We take a look back at the biggest clues and possible hints in EastEnders' whodunit mystery. Follow Digital Spy on Twitter at / digitalspy Like Digital Spy on Facebook at digitals...
I think jake did it, because he left abruptly after Lucy's death and he knew that Lauren knew that he had killed someone. So maybe, because Lucy and Lauren were wearing the same suit and they had their hair the same, jake meant to kill Lauren but killed Lucy instead?
I know this would be the biggest let down...but what if Lucy - after arguing with everyone on that night, accidentally overdosed on cocaine and died. She did this while she was at home, she opened her music box, took the drugs out and overdosed (hence why she heard the music before she died). Someone found Lucy's body, probably Jane, and she saw that Lucy had overdosed on cocaine with the drugs next to her - so to protect Peter from getting arrested since he supplied the drugs, Jane took Lucy's body and dumped it on Walford common to make it look like a murder. Also, Lucy hit her head when she was at the car lot which explains why the police say there is head trauma and that's how she died. (so they think.) The number that Lauren saw on Emma's paper thing was in fact related to Peter that's why she looked shocked and decided to break off the marriage because she thought Peter murdered Lucy. Emma also thought the same as Lauren and thought it was murder but it actually wasn't. Stupid theory but I thought i'd give it a go :)
It was Cindy, her and Lucy got into an argument and with Cindy being pregnant she didn't want to hit lucy so grabbed the only thing closest to her, the jewellery box. Cindy goes to find Ian, and realises he's not at the restaurant, that's why she knows his alibi is wrong, she goes back to the house and jane and bobby are already there, Jane then helps her get rid of the body. Emma put the box under the tree at Christmas because she believed that it had something to do with the murder, she wanted to see everyone's reactions, when Emma was in the pub and Denise said 'I've only left him for 5 minutes' she put two and two together when bobby went missing and Jane said the exact same thing, she then thought the killer was jane! At the park she met up with jane and she told her what actually happened with Cindy and that's why Emma said it's still murder though, later she text jane saying she can't keep the secret. It was jane's phone who went off. Emma isn't dead she is under witness protection and I think the undertaker (les) has faked the funeral etc like he did with nick cotton, and she will come back at the wedding with the police and reveal all
lara massarella there was hardly any blood that is why jake got out, she could of injured herself as she did go there a couple of times and on the night of her death
When trying to work out who killed Lucy, there are the main things you have to think about. Emma was the first to find out, but how? Was it someone she already knew or was it someone she interviewed, became curious about that person and checked for clues? Obviously there's no point in wondering if it was someone who didn't like her because a lot of people fell out with Lucy in the past and near when she was murdered. But then you have to watch who acts the most uncomfortable when Lucy is brought into a conversation such as being fidgety, sort of hiding their face or stuttering when speaking or being desperate to leave the room/building. Example: After Lucy's funeral when Peter arrived in the pub and told everyone he was going to buy them all drinks to toast Lucy and right after Whitney wanted to leave even though she just came into the pub a minute before and seemed a bit too desperate about it. But the main clue you have to think about now, is the music box. Who could have been able to have their possession of it. Was it someone living in the Beale house? Was it someone who knew how to break into houses? Or was it someone confident enough to have just walked into the house maybe when the door wasn't locked and stole the box? But that wouldn't have been necessary, unless they wanted the box for something? (Sorry I just like to try solving things even though I know we're all going to find out possibly in a months time :P)
I know loads of people were acting uncomfortable/dodgy etc since the killing, but didn't the writers/actors not even know who it was going to be back then so they would of just got everyone to act a bit that way
It was Cindy. She hid the jewelry box under the tree and played like it wasn't her to frame everybody else. She knew that Lucy took cocaine, and that she hid it in there because she used the music from the box to help get her baby, Beth, to sleep. Beth has been seen crying a lot? She discovered the cocaine when using the box to get Beth to sleep and angrily she hit Lucy over the head with the box. I know this because it was revealed at the NTA's that the music was the last thing she heard. And she panicked so I think she asked someone (maybe Jane or Bobby) to help her carry the body into the forest to make it look like she'd been mugged by someone else.
There are 3 things that killed lucy 1.the head injury 2.the drugs 3.THE KILLER When lucy banged her head at Max's work it was badly injured And she took drugs,that effected her The killer idk But did u notice when Emma met up with the killer she said he might be hungry to the van so it could be a man or boy and when she died she whispered to max"u know" which kinda gives us a clue that max helped the killer or is covering for her or knows who it is?
The biggest clues I got were from Abi's behaviour & her life events, Max could have found out & hid the murder weapon. The way Emma talked to the culprit & acted in January, has only strengthened my theory that it must be Abi. I'll be very surprised if I'm wrong.
Most people are forgetting the fact that Lucy's ear ring and blood were found in the flat that Jake and Alex lived in. It was revealed that only 2 people other than the people who were already living there had access to the flat which were Billy and Peter. Meaning that unless there is something else we are missing it can only be one of those 2 who murdered Lucy, with them probably attempting to setup Jake for the Murder. All the evidence points towards Peter being the killer, with Jane helping out.
It was Bobby the night before she got "murdered" was actually the night she got murdered! Bobby was playing with the clock thing and found the drugs. He pushed her away when she tried to take them off him and she fell and died. Jane moved the body.
I heard that the killer is Lee because apparently there was meant to be a clue in the EastEnders Children in Need special, and apparently the clue was on Ian's crossword puzzle near the end and it has "stop it Lee" or "Lee stop it" written on it somewhere or something...but I dunno...
It was Ian. Because after tonight's partly live episode it was revealed she was killed at home so it must be Ian or Jane. But remember Ian got in to an argument with Lucy that day and left a voicemail on her phone saying 'sorry' so it must be Ian and it's not obvious enough not to be Ian because the creators want to shock people.
Quote " Emma also asked the ice cream man to stay open probably so Bobby could get an ice cream" more likely she asked them stay open abit longer because she was meeting a killer and didnt want to meet them without there being a witness to that meeting ... maybe?
