Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Why did Jesus call the Canaanite woman a dog? | GotQuestions.org
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 вер 2020
- Matthew 15:21-28, why did Jesus call the Canaanite woman a dog? Is this a story about the faith of the Canaanite woman? Or is it that Jesus calls a woman a dog in order to insult her? Also, why did Jesus initially refuse to help a gentile woman? In this video, Pastor Nelson with Bible Munch answers the question, “Why did Jesus call the Canaanite woman a dog?”.
*** Source Article:
www.gotquestio...
*** Check out, Bible Munch!
/ biblemunch
*** Recent @BibleMunch Videos:
Psalm 1:1-6 - The Actual Prosperity Gospel
• Preacher Shares the Ac...
Proverbs 20:7 - Dear Dads, - BE THE GIFT -
• Dear Dads, BE THE GIF...
John 14:6 - This TRUTH is what we need now!
• This TRUTH is what we ...
*** Recommended Resource:
God the Son Incarnate: The Doctrine of Christ
By: Stephen J. Wellum, John S. Feinberg
bit.ly/31VSdud
*** Related Questions:
What did Jesus mean when He said to not cast your pearls before swine (Matthew 7:6)?
www.gotquestio...
What did Jesus mean when He said it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to get into heaven?
www.gotquestio...
Why did Jesus say that He was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel (Matthew 15:24)?
www.gotquestio...
Intro/Outro Music: www.purple-pla...
Note: Some links are affiliate links which cost you nothing, but help us share the word of God.
Jesus said: "Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven."
And the woman is truly poor in spirit, and the kingdom promised by Jesus belongs to her
how is she poor in spirit?
As a gentile ... I was emotional when i read this chapter of Matthew about the Faith of the gentile woman because of her Faith ...she humbled herself by saying even dogs eats the crumbs that falls from their master's table.... She knows that a crumbs is enough to heal her demon possessed daughter or simply she has the faith that its just a small thing or too easy for Jesus Christ to heal her daughter.
@לאישה יש חולבים גדולים Yes my brother/sister in Christ..... We are so grateful for what Jesus did on the cross and His sacrifice will never be forgotten. His Grace was freely given to us and Jesus Christ is our hero ... Our saviour and our everything because without Him, then we are all nothing but a fallen creation/sinners heading to hell.
He calls her a dog and Israelites children, Judaism is racist.
@@algerianchaouki5705 I love Dogs and Israel and children. For aren't we all children of God when we have Faith? Or is it only those of us born as Judeans that have no faith in God that are? Dont be like a plant that will be uprooted but turn to God and dig your Faith deeper in the rich soil of God's word.
@@algerianchaouki5705 look at the christian kingdom size now thanks to the jewish peoples horrible behavior. we are to make them jealous. they are so small and we surround them around the world
bro what a fuckin cope
This explanation really helped my spirit, I swear I could've cried. A few weeks ago I saw a video on this situation of Jesus calling the Caananite woman a dog, and I did not recall reading that passage. So I opened my Bible and read it for myself, and I found myself actually quite upset by it. By how Jesus seemed to ignore the woman the first time, and then made that statement seeming to say she was a little dog that was lesser.
This honestly had me pretty upset with God for days, at a time when I was already having a challenge to my faith. But then I found this video and it all makes so much sense. I literally laughed in joy from it, and I had to repent for my anger, and it's like Jesus was saying "That's right, buddy. You owe me an apology." Afterwards I felt like a dark ugliness was lifted from me and I was no longer in a place of dark, angry feelings towards God. Thank you for this message.
He didnt call her a dog ..read the chapter and verse until her daughter is saved by jesus..
He was saying if one had a child at home ..and a dog...u would feed the child and make sure the first fruits went to the child...
Jesus said his main aim is to correct the path of the tribe of israel that the pharisees led astray ...thoae r jesus child...
The woman was not goven help intially beciase as she was a polytheist she was inviting such spirtis that now attacked her daughter ...
But then she says doesnt the dog feed of the remains of the food off the table...
This showed jesus that she understood the gravitynand power of the food jesus was trying to feed the child..
He then praised her becuase she understood the gravity of jesus work and that it was worthwile that even the crumbs of jesus work would be sufficient to feed her and her daughter ...
Jesus then saved the gentile ..
This shows that jesus message and thus salvation is for anyone who understands the power and gravity of the message nd thus salvation..
You could say the gentile woman was the first christian ..and the first to be saved by christ ...
Read thw whole chapter and understand it ..
He never calls her a dog..he was laying out an analogy as to the message he was bronging was important to his children...she reminded him that the message eventually would feed the loweer gentile ( lower beciase gentiles was visiting karma for not following the ten commandments and instead follow idols and spirits )
The crumbs that would save her ..showed that she understood the power of jesus salvation ..and that is available foe the gentiles to feed off of and be saved ..
@@kaydee3407Cannanites were cursed.
She wasn't just a gentile.
I freaked out too and I repent..
No matter how you all try to spin it she’s still compared to a dog, point blank period! She wasn’t compared to meek turtle doves.
And Dogs are very very loyal I wouldn't mind at all. Killer dog and loyalty heck yes!!!!!! And The Israelites had dogs in their houses it's not an unclean animal.
@@sarahwaters10sw ok
@@BMoreGoHard read the list of unclean animals, Dogs not in there, and Dogs are very loyal, they would literally die for you!!!!!
@@sarahwaters10sw I guess that’s why people kiss dogs in the mouth and see nothing wrong with it. What does a dog being loyal have to do with anything?
Let me school you. Anything that’s not on the list named to be clean is unclean by default. Do you understand that?
@@BMoreGoHard what ever Buddy and not every one kisses their dogs on the mouth now. I know I don't. But when I leave my house my big dogs protect it. And when I go out I take one with me and my dogs will chew apart anybody who comes near me to hurt me. You go ahead and keep being ignorant, peace be with you and have a great night
Jesus said all you need is a crumb of faith
It shows that through faith we are Israelites, just some of us are adopted
You cannot be an Israelite through faith please unlearn this fallacy & live as a gentile
@@jaehutch7173 We are all His people. Of course I’m Caucasian but spiritually, and metaphorically we who are in Jesus are.
Thank you for the great explanation. I have been looking for answers to different sources and now I found this wonderful explanation to the question as I am teaching a lesson in our Values class in Grade 3, comprehensible by young minds.
Be sure to point out to the children that Jesus treated her differently to the Israelites because of her race, (Greek). You could also point out other chapters where Jesus is helping the sick Jewish people without the need to compare them to a dirty pet animal. Jesus truly is a loving man who clearly supports race equality.
@ArchimedesBCJesus said you do not take the food from the children and give it to dogs, which this word means House pet type of dog, how do we know he is referring to a house pet and not a nasty dog on the street??? Cuz the Caananite woman responds "and even the (housepet dog) eats the scraps that fall the master's table", did u catch that?? "THE MASTER'S Table!" That means the dog is a housepet, it belongs to the master and is under his table, so even if u didnt know the hebrew, u see both Jesus and the Woman know what each are referring too and Jesus rewarded her for her faith by healing possessed daughter.... Jesus was fulfilling the prophecy, He came for the Children of Israel first, then the Gentiles next, so it wasn't her turn Just yet, Jesus is the Food for the Children, but like a housepet in Jesus Mercy he gave some "Food" aka crumbs to the Gentile (healed her daughter) to hold her over in the meantime, same way u do ur housepet Dog, and Jesus just that, Children of Israel had a chance at Jesus they rejected him and then he extended himself to ALL the world, gentiles included...and fyi Jesus used another word to refer to nasty stray dogs who referring to evil sinful people and thats not the word used here in greek, this the housepet version of the word
@ArchimedesBC
He didnt call her diectly a dog ..read the chapter and verse until her daughter is saved by jesus..
