the evolution of "like and subscribe"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 вер 2022
- button button button button button
Twitter: / mancarrying
Our second channel: / @womancarryingman
Patreon: / mancarryingthing
TikTok: / mancarryingthing
Reddit: / mancarryingthing
Discord: / discord
Instagram: / mancarryingthing
Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/ManCarrying/
#smashthatlikebutton - Комедії
I once saw an Indian youtuber who said: "If you liked the video, leave a like. If you didn't, leave a dislike and comment on how I can improve in the future." He is my hero.
Science is dope?
I saw an American UA-camr once go vegan for an hour
I mean, all engagement is good engagement, as far as the algorithm is concerned
@@aspebb I go vegan for 8 hours every night.
Some ordinary gamers?
It's scary how accurate the 2020 one was.
It's literally word for word
i swear they use that same screenshot too that's scary asf
@@jessetaylor1437 i just noticed that i saw it on many youtubers nowadays lol
2013 was oddly specifically correct.
@@jessetaylor1437 fr
and it's always them mfs with background gameplay
You forgot about the ”Theres a youtube glitch going around causing people to randomly unsubscribe”
This annoys me the most. No the fuck this isnt happening lol. They are straight up just lying now to get more subs
@@mystraunt2705 agreed
@@mystraunt2705 actually there was one glitch, Pewdiepie and a lot more youtubers (even non english ones) lost a LOT of subscribers for that, but thankfully UA-cam fixed it and gave back all the subs. But yeah this glitch EXISTED.
@@luigino2366 that glitch is completely unrelated to the so called ”glitch” current minecraft youtubers are talking about today.
@@Knarkameloh ok
Back in the early days of UA-cam, there were no like buttons, only stars.
They switched in 2010
Very true. Only comments had likes (I think likes on comments were added in 2007 or 2008, at the time I thought they were doing it to copy Yahoo Answers). I remember when they changed over to likes it was spring 2010, I wasn't too happy because I much preferred the star system (it was a couple months before my 10th birthday so that's how I remember it so exact).
@@ankharahallstrom1580You seem like an Og
I feel like instead of UA-camrs asking for likes and subscribes, they would instead end with “Because UA-cam is, where the poop is!” But back in those days I primarily watched UA-cam poops or UA-cam poop like videos.
Don't forget to rate the video 5 stars if you liked it!
Legends say to this day, people are still waiting for that cookie
yoo its bendyfan
But my family WAS murdered!
@@4862cjc BY ME
UA-cam’s loaded them all into your browser.
I’m still waiting for 87 cookies
I like the implication that Minecraft is immortal, and will still be an incredibly popular game after decades.
its more like the minecraft mod that is the origin point of all factorio-like games, and that drarf-fortess city builders and minecraft strongly infuenced each other since minecraft alpha.
sorry I can't hear you my subconscious is in minecraft atm I can only likeandsubscribe
Once the 1:1 scale mod of the entire Earth is finished, I could see its longevity skyrocketing.
Nope it’s dying because of the new censorship by Microsoft
I really am glad that u got the right takeaway from this video!👍👍👍
the color correction and aspect ratios really sold this. your editing is always so on point
And the camera angles are so on point.
frfr
Missed the sound though!
the 2013 color aspect, ratio, and angle was so accurate
Sound and image should have been destroyed a little as well. UA-cam didn’t support HD for the longest time, many old videoes from the “good” old days where 240p and such
One creator I follow did a test. He never said “like and subscribe” in his videos because he thought it was tacky. It turns out, after he tried saying it, he got a boost in his subscription numbers. Some people actually respond to being told to subscribe.
People are machines confirmed
My mind immediately went to CONEY but I'm not sure if it was
It actually makes sense when you think about it. A UA-camr I watch explained it like this: the reason saying “like and subscribe” is effective isn’t because people are sheep or anything like that, it’s because people often forget that liking/subscribing is even a thing until they are reminded of it. Whenever you upload a video that performs well, there will be a certain number of viewers who enjoyed the content and who *would’ve* liked/subscribed had they remembered to do so. So when those people hear the “like and subscribe” message, they think “Oh right. I should do that, since I do like this person’s content.”
I do when it comes to liking videos. I just forget most of the time.
There's kind of an element of 'you just enjoyed your time here...now you owe me' that seems to work. Like a Guilt Subscribe.
The fact you disrespect our history, and did not include "LEAVE A FIVE STAR REVIEW" is foul.
I was hit by a sudden wave of nostalgia at your mention of stars! I had totally forgot!
Even better if he points to his left since that’s where the old subscribe button and description box used to be
@@niharsheth Damn I totally forgot about that. Remember the confusion during the transition period where people would confusingly point to the side and then the bottom and say something cheeky like “or wherever it is now” lol.