I think it was Peter. He was angry at Lucy being the 'only one' to Ian and fed up of her taking drugs yet seeming 'perfect'. He also lived in the flat where her DNA was found. Also it is likely to be someone leaving Eastenders. Nick dies this week so that lets him out, Lauren is leaving to have a baby in April and Peter is leaving so it could well be him. Bobby put Lucy's jewellery box under the tree at christmas.
I think Lauren did it, she lied about her whereabouts the day she died, they didn't include her in the ending photo of all the suspects and may have gotten angry when realizing that Lucy had been having an affair with Max. However, Max believes it is Abbey and is trying to protect her. Lauren has already tried to leave the house.
so many people loving my theory! It won't let me reply to some of the comments but, to answer some of them... janes reason for covering for Cindy is because Cindy didn't want to lose the baby, and because jane can't have babies. Made her want to do it more. Her blood was in the flat because she went home with jake to his house after getting hit by ABI which I figured out last night, the producers said she had three strikes to the head, max doing the first one. Then abi, so the third person hitting her killed her. At the time (Christmas Day) Emma was doing the investigation herself, therefore probably seen no reason to hand the jewellery box in, as she was trying to solve the case herself and she was nothing more To do with the police as they dropped her from the case. I don't think Cindy done it on purpose, she obviously didn't know that Lucy had already been injured beforehand, third strike on the same place obviously killed her, I believe Ben and jay have something to do with it because Abi thinks she killed her that's why she needed jay and Ben so cover for her! I think tonight's will be a case of peter pointing his fingers at his dad and jane and everyone's shouting at each other and Cindy just says 'it was me' or something like that, doof doof doof....
It was bobby! Lucy was writing something and bobby hit her with the box then jane comes in and starts to cry and turn round and bobby says whatever she says its her fault she made evryone unhappy.
so it must be someone rom the beale house hold,ian,peter jane or bobby,wait there is denise,,,,money is on peter,denise knows,maybe thatswhy she is drinking so much,hell it couldn't be because of breaking up with ian,she wanted to do that before lucy died
bobby.. in the ad it showed lucys handprints on the shop door bottle caps in the shop and lights flickerin in the shop and bobby beale was in the shop!!
I can not sleep been over 4 hours since it was revealed that Bobby killed Lucy! I did like how EastEnders did the GOOD FRIDAY Episode. It has a different edge to it! Like an AFTER HOURS edge to it!
I think Denise - she's close enough to the family so she left Lucy's body in a place where she knew it would be found quickly. She has also been shown to be declining mentally and has been abusive towards Patrick. She has a motive - she didn't want to be with Ian and maybe wanted to hurt him very badly. The only thing I can't piece together is her finding the purse and phone in the allotment. It is a mystery indeed... looking forward to finding out who the killer is!
I love eastenders but it always goes the same way with this programme it's been the same for as many years as I can recall my 3 theories on who killed Lucy are as follows Cindy: Cindy wasn't getting any attention at all she felt like the outsider. She found out about the drugs before hand and threatened Lucy to tell Ian. .Maybe she hit Lucy over the head with the jewellery box(as Lucy's death was a head injury) came to a shove. I.e she killed lucy. She told jane , and Jane met up with Emma I remember Emma saying "it's still murder"Emma was reluctant to report Cindy as she is a young mother. there was a trailer that the last thing Lucy Heard was the jewellery box. Cindy gave Jane the jewellery box and it was put under the tree. But know one would suspect it was Cindy with the shocked look on her face. Jane hid the jewellery box under the floor board, but is she protecting Cindy or herself? Peter: overheard Ian telling Lucy she was the favourite and as any sibling would be was devastated we saw Lucy run out the house and call after peter. She the walked up bridge street towards the common and he followed her they talked and I don't think he intentionally killed her but maybe she riled him a bit and he pushed her and she banged her head. After hearing she died of a head injury he could he have been guilty. Peter was told by Ian about the fatality death of his sister and he was screaming outside of the Vic could this be an admission of guilt? Abi: she found out about ax and Lucy dirty little rump an she "when max was walking the dog" went out to confront Lucy, who was at the common and she killed her. When Abu returned home she she probably got chips or a takeaway and told her dad she went out to get chips or something. I think maybe Abi stole Beth's jewellery box and tried to frame Cindy and put her in the frame as when you hear the phrase jewel box you think girly young girl little baby and Cindy's got one of those. But what I want to know is why did Abi stalk Lauren on halloween. Could be the act of someone who is guilty of something to you? I did think it was Denise but she was at Oxford all day but I think she either was involved in a way or know who instigated the terrible attack Thank you for reading my theories
I am certain its abi-3 letter name,no strong alibi,went pysco at halloween stalking and nearly drowning lauren,she was in the beale house at christmas,every time lauren brings up the subject she shuts it down
It's actually hilarious how people think the killer is someone who likes tea... Jesus Christ. Emma doesn't know the killer likes tea, she ordered them both a drink.... What's the drink that most people order? Tea! People are reading way too much into it because they all like to think themselves as great detectives... It's so laughable
I think it's Abby because it just seems like the one you least expect... Although Lauren may not be marrying Peter because she feels guilty since her sister killed Peter's Sister
It was Bobby who killed Lucy Beale with her music box apparently she started it and made everyone unhappy so he hit her, and rang Jane, telling her that lucie wasn't waking up, and when Jane came, she found Lucy dead and Bobby confessed.
I think it was Cindy, but the show wants us to think it was abbi, but on the episode were Emma met with the killer at the cafe before she met them, it showed her texting someone and it showed cindy giving her baby to ian, and she was somehow the one that first saw lucy's music box, but it could also be jane when she was hiding Emma's phone
What if the killer kept the music box and kept it in there house, then one day the family were throwing things out giving things to charity and the music box makes its way into the collection, now imagine if someone thought "i know i'll put this under the tree for cindy's baby," cindy had recently confided in emmaabout how hard being a teen mum is for her in the beale house and emma was the sort of woman who would give an anonymous gift in these circumstances. I think it was abi (although the obvious choice is normally the wrong choice) abi killed lucy with the music box used her dads car to move the body took the music box home and was throwing it away and emma took it(not knowing it was lucys) to give to cindys baby. Also abi mentioned that she was sure that the police would catch lucys killer using "HER" to refer to the killer. Billys just a perv for having those photos and aleks had the laptop because lucy had been round the flat with jake creating their website, she must have left it in there, the same goes for the blood and the earing
Well at today's episode that I watched it was about a vision of what happened in Lucy's past ,Lucy was found dead in between two beds in I think it was the kids bedroom,and then someone came in and found her laying on the floor dead after that the little boy came in and said something. So in my opinion I think the little boy did it and the lady that had a fight with Lucy earlier in the vision covered for him. Answer me if you think I got it wrong or if you think there is any more clues I missed. thank you and reply to this message. All my love Matilda 🐾🐙
I think it's Abi because Abi had dated Jay in the past and had got mad at Lucy for liking Jay. I think Jay is innocent (in a way). Abi's alibi isn't reliable because Max went out and Lucy was on her phone as well that night.
