Phil is a living legend. He could sing from his couch and he would still knock it out of the park. Sure he is older and has mobility issues but he’s given his body to his music his whole life and now must sit. Big whoop. He’s still amazing.
He is a living legend and I love his music. It's sad about his mobility issues and sadly he can't sing like he used to he sings in a lower octave. Would be best just to retire a living legend then play old hits that sound much worse than they should.
He had to change some of the "octaves" for some f the songs from the Genesis live in Rome tour" . does not mean he should retire ( that was only 11 years ago ) Brilliant concert !!.Do not forget he's just come off from a bad case of depression / & Alcohol abuse he will get himself back together. He should never retire.A true musician never retires especially since his fans ( all over the world ) still want to see him on stage. I went to see this particualr concert in Paris on June 19th 2017 a day after my birthday. I did shed a tear he has been my inspiration all of my life in music , it was sad to see him the way he was but the crowd still loved him & that Mr Stonley is what it's all about.
Saw this show a few weeks back in Oakland Ca. So cool to see Phil and his son having so much fun. Everyone singing along and sharing a memorable evening. Thanks Phil and band. LOVE to see the Older statesman out there still performing and lighting up the crowd like Phil and his crew did for my wife and I. CLASSIC Phil!
Jamais imaginei que o Phill viesse ao Brasil,e que podesse assistir este espetáculo !!So tenho que agradecer por esse dia inesquecível ...Phill Collins eternamente!!!
Just went yesterday to his show, i could not find this song in my memory and i spent 30 minutes searching all of his song until i came here and heard it again and again.
Acredito que todos vivemos um sonho que dificilmente poderá se realizar novamente. Eu particularmente já tinha perdido as esperanças de ver Phil ao vivo. Tocando Genesis então... as lágrimas desceram nesta música.
estava ai.... nunca mais esse momento vai me deixar. um dos melhores e unicos momentos que passei na minha vida. ver Genesis/Phil Collins ainda cantando essa canção, ja valeu por tudo. obrigado Deus pela oportunidade. Obrigado amigo @geohoche pelo presente. obrigado amor pela companhia. Vida Longa Phil Collins....
Eu também estava lá, e tenho os mesmos sentimentos que você. Felizmente eu o vi anos atrás na turnê de Both Sides no exterior, na época já me senti realizado, pois achei que jamais ele viria ao Brasil, ainda mais por ter se aposentado dos palcos. mas como você citou, foi um momento e oportunidade único que ficará em nossas histórias.
Foi maravilhoso do início ao fim,emoção extrema,esse momento mesmo tds interagindo foi nota 1.000 ,valeu muito a pena ver esse cara que é um gênio da música....
Phil’s voice still has that incredible timber( like Sting and Winwood). 45 years of drumming will ruin your body. Phil drumming history defined rock and pop for years. Howard Jones wouldn’t have had a career without Phil.
Bri Mack go back and watch some video of Phil in that golden period just beforeHackett left. The film Genesis- In Concert shows him on top his game playing with Bruford and Thompson.
He's actually a pretty legendary drummer. Very technically gifted jazz trained drummer. He was inspired by Ringo Starr, so he always did have a slight preference towards heavy bellicose and simple drumming despite his skill and talent.
It's not just the drumming, Its also the alcohol, also the touring, probably also the psychological hammering being that big of a star for so long must take. Not everyone his age struggles like he does, it just sucks that it had to be him.
imjustsomeguy72 three divorces, a sudden onset of extreme depression and alcoholism, and being at war with his own public perception, as well as just being a workaholic, yikes.
Eu assisti aí ao lado direito do palco.. ficará pra sempre...como sempre foi ao ouvir ..mas ver ele cantar foi esplêndido.. agradecer sempre a Deus por um momento tão especial.
If Phil came to my town, I would pay whatever he was asking to see him because I’ve never seen him live. Having said that, seeing him in this condition, singing in much-lower keys, makes me sad.
Not the same as he used to be but great to see him of course!! Darryl is still there and Phil’s son on drums!!! I was fortunate to see Phil live in Paris back in ‘89 and of course an awesome performance!!
