You are lost then, and one thing always remember how a well learned Shaikh can call someone kafir, if they believe in one God. Isn't it seems vice-versa valid. Dear brother I wish Allah guides u again. And don't be a sinner. You had proofs with you
There is no unity between Muslims and polytheists. The Quran is clear on al wala’ wa’l bara. Those who reject the Quran and the teachings of the Prophet AS while worshiping men and idols, cursing those whom the Prophet AS loved can never be reconciled with unless they change their ways and accept Islam.
@@NesarsayedDude your comment are like christians. We don't born with sin. Like every children is pure and innocent. As we grow up if we follow true teaching Muhammad pbuh and believe in one true God Allah inshallah we will go to heaven.
@@gamingwithhridoy143 you say you sunnis are all righteous. don't y'all sin? you're a sunni but what about not obeying RasulAllah saws when he said He's leaving behind Quran and Ahlulbayt. follow these two things and not go astray? We Shia follow these as it's something Allah and His Messenger pbuh obeyed us to follow. Our Imams (the successors of Prophet Muhammad saws) teach nothing but Tawheed, compassion, mercy and clemency. You can read Kitab Al tawheed by Shaykh Saduq to know how pure our tawheed is. Imam Jafar Sadiq, Imam Mahdi, Imam Baqir pbut have cursed those who claim to be shia but then believe that the Ahlulbayt provides rizq or things which only Allah swt has control over. Tawassul is proved however from both Shia and Sunni traditions and mainly Quran. It's written in your main 6 books that the Holy Prophet saws have said not to takfir a believer out of ignorance and assumptions. This is what y'all do to Shia. You see some videos of people claiming to be Shia doing crazy stuff and think that's our faith. No. Curse be upon those who lie on the name of Prophet and his household. Indeed Shirk is the greatest sin ever and whoever associates partners with God he's a dweller of hellfire. Also why do you ask other people about who Shia are? ask us directly, listen to our scholars the ones who are actually scholars, visit us and see what we're like. People who destroy the religion and are hypocrites are in every school of thought/jurisprudence. Also i know whatever i said, you'll turn a deaf ear to it and you're gonna say the same default insults or accusations that Shias do this and Shias do that, well Prophet saws and his household made it clear what their Shia (followers) should do. Insulting wives of the prophet is forbidden. we reject those who oppressed Ahlulbayt. we have our disagreements and we don't see them in good sight. but those who go extreme have nothing to do with the real Shias. they're the ghulat and curse is upon them as well from the Imams of Ahlulbayt.
I'm Shia, I don't curse the prophets companions. I don't believe the Quran has changed. Strange where has he heard shias saying the Quran has changed? Isn't that one of the main beliefs of Muslims that that Quran is flawless?
That could mean you are not following the shi'ah beliefs. This is in their books and belief. Moreover they make duaa to other than Allaah like Ya Ali and Ya Hussain which is major shirk and brings someone out of the fold of Islam.
you arent following Muhammad's saw sunnah and teachings. Your belief formed after the death of Muhammad saw where you invented things that were taught by him. And Bidaah belongs nowhere in Islam
Why not stop it then. After all it’s foundation is kufr. Why trying to follow because your forefather were following. Remember you would stand in front of Allah alone. Make the hard choice because it’s necessary
As a ex Shia Iranian . Shia is different religion. They hate companion . And make horrible comments from their dirty mouths. to mother عایشه رضی الله عنها
@@HashShYT . He is doing Taqiyyah maybe. Iran is a boogeyman In region . Without Iran . USA can’t fool rich Arab countries and sell them weapons. Iran with his empty threats . Gives Isreal lot of privileges
@@HMD1986- Shameless lies. Everyone can see who supports the genocidal maniacs and who opposes them. You are the one doing the lying. BTW i am Muslim and learned only from Sunni, not from Shia. Nothing to do with that, just stop spreading lies where the evil ones are the good ones.
they slandered each other lol. Why Aisha and Muawiya fought Imam Ali? Why Abu Bake didn't give Fatima the lady of heaven her right? Why Muawiya ordered cursing Imam Ali from pulpits? Why Aisha stopped funeral of Imam Hasan? All these things are written in your books and so much more. But you're certainly blind (and your reply is gonna be you insulting be and saying the same default insults and accusations) so it's pointless to argue with yall. It's a problem when we slander your caliphs what about when you say the parents and the uncle of the Holy Prophet saws are in hellfire??? Curse be upon anyone who thinks such about the family of the greatest and the most noble creation of Allah swt
@@mrmghouse Shias also do that, so they are muslims by definition. Also they only have to follow the 5 pillars of Islam to be considered Muslim. Why are you adding more rules and circumstances? That is bidah.
@@iceycones654كلامك غير صحيح بالمره لا يومن اكثرهم بالله الا وهم مشركون ايه كريمه هل تعلم ان كفار قريش كانو مومنين بان الله واحد ولاكنهم كانو يعبدون الاصنام لتقربهم لله وقالو ما نعبدهم الا ليقربونا الى الله زلفى وَيَعْبُدُونَ مِن دُونِ اللَّهِ مَا لَا يَضُرُّهُمْ وَلَا يَنفَعُهُمْ وَيَقُولُونَ هَٰؤُلَاءِ شُفَعَاؤُنَا عِندَ اللَّهِ ۚ قُلْ أَتُنَبِّئُونَ اللَّهَ بِمَا لَا يَعْلَمُ فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَلَا فِي الْأَرْضِ ۚ سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ عَمَّا يُشْرِكُونَ الله وصف الذى يضع بينه وبين الله وسيط بالمشرك وقال ربكم ادعونى استجب لكم وايضا قال تعالى ونحن اقرب اليه من حبل الوريد اما الوسيله المشروعه فى الاسلام هى فقط دعوه الله بالاسماء والصفتت مثل يا رحيم ارحمنى يا رزاق ارزقنى ودعوه الله بالعمل الصالح مثل اياك نعبد واياك نستعين اهدنا السراط المستقيم عوه الرجل الصالح وهو حى مثل اخوه يوسف عندما قالو يا ابانا استغفر لنا لان ابوهم صالح وشرط انه على قيد الحياه ولو كان يجوز دعاء لااموات لسجدو لقبر جدهم ابراهيم وهو افضل من ابيهم ولاكن الاسلام حرم دعوه الاموات لان الميت لا ينفع ولا يضر اما زياره القبور ففقط تذهب وتدعى لصاحب القبر بالرحمه ان يرحمه الله وليس العكس وتطلب منه ان يرحمك ويرزقك وهو تحت التراب 😂😂
Shi'as say Quran is altered? They have their own Quran? They hate all Sahabas? Ok brother. If those are the things you want to tell yourself, and everyone else so that you have an acceptable excuse for hating, then sure, but for those who genuinely want to know Shi'as are just like Sunnis, with only a few differences. Firstly, Shia's DON'T HAVE THEIR OWN QURAN, OR THEIR OWN SHAHADA. Secondly, we don't hate all Sahabas, not even the majority of them. Thirdly, Shi'as don't seek revenge either, they just want to keep the memory, and the teachings of the beloved grandson of the Propeht (P.B.U.H) with them, and naturally despise those who had a part in his killing. They don't go around saying we have to take revenge because as you said there is nobody to exact revenge on, since all of their oppressors are long gone. As for the different books you mentioned, in that case, there are also those who believe Hazrat Ali(A.S) to be god, obviously those are not Shia's, they're the ones who are committing kufr, these are called different schools of thought similar to the different schools of thought that sunnis have, but in the case with Shi'as these are very niche, and very extreme unlike the sunnis, with only a few Shi'as following their teachings, and these are the primary source used to make sunnis hate shia's by putting all of them under this one umbrella, just like you did, and if questioned, one can easily get away by saying they are still Shi'a, which technically isn't wrong. But please, if the Sheikhs' words help you sleep at night after calling another Muslim Kafir, then by all means pretend you didn't read this.
I think you are someone who is a "Cultural Shia" who doesn't even read his own books. I can show you from Shia Scholars and Shia hadith books such as Al-Kafi where Shia consider majority of Sahaba as Apostates and Sheikh Assim already mentioned the sources for Shia beliefs of Quran being distorted, this was also shown with evidence on Sunnah Discourse and by Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen in a debate with Shia. These are from the main stream beliefs of Twelvernism Shia (Ithna Ashariyyah) who are the majority of the Shia today. It is you who is trying to comfort himself to sleep at night and as far as "Calling another Muslim Kafir" is concerned, whoever curses Aisha (Radi Allah Anha) is a Kafir because 33:6 and 33:33 mention wives of Prophet SAW as mothers of believers and from Ahlulbayt.
and to add on to Sheikh Assim-Al Hakeem's points, in the subcontinent specially Shia say "Ya Ali Madad" which is literally shirk and constitutes disbelief because they call out to Ali saying "Oh Ali Help" yet, they try to justify this by saying Ali (Radi Allah Anhu) will ask Allah for dua, but this isn't the meaning of the words they utter when they say "Ya Ali Madad" they try to provide their own explanation, different than what the meaning of the words utter actually means.
@@irtazza133I have seen a video of Shia in makkah near makam Ibrahim near kabah ... doing Azan among pilgrims and at part of Azan when we say Ash Ana Muhammad RasoolAllah... he was changing and saying a version not mentioning Prophet Muhammad but saying "Ali Ullah" .... many things come under questions in your beliefs yet you lot are getting defensive.
@@irtazza133 "Cultural Shia who doesn't even read his own books" what a nice assumption. I literally didn't even deny the existence of those books, I mentioned that they belong to a different school of thought, just like those who consider Hazrat Ali(A.S) to be god. Obviously, you are the one who hasn't researched enough about Shi'as thinking that those books are the main source of guidance for every Shia. Also, if by majority you mean the people who followed Muawiyah and their like, then yes you are correct, most of them are considered as bad people among Shias. Also the guys debating Shekih Ibn Uthaymeen are mostly from Iran, and/or Iraq, and yes, in those parts, Shi'aism is not what it actually should be, and the essence has been lost. I can say that because I know about a lot of their practices, and they are not right, not just by shia standards, but by basic Islamic standards. Also, you just made up someone being Kafir by mentioning 33:33 and 33:6, when nowhere in there it says anything about such a punishment. Also, the end of the verse reads "Allah only intends to keep ˹the causes of˺ evil away from you and purify you completely, O members of the ˹Prophet’s˺ family!" You know what this means? It means Allah wants to keep evil away from them, and wants to purify them, but if they themselves go near those causes then what? Or are you going to argue that Allah took away their autonomy and they could not do anything of their own will?
@@ahmadharis4u nah still no sections though follow the sunnah and Quran makes u a real Muslim not calling yourself a Sunni give me a Hadith where the prophet called himself a Sunni nah u guys are still falling into sections. Get a grip it’s Islam not Islam with multiple sections.
@@4912-w5l Sunni is a word crafted for those who follow the Sunnah. This might have been done after Shia came into existence. I'm not a scholar but this seems logical. It's not a sect in itself, rather to differentiate from Shia who called themselves Muslims without following the teachings of our Prophet (s.a.w.)
Verse 159 of Surah Al-An'am in the Quran states that those who divide their religion and become sects are not associated with the Prophet Muhammad and that their judgment is with Allah (6:159) Surely you have nothing to do with those who have made divisions in their religion and become factions.141 Their matter is with Allah and He will indeed tell them (in time) what they have been doing.
@@meggimeggi3650 Have u heard of google you can google it yourself. You are lazy "(6:159) Surely you have nothing to do with those who have made divisions in their religion and become factions.141 Their matter is with Allah and He will indeed tell them (in time) what they have been doing."
Ex-shia here🤚🏻 I was born in shia family but they are not like what you describe them (I mean my family only) They don't curse anyone and they don't think Quran has been changed or something
Im an Ex-shia from Pakistan. And my family always curses Abubakr, Umar, Uthman and Aisha (Radi Allah Anhuma) it isn't about what your family or my family do. It is about the Shia beliefs from their books and core doctrine and they absolutely do the things that the Sheikh Assim Al-Hakeem mentioned.
Been around Shias my whole life. Became a shia myself. All things people accuse us of are just accusations. They don't even know what we believe in. Us believing in changing of Quran is the funniest thing ever. curse be upon those who believe the word of God can be changed
Sheikh I wasn't expecting this kind of answer from you. Shia scholars refute all the claims you are making. In Pakistan there are Shia scholars who say "May Allah be pleased with him" with the name of AbuBakr and Umar. Khumeini gave fatwa in Iran that cursing the wives of Prophet SAW is haram. They also believe in the same Quran and no one among them say that the Quran Ahlul Sunnah have is different. All these things you say are just because of your hatred towards them. It's a typical wahabi attitude most of the Arab scholars have. Fear Allah, what if Allah holds you accountable for things you say which are not true??? May Allah guide us all.
I know what you are saying but what Sheikh said here unfortunately is true. I've heard these things from other sources as well and some very credible. I believe some branch of Shia's maybe don't beleive in these things but they do exist in Shia's.
