The Score in this scene really gives you chill of tears in addition to watching everyone in that scene have an emotional moments especially Regina. I started tearing up at 1:05 and the score just built up more tension toward the end of the scene and with a bit of Emma's theme added to it, it really is enough to make anyone tear up.
Hook too. He was never part of the curse and could have left if he wanted. I could understand Hook not wanting to get in the way of Bealfire and his son, but Bea wasn't leaving either. At least one of them could have stayed T-T
He would be swept up by it because he was born in the Enchanted Forest the only reason. Henry wouldn't be able to go is because he was "born in a land without magic".
Actually Regina, that's not true. It is their price too. It's Snow's, it's Charming's, it's Emma's, it's Henry's, and it's Neal's. Snow and Charming be with their daughter. Emma can't be with her parents. Henry can't be with his grandparents and father. And Neal can't be with his son.
METerrell Henry wasn’t born in Storybrooke. But his parents were, so when the curse was destroyed it sent everyone born in Storybrook back to the enchanted forest. But because Henry is technically not from the EF he will have to stay behind alone. He couldn’t stay behind all alone without his memories, he would end up in foster care or worst. So the only solution was that Emma would have to stay with him. Neal technically could but it would have changed too much. With Emma staying behind with Henry the only thing that would have changed was Emma keeping him.
@@YourMomz07 it's because she's able to cross the town line so she can escape the curse cloud. That's also why Hook and Neal should also technically be able to leave but I guess the writers wanted to just focus on Emma and Henry
They'll remember; we know from the promo that they do (Snow says "We're back") the symmetry of this resolution is great: in the first curse none of them knew but Henry and Emma weren't cursed, now the fairytale lot will remember but Emma and Henry are the ones who need to have the spell removed rrrrrrrrroll on March 9th!!!!
Has everyone forgotten about Alexandra, Prince Thomas and Cinderella’s daughter? What will happen to her? She was born in Storybrooke and not the Enchanted Forest! Will she be stuck in reality as well? Will she be the new Emma, separated from her parents?! We need more info on more characters. More flashbacks! Aurora? Robin Hood? Cinderella? Mulan? And what happened to Red?!
Yeah Lana Parrilla absolutely killed it in this episode. This whole season is what really made her character development one of the best characters of the show. Sorry...THE best character!!
Still crying over this scene, especially Snow's lines. It came full circle, mothers giving up their babies to give them their best chance D,x Dang you Regina & Snow!!! *can't wait to see how hook's plan to fix this * CaptainSwan FTW!!!
@Colin Mahoney 100%ly agree. I remember waiting months for the next episode and then they just came up with a new curse. The writing became really bad. Suddenly the new villain (Zelena) is Regina's never mentioned sister (because the idea of adding her came just up). It's so stupid making her Regina's sister. Everything had to be connected: Ingrid was Emma's foster mom, Lily was Emma's best friend (we had that plot already with Neal, why again?), Hades loves Zelena, etc... So many plot holes came up since season 3B, for example the inventor of the curse. In seasons 1-3A it was said that Rumple created the curse. Later they change it into Rumple stole it with the help of the queens of darkness from a monster and then it was said that the black fairy was the inventor of the curse. It's so stupid writing. Rumple being the inventor, like they told us in the first two and a half seasons, made much more sense. He created the curse to find his son. In my opinion Hook and Emma don't have such a chemistry as Neal and Emma. They were way more emotional, at least to me. 1x01 - 2x16 perfect writing 2x17 - 3x11 still very good 3x12 - 3x22 it's okay 4x01 - 6x22 wtf... character developments always go back and forth, depending on the plot. Snow, Charming, Henry and a lot of other characters went from cool main characters to characters who just were there. If those three were quitting after season 3, the plot still would've be mostly the same. Because no one cared about snow and charming anymore after this writing. In season 1,2,3A Gold was never the main villain. He played for himself and he even helped the charmings if he gets something out of it. To emma he was more likely a mentor. Since season 3, especially 3B (but it already started on 3A) they've changed the theme, Regina and Gold switched roles. Before Regina was the enemy, later gold was the main enemy and Regina helped the charmings. I liked the former layout more that Gold helped if necessary and Regina was the villain. That happened ever since gold was revived. It feels like the writers didn't know what to do with Gold after he was resurrected from the dead.