It's funny you know, Cause there's an old rock 'n' roller He's got nowhere to go. Well lately I've seen him Walking down the street, kinda moving his feet, Ah - see him smile.
Need I say I love you Need I say I care Need I say that emotion's, Something we don't share I don't want to be sitting here Trying to deceive you Cos you know I know baby
Nobody is a "bigger" Phil Fan than me. I'll go head to head with anyone to make my case on that point. I will say though, seeing Phil tour seated throughout most the show and singing this (one of my favorite Genesis songs) transposed down 3 semi-tones from the original key is heartbreaking. Between '78 and 2007 I've seen him live 9 times… from up close in a small venue in San Francisco playing drums (only) with Brand X, to 5 Genesis tours and 3 solo tours, I feel like over a 30 year period I've seen the full spectrum of Phil. Along with Elton John's work between '70-'75, Phil's recorded works served as the soundtrack of my life and will shine forever in my mind, but to have him go out and tour like this is just sad.
I'm not… I didn't get past the first minute of this one. Not saying "Phil Sucks"… he's got plenty of haters out there, I'm not one of them (or didn't get that from my comment?)… I'm a life long fan. Phil went into retirement a number of years ago… not only should singing musicians be able to do that, the smart ones choose to before they can no longer perform up to the standard that made them famous. Sorry you can't tell the difference between Phil then and now.
I agree. I've also seen him perform with Brand X, Eric Clapton, The Phil Collins Big Band, Genesis, All of his solo Tours. Not to see him play drums is not seeing the real Phil collins.
I'll always be thankful that I got to see Phil drum and perform live. One of the greatest drummers and the performer that "made me" (not just inspired me) to play drums - though I didn't go lefty. I'm so happy that there are videos available of most of his performances. He is so under appreciated as a live performer. The haters just know his pop, soundtrack and ballads from the radio. I bet they have never seen him perform. Seeing him stationary, singing from a seat is hard for me, but I still love Phil more than anyone. What gives me a smile with this is seeing him on stage with his son behind that classic, white Gretsch concert-tom kit. I don't have kids and that still chokes me up to think about. Still, I need to go watch Hand-in-Hand from Serious Hits Live now.
not dead yet but still costs $275...geez..might as well be in a wheelchair..i'd love to go..would be a night of great music and i could sit in the last row..but...i don't know...it could be a disappointment
James Powlett - No matter how heartbreaking it might be to see Phil in this condition, we have no right to ask him to retire. If he wants to continue touring and writing music, he should do so. It's his life. People telling Keith Emerson to retire due to his hand injury is what ultimately lead to him committing suicide. Keith was doing what he loved. The only thing he ever knew. Telling him that he should stop playing was like telling him to stop living.
Let me start out by saying I absolutely LOVE Phil Collins...I love his music...and his understanding of what is it to be a musician and entertainer. But I will also say that arguing he is a god among men in his field is giving too much credit. He definitely has a mastery for reverb with his sound technicians and figuring out some of the most unique sounds possible, through digital manipulation. Saying he is the best of the best on drums and or singing is just incorrect. Unique and awesome no doubt...but if you don't understand what people sound like BEFORE a sound-man does their trick...then you shouldn't be commenting.
This is now of the songs I can't hear it anymore. Do tired of it. I know this is an audience feel good participation song. But for me so boring. Long time over played. I hate this song. But who loves it... Enjoy.
Jason Speth if you look into it, it's been a long process based around the recent change of public opinion on Collins. He has had a long time to reevaluate his music career, and his family and friends have encouraged him to return to music.
CKT1138 Of course they've encouraged him... it's all about the dollar signs. Phil seemed pretty content on being retired. Just like countless other bands from the sixties and seventies there's money to beade on nostalgia. This band isn't bad, I'd rather see Musical Box if I want nostalgia. Just my two cents....
Phil Collins deserves an OBE for his contribution to music ! Make this statement go Viral
Phil is a living legend. He could sing from his couch and he would still knock it out of the park. Sure he is older and has mobility issues but he’s given his body to his music his whole life and now must sit. Big whoop. He’s still amazing.
Um, he is singing from his couch?