@@aviatorzthebest2452 of course they exist no one is denying that but such people exist in Ahlul Sunnah too. In the sub continent, sunni muslims visit shrines asking the dead ones for help. If we start labelling the whole sect as kafir because of the actions of a particular group of people then there would be no muslim in the world. In the video Sheikh said, Prophet Muhammad PBUH was a sunni. I mean seriously?? I don't expect such an absurd and stupid thing from a sheikh. The Prophet SAW always called himself a Muslim because in the Quran Allah SWT named us Muslims.
@@muzammilbukhari5926 Your first point is correct, I agree. For second, I don't have enough knowledge to say anything. One thing however, just for my understanding and clarity, and in case if you know it... in the core/heart of Shia sect, do Shias beleive in Quran? and only few misguided ones beleive in this 'missing chapter' story? Is that correct or is it not?
@@aviatorzthebest2452 it's not. I know a lot of shia and neither they nor their scholars believe in this. It's just our perception about them. Instead of making claims I think we should ask them about their beliefs and not just believe in the heresay.
@@aviatorzthebest2452No bro we don't believe Quran has changed. And how can he call us kafir if we believe in one God and his prophet SWt also Quran. It seems he is misguided 😅😅
Shias don't accept the Quran 100 percent. If you see a debate between a Shia and a Sunni Muslim, and we use only the Quran, the Shia will be dumbfounded and have no answer.
@@1280-user we live according to it Alhamdulillah. We don't takfir people like y'all do. We fear Allah swt. we Follow The holy Prophet saws and his Household. We fight against oppression and help and assist those who are oppressed.
I respect the sheikh but what he said about shia is not right.. If they are not Muslim why are they allowed to go for hajj and umrah? Similarly, they follow the same quran as us. ( the missing chapter hadith can also be found in our hadith books as well but we consider these hadith as daeef) I agree that they curse sahaba r.a but not all of the shia.. Those who have good knowledge they respect although they have different opinion about some sahaba r.a I am not defending but telling what is true And Allah knows the best. May Allah guide us all and keep the whole Muslim. Ummah united. P.s : I am a Sunni Muslim
The last I checked Shia were helping Palestine too. Enough with these divisions already. What are we, as Muslims, doing for Palestine? The suffering of our brothers and sisters in Palestine is heartbreaking, and it is time to ask ourselves how we are contributing to their support. It’s clear that our divisions, whether sectarian or otherwise, only weaken us. Nonbelievers don’t care about our internal differences; they see us as one. Why can’t we do the same? The most critical need right now is unity-it’s more important than all these divisions.
Many Christians and Atheists are helping Palestine, too. Does that mean they are on the straight path? The most important thing in this world is to worship Allah (SWT) the way He told us to worship Him. We can't water down our religion because our brothers and sisters are suffering.
@@ActualMorality So, is our best course of action to turn on one another, fostering disunity and contributing to the tragic loss of Muslim lives, rather than supporting one another as brothers and sisters? The Prophet (PBUH) foretold that the Ummah would divide into 73 sects, a reality that was destined to unfold. But instead of deepening this divide through conflict and bloodshed, why not focus on the most fundamental truth we all share-the belief in Allah and His Messenger? Look around the Muslim world today. Do we truly believe that the unrest we see is solely caused by external forces? Much of it stems from our own disunity. Even our respected scholars and sheikhs, whom we love and admire, are contributing to the fragmentation of the Ummah. One day, it’s Shia versus Sunni; the next, we label others as enemies. This cycle of division is tearing us apart. Instead of focusing on these differences, shouldn’t we rally around the common ground that unites us?
@@suallaribrahim3843 I absolutely agree with you, that we should come to common grounds, but we shouldn't do that if we have to compromise our religion. I'm not saying it's the case if we align with Shia, it's just a general ruling that I use to align with people. I'm a new Muslim, so I am not knowledgeable enough to discuss Shia (to my understanding there are different types of them), so I just follow the general ruling when it comes to kuffaar or different Muslim sects.
Shias believe Allah, rasools, Quran, resurrection, angles. Shias pray, give zakath, perform Haj, fast in Rama an, work and sacrifice against zionist occupiers 100 times more than sunnies. Still you believe that their religious attitudes will not be counted.
@user-it1ek5ok7w the elder Shiite scholars preached that the Quran is distorted. However these days few of them say this publicly because they know they will be publicly humiliated in debate. It's hard to tell if they actually discarded it because they practice something called "Taqiyaah" which is lying about one's belief out of fear from other. This is a common practice amongst cults. It should be noted that shiism really only turned into a cult during the saffavid period of Iran. That's when the saffavid regime adopted Shiism as a way to create hatred against the ottomans who they saw as competiton. So they came up with a lot of vengeful nonsense such as self beating rituals and cursing.
They believe in same Allah (azzawajal), same prophet Muhammad (sallallahu alaihi wasallam) so it's not other religion but they exaggerated in very big things, May Allah guide them, may Allah make us steadfast on Islam...
You can not takfir Ahl-al Qiblah is the principle we are taught by our imams here in Turkey. Our Hanafi and Shafi scholars disapprove of Shia but do not takfir them either.
From a Shia, thank you. we have our differences but good to know you don't takfir us. I've shafi friends they're really nice. May Allah swt bless the believers 🤍
@@ath_thabaat @TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper There are two types of scholars: 1- Imams who kept away from official positions, like Abu Hanifa, or were in trouble with officials and jailed, like Imam Shafi... Speaking Of Imam Shafi, be aware of him to have been killed by ignorant Imam Malik followers. He was killed because of accusation of kufr. Unbelievable huh? That's why sunni imams said it is deadly dangerous to takfir muslims. Read Faisal Al Tafriqah by Imam Ghazali and other independent scholars' ijtihads and fatwas about this topic. (They were independent on their ijtihads and fatwas from political authorities like sultans, kings, shahs etc.) 2- Scholars who kept official positions like Ebussud Efendi. They gave fatwas according to the sovereignity of the authority (sultans, kings, shahs etc.) they were affiliated to. Their fatwas aim to strengthen for power of an authority. They serve a purpose. These two types of scholars also the case for Shia side of course. There were and are mullahs, ayatollahs etc. who were/are affiliated by authorities. They support oppression from those authorities by their fatwas. Just be aware of the distinction between to oppose some muslims and to takfir them.
I am Shia and this is not what I'm taught, we take the religion from Quran and the prophet (peace be upon him) and he told us muslims : اني تارك فيكم الثقلين ما إن تمسكتم بهما لن تضلوا: كتاب الله وعترتي أهل بيتي وأنهما لن يفترقا حتى يردا علي الحوض. We don't hate anybody, but we don't like anyone who hurts the prophet or his beloved family, and we don't like anyone who hurts Islam and Muslims, we stand against them because it's our duty not our hatred Islam's strength had never been the number of Muslims mainly. In conclusion, we are on the prophet's Sunnah by doing what he told is in حديث الغدير and my other hadiths. the proof are the there look for them from the main sources and judge with knowledge and a clear heart. And again, I'm not an enemy to any other Muslim who wants unity to the Umma we're in this together and Allah is the judge. Peace be upon you all.
@@Abdur-Rahman862 How does that make twelverism true? Is Christianity true cause South Africa supports Palestine? Is Sunnism & Zaydism true simply because Zaydis are supporting Palestine If Sunni Rullers represent Sunnis, then Shia scholars represent Shias even more. So according to this logic Shiism is false cause 1000s of Shia scholars say the Quran was changed by the Sahaba
❗Totally wrong. They have some differences. But we can't say that they are kafir. They also accepted the kalima لا إله إلا الله محمد رسول الله. Sheikh should watch Sheikh Yasir Qadhi's lecture where he clearly explains the differences. ua-cam.com/video/Wq6tTR1tbqc/v-deo.htmlsi=vI3QUgSk9IlE208g
@@mohammedzaidh123 Saying the Kalima does not mean you are a muslim. It is in the works. If you say "There is no god worthy of worship but Allah" yet you keep calling dead people for help, then you don't believe this Kalima. If you say "Muhammad is the messenger of Allah" yet you curse and cal his companions murtadeen, then you don't believe this Kalima.
@@Mzee-z5fwe have the same Quran,who is displaying hate?the sheikh ?why the don’t tell about Mr Abu Bakr went to saqifa to be elected as khalifa,lady Aisha rode on a camel to fight Ali,remember sheikh according to Quran the mayority of people is lost,so mayority doesn’t make you right, the genocide in Palestina have exposed the mayority of Sunnis ,particularly those sheikh who have a big tongue to attack the shias but bite their tongue in the face of the oppessors and taguts,,😂
With all due respect, the Sheikh’s analysis of the Shia school is totally incorrect. Anyone seeking a well informed answer should do their own research and not take this explanation as truth. 1. The Shia believe in the absolute necessity of adhering to the sunnah. The difference of opinion lies in what the sunnah constitutes and how to access it. For the Shia, they rely more heavily on the prophetic household (Ahlulbayt) as the most reliable avenue to the sunnah. The Hadith of the “Two weighty things” (Hadith althaqlayn contextualises this). 2. The Shia believe in the exactly the same Quran, and believe that it remains unadulterated and protected. Anybody claiming otherwise is a liar and anyone who believes the Quran is deficient has committed kufr. 3. The Shia do not have a blanket anti-sahaba policy. Rather, they assign differing levels of reverence and respect to the sahaba based on their merit. For example, they love the likes of Ammar Ibn Yasir RA, Abu Dharr Alghifari RA, Salman RA, Jabir AlAnsari RA etc and only have reservations against the sahaba who demonstrated animosity towards the Ahlulbayt AS. Mu’awiyah was technically a sahabi, but waged war again Imam Ali Ibn Abi Talib during his caliphate - that’s a big deal. Ayesha RA is actually respected by the mainstream Shia, but criticised for her recalcitrance and raising an army to fight Imam Ali AS during his caliphate. 4. It’s not fair to categorise all members of the Shia School as being a single ideology. The mainstream majority are moderate, respectful and advocates of Islamic unity. Whereas there is a vocal minority within the group that gets all the attention and they are typically the ones engaging in acts of extremism, cursing etc and cannot be considered orthodox or mainstream. 5. The Shia school is built on the Hadith of Ghadeer Khumm (cited in Sahih Muslim and others) where the prophet SAW raised the hand of Ali AS in front of the Muslim pilgrims returning from Hajj and declared “To whomever I am a MAWLA, then ALI is their MAWLA”. Shias and Sunnis disagree on what the term MAWLA means in this context: friend or master? 6. The Shia school in a nutshell, is the belief that the completed and perfected religion of Allah (Al-Islam) is to be represented by designated members of the Prophetic household (The Imams of Ahlulbayt) after the demise of the Prophet SAW. This aligns with the Hadith of the two weighty things I mentioned earlier “I leave behind the Quran and my ahlulbayt…”. This is in contrast to accepting the caliph Abu Bakr that was elected at the secret meeting at Saqifa whilst Ali Ibn Abi Talib AS was occupied with the burial rituals of the prophet SAW. And the rest is history.. 7. Perhaps I can dedicate another comment another time about the significance of the battle of Karbala and why the martyrdom of AlHussain AS orchestrated by the hands of the ummayids was so tragic, but also why is served as a wake-up call to galvanise the ummah that had drifted so far away from the sunnah of his grandfather the Prophet SAW. This battle exposed the hypocrisy and the ulterior motives of the Ummayid dynasty. Namely Yazid and his father Mu’awiyah ( who btw violated the treaty he signed with Imam Al-Hassan AS). 8. The Shia get their fiqh (jurisprudence) from Imam Jafar AlSadiq (the teacher of Imam Abu Hanifa amongst others). 9. If you actually want to know a credible Sunni stance on the Shia school I suggest you look up the Fatwa issued by Shaikh Mahmood Shaltoot in 1959 (the head of Al-Azhar at the time) where he reiterated the legitimacy of the Shia school. May Allah (swt) guide us all Ameen.
He have no Idea about Shia. He get some attitude of some people and say that is all of shia . Same attitude anti islams have , they say look at isis so Islam is isis .
@@obscurifyed *Shiaa ( the real nawasib) believe Fatima "RadiAllahu Anha" insulted Ali "RadiAllahu Anhu" and gets angry at him three times* These are three different stories among Shiaa books regarding Fatimah's anger towards Ali (bearing in mind that shias believe Ali and Fatimah are infallible and incapable of committing any sin or mistake, like the angels):
I am very sorry to say this I am sunni living with shia for more than 40 years and I have never ever heard once someone saying that our coran is different than theirs or that the sunni are kafer the only thing that comes up most of the time is that they believe that ahl lul beit where closer to our prophet sas than the companions of the prophet sas so please don't say things that are not true
Before the Jew Abdullah ibn Saba created the Shia sect there were no Sunnis it was only Muslims, when Shias came they named these Muslims simply as Sunnis. For ones I agree with this sheikh, they are not Muslims
No Shia knows who that mf Abdullah Ibn Saba? he's a mere myth. Read all our books if you can. You don't see his name even once It's you who pray like Jews, fast on ashura like jews. Curse be upon Ibn Saba if he ever existed and upon the liars
I don’t agree with the sheikh on many points, only because he studied the Quran and Sunnah doesn’t mean he understands them, I listen to Allah and prophet peace be upon him. If you want to make this sheikh your mentor you do it.