"it's not our curse it's mine" when i rewatch this scene i can't help but think she is wrong,i mean i get why she think it's her curse but it's this others as well: Hook lose Emma,Bae just lose his father and now Emma and Henry as well, the Charmings lose their daughter and grandson, Belle just lost Rumple, Emma and Henry lose her evryone except from themself and forget about everything this Scene is so sad i can't wait for march
This would have been the perfect ending except Neal could have stayed since he wasn't affected by the 1st curse and gave Emma, Henry & Neal a chance to be a happy family. The 3 have suffered so much without fault of their own. Emma & Henry were both given up due to circumstances of their parents, Neal was abandoned. As much as I'd love to see Hook & Emma, he did partake in destroying Neal's family so let's say this is now the karma he has to pay. Those that must return to the enchanted forest should have their memories of Storybrooke wiped too so they can all restart, Charming & Snow get a 2nd chance to start a family without memories of Emma & Henry as that will forever sadden them, make Regina a Queen instead of evil Queen and let everyone love her. I truly enjoy S1-S3 only until this point. After that the writing is all over the place. Adding more & more characters that feel so forced. Unfortunately when a TV show is only focusing about prolonging for profit, that's the story you're getting. I was so annoyed when Hook showed up in NY. I just want Henry & Emma to be happy together forever. They so deserve it
Yeah but he wasn't born there. So, technically speaking, he doesn't "belong" there because he doesn't have a story there. He would have nothing to go back to. Think of it like DBZ. Remember why Goku and Krillin couldn't be wished back right away after Namek? Because since Namek died, they'd have no place to be wished "back" to? Same concept. Henry doesn't have a "tale" to live out from the Enchanted Forest. Neither does Emma for that matter. He has no place for the curse to put him in. If he had a Magic bean or something that could just transport him, it would be different. But Regina undoing the curse can't bring him because the curse didn't put him there to begin with
This whole mid-season finale pissed me off. The only good thing was Pan dying but that was ruin with Rumple dying! Now the Charming family is once again apart, poor Belle heart is broken & to top it off we gotta wait till MARCH 9... Ehh just depressing. THE WRITERS BETTER FIX THIS & BRING RUMPLE BACK.
They were in shock. All of them.They just saw Rumple kill his father and himself (as far as they knew) right in front of them. And then they still had to deal with the curse that Pan had cast.
I'm glad this wasn't the end of the show!this isn't a happy ending at all!maybe it can be good for Snow,David and Regina!because they can be finally the family which they never were before and Snow can have a new baby,with the love of her life and good side of her step-mother!Regina can be queen again but with a new chance and new family!but the price was loosing Emma and Henry💔and no way I will accept Rumple and Belle can never be together again😢and Neal!he literally lost everything!he never had any interest in Enchanted Forest and in this episode he lost his father as well💔there was nothing left for him in Enchanted Forest!all he had was Emma and Henry in this world!why shouldn't he come with them? Thank God!I would never accept this kind of ending!
that's what I'm asking!even if he belonged to Enchanted Forest,now he has nothing there!his father was dead!all he had was just Emma and Henry on this world!
I just don't get one thing... When they get back to Enchanted forest will they remember this? I guess not but then then regina will be probably evil again :(
Wait…so Regina cast the curse with the heart of the thing she loved most (her father), but the price to break the curse is…also the heart of the thing she loves most? How does that even work? It almost ensures that it never gets broken, since it can’t be guaranteed that the original caster finds something else to love.
