No one can beat the original "HYAAA". And when in the hollows the original had a voice line that said "Why didn't you buy any snacks?!" It showed a side of Soukaku that let you know she was an oni and you didn't want to make her angry. I know they'll never hire the old VA but whereever she is she has left a deep void in my heart that she's no longer Soukaku's voice
1.3 clearly got more time to try & recapture the feeling of 1.0 while also trying to put their own spin on it. Though I will forever miss 1.0, I welcome 1.3 soukaku Istg if we get a 1.4 soukaku I will lose my mind
It's clear that 1.0 had most time to perfect it. 1.1 was rushed and resulted in very different feel (imo, it was hurt by unintended lack of energy, especially in the ultimate) 1.3 seems to try to return to 1.0 feel, imo does not quite reach but is mostly better than 1.1, however I will miss "is food included" from 1.1, that was the perfect read for that line, imo.
It kinda sounds like they just had the new VA re record the lines so they were more in line with what the original VA did (because there were complaints?) but honestly I have a hard time telling the difference between them with just battle lines.
@@johncarlofernandez2698 the VAs are striking because the company hoyo uses for a lot of their voice casting is saying they are going to use AI of the VAs they hire, which is terrible. the VAs are right in boycotting this, they're not doing it specifically TO genshin/zzz etc, but the casting company.
it would appear with Soukaku, her childlike character direction wasn't really solidified until 1.3. Her speaking lines for 1.1 doesn't really give off a youthful innocence vibe and more of a teenager type deal. They clearly leaned very heavily into her being a kid mentally, what with all her doodles in the section 6 office space and the ABCs books, so i guess changing her voice again makes sense. Though i have no idea why they didn't simply get the 1.1 voice actress to redo the lines with the new direction.
@former_dough Rules are made to be broken ⚾️✨. 1.3 is my favorite because she's just so darn cute, I played 1.3 story and I love how the new VA delivered her lines in the cutscenes
That was easily my favorite line from the 1.1 voice. She did that one really well. It was comparable to my favorite line from 1.0 and 1.3, which is the “Here we GO!”
Yeah I got too used to 1.1's voice lines. 1.0 and 1.3 feel very similar, but I feel like 1.1 just captures that Oni gremlin-snack-fiend vibe so well. Especially in the Hollow Zero levels where she's constantly asking about snacks. The new 1.3 voice sounds like a bit like Ash but it's also softer in parts and feels like off kilter compared to the rest of the voices, where those in your 3-man cell or even compared to the Virtual Vengeance storyline. I don't know what HoYoverse were thinking with this one.
That kinda low voice for "is food included >ω>" is really nice, 1.1 got that right. But the 1.1 HYAH was so so bad, it had no feeling of impact. If by 1.4 they change her va AGAIN i hope they take the best out of all three versions
Miss 1.0 soukaku but 1.3 soukaku is a close match trying to get that 1.0 energy and i can respect it and also.. hungy!!! The yanagi soukaku is really adorable
Clearly Soukaku is ready (to change voice actress) xD Kinda love the 2nd one tho, shame... How many times do we have to see the voice actress get changed -old man- Hoyo!! 😭🤣🤣
While 1.3 is not exactly the same as 1.0, it comes very close to it. I don’t play soukaku often so if there was no version 1.1 I would’ve never noticed the change. The VA did a fantastic job
New voice sounds better than the 2nd one, but still pales in comparison to the OG, I'm quite happy they decided to steer the voice acting direction closer to the original one.
1.0 I still personally feel is the best, but can't fault Hoyo for kicking the VA to the curb. 1.3 is definitely an improvement over 1.2 though, so I'm happy.
"There's conflicting reports that this oni changes her voice about every month or so to keep people guessing her persona, very cunning, we'll have to keep an eye on this one." -Soukaku; initial impressions
Guys go and listen to the lady at the music store her voice actor was changed too, sounds like it. The original VA was a perfect fit for the character.
All this told me is that I don't know what I had til I lost it. Loved 1.0's Voice. Despised 1.1's but came to love it as it's own voice. And now 1.3 is just. Yeah I shoulda never said in my Survey to change Soukaku's Voice back cuz now it won't come back even MORE now.
![[2.6] Polka Kakamond is Dictating the Future - Honkai: Star Rail Lore & Theory](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mOSKBH_S9-I/mqdefault.jpg)
cant wait for her new voice in 1.4
💀
i won't even be surprised
🤣🤣🤣
For real, at this point it should just be a running gag.
@@RealTyrakIGuess 😂
1.0: Full
1.1: Hungry
1.3: Fed by Yanagi
What’s next, 1.4 on a diet?