@@sabdulrahmanshaikh1621 He literrally said "adore" towards other than Allah? Check the definition (the first and most popular(/used) meaning of the word and tell me wether you "adore" other than Allah. Edit (for reference: 1:40)
There is another difference. The Shia have a spine. Sunni leaders watch on with hopelessness accetance. The Sunni leaders are spineless. Sunni and Shia need to unite. Some how, some way. Allahu Akbar.
Has the situation in Palestine improved since Iran's involvement? Has the quality of life of thr Palestinians improved? Why not? Aren't the Shia helping?
Shia testify shahada, pray salah, fast Ramadan, pay zakat, perform hajj to Mecca, believe in Allah, his angels, prophets, messengers, his scriptures, qadr and the day of judgement. Yet somehow we are not muslims?? Takfiri culture on full display. How many shekels did they pay you to say that sheikh? All from the nasibi school of hatred.
Your so called testifying is very twisted, if you're truly a shia you will know the shahada they do is not like what prophet Muhammed peace be upon him taught us , the same with prayer fasting and many other things they twist and add to the religion while even cursing the best of the people who are the companions of the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him which Allah and His messenger warned against those who say bad things about the companions specially the first Khalifa Abu bakr may Allah be pleased with him which has one of the highest status among the companions on the day of judgment and if the Prophet Muhammad would have taken a friend in this world it would be him as He said during his life time......
believe his prophets? and not follow the last prophet Muahmmad SAW? believe Allah, but also treat humans like gods? like using labbayka when refering to humans, pray? and make adan and wudu and even prayer different than what our prophet taught us?
@@brightnessunknown9605 we believe and follow what Prophet Muhammad saws has taught us. Why do we follow your readings? What makes the way you pray right? We have our own readings, you have yours. By that logic, you people also don't follow Islam the way Prophet did. we can say that too and takfir you on the basis of that. You all say the parents of holy prophet saws and his uncle are in hellfire we still dont make takfir of you. Why do you all do that? even when your books sa not to do that
Uthman Ibn Affan became caliphate and was murdered by (misguided) muslims because they didn’t like how he “ruled”- (they wanted revenge on those who murdered Umar RA and he refused) he said “By God, if you kill me you will never again have love for one another, nor will you ever pray together again, nor will you be ever united in fighting an enemy.” They eventually killed him. Such a shame the level of misguidance that came about after the prophet SAW death between the muslims regarding the Caliphates.
Shia’s have a strong hatred to most of the companions which is not permissible. Allah is pleased with the companions and has prepared Jannah for all of the companions.وَٱلسَّـٰبِقُونَ ٱلۡأَوَّلُونَ مِنَ ٱلۡمُهَـٰجِرِینَ وَٱلۡأَنصَارِ وَٱلَّذِینَ ٱتَّبَعُوهُم بِإِحۡسَـٰنࣲ رَّضِیَ ٱللَّهُ عَنۡهُمۡ وَرَضُوا۟ عَنۡهُ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمۡ جَنَّـٰتࣲ تَجۡرِی تَحۡتَهَا ٱلۡأَنۡهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِینَ فِیهَاۤ أَبَدࣰاۚ ذَ ٰلِكَ ٱلۡفَوۡزُ ٱلۡعَظِیمُ﴿ ١٠٠ ﴾ • Dr. Mustafa Khattab: As for the foremost-the first of the Emigrants[[ i.e., the early Muslims who emigrated from Mecca to Medina, known as Al-Muhâjirûn.]] and the Helpers[[ i.e., those from Medina, known as Al-Anṣâr, who accepted Islam and sheltered Muslim emigrants from Mecca. ]]-and those who follow them in goodness, Allah is pleased with them and they are pleased with Him. And He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow, to stay there for ever and ever. That is the ultimate triumph. At-Tawbah, Ayah 100.
@@pUbErtYy_49 brother I come from a Shia background but as I have studied deen myself I have come to know that real ahle sunnah is authentic as per my knowledge, I may be wrong or may not be may ALLAH guide us all to Haq ( Truth ). But as for the Shias, i know Shias who respect the sahabas r.a and that includes ( Abu bakr, Umar, uthman, and other sahabas r.a ) but you just can't blindly say that shias are Kaffir. The mainstream media only shows the harsh face of the Shias, and vice versa.
@@Viralshow567 Akhi I have the same background in the first place, the thing is the word Shia is almost always associated with ithna ashariyah (twelves). Their doctrines are full of Kur and Shirk, like catholics. Yes there are people ascribing themselves to catholic faith, but don't believe in the trinity etc. Also the Sheikh seems to know a good portion, since he knew their books and scholars. But that's only about ithna ashariyah. Very few Muslims know about Zaydiyah and Mansuriyah. And even in Yemen Huuti got to close to Twelverism. So Zaydis are getting as irrelevant as Mansuriyah. So its not 100% correct to say all Shia are Kupfer, but all believing Ithna Ashariyah are. And this is the only cult known for the name Shia in probably some years.
@@Viralshow567 if they cant beleive Quran 100 percent then they are kaffir, but majority of shais are confused that dont know about there own books of i dont know may be 12 imams, there so much messed up things. If they know about there books and doesnt accept the quran 100 percent then they are not muslims. if they are confused i cant blame them
Nothing but those who follow the Sunnah of Mohammad Salalah hi wasallam is directly comes under sunni. At the time of Mohammad sws there was no sect like suuni or Shia.
don't make comments like those brother, you will only creat fithna and attract hatred. All madhabs have their pros and cons. We say that Hanbali Madhab is one of the best. May Allah SWT guide as all. Ameen
@@Hasanaljadid You have no right to say that. Even Al Allamah Sheikh Saleh al Fawzan calls out anyone who slanders Imam Abu Hanifa and his madhhab. Imam Abu Hanifah is our imam. رحمه الله رحمة واسعة
Shia’s have a strong hatred to most of the companions which is not permissible. Allah is pleased with the companions and has prepared Jannah for all of the companions.وَٱلسَّـٰبِقُونَ ٱلۡأَوَّلُونَ مِنَ ٱلۡمُهَـٰجِرِینَ وَٱلۡأَنصَارِ وَٱلَّذِینَ ٱتَّبَعُوهُم بِإِحۡسَـٰنࣲ رَّضِیَ ٱللَّهُ عَنۡهُمۡ وَرَضُوا۟ عَنۡهُ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمۡ جَنَّـٰتࣲ تَجۡرِی تَحۡتَهَا ٱلۡأَنۡهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِینَ فِیهَاۤ أَبَدࣰاۚ ذَ ٰلِكَ ٱلۡفَوۡزُ ٱلۡعَظِیمُ﴿ ١٠٠ ﴾ • Dr. Mustafa Khattab: As for the foremost-the first of the Emigrants[[ i.e., the early Muslims who emigrated from Mecca to Medina, known as Al-Muhâjirûn.]] and the Helpers[[ i.e., those from Medina, known as Al-Anṣâr, who accepted Islam and sheltered Muslim emigrants from Mecca. ]]-and those who follow them in goodness, Allah is pleased with them and they are pleased with Him. And He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow, to stay there for ever and ever. That is the ultimate triumph. At-Tawbah, Ayah 100.
Jazakallahu Khairan sheikh may Allah SWT reward you abundantly goodness and grant you more knowledge and wisdom ameen the companion of the prophet Muhammad SALLALLAHU ALAYHI WASALLAM PBUH his family and his companion they sacrifice their life for the Deen so we need to appreciate them not to insults them may Allah SWT protect us from the Shia allahumma ameen jazakallahu Khairan sheikh
Why do we call ourselves Sunnis, if Allah calls us Muslims, aren't we also a sect or if we call ourselves Salafists? I am a Muslim, Alhamdulliah, not a Sunni, not a Shia. I am a Muslim who follows the Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet s.a.s. follows
There's no separation in Deen as Shia or Sunni. it's all bogus politically motivated , economically motivated , nothing to do with the ways of the Deen.
@@nhafa121 That' was set in your mind by your evil Sheikh... Now Prophet Muhammad(saww) raised the hand of Imam Ali(a.s) in Ghadirr khumm(pond) in front of thousands of people's...
@@Mohammed523 The Persians (modern-day Iran) were actually Sunni until The Safavid Empire wanted something different they wanted their own community Ismāil the first began to adopt Shiasim and kil1ed Sunnis and actively persecuted them through tribal allies of the Shah. His armies also destroyed several important Sunni sites, including the tombs of Abū Ḥanīfa and Abdul-Qadir Gilani. The Safavids even expelled the family of Gilani from Mesopotamia. He forcefully converted Sunnis to Shiaiasm. Ismail the first announced himself as the Mehdi and the first Imam. He killed Sunnis for not praying like Shia. The first person to bring Shiaism into existence was ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’ was a Jew who pretended to be Muslim. He was originally from Yemen, and travelled to spread his fitnah (turmoil) in the Hijaz, then Basra and Kufah. He went to Damascus during the caliphate of ‘Uthmaan ibn ‘Affaan (may Allah be pleased with him) and was expelled by its people, then he went to Egypt and started to openly promote his bid‘ah (innovation). Abudllah ibn Saba claimed that Ali ra was a divine and said there are 12 Imams. " The first one to introduce the innovated view that ‘Ali was infallible and that he should have been the caliph on the basis of religious texts was the leader of these hypocrites, ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’, who was originally Jewish, then pretended to be Muslim and aimed to corrupt the Islamic religion as Paul had corrupted the Christian religion." The view that the Jew ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’ was the founder of the Raafidi sect and that he established it in an effort to conspire against the Muslims and widen divisions among them, is a valid opinion that carries weight, with which the books of history and the study of sects and groups are filled, and it is not even denied by the Raafidis themselves. With regard to the attempt of some of them to deny the existence of ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’, that is pure propaganda by means of which they are trying to refute what has become widely known among their opponents of the fact that this Jew was the founder of their madhhab. The Dajjal would be followed by seventy thousand Jews of Isfahan wearing Persian shawls. (Sahih Muslim 2944). It is highly possible that Dajjal would be a shia. The shia have levels I know there are some low-level Shias who don't know much of anything layman and they are shia because their parents are shia. If you study Shiaism how it came into existence and how it persecuted sunni Persians and forced them to convert to Shiasim which is haram in Islam. The only way is to follow the Quran and Sunnah. They started as a power-hungry false madhab and will continue that way.
According to all Shia sects, when Allah was revealing verses 33:6, 9:100, 48:29, and 59:8-9, Allah did not know in advance that Aisha (r.a.) would battle against Ali (r.a.) or that many companions would become disbelievers or hypocrites. That is why, they argue, Allah did not exclude them from these verses. Therefore, they have no doubts that these companions should be considered hypocrites. Astagfirullah
And Al-Muttaqûn will be far removed from it (Hell). He who spends his wealth for increase in self-purification, And who has (in mind) no favour from anyone to be paid back, Except to seek the Countenance of his Lord, the Most High. He surely will be pleased (when he enters Paradise). [Surah al-Layl 92:17-21] According to Ahlus-Sunnah, ٱلْأَتْقَى refers to Abu Bakr and was revealed regarding him whereas the Shi'a say this refers to Ali. There is no third Hadith. Now for some context: This is a Makki surah, and Ali during this time was poor, so he did not have wealth to spend. During the time of Makkah, the Prophet took Ali into his home, so he did have a dunyawi favor from the Prophet which could be paid back, whereas Abu Bakr had no dunyawi favor from the Prophet but rather only the favor of deen. How does Allah describe الأتقى here? they give their wealth to purify themself & they don't have a favor from anyone to be paid back So how would this ayah fit for Ali, who was not wealthy during this time & had a wordly favor from Rasoolullah that could be paid back? And if it does not fit for Ali, the only other option would be Abu Bakr- Allah would be describing him with Taqwa and a promise to save him for Hellfire
Very important to note that sheikh isn’t doing takfir on the individual shia person that you might know. Maybe he was just born into it and doesn’t know anything about shiaism. Only if he tells you all the things sheikh counted, then yeah he has a big problem lol
It is important to note, however, that the average Shia does not know what their sect respresents; They are not aware of the shirk and kufr their ullama have written. I believe the sheikh was talking about the knowledgeable Shia and not the laymen. Lastly, it is not upon us to give takfir. The sheikh was right in what he said but we cannot go up to an individual and call them a kafir just because they are Shia, because we do not know the extent of their knowledge and practice. I advise you to fear Allah regarding this.
This sheikh wow... He says Shia are alright in one video and calls them kafir in another. Very well educated sheikh but speaks nonsense when his biases flare up...
Oufffff unbelievable the amount of misinformation this guy is spreading is scary and he is asking a 110$ for a half-hour consultation session and asking for people to donate to others who cannot afford it just HILARIOUS
Allahummabarik, don't worry about them they are people who call themselves Muslim but majority of them have beliefs and do things that take them out of Islam
@@fatima.x11SIMPLY SHIA ARR NOT MUSLIMS THEY ARE KAFIRS PRETENDING TO BE MUSLIMS... THEY ABUSE THE GREAT COMPANIONS OF THE PROPHET AND HIS WIVES..THEY PRAY DIFFERENT. THEY ARE ALWAYS OPPOSITE FROM THE TEACHINGS OF THE PROPHET. THEY ARE DEVILS CREATING CONTROVERSIAL TO DIVIDE THE MUSLIM UMMAH
@@fatima.x11 Yes, if it's clear then they're kuffar.. They believe Quran is corrupted.. they call the wife of the prophet a pros*itute.. Is that a muslim to you? They say Ali and Hassan and Hussien are the ones who created everything.. They say Ali is the one who decides who go to jannah and who go to jahnnam... is this some kind of a joke? how do you call these muslims?