Just out of curiosity I watched this scene and scene they give her up first time in comparison. Just couldn´t understand how this seems so much less painful for them ;( Or is it just act because now Emma knows also what is happening?
Aurinkohelmi I get a little bit of what you're saying but I also think that it's a bit of ' we just found you and now we're going to lose you again but it's for the best so we know that we have to do it '.
To this day, I still don't understand why Hook and Neal had to return. The curse did not bring them here. They should've been able to leave Storybrooke.
Perhaps with Hook it's because he entered our world through Storybrooke so if the curse never existed he could never have entered, which would also be why as a not originally cursed person he could come back. No explanation for Neal at this time. Perhaps because he wouldn't have come to Storybrooke if it had never existed, so his being there is an example of its existence? It doesn’t really work: what would is him having his memories replaced with Emma and Henry. Of course that would have made the Captain Swan ship harder to steer, which may explain why it was written the way it was.
What if Emma had been stuck in the Enchanted Forest because she was born there? But Hook wasn't. He was born in the real world, albeit a few hundred years earlier. What if he had taken care of Henry in the real world?
+Leon King Presents in his backstory they were in the kings Navy. And the original story of captain hook he was born in England. Is it ever really stated that he was born in the fairytale world? It's not like you can't be born in the normal world. Cruella De vil was
When Snow said "Emma you have to go" look at the panic on hooks face :( my babies
"Emma you have to go!" I hate and love at the same time how Hooks head snaps round his expression kills me :(
When Regina tells her that she has to go- the first close up is on Hook looking devastated then at Snow. Such an emotional scene. Good job OUAT.
Poor Hook! How many looks of devastation can one guy express in a single scene.
The Score in this scene really gives you chill of tears in addition to watching everyone in that scene have an emotional moments especially Regina. I started tearing up at 1:05 and the score just built up more tension toward the end of the scene and with a bit of Emma's theme added to it, it really is enough to make anyone tear up.
Agreed. I just wish I knew who sang the song in Emma's apartment when she was cooking breakfast.
IndigoRoseDiaries The song is by Lou Reed - Charley's Girl :)
Thanks, Erika. I found it.
:)
Awww Regina in this scene, There is no more evil queen, Poor emma she has lost her parents again x
REGINA IN THIS EPISODE!!!! XDDDD
Don't you mean Rumple😭😂
Never understood why Neil never went with Emma and Henry. He wasn’t swept up in the first curse, he should have been able to escape Pan’s.
Hook too. He was never part of the curse and could have left if he wanted. I could understand Hook not wanting to get in the way of Bealfire and his son, but Bea wasn't leaving either. At least one of them could have stayed T-T
He would be swept up by it because he was born in the Enchanted Forest the only reason. Henry wouldn't be able to go is because he was "born in a land without magic".
I don't know why when I saw this episode I started cry so much I love this song
and this is where i started losing it...
Actually Regina, that's not true. It is their price too. It's Snow's, it's Charming's, it's Emma's, it's Henry's, and it's Neal's. Snow and Charming be with their daughter. Emma can't be with her parents. Henry can't be with his grandparents and father. And Neal can't be with his son.
METerrell Henry wasn’t born in Storybrooke. But his parents were, so when the curse was destroyed it sent everyone born in Storybrook back to the enchanted forest. But because Henry is technically not from the EF he will have to stay behind alone. He couldn’t stay behind all alone without his memories, he would end up in foster care or worst. So the only solution was that Emma would have to stay with him. Neal technically could but it would have changed too much. With Emma staying behind with Henry the only thing that would have changed was Emma keeping him.
Hey, Neal could've gone with them.
yeah... actually it doesn't make sense why Emma could stay... she was technically born in the enchanted forest
@@YourMomz07 it's because she's able to cross the town line so she can escape the curse cloud. That's also why Hook and Neal should also technically be able to leave but I guess the writers wanted to just focus on Emma and Henry
They'll remember; we know from the promo that they do (Snow says "We're back") the symmetry of this resolution is great: in the first curse none of them knew but Henry and Emma weren't cursed, now the fairytale lot will remember but Emma and Henry are the ones who need to have the spell removed rrrrrrrrroll on March 9th!!!!