He was using an anolgy of a househilder with food brought to home..would u feed ur child first who needs it or ur domestic dog first..
Both r members of the family ..but the child will get the first attention ..then the pet dog
He was saying if one had a child at home ..and a dog...u would feed the child and make sure the first fruits went to the child...
Jesus said his main aim is to correct the path of the tribe of israel that the pharisees led astray ...thoae r jesus child...
The woman was not goven help intially beciase as she was a polytheist she was inviting such spirtis that now attacked her daughter ...
But then she says doesnt the dog feed of the remains of the food off the table...
This showed jesus that she understood the gravitynand power of the food jesus was trying to feed the child..
He then praised her becuase she understood the gravity of jesus work and that it was worthwile that even the crumbs of jesus work would be sufficient to feed her and her daughter ...
Jesus then saved the gentile ..
This shows that jesus message and thus salvation is for anyone who understands the power and gravity of the message nd thus salvation..
You could say the gentile woman was the first christian ..and the first to be saved by christ ...
Read thw whole chapter and understand it ..
He never calls her a dog..he was laying out an analogy as to the message he was bronging was important to his children...she reminded him that the message eventually would feed the loweer gentile ( lower beciase gentiles was visiting karma for not following the ten commandments and instead follow idols and spirits )
The crumbs that would save her ..showed that she understood the power of jesus salvation ..and that is available foe the gentiles to feed off of and be saved ..
@@yesthejets3368
He didnt call her a dog ..read the chapter and verse until her daughter is saved by jesus..
He was saying if one had a child at home ..and a dog...u would feed the child and make sure the first fruits went to the child...
Jesus said his main aim is to correct the path of the tribe of israel that the pharisees led astray ...thoae r jesus child...
The woman was not goven help intially beciase as she was a polytheist she was inviting such spirtis that now attacked her daughter ...
But then she says doesnt the dog feed of the remains of the food off the table...
This showed jesus that she understood the gravitynand power of the food jesus was trying to feed the child..
He then praised her becuase she understood the gravity of jesus work and that it was worthwile that even the crumbs of jesus work would be sufficient to feed her and her daughter ...
Jesus then saved the gentile ..
This shows that jesus message and thus salvation is for anyone who understands the power and gravity of the message nd thus salvation..
You could say the gentile woman was the first christian ..and the first to be saved by christ ...
Read thw whole chapter and understand it ..
He never calls her a dog..he was laying out an analogy as to the message he was bronging was important to his children...she reminded him that the message eventually would feed the loweer gentile ( lower beciase gentiles was visiting karma for not following the ten commandments and instead follow idols and spirits )
The crumbs that would save her ..showed that she understood the power of jesus salvation ..and that is available foe the gentiles to feed off of and be saved ..
Boy. Is this a sugar coating of a Obvious Jewish only original racist ideology.
Nah. This Gentile woman was praised for her great faith along with other gentiles. In contrast, Jews were rebuked and scolded for their lack or little faith by Christ. Plus, Jesus tested her and said that the children get the food first and later the pet or puppy. Jesus and the Apostles called Jews worse things.
@@carlomariaromano4320 she agreed that she was a dog and Jesus didn't say anything to the contrary. I have come only for the lost sheep of the house of isreal. Jesus wasn't a jew...
@@jjs44544 Don't you know that Jesus of the Christian Bible wasn't a mere human but the incarnated Son of God?
But isn't Jesus supposed to be the father to all??
Also, since when do people call their mom or daughter or wife a 'pet dog'?
Finally, parable or not, this is no way to refer to any female. Be real people.
The thing is, that the bible refers to women alot in a belittling way, we all know this.
You are an ignorant.. Jesus called the pharisees as snakes. I believe you haven't read any verses of the old testament to understand this simple thing
I don't care whatever excuse you have. The judgement is in God hand, the fact that you are offended by the gospel, means you love your sins more than God. Not my job to condemn you, i have one advice. Use wisdom, people from modern world are easily offended by words. If you are offended and don't even see/understand the message then you are a fool.
@@None-if3mo I'm not the one offended by the gospel, it's my source of guidance. Maybe it's you the one ashamed of it, and rightfully so. Figures by the arrogant way you speak lol, take care.
Ahhh, finally a good explanation to Jesus calling a woman a dog. Some Bible passages need to be explained according to the culture, time & circumstance. Tnx Sam for this passage clarification.
So jesus wasn’t just a jew, he was a nationalist jew and judging by how he calls non jews he was racist too lol
Jesus wasn't a jew
@@jjs44544 you sure about that😂
The word "meet" in this context means "proper" or "appropriate." So when Jesus says "It is not meet to take the children's bread and to cast it to the dogs," He is saying that it is not proper or appropriate to take something that is meant for one group of people (the children) and give it to another group (the dogs).
In this passage, Jesus is speaking with a Canaanite woman who has come to Him asking for healing for her daughter. At first, Jesus seems to ignore her, but when His disciples urge Him to send her away, He tells her that His mission is to the lost sheep of the house of Israel. The woman persists in asking for help, and Jesus responds with the statement about not giving the children's bread to the dogs.
Some scholars interpret Jesus' statement as a test of the woman's faith and persistence. Others suggest that He may have been using the language and attitudes of His culture to challenge the prevailing notion that non-Jews were inferior to Jews. In either case, the woman's response shows her faith and humility, and Jesus commends her for her great faith and heals her daughter.
@markcannon8522 he wasnt a nationalist Jew, but many of his disciples were, he wanted to teach them that their supremacist pride was foolish, and that he would help anyone regardless of being Jewish or Gentile. If he really disregarded the woman as a dog, then he wouldnt give her food and a place in the kingdom of Heaven
Because Jesus is a figure from the extremely ethnocentric judean traditions, simple as
Not really.
@Jesus is King When Jesus said Salvation comes from the Jews he was referring to himself. And later he said It doesn't matter where you are or what religion you belong to; you can worship God. True worship is in spirit and in truth. Jesus came didn't came primarily for the lost sheep of Israel. He came for all humans. However, the gospel was preached first to the Jews because they were waiting for the Messiah. Once again, there is no favoritism in Christianity. There is neither Jew nor Gentile in Christ.
@N1g3r You are obviously not a Christian.
@N1g3r When Jesus was on earth, he went to the lost Sheep of Israel. However, most Jews didn't accept him as the Savior. After the resurrection Jesus said, ”As you sent me into the world, I have sent them into the world” (John 17:18), and he told his disciples, ”Go into all the world and preach the good news to all creation” (Mark 16:15). Besides, I don’t deny that Christianity has Hebrew/Judean roots, but Christianity is a UNIVERSAL and not an ethno-religion. Moreover, St. Paul's teachings are in line with the teachings of Christ.