Honeslty, if a Muslim doesn't follow the prophet (pbuh) then I dunno what they're doing... like bruh. Do you not know the shahada/first pillar of islam???
@@ibrahimkassim8289 This Ummah will not stand without Tawheed. Palestine will never be free without Tawheed. So do not say stop discussing about this things.
All sects are haram. These people would not have a job if there wasn't a sunni or shia sect. The Quran is enough: Indeed, you ˹O Prophet˺ are not responsible whatsoever for those who have divided their faith and split into sects. Their judgment rests only with Allah. And He will inform them of what they used to do. Q6:159
Respected Maulana, I appreciate your dedication to sharing knowledge. However, I would like to clarify that information you shared about Shia community to your followers in this video is not at all accurate. The primary difference between Shia and Sunni Muslims lies in their belief regarding leadership after the Prophet Muhammad's death. Shia Muslims believe in the concept of Imamat, which holds that the leadership should remain within the Prophet's family, specifically through his son-in-law Ali and his descendants. Sunni Muslims, on the other hand, follow the principle of Khilafat, which emphasizes the selection of leaders through consensus and election. This fundamental difference in belief has shaped the theological, juridical, and cultural practices of both traditions.
I have a question: What defines a Muslim? Do Shias believe in Allah and the Prophet (peace be upon him)? Do they follow the five pillars of Islam? If the answers are yes, then why are some sheikhs claiming they aren’t Muslims? This divide between Shia and Sunni has always been rooted in politics, but it’s becoming more harmful when our religious leaders fuel hatred instead of fostering unity.
We should guide others to the right path through dialogue and diplomacy, not division. Look at what’s happening in the Arab world-aren’t we learning anything from this? Let’s stop the hatred.
@@suallaribrahim3843Abu Bakr is promised paradise. Shias claim he is Kafir. Some even claim that he was a hypocrite which is worse. We know from ahadith that when you takfir your brother, the takfir must be true of one of you. if Shias are Muslim, I don't see why Qadianis can't be Muslim as well
The Kufan Shia themselves acknowledged that they were the ones who killed Sayyidina Husain. This group, who claimed responsibility for killing Sayyidina Husain, later emerged as the “At-Tawwabun” faction, claiming to regret their actions. As an act of repentance, they killed one another, similar to what the Jews did as an expression of repentance to Allah for the sin of worshipping the golden calf after Prophet Musa ascended to Mount Sinai. The blood tears shed by the “At-Tawwabun” faction remain vividly visible in the pages of history and have not been erased, despite countless attempts to do so. The confession of the Shia who killed Sayyidina Husain has been immortalized by Shia scholars who are pillars of their faith, such as Baqir Majlisi, Nurullah Shustri, and others, in their respective books. Baqir Majlisi wrote: “A group of people from Kufah were startled by a mysterious voice. They said, ‘By God! What we have done has never been done by anyone else. We killed the "Leader of the Youth of Paradise" because of Ibn Ziyad, that illegitimate son.’ There, they pledged allegiance to rebel against Ibn Ziyad, but it was of no use.” (Jilaau Al'Uyun, p. 430) Qadhi Nurullah Shustri also wrote in his book Majalisu Al'Mu'minin that after a long time (approximately 4 or 5 years) following the killing of Sayyidina Husain, the leaders of the Shia gathered their followers and said, "We invited Sayyidina Husain, pledging our allegiance to him, but then we betrayed him by killing him. Our sin is so great that it can only be forgiven by killing one another.” Thus, a large group of Shia gathered by the Euphrates River, reciting the verse which means, “So repent to your Creator and kill yourselves. That is better for you in the sight of your Creator.” (Al-Baqarah: 54). Then they slaughtered one another. This group became known in Islamic history as the “At-Tawwabun.”
Sayyidina Husain’s own words, recorded in history before he was killed, were directed at the Kufan Shia who were ready to fight him: “O people of Kufah! May you be cursed just as your evil intentions have been cursed. O deceitful, oppressive, and treacherous people! You invited us to defend you in your time of hardship, but when we came to lead and protect you, trusting in you, you now unsheathe your swords of vengeance against us and assist our enemies in fighting us.” (Jilaau Al’Uyun, p. 391). He also said to the Shia: “Woe to you! How could you unsheathe the swords of your vengeance without any enmity or conflict between you and us? Why are you so eager to kill the Ahlul Bayt without any cause?” (Ibid). Finally, he invoked a curse upon the Shia who were about to engage in battle with him: “O Allah! Withhold the blessings of the earth from them and scatter them. Make the hearts of their rulers despise them, for they invited us under the pretense of defending us, but now they unsheathe their swords of vengeance against us.” (Ibid). He is also recorded to have cursed them further, saying: “Woe to you! God will avenge me in this world and the hereafter... You will punish yourselves by striking your own bodies with swords, and your faces will be stained with your own blood. You will not prosper in this world, and you will never attain your desires. When you die, the torment of God will await you in the hereafter. You will suffer the punishment reserved for the most wicked disbelievers.” (Mulla Baqir Majlisi, Jilaau Al’Uyun, p. 409).
As a sunni I condemn any kind of hatred and lie against shias. Please don't fall into zionist's tricks. We are all muslims, and that's the most important. Hate against another muslims is not what helps for the ummah, it helps only for zionists.
@@_ibnmuhammad Allah is the greatest, none of any curses can do anything if Allah is protecting you and your family. But I understand your point, I know that it's not easy for shias because a lot of sunnis who are brainwashed by wahhabi-zionist influence are constantly cursing them. I feel sorry for them when some sunnis say that they will burn in hell and these speeches. As a sunni I don't claim these people. The Quran forbids hatred against another muslims. That's why those self-proclaimed sheykhs who are spreading hatred against another muslims are obviously zionist-backed. Hence that's Israel's aim. They cannot destroy the ummah, so they use their intelligence services to spread hatred inside the ummah, to destroy it from inside. But the muslims who follow Allah and not the bribed propagandists are not fooled to these tricks.
@@DavidRobertJohns This isn't a hatred. Calling someone of their deviance is not hatred. Calling people into the guidance is not hatred. It is actually a mercy for them. Don't you want your brothers to be with you in the paradise Allah had prepared for you? If yes, then engage in da'wah, call them to the correct path of your Prophet ﷺ If no, then just let them curse the Mothers of the believers, call the companions of your prophet as hypocrites and disbelievers.
Allah said HE WILL PROTECT THE QURAN, which means any altered version of The Quran won't be established in this world. If you don't believe in Allah's words then I think you are not a Muslim.
Okay now you're just making stuff up. Shias don't say there are different versions of the Quran. This is an absolute lie. You should debate a Shia Imam.
There are NO difference between Sunnah and Shia. Please be an agent of unifications NOT fragmentations. As long as a Muslim believe in Quran and Sunnah, then case closed .... HE IS MUSLIM AS GOOD AS YOU AND ME. Leave judgment to GOD not to you or other humans. PLEASE!!!!
I was shia until November 2020 and I left for the reasons he said and more. Alhamdulillah for Islam. Quran and the Sunnah is the way.
@@VISUALW0RLD May Allah keep you steadfast
Alhamdulillah. Allah guided you to the right path.
May Allah keep you steadfast
You are lost then, and one thing always remember how a well learned Shaikh can call someone kafir, if they believe in one God. Isn't it seems vice-versa valid. Dear brother I wish Allah guides u again. And don't be a sinner. You had proofs with you
Shias call people who died 1200 kaffur
May Allah reunite the ummah Aameen
Upon the way of our Nabi saw. Shias are non believers. Period
Amin
There is no unity between Muslims and polytheists. The Quran is clear on al wala’ wa’l bara. Those who reject the Quran and the teachings of the Prophet AS while worshiping men and idols, cursing those whom the Prophet AS loved can never be reconciled with unless they change their ways and accept Islam.
Ameen
The Ummah is united alhamudlillah. If you mean the Shia then supplicate for their guidance. They aren't a part of the Ummah of Mohammed saw.
Make Dua for my father, he passed away yesterday
إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون
اللہ یرحمہ
ﺇِﻧَّﺎ ﻟِﻠّﻪِ ﻭَﺇِﻧَّـﺎ ﺇِﻟَﻴْﻪِ ﺭَﺍﺟِﻌﻮﻥَ may Allah grant him the highest of jannah
May Allah grant him jannah
May ALLAH forgive is sins and grant him Jannat Firdous
allah yarhamo
May Allah almighty guide all shia. Ameen.
All of us. Dont think you get pass. Every children of Adams saw is a sinner.
Please write Almighty with capital A
@@NesarsayedDude your comment are like christians. We don't born with sin. Like every children is pure and innocent.
As we grow up if we follow true teaching Muhammad pbuh and believe in one true God Allah inshallah we will go to heaven.
Allahuma Ameen
@@gamingwithhridoy143 you say you sunnis are all righteous. don't y'all sin? you're a sunni but what about not obeying RasulAllah saws when he said He's leaving behind Quran and Ahlulbayt. follow these two things and not go astray? We Shia follow these as it's something Allah and His Messenger pbuh obeyed us to follow. Our Imams (the successors of Prophet Muhammad saws) teach nothing but Tawheed, compassion, mercy and clemency. You can read Kitab Al tawheed by Shaykh Saduq to know how pure our tawheed is. Imam Jafar Sadiq, Imam Mahdi, Imam Baqir pbut have cursed those who claim to be shia but then believe that the Ahlulbayt provides rizq or things which only Allah swt has control over. Tawassul is proved however from both Shia and Sunni traditions and mainly Quran. It's written in your main 6 books that the Holy Prophet saws have said not to takfir a believer out of ignorance and assumptions. This is what y'all do to Shia. You see some videos of people claiming to be Shia doing crazy stuff and think that's our faith. No. Curse be upon those who lie on the name of Prophet and his household. Indeed Shirk is the greatest sin ever and whoever associates partners with God he's a dweller of hellfire. Also why do you ask other people about who Shia are? ask us directly, listen to our scholars the ones who are actually scholars, visit us and see what we're like. People who destroy the religion and are hypocrites are in every school of thought/jurisprudence. Also i know whatever i said, you'll turn a deaf ear to it and you're gonna say the same default insults or accusations that Shias do this and Shias do that, well Prophet saws and his household made it clear what their Shia (followers) should do. Insulting wives of the prophet is forbidden. we reject those who oppressed Ahlulbayt. we have our disagreements and we don't see them in good sight. but those who go extreme have nothing to do with the real Shias. they're the ghulat and curse is upon them as well from the Imams of Ahlulbayt.
Thank you dear shaikh. Jazakallahul khairan.
I'm Shia, I don't curse the prophets companions. I don't believe the Quran has changed. Strange where has he heard shias saying the Quran has changed? Isn't that one of the main beliefs of Muslims that that Quran is flawless?
That could mean you are not following the shi'ah beliefs. This is in their books and belief.
Moreover they make duaa to other than Allaah like Ya Ali and Ya Hussain which is major shirk and brings someone out of the fold of Islam.
you arent following Muhammad's saw sunnah and teachings. Your belief formed after the death of Muhammad saw where you invented things that were taught by him. And Bidaah belongs nowhere in Islam
@hueshangdangergeld we are closer than we think brother, May Allah guide us all Ameen
Do you believe in 12 imamaat that are INFALLIBLE
Why not stop it then. After all it’s foundation is kufr. Why trying to follow because your forefather were following. Remember you would stand in front of Allah alone. Make the hard choice because it’s necessary
As a ex Shia Iranian . Shia is different religion. They hate companion . And make horrible comments from their dirty mouths. to mother عایشه رضی الله عنها
You know Iran Supreme leader. Does he hate the companions because Iran is only one helping Falasteen 🇵🇸
@@HashShYT . He is doing
Taqiyyah maybe. Iran is a boogeyman
In region . Without Iran . USA can’t fool rich Arab countries and sell them weapons. Iran with his empty threats . Gives Isreal lot of privileges
@@HMD1986- Shameless lies.
Everyone can see who supports the genocidal maniacs and who opposes them.
You are the one doing the lying.
BTW i am Muslim and learned only from Sunni, not from Shia. Nothing to do with that, just stop spreading lies where the evil ones are the good ones.
@@HashShYT helping falasteen is not criteria of good religion..
@@HMD1986- Israel and Iran are best friends
Difference between Sunni and Shia is like Islam and other religions. Just love sheikh Assim. 👍
Maa Shaa Allah ❤
جزاك الله خيرا
Jazāk-Allāhu khayrā.
May Allah reward you with goodness.
THIS IS THE BEST ANSWER ✅✅☝🏻
You know nothing about them, that's why you say so
Mia Fil Mia yaa Shaikh.