Can't come soon enough!
AMEN!
1:59- She looks at Regina! XD
If they had stretched this story across the rest of the Season then this could've been a better ending.
Has everyone forgotten about Alexandra, Prince Thomas and Cinderella’s daughter? What will happen to her? She was born in Storybrooke and not the Enchanted Forest! Will she be stuck in reality as well? Will she be the new Emma, separated from her parents?! We need more info on more characters. More flashbacks! Aurora? Robin Hood? Cinderella? Mulan? And what happened to Red?!
They've said what happened to Alexandra; she was CONCEIVED in the Enchanted Forest... so went back.
Regina in this episode nearly killed me meyn
She DID kill me! ;")
Yeah Lana Parrilla absolutely killed it in this episode. This whole season is what really made her character development one of the best characters of the show. Sorry...THE best character!!
That was such a great episode! One of the best of the series!
Ahhh! The feels!!
Still crying over this scene, especially Snow's lines.
It came full circle, mothers giving up their babies to give them their best chance D,x
Dang you Regina & Snow!!!
*can't wait to see how hook's plan to fix this * CaptainSwan FTW!!!
eoddekdd
Sod do ekddk
Lsdldkd, ekdkkskskedke235
Im extremely happy the show was given another season an ending like this would have really sucked
You got that right ;-)
Marshan Mitchell well I would love this to be the end it's so bittersweet happy endings aren't what you think they will be
@Colin Mahoney 100%ly agree. I remember waiting months for the next episode and then they just came up with a new curse. The writing became really bad. Suddenly the new villain (Zelena) is Regina's never mentioned sister (because the idea of adding her came just up). It's so stupid making her Regina's sister. Everything had to be connected: Ingrid was Emma's foster mom, Lily was Emma's best friend (we had that plot already with Neal, why again?), Hades loves Zelena, etc...
So many plot holes came up since season 3B, for example the inventor of the curse. In seasons 1-3A it was said that Rumple created the curse. Later they change it into Rumple stole it with the help of the queens of darkness from a monster and then it was said that the black fairy was the inventor of the curse. It's so stupid writing. Rumple being the inventor, like they told us in the first two and a half seasons, made much more sense. He created the curse to find his son.
In my opinion Hook and Emma don't have such a chemistry as Neal and Emma. They were way more emotional, at least to me.
1x01 - 2x16 perfect writing
2x17 - 3x11 still very good
3x12 - 3x22 it's okay
4x01 - 6x22 wtf... character developments always go back and forth, depending on the plot.
Snow, Charming, Henry and a lot of other characters went from cool main characters to characters who just were there. If those three were quitting after season 3, the plot still would've be mostly the same. Because no one cared about snow and charming anymore after this writing.
In season 1,2,3A Gold was never the main villain. He played for himself and he even helped the charmings if he gets something out of it. To emma he was more likely a mentor.
Since season 3, especially 3B (but it already started on 3A) they've changed the theme, Regina and Gold switched roles. Before Regina was the enemy, later gold was the main enemy and Regina helped the charmings. I liked the former layout more that Gold helped if necessary and Regina was the villain.
That happened ever since gold was revived. It feels like the writers didn't know what to do with Gold after he was resurrected from the dead.
this is probably my favorite episode of once upon a time !
This scene and the whole episode break my heart =(
I can't believe we have to wait until March! =( =(
Once upon a time. Family cry. Good bye😭
Ah, the good ol' days of OUAT...
