It seemed like Gayoon was about to cry at the start.Evem Nam jihyun had tears in her eyes at 1:57.I guess because of the disbandment thing. Fighting 4minute!!!
4M always bring something exciting to the table. It's a shame to see this amazing comeback gets completely buried under the traditional, safe innocent concept.
+KpopNoodle People gave it a chance, they just didn't like it. You can't force Korean to like 4 Minutes Hate any more than forcing a Rap fan to like Nine INch Nail death metal. Again the most common complaints I heard is that the hook "bum ba bum ba bum." sounds like fart noise. THis was from younger Netizens fyi and keep in mind it's the young teens that consume anda are the deciding factors for all of these teams.
yeah but Koreans are mean with them... if international fans could vote, 4minute would have at least 4 wins now and they wouldn't have the goodbye stage ;-;
Just the fact that Hyuna was so happy seeing their fans made it alright that they didn't win anything. I was pretty upset that they won nothing for this song, but her smile reminded me that they do this for their fans, not awards. 4minute is truly one of the best girl groups and groups in general. They are so wonderful and humble and loving. I would rather have a Hyuna and 4minute that's smiling all the time over them winning award after award. 4mintue hwaiting!!!!
So... goodbye stage. Please rest well and comeback soon, 4NIA believe in you and will be waiting for you. Thank you for Hate promotions, Act.7 was incredible.
SuperNovah fans and staff since this is their last comeback and this isn't an official competition so they could play around with the hate lyrics and change it to love~♡
even though I didn't become a fan until after their disbandment, it makes me so sad to think that they won't release more music. I really love them. they give of such a different feel from must girl groups
+Andreea Mazalu What I'm seeing is kpop/fans seem to prefer representations of female idols with a mental age of maybe 13 - all the plush toys I see them with - wtf? Portraying women as powerful ain't generally what's wanted is my take on this.
+Ruru 4Nia It had nothing to do with Gfriend. Even if they weren't promoting the chance of 4minute winning was low. Koreans simply didn't like the song.
+joshy77777 If they do disband they can no longer use 4 Minutes songs, but their new company and let them make NEW songs. Songs that they have full creative control over. Cube though Skrillex would be a huge hit in Korea. THey were wrong. Even 4 Mintues felt a bit off with this concept but they decided to make it work.
+Mohammed Ansari BEAST and 4minute are thinking to leave their company for a better one, who works more for the a good of their careers, promotions, their fans, concerts and all...the example is G.na, she ends this year her contract like them and she leaves (confirmed) and Beast and 4minute can leave. If they stay they have a lot of conditions in their hands... Better promotion is one, Cube lack a lot of that. Cube in the last year are more interested in Btob and CLC for something... because if 4minute and Beast left Cube, they will lost a lot.
+Vitalia Aravena Figueroa Yeah but some companies are unethical... Cube sucks but at least they treat our girls well. It's their choice but I just want them to be treated to well. But you're right.
+Vitalia Aravena Figueroa and even CLC got a great debut but their comebacks and promotion are so weak... cube really needs to make their artists shine
Why is youtube recommending me this in 2019.. Do you want me to cry or what? Do you think I dont miss 4Minute? Huh?.... I'm gonna watch it either way and cry
4minute, my girls have to be strong, this happens in every group, there are times when we must say ready we go again. with more force, but for me I am the best and I love this song, I wish only to present the stranger out to see that his followers love them and will always do so, I encourage 4nias. encourage 4minute we can make this the best of the best. as it has always been. Hate, hate, hate, all the time in my head. my girls I love them.
They've won a LOT of shows in the past, and they got so many fans and popularity! There is no reason why Hate wasn't as well received as their older songs :(
Ramyeon Han Too hard hitting for most Koreans I guess. Seeing a female Kpop group sing/rap about hate is basically unheard of. I think Act. 7 would have done better if Canvas was the title track. None the less they went out in the best way possible with a truly unique concept. Never sold out and did the super sexy concept like many girl groups have to do to scrape by.
As they now drop off the top 10 list here in inkigayo, finally its a wrap up. Hope they will comeback bigger and really capture the attention of the masses. Act.7 is still an amazing album. Loved every song in it!
4minute has such a complicated relationship with their fans. One minute they're saying how they hate them then they put up so many hearts. WHICH IS ITTTT
I