Allah Bless you 🙏
Jazak Allah Khair
May Allah bless you shykh Aameen ❤
Astagfirullah may Allah SWT guide the Shias... how can they slander our Beloveds
Make Duo that Allah keeps you on Islam. Don't take it for granted. If you realize that you may understand why these people are as they are
they slandered each other lol. Why Aisha and Muawiya fought Imam Ali? Why Abu Bake didn't give Fatima the lady of heaven her right? Why Muawiya ordered cursing Imam Ali from pulpits? Why Aisha stopped funeral of Imam Hasan? All these things are written in your books and so much more. But you're certainly blind (and your reply is gonna be you insulting be and saying the same default insults and accusations) so it's pointless to argue with yall. It's a problem when we slander your caliphs what about when you say the parents and the uncle of the Holy Prophet saws are in hellfire??? Curse be upon anyone who thinks such about the family of the greatest and the most noble creation of Allah swt
@@fatima.x11ok I can give your all ans
Write the full version not SWT
@@fatima.x11
So according to you Uncle of Prophet saw is in Heaven?
Abu Talib who died as a Kafir is in Heaven?
True that Alhamdulillah
I love this sheikh may Allah protect you amen
I was Shi´a and now Sunni since 7th November 2023.
My goodness Sheikh didn't know that. Thank you. Allah bless you InshaAllah Ameen.
@@MM6M5 sheikh is the worst enemy off islam
Alhumdulilah for the blessing of sunnah. May Allah be pleased with all the companions of Prophet Muhammad ❤❤❤
Your allah is terrorist, your deen is the deen of terrorists, your prophet was a terrorist, there is no sense of pride.
@@mfahadfayt there is not sunnah off the prophet
Allahu Akbar
Whoever says La ilaha illallah, muhammadu rasoolullah is a muslim. May make mistakes and be sinful, but is still muslim. May Allah guide us all ameen.
Just saying Sahada is not sufficient, one has to pray and do righteous deeds etc.
@@mrmghouse Shias also do that, so they are muslims by definition. Also they only have to follow the 5 pillars of Islam to be considered Muslim. Why are you adding more rules and circumstances? That is bidah.
@@iceycones654كلامك غير صحيح بالمره لا يومن اكثرهم بالله الا وهم مشركون ايه كريمه هل تعلم ان كفار قريش كانو مومنين بان الله واحد ولاكنهم كانو يعبدون الاصنام لتقربهم لله وقالو ما نعبدهم الا ليقربونا الى الله زلفى
وَيَعْبُدُونَ مِن دُونِ اللَّهِ مَا لَا يَضُرُّهُمْ وَلَا يَنفَعُهُمْ وَيَقُولُونَ هَٰؤُلَاءِ شُفَعَاؤُنَا عِندَ اللَّهِ ۚ قُلْ أَتُنَبِّئُونَ اللَّهَ بِمَا لَا يَعْلَمُ فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَلَا فِي الْأَرْضِ ۚ سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ عَمَّا يُشْرِكُونَ
الله وصف الذى يضع بينه وبين الله وسيط بالمشرك وقال ربكم ادعونى استجب لكم وايضا قال تعالى ونحن اقرب اليه من حبل الوريد اما الوسيله المشروعه فى الاسلام هى فقط دعوه الله بالاسماء والصفتت مثل يا رحيم ارحمنى يا رزاق ارزقنى ودعوه الله بالعمل الصالح مثل اياك نعبد واياك نستعين اهدنا السراط المستقيم عوه الرجل الصالح وهو حى مثل اخوه يوسف عندما قالو يا ابانا استغفر لنا لان ابوهم صالح وشرط انه على قيد الحياه ولو كان يجوز دعاء لااموات لسجدو لقبر جدهم ابراهيم وهو افضل من ابيهم ولاكن الاسلام حرم دعوه الاموات لان الميت لا ينفع ولا يضر اما زياره القبور ففقط تذهب وتدعى لصاحب القبر بالرحمه ان يرحمه الله وليس العكس وتطلب منه ان يرحمك ويرزقك وهو تحت التراب 😂😂
@@محمدعلىحمدالله-ث5ي Bro I don't speak arabic.
May allah SWT guide all shia
And respect shikh from Ethiopia 🇪🇹
Plz do a 40' video about this topic
Shi'as say Quran is altered? They have their own Quran? They hate all Sahabas? Ok brother. If those are the things you want to tell yourself, and everyone else so that you have an acceptable excuse for hating, then sure, but for those who genuinely want to know Shi'as are just like Sunnis, with only a few differences. Firstly, Shia's DON'T HAVE THEIR OWN QURAN, OR THEIR OWN SHAHADA. Secondly, we don't hate all Sahabas, not even the majority of them. Thirdly, Shi'as don't seek revenge either, they just want to keep the memory, and the teachings of the beloved grandson of the Propeht (P.B.U.H) with them, and naturally despise those who had a part in his killing. They don't go around saying we have to take revenge because as you said there is nobody to exact revenge on, since all of their oppressors are long gone. As for the different books you mentioned, in that case, there are also those who believe Hazrat Ali(A.S) to be god, obviously those are not Shia's, they're the ones who are committing kufr, these are called different schools of thought similar to the different schools of thought that sunnis have, but in the case with Shi'as these are very niche, and very extreme unlike the sunnis, with only a few Shi'as following their teachings, and these are the primary source used to make sunnis hate shia's by putting all of them under this one umbrella, just like you did, and if questioned, one can easily get away by saying they are still Shi'a, which technically isn't wrong.
But please, if the Sheikhs' words help you sleep at night after calling another Muslim Kafir, then by all means pretend you didn't read this.
I think you are someone who is a "Cultural Shia" who doesn't even read his own books. I can show you from Shia Scholars and Shia hadith books such as Al-Kafi where Shia consider majority of Sahaba as Apostates and Sheikh Assim already mentioned the sources for Shia beliefs of Quran being distorted, this was also shown with evidence on Sunnah Discourse and by Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen in a debate with Shia. These are from the main stream beliefs of Twelvernism Shia (Ithna Ashariyyah) who are the majority of the Shia today.
It is you who is trying to comfort himself to sleep at night and as far as "Calling another Muslim Kafir" is concerned, whoever curses Aisha (Radi Allah Anha) is a Kafir because 33:6 and 33:33 mention wives of Prophet SAW as mothers of believers and from Ahlulbayt.
and to add on to Sheikh Assim-Al Hakeem's points, in the subcontinent specially Shia say "Ya Ali Madad" which is literally shirk and constitutes disbelief because they call out to Ali saying "Oh Ali Help" yet, they try to justify this by saying Ali (Radi Allah Anhu) will ask Allah for dua, but this isn't the meaning of the words they utter when they say "Ya Ali Madad" they try to provide their own explanation, different than what the meaning of the words utter actually means.
@@irtazza133I have seen a video of Shia in makkah near makam Ibrahim near kabah ... doing Azan among pilgrims and at part of Azan when we say Ash Ana Muhammad RasoolAllah... he was changing and saying a version not mentioning Prophet Muhammad but saying "Ali Ullah" .... many things come under questions in your beliefs yet you lot are getting defensive.
@@irtazza133 "Cultural Shia who doesn't even read his own books" what a nice assumption. I literally didn't even deny the existence of those books, I mentioned that they belong to a different school of thought, just like those who consider Hazrat Ali(A.S) to be god. Obviously, you are the one who hasn't researched enough about Shi'as thinking that those books are the main source of guidance for every Shia. Also, if by majority you mean the people who followed Muawiyah and their like, then yes you are correct, most of them are considered as bad people among Shias. Also the guys debating Shekih Ibn Uthaymeen are mostly from Iran, and/or Iraq, and yes, in those parts, Shi'aism is not what it actually should be, and the essence has been lost. I can say that because I know about a lot of their practices, and they are not right, not just by shia standards, but by basic Islamic standards. Also, you just made up someone being Kafir by mentioning 33:33 and 33:6, when nowhere in there it says anything about such a punishment. Also, the end of the verse reads "Allah only intends to keep ˹the causes of˺ evil away from you and purify you completely, O members of the ˹Prophet’s˺ family!" You know what this means? It means Allah wants to keep evil away from them, and wants to purify them, but if they themselves go near those causes then what? Or are you going to argue that Allah took away their autonomy and they could not do anything of their own will?
Brother you are very educated, Allahumma Barik 😊😊@@irtazza133
thank you for clarity
As Salaam Alaakum. With all due respect, Prophet Muhammad pbuh was a Muslim. And we need to follow his example. He was neither Sunni or Shia.
YES BROTHER YES THIS IS THE ANSWER YOU SAID IT AKHI
Ah, so the people who call Aisha raa a prosti*ute are muslims? The people who say the Quraan is corrupted are muslims? What is a muslim to you?
His examples are his Sunnah which Shia don't follow. That's what the Sheikh is saying.
@@ahmadharis4u nah still no sections though follow the sunnah and Quran makes u a real Muslim not calling yourself a Sunni give me a Hadith where the prophet called himself a Sunni nah u guys are still falling into sections. Get a grip it’s Islam not Islam with multiple sections.
@@4912-w5l Sunni is a word crafted for those who follow the Sunnah. This might have been done after Shia came into existence. I'm not a scholar but this seems logical. It's not a sect in itself, rather to differentiate from Shia who called themselves Muslims without following the teachings of our Prophet (s.a.w.)
Verse 159 of Surah Al-An'am in the Quran states that those who divide their religion and become sects are not associated with the Prophet Muhammad and that their judgment is with Allah
(6:159) Surely you have nothing to do with those who have made divisions in their religion and become factions.141 Their matter is with Allah and He will indeed tell them (in time) what they have been doing.
@@gokuha8676 sunni shia and others are sects 🤣🤣
@@meggimeggi3650 The quaran says NO sects read it
@@gokuha8676 show the vers
@@meggimeggi3650 Have u heard of google you can google it yourself. You are lazy
"(6:159) Surely you have nothing to do with those who have made divisions in their religion and become factions.141 Their matter is with Allah and He will indeed tell them (in time) what they have been doing."
Well explained!
Ex-shia here🤚🏻
I was born in shia family but they are not like what you describe them (I mean my family only)
They don't curse anyone and they don't think Quran has been changed or something
Why ex- Shia?????
he's not talking about shias like ur family, hes talking about twelver shias
Im an Ex-shia from Pakistan. And my family always curses Abubakr, Umar, Uthman and Aisha (Radi Allah Anhuma) it isn't about what your family or my family do. It is about the Shia beliefs from their books and core doctrine and they absolutely do the things that the Sheikh Assim Al-Hakeem mentioned.
@@irtazza133 exactly
Been around Shias my whole life. Became a shia myself. All things people accuse us of are just accusations. They don't even know what we believe in. Us believing in changing of Quran is the funniest thing ever. curse be upon those who believe the word of God can be changed
Spoken like a true kaffir. Subhanallah
Subhanallah /mashallah
Sunnis follow the sunnah of the messenger and adhere to the Al-Quran. Taqaballahu minna wa minkum.
May Allah Guide them,
May Allah Guide us All Muslims to follow SUNNA OF OUR BELOVED PROPHET MUHAMMAD PEACE BE UPON HIM
Sheikh I wasn't expecting this kind of answer from you. Shia scholars refute all the claims you are making. In Pakistan there are Shia scholars who say "May Allah be pleased with him" with the name of AbuBakr and Umar. Khumeini gave fatwa in Iran that cursing the wives of Prophet SAW is haram. They also believe in the same Quran and no one among them say that the Quran Ahlul Sunnah have is different.
All these things you say are just because of your hatred towards them. It's a typical wahabi attitude most of the Arab scholars have.
Fear Allah, what if Allah holds you accountable for things you say which are not true??? May Allah guide us all.
I know what you are saying but what Sheikh said here unfortunately is true. I've heard these things from other sources as well and some very credible. I believe some branch of Shia's maybe don't beleive in these things but they do exist in Shia's.
@@aviatorzthebest2452 of course they exist no one is denying that but such people exist in Ahlul Sunnah too. In the sub continent, sunni muslims visit shrines asking the dead ones for help. If we start labelling the whole sect as kafir because of the actions of a particular group of people then there would be no muslim in the world.
In the video Sheikh said, Prophet Muhammad PBUH was a sunni. I mean seriously?? I don't expect such an absurd and stupid thing from a sheikh. The Prophet SAW always called himself a Muslim because in the Quran Allah SWT named us Muslims.
@@muzammilbukhari5926 Your first point is correct, I agree. For second, I don't have enough knowledge to say anything.
One thing however, just for my understanding and clarity, and in case if you know it... in the core/heart of Shia sect, do Shias beleive in Quran? and only few misguided ones beleive in this 'missing chapter' story? Is that correct or is it not?
@@aviatorzthebest2452 it's not. I know a lot of shia and neither they nor their scholars believe in this.
It's just our perception about them. Instead of making claims I think we should ask them about their beliefs and not just believe in the heresay.
@@aviatorzthebest2452No bro we don't believe Quran has changed. And how can he call us kafir if we believe in one God and his prophet SWt also Quran. It seems he is misguided 😅😅
$110 / Half Hour Session.. MASHA ALLAH brother..
and?
Why shias participate in global Qur'an competitions then ? 😊 Are they reciting something else ?
Not every Shi'i is a Shi'i
The same for catholics
Shias don't accept the Quran 100 percent. If you see a debate between a Shia and a Sunni Muslim, and we use only the Quran, the Shia will be dumbfounded and have no answer.
reciting is a thing, and living according to it is another
@@1280-user we live according to it Alhamdulillah. We don't takfir people like y'all do. We fear Allah swt. we Follow The holy Prophet saws and his Household. We fight against oppression and help and assist those who are oppressed.