OMG I cried When They Said Goodbye 😥
"it's not our curse it's mine" when i rewatch this scene i can't help but think she is wrong,i mean i get why she think it's her curse but it's this others as well: Hook lose Emma,Bae just lose his father and now Emma and Henry as well, the Charmings lose their daughter and grandson, Belle just lost Rumple, Emma and Henry lose her evryone except from themself and forget about everything this Scene is so sad i can't wait for march
I ruii was gonna you like a goat 🐐 I gotta was
I miss this show!!! Sunday nights are not the same!!!
This scene made me cry
This would have been the perfect ending except Neal could have stayed since he wasn't affected by the 1st curse and gave Emma, Henry & Neal a chance to be a happy family. The 3 have suffered so much without fault of their own. Emma & Henry were both given up due to circumstances of their parents, Neal was abandoned. As much as I'd love to see Hook & Emma, he did partake in destroying Neal's family so let's say this is now the karma he has to pay.
Those that must return to the enchanted forest should have their memories of Storybrooke wiped too so they can all restart, Charming & Snow get a 2nd chance to start a family without memories of Emma & Henry as that will forever sadden them, make Regina a Queen instead of evil Queen and let everyone love her. I truly enjoy S1-S3 only until this point. After that the writing is all over the place. Adding more & more characters that feel so forced. Unfortunately when a TV show is only focusing about prolonging for profit, that's the story you're getting. I was so annoyed when Hook showed up in NY. I just want Henry & Emma to be happy together forever. They so deserve it
Once upon a time story book best
But Henry is the son of two people FROM the enchanted forest. He DOES belong there!
Yeah but he wasn't born there. So, technically speaking, he doesn't "belong" there because he doesn't have a story there. He would have nothing to go back to.
Think of it like DBZ. Remember why Goku and Krillin couldn't be wished back right away after Namek? Because since Namek died, they'd have no place to be wished "back" to? Same concept. Henry doesn't have a "tale" to live out from the Enchanted Forest. Neither does Emma for that matter. He has no place for the curse to put him in. If he had a Magic bean or something that could just transport him, it would be different. But Regina undoing the curse can't bring him because the curse didn't put him there to begin with
Oh! Okay, I see! I’ve never watched DBZ, but I get what you’re saying. That makes sense.
the problem is Regina had to gave him up!means he couldn't come with them in anyway possible
i cry by this scene by this episode is so sad :'( :'(
Regina is my one and only favourite.
I cry for this episode... ç-ç
Did u see hooks face when snow said "emma you have to go" i was like nooooooo what about bout hook he deseavers his true live
This whole mid-season finale pissed me off. The only good thing was Pan dying but that was ruin with Rumple dying! Now the Charming family is once again apart, poor Belle heart is broken & to top it off we gotta wait till MARCH 9... Ehh just depressing. THE WRITERS BETTER FIX THIS & BRING RUMPLE BACK.
He's not dead. The Dark One probably is, but Rumple isn't.
He better not be dead!!
And how could they just stand there while Belle was sobbing in the middle of the street... so heartless.
They were in shock. All of them.They just saw Rumple kill his father and himself (as far as they knew) right in front of them. And then they still had to deal with the curse that Pan had cast.
RIGHT! If they can do a mass petition to bring back that stupid dog back on Family Guy, we can have our bowl of soup back!
We need to see an episode when Emma was a baby what would of happen if she stay w her parents?!
I'm glad this wasn't the end of the show!this isn't a happy ending at all!maybe it can be good for Snow,David and Regina!because they can be finally the family which they never were before and Snow can have a new baby,with the love of her life and good side of her step-mother!Regina can be queen again but with a new chance and new family!but the price was loosing Emma and Henry💔and no way I will accept Rumple and Belle can never be together again😢and Neal!he literally lost everything!he never had any interest in Enchanted Forest and in this episode he lost his father as well💔there was nothing left for him in Enchanted Forest!all he had was Emma and Henry in this world!why shouldn't he come with them?
Thank God!I would never accept this kind of ending!