@@olive8604 There was a brief period where they had it on top of the video as well. Also when they changed the button from yellow to red.
@@niharsheth On top?? When was that? 😆
I do remember a period in the early 2010s where the site was undergoing so many rapid changes that it felt like new features and designs were popping up for just a few weeks and then disappearing again lol.
One feature I really miss was being able to queue up videos by pressing the plus sign on the thumbnail. It was so useful! Maybe it’s still around but I haven’t been able to find it since, and this was like 10 years ago at this point.
On point as always, but you’re missing that 2016-2019 era where they would promise free giveaways and merch if you liked, subscribed and commented a response to some bs prompt like “what’s YOUR favorite lewd Minecraft mod? Let me know and I’ll read your comments :)” when they totally don’t read any
2008 should have mentioned rating the video as well.
Did anyone get the merch?
my favorite lewd minecraft mod is the jenny mod
The douchetuber era ....clearly a dark time of UA-cam that we are all trying to forget ever existed
@Newcious your profile pic alone is not helping you my guy. Nobody's gonna click that link.
The only reason i watched this video was to see if the subscribe button would light up
it only done that once
Yoooo same wtf
Only did once. 😂
Yeah same lmao it lit up once.
same 😅😅
For 2008 he should mention rating 5 stars as well
2008's is so adorable. It's like he's just proud that he got a video out there into the world. And he should be. Sharing digital media to random people all over the world is a marvel of human accomplishment.
Except Likes didn't exist yet. UA-cam started with a 5 star rating system.
@@mariokarter13 yup
@@mariokarter13 every now and then i unearth an old 240p windows movie maker AMV from the early days that survived the purges, and at the end they sometimes ask you to rate their video. oh the old days of youtube...
Eh I don't know. I thought UA-cam was gonna be a platform for film makers with no money. Instead it became a friendship simulator for lonely kids who should just go out and make real friends
@@CharlieBrown20XD6 I think UA-cam became like that more in the past 2-5 years because before then most content creators were actually more passionate. Now it is about making money and gaining subscribers/influence by learning the algorithm (not to say there aren’t any good creators though).
Making a video mocking UA-camrs for asking for likes and subscribing is such genius. It’s like a company mocking other companies for advertising. You’re a master. I smashed the like button so hard I need a new mouse.
You launched a channel yesterday but trust me you will be offering freshly baked cookies reeeeal soon.
@@jamesforrester2876 They’re already in the oven. When do I become famous and get to quit my job? A week? Two tops?
@@PaperbackJourneys about that yeah
Mascots are silly. Saving money isn’t.
@Newcious no
Only thing is, in 2008 it would have been "rate 5 stars and subscribe" since like and dislike came later. But yeah, this is pretty accurate.
0:23 subscribe button glows
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
true
The genuinety in 2008 version is real. People looked like humans while asking to subscribe, now it's constant yelling at screen in a forced excited way
Only difference is I think it was the star system then still.
@@heyimclcktwn9243 Yep. The star system was in place until sometime in 2010. Also, the subscribe button was yellow back then.
I miss the lightsaber
@@hawkofthereborn43 I got the "return YT dislikes" app which also brought back the lightsaber on heavily disliked videos. I never figured out what it was called when it was mostly green (I once heard it called a joint being smoked).
2020 is fine wdym
nowadays i feel like the message to 'like and subscribe' has become an existential mind game of how to manipulate your audience or how to be genuine
dang, so well put!!!
I like when they pull out the reverse psychology.
And Man Carrying Things wins this game
The worst part is it's so unbelievably transparent that the only people this shit can manipulate is little kids. Like what adult hears "Pwease wike and subscwibe" or the stupid fucking mouse clicking animation and is like "durrr ok"? It's really creepy if you think about it.
Baby's first politics
somehow he even got the lighting right for each era
POV: you came here to test out the new youtube sub glow effect
Does not work :(
@@stnjanusic8120it did work for me. Turns out, you have not have currently liked or subscribed in order for it to work. (The Like button didnt glow up but the sub button did at around 0:24 )
huh@@stnjanusic8120
0:21
aint no way bro just read my mind 💀💀 is schnawg watching me
I love that story about the toddler in Japan who says "Like and subscribe!" to his friends when he says goodbye because he thinks it's a normal farewell phrase.