I entered the competition and said Cindy Beale because I think Emma put the box under the tree for Cindy because she wanted to see her reaction to it. She didn't tell the police because Cindy has a baby to look after and she is young, and I believe that it was an accidental murder. I also think Jane helped Cindy get rid of Lucy's body and then met Emma in the park to explain that Cindy did it, but that she cant tell the police. I don't know, but im thinking that or Peter.
I personally think 2 people were involved in her murder. I think it was Abi and Jane. Lucy had a text of an unknown person, I think that unknown person was Abi. Lauren left a card for Jane in tonight's episode saying Lucy was killed at home. Abi could of sent the message to Lucy saying meet me at your house we need to talk or something like that. They had an argument at Lucy's about Lucy sleeping with Max, Abi lashes out and Lucy ends up unconscious. Abi thinks she killed Lucy leading her to run home pretending nothing happened. As Lucy begins opening her eyes, Jane comes in and as Lucy begins to get up, Jane in startled and doesn't see who it is, Jane lashes out and ends up finishing her off. (That's probably the dumbest theory but I think the Abi part could be true but I'm sticking to I think that 2 people were involved)
I think Lee Carter killed her and confided in Mick, those two were making some strange faces after she was killed, i think they originally planned for it to be Mick/Danny Dyer, but he proved to be a well liked character, so they'll dump it on Lee Carter instead. It's all so silly, but that's my guess :)
i think it was abi as she was jealous of Lucy and she slept with her dad, i think there were two people went to see Emma, jay and Ben, abi had told them and they would cover up for her, also max knows as he said sorry to Emma when she died. lauran knows who killed Lucy as she found out in yesterdays episode and she cant look at abi the same way. also abi may have saw max fighting with Lucy that night and it made her angry, whilst max kept on walking the dog, she snuck out and killed her or told Ben and jay to do it for her............
Billy Mitchell? Lucy and that other guy took over Janine's business and took the money from it and didn't give any to Billy (or something like that I can't remember) I just remember those episodes where Billy and Lucy weren't getting along because of Janine's business. Plus he had the photos under his fridge !!!
I think it was Bobby this is why 1bobby agent through Lucy's jewellery box nd found the heroin then Lucy got mad and forced Bobby to through the box in her head then Jane came down and being the mother and called masood to cover it up they ditched the body in the common and left her bag there so it p looked like she had been mugged
Instead of thinking about who did it and why, think about who has the most connections round the square! Lauren said that when it is revealed who did it, it will change everything and the directors say it will change everyone's relationship with each other! So figure out who is the most connected then if they have motive, then you most likely have the killer.... So, using this logic, I think it is either Ian (as he has many connections and it would make sense as to why Peter and Lauren leave) or Jane (for the same reasons as Ian) or another random person like Jay or someone
Emma sent the box to see the reactions of everyone there, she had access to the Beale's house during the initial investigation and probably took it then. My theory is that Whitney accidentally killed Lucy, Lee knows as well. Emma found out when she looked at Roxy and Ronnie's house at the end of an episode and remembered Lee had enough time to leave the party without much notice to go to the Beale's and help her, going back after Lucy dies. Lucy was also standing on her home during a trailer suggesting she was killed there too. Everything else is a red herring. What makes this more plausible is that Lee would be strong and able enough to move her body to somewhere she would be found quickly. Whitney and Lucy were never really great friends, only coming together for Lauren. Tolerating each other for a few weeks they fall out over a boy, again. This is Whitney's motive for being in her room. She's acted guilty from the beginning He would also be clever enough to divert suspicion away from himself and Whitney, telling the police about Billy and Lucy's argument that night; he later sent incriminating evidence he found of Lauren to frame her which deflects attention. Lee also phoned Lucy and left a message after returning to the party to give himself an alibi. Nancy questions him about not being there the whole night at some point also suggesting he is lying about his whereabouts too.
from the very beginning i have said abi branning, i have not changed it even now i have even entered her name into the competition, people are twisting little information and overthinking it, she wouldnt commit suicide, that would be a pointless ending to a 10 month storyline, plus it has to be interesting, i doubt her family killed her, i mean would they really think her family would be capable of murdering her no, it has to be someone out of her family, i doubt the guy or woman who owns the funeral home would do it, they wasnt in it long enough to have thought of killing her, they would get more buisness from old people dying than killing a young person like lucy, max is out i believe, emma texted the killer when she was sat next to max in the car what would the point of that, plus the way emma was talking to the person it was like she was talking to a young person, if she talks to a adult like that i would be left wondering wtf is wrong with her, that leaves jay, ben or abi.. when heather was killed by ben, jay couldnt cope and had a breakdown, he couldnt keep the secret long enough and if they have forgotten that then i would be wondering why, ben had only just got out for murdering heather, i doubt he would have murdered lucy just after he got out, that leaves ABI, she killed her dog and acted like she didnt care, she helped her father clean up his work place i mean that was suspicious from the very beginning and she scared lauren and she tried to kill her, she wouldnt of let go if she had to choice, it could have been a accident but i do believe abi
Bobby killing lucy to me is just not plausible. Even by accident. He's a child, he would have been pretty distressed and cracked by now. I think Jane deffinetely covered the death up, question is for who and is she aware of who? What puzzles me is the killers interaction with Emma. Emma says "it's still murder". Now that clearly tells me it must have been some sort of accident and the killer gave an explanation. Or Emma would have gone straight to the police. But it also tells me that the person who she spoke to is aware of what they did, right? It makes sense to me that she was speaking to Jane; she respects her and wouldn't go straight to the police without her side of the story. So since Jane KNEW who she was covering up (didn't just find lucy dead) it could have only been a close family member/friend. It's not Peter he barged in yesterday accusing the rest of his family; you just wouldn't do that if you were the killer. It's not Bobby for reasons above. And Ian was just much too distraught after the death it doesn't make any sense. That leaves Cindy. Sure Cindy and Lucy didnt get on. But I can't see that story as being very emotional or worthy of a after 30 years of Eastenders live show..