This video is complete BS
Also, the crumbs symbolize rumors about Jesus and His teachings being picked up by some of the gentiles.
Jesus didn't only delivered the sick child He also delivered some from their prejudice.
This is helpful ive been looking for some answers in this verse thank you.
The first thing is that the last called Jesus "son of david". And the only people that called Jesus was the Jews. Canaanites did not call Jesus son of David. She was trying to act like a Jew. He wanted her to get away from her pretense.
maybe
He wasn’t comparing her to a dog. He called her a dog cuz the Canaanites were open to all doctrines and mixed them together and into a jumbled mess. He’s telling her that his teachings are for Israel and our set part. When she says she can get something out of them even if they’re just crumbs then he sees that she hasand what he is teaching. It has nothing to do with food. The food is his teaching.
I Love my "Kyon".
lul
So, if I say to people “you are like a dog” they should not be offended, right? Maybe I should explain that I am just following Jesus example. They’ll be so happy 😅
I like your humour sense brother 🤜🤛
The word "meet" in this context means "proper" or "appropriate." So when Jesus says "It is not meet to take the children's bread and to cast it to the dogs," He is saying that it is not proper or appropriate to take something that is meant for one group of people (the children) and give it to another group (the dogs).
In this passage, Jesus is speaking with a Canaanite woman who has come to Him asking for healing for her daughter. At first, Jesus seems to ignore her, but when His disciples urge Him to send her away, He tells her that His mission is to the lost sheep of the house of Israel. The woman persists in asking for help, and Jesus responds with the statement about not giving the children's bread to the dogs.
Some scholars interpret Jesus' statement as a test of the woman's faith and persistence. Others suggest that He may have been using the language and attitudes of His culture to challenge the prevailing notion that non-Jews were inferior to Jews. In either case, the woman's response shows her faith and humility, and Jesus commends her for her great faith and heals her daughter.
@@Hoenuman5 If you have to explain that the word "...." means something else, why use it at all? Has language lost its communicative powers?
@@estuchedepeluche2212It wasnt about her, It was about the disciples. The goal of Jesus in that passage was to show his disciples that he was going to help anyone, be It Jew or Gentile. Many of his disciples were Jewish supremacists, and they were offended at Gentiles asking food for Jesus. Jesus, knowing that, and also knowing the woman would remain faithful, he says what is in their mind, then grants her food and a place in Heaven in the front of them. And they realize their sentiment is foolish and that Jesus teachings and charities were for everybody. Thats the moral of this passage
@@maroneveg Cool!
Don’t forget about Matthew 11:6. Blessed are those who are not offended by me are Jesus Christ words. Jesus was sent to unite the children of Israel it was not time for the gentiles yet. He wanted to test her resolve and she passed by humbling herself and gave a great response. That’s why she was blessed.
The reason why Jesus didn't answered her at first was because she was a Canaanite woman pretending to be a Jew using the term "Son of David" >
He answered her after she dropped the term "Son of David"
“Lord, help me!” she said. >
kunarion
Strong's Concordance
kunarion: a little dog
Original Word: κυνάριον, ου, τό
Part of Speech: Noun, Neuter
Transliteration: kunarion
Phonetic Spelling: (koo-nar'-ee-on)
Definition: a little dog
Usage: a little dog, a house dog.
To help you understand better, the word dog in ancient Greek is κύων but the suffix -άριον is used in diminutive nouns, meaning words that express smaller or more tender forms of the object they describe.
For example:
"δάκτυλος" (finger) → "δακτύλιον" (small finger) "κύων" (dog) → "κυνάριον" (small dog/puppy)
"πλοῖον" (ship) → "πλοιάριον" (small ship)
This suffix gives the word a diminutive or affectionate character, often indicating something smaller or cuter than usual. So the word dog here is meant as a loving puppy
If God's all knowing wouldn't he know she was worthy?
He knew, so what? This is why you should read the whole context instead of asking dumb question. Jesus was trying to teach his disciple/israelites a lesson here, the message is in fact for us.
@@None-if3mo oh, I get. Eat the crumbs, dog. You can only eat what your master drops on the dirty floor
I dont eat from his or her table last time i checked they eat of the table i keep on trying to create
Another interpretation is based in the drawing out of what "is" in Mathew, instead of reading into Mathew what you wish to be in Mathew. Mathew reveals Jesus blatantly saying he came for the Jewish people, not the Gentiles. Furthermore, Jesus referred to the Gentiles as being outside his goal, or mission, because he was only interested in preaching to Jewish people. Jesus was Jewish, was raised in a Jewish family, and only had Jewish followers. This is why he said, "I was not sent except to the lost sheep of the house of Israel." The woman continued to 'beg' Jesus for help and Jesus said, "It is not good to take the children's bread and throw it to the little dogs." After Jesus appears to be admitting he thinks very poorly of non Jewish people he states he believes they should not be fed because feeding the Jewish people matters more to him and his mission. Only when the woman excepts Jesus' low opinion of her (little dog) does Jesus agree to help her.
This is not true at all, it irritates me nobody gets this parable, Jesus said to her "u dont take the food of children and give it to dogs", first of all in greek this version of dog is referring to Housepet type of dog, and even if u didnt know that, did u catch the Caananites womans response she said" Yes Jesus but even house pet dogs are given the scraps of food by their masters", keyword "MASTER"!! Meaning this is dog that kept by the master, which is in ur house, which is a beloved pet animal, he is not insulting her and she didnt take it as an insult, Jesus uses dog to refer to evil ppl earlier in the gospels and its a different word... and Jesus responses like ur faith is so great ill reward by healing ur daughter..... Jesus primary goal was to rescue the Children of Israel, hence the "Children" reference, we non Jews / Gentiles are the "House Pets" and it was all apart of Gods plan cuz what happened they rejected Jesus, and thats all Jesus was saying like hey im here for the Jews not the not Jews its not ur time yet for me to give you FOODDDD and the woman Responded, saying basically i know u cant gimme Food im not ur child but even im ur loving house pet and even Food aka crumbs is given to the loving housepet. And Jesus was like basically like that that is a great point, ima reward you...and this goes over everyones heads in the comment section
@yesthejets3368 your whole response is basically theological stockholm syndrome.
Man, you make great biblical observations!
Bravo . Glory to God of course.
The kicker to that story is that in all reality,
that came in a woman should not even have existed !
Gob ordered the Hebrews to destroy the Canaanites but instead the Hebrews put them under tribute . (Made them slaves for self advancement.)
The fact that Jesus, after the conversation, said that she had great faith and then healed her, showed that indeed a new dispensation had arrived.
The savior of the world regardless of any past affiliation!
A huge moment!
Jesus let us know that's it's ok to favour and help your own people, your family or people you feel similar to
Its not okay to favour one race over another.
@@cypherpunk12 people do it all the time lol
People who claim to be victims of racism only favour there race, and fail to even notice bad things that happen to other races.
Grow up
@@am4456 I agree with you 100% but that does not make it okay right?
In this story Jesus treated the woman differently because of her race. He is going all about the lands helping the Hebrew people with diseases and even hunger, but the moment he encounters a Phonetician woman he makes her jump though all kinds of hoops to get help. He makes it harder because of her race, is this not racism?
@@cypherpunk12 ok but where does it end?