So glad they removed the "time to EEEEEEEEEEE" though, they'll get there one day.
No one can beat the original "HYAAA". And when in the hollows the original had a voice line that said "Why didn't you buy any snacks?!" It showed a side of Soukaku that let you know she was an oni and you didn't want to make her angry. I know they'll never hire the old VA but whereever she is she has left a deep void in my heart that she's no longer Soukaku's voice
Why was is changed though???
If only she didn't talk trash to her own work company, we'd still have the 1.0 voice.
Yeah it was fun to hear maybe once or twice. But after a while... Oh god can you shut up and stop screaming into my ears about those damn snacks
@@tibbers_hastur Her VA isn't Courtney Lin, the pitch is too different
In the Chinese dub Caesar and Lycaon have comparable shouts
Damn puberty is hitting soukaku differently
other way around puberty
I miss the original HYAH 😔
Bro it's made my ear tingling sonetime😅😅
True. I played her all the time then. Now I barely look at her.
Yeah the 1.0 ult voice sounds so fit and intense to battle
that i do. Too
It matched the intensity of the attack.
come on bruh the second one was even starting to grow on me
I’m not acoustic but they’re making too many changes 😢
Same
For real like stick with it bro omfg
Naw nothing beating the first VA
I said the same shit when I opened the game and did my dailies with her then I was like "why tf so they keep doing this shit"
I welcome this change but I still miss 1.0 “Hyah!” There was power in it.
1.3 clearly got more time to try & recapture the feeling of 1.0 while also trying to put their own spin on it. Though I will forever miss 1.0, I welcome 1.3 soukaku
Istg if we get a 1.4 soukaku I will lose my mind
Every patch gets a new soukaku va? Can't wait for an Ojou-sama take for her!
@@subscriber101ablethat's when soukaku steps up and leads the oni clan 😊
@@subscriber101able Now that you've said that, part of me WANTS them to change the VA every patch.
Nah it gotta happen on 1.5 since odd numbers 🤣
It's clear that 1.0 had most time to perfect it.
1.1 was rushed and resulted in very different feel (imo, it was hurt by unintended lack of energy, especially in the ultimate)
1.3 seems to try to return to 1.0 feel, imo does not quite reach but is mostly better than 1.1, however I will miss "is food included" from 1.1, that was the perfect read for that line, imo.
um... yes... wow... my thoughts have been made words by you. Thank you.
I was thinking the same thing. 1.0 lines just feels *right.*
I agree with this, 1.0 was perfect but 1.3 is closer at least.
Am I the only one who likes 1.3 least?
1.1 was perfect. Well, not perfect but the best
I'm glad they tried (?) to imitate 1.0 but the HYAH just is still lacking. (My opinion)
I agre and I don't mean to sound mean to the actress of the 1.3 soukaku but it sounds like the "HIYAH" from 1.0 but neutered 😅
Im glad im partially def cuz 1.0 and 1.3 sound very similar. Im content 😊
Hi......YAAAAAAH 👹👹👹
Then Ellen comes in for the kill with the damage buff 😈
I still reeaalllyy miss some 1.0 lines, like the burst yell. But 1.3 has that raspy tomboy voice and it suits her :)
spot the genshin player
At least theyre closer to the 1.0 "Hyaah!"
It kinda sounds like they just had the new VA re record the lines so they were more in line with what the original VA did (because there were complaints?) but honestly I have a hard time telling the difference between them with just battle lines.
The scream at the end of the ultimate for v1.0 just HITS DIFFERENT, I will never not miss it
1.3 sounds like an attempt to bring back her 1.0 voice
Nothing can beat 1.0 "HYAH!"
Saaame!!!
I miss her 1.0 voice so much! She was so energetic😢 why did they changed her😔
I think the first VA was part of the hoyo boycot so they dropped them
@@jtwhat3004 i knew it! this whole thing sucks ngl😭
wait would va going against the companies that hire them just because some fans are mad?@@jtwhat3004
@@jtwhat3004damn. At least Hoyo isn't letting this one slide unlike Genshin.
@@johncarlofernandez2698 the VAs are striking because the company hoyo uses for a lot of their voice casting is saying they are going to use AI of the VAs they hire, which is terrible. the VAs are right in boycotting this, they're not doing it specifically TO genshin/zzz etc, but the casting company.
I MISS THE “HYA” FROM THE V1.0 ULTIMATE IT SOUNDED SO COOL😭
it would appear with Soukaku, her childlike character direction wasn't really solidified until 1.3. Her speaking lines for 1.1 doesn't really give off a youthful innocence vibe and more of a teenager type deal. They clearly leaned very heavily into her being a kid mentally, what with all her doodles in the section 6 office space and the ABCs books, so i guess changing her voice again makes sense.