Just watched part 2 OMG I can't believe bobby would do it I knew there would be some kind of twist but I diddent get the beginning of part 2 were Lucy was floating off the ground and then she opens her eyes someone please let me know what that's all about.
I think it was Max the only person that can drive or one of the Beales because they are all happy but it is gonna come crashing down and the killer will be found out at Ian's 5 th wedding - his parteners are like busses - one goes and another one comes . :)
It was bobby that killed lucy jane went to ians house to find lucy dead on the floor and she stood up and bobby was there with a box and bobby said it was her fault 😱
OMG Bobby killed Lucy he hit her with a box because he thought that she was marking every one unhappy also he herd Denis and Lucy fighting so he thought he needed to kill her😱 Bobby was in the egsact same spot where him and Jane must of moved her but if they were in Cardiff how does he no where she was found ? And when Jane went looking for him she did not find him masood found when he was delivering mail when max went by Lucy's gate I thought that max went in but it was Bobby I know it but I had lots of douts though.😨😱😱😱😱
I think max said that Abi killed Lucy because he knew Lauren knew something and when she left in a hurry he assumed she was leaving because he thinks that Lauren leaving coz Abi killed Lucy. That is why i though Max said that XD
I think he said that since he thinks she did but I don't think Abi did it, I think it's to drive us away from who really did it. Know what I'm sick of? This, if I was Lauren no matter how hard it was I would of given the police everything and told them all I know. But I know this is a soap so I'll shut up since it's meant to be drama filled. XD
I think Jane killed Lucy because shes a suspect and it's ian and janes wedding day soon and when it is Lauren will confront Jane and expose the secret to everyone
It was Bobby he pushed lucy and she fell and died and Jane is covering for her but in the episode a boy took Lucy's phone so he has that now and she wrote a note
I think the killer is Cindy. The show wants us to think that it's Abi, because of Max and Lucy sleeping together, but the killer being Abi is too obvious. I think the killer is Cindy because of how she acted when Lucy died. Cindy wasn't so shocked as much a Peter and Ian was, heck Denise was more shocked than Cindy. Plus Cindy lied that Ian wasn't at home with her on the night Lucy died. Why would she lie about it, and why would she kill Lucy is what I'm questioning? Was Cindy jealous of Lucy?
Because Cindy doesn't like Lucy that much and she doesn't know her that well. Plus Peter is her twin and Ian is her dad. Denise would have been her step-mum and knew her for years. They are obviously going to have the worse reactions to it. Also Cindy has no motive and no clear evidence.
It's gonna be someone everyone least expects,, my guess is les Crocker,, because he is still a suspect, but no one ever talks about him,, also I heared from a spoiler a long time ago, it was les, but not sure true or not
I can't believe Bobby did it!
Too much GTA boy! XD
pokedragonS8 HA
My goodness the killer likes Tea! Narrowing it down to everyone in England!
Your racist bastard I hate tea
I think jake did it, because he left abruptly after Lucy's death and he knew that Lauren knew that he had killed someone. So maybe, because Lucy and Lauren were wearing the same suit and they had their hair the same, jake meant to kill Lauren but killed Lucy instead?
I think is Lauren Emma jay Ben 💔
It's weird that Bobby wasn't mentioned in this at all , but he was really the killer .
I know this would be the biggest let down...but what if Lucy - after arguing with everyone on that night, accidentally overdosed on cocaine and died. She did this while she was at home, she opened her music box, took the drugs out and overdosed (hence why she heard the music before she died). Someone found Lucy's body, probably Jane, and she saw that Lucy had overdosed on cocaine with the drugs next to her - so to protect Peter from getting arrested since he supplied the drugs, Jane took Lucy's body and dumped it on Walford common to make it look like a murder. Also, Lucy hit her head when she was at the car lot which explains why the police say there is head trauma and that's how she died. (so they think.) The number that Lauren saw on Emma's paper thing was in fact related to Peter that's why she looked shocked and decided to break off the marriage because she thought Peter murdered Lucy. Emma also thought the same as Lauren and thought it was murder but it actually wasn't. Stupid theory but I thought i'd give it a go :)
I think that it was jay or Max. They make it the person you would least expect
It was Cindy, her and Lucy got into an argument and with Cindy being pregnant she didn't want to hit lucy so grabbed the only thing closest to her, the jewellery box. Cindy goes to find Ian, and realises he's not at the restaurant, that's why she knows his alibi is wrong, she goes back to the house and jane and bobby are already there, Jane then helps her get rid of the body. Emma put the box under the tree at Christmas because she believed that it had something to do with the murder, she wanted to see everyone's reactions, when Emma was in the pub and Denise said 'I've only left him for 5 minutes' she put two and two together when bobby went missing and Jane said the exact same thing, she then thought the killer was jane! At the park she met up with jane and she told her what actually happened with Cindy and that's why Emma said it's still murder though, later she text jane saying she can't keep the secret. It was jane's phone who went off.
Emma isn't dead she is under witness protection and I think the undertaker (les) has faked the funeral etc like he did with nick cotton, and she will come back at the wedding with the police and reveal all
What about the blood in the flats were Tina used to live
Maybe she went round to Tina's after being hit on the head then left.
and bring back Grant to help sort Max out
lara massarella there was hardly any blood that is why jake got out, she could of injured herself as she did go there a couple of times and on the night of her death
I completely agree, apart from the bit about Emma not really being dead.
