanese hokkien, which my family uses in daily conversations.
      The list goes on, but hopefully you find this helpful 🙂

    • @matteogibbone8917
      @matteogibbone8917 Рік тому +1

      @@brendonzhan6633 thanks you for the explanation

  • @JakubSobczyk2137
    @JakubSobczyk2137 Рік тому +101

    Holy Moly The Real China

    • @AportuGeese
      @AportuGeese  Рік тому +23

      dont you mean the "only china"

    • @pituman7777
      @pituman7777 Рік тому +4

      ​@@AportuGeeseis the only one but Winnie the Pooh controls the continent...for now

    • @caiodreemurr7837
      @caiodreemurr7837 Рік тому +4

      -999999999999999999 social credit

  • @njung1990able
    @njung1990able Рік тому +22

    Woah this was quicker than my ex

  • @starcobra2575
    @starcobra2575 Рік тому +18

    Kingdom of IKEA becoming history: Tip; Whilst most games show sweden as a united state during this time... Sweden was only really united somewhere in the 1200s, and was mostly divided by the Geats and Swedes.

  • @NupidStigger
    @NupidStigger Рік тому +36

    -100,000,000 social credit

  • @ddaydmox_dixie
    @ddaydmox_dixie Рік тому +7

    as a taiwanese🇹🇼 I can confirm this video❤👍

  • @mosbang2700
    @mosbang2700 Рік тому +12

    Can cofirm Taiwan is pretty safe. Last time I lost my wallet inside a train station and noting went missing after I retrieved my wallet from Lost & Found

    • @brendonzhan6633
      @brendonzhan6633 Рік тому

      I am glad that you enjoyed your trip 😊😊
      Hopefully you didn't find the streets a bit too...hectic..

    • @mosbang2700
      @mosbang2700 Рік тому +2

      ​@@brendonzhan6633 I'm Taiwanese. Well yeah the traffic here is basically warzone

    • @danshakuimo
      @danshakuimo Рік тому +1

      @@mosbang2700 One life crossy road

    • @brendonzhan6633
      @brendonzhan6633 Рік тому

      @@mosbang2700 so you definitely get what I mean, brother 😂

    • @brendonzhan6633
      @brendonzhan6633 Рік тому

      @@danshakuimo Indeed.

  • @wheresmyeyebrow1608
    @wheresmyeyebrow1608 Рік тому

    3:12 "I am Liutenant Kim Kitsuragi, from Precint 57"

  • @empireofnewjersey7117
    @empireofnewjersey7117 Рік тому +14

    Social Credits deduction -50000000000000000000

  • @somemeansfish8987
    @somemeansfish8987 Рік тому +11

    Damn I thought it might just be Bulgaria today considering it's our national holiday

  • @stuadel
    @stuadel Рік тому +3

    Chiang and Mao where good friends lol

  • @Igor-tn6cw
    @Igor-tn6cw Рік тому +1

    What's the last song? I couldn't find it in the description but it's fammiliar

  • @carpathianwolf3523
    @carpathianwolf3523 Рік тому +3

    Swamp Germany next video

  • @IronWolf123
    @IronWolf123 Рік тому +7

    Do one for Australia

  • @graalpom7902
    @graalpom7902 Рік тому

    Based video although with a few historical inaccuracies but understandable due to the 3 minutes format. Great video nonetheless.

  • @billybob892
    @billybob892 Рік тому +1

    Music for 1:57?

  • @slavqka666
    @slavqka666 Рік тому +8

    The girl's name you put as olympic gold medalist is actually a weightlifter, now im not sure if she was the first to win a gold or not tho :D

  • @OEN_WORLD
    @OEN_WORLD 10 місяців тому

    Holy cow the real chainese

  • @achour.falestine
    @achour.falestine Рік тому +5

    -100%
    Social credit

    • @adnan_honest_jihadist5775
      @adnan_honest_jihadist5775 Рік тому +2

      doesnt matter taiwan/ROC is still independent de facto

    • @achour.falestine
      @achour.falestine Рік тому +3

      @@adnan_honest_jihadist5775 personally i would have agreed
      but my social credit card maaaaaan

  • @iustintudor6874
    @iustintudor6874 Рік тому +1

    What is the name of the song in the spanish colony period?
    Please I love the song but I dont know its name

  • @Pillzpop
    @Pillzpop Рік тому +1

    Plz do The Netherlands next! Greetings from Canada!🍁

  • @vanir762
    @vanir762 Рік тому +21

    Ironic how in the past Taiwan and China had the same Dynasties, but today they are separate peoples

    • @kaspervletter290
      @kaspervletter290 Рік тому +7

      Ultimately the chinese and taiwanese are the same people
      (I’m not being a ccp fanboy here, most taiwanese are of han origin)

    • @jeffsirloin2558
      @jeffsirloin2558 Рік тому

      @@kaspervletter290 the ccp? what is that? do you mean the cpc?