Though i have no idea why they didn't simply get the 1.1 voice actress to redo the lines with the new direction.
1.0: most energetic voice
1.1: most curious voice
1.3: most cute voice
Personally I like 1.3 voice, especially in the new Yanagi trailer
1.0 has to be your favorite its in the constitution is a law bro
@former_dough Rules are made to be broken ⚾️✨.
1.3 is my favorite because she's just so darn cute, I played 1.3 story and I love how the new VA delivered her lines in the cutscenes
Yep. 1.3 voice fits her really well. I welcome it with open arms
What actually turned me off to the 1.3 voice was the Yanagi trailer. I thought she sounded terrible tbh
"HUNGWY"
~ most adorable little oni ever
I like the 1.1 "Just don't Blink" that BLINK had a good feeling
The blink was kinda teasing, its perfect for her tbh
That was easily my favorite line from the 1.1 voice. She did that one really well. It was comparable to my favorite line from 1.0 and 1.3, which is the “Here we GO!”
Her battle voice lines are actually better in 1.3 but i still like the 1.0 one for the menus
I feel like i'm the only one who couldn't hear her voice in menu
Yeah I got too used to 1.1's voice lines. 1.0 and 1.3 feel very similar, but I feel like 1.1 just captures that Oni gremlin-snack-fiend vibe so well. Especially in the Hollow Zero levels where she's constantly asking about snacks. The new 1.3 voice sounds like a bit like Ash but it's also softer in parts and feels like off kilter compared to the rest of the voices, where those in your 3-man cell or even compared to the Virtual Vengeance storyline. I don't know what HoYoverse were thinking with this one.
I love the 1.0 “HYAH” that sounds genuinely threatening, how an onion should sound.
i miss the 1.0 'blow blow blow away your troubles' but this 1.3 one sounds much more 'soukaku' than the 1.1 one so im satisfied
1.0: A real Soukaku
1.1: Paimon, is that you?
1.3: This is... um... a teenage Soukaku?...
1.3 is fitting then because Soukaku isn't old enough to drink
1.3 sure does wanna bring back the og soukaku we know in 1.0
Aww, I was really liking the 1.1 version
still gonna miss the full force HYAAAA! the 1.0 one makes on their ultimate.
I still prefer her 1.0 but I’ll admit that I do enjoy the 1.3 😊
1.1 Is food included is my favourite
Thank you! You are not alone :3
1.3 is bad acting included? yes it is
That kinda low voice for "is food included >ω>" is really nice, 1.1 got that right.
But the 1.1 HYAH was so so bad, it had no feeling of impact.
If by 1.4 they change her va AGAIN i hope they take the best out of all three versions
For me , the latest one is the best. It's not over high pitched, but still retain her joyfulness
Will miss the 1.1 voice 😢
1.1 Is best girl for real. They should have kept it. Has more personality, but of course people will prefer the baby like sound of 1.3 in this game.
Ohhh!! I think the third one is the most similar to original one! I love it!!!
....Hope, hsr Argenti will have a third va too
Miss 1.0 soukaku but 1.3 soukaku is a close match trying to get that 1.0 energy and i can respect it and also.. hungy!!! The yanagi soukaku is really adorable
gonna be honest I like the newest voice the best
gonna be dishonest I agree
Nah, the 1.0 voice was the best. But I do think the 1.3 voice feels more natural than the takes for the 1.1 voice.
@@Cronomancer YEAHHHHHHH I AGREE!! I prefer the 1.3 over 1.2
hmm i agree too, 1.0 was the best but 1.3 is really fit. since im often use her with Ellen team even now, im not even mad.
Imo
1.0>1.3>1.1
Looks how they massacred my food goblin
AGAIN!!!!!
honestly i really like the 1.1 VA
After watching her backstory
1.0 and 1.3 is most fitting
If you just listen to 1 and then skip to 3, honestly it sounds like it's done by the same person
I will forever miss 1.0.. Hoyo can act like nothing was lost, but not the fanbase.
Now she's just another cute girl.
While the EN VA enjoyers are panicking, the JP VA enjoyers are sipping their tea 🍵
"DOREH" Gang over "HYAH" gang
I listen and understand “the first replacement of the original actress was still good”
Am I the only one that really likes her 1.1 voice? She sounds so cute and I like the delivery of the lines, but the original HYAHH will never be beat😔
Don't worry, check around, you are not alone ^-^
me either
Same the Food included 1.3 like is the ONLY thing I don't like about the character
I like 1.1 most
Clearly Soukaku is ready (to change voice actress) xD
Kinda love the 2nd one tho, shame... How many times do we have to see the voice actress get changed -old man- Hoyo!! 😭🤣🤣
as someone who isn't biased toward the 1.0 voice, because I play in a different language the 1.3 voice is definitely best one overall between the 3.