Is Jesus a racist for not jumping on a boat and going to sub Saharan Africa to help people there in much more need then in Judea??
Your judging Jesus on ideals created by Marxists. And Marx was a Satanist.
Jesus had a mission, he was born within a tribe of Judea
@@cypherpunk12 it kinda is😢
Exactly, friend exactly no matter how he tries to explain it as a pastor the Bible is still saying, Jesus called her dog
It's in plural, He is relating to gentiles .
He is not calling her directly a dog, as you may see this through modern eyes.
John 10:30-36
King James Version
I and my Father are one
Psalms 96:9 - O worship the LORD in the beauty of holiness: fear before him, all the earth
This is a helpful explanation...I'd like to add that one of the 12 disciples was Simon the Canaanite. 👍🏿
I had actually heard that this is not what theGreek means, but that she was proving that she was not a dog by showcasing her great faith in the Messiah.
Jesus knew her response would be of "Great Faith" so He used it as a chance to do so much with the Gentiles who were not seen a Children of God and were seen as having no Faith in God. God wants us to have Great Faith no matter the test at hand.
@ArchimedesBC wow, easy there! If that’s what the Greek means, then, that’s what the Greek means. I’m not a Greek scholar. I’m just telling you some thing I heard. He could’ve been right or he could’ve been wrong. I’m not sure. I have a need a clear example either from scripture or another Greek text from the same time. That uses those terms in two different ways, and clarification, but it meant that in that original text. this person isn’t the only source to point out the difference that may exist between these two words, but I don’t know Greek, well enough to confirm or dispute that claim on my own grounds. Blessings!
Wow what a bunch of lies
הב-הב
But he who is joined with all the living has hope, for a living dog is better than a dead lion.
Ecclesiastes 9:4
When Jesus refused her, does that make Jesus unloving or how does love ❤️ thy neighbor as yourself apply here in context ?
Personally I think Jesus knows what he’s doing & it’s about his priority in his mission at that juncture. Most people might expect Jesus to show too much love ❤️ to that woman but it’s a very worldly understanding of Love. Jesus is not going to waste time showing this emotional love to everyone because that’s very shallow & that is not his Purpose.
Jesus tests people’s faith all the time and heals them. Yet every time atheists claim this is something bad 🙄
I read Mark and it sounds like Jesus is giving this woman sage advice like he is picking up on what she is doing in her life and giving her advice to put the children first. She agrees and says Yes Lord and then he heals her daughter and demons removed. Jesus can be misunderstood often. If he truly thought she was a dog and called her a dog such as said "I would heal you but YOU ARE A DOG" that would be different. Those who give sage advice because they are empaths know we can pick up on personal things about people and guide them in the right direction. Chances are this woman was doing something to invite demons into her life.
What if she gave up after the first try that would have been really sad and really bad even the 12 keep telling Jesus tomsend her away yo what does that say about them?!?!?
In Hebrew, He called her a house dog.
She called herself a dog first. And Jesus, in fact, was even harsher than described.. but it was all an act, a show by Jesus, as every great teacher does, because He wanted to teach the disciples a lesson; that He is here for everyone who needs Him, irrespective of them being Jew or Gentile, and that there are many who yearn for Him.
Read Poem of the Man God chapter 330. To understand it further, read from Chapter 325. Jesus and the disciples have been insulted and driven away from so many places that the disciples are furious by how He is being treated, say that there is no point spreading the message to these people, no one here needs Him, and even loving and tender John begins to scheme to physically assault a few who insulted Jesus. Jesus is deeply hurt by the disciples' behaving this way despite Him teaching them love and forgiveness.
The Canaanite woman comes to Jesus as He is leaving a house early in the morning. He is "inexplicably hard" towards the woman. He even says to Jonah, who has hosted Him, "«I have no time, Jonah. I have a long way to go and in any case I have come for the sheep of Israel."
The woman desperately pleads to Him saying "«I saw You yesterday while You were crossing the torrent and I heard them call You: “Master.” I followed You, among the bushes, and I heard what these people were saying. I understood who You are... And I came here this morning before daybreak and I remained here, on the threshold, like a little dog, until Sarah got up and made me go in. Have mercy, my Lord, on a mother and a little girl!
But Jesus is walking fast and turns a deaf ear to her entreaties.
The people of the household say to her: «Resign yourself! He will not listen to you. He said so Himself: He has come for the children of Israel...»
She is desperate but at the same time full of faith, and she stands up saying: «No. I will pray until He listens to me.» And she follows the Master shouting her entreaties, which draw to the doors of the houses in the village all those who are already awake and who, like the people of Jonah's household, begin to follow her to see what happens.
In the meantime the apostles, seized with astonishment, look at one another and whisper: «Why is He doing that? He has never done it before!...»»
In the meantime the apostles, seized with astonishment, look at one another and whisper: «Why is He doing that? He has never done it before!...»
And John says: «He cured also those two people at Alexandroscene.» «But they were proselytes» replies Thaddeus.
«And what about the woman He is going to cure now?»
«She is a proselyte as well» says the shepherd Annas.
«Oh! but how many times has He cured Gentiles or heathens! And what about the Roman girl?...» says Andrew desolately, as he cannot set his mind at rest seeing Jesus' harsh behaviour towards the Cananean woman.
After even more drama and exchanges between Jesus and the woman, Jesus finally lights up with joy seeing her faith and persistence of the Gentile woman, that has persisted for so long, right in front of the disciples who were alarmed by Jesus' harshness ("...while Andrew whispers: «Poor woman!», and John repeats continuously: «I do not understand... I do not understand...» John is dumbfounded at Jesus' behaviour.")
He blesses her, and says to the disciples:
«But, Master, why did You make her implore You so much, before listening to her?» asks James of Zebedee.
«Through your fault and the fault of all of you. That is not a defeat, James. I was not expelled, derided or cursed here... Let that be a relief to your disheartened spirits. I have already had today My most delicious food. And I bless God for it. And now let us go and see this other woman who believes and can wait with firm faith.»
Well there are parts we don't discuss. Jesus ignored her and didn't just call her a dog He called all of her people dogs, and He did not help her until she learned the Israelites come first and her place was under the table. We don't need to sugar coat it. It is what it is.
Those who curse his people will be cursed and those who bless his people will be blessed. If we believe that Jesus is Lord and He can see into the future and know all things, it's not hard to see why He called people dogs nowadays.
Jesus' people are those who believe in him, regardless of whether Jews or Gentiles. In fact, the Jews who reject Christ and the Gospel are not his people. Concerning the Gentiles, God says in the prophecy of Hosea, “Those who were not my people, I will now call my people. And I will love those whom I did not love before.” Romans 9:25. Christians are already blessed by their faith in Jesus. Besides, God is not a respecter of persons. Stop inserting your own views into the bible and pretend that Gentiles are second-class people. Matthew 21:43 Having denounced the sin, Christ now enunciates the punishment thereof, in continuation of his parable. Because ye slay the Son, reject the Cornerstone, the vineyard, i.e. the kingdom of God, shall be taken from you. Ye shall no longer be God's peculiar people; your special privileges shall be taken away. It's obvious that you have your knowledge about Christianity from these TV preachers and mega-churches.