When trying to work out who killed Lucy, there are the main things you have to think about. Emma was the first to find out, but how? Was it someone she already knew or was it someone she interviewed, became curious about that person and checked for clues? Obviously there's no point in wondering if it was someone who didn't like her because a lot of people fell out with Lucy in the past and near when she was murdered. But then you have to watch who acts the most uncomfortable when Lucy is brought into a conversation such as being fidgety, sort of hiding their face or stuttering when speaking or being desperate to leave the room/building. Example: After Lucy's funeral when Peter arrived in the pub and told everyone he was going to buy them all drinks to toast Lucy and right after Whitney wanted to leave even though she just came into the pub a minute before and seemed a bit too desperate about it. But the main clue you have to think about now, is the music box. Who could have been able to have their possession of it. Was it someone living in the Beale house? Was it someone who knew how to break into houses? Or was it someone confident enough to have just walked into the house maybe when the door wasn't locked and stole the box? But that wouldn't have been necessary, unless they wanted the box for something? (Sorry I just like to try solving things even though I know we're all going to find out possibly in a months time :P)
I know loads of people were acting uncomfortable/dodgy etc since the killing, but didn't the writers/actors not even know who it was going to be back then so they would of just got everyone to act a bit that way
It was Cindy.
She hid the jewelry box under the tree and played like it wasn't her to frame everybody else.
She knew that Lucy took cocaine, and that she hid it in there because she used the music from the box to help get her baby, Beth, to sleep. Beth has been seen crying a lot?
She discovered the cocaine when using the box to get Beth to sleep and angrily she hit Lucy over the head with the box. I know this because it was revealed at the NTA's that the music was the last thing she heard. And she panicked so I think she asked someone (maybe Jane or Bobby) to help her carry the body into the forest to make it look like she'd been mugged by someone else.
I bet american people think this is a legitimate case going. HAHAH!
When Emma Went To Meet The Person,They Showed an Empty Living Room. That Living Room Was The Brannings Living Room.
Not one mention of Billie in this video. He has photos of Lucy hidden under his fridge, but creepy . I also think Abi may be the killer too
Q:Who killed Lucy Beale?
A: Bobby
How?:With A MusicBox
There are 3 things that killed lucy
1.the head injury
2.the drugs
3.THE KILLER
When lucy banged her head at Max's work it was badly injured
And she took drugs,that effected her
The killer idk
But did u notice when Emma met up with the killer she said he might be hungry to the van so it could be a man or boy and when she died she whispered to max"u know" which kinda gives us a clue that max helped the killer or is covering for her or knows who it is?
The biggest clues I got were from Abi's behaviour & her life events, Max could have found out & hid the murder weapon. The way Emma talked to the culprit & acted in January, has only strengthened my theory that it must be Abi. I'll be very surprised if I'm wrong.
Most people are forgetting the fact that Lucy's ear ring and blood were found in the flat that Jake and Alex lived in. It was revealed that only 2 people other than the people who were already living there had access to the flat which were Billy and Peter. Meaning that unless there is something else we are missing it can only be one of those 2 who murdered Lucy, with them probably attempting to setup Jake for the Murder. All the evidence points towards Peter being the killer, with Jane helping out.
I have always believed it was peter,wow,only 10 more days,then it will all be over
It was Bobby the night before she got "murdered" was actually the night she got murdered! Bobby was playing with the clock thing and found the drugs. He pushed her away when she tried to take them off him and she fell and died. Jane moved the body.
You missed the part when jay burns the west ham hat when he gets noticed on the bus with Lucy before she dies
I heard that the killer is Lee because apparently there was meant to be a clue in the EastEnders Children in Need special, and apparently the clue was on Ian's crossword puzzle near the end and it has "stop it Lee" or "Lee stop it" written on it somewhere or something...but I dunno...
looking forward too the live week, we gonna finally find out who killed lucy!!!
It was Ian. Because after tonight's partly live episode it was revealed she was killed at home so it must be Ian or Jane. But remember Ian got in to an argument with Lucy that day and left a voicemail on her phone saying 'sorry' so it must be Ian and it's not obvious enough not to be Ian because the creators want to shock people.
Quote " Emma also asked the ice cream man to stay open probably so Bobby could get an ice cream" more likely she asked them stay open abit longer because she was meeting a killer and didnt want to meet them without there being a witness to that meeting ... maybe?
I think it was Peter. He was angry at Lucy being the 'only one' to Ian and fed up of her taking drugs yet seeming 'perfect'. He also lived in the flat where her DNA was found. Also it is likely to be someone leaving Eastenders. Nick dies this week so that lets him out, Lauren is leaving to have a baby in April and Peter is leaving so it could well be him. Bobby put Lucy's jewellery box under the tree at christmas.
I think Lauren did it, she lied about her whereabouts the day she died, they didn't include her in the ending photo of all the suspects and may have gotten angry when realizing that Lucy had been having an affair with Max. However, Max believes it is Abbey and is trying to protect her. Lauren has already tried to leave the house.
so many people loving my theory! It won't let me reply to some of the comments but, to answer some of them...
janes reason for covering for Cindy is because Cindy didn't want to lose the baby, and because jane can't have babies. Made her want to do it more.
Her blood was in the flat because she went home with jake to his house after getting hit by ABI which I figured out last night, the producers said she had three strikes to the head, max doing the first one. Then abi, so the third person hitting her killed her.
At the time (Christmas Day) Emma was doing the investigation herself, therefore probably seen no reason to hand the jewellery box in, as she was trying to solve the case herself and she was nothing more
To do with the police as they
dropped her from the case.
I don't think Cindy done it on purpose, she obviously didn't know that Lucy had already been injured beforehand, third strike on the same place obviously killed her, I believe Ben and jay have something to do with it because Abi thinks she killed her that's why she needed jay and Ben so cover for her!
I think tonight's will be a case of peter pointing his fingers at his dad and jane and everyone's shouting at each other and Cindy just says 'it was me' or something like that, doof doof doof....
i love how boby was never in any of these videos yet it was him then Jane moved her body to the wood where she was found
Very intriguing and mysterious.
It was bobby! Lucy was writing something and bobby hit her with the box then jane comes in and starts to cry and turn round and bobby says whatever she says its her fault she made evryone unhappy.