Agree! Well said!
He meant if he could sing from his couch , couch meaning ( sofa )
He is a living legend and I love his music. It's sad about his mobility issues and sadly he can't sing like he used to he sings in a lower octave. Would be best just to retire a living legend then play old hits that sound much worse than they should.
He had to change some of the "octaves" for some f the songs from the Genesis live in Rome tour" . does not mean he should retire ( that was only 11 years ago ) Brilliant concert !!.Do not forget he's just come off from a bad case of depression / & Alcohol abuse he will get himself back together. He should never retire.A true musician never retires especially since his fans ( all over the world ) still want to see him on stage. I went to see this particualr concert in Paris on June 19th 2017 a day after my birthday. I did shed a tear he has been my inspiration all of my life in music , it was sad to see him the way he was but the crowd still loved him & that Mr Stonley is what it's all about.
Saw this show a few weeks back in Oakland Ca. So cool to see Phil and his son having so much fun. Everyone singing along and sharing a memorable evening. Thanks Phil and band. LOVE to see the Older statesman out there still performing and lighting up the crowd like Phil and his crew did for my wife and I. CLASSIC Phil!
Phil totally rocks, I have always enjoyed his music.
It’s really cool that Phil got Father Time to play bass for him ;)
Avalanche Fan Leland sklar
There are too many jokes about Lee Sklar being Gandalf, Father Time, Dumbledore, playing bass for Phil Collins, Toto, and Dolly Parton. Funny to read.
Jamais imaginei que o Phill viesse ao Brasil,e que podesse assistir este espetáculo !!So tenho que agradecer por esse dia inesquecível ...Phill Collins eternamente!!!
It came in and out, like great songs do. Great. Thanks for posting!
Estava lá!!! Foi o show da minha vida!!!
Just went yesterday to his show, i could not find this song in my memory and i spent 30 minutes searching all of his song until i came here and heard it again and again.
Yeah, but to me its sound so different from the album version. I prefer it Live
Acredito que todos vivemos um sonho que dificilmente poderá se realizar novamente. Eu particularmente já tinha perdido as esperanças de ver Phil ao vivo. Tocando Genesis então... as lágrimas desceram nesta música.
Daniel Mendes Lima chorei muito nessa h . Muita energia boa envolvida. Vida longa phil Collins
his son wanted to be up there..so phil is giving it one more round..god bless him *
Como podem falar q funk é musica? Pqp ...Phil Collins monstro eterno
Por isso que eu sou feliz por estar envelhecendo! Ter nascido na década de 70 foi um privilégio.
Fui um dos primeiros a entrar no estádio, fiquei bem na frente dele na pista Premium foi inesquecível, melhor dia da minha vida! Saudades
Love you Phil, the best of all times.
I see some fellow musicians on stage from the No Jacket Required days
He loves music ....and I am verry happy To see and heard him ....
What a voice !!! And beautiful drumming
estava ai.... nunca mais esse momento vai me deixar. um dos melhores e unicos momentos que passei na minha vida. ver Genesis/Phil Collins ainda cantando essa canção, ja valeu por tudo. obrigado Deus pela oportunidade. Obrigado amigo @geohoche pelo presente. obrigado amor pela companhia. Vida Longa Phil Collins....
Verdade! Momento inesquecível! Também não esperava ver um dia o Grande Phil Collins!
Eu também estava lá, e tenho os mesmos sentimentos que você. Felizmente eu o vi anos atrás na turnê de Both Sides no exterior, na época já me senti realizado, pois achei que jamais ele viria ao Brasil, ainda mais por ter se aposentado dos palcos. mas como você citou, foi um momento e oportunidade único que ficará em nossas histórias.
Adilson Alves Fantástico inesquecível Amei
Foi maravilhoso do início ao fim,emoção extrema,esse momento mesmo tds interagindo foi nota 1.000 ,valeu muito a pena ver esse cara que é um gênio da música....
e vc acredita que tem gente que nao gosta?
Phil’s voice still has that incredible timber( like Sting and Winwood). 45 years of drumming will ruin your body. Phil drumming history defined rock and pop for years. Howard Jones wouldn’t have had a career without Phil.
