NEET 2024 Row: Advocate J Sai Deepak On NEET 2024 Controversy | NEET Scam | English News | News18
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 чер 2024
- The Centre on Thursday told the Supreme Court that the grace marks of 1563 students who appeared for National Eligibility cum Entrance Test Undergraduate 2024 (NEET-UG 2024) will be cancelled and they will have the option to reappear for the exam. The court, after hearing the Centre’s decision, said that a re-exam will be conducted for the 1,563 students, which is scheduled to be held on June 23.
“A subsequent Committee has made recommendations after deliberations which are placed before us. According to recommendation, scorecards of 1563 candidates will be cancelled and stand withdrawn. A re-exam will be conducted for these 1563 candidates. The results of those who don’t wish to appear will be based on their actual marks without compensatory marks,” the Vacation Bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta said.
#neet2024 #neetpg #neetexam #news18live #cnnnews18
News18 Mobile App - onelink.to/desc-youtube
n18oc_politics
1. Re exam is MUST for everyone.
2. The entire NTA team who conducted NEET should be suspended and investigated by CBI.....and if found guilty should be dismissed.
3. Persons who leaked the paper should be dismissed from service and put in jail for at least 10 years.
4. Parents and students who participated in this scam should be banned forever from giving NEET or any other medical exam.
5. Such national level exams should be conducted in a strict and trustworthy manner, and a complete overhaul of the system is needed.
IF THERE WILL BE RENEET
all the big institute will have to pay for ranks again
they have already paid nta to get the ranks
THEY BOUGHT ALL THE JUDGES THEY WEERE BARELY LISTENING
THERE IS NO CHANCE OF RENEET
I don’t want to write exam for one more time as I have got decent marks. who are you to tell that re exam must for everyone ?
Speak for yourself
Supreme courts decision causes injustice to NEET 2024 students. Damage happened in Lakhs of ranks due to paper leakage and NTA correcting in Hundreds of Ranks based on Normalisation. Ranks may improve by just 1563, which doesnot justify damage. Paper leaked Institute and students are to be debarred or Re-NEET exam is the only solution.
This is a massive scam of
Rs 1000+ crore. Nexus of coaching centers, Paper leakers, Paper solvers, Test administrators etc
Sab mile hue hai
even JUDGE AND POLITICIANS BOTH OPPOSTITION AND RULING
Leak the Neet paper & pay the undeserved doctor to treat you wrong😂
Save India 🙏🏻Save Yourself😅1st from this doctors
neet should be conducted in the online mode in the future
😂😂😂tab to jee Wale bhi top karenge
Yes
My daughter lost 12 minutes because the invigilator asked her to fill out particulars after exam already started. In Meghalaya, students in many centres were distributed wrong question paper which were replaced, thereby causing loss of time.
Forget about grace marks and shit, 67 of the students got 720/720 full marks and check the no. of full marks in the previous years ... hardly 3 students have scored full
IIT papers used to be printed in Government Security press where bank notes are printed. That policy was changed citing various logistical and financial difficulties. We should go back to the old policy. Middle class dreams are not for netas to play political football.
Leakage might be everywhere. Who knows? So, better to re neet or reexam not to make the matter worst for all neet aspirants and also to maintain uniform examination all over India. Otherwise abolish NTA forever. ☝
There seems to be a misunderstanding regarding the marks... Ranks are rewarded based on percentile in such exams because each year the performance of students is different. If the current years paper was relatively easy, then there is an anticipated crowding of ranks near a small range of marks, that too in the upper percentages. Maybe there should be an audit into the past 10 years of neet/aipmt exams and see where they have taken shortcuts?
Pradhan and nta both must go, must be punished also.
Paper leaks have been happening over decades..it is not a new issue. However it needs to be tackled.
There is no pdf list for those who got grace mark too….
When you have 12th, why you need entrance exam? to benefit coaching centers?
good, now u're catchin onto Tn educationists and students protests. now most of the kids that get seats are repeaters from coaching centers. 12th is rendered wasted by the union govt - the congi mafia that tried to get this and now the sanghi goons that pushed this down the students throats
JSD 🙏.. very impressive extremely balanced view to stear clear of politics played by parties and as a representative for his client.
Students who are appearing again should be given financial compensation for the extra cost they have incurred.
If that 1563 students approach the court and argue strongly to protect their rights then reneet to all will be the only solution Right to equality
Paper leak is the main point
The following concerns to be addressed by NTA:
Highlights ( please refer to Details below for more explanation/ information of each of them):
1. Grace marks given for one physics question (related to “atom”) to be extended to all candidates or drop off the question.
2. Scanning software logic to be revalidated
3. “Time lost” grace marks to be extended to most of the students
Details:
1. The grace marks given for a physics question:
The grace marks given for a physics question where NTA awarded marks to limited students who answered anyone of two (defined) choices.