The last thing that Lucy heard was a music box and there was a music box under the tree on Christmas morning
so it must be someone rom the beale house hold,ian,peter jane or bobby,wait there is denise,,,,money is on peter,denise knows,maybe thatswhy she is drinking so much,hell it couldn't be because of breaking up with ian,she wanted to do that before lucy died
bobby..
in the ad it showed lucys handprints on the shop door bottle caps in the shop and lights flickerin in the shop and bobby beale was in the shop!!
I can not sleep been over 4 hours since it was revealed that Bobby killed Lucy! I did like how EastEnders did the GOOD FRIDAY Episode. It has a different edge to it! Like an AFTER HOURS edge to it!
I think Denise - she's close enough to the family so she left Lucy's body in a place where she knew it would be found quickly. She has also been shown to be declining mentally and has been abusive towards Patrick. She has a motive - she didn't want to be with Ian and maybe wanted to hurt him very badly. The only thing I can't piece together is her finding the purse and phone in the allotment. It is a mystery indeed... looking forward to finding out who the killer is!
ben and jay buried it there,she as digging up produce for patrick after his stroke
I love eastenders but it always goes the same way with this programme it's been the same for as many years as I can recall my 3 theories on who killed Lucy are as follows
Cindy: Cindy wasn't getting any attention at all she felt like the outsider. She found out about the drugs before hand and threatened Lucy to tell Ian. .Maybe she hit Lucy over the head with the jewellery box(as Lucy's death was a head injury) came to a shove. I.e she killed lucy. She told jane , and Jane met up with Emma I remember Emma saying "it's still murder"Emma was reluctant to report Cindy as she is a young mother. there was a trailer that the last thing Lucy Heard was the jewellery box. Cindy gave Jane the jewellery box and it was put under the tree. But know one would suspect it was Cindy with the shocked look on her face. Jane hid the jewellery box under the floor board, but is she protecting Cindy or herself?
Peter: overheard Ian telling Lucy she was the favourite and as any sibling would be was devastated we saw Lucy run out the house and call after peter. She the walked up bridge street towards the common and he followed her they talked and I don't think he intentionally killed her but maybe she riled him a bit and he pushed her and she banged her head. After hearing she died of a head injury he could he have been guilty. Peter was told by Ian about the fatality death of his sister and he was screaming outside of the Vic could this be an admission of guilt?
Abi: she found out about ax and Lucy dirty little rump an she "when max was walking the dog" went out to confront Lucy, who was at the common and she killed her. When Abu returned home she she probably got chips or a takeaway and told her dad she went out to get chips or something. I think maybe Abi stole Beth's jewellery box and tried to frame Cindy and put her in the frame as when you hear the phrase jewel box you think girly young girl little baby and Cindy's got one of those. But what I want to know is why did Abi stalk Lauren on halloween. Could be the act of someone who is guilty of something to you?
I did think it was Denise but she was at Oxford all day but I think she either was involved in a way or know who instigated the terrible attack
Thank you for reading my theories
I think it was jay or abi because jay followed Lucy off the bus and Max said that Lauren found out that it was her but as well I think it was Max
I am certain its abi-3 letter name,no strong alibi,went pysco at halloween stalking and nearly drowning lauren,she was in the beale house at christmas,every time lauren brings up the subject she shuts it down
It's actually hilarious how people think the killer is someone who likes tea... Jesus Christ. Emma doesn't know the killer likes tea, she ordered them both a drink.... What's the drink that most people order? Tea! People are reading way too much into it because they all like to think themselves as great detectives... It's so laughable
You can't presume everyone drinks tea! Buy them a water. Anyway most people I know drink coffee not tea
I think it's Abby because it just seems like the one you least expect... Although Lauren may not be marrying Peter because she feels guilty since her sister killed Peter's Sister
It was Bobby who killed Lucy Beale with her music box apparently she started it and made everyone unhappy so he hit her, and rang Jane, telling her that lucie wasn't waking up, and when Jane came, she found Lucy dead and Bobby confessed.
It's funny how it doesn't even mention booby who is here actual killer
*bobby
Gx HAVOCZz he wasn't a suspect normally they do that for tension and views so people will watch to find out who done it
I think it was Cindy, but the show wants us to think it was abbi, but on the episode were Emma met with the killer at the cafe before she met them, it showed her texting someone and it showed cindy giving her baby to ian, and she was somehow the one that first saw lucy's music box, but it could also be jane when she was hiding Emma's phone
What if the killer kept the music box and kept it in there house, then one day the family were throwing things out giving things to charity and the music box makes its way into the collection, now imagine if someone thought "i know i'll put this under the tree for cindy's baby," cindy had recently confided in emmaabout how hard being a teen mum is for her in the beale house and emma was the sort of woman who would give an anonymous gift in these circumstances. I think it was abi (although the obvious choice is normally the wrong choice) abi killed lucy with the music box used her dads car to move the body took the music box home and was throwing it away and emma took it(not knowing it was lucys) to give to cindys baby. Also abi mentioned that she was sure that the police would catch lucys killer using "HER" to refer to the killer. Billys just a perv for having those photos and aleks had the laptop because lucy had been round the flat with jake creating their website, she must have left it in there, the same goes for the blood and the earing
Bobby killed Lucy, but Jane and Ian are trying to protect him and get max sent down 😊
Well at today's episode that I watched it was about a vision of what happened in Lucy's past ,Lucy was found dead in between two beds in I think it was the kids bedroom,and then someone came in and found her laying on the floor dead after that the little boy came in and said something. So in my opinion I think the little boy did it and the lady that had a fight with Lucy earlier in the vision covered for him. Answer me if you think I got it wrong or if you think there is any more clues I missed. thank you and reply to this message. All my love Matilda 🐾🐙
I think it's Abi because Abi had dated Jay in the past and had got mad at Lucy for liking Jay. I think Jay is innocent (in a way). Abi's alibi isn't reliable because Max went out and Lucy was on her phone as well that night.
Bobby threw her music box at her, mini Ben now. Ain't he!