    • @jeffsirloin2558
      @jeffsirloin2558 Рік тому

      far from separate people. they have the same culture, history, everything. the only reason taiwan is separate at all right now is because of colonialism and fascism

    • @kingking-ci1gf
      @kingking-ci1gf Рік тому +3

      @@jeffsirloin2558 id say it would be better this way. Truth is, the majority of the population doesnt really think Taiwan should be reunited with mainland China, democratic or not. The old "take back the mainland" folks are either sitting in an eldercare or six feet under. But hey, im not here to change your views on the matter, just providing you with some information, if you dislike it, just mark it as propaganda and move on.

    • @Ranze
      @Ranze Рік тому

      nah we the same people just different governments

  • @MikeBison_
    @MikeBison_ Рік тому

    Surely you’ve used every Sonic Unleashed track by now lmao

  • @OneTrueVikingbard
    @OneTrueVikingbard Рік тому

    Lol “kingdom of ikea”

  • @dpatty999
    @dpatty999 Рік тому +3

    do one for Singapore

  • @lessssssgooooo
    @lessssssgooooo Рік тому +1

    Bing chilling.

  • @gigachad2162
    @gigachad2162 Рік тому

    Based Kuomintang

  • @safetyawareness5353
    @safetyawareness5353 Рік тому

    3:12 is that Kim Kitsuragi?

  • @brainsterb107
    @brainsterb107 Рік тому

    Ah I see, Kim Kitsuragi, I see ur a man of culutre!!

  • @sbd03
    @sbd03 Рік тому +1

    You have -999999999999999 social credit now.

  • @leon1x1
    @leon1x1 Рік тому +1

    -9999999999999999999 Social Credit 😨😨😨😨

  • @Steppenwolf.85
    @Steppenwolf.85 Рік тому

    Swamp Germany for sure

  • @DJ7ful
    @DJ7ful Рік тому

    You forgot about the Republic of Formosa.

  • @khaleef420
    @khaleef420 Рік тому +1

    Do finland becoming history pls

  • @RomGe336
    @RomGe336 Рік тому

    TAIWAN REAL CHINA! LESSGOOOOOOO

  • @yahyahmensahstudios4828
    @yahyahmensahstudios4828 Рік тому

    Tai- what ?

  • @dandycrowks7903
    @dandycrowks7903 Рік тому

    Yo its Taiwan

  • @omaruto9254
    @omaruto9254 Рік тому

    I would love a korea video

  • @ricardogunnz2
    @ricardogunnz2 Рік тому

    It's like Israel, recognized by a few and still it's the only country in the middle east that is not a shithole.

  • @LouBoyo
    @LouBoyo Рік тому +2

    Tens de fazer um video sobre o afonso de albuquerque e como ele aterrorizou os arabes🤣

  • @mihaimarius
    @mihaimarius Рік тому

    Another banger

  • @Kayypags
    @Kayypags Рік тому +1

    Woah, first Person Here..

  • @heitormedina7098
    @heitormedina7098 Рік тому

    Do one for china

  • @savongoldledoree8619
    @savongoldledoree8619 Рік тому

    *East Taiwan

  • @noidea5984
    @noidea5984 Рік тому

    Ikea pliss

  • @AUGUSTUSCAESAR-gz1qe
    @AUGUSTUSCAESAR-gz1qe 9 місяців тому

    Free west Taiwan

  • @niateppelin5287
    @niateppelin5287 Рік тому

    Wrong flag sir taipei island is part of PRC

  • @pyophyo8901
    @pyophyo8901 Рік тому

    0:08 since when did Polynesians settled into Taiwan? Didn't a group related to melanesians and negritoes were the first to settle there before the pre-austronesians came later?

  • @SSA-qb6pb
    @SSA-qb6pb Рік тому

    One of the only asian countries that has life quality of Western Europe👍👍