I don't know if this is real but i got so happy thinking about it hshs
I'd definitely subscribe to his friendship
id join that conversation ngl
The last time I heard someone mentioning children thinking that this phrase is a normal way to say goodbye, everyone was having a feeling of doom
@@kevintrang6447 i mean, baby boomers were saying that shit about millennials when we started using "text slang" in verbal communication.
it's just a normal human thing to repeat the phrases we're exposed to. it's not some sign that we're doomed as a society.
This is an instant classic like always but technically incorrect because UA-cam was still using the star rating system in 2008.
Technically - the best kind of incorrect.
"Please rate me 5 stars, favorite this video, and don't forget to send a video reply with your best Heath Ledger joker impression."
Asking people to share videos specifically is something that a lot of people used to ask others of, but nowadays not many do
@@MrR2TheZ Favoriting videos seems like such an odd concept now. It made more sense in the 2000’s when UA-cam was mainly full of one-off videos that consisted of strange memes that you’d want to show friends when they visit (because you didn’t have a phone that could send a link). But now you got a lot of video essays and long form content that most people aren’t going to watch more than once.
I was there, great times.
You gotta update it now that the sub button glows when you say it
0:02
Was expecting this to start with "don't forget to rate 5 stars"
It should've.
You forgot to tell us to ring the bell and force us to receive notifications and ensure we can never escape the neverending vortex of content
this
They really perfected this method in 2133 when youtubers were able to phase through the screen and threaten you at gunpoint to subscribe.
bro in 69420 they will control ur brain to subscribe
Or in 2200 when they did that but with plasma guns
You forgot to remind us to SMASH THAT NOTIFICATION BELL so we can get updates EVERY SINGLE TIME you upload (even though it still doesn't work half the time) and to share with all our friends and check out your merch/today's sponsor/your second channel/your Twitch no one cares about...
i feel like the 2008 one should've just been that blue background with the text on it like "plz rate 5 star and subrib"
The dramatic “SMASH” with the bell noise was so accurate for 2015. But it needed more airhorn noises.
"Like, subscribe, and share" is "live, laugh, love" for internet dwellers
Why do I have to read this with my eyes and also it's true?
That's a genuinely poignant observation. (Applause from the back)
@@chem_mong read it with ur nose if u dont want to read it with ur eye
(ikr its unfunny)
0:24 *suscribe button glows*
the subcribe button only lit up once. C'MON!!!
I don't know why but I suddenly have an urge to like and subscribe to your channel
yo no way me too!!
Ignore it.
ebirc sbu sd naekil
Don’t be fooled, this is just a plot to get us to like and subscribe.
I miss “If you liked the video, like, if not, dislike.”
Hi checkmark
Hi, !
idk why this was recommended to me a year later but it was fun watching the buttons to see if they'd change color :D
It's a good video but it needs a "call to action," something to remind your audience to come back and continue to consume your content.
I wish there was a button that we could click to let the uploader know we appreciate them. And maybe a feature that'll alert us and tell us when a new video comes out!
I’d love to know what the audience thinks about this topic
I'd love to show my appreciation for your witty comment, but I just don't know how! If only...
I used to teach classes on how to making UA-cam videos and I lost track of how many times I said “call to action” to a nine year old.
@@chudleycannonfodder It's one of my least favorite terms.
Too bad he didn’t tell me to like and subscribe at the end, I don’t know what to do now
I couldn’t resist liking and subscribing
You entirely forgot 2017 when people were telling kids that if they didnt subscribe a spider would crawl on their bed
Remember when we would get prizes
I remember when it was a star rating system
I ask people to rate five stars in my videos just to be weird and outdated.
@@elijahfordsidioticvarietys8770 Sometumes the UA-cam homepage still asks me to give stars to random videos in my watch history.
Me too I was expecting the first one to be "comment, rate and subscribe"
I had to scroll way too far for this! There weren't likes in the early days!
@@WyattBrown377 Yep, I remember old school UA-cam. I liked the star system, five stars for "I loved it", four stars for "I liked it a lot", three stars for "I liked it a little", two stars for "I didn't like it, one star for "I hated it", and no rating for a neutral opinion (or if it had super high rating I'd give two stars to express a neutral opinion or three if it had low rating). Only comments had likes (and the dislike button worked on comments, I saw some with negative ratings in the thousands) and the comment section worked differently back then (there were no threads). You could rate videos five stars, the subscribe button was yellow, and channel pages felt a lot more like MySpace profiles. Also, UA-cam had separate friends and subscriptions/subscribers lists (you could also PM people on here, I had so many great conversations with friends when I was little that are now gone forever). Also video responses. I apologize for the long-winded comment, you just sent me on a nostalgia trip to childhood.
Bro when he said subscribe one time the buttern glowed...