But there are students (including my child) who did not attend/ attempt the question as those answers are contradicting each other and attempting to answer would lead to negative marking.
so, the question should be dropped from the overall questions and correspondingly from the total marks. That is, the total number of questions should be 179 instead of 180. Similarly, total marks should be 716 instead of 720.
2. Revalidation of OMR scanning software logic:
To accommodate assigning 4 marks to the students who answered any one of the two defined choices for a physics question ( related to “atoms”), NTA might have changed the software application logic to read more than one choices as correct answers during scan of the OMR sheet.
NTA should ensure that the software assigns only 4 marks one time only and only to that one question. Other questions where a student might have marked more than one choices as answer should be considered as invalid or negative.
Otherwise there are chances of awarding 4 marks for invalid answer selection for questions and/or choices.
3. “Time lost” grace marks to be extended to most of the students:
Awarding grace marks for only limited students for "time lost" is an inappropriate decision. In most of the exam centers and for most of the students ( including my child), the time was not given for full 3 Hrs 20 mins because of one or more following reasons:
a) The question paper was not given/ distributed to all students uniform time at the beginning of the exam by the invigilator as he/she had to distribute the question paper in person to all students in the exam hall.
b) Similarly, collecting the OMR sheets at the end of the exam period was not uniform. As the invigilator will not be able to collect the OMR sheets from all at once.
c) During the examination, the invigilator had taken the signature from the student and he/she signed. The time was wasted for this process and it varies between 5 to 10 and is not uniform for all students.
So, grace marks for "time lost" up to 15 -20 mins to be given for most of the students including my child.
Certain .....how much !?
Nta mus prove
1.only 1563 students got grace mark
2.This 1563 were gone to court we don't know
The tv anchor always want his answer. If somebody answers otherwise, he can't listen.
One more thing . If there is any problem for the students, only opposition parties can help for the solution. Students can't fight against the Government.
One more thing. Many state governments didn't agree for Neet. Even Telangana did not agree. They were forced to agree stating that their students don't be considered as for admission to national colleges. States are not happy with this. Education is in Concurrent list. Hence states should be allowed to have it's own examination instead of forcefully taking it. Even media is on the side of government which is not right. They have we to question on behalf of the people
TN has a solid rationale for opposing NEET.
@@hema_raghuTN solid rational because it is stopping there medical seat selling Mafia
First you should know that state governments did not agreed because they cannot sell the medical seats for lumpsum amount to their desired candidates from private medical universities , and should I give you the details of corrupt management scams which used to happen in medical entrance exam which used to conducted by state boards (before NEET) in EAMCET, KCET, should I give you the details of AP PG medical entrance paper leak
What you said state government should be allowed to conduct their own exams in medical (so that they can sell medical seats for their desired amount), you are telling that you are questioning behalf of the people but the reality is you people are questioning behalf of the state governments
@@hema_raghubecause TN know this neet exam is totally a scam… look at top hospitals and doctors in India and where they studied…
This anchor is a stooge
My favorite theologist good book written by j sai sir
U r best sir
1. Re-Exam is required because it will balance their fundamental rights (right to equality).
2. I believe in NTA because at the top positions qualified bureaucrats are managing but still the structure of NTA won't depend only on top positions the corruption lies in middle and at the root base base part.
3. To improve the exam conduction a fair and transparent investigation over NTA by CBI Or a committee having hon'ble ex-supreme court judge must be required.
4. NEET exam structure must be changed like UPSC there will be chances for better exam structure
5. NTA is not a culprit but some people inside it may be corrupt! In bureaucracy, we have confidence and trust because they go through such a worthy competitive exam UPSC civil services that can be implemented to these exams too.
No reneet I stand against reneet
@@kiwi-dq9ni why you stand against re-neet are you a neet aspirant? Ask them what they want any hardworking student who believes in themselves are comfortable with re-neet but those incompetent people say they don't want re-neet
@@aarpitdubey dekheyi I have given my neet exam genuinely and I will never go through the mental pressure again simply I will not suffer plus luck cannot be by your side twice
@@keie_krie I understand your concerns, haan yeh bhi baat sach hai ki Neet exams mein jin logo ne genuinely hard work krke acche scores laaye hai re-neet se unlogo ko nukshan hoga or mental pressure kind of harassment hoga but see agar aapne genuinely hard work kiya hai toh vo Confidence aap mein hoga ki aap apne current score se bhi better score kar payenge! For example aap ne 12th board exams diye hai correct but usske phele pre-board hote hai toh yeh neet ko aap pre-neet samjhe sample exam k jaise samjhe or itni mehant or kare ki you can top this exam. Re-neet hi ek acchi opportunity hogi but jaisa students ko theek lage or hon'ble supreme court ko!
Students who are appearing again should be given financial compensation for the extra cost they have incurred. P
How I run education in my state is my business… why do you mandate that I consider only marks from this one fixed test??