I entered the competition and said Cindy Beale because I think Emma put the box under the tree for Cindy because she wanted to see her reaction to it. She didn't tell the police because Cindy has a baby to look after and she is young, and I believe that it was an accidental murder. I also think Jane helped Cindy get rid of Lucy's body and then met Emma in the park to explain that Cindy did it, but that she cant tell the police. I don't know, but im thinking that or Peter.
With Lauren entering the Beales house,hold she,actually turned,back and,Jane has,been seen witness
The Music was also used by The 60's Girl Group The Shangri-Las as well
I personally think 2 people were involved in her murder. I think it was Abi and Jane. Lucy had a text of an unknown person, I think that unknown person was Abi. Lauren left a card for Jane in tonight's episode saying Lucy was killed at home. Abi could of sent the message to Lucy saying meet me at your house we need to talk or something like that. They had an argument at Lucy's about Lucy sleeping with Max, Abi lashes out and Lucy ends up unconscious. Abi thinks she killed Lucy leading her to run home pretending nothing happened. As Lucy begins opening her eyes, Jane comes in and as Lucy begins to get up, Jane in startled and doesn't see who it is, Jane lashes out and ends up finishing her off. (That's probably the dumbest theory but I think the Abi part could be true but I'm sticking to I think that 2 people were involved)
It was jane she was jelous of max being around lucy all the time so she murdered her
I think Lee Carter killed her and confided in Mick, those two were making some strange faces after she was killed, i think they originally planned for it to be Mick/Danny Dyer, but he proved to be a well liked character, so they'll dump it on Lee Carter instead.
It's all so silly, but that's my guess :)
Omg guys stop saying that it's Jane and Bobby u watched the live week
i think it was abi as she was jealous of Lucy and she slept with her dad, i think there were two people went to see Emma, jay and Ben, abi had told them and they would cover up for her, also max knows as he said sorry to Emma when she died. lauran knows who killed Lucy as she found out in yesterdays episode and she cant look at abi the same way. also abi may have saw max fighting with Lucy that night and it made her angry, whilst max kept on walking the dog, she snuck out and killed her or told Ben and jay to do it for her............
It's Bobby, he got in a fight with Lucy and hit her. And Jane covered for him. In the woods was a different murder
Billy Mitchell? Lucy and that other guy took over Janine's business and took the money from it and didn't give any to Billy (or something like that I can't remember) I just remember those episodes where Billy and Lucy weren't getting along because of Janine's business. Plus he had the photos under his fridge !!!
very true,if it where a dark horse,billy would be the perfect murderer
I don't think billy would have the hartt and guts to do something like that
I agree
But Billy isn't one of the 13 suspects or Lola, I thought it had to be one of the final 13?
The scene where Emma met the killer, the scene previous was Lola and Billy just coming out of their house, can't be either of them.
It was bobby
manslaughter and jane opened the door the moment it happened and helped hide the body
I think it was Bobby this is why 1bobby agent through Lucy's jewellery box nd found the heroin then Lucy got mad and forced Bobby to through the box in her head then Jane came down and being the mother and called masood to cover it up they ditched the body in the common and left her bag there so it p looked like she had been mugged
I'm sure its not one person, but some reason I think Whitney is involved. I'm not convinced by Ian or Peter being a part of it.
Instead of thinking about who did it and why, think about who has the most connections round the square! Lauren said that when it is revealed who did it, it will change everything and the directors say it will change everyone's relationship with each other! So figure out who is the most connected then if they have motive, then you most likely have the killer.... So, using this logic, I think it is either Ian (as he has many connections and it would make sense as to why Peter and Lauren leave) or Jane (for the same reasons as Ian) or another random person like Jay or someone
i still don't think bobby killed lucy, i think bobby is covering for CINDY
No I think it is Bobby,Jane or nick because it says who is leaving walford he's dead (nick) and I think Jane is covering for Bobby
Bobby killed Lucy and Jane found her and covered up for him and this is true because it happened in the flashback episode last night
according to the trailer i think either Dean Wicks and the cokers are my #1 and #2 suspects by what they said
It's either Cindy or Peter.
Emma sent the box to see the reactions of everyone there, she had access to the Beale's house during the initial investigation and probably took it then. My theory is that Whitney accidentally killed Lucy, Lee knows as well. Emma found out when she looked at Roxy and Ronnie's house at the end of an episode and remembered Lee had enough time to leave the party without much notice to go to the Beale's and help her, going back after Lucy dies. Lucy was also standing on her home during a trailer suggesting she was killed there too. Everything else is a red herring.
What makes this more plausible is that Lee would be strong and able enough to move her body to somewhere she would be found quickly.
Whitney and Lucy were never really great friends, only coming together for Lauren. Tolerating each other for a few weeks they fall out over a boy, again. This is Whitney's motive for being in her room. She's acted guilty from the beginning
He would also be clever enough to divert suspicion away from himself and Whitney, telling the police about Billy and Lucy's argument that night; he later sent incriminating evidence he found of Lauren to frame her which deflects attention.
Lee also phoned Lucy and left a message after returning to the party to give himself an alibi. Nancy questions him about not being there the whole night at some point also suggesting he is lying about his whereabouts too.
from the very beginning i have said abi branning, i have not changed it even now i have even entered her name into the competition, people are twisting little information and overthinking it, she wouldnt commit suicide, that would be a pointless ending to a 10 month storyline, plus it has to be interesting, i doubt her family killed her, i mean would they really think her family would be capable of murdering her no, it has to be someone out of her family, i doubt the guy or woman who owns the funeral home would do it, they wasnt in it long enough to have thought of killing her, they would get more buisness from old people dying than killing a young person like lucy, max is out i believe, emma texted the killer when she was sat next to max in the car what would the point of that, plus the way emma was talking to the person it was like she was talking to a young person, if she talks to a adult like that i would be left wondering wtf is wrong with her, that leaves jay, ben or abi..
when heather was killed by ben, jay couldnt cope and had a breakdown, he couldnt keep the secret long enough and if they have forgotten that then i would be wondering why, ben had only just got out for murdering heather, i doubt he would have murdered lucy just after he got out, that leaves ABI, she killed her dog and acted like she didnt care, she helped her father clean up his work place i mean that was suspicious from the very beginning and she scared lauren and she tried to kill her, she wouldnt of let go if she had to choice, it could have been a accident but i do believe abi
Bobby killing lucy to me is just not plausible. Even by accident. He's a child, he would have been pretty distressed and cracked by now.