New UA-cam feature in A/b testing.
i call it pointless shit
I know I'm not the only one who was staring at the subscribe button the whole time and waiting for it to do the rainbow thing
I liked and subscribed.
Mr beas giv me a million. Dollar's
Real talk though: has anyone ever actually decided to like and subscribe after being asked, despite not planning to do so beforehand?
for some reason i always do it after being told so if i enjoyed the video
yeah
Nope, I don't like being told what to do. I watch a lot of videos without liking or subscribing, and I could be subscribed to a channel to know when they upload videos and never like any of their videos, especially if they're reactions or something similar. I don't need all that fodder in my liked videos list.
A ton of people do. There was some research done into it, and asking people to like and subscribe helps a lot. As for me, if I did like a video but forgot to like it, I like it after being asked to. (What a sentence.) The main reason for that is that it’s my small way of helping creators I like, even if asking people to do it is annoying. It’s zero effort on my end to help someone out.
Nope. I rarely do either anymore since it seems pointless. UA-cam automatically recommends me videos from people I like, and the few times I actually do subscribe it seems to show me *less* of that person’s videos.
So I’m in this weird scenario where my recommendations tab are filled with videos I want to watch from people I’m not subscribed to, and my subscriptions tab is all irrelevant stuff from people I don’t even remember subscribing to.
It seems UA-cam is better at figuring out what I want to watch than I am, so why bother? 🤷🏽♂️
I watched this to see if my subscribe button glows
it worked! the subscribe button glowed when he said it
Who else mainly remembers the “smash that like button” phase?
I still see some people use that... mostly just Smash Bros youtubers though. XD
2022: a short meta sketch vid about like and subscribe.
I just watched this to see the subscribe button glow
0:23 Subscribe button is highlited
ye
We can't ask much of creators especially with how bad the platform has gotten but the "only a small percentage of my viewers" one irks me so much. It makes me feel really guilty even when I am already subscribed to be watching the content casually and after hearing it I feel like I can't close the video midway through because it would make the numbers look bad
bro. its their issue, not yours.
Yea hit a fat dislike so they know you care
This UA-camr named LegalEagle did it in one of his videos. But the chart showed him that a majority of his viewers *were* subscribed. I can't believe that a lawyer would be deceptive on a platform like UA-cam!
The funny thing about that too is that that data doesn't necessarily mean that noone is subscribing. It just means that your videos are getting recommened alot to people who haven't subscribed, which is great!. You want your videos to be seen by alot of new people so you can grow your audience.
@@simonrockstream oh absolutely I'm just very suggestible and prone to making a big deal out of nothing haha
This video is an illustration of the gross power dynamic between viewers and creators. We as the viewers are by our whims wielding immense power to withhold or bestow success. If creators were to simply pay people to like and subscribe, this discourse would die. I will like for one dollar, mister thing. Subscription costs ten.
Well the point is they usually make money out of subscriptions so that wouldn't work
Well the point is they usually make money out of subscriptions so that wouldn't work
We already have “joining,” which is where you pay _them_ to subscribe
@@AshZucchini8168 lmao
in 2008 there were no likes or dislikes, instead we would say "rate 5 stars"
There is one channel I watch who just ends his videos with “thanks for watching and I’ll see you next time.” I don’t think he’s ever asked for likes or subscribers because they’ll do what they’re gonna do regardless of what you say imo. It’s very refreshing
It does feel nice not to have my intelligence insulted when channels forgo the "like and subscribe" shtick.
At this point, I can't tell if this is purely a comedy skit or if MCT is telling us to like and subscribe through a skit about liking and subscribing.
Two birds one stone.
For me it worked
Like-ception
I still remember "Please give the video five stars and add it to your favorites"
The real OGs remember when it was a 5 star rating system and not a like/dislike
On 2021, the subscribe button glows when he says subscribe. I'm freaking out, how does youtube know when he said subscribe?!
2021?
0:21@@Meme.hub145
Idk what it was about 2013 but you are spot on that content creators constantly threatened me and my family in an attempt to get me to sub
Thanks for clarifying that 2076 is in fact the future. Man carrying my feeble powers of deduction indeed
I wouldn't want to get it confused with 2076 (the past)
0:21 subscribe button lights up
THIS MADE MY SUBCRIBE BUTTON RAINBOW
WELCOME TO BLOXBURG
My mum still thinks subscribing costs money, which when you think about it, is using the word subscription as it should be, but is still funny.
@@tanmayadithya lol that's pretty weird orphan.
I mean, subscribing on twitch costs money.
UA-cam is just an exception.
@@tanmayadithya i was gonna say bookmark exists, then realized people watch UA-cam on phones when they were kids.
Now I feel like a fossil
I don't subscribe to that notion.