@@carlomariaromano4320 Carlo at the end of the day the isrealites will get the favortism even though gentiles can be saved as well, the new jerusalem is only for isrealites that make it
@@everydaynine_2282 There is no favoritism for Israelites according to the New Testament. Romans 2:11 For God does not show favoritism. In fact the new Israel is the Church. You are not a Christian this is crystal clear.
@@carlomariaromano4320 I meant God only promised Abraham that his seed/bloodline will get the promise, Jesus even told the lady “in short”. Why will I give what’s to the children into the dogs.
Jesus was meaning why would I give what’s for my bloodline children unto the step child; still because of the woman faith he blessed her. The New Jerusalem is only for Israel not for the other nations, it has 12 Gates not 1 gate. Only for the 12 tribes
In the kingdom Israel will be on top
@@everydaynine_2282 You are not a real Christian. According to the New Testament, The Jews who reject the Gospel and Christ are not the Chosen people anymore. Christians and the Church are the New Israel. God won't forget Israel though. Modern day secular Israel is not the Israel of the promise nor the bible. Besides, Jesus himself told the Jews that the Kingdom of God will be taken from them and be given to other people. Of course, this bible verse you ignore. Anyway, faith not bloodline saves. Jews and Gentile alike are saved by faith in Christ. Hence, being a physical descendant of Abraham means nothing when you reject Christ. Arabs are the physical descendant and blood of Abraham, too. Who cares? The promise to Israel and the Jews was always conditional to begin with.
well the jews still think of us as dogs and in a bad way unlike jesus' pup dog. why isnt dog translated puppy dog to show the true intention of jesus isntead people always freak out about this verse. the bible has many such inappropriate translations for english.
Why did Jesus say not give the dogs the holy scripture or throw them your pearls because they will turn around and attack you.
Because he didn’t say that. He said, “Do not give dogs what is sacred.”. Dogs here are hypocrites as is clear in the context. What is “sacred” in context is something valuable, just like “pearls.”. The context is teaching some people are hypocrites and will not value what is important.
"His duty was to the people of Israel, not to the Gentile, are we people of Israel or gentile?
Bro I’m sorry you have the worst understanding of the Bible…
The meaning behind this story is to show that it’s all About faith, because as we can see, Jesus still Grants her wish at the end, because she had great faith. Jesus was showing how his ministry rn may be towards the Jews, but it’s open for everyone who has faith. Nothing racist, just your lack of understanding the Bible
I subscribed because I got a whole lot of questions please, Please help me with this question, there is a place I read but can't seem to remember the vers when the Bible said "with more knowledge comes more pain. Please help me explain if you see the vers
Ecclesiastes 1 : 18
Listen man, a person with a will to know could look into Canaan and see the answers to this question. The answers however have some implications depending on who understands them. Firstly he called her a dog because it’s the symbol of Canaan. (See: Canaan Dog)
His behavior toward his is because of something we don’t see from Jesus any other time in the Bible; kinship. He tells the woman she doesn’t need his blessing, she already has it and to be home with her child. You see, jesus was a Canaanite. This is why he calls Jews, Jews. And doesn’t call people gentiles. They are just gods children, people, his people.
Knowledge plays a role. The son of man, is what Jesus claimed to be, it’s what he taught his followers. Why did he ask “what do you say I am”? Because in his mind he was just a messenger of the most high, elio(Canaanite: el of mine) as he said on the cross. The son of man isn’t a messiah, a king, he is an anointer, a cup of gods love. He is the product of mankind, a soul god keeps here all the time to gauge the progress of the human experience. He isn’t a judge, or a king, but a leader and a follower what we call Peer. What he wanted to hear was these people were listening to his actions when he said “who do you say I am”. His hope was they would “just as me”.
Nazarites we’re around before Hebrews…and it was documented. Jesus was titled “Nazarene” in life. The church said he was “of Nazareth” the error here is Nazareth was not a founded city until 300ad. Before this for over a thousand years Nazareth existed under many names, the word literally means “house of the eye”, the Nazarite those under the vow of the most high left a trinket where they travelled a Nazar 🧿. This symbol can be found in a time far older than any happenings of the Middle East, or most of the Egyptian histories. It is first recorded as a intact symbol in the caucus and Himalayas around 3000bc, before the time of King Gilgamesh, Numrod, or the Tower of Babel. The leader of this group, who is just a Nazarite himself, a peer, is called “Nazarene” which means “the upper eye” and would be seen as the high priest/king of the group of nomads that was Nazareth in biblical times. Melchizedek was one of these Nazarite, and Jesus was said to be the last high priest in order of Melchizedek. Melchizedek was also a Canaanite, not a Jew, and gave blessing to an Iraqi not a Hebrew.
Correct verses (13:39)- 13:39) Allah effaces whatever He wills and retains whatever He wills. With Him is the Mother of the Book.
“He’s not calling her a dog”
And this word means small pet or dog 😂
Wow!! This is some twisting of words!! Jesus called the women a dog and that is a pathetic thing to say.
Truth hurts
They would hurt if I was a christian and the god I believed in was a big jerk. I would not want to follow a person like that at all.
@@laurodavalos1685 i hope you're never a parent
@@jjs44544 I am and i would never call my daughters dogs! What kind of person does that. I hope you don’t.
@@laurodavalos1685 Jesus called a dog a dog not his children
That was harsh. If that was Christ's only goal, then explain John 3:16?
Question and Answer perspective how can this passage related to Luke16:19-21😂😂😂😂
I thought the caananite people were destroyed please explain
After having been a cause of scandal in his homeland, in Nàzaret, and having received the announcement of the death of John the Baptist, Jesus had withdrawn on the boat, in a deserted place, on the sidelines: nevertheless a large crowd had followed him on foot, leaving the
city. Now, after having reproached Peter for doubting and having been a man of little faith, and having discussed with scribes and Pharisees about what causes uncleanness to men (Matthew 15: 1-20), he withdraws again, this time. in pagan land, in the area of Tire and Sidone: there too he is joined, not by an Israelite crowd, but by a pagan woman. The counterpoint, in truth, between Jesus' retreat and his attracting a multitude to himself in this way, is even stronger than the previous one: in fact, the woman is one, but she is the symbol of all the nations to which the gospel, to the ends of the earth (Acts 1,8).
The starting point, for the infidels, is the same as for the Israelites: their daughter is possessed by a demon. Common is the fatigue of living for all men, without distinction: being paralyzed by sin, slaves to one's vices, not being able to flourish. However, Jesus' reaction is very different: in Israel he never tires of teaching; here he instead he doesn't utter a word. In fact, in his short life, Jesus only addressed the Jews: it is the price of the incarnation, self-limitation of the One who is infinite in a defined point in time and space. Just as he was unable to make his earthly voice heard if not for a few years, so he was unable to push it except within a limited region.
Nonetheless, his Word has come down to us through the centuries: thanks to the testimony of his disciples, from generation to generation, in an unbroken chain (Luke 1,1-4; 1 John 1,1-3). The delimitation of his historical mission requires our involvement: we become missionaries together with him, children of the same Father. However, that woman already received the gift of healing her daughter directly from Jesus: how did she manage to force him, to anticipate her times? Jesus himself gives the answer: through the greatness of his faith. In women, faith is recognizing in herself her own need and indigence, and in Jesus the medicine capable of healing her, the bread capable of satisfying her (John 6:35). However, it is enough for her to collect a single crumb of the bread multiplied in the desert, a particle of the Eucharist: and then, as the desert was transformed into a garden (Matthew 14:19). The Son offered his body for everyone, so that each one, welcoming it, learns in turn to live as a son.