I think Jane deffinetely covered the death up, question is for who and is she aware of who? What puzzles me is the killers interaction with Emma. Emma says "it's still murder". Now that clearly tells me it must have been some sort of accident and the killer gave an explanation. Or Emma would have gone straight to the police. But it also tells me that the person who she spoke to is aware of what they did, right?
It makes sense to me that she was speaking to Jane; she respects her and wouldn't go straight to the police without her side of the story. So since Jane KNEW who she was covering up (didn't just find lucy dead) it could have only been a close family member/friend. It's not Peter he barged in yesterday accusing the rest of his family; you just wouldn't do that if you were the killer. It's not Bobby for reasons above. And Ian was just much too distraught after the death it doesn't make any sense. That leaves Cindy. Sure Cindy and Lucy didnt get on. But I can't see that story as being very emotional or worthy of a after 30 years of Eastenders live show..
Just watched part 2 OMG I can't believe bobby would do it I knew there would be some kind of twist but I diddent get the beginning of part 2 were Lucy was floating off the ground and then she opens her eyes someone please let me know what that's all about.
It was bobby and Jane is covering and it was bobby who put the music box underneath the Christmas tree
I think it was Max the only person that can drive or one of the Beales because they are all happy but it is gonna come crashing down and the killer will be found out at Ian's 5 th wedding - his parteners are like busses - one goes and another one comes . :)
In the children in need special there's a clue underneath 'I Love You' it's say Lee stop it !!
That's what I saw but I think Jane killed Lucy Beale
GUYS IT WASNT ABBY!!!!!!!
EASTENDERS ARE CONFUSING US!!! ABBY DIDN'T KILL LUCY WE DON'T KNOW WHO DID UNTIL THE 19th!!!!
It was bobby that killed lucy jane went to ians house to find lucy dead on the floor and she stood up and bobby was there with a box and bobby said it was her fault 😱
OMG Bobby killed Lucy he hit her with a box because he thought that she was marking every one unhappy also he herd Denis and Lucy fighting so he thought he needed to kill her😱 Bobby was in the egsact same spot where him and Jane must of moved her but if they were in Cardiff how does he no where she was found ? And when Jane went looking for him she did not find him masood found when he was delivering mail when max went by Lucy's gate I thought that max went in but it was Bobby I know it but I had lots of douts though.😨😱😱😱😱
I think it is Jay because it is a bit suspicious that Jay was on the same bus as her and he followed her of the bus
I think is jay because it a bit suspicious jay was on the same bus as her and he followed her of the bus
Ah I'm getting too hyped up
I wanna know now
I watched tonight's episode And Max at the end said Abi did it or something
I think max said that Abi killed Lucy because he knew Lauren knew something and when she left in a hurry he assumed she was leaving because he thinks that Lauren leaving coz Abi killed Lucy. That is why i though Max said that XD
I think he said that since he thinks she did but I don't think Abi did it, I think it's to drive us away from who really did it.
Know what I'm sick of? This, if I was Lauren no matter how hard it was I would of given the police everything and told them all I know. But I know this is a soap so I'll shut up since it's meant to be drama filled. XD
IK *****
No abi asked max why are you getting Lauren and max said she knows who killed lucy
I think it's going to be the most unexpected person you can think of
I think Jane killed Lucy because shes a suspect and it's ian and janes wedding day soon and when it is Lauren will confront Jane and expose the secret to everyone
i think it was jay, max, ben, and witny all working together
The killers has to be the writers...
Here lies the body of Lucy Beale.
Sadly died of yet another boring storyline.
RIP
Anyone who said it was Bobby, my sister just watched Eastenders and it was him.
It was Bobby he pushed lucy and she fell and died and Jane is covering for her but in the episode a boy took Lucy's phone so he has that now and she wrote a note
I can't believe it was bobby...the last person you would think killed her. I was quite disappointed tbh
I don't know If this was a clue but in the children and need special on the crossword underneath "I love you" which Lucy wrote It said "lee stop it"
Keep in mind that it is not the obvious people. They're pin pointing it on them to make you think it is
i think it was whitney because lucy had been bullying her and she deleted the conversation between her and lucy
Jayne because she was not in the picture when the young girl opend the lucys music box.
If you watched 17/2/15, Lucy's murderer was actually someone who I had NEVER thought would do this. It was actually Abi...
Millie C Dowling-Smith no it wasn’t
it said that she died of a head injury and that she was killed at home so i think it is one of the Beals who killed lucy
Or perhaps even Lauren, she may have done it when she was drunk and now remembers?
It was deffo abi cause she probably found out about her dad and lucy sleeping together and killed lucy
it was Bobby. I know he's not on the list but I've already seen the episode
Bobby and Jane was like covering over him to do it
I think the killer is Cindy. The show wants us to think that it's Abi, because of Max and Lucy sleeping together, but the killer being Abi is too obvious. I think the killer is Cindy because of how she acted when Lucy died. Cindy wasn't so shocked as much a Peter and Ian was, heck Denise was more shocked than Cindy. Plus Cindy lied that Ian wasn't at home with her on the night Lucy died. Why would she lie about it, and why would she kill Lucy is what I'm questioning? Was Cindy jealous of Lucy?
Because Cindy doesn't like Lucy that much and she doesn't know her that well. Plus Peter is her twin and Ian is her dad. Denise would have been her step-mum and knew her for years. They are obviously going to have the worse reactions to it. Also Cindy has no motive and no clear evidence.
It's gonna be someone everyone least expects,, my guess is les Crocker,, because he is still a suspect, but no one ever talks about him,, also I heared from a spoiler a long time ago, it was les, but not sure true or not
Bobby accidently hit Lucy with the julerry box
Not Lauren so it must be the people that killed their own son.
how come Bobby killed her but he wasn't a suspect?
Before it was reviled me my brother and my sis thought it was Abi but when we found out it was Bobby we were like ...
Bobby killed Lucy and Jane is covering up for him
I agree, I think Bobby killed Lucy and Jane is covering for him
Emma,s Midly Entertaining Life wow smart