It does cost time and a little bit of your soul.
Its insane how Dream modified the Like and Subscribe trends with those stats
yes, but it tricks some people with small IQ (But they are nice anyway, and good at something
@@wojtekgame it doesn’t just trick stupid people😐
@@3upProd today you found out everyone thinks you're stupid
TF did dream do I don't even watch him cause I ain't 11
Of fucking course the most annoying way content creators ask for subscriptions was invented by Dream...
wtf, on 0:23 subscribe button starts to glow!
Thats a new feature
thats why were here
@@TheRealAlanGod fr
the fact the subscribe button turned colors
I love how the visual quality of each part changes and gets better to go along with the years. Nice touch.
“Also it’s free and you can change your mind any time”
Goddamn he knows what he’s doing
The pulling out the statistics and saying "Only a small amount of my viewers are actually subscribed" method is the most infuriating one.
0:22 the subscribe button glows.
Instead of like AND subscribe we should pit the two against each other in a deathmatch. Like VS Subscribe, battle of the analytics.
Before Twitter added polls people used to do Like v Retweet (totally not a cynical way to get loads of engagement): “Who do you think is going to win the Super Bowl? Like for Patriots, Retweet for Falcons”
The fact these always got loads of engagement is probably why Twitter (and UA-cam) added polls.
"It's subscribin' time"
-Man, as he likes and subscribes to things.
Pre-2010 youtube used rating stars and not likes.
The amount of research that must have gone into this is amazing.
As always, I'm agreeing with every single video you've ever made. I'm awaiting for the one single opinion that differs from mine to cancel you forever, as the Internet Law dictates.
Gotta give this man credit for spending 14 years to make this video
2008 had a star system, the website redesign with the "like" and "dislike" buttons didn't go live until around 2010.
I remember at one point things got so bad people were saying stuff like "destroy that like button", "obliterate that like button", "murder that like button", "nuke that like button".
I remember when you'd ask to give the video five stars
I love how the 2008 & 2011 examples use that gross, de-saturated video look that so many videos had around this time. These basically hit the mark tbh!
Yes, what was up with that btw?
@@themadtitan7603 People filming on crappy webcams, and not understanding the importance of good lighting.
@@siukong Makes sense. It felt like bigger channels and smaller ones on UA-cam filmed videos had that same poor, desaturated look to their videos back then and I guess this helps explain why.
Makes it feel more nostalgic tho
At 0:21 when he says subscribe, you can see subscribe button gets colorful
The ‘don’t forget to SMASH that like button’ was insanely accurate 😂
Before 2010, instead of likes, we gave ratings between 1 and 5 stars.
"UA-cam is randomly unsubscribing people so make sure you're subscribed" is a popular one that I saw a lot
I genuinely thought these were actual old clips from a UA-camr, but according to other comments it’s acted? If so it’s so good I couldn’t even tell
0:23 the subscribe button is glowing when he said subscribe here
I expected the good old: Please rate 5 stars, add the video to your favourites and subscribe
It took me two viewings of this video to realize that this is your way to tell us to like and sub without directly saying it
Mad respect to you
Watching CityNerd recently and he is one of the few I watch who sometimes says "just click the things" in the most monotone way possible. Pure sarcasm, I love it.
I will never understand because people continue to ask for these 2 things as if it really worked.
It looks like that same phrase that everyone speaks all the time "Let's be at peace" and 5 seconds later is doing something annoying or crazy that will generate conflict
You missed the part where the bell got added in, so you also have to talk about that, too. It makes the 2076 bit unrealistic, as I assume UA-cam will have added six more layers of things creators will need viewers to do in order to actually know about their videos.
I think the idea that UA-cam will exist in 2076 is unrealistic tbh
I don't think I've ever 'hit the bell' before, and still never missed anything
@@wanderingrandomer Tbf you might have missed things, unless you religiously crosscheck every channel you're subbed to with everything that shows up on your feed
@@wanderingrandomer i once hit the bell lol the sound was so loud , someone from another universe could hear it
subversion of subscriber expectations is done so often that it's actually better to just straight up ask them to subscribe now
the cookie one is so accurate
and in 2019 it was " LikE oR tHis sPidEr WiLl bE iN yOuR bEd" 💀
2076 was the most relatable
Man Carrying Thing doesn't tell you to "like and subscribe," he makes a video about it and then, of course, you like and subscribe. Out here playing 4D chess.
The 2076 one was so accurate.
00:18, I’d say Grian is an exception to this one, he said this sort of line, but there really were big gaps between when he’d say it in videos. Though he did start asking more often later when there was a noticeable improvement in people subscribing after he started.