Bri Mack go back and watch some video of Phil in that golden period just beforeHackett left. The film Genesis- In Concert shows him on top his game playing with Bruford and Thompson.
He's actually a pretty legendary drummer. Very technically gifted jazz trained drummer.
He was inspired by Ringo Starr, so he always did have a slight preference towards heavy bellicose and simple drumming despite his skill and talent.
Bri Mack No man, he is a beast of a drummer, go listen to his earlier work in other projects
It's not just the drumming, Its also the alcohol, also the touring, probably also the psychological hammering being that big of a star for so long must take. Not everyone his age struggles like he does, it just sucks that it had to be him.
imjustsomeguy72 three divorces, a sudden onset of extreme depression and alcoholism, and being at war with his own public perception, as well as just being a workaholic, yikes.
Demais ...momento único,parecia ser um sonho e se tornou real ,nem acredito que estava aí com esse ídolo .Phil eu te amo ❤️
Estava lá, até hoje me emociono!!!!
estava ai juntinho dele ... foi a melhor emoção da minha vida ... quero mais ... muito mais ...
Não poderia deixar de elogiar a qualidade do vídeo. Excelente, principalmente por se tratar de um dispositivo portátil.
É uma honra tê- lo aqui bem pertinho de mim. Te amo sempre Phil!!!
This is the first time I’m seeing Phil perform this Genesis song without Mike and Tony of Genesis. You got Brad, Daryl and Leland performing.
Eu assisti aí ao lado direito do palco.. ficará pra sempre...como sempre foi ao ouvir ..mas ver ele cantar foi esplêndido.. agradecer sempre a Deus por um momento tão especial.
Assistir ao show de Phil Collins encheu meu coração de alegria. Emoção do começo ao fim. Quero mais ...
Phil Collins você é inconfundível maravilhoso Amo suas músicas
Mijn God, Phil wat doe je je zelf aan. Last ons je herinneren zoals je was.
Ga genieten van je leven.
If Phil came to my town, I would pay whatever he was asking to see him because I’ve never seen him live. Having said that, seeing him in this condition, singing in much-lower keys, makes me sad.
lindo demais esse show! phill collins ele é D+
Tô assistindo aos vídeos e revivendo esse momento...que lindo...
nao puder ir, seria um sonho, toco a maioria das musicas deles!!!!
Phil Collins. Awesomeness. Love The Invsible Touch album.
Ya look and sound great, Phil!
Not the same as he used to be but great to see him of course!! Darryl is still there and Phil’s son on drums!!!
I was fortunate to see Phil live in Paris back in ‘89 and of course an awesome performance!!
Esse eu fuiiiiiii 25/02/18❤love love love
maravilhoso!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Parabėns pelo vídeo e fico grata por postar. Que aparelho vocę usou para a captaçāo pois a imagem estå incrīvel.
It's funny you know,
Cause there's an old rock 'n' roller
He's got nowhere to go.
Well lately I've seen him
Walking down the street, kinda moving his feet,
Ah - see him smile.
Sensacional.
para mim o Phil e 1 grande batera ,, desde inicio dos Genesis ,, os vi em portugal em 1979 ,,, como cantor respeito mas nao faz minha praia
Phil: no tendrías que morirte nunca.
Una leyenda......... ❤️
Emocionante!!!
Fabulous amazing legend
Great Genesis song. Sad that Phil’s back is so bad!
Need I say I love you
Need I say I care
Need I say that emotion's,
Something we don't share
I don't want to be sitting here
Trying to deceive you
Cos you know I know baby
Lindo!
Te Amo ....te amo...
Nobody is a "bigger" Phil Fan than me. I'll go head to head with anyone to make my case on that point. I will say though, seeing Phil tour seated throughout most the show and singing this (one of my favorite Genesis songs) transposed down 3 semi-tones from the original key is heartbreaking. Between '78 and 2007 I've seen him live 9 times… from up close in a small venue in San Francisco playing drums (only) with Brand X, to 5 Genesis tours and 3 solo tours, I feel like over a 30 year period I've seen the full spectrum of Phil. Along with Elton John's work between '70-'75, Phil's recorded works served as the soundtrack of my life and will shine forever in my mind, but to have him go out and tour like this is just sad.