This is so sad.. it looks like the story is already over...i started tearing apart on this part...
oskskkkdkssksk
Kssksksksl
Owwkwwkwkskskkskss sk sk
Everyone is talking about Hook’s face, and I’m like, Neal’s face is, “I lost my father now I’m losing the love of my life and my son”.
I think this would have been the perfect place for the series to end. It went full circle.
Despite being series finale-ish having Emma and Henry forget their family didn’t feel right.
NO NO NO is HOOK!!!? 😍😍
I feel so bad for snow
Regina mills. Bye cry Henry Regina mills
this episode is so sad :(
Poor hook. Hes so sad
soskkksk Ks kdkdkd
Lwwkskskksk
Kskeksmwkwkwkdm
😭❤
What I don’t get is why didn’t neal leave with emma and henry
that's what I'm asking!even if he belonged to Enchanted Forest,now he has nothing there!his father was dead!all he had was just Emma and Henry on this world!
10 years ago?!?!?!? 😭😭😭
It be cool goosebumps and jungle book and magic school bus and American tall tales show up in once upon a time
@2:47
Hook: Well.... fuck.
HENRY DOESNT EVEN CARE ABOUT NEVER SEEING REGINA AGAIN!! (He will soon though!)
W
I just don't get one thing... When they get back to Enchanted forest will they remember this? I guess not but then then regina will be probably evil again :(
on march 9th the witch of the west is coming to Once Upon a Time
Hook
Wait…so Regina cast the curse with the heart of the thing she loved most (her father), but the price to break the curse is…also the heart of the thing she loves most? How does that even work? It almost ensures that it never gets broken, since it can’t be guaranteed that the original caster finds something else to love.
Just out of curiosity I watched this scene and scene they give her up first time in comparison. Just couldn´t understand how this seems so much less painful for them ;( Or is it just act because now Emma knows also what is happening?
Aurinkohelmi I get a little bit of what you're saying but I also think that it's a bit of ' we just found you and now we're going to lose you again but it's for the best so we know that we have to do it '.
To this day, I still don't understand why Hook and Neal had to return. The curse did not bring them here. They should've been able to leave Storybrooke.
Perhaps with Hook it's because he entered our world through Storybrooke so if the curse never existed he could never have entered, which would also be why as a not originally cursed person he could come back.
No explanation for Neal at this time. Perhaps because he wouldn't have come to Storybrooke if it had never existed, so his being there is an example of its existence? It doesn’t really work: what would is him having his memories replaced with Emma and Henry. Of course that would have made the Captain Swan ship harder to steer, which may explain why it was written the way it was.
@@rtozier2011 yeah but he was able to leave town so he could have just crossed over the town line when the curse hit and avoided it lol
só eu de BR q chorou ?
Oi aqui kkk😍
What if Emma had been stuck in the Enchanted Forest because she was born there?
But Hook wasn't. He was born in the real world, albeit a few hundred years earlier. What if he had taken care of Henry in the real world?
+Breeanna Leavitt No, Hook was born in Fairy-Tale world.
+Leon King Presents in his backstory they were in the kings Navy. And the original story of captain hook he was born in England. Is it ever really stated that he was born in the fairytale world? It's not like you can't be born in the normal world. Cruella De vil was
+Breeanna Leavitt I am talking about Once Upon a Time version, as for Cruella, she was born in fictional 1920s world.
+Leon King Presents
True enough. I didn't know. Is it ever stated he was born in the fairytale land specifically? I don't remember when it was.
But caption swan hooks face just kills me
henry come home to me and your sisters
Donny beoint. I am. go. sent you. Emma and. Henry. are. leave. stroybrooke. from your. friend. Tanya Lynn venema larente
silly? not to sound rude but is Snow white pregnant in this episode?
The character wasn’t yet, but Ginnifer Goodwin might’ve been.
@@lavendertheflower4352 Thanks.
NO NO NO is HOOK!!!? 😍😍