Excellent
act sunni but don't call yourself sunni
simple
any one can change for the better if they want, insyallah
No
@@getbluespheres3kyou are obligated to call yourself Muslim.
@@Gereeen We're saying we are sunni just to distinguish ourselves with the people of desires.
@@_ibnmuhammad it's a case of Muslims vs Disbelieving Muslims
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله و بركاته
ʿalaykum Assālamu wa raḥmatu-llāhi wa barakātuh.
Peace be upon you, and the mercy and blessings of Allah.
I respect the sheikh but what he said about shia is not right.. If they are not Muslim why are they allowed to go for hajj and umrah?
Similarly, they follow the same quran as us. ( the missing chapter hadith can also be found in our hadith books as well but we consider these hadith as daeef)
I agree that they curse sahaba r.a but not all of the shia.. Those who have good knowledge they respect although they have different opinion about some sahaba r.a
I am not defending but telling what is true And Allah knows the best. May Allah guide us all and keep the whole Muslim. Ummah united.
P.s : I am a Sunni Muslim
Can u pls share the missing chapter of hadith
Yup pt. The shaikh needs to learn 😅😅
Shia say Ali is the best but Al-Mahdi is a hero upgrade from Ali
The last I checked Shia were helping Palestine too. Enough with these divisions already.
What are we, as Muslims, doing for Palestine? The suffering of our brothers and sisters in Palestine is heartbreaking, and it is time to ask ourselves how we are contributing to their support. It’s clear that our divisions, whether sectarian or otherwise, only weaken us. Nonbelievers don’t care about our internal differences; they see us as one. Why can’t we do the same? The most critical need right now is unity-it’s more important than all these divisions.
Many Christians and Atheists are helping Palestine, too. Does that mean they are on the straight path? The most important thing in this world is to worship Allah (SWT) the way He told us to worship Him. We can't water down our religion because our brothers and sisters are suffering.
@@ActualMoralityNo Christian country or Atheist country has attacked Israel. Only Shia countries.
@@ActualMorality So, is our best course of action to turn on one another, fostering disunity and contributing to the tragic loss of Muslim lives, rather than supporting one another as brothers and sisters? The Prophet (PBUH) foretold that the Ummah would divide into 73 sects, a reality that was destined to unfold. But instead of deepening this divide through conflict and bloodshed, why not focus on the most fundamental truth we all share-the belief in Allah and His Messenger?
Look around the Muslim world today. Do we truly believe that the unrest we see is solely caused by external forces? Much of it stems from our own disunity. Even our respected scholars and sheikhs, whom we love and admire, are contributing to the fragmentation of the Ummah. One day, it’s Shia versus Sunni; the next, we label others as enemies. This cycle of division is tearing us apart. Instead of focusing on these differences, shouldn’t we rally around the common ground that unites us?
@@iceycones654 shias have done a lot of loss to muslim ummah in iraq syria yemen , they r worse then non muslims
@@suallaribrahim3843 I absolutely agree with you, that we should come to common grounds, but we shouldn't do that if we have to compromise our religion. I'm not saying it's the case if we align with Shia, it's just a general ruling that I use to align with people. I'm a new Muslim, so I am not knowledgeable enough to discuss Shia (to my understanding there are different types of them), so I just follow the general ruling when it comes to kuffaar or different Muslim sects.
Subhana Allah
Shias believe Allah, rasools, Quran, resurrection, angles.
Shias pray, give zakath, perform Haj, fast in Rama an, work and sacrifice against zionist occupiers 100 times more than sunnies.
Still you believe that their religious attitudes will not be counted.
How do they believe in Qur'an when they say it is distorted?
Shia are all kuffar mushrikeen. They curse mother Aisha RA
Shias are massacring sunnis in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Yemen
@@Umar-qy3bd Taqiya mode on!
Shias believe in every other false god other than Allah,
@user-it1ek5ok7w the elder Shiite scholars preached that the Quran is distorted. However these days few of them say this publicly because they know they will be publicly humiliated in debate. It's hard to tell if they actually discarded it because they practice something called "Taqiyaah" which is lying about one's belief out of fear from other. This is a common practice amongst cults. It should be noted that shiism really only turned into a cult during the saffavid period of Iran. That's when the saffavid regime adopted Shiism as a way to create hatred against the ottomans who they saw as competiton. So they came up with a lot of vengeful nonsense such as self beating rituals and cursing.
I think it is useful for the sheikh to be honest.
No sunni no shia. Only muslim.
Whoever says the Quran has been changed is a disbeliever, even if he fasts for 365 days. Period
من يلعن ابو بكر كافر
if you born shia and dont read what you are then i dont think you really a shia, thats why its pointless to hate clueless people
Good slogan
@@zaeemtahir3020I’m ex Shia الحمدالله
They believe in same Allah (azzawajal), same prophet Muhammad (sallallahu alaihi wasallam) so it's not other religion but they exaggerated in very big things, May Allah guide them, may Allah make us steadfast on Islam...
You can not takfir Ahl-al Qiblah is the principle we are taught by our imams here in Turkey. Our Hanafi and Shafi scholars disapprove of Shia but do not takfir them either.
What???.. we can based on condition
From a Shia, thank you. we have our differences but good to know you don't takfir us. I've shafi friends they're really nice. May Allah swt bless the believers 🤍
But the ottoman empire scholars takfired the shia, the fatwa exists, look for it.
Shias were historically takfired by the ottoman caliphate alongside the other caliphates as well
@@ath_thabaat @TitaniumSlayerNinjaCopper
There are two types of scholars:
1- Imams who kept away from official positions, like Abu Hanifa, or were in trouble with officials and jailed, like Imam Shafi...
Speaking Of Imam Shafi, be aware of him to have been killed by ignorant Imam Malik followers. He was killed because of accusation of kufr. Unbelievable huh? That's why sunni imams said it is deadly dangerous to takfir muslims.
Read Faisal Al Tafriqah by Imam Ghazali and other independent scholars' ijtihads and fatwas about this topic. (They were independent on their ijtihads and fatwas from political authorities like sultans, kings, shahs etc.)
2- Scholars who kept official positions like Ebussud Efendi. They gave fatwas according to the sovereignity of the authority (sultans, kings, shahs etc.) they were affiliated to. Their fatwas aim to strengthen for power of an authority. They serve a purpose.
These two types of scholars also the case for Shia side of course. There were and are mullahs, ayatollahs etc. who were/are affiliated by authorities. They support oppression from those authorities by their fatwas.
Just be aware of the distinction between to oppose some muslims and to takfir them.
I am Shia and this is not what I'm taught, we take the religion from Quran and the prophet (peace be upon him) and he told us muslims : اني تارك فيكم الثقلين ما إن تمسكتم بهما لن تضلوا: كتاب الله وعترتي أهل بيتي وأنهما لن يفترقا حتى يردا علي الحوض.
We don't hate anybody, but we don't like anyone who hurts the prophet or his beloved family, and we don't like anyone who hurts Islam and Muslims, we stand against them because it's our duty not our hatred
Islam's strength had never been the number of Muslims mainly.
In conclusion, we are on the prophet's Sunnah by doing what he told is in حديث الغدير and my other hadiths.
the proof are the there look for them from the main sources and judge with knowledge and a clear heart.
And again, I'm not an enemy to any other Muslim who wants unity to the Umma we're in this together and Allah is the judge.
Peace be upon you all.
Did sunnis help Palestine?
NO!
Did Shia help Palestine?
Hell Yeah!!!
Did South Africans help Palestine , yes
did Muslims help Palestine, no
lol
This is my proof that Jesus is the 13th infallible imam lol
Do Muslims rule Palestine, no
Do Jews rule Palestine, yes
Moses is the 14th imam
Salawat
What kind of idiotic proof of the imama of aljawad is this. Even my 5 year old can bring better proofs
Help Palestine do what? What improvement has occurred in Palestine due to Shia presence?
@@Abdur-Rahman862 How does that make twelverism true?
Is Christianity true cause South Africa supports Palestine?
Is Sunnism & Zaydism true simply because Zaydis are supporting Palestine
If Sunni Rullers represent Sunnis, then Shia scholars represent Shias even more. So according to this logic Shiism is false cause 1000s of Shia scholars say the Quran was changed by the Sahaba
But Muhammad didn't say you should yourselves call sunnis. This is innovation again
❗Totally wrong. They have some differences. But we can't say that they are kafir. They also accepted the kalima لا إله إلا الله محمد رسول الله.
Sheikh should watch Sheikh Yasir Qadhi's lecture where he clearly explains the differences.
ua-cam.com/video/Wq6tTR1tbqc/v-deo.htmlsi=vI3QUgSk9IlE208g
@@mohammedzaidh123 Saying the Kalima does not mean you are a muslim. It is in the works. If you say "There is no god worthy of worship but Allah" yet you keep calling dead people for help, then you don't believe this Kalima. If you say "Muhammad is the messenger of Allah" yet you curse and cal his companions murtadeen, then you don't believe this Kalima.
@@_ibnmuhammad agreed. They even considers Ali and Hussain superior to Prophet
Iam A sunni from Kenya, but I can confidently say shias have more truth than Sunnis
Backing you from Uganda. And i like to know do we read different Qurans
@@Mzee-z5fwe have the same Quran,who is displaying hate?the sheikh ?why the don’t tell about Mr Abu Bakr went to saqifa to be elected as khalifa,lady Aisha rode on a camel to fight Ali,remember sheikh according to Quran the mayority of people is lost,so mayority doesn’t make you right, the genocide in Palestina have exposed the mayority of Sunnis ,particularly those sheikh who have a big tongue to attack the shias but bite their tongue in the face of the oppessors and taguts,,😂
With all due respect, the Sheikh’s analysis of the Shia school is totally incorrect. Anyone seeking a well informed answer should do their own research and not take this explanation as truth.
1. The Shia believe in the absolute necessity of adhering to the sunnah. The difference of opinion lies in what the sunnah constitutes and how to access it. For the Shia, they rely more heavily on the prophetic household (Ahlulbayt) as the most reliable avenue to the sunnah. The Hadith of the “Two weighty things” (Hadith althaqlayn contextualises this).
2. The Shia believe in the exactly the same Quran, and believe that it remains unadulterated and protected. Anybody claiming otherwise is a liar and anyone who believes the Quran is deficient has committed kufr.
3. The Shia do not have a blanket anti-sahaba policy. Rather, they assign differing levels of reverence and respect to the sahaba based on their merit. For example, they love the likes of Ammar Ibn Yasir RA, Abu Dharr Alghifari RA, Salman RA, Jabir AlAnsari RA etc and only have reservations against the sahaba who demonstrated animosity towards the Ahlulbayt AS. Mu’awiyah was technically a sahabi, but waged war again Imam Ali Ibn Abi Talib during his caliphate - that’s a big deal. Ayesha RA is actually respected by the mainstream Shia, but criticised for her recalcitrance and raising an army to fight Imam Ali AS during his caliphate.
4. It’s not fair to categorise all members of the Shia School as being a single ideology. The mainstream majority are moderate, respectful and advocates of Islamic unity. Whereas there is a vocal minority within the group that gets all the attention and they are typically the ones engaging in acts of extremism, cursing etc and cannot be considered orthodox or mainstream.
5. The Shia school is built on the Hadith of Ghadeer Khumm (cited in Sahih Muslim and others) where the prophet SAW raised the hand of Ali AS in front of the Muslim pilgrims returning from Hajj and declared “To whomever I am a MAWLA, then ALI is their MAWLA”. Shias and Sunnis disagree on what the term MAWLA means in this context: friend or master?
6. The Shia school in a nutshell, is the belief that the completed and perfected religion of Allah (Al-Islam) is to be represented by designated members of the Prophetic household (The Imams of Ahlulbayt) after the demise of the Prophet SAW. This aligns with the Hadith of the two weighty things I mentioned earlier “I leave behind the Quran and my ahlulbayt…”. This is in contrast to accepting the caliph Abu Bakr that was elected at the secret meeting at Saqifa whilst Ali Ibn Abi Talib AS was occupied with the burial rituals of the prophet SAW. And the rest is history..
7. Perhaps I can dedicate another comment another time about the significance of the battle of Karbala and why the martyrdom of AlHussain AS orchestrated by the hands of the ummayids was so tragic, but also why is served as a wake-up call to galvanise the ummah that had drifted so far away from the sunnah of his grandfather the Prophet SAW. This battle exposed the hypocrisy and the ulterior motives of the Ummayid dynasty. Namely Yazid and his father Mu’awiyah ( who btw violated the treaty he signed with Imam Al-Hassan AS).
8. The Shia get their fiqh (jurisprudence) from Imam Jafar AlSadiq (the teacher of Imam Abu Hanifa amongst others).
9. If you actually want to know a credible Sunni stance on the Shia school I suggest you look up the Fatwa issued by Shaikh Mahmood Shaltoot in 1959 (the head of Al-Azhar at the time) where he reiterated the legitimacy of the Shia school.
May Allah (swt) guide us all Ameen.