He is still comparing a human to an unclean pet animal, this is still extremely offensive. This is also based on her race, because the Jews are concerned a race, so it's also quite racist. Simply put he's putting her second based on her race, that is pretty much the definition of racist. Calling someone a "dog" in the English language is offensive but calling them "a little pet dog" is not much better. Am I missing something here, or is this a blatantly offensive way to treat someone?
No, it was not about race, but about religion. The Canaanites had human sacrifices. From the context, it is clear, that Jesus was testing this Canaanite woman and taught the apostles a lesson. A little pet dog that belonged to the family is not comparable to a stray dog. Yes, Jesus was provocative here, but to illustrate things. However, he compared the Pharisees with snakes and called them worse names than a little pet dog.
@@carlomariaromano4320 What religion were the Canaanites, how did you come to the conclusion they had human sacrifices? To which deity and why? If you follow the Bible, the Jews also had human sacrifices, there was 3 we know of with Jesus. If it was about religion why not simply say her religion and not her race? They identified her religion based solely on her race, this is called racial profiling. If Jesus were the son of God he would have known this woman was a good person, so he tested her for nothing, made her admit she was inferior to teach the disciples a lesson.
Dog was a massive insult especially when compared to a human, whether a pet or a stray, its still disgusting to make such a comparison, to assume that someone is inferior because of their parents.
As for teaching the disciples a lesson, I think this is where I somewhat agree. But think of it like this, what if a doctor made someone admit they were like a dog before he helped them, based on their ethnicity and assumed religion and practices? You know it would be wrong, you wouldn't make excuses for this doctor, you wouldn't try and say "hes teaching the other doctors a lesson" would you? At the end of the day you can see that its racist, but because its Jesus you will make special excuses.
Did you know this is one of the two main parts of the Bible used by the Ku Klux Klan, to justify their racism? The first is they claim the mark of Cain is black skin, (Bible does not actually say what the mark is). They believe that the Greek/Phonetician woman had darker skin than the Israelites and Greek people did. The KKK will actually help another race if they admit they are inferior to them, just like Jesus did here.
I don't support racism period. I don't make special exceptions for anyone with racism.
@@cypherpunk12 👏 Carlos can't argue with your comment.
@@freespirit7450 I wrote more than 3 sentences, its very rare that people will read my whole comment. The trouble is people do not want to admit the bible has bad parts. I actually challenge people to find any being that has done more horrid stuff than the God of the Bible, real or fictional. I have yet to have someone even come close.
@@cypherpunk12 How far are you willing to learn because I have a bunch of BibleProject videos and podcasts that answer all those questions you asked. But its going to be a days worth of content because they dive deep into every little detail and nuance and go into the language, culture, context, literary styles and the cultures surrounding them. They are on UA-cam and spotify and have a website. But this may take up to 8 hours of learning just by your comment alone.
BASED
Good vid but guy presenting is just a little too animated. Just tone it down like 10%.
I guess it is fine to have a strong faith in being God Almighty, not YHWH anymore, which sounds absurd.
Fantastic. Im a pet dog.
Or He was complimenting her. Dogs have a good sense with their nose. He could been saying you were a good dog for discerning He was a good guy with knowing how to find Him as a dog could follow a scent and get to what it's looking for. Imagine a dog trying to find what its looking for. What it's desire is to find and yet He was so much more compared to a small dog. Also, dog is God spelled backwards.
Wrong, Jesus was sent to the lost sheep of the house of Israel. Now grace is given to all at the time salvation was of the Jews and Gentiles get blessings by blessing Israel for being Gods people. It was a dispensational matter, Jesus told them go not to the Gentiles. Now we can be saved by believing the gospel of the grace of God regardless of Jew or Gentiles 1 Corinthians 15:1-4
you could be right.
What the hell are u talking about😂
@@The_Mosaic What are you incapable of understanding?
@@fairymairah only God is right sister. What is of the Spirit is spirit and of the flesh is flesh.
9:111] Surely Allah has purchased of the believers their lives and their belongings and in return has promised that they shall have Paradise. They fight in the Way of Allah, and slay and are slain. Such is the promise He has made incumbent upon Himself in the Torah, and the Gospel, and the Qur'an.
3:01
So.. jesus is a prophet after all!
Cool
What nobody ever said Jesus wasn’t a prophet lol. I think you might be confused
@@Wait8OO aren't you guys syaing that he's god?
@@ay_yowtf a prophet is someone who is sent by God to deliver a message Jesus is the son of God but he was also sent with the message of salvation so he can also be considered a prophet (being a prophet doesnt disprove he is the son of God because he can still be a prophet while being the son of God
Testing her? Show me that book chapter verse. 1 peter 2 says there was no deceit in his mouth. He meant what he said, that woman was annoying him so he gave her a crumb, not the bread. Rev 22 14 15 says dogs have no rights to the tree of life and wont enter the gates 😂😂
I love the Bible but I hate Christianity because of its plethora of false pagan doctrines. The Bible is a book, written by Israelites, for Israelites. Then people (gentiles) got the book, read it and started to insert themselves into the book and there’s where the confusion began.
Fine, let’s say Jesus was creating some metaphor which he is not, what do you say about the disciples who had the same mind? Was Jesus talking to them about this so called metaphor before the woman came up? If you say yes, show me the scripture that has this conversation? I bet you that you can’t because you don’t want to accept the truth.
The Bible is not an all inclusive book. Even in Deuteronomy God forbid a Canaanite to enter into the congregation and hated them and remember Esau’s wife was Canaanite and it displeased God and his father. The fact of the matter is, Jesus did not care for the Canaanite woman and neither did the 12 disciples and that’s why she was called a dog. She even acknowledged herself as a dog and because she did that and had faith that Christ would heal her daughter, Christ gave her a crumb. Her daughter could get sick the next day, he did accept her and her daughter.
Do you know that the Samaritan lady at the well was an Israelite? Do you know the difference between a Jew and an Israelite? All the real Jews are Israelite but not all Israelite are Jews. Samaria was the capitol of the northern kingdom which was scattered before Christ came and the Southern Kingdom (Judah, Benjamin, Levi) and they did not like each other. So that’s why she was surprised that Christ spoke to her. She realized that Christ was a Jew, perhaps by his attire maybe language. So how am I so sure that she was an Israelite?
John 4:12
King James Version
12 Art thou greater than OUR FATHER Jacob, which gave us the well, and drank thereof himself, and his children, and his cattle?
She acknowledged Jacob as her forefather. I say that to say, some of the people who you may think are of other nations are actually Israelite! Paul was an Israelite and a Roman. So when you see Paul writhing to the Romans, it wasn’t everybody in Rome, it was to the Roman Israelites (Northern Kingdom) scattered who were referred to as Gentiles because they adopted the ways of their captors. The book of Maccabees explain all of this.
So then you see a Christian take up the book and see that there are no Jew nor Greek, not knowing its a reference to the Southern Kingdom (Judah) and the Northern Kingdom and that the Northern Kingdom was forced to adopt the customs and identity of the Greek whilst in slavery, the use it to say that Greek means every other gentile and that Israel is done away with.