I didn’t even realize they changed it again. I mostly stopped using her after the first voice change.😅
I wanted to see the "arround and around and around and STOP!", because that's the line I liked most from Soukaku
I miss the growl and grit of her 1.0 voice
it kinda feels like they tried to get closer to her 1.0 voice while including some stuff from her 1.1 voice
Bruh her first VA was the best
Current voice is just *PERFECT*
While 1.3 is not exactly the same as 1.0, it comes very close to it. I don’t play soukaku often so if there was no version 1.1 I would’ve never noticed the change. The VA did a fantastic job
1:16, 1:50 and 2:23 are W
The original one just fits for the uber energetic ogre type of character, sad they had to change it.
1.3 really feels like a mix between 1.1 and 1.0
New voice sounds better than the 2nd one, but still pales in comparison to the OG, I'm quite happy they decided to steer the voice acting direction closer to the original one.
They just shouldn't have changed anything at all. The first one was the best.
I'm happy that the new one kind of resembles the 1.0 voice.
I don't think soukaku will ever be ready
I like the 1.3 voice the most
1.0 I still personally feel is the best, but can't fault Hoyo for kicking the VA to the curb. 1.3 is definitely an improvement over 1.2 though, so I'm happy.
The first version really was the right one.
at least she sounds more energetic than last time tho
I miss her v1.0 ultimate. Nothing else resonance with that war cry.
Hoyo, please. I just starting to get used to her 1.1 voice. Buttt at least now she sounds more like her 1.0 voice back then which is my favorite🙇♂️
I like/ prefer 1.0 since it was the first one I
Heard and it feels more natural
THIS IS GREMLIN ERASURE AAAAA 😭😭😭
I like 1.1 Ultimate “HA HAA!! JUST DONT BLINK” line. Delivery from 1.1 was the best other that 1.0’s “HIYYAAAAHH!!”
THE GROWL IS BACK!!!!! WOOHOO!!!!
Baby girl can't catch a break
1.0 voice will always be my favorite 1.1 voice just makes me go 'Annis is that you?' and 1.3 I haven't heard enough to establish an opinion.
1.0 Ultimate scream at the end goes insanely hard
For the love of- *AGAIN?* Hoyo, please give the poor blue oni girl a break...
the 1.1 ultimate lines fits perfect with the 1.0 "HYAH" for its similar tone
I like 1.1's version tbh
V1.1 was the best in my oppinion.
Personally I like 1.3 the best, which feels like the minority opinion.
I honestly hope at this point that this becomes a running gag and her voice changes with every major update.
Damn. I liked 1.1's "Why didn't you buy any snacks..?" It was accusatory and grumpy and phekin cute.
“I can also become an asura!” 1.0 was awesome 😭😭
ngl I love all the voices I wish I could switch through them whenever I feel like it
"There's conflicting reports that this oni changes her voice about every month or so to keep people guessing her persona, very cunning, we'll have to keep an eye on this one." -Soukaku; initial impressions
Her “is it work time? Is food included?” 1.0 va sounds so constipated😭 however her attack voice lines were so good
i really liked the first one : (
I legit miss 1.1 Soukaku, the actor/tress _felt_ like soukaku.
I have no other adequate way of putting it. I sorely miss and mourn the loss.😔
I knew I wasnt going crazy.
I really miss the energy she had with the first two voice actors.
She going through puberty every version
I MISS V1.0 AAAA
I honestly wouldn't even mind if they had a bit where they changed Soukaku's ENG VA every two versions or so
Bruh and i got attached to 1.1 V of her voice already💀
SAME , I hate the 1.3 voice bc it doesn't feel right and the HYAHH
OMG I KNEW HER VOICE FELT DIFFERENT THESE DAYS, I'm kinda new to zzz tho and I wasn't confident enough to be 100% sure
She sounds more like first time, i like it.
The second "is food included" was really good though...
Her "Around, & around & around" was the best in 1.0 :c
I just really miss the way she says "Round and a round and STOP!" in the 1.0 voice.
Guys go and listen to the lady at the music store her voice actor was changed too, sounds like it. The original VA was a perfect fit for the character.
All this told me is that I don't know what I had til I lost it. Loved 1.0's Voice. Despised 1.1's but came to love it as it's own voice. And now 1.3 is just.
Yeah I shoulda never said in my Survey to change Soukaku's Voice back cuz now it won't come back even MORE now.