Alhamdullilah
He have no Idea about Shia. He get some attitude of some people and say that is all of shia . Same attitude anti islams have , they say look at isis so Islam is isis .
shia is misguided and a cult
did Muhammad saw hate the companions? He clearly states that you should follow what he did but what the shias did is after his death
@@obscurifyed shia fallow teaching of prophet Muhammad (pbuh) also . You have lack of information about shias .
@@obscurifyed Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said whoever angers Fatima (SA), has angered me, so in fact, his companions did anger him.
@@obscurifyed *Shiaa ( the real nawasib) believe Fatima "RadiAllahu Anha" insulted Ali "RadiAllahu Anhu" and gets angry at him three times*
These are three different stories among Shiaa books regarding Fatimah's anger towards Ali (bearing in mind that shias believe Ali and Fatimah are infallible and incapable of committing any sin or mistake, like the angels):
These are signs of the last hour
I am very sorry to say this I am sunni living with shia for more than 40 years and I have never ever heard once someone saying that our coran is different than theirs or that the sunni are kafer the only thing that comes up most of the time is that they believe that ahl lul beit where closer to our prophet sas than the companions of the prophet sas so please don't say things that are not true
They don't express their thoughts..
It's called Taqiya. Research the term
Taqqiyah
If the sheikh said it then he’s right
Before the Jew Abdullah ibn Saba created the Shia sect there were no Sunnis it was only Muslims, when Shias came they named these Muslims simply as Sunnis. For ones I agree with this sheikh, they are not Muslims
For once??? What are you on...Shaikh is always on point
No Shia knows who that mf Abdullah Ibn Saba? he's a mere myth. Read all our books if you can. You don't see his name even once
It's you who pray like Jews, fast on ashura like jews. Curse be upon Ibn Saba if he ever existed and upon the liars
I don’t agree with the sheikh on many points, only because he studied the Quran and Sunnah doesn’t mean he understands them, I listen to Allah and prophet peace be upon him. If you want to make this sheikh your mentor you do it.
@@sabdulrahmanshaikh1621 He literrally said "adore" towards other than Allah? Check the definition (the first and most popular(/used) meaning of the word and tell me wether you "adore" other than Allah.
Edit (for reference: 1:40)
@@AbuBakrAlKamardi-cg9jqhe himself said that he speaks 99% of the time from the most authentic scholar opinions and not himself
There is another difference.
The Shia have a spine. Sunni leaders watch on with hopelessness accetance.
The Sunni leaders are spineless.
Sunni and Shia need to unite. Some how, some way.
Allahu Akbar.
Has the situation in Palestine improved since Iran's involvement? Has the quality of life of thr Palestinians improved? Why not? Aren't the Shia helping?
Shia testify shahada, pray salah, fast
Ramadan, pay zakat, perform hajj to Mecca, believe in Allah, his angels, prophets, messengers, his scriptures, qadr and the day of judgement.
Yet somehow we are not muslims??
Takfiri culture on full display. How many shekels did they pay you to say that sheikh?
All from the nasibi school of hatred.
Your so called testifying is very twisted, if you're truly a shia you will know the shahada they do is not like what prophet Muhammed peace be upon him taught us , the same with prayer fasting and many other things they twist and add to the religion while even cursing the best of the people who are the companions of the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him which Allah and His messenger warned against those who say bad things about the companions specially the first Khalifa Abu bakr may Allah be pleased with him which has one of the highest status among the companions on the day of judgment and if the Prophet Muhammad would have taken a friend in this world it would be him as He said during his life time......
believe his prophets? and not follow the last prophet Muahmmad SAW? believe Allah, but also treat humans like gods? like using labbayka when refering to humans, pray? and make adan and wudu and even prayer different than what our prophet taught us?
And beleive in scriptures???. You reject the scripture that tells muhajirun and ansars are all heaven bound
How can they believe in the scriptures, specifically in the Qur'an, when they say the Qur'an is distorted?
@@brightnessunknown9605 we believe and follow what Prophet Muhammad saws has taught us. Why do we follow your readings? What makes the way you pray right? We have our own readings, you have yours. By that logic, you people also don't follow Islam the way Prophet did. we can say that too and takfir you on the basis of that. You all say the parents of holy prophet saws and his uncle are in hellfire we still dont make takfir of you. Why do you all do that? even when your books sa not to do that
Uthman Ibn Affan became caliphate and was murdered by (misguided) muslims because they didn’t like how he “ruled”- (they wanted revenge on those who murdered Umar RA and he refused) he said “By God, if you kill me you will never again have love for one another, nor will you ever pray together again, nor will you be ever united in fighting an enemy.” They eventually killed him. Such a shame the level of misguidance that came about after the prophet SAW death between the muslims regarding the Caliphates.
The hatred towards shias are evident in your speech. Sheikh please do your research on authentic shias
Shia’s have a strong hatred to most of the companions which is not permissible. Allah is pleased with the companions and has prepared Jannah for all of the companions.وَٱلسَّـٰبِقُونَ ٱلۡأَوَّلُونَ مِنَ ٱلۡمُهَـٰجِرِینَ وَٱلۡأَنصَارِ وَٱلَّذِینَ ٱتَّبَعُوهُم بِإِحۡسَـٰنࣲ رَّضِیَ ٱللَّهُ عَنۡهُمۡ وَرَضُوا۟ عَنۡهُ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمۡ جَنَّـٰتࣲ تَجۡرِی تَحۡتَهَا ٱلۡأَنۡهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِینَ فِیهَاۤ أَبَدࣰاۚ ذَ ٰلِكَ ٱلۡفَوۡزُ ٱلۡعَظِیمُ﴿ ١٠٠ ﴾ • Dr. Mustafa Khattab: As for the foremost-the first of the Emigrants[[ i.e., the early Muslims who emigrated from Mecca to Medina, known as Al-Muhâjirûn.]] and the Helpers[[ i.e., those from Medina, known as Al-Anṣâr, who accepted Islam and sheltered Muslim emigrants from Mecca. ]]-and those who follow them in goodness, Allah is pleased with them and they are pleased with Him. And He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow, to stay there for ever and ever. That is the ultimate triumph. At-Tawbah, Ayah 100.
Sure maybe he was little harsh but it was factual. Shia’s are not real/full Muslims
@@pUbErtYy_49 brother I come from a Shia background but as I have studied deen myself I have come to know that real ahle sunnah is authentic as per my knowledge, I may be wrong or may not be may ALLAH guide us all to Haq ( Truth ). But as for the Shias, i know Shias who respect the sahabas r.a and that includes ( Abu bakr, Umar, uthman, and other sahabas r.a ) but you just can't blindly say that shias are Kaffir.
The mainstream media only shows the harsh face of the Shias, and vice versa.
@@Viralshow567 Akhi I have the same background in the first place, the thing is the word Shia is almost always associated with ithna ashariyah (twelves). Their doctrines are full of Kur and Shirk, like catholics. Yes there are people ascribing themselves to catholic faith, but don't believe in the trinity etc.
Also the Sheikh seems to know a good portion, since he knew their books and scholars. But that's only about ithna ashariyah.
Very few Muslims know about Zaydiyah and Mansuriyah. And even in Yemen Huuti got to close to Twelverism.
So Zaydis are getting as irrelevant as Mansuriyah. So its not 100% correct to say all Shia are Kupfer, but all believing Ithna Ashariyah are. And this is the only cult known for the name Shia in probably some years.
@@Viralshow567 if they cant beleive Quran 100 percent then they are kaffir, but majority of shais are confused that dont know about there own books of i dont know may be 12 imams, there so much messed up things.
If they know about there books and doesnt accept the quran 100 percent then they are not muslims.
if they are confused i cant blame them
Make Dua for my father and my mother passed away thanks
allah yarham omak ya habibi
Prophet was not Sunni either, the word or sect "Sunni" originated 100 years after the demise of Rasul Allah (S.A.W.W.).
Nothing but those who follow the Sunnah of Mohammad Salalah hi wasallam is directly comes under sunni. At the time of Mohammad sws there was no sect like suuni or Shia.
The word for sect in Arabic is shia, not sunni. Sunni means someone who follows a sunnah i.e., a way of life.
@@danalidahraj Of course the Prophet was not a sunni, because a sunni is the one who follows the SUNNAH of the Prophet.
@@Free_Falastin2024And Shia means follower… z
@@suggondees4882 Sunni is considered a sect in Islam, so this kinda sounds like an excuse.
All of them are innovations, true Islam has nothing to do with both, just follow the Qur'an and I am 100% sure you'll forever be guided.
Hanbali Madhab is closest to original Islam
don't make comments like those brother, you will only creat fithna and attract hatred. All madhabs have their pros and cons. We say that Hanbali Madhab is one of the best. May Allah SWT guide as all. Ameen
Hanafi Madhab is to much dependent on iztijad or personal reasoning but Hanbali Madhab is judt direct transliteration of The Quran And The sunnah
@@Hasanaljadid You have no right to say that. Even Al Allamah Sheikh Saleh al Fawzan calls out anyone who slanders Imam Abu Hanifa and his madhhab. Imam Abu Hanifah is our imam. رحمه الله رحمة واسعة
Alhamdulillah the day i entered islam took my Shahada im muslim i don't know about them
Sheikh Shias are not Kaffir. Astaghfirullah
Shia’s have a strong hatred to most of the companions which is not permissible. Allah is pleased with the companions and has prepared Jannah for all of the companions.وَٱلسَّـٰبِقُونَ ٱلۡأَوَّلُونَ مِنَ ٱلۡمُهَـٰجِرِینَ وَٱلۡأَنصَارِ وَٱلَّذِینَ ٱتَّبَعُوهُم بِإِحۡسَـٰنࣲ رَّضِیَ ٱللَّهُ عَنۡهُمۡ وَرَضُوا۟ عَنۡهُ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمۡ جَنَّـٰتࣲ تَجۡرِی تَحۡتَهَا ٱلۡأَنۡهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِینَ فِیهَاۤ أَبَدࣰاۚ ذَ ٰلِكَ ٱلۡفَوۡزُ ٱلۡعَظِیمُ﴿ ١٠٠ ﴾ • Dr. Mustafa Khattab: As for the foremost-the first of the Emigrants[[ i.e., the early Muslims who emigrated from Mecca to Medina, known as Al-Muhâjirûn.]] and the Helpers[[ i.e., those from Medina, known as Al-Anṣâr, who accepted Islam and sheltered Muslim emigrants from Mecca. ]]-and those who follow them in goodness, Allah is pleased with them and they are pleased with Him. And He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow, to stay there for ever and ever. That is the ultimate triumph. At-Tawbah, Ayah 100.
This is just 1 reason for why Shia’s are not considered full/real Muslims
Anyone who claims Quran is not perfect is a kafir.
@@pUbErtYy_49 You believe Abu Talib and parents of the Holy Prophet saws are in hellfire. should i call you a kafir too now??
Jazakallahu Khairan sheikh may Allah SWT reward you abundantly goodness and grant you more knowledge and wisdom ameen the companion of the prophet Muhammad SALLALLAHU ALAYHI WASALLAM PBUH his family and his companion they sacrifice their life for the Deen so we need to appreciate them not to insults them may Allah SWT protect us from the Shia allahumma ameen jazakallahu Khairan sheikh
Sheikh we love you
Why do we call ourselves Sunnis, if Allah calls us Muslims, aren't we also a sect or if we call ourselves Salafists? I am a Muslim, Alhamdulliah, not a Sunni, not a Shia. I am a Muslim who follows the Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet s.a.s. follows
There's no separation in Deen as Shia or Sunni. it's all bogus politically motivated , economically motivated , nothing to do with the ways of the Deen.
Quran is same, qibla is same, prophet is same, but sunni beieve in sahaba's and Shia believe in Imam's after prohet Muhammad (saww)
Not imam a Family Ahlul Bait
@@syedreza313 yeah but imam 12 is the main Leader.
@@nhafa121 That' was set in your mind by your evil Sheikh... Now Prophet Muhammad(saww) raised the hand of Imam Ali(a.s) in Ghadirr khumm(pond) in front of thousands of people's...
@@nhafa121 Also Imam Ali(a.s) ruled around 4 year 9 month.
@@Mohammed523 The Persians (modern-day Iran) were actually Sunni until The Safavid Empire wanted something different they wanted their own community Ismāil the first began to adopt Shiasim and kil1ed Sunnis and actively persecuted them through tribal allies of the Shah. His armies also destroyed several important Sunni sites, including the tombs of Abū Ḥanīfa and Abdul-Qadir Gilani. The Safavids even expelled the family of Gilani from Mesopotamia. He forcefully converted Sunnis to Shiaiasm. Ismail the first announced himself as the Mehdi and the first Imam. He killed Sunnis for not praying like Shia. The first person to bring Shiaism into existence was ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’ was a Jew who pretended to be Muslim. He was originally from Yemen, and travelled to spread his fitnah (turmoil) in the Hijaz, then Basra and Kufah. He went to Damascus during the caliphate of ‘Uthmaan ibn ‘Affaan (may Allah be pleased with him) and was expelled by its people, then he went to Egypt and started to openly promote his bid‘ah (innovation). Abudllah ibn Saba claimed that Ali ra was a divine and said there are 12 Imams. " The first one to introduce the innovated view that ‘Ali was infallible and that he should have been the caliph on the basis of religious texts was the leader of these hypocrites, ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’, who was originally Jewish, then pretended to be Muslim and aimed to corrupt the Islamic religion as Paul had corrupted the Christian religion."