That’s the problem when you read a book that is not yours and wasn’t meant to be taught by you! You insert yourself and start lying on the scriptures just like this guy is doing because he can’t phantom that the image of Christ they painted is a wrong one.
CHRIST SAID OUT OF HIS OWN MOUTH THAT HE WAS ONLY SENT UNTO THE LOST TRIBE OF ISRAEL BUT PEOPLE DONT WANT TO ACCEPT IT.
The sooner you accept it and find out who the real children of Israel are and cling to them, the sooner you get on your path to being saved. If you don’t know who the real people are and you hate them, you are as good as dead! You can’t love God and hate his people.
Edit: Believe it or not, there’s only one group of people who were sent to the four corners of the earth as slaves for over 400 years and people hate to this day with no logical reasoning behind it. I’m not going to mention who they are, you know who they are, but the spirit that is upon you don’t want you to say it. All of this has been spoken of by the prophets. So keep believing the imposters and pretty soon you will say these very words.
Jeremiah 16:19
King James Version
19 O Lord, my strength, and my fortress, and my refuge in the day of affliction, the Gentiles shall come unto thee from the ends of the earth, and shall say, Surely our fathers have inherited lies, vanity, and things wherein there is no profit.
God loves mankind so much that he died for them. Does God not love the angels? If yes why can’t angels have children? If God doesn’t love angels who love him I will. If he won’t hear them I will I’d give an angel my birthright.
Are you referring to the Old Testament when the Angels left heaven to be with the daughters of men?
@@solaceboy God Jesus= Angel God doesn’t have a seed and he himself isn’t allowed children
@@solaceboy bruh🤣
God is Love
@@sarahforg4643 but isnt jesus the son of God?
This guy should get into politics if he ever gets tired of selling cars and life insurance.
Learn your bible passages!!!!!!!
That is your own interpretation of the text.
The word "meet" in this context means "proper" or "appropriate." So when Jesus says "It is not meet to take the children's bread and to cast it to the dogs," He is saying that it is not proper or appropriate to take something that is meant for one group of people (the children) and give it to another group (the dogs).
In this passage, Jesus is speaking with a Canaanite woman who has come to Him asking for healing for her daughter. At first, Jesus seems to ignore her, but when His disciples urge Him to send her away, He tells her that His mission is to the lost sheep of the house of Israel. The woman persists in asking for help, and Jesus responds with the statement about not giving the children's bread to the dogs.
Some scholars interpret Jesus' statement as a test of the woman's faith and persistence. Others suggest that He may have been using the language and attitudes of His culture to challenge the prevailing notion that non-Jews were inferior to Jews. In either case, the woman's response shows her faith and humility, and Jesus commends her for her great faith and heals her daughter.
🚨🐍🚨 [13:39] GOD erases whatever He wills, and fixes. With Him is the original Master Record.
[9:111] GOD has bought from the believers their lives and their money in exchange for Paradise. Thus, they fight in the cause of GOD, willing to kill and get killed. Such is His truthful pledge in the Torah, the Gospel, and the Quran-and who fulfills His pledge better than GOD? You shall rejoice in making such an exchange. This is the greatest triumph.
Jesus knew exactly what He was doing and what her response would be & would rub it in every Jew person's face for her amazing faith.
Soooo call Him racist, bad, whatever.... lol... He's not gonna be provoked by future accusations of people like us & change His plan & the lesson taught & her name mentioned & praised in the Bible above Jews, etc. Lol. He created that woman & and loved her equally and knew exactly what He was doing.
After hearing that jesus is definitely a flawed man, he is no "son of god" and muslims are completely correct in demoting him to messenger status...
Absolute and total nonsense..
Maybe he was speaking the minds of his disciples about what they were thinking of that woman. GOD has every right to call everyone dogs, he even called Israelite priestly class as brood of vipers. But He forgave them all. Beggars are not choosers. He tested her faith. God looks at our heart and not flesh/race. Maybe he was breaking the norms of racism, when you break a house its dust also falls on you too, you can't escape it. When you try to clean a house, it is obvious you will also get little dirty. When you preach someone from another language, you first learn their language & beliefs and then change it. Isn't it? There were (and still are) different versions of "gods" which belonged to different groups and races, He was trying to break that norm.
Naming calling really? Childish.
The vipers were referenced again in rev 3:9
Stop that cringe sound in the back ground.
That Canaanite Woman was a Phoenician, as said in Matthew 7:26, and Jesus stating that he was sent not, but to the lost sheep of the house of Israel, that is what she was.
Phoenicians are from the Hebrew Tribe of Asher, who mixed with the Northern Canaanite Tribes, and follow Canaanite Polytheism, because of their Hebrew mixed Canaanite Heritage.
This Phoenician Woman was a lost tribe of Israel, cause she is descended from Asher, one of the 12 sons of Jacob/Israel.
Jesus was never talking about these evil spawns from Judah, when saying that he came for the lost sheep of the house of Israel.
Not true
Because jesus is love and all that shiet Amirite?
Outright racism. I refuse to believe that Jesus Christ said such a disgusting thing.
dogs are wrathful and savages, it's a comparison to how the people from that area were, and when the woman proved to Jesus she wasn't like that and she had faith, he saw that she was good, and healed her daughter
people in other countries served Baal and the enemies of our creator and were dogs and sorcerers and really wicked so their view of the world was not that great, and Jesus knows that not everyone is bad so like with this woman he helps them too
Jesus was a great guy! He had a sense of humor. People without humor don't have little children throng to them.
I think he was bantering with her. He was a real human being, 100% man, while also 100% God, so he had a sense of humor as well as all the other emotions. He had fierce anger such as when He chased the money changers et al out of the Temple grounds. (incidentally, this is the start of the "International Whip a Banker Day") He cried when His good buddy Lazarus died. He hid Himself at times.
So, He had the full range of emotions just like any other healthy human being. The way I see it He was teasing the woman, her reply brought her a reward. She had a wry sense of humor as did Jesus.
He called her a dog and she claimed to be a puppy. How can you kick a puppy? No, you would give a puppy, even a wild puppy, food. Jesus had heart!
Here, the story of the gentile woman not only proves Jesus’ mercy and his power to cure a child from a distance, but it also builds up suspense in a series of ten passages that refer to food, with a minor theme of not understanding:
Jesus and the disciples had no leisure so much as to eat , so they went into a desert place (6:31-32)
Feeding the 5000 (6:33-44)
When Jesus walked on water the disciples were amazed, for they considered not the miracle of the loaves (6:45-54)
Pharisees complain about the disciples eating with unwashed hands (7:1-8)
Discourse - what goes into a man goes into his belly and does not defile (7:9-23)
Greek woman metaphorically begs for crumbs from the table (7:24-30)
Feeding the 4000 (8:1-9)
Disciples are hungry and have only one loaf of bread (8:13-14)
Jesus warns the disciples about the leaven of the Pharisees and they reason, "It is because we have no bread," showing they do not understand (8:15-17)
Summary by Jesus of the two feasts (8:18-21)
Also During that time period dogs was just another name for a Gentile. A non-Jewish person.