This shows you can afford for additional coaching if you are rich…. You get question paper and grace marks if you are super rich….. way to go neet…..you credibility exposed…
# no reneet for everyone here are views why so:
1 , all the sincere students who actually managed to secure seat will face greatest injustice
2 , nobody can take same mental pressure again
3, even if somebody is involved we will not give our time and efforts again
4, reneet is demanded by unqualified students they just want second chance they do not actually care about scams
5 , there is no guarantee of honesty again..
Please see asba student and his parent. Then we know the concerns
Is tarah ke audios banana to bilkul mushkil nahi Gagoi… tum jo Amit Shah ki speech ki clip ko edit kerke public ko bhardka sakte ho, ye to mamooli baat hai
Bas rank inflation Km hona chahiye ..650 wala bi gov medi College m nhi Ja Raha...or kon se 1563 unme se bi 790 n qualify Kiya matlav 164 marks se jyada aaye as per NTA...koi 20k 30k...rank ka fark nahi aane wala....rank inflation ka kuch kijiye
आत्मनिर्भर युवा बढ़ता पकौड़ा बिजनेस की तरफ,बधाई🎉
NEET collects over 400 crores just from the application forms of 24lakh students. Each Medical seat cost 1 crore, clearly where a lot of money is involved, a lot of crooks are attracted.
We don't want reneet we want reevaluation
in tamilnadu,... students with 0%age marks can become surgeons,... i like it,... i like it,... whole world please come to tamilnad and become surgeons,....
Is this a joke
This year's NEET exam has spoiled the future of deserved ones... Complete failure and mis management. What is happening? Given grace and now taking it back.... So proving that the entire system has failed and making everyone to loose the Trust of the testing agency .
The shameless HRD Minister should resign immediately
Wat happened all are so alert suddenly....drama drama
Questions leaked& Cheating : #Reneet for all
Loss of time was there in Manipur too due to Severe Hailstrom …..
JSD is wrong on neet. his story that's life etc is all bs. upsc and other exams are for adults that know what they're getting into and are on same study reqts and competing for institutions union govt has established - ias, ips, etc . thats not the case with 10-12th students. state syllabus students have a huge disadvantage vs the cbse that neet is based on . state syllabus should improve etc , no one is arguing that they should be on higher par with all states and cbse, etc. but reality is that most kids that study state syll. are from semi-urban and rural areas and they score high marks in the only course they're into. so they should get the seats of our govt colleges . let the neet students compete for highly expensive private colleges if they can afford the atrocious donations-turned-fees now. rural students dont have the budget to go to coaching classes and repeat for 2-3 yrs but thye wouldve got the govt seats based on their state syll. marks alone. thats the problem . u cant substitute an allegedly flawed system with an even worse exploitative racket .
as for neighboring states agreeing to neet, TN's neighbors dont have the high # of govt colleges so those lazy bums are ok with their students grabbing tn kids seats.
so neet is a fraud on the tn students played by that misra sc judge , incompetent and corrupt edappadi, walkout by even worse dmk , and the ever conniving union govt - modi /shah . thats the main prob.
let cbse board build medical colleges for their 7-10% student strength in each state and not grab our kids seats
Why retest only for these few students. This is a special status created for them. Make a new exam possible for all then. Make it a level playing field. Be fair in word and deed.
People who scored well might commit suicide if they don’t clear the retest, the only people want retest is the one who thinks the score is unfair
😂😂
NTA- Never Trust Agency.
NTA- National Thattippu Agency.
NTA- National Thamasa Agency.
NTA- National Trauma Agency.
NTA - National Tragedy Agency.
NTA- Best cooked story .😅😅
Education minister.... ability or neeyat under questions
every tests are manipulated by interested lobbyists in Delhi.
First the govmt shud bloody build more colleges … fgot job generation … can’t u give education to deserving candidates ??? Why the hell is this all India exam .. have decentralised exam
Bhai ko masala nahi mila😢😢
MR.PRADHAN &N TA MUST PUNISHED SCAMERS
😡GODI- Media 😡
The journalists who supported and campaigned for Modi shamelessly have been raising their voices against the scam of NEET made by Modi Govt in the name of NTA. It feels good. Govt. should come forward to work out the problem of NEET aspirants without losing a moment .
No one heard the DMK voice for the past several years.
Why now?
Always Truth will be succeeded
Many states opposed this earlier also. But it was by force they accepted
@@srinivasaprasadm5351that includes gujrat when the present PM was it's CM! Reason?
Don't politicize the matter they want ban so as to earn by selling seats . Neet should be there but by CBSE not by NTA.
Reneet 2024
Sai Deepak is just another educated Sanghi posturing as a buffer to save NDA govt criticism...
I had winded up my tv set in 2020 just to avoid godi media channels like this one, cnn18.... ye saale u-tube par bhi aa gaye!😊