The view that the Jew ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’ was the founder of the Raafidi sect and that he established it in an effort to conspire against the Muslims and widen divisions among them, is a valid opinion that carries weight, with which the books of history and the study of sects and groups are filled, and it is not even denied by the Raafidis themselves.
With regard to the attempt of some of them to deny the existence of ‘Abdullah ibn Saba’, that is pure propaganda by means of which they are trying to refute what has become widely known among their opponents of the fact that this Jew was the founder of their madhhab.
The Dajjal would be followed by seventy thousand Jews of Isfahan wearing Persian shawls. (Sahih Muslim 2944).
It is highly possible that Dajjal would be a shia. The shia have levels I know there are some low-level Shias who don't know much of anything layman and they are shia because their parents are shia. If you study Shiaism how it came into existence and how it persecuted sunni Persians and forced them to convert to Shiasim which is haram in Islam. The only way is to follow the Quran and Sunnah. They started as a power-hungry false madhab and will continue that way.
According to all Shia sects, when Allah was revealing verses 33:6, 9:100, 48:29, and 59:8-9, Allah did not know in advance that Aisha (r.a.) would battle against Ali (r.a.) or that many companions would become disbelievers or hypocrites. That is why, they argue, Allah did not exclude them from these verses. Therefore, they have no doubts that these companions should be considered hypocrites. Astagfirullah
I can prove from the books of the Rafidha that Bibi Aisha (ra) is in Janna and that Jaffar assadiq (who is actually a Sunni scholar) commited sins
And Al-Muttaqûn will be far removed from it (Hell). He who spends his wealth for increase in self-purification, And who has (in mind) no favour from anyone to be paid back, Except to seek the Countenance of his Lord, the Most High. He surely will be pleased (when he enters Paradise).
[Surah al-Layl 92:17-21]
According to Ahlus-Sunnah, ٱلْأَتْقَى refers to Abu Bakr and was revealed regarding him whereas the Shi'a say this refers to Ali. There is no third Hadith.
Now for some context:
This is a Makki surah, and Ali during this time was poor, so he did not have wealth to spend.
During the time of Makkah, the Prophet took Ali into his home, so he did have a dunyawi favor from the Prophet which could be paid back, whereas Abu Bakr had no dunyawi favor from the Prophet but rather only the favor of deen.
How does Allah describe الأتقى here? they give their wealth to purify themself & they don't have a favor from anyone to be paid back
So how would this ayah fit for Ali, who was not wealthy during this time & had a wordly favor from Rasoolullah that could be paid back?
And if it does not fit for Ali, the only other option would be Abu Bakr- Allah would be describing him with Taqwa and a promise to save him for Hellfire
@@Angelo-Rules is English your 2nd language?
@@Shiyam-eh3djyes
@@Angelo-Rules you didn’t understand of my comment bro
If you study deeply you will find Shia and Sikh's are almost the same!
"When we see them"😂
Wish we could lol
❤❤❤correct
MUSLIM✔️
there is no difference between Quran in Shia and Quran in Sunni
Very important to note that sheikh isn’t doing takfir on the individual shia person that you might know. Maybe he was just born into it and doesn’t know anything about shiaism.
Only if he tells you all the things sheikh counted, then yeah he has a big problem lol
They piss there pants hearing the name of Muawiya R.A ❤
Muawiya L.A
It is important to note, however, that the average Shia does not know what their sect respresents; They are not aware of the shirk and kufr their ullama have written. I believe the sheikh was talking about the knowledgeable Shia and not the laymen. Lastly, it is not upon us to give takfir. The sheikh was right in what he said but we cannot go up to an individual and call them a kafir just because they are Shia, because we do not know the extent of their knowledge and practice. I advise you to fear Allah regarding this.
This sheikh wow... He says Shia are alright in one video and calls them kafir in another. Very well educated sheikh but speaks nonsense when his biases flare up...
Oufffff unbelievable the amount of misinformation this guy is spreading is scary and he is asking a 110$ for a half-hour consultation session and asking for people to donate to others who cannot afford it just HILARIOUS
Im revert Muslim Alhamdulillah
😅 Who is shia now????
Allahummabarik, don't worry about them they are people who call themselves Muslim but majority of them have beliefs and do things that take them out of Islam
@@irtazza133 who are you?? Allah or His messenger saws? You don't have the right to take someone out of the fold of Islam
@@fatima.x11SIMPLY SHIA ARR NOT MUSLIMS THEY ARE KAFIRS PRETENDING TO BE MUSLIMS... THEY ABUSE THE GREAT COMPANIONS OF THE PROPHET AND HIS WIVES..THEY PRAY DIFFERENT. THEY ARE ALWAYS OPPOSITE FROM THE TEACHINGS OF THE PROPHET. THEY ARE DEVILS CREATING CONTROVERSIAL TO DIVIDE THE MUSLIM UMMAH
@@fatima.x11 Yes, if it's clear then they're kuffar.. They believe Quran is corrupted.. they call the wife of the prophet a pros*itute.. Is that a muslim to you? They say Ali and Hassan and Hussien are the ones who created everything.. They say Ali is the one who decides who go to jannah and who go to jahnnam... is this some kind of a joke? how do you call these muslims?
Honeslty, if a Muslim doesn't follow the prophet (pbuh) then I dunno what they're doing... like bruh. Do you not know the shahada/first pillar of islam???
Sheikh , Kindly don't mix lies with reality !
Shia have same Quraan as we do.
Their translation is different and filled with lies
@@MDShadman-jt3tz May ALLAH azawajal bless Hidayah to the Munafiqs like you who are hell bent on destroying UMMAH from within.
Muslims have been attacked, lets stop discussing our differences. It's time to unite. This case has been there for ages why now?
@@ibrahimkassim8289 This Ummah will not stand without Tawheed. Palestine will never be free without Tawheed. So do not say stop discussing about this things.
This is the stance one takes when he has but surface level knowledge
Which study is haram tell about this full information sheikh
All sects are haram. These people would not have a job if there wasn't a sunni or shia sect. The Quran is enough: Indeed, you ˹O Prophet˺ are not responsible whatsoever for those who have divided their faith and split into sects. Their judgment rests only with Allah. And He will inform them of what they used to do. Q6:159
Respected Maulana, I appreciate your dedication to sharing knowledge. However, I would like to clarify that information you shared about Shia community to your followers in this video is not at all accurate.
The primary difference between Shia and Sunni Muslims lies in their belief regarding leadership after the Prophet Muhammad's death.
Shia Muslims believe in the concept of Imamat, which holds that the leadership should remain within the Prophet's family, specifically through his son-in-law Ali and his descendants.
Sunni Muslims, on the other hand, follow the principle of Khilafat, which emphasizes the selection of leaders through consensus and election.
This fundamental difference in belief has shaped the theological, juridical, and cultural practices of both traditions.
I have a question: What defines a Muslim? Do Shias believe in Allah and the Prophet (peace be upon him)? Do they follow the five pillars of Islam? If the answers are yes, then why are some sheikhs claiming they aren’t Muslims? This divide between Shia and Sunni has always been rooted in politics, but it’s becoming more harmful when our religious leaders fuel hatred instead of fostering unity.
We should guide others to the right path through dialogue and diplomacy, not division. Look at what’s happening in the Arab world-aren’t we learning anything from this? Let’s stop the hatred.
@@suallaribrahim3843Abu Bakr is promised paradise. Shias claim he is Kafir. Some even claim that he was a hypocrite which is worse.
We know from ahadith that when you takfir your brother, the takfir must be true of one of you.
if Shias are Muslim, I don't see why Qadianis can't be Muslim as well
Sheikh What do the men who are in a state of ritual impurity do in Aisha's house?
Who killed husain, who killed fatima ,only sunnis were behind these killings
The Kufan Shia themselves acknowledged that they were the ones who killed Sayyidina Husain. This group, who claimed responsibility for killing Sayyidina Husain, later emerged as the “At-Tawwabun” faction, claiming to regret their actions. As an act of repentance, they killed one another, similar to what the Jews did as an expression of repentance to Allah for the sin of worshipping the golden calf after Prophet Musa ascended to Mount Sinai.
The blood tears shed by the “At-Tawwabun” faction remain vividly visible in the pages of history and have not been erased, despite countless attempts to do so.
The confession of the Shia who killed Sayyidina Husain has been immortalized by Shia scholars who are pillars of their faith, such as Baqir Majlisi, Nurullah Shustri, and others, in their respective books. Baqir Majlisi wrote:
“A group of people from Kufah were startled by a mysterious voice. They said, ‘By God! What we have done has never been done by anyone else. We killed the "Leader of the Youth of Paradise" because of Ibn Ziyad, that illegitimate son.’ There, they pledged allegiance to rebel against Ibn Ziyad, but it was of no use.” (Jilaau Al'Uyun, p. 430)
Qadhi Nurullah Shustri also wrote in his book Majalisu Al'Mu'minin that after a long time (approximately 4 or 5 years) following the killing of Sayyidina Husain, the leaders of the Shia gathered their followers and said, "We invited Sayyidina Husain, pledging our allegiance to him, but then we betrayed him by killing him. Our sin is so great that it can only be forgiven by killing one another.” Thus, a large group of Shia gathered by the Euphrates River, reciting the verse which means, “So repent to your Creator and kill yourselves. That is better for you in the sight of your Creator.” (Al-Baqarah: 54). Then they slaughtered one another. This group became known in Islamic history as the “At-Tawwabun.”
Sayyidina Husain’s own words, recorded in history before he was killed, were directed at the Kufan Shia who were ready to fight him:
“O people of Kufah! May you be cursed just as your evil intentions have been cursed. O deceitful, oppressive, and treacherous people! You invited us to defend you in your time of hardship, but when we came to lead and protect you, trusting in you, you now unsheathe your swords of vengeance against us and assist our enemies in fighting us.” (Jilaau Al’Uyun, p. 391).
He also said to the Shia:
“Woe to you! How could you unsheathe the swords of your vengeance without any enmity or conflict between you and us? Why are you so eager to kill the Ahlul Bayt without any cause?” (Ibid).
Finally, he invoked a curse upon the Shia who were about to engage in battle with him:
“O Allah! Withhold the blessings of the earth from them and scatter them. Make the hearts of their rulers despise them, for they invited us under the pretense of defending us, but now they unsheathe their swords of vengeance against us.” (Ibid).
He is also recorded to have cursed them further, saying:
“Woe to you! God will avenge me in this world and the hereafter... You will punish yourselves by striking your own bodies with swords, and your faces will be stained with your own blood. You will not prosper in this world, and you will never attain your desires. When you die, the torment of God will await you in the hereafter. You will suffer the punishment reserved for the most wicked disbelievers.” (Mulla Baqir Majlisi, Jilaau Al’Uyun, p. 409).
As a sunni I condemn any kind of hatred and lie against shias.
Please don't fall into zionist's tricks. We are all muslims, and that's the most important. Hate against another muslims is not what helps for the ummah, it helps only for zionists.
@@DavidRobertJohns What will you do if someone cursed your mother?
@@_ibnmuhammad Allah is the greatest, none of any curses can do anything if Allah is protecting you and your family.
But I understand your point, I know that it's not easy for shias because a lot of sunnis who are brainwashed by wahhabi-zionist influence are constantly cursing them.
I feel sorry for them when some sunnis say that they will burn in hell and these speeches. As a sunni I don't claim these people.
The Quran forbids hatred against another muslims.
That's why those self-proclaimed sheykhs who are spreading hatred against another muslims are obviously zionist-backed. Hence that's Israel's aim. They cannot destroy the ummah, so they use their intelligence services to spread hatred inside the ummah, to destroy it from inside.
But the muslims who follow Allah and not the bribed propagandists are not fooled to these tricks.
@@DavidRobertJohns No one is even talking about zionist and israel here. What are you on about?
@@_ibnmuhammad Then please answer to the question that whom does it help to make hatred inside the ummah and making muslims hatred against each other?
@@DavidRobertJohns This isn't a hatred. Calling someone of their deviance is not hatred. Calling people into the guidance is not hatred. It is actually a mercy for them. Don't you want your brothers to be with you in the paradise Allah had prepared for you? If yes, then engage in da'wah, call them to the correct path of your Prophet ﷺ If no, then just let them curse the Mothers of the believers, call the companions of your prophet as hypocrites and disbelievers.
Allah said HE WILL PROTECT THE QURAN, which means any altered version of The Quran won't be established in this world. If you don't believe in Allah's words then I think you are not a Muslim.
Astagfiruulah shaykh, The Prophet Muhammad S.A.W Is Muslim
He is a Wahhabi
All Sunnis love Sahaba and hate shias.
You don't need to be a Wahabi.
You can be Deobandi, you can be Ashari
Okay now you're just making stuff up. Shias don't say there are different versions of the Quran. This is an absolute lie. You should debate a Shia Imam.
There are NO difference between Sunnah and Shia. Please be an agent of unifications NOT fragmentations. As long as a Muslim believe in Quran and Sunnah, then case closed .... HE IS MUSLIM AS GOOD AS YOU AND ME. Leave judgment to GOD not to you or other humans. PLEASE!!!!