Also No one called the Romans dogs. It was basically just the Gentiles. If you remember the story of the Good Samaritan, the Samaritan was even lower than the DOGS..and Jesus even healed roman soldier and all roman soldiers were gentiles, ( were not jews). Jesus says to the listening crowd, that he had never seen such faith in all of Israel, meaning that this gentile had more belief than any of the jews establishment.. He says from verse 11 “ i say to you that many will come from the east and the west, and will take there places at the feast with abraham, isaac and jacob in the kingdom of heaven. But the subjects of the kingdom will be thrown outside into the darkness, where there Will be wailing and gnashing of teeth”…. God bless..
It wasnt about her, It was about his disciples. See, Jesus knew the woman would remain faithful, and he knew that among his disciples, some were offended at a Gentile woman asking food from him. Because many of Jesus followers were Jewish supremacists. So he teached them this lesson, that his teachings and charities were for everybody, be them Gentiles or Jews. And eventually all his disciples understood that
That's the biggest "crock of bull" I've ever heard.
Jesus was a Jew, therefore, he followed the doctrine of the Jews...............that is, Jews are God's "chosen people". Everybody else was INFERIOR.
That's right Jesus was RACIST...................I repeat: RACIST........the disciples were just as RACIST. They kept telling Jesus "Send her away. She's not one of us (Jews)".
Apologists like the guy who made this video will always find "ways around it" to fit their narrative.
Of course, those who don't open their mind will just lower their eyes and continue their "belief".
This guy says "At this time in Jesus life" he's there for the Jews not for the "low lifes"(the Gentiles).
In fact, even to this day, Jews continue their belief of SUPERIORITY.........look at what they're doing to the Palestinians.
In fact, their doctrine says that Gentiles will be slaves to the Jews. Google it. I believe it's in the Talmud/Torah.
u gotta good pooint, but u gotta realize they threw Jesus out of the synagogue after telling them about what God did for the "gentiles"
you also gotta read the whole bible how "God of Israel" used the Assyrians, Persians, Egyptians, Babylonians to scatter the Jews around the world for their rebellion... cutting off their ears, noses, even burning them alive... and how the Lord punished all these nations as a sign for us
study the blessings & curses of Moses, the prophecy of Daniel, etc so you can understand that Jesus isn't just some Jew...how can you say He followed their doctrine when He attacked their doctrine.... and was thrown out by his own people or even crucified.
this all had to happen to fulfill the prophecies of the Lord's prophet... read the prophets you will understand what will happen to the world and Israel in the last days.
Mental gymnastics. If you are not a jew , he thought of you as a dog.
No need to turn to atheism, the ancient Greek gods wouldn't reject you for those reasons.
I don't see and have never seen why most if the world follow their god.
Jesus was clearly testing the faith of the Gentile female. And he called the Jews who rejected him even worse things.
Their god?! God is One. He's common to all the world and is above all His creation inspite of how men with their limited knowledge attempt to comprehend Him and derive conclusions. Absolute truth isn't denied or nullified by perspectives that lack wholesome understanding that's obtained by consideration of well-known and accepted facts that reflect reality. God reveals Himself to those who need Him and no science that doesn't see things as they are with a wide vision can comprehend Him!!! He's too marvellous for the natural human mind, unless it's divinely touched to know/understand Him.
P.S.: Jesus never had the habit of insulting. He didn't insult even those who abused Him though He showed His fierceness whole confronting the hyprocrites who knew the truth and yet didn't take it as anything serious, rejecting God's goodness, perfection, love and justice by their actions. Jesus is known for His meekness. He's the perfect reflection of God and anything contrary indicates that it's far from truth.
🙏
Ohhh I want to learn about the Greek Gods.
Jesus was a great guy! He had a sense of humor. People without humor don't have little children throng to them.
I think he was bantering with her. He was a real human being, 100% man, while also 100% God, so he had a sense of humor as well as all the other emotions. He had fierce anger such as when He chased the money changers et al out of the Temple grounds. (incidentally, this is the start of the "International Whip a Banker Day") He cried when His good buddy Lazarus died. He hid Himself at times.
So, He had the full range of emotions just like any other healthy human being. The way I see it He was teasing the woman, her reply brought her a reward. She had a wry sense of humor as did Jesus.
He called her a dog and she claimed to be a puppy. How can you kick a puppy? No, you would give a puppy, even a wild puppy, food. Jesus had heart!
Here, the story of the gentile woman not only proves Jesus’ mercy and his power to cure a child from a distance, but it also builds up suspense in a series of ten passages that refer to food, with a minor theme of not understanding:
Jesus and the disciples had no leisure so much as to eat , so they went into a desert place (6:31-32)
Feeding the 5000 (6:33-44)
When Jesus walked on water the disciples were amazed, for they considered not the miracle of the loaves (6:45-54)
Pharisees complain about the disciples eating with unwashed hands (7:1-8)
Discourse - what goes into a man goes into his belly and does not defile (7:9-23)
Greek woman metaphorically begs for crumbs from the table (7:24-30)
Feeding the 4000 (8:1-9)
Disciples are hungry and have only one loaf of bread (8:13-14)
Jesus warns the disciples about the leaven of the Pharisees and they reason, "It is because we have no bread," showing they do not understand (8:15-17)
Summary by Jesus of the two feasts (8:18-21)
Also During that time period dogs was just another name for a Gentile. A non-Jewish person.
Also No one called the Romans dogs. It was basically just the Gentiles. If you remember the story of the Good Samaritan, the Samaritan was even lower than the DOGS..and Jesus even healed roman soldier and all roman soldiers were gentiles, ( were not jews). Jesus says to the listening crowd, that he had never seen such faith in all of Israel, meaning that this gentile had more belief than any of the jews establishment.. He says from verse 11 “ i say to you that many will come from the east and the west, and will take there places at the feast with abraham, isaac and jacob in the kingdom of heaven. But the subjects of the kingdom will be thrown outside into the darkness, where there Will be wailing and gnashing of teeth”…. God bless..
@@Hoenuman5 only decent response I got. Anyway besides wipe a banker day, I'm still not a Jesus fan, but I thank you for explaining how bread was used metaphorically.
I also heard the foot washing was something metaphorical for something sexual. Not saying that is true3
Imagine calling black person a small monkey how will he feel is hard to take in and worse it is was jesus
errr wrong. read the didache.
oh and jesus wasnt a jew. not sure why you said the woman was a gentile. those folks were from abraham yet slaughtered due to their transgressions.
I now longer a Christian Im a born again Atheist 🤣🤣🤣🤣 ever looking back
@@user-xu7mn5ks8s Christianity destroyed all the Cultures and religions of Europe even steeling there festivals so they would convert fast enough how the Indo Europeans fell for it I never know.
@@joannechisholm4501 Jesus is the way the truth and the life
@@joannechisholm4501 No, it was People who did that. They used religion, blame the people not the ideology that was purposefully misrepresented….thats coming from a Muslim btw
@@Random131_ It doesnt matter any more religion all the same they poke fun at at each other and pretend to be friend but there not really. It all a front. Im done with religion gone gone done.
@@joannechisholm4501 That's stupid, religion didn't do that, people did... People did the same with many things as well, like skin color for instance.
For your situation, removing religion won't fix it, people will just find another thing to abuse
Am I unclean
Are we dogs
Jesus feed me I'm a hungry puppy arf arf