VengefulSage … ok tough guy… A) i’m not going to “stfu”… B) Like I said, it’s just sad, not enjoyable to me at all.
I'm not… I didn't get past the first minute of this one. Not saying "Phil Sucks"… he's got plenty of haters out there, I'm not one of them (or didn't get that from my comment?)… I'm a life long fan. Phil went into retirement a number of years ago… not only should singing musicians be able to do that, the smart ones choose to before they can no longer perform up to the standard that made them famous. Sorry you can't tell the difference between Phil then and now.
I agree. I've also seen him perform with Brand X, Eric Clapton, The Phil Collins Big Band, Genesis, All of his solo Tours. Not to see him play drums is not seeing the real Phil collins.
I'll always be thankful that I got to see Phil drum and perform live. One of the greatest drummers and the performer that "made me" (not just inspired me) to play drums - though I didn't go lefty. I'm so happy that there are videos available of most of his performances. He is so under appreciated as a live performer. The haters just know his pop, soundtrack and ballads from the radio. I bet they have never seen him perform. Seeing him stationary, singing from a seat is hard for me, but I still love Phil more than anyone. What gives me a smile with this is seeing him on stage with his son behind that classic, white Gretsch concert-tom kit. I don't have kids and that still chokes me up to think about. Still, I need to go watch Hand-in-Hand from Serious Hits Live now.
If you read his book, you'd know that he wanted to tour again, no matter his voice.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Phil เป็นหยัง ทำไมไม่เดินเลยอ่า
4:07 - I guess the band was almost like: it's not that verse, Phil!
not dead yet but still costs $275...geez..might as well be in a wheelchair..i'd love to go..would be a night of great music and i could sit in the last row..but...i don't know...it could be a disappointment
Phil please retire you’ve had a fab career awesome songs over the years it’s time to go home and put your feet up mate with your family
James Powlett - No matter how heartbreaking it might be to see Phil in this condition, we have no right to ask him to retire. If he wants to continue touring and writing music, he should do so. It's his life. People telling Keith Emerson to retire due to his hand injury is what ultimately lead to him committing suicide. Keith was doing what he loved. The only thing he ever knew. Telling him that he should stop playing was like telling him to stop living.
Let me start out by saying I absolutely LOVE Phil Collins...I love his music...and his understanding of what is it to be a musician and entertainer. But I will also say that arguing he is a god among men in his field is giving too much credit. He definitely has a mastery for reverb with his sound technicians and figuring out some of the most unique sounds possible, through digital manipulation. Saying he is the best of the best on drums and or singing is just incorrect. Unique and awesome no doubt...but if you don't understand what people sound like BEFORE a sound-man does their trick...then you shouldn't be commenting.
Sad
So tired....
This is now of the songs I can't hear it anymore. Do tired of it. I know this is an audience feel good participation song. But for me so boring. Long time over played. I hate this song. But who loves it...
Enjoy.
Sad ain’t it?
not too many of us gunna end up any better once we put in 67 years, mate..give him credit for giving it another go
Sorry Phil, it's time to hang up the boots and call it a day!...leave us with all the beautiful memories!
Glenn Alexander He's superb!!
Only if you are deaf and blind!
Phil must need some more cash for his ex's. This sounds minimally rehearsed.
It doesn't sound unrehearsed, a minimally rehearsed show would be much sloppier.
CKT1138 I don't want to split hairs but the dude clearly needs more cash for the Misses.
Jason Speth if you look into it, it's been a long process based around the recent change of public opinion on Collins. He has had a long time to reevaluate his music career, and his family and friends have encouraged him to return to music.
CKT1138 Of course they've encouraged him... it's all about the dollar signs. Phil seemed pretty content on being retired. Just like countless other bands from the sixties and seventies there's money to beade on nostalgia. This band isn't bad, I'd rather see Musical Box if I want nostalgia. Just my two cents....
So embarrassing. Give it up man.
for a "father" you're kind of a knob 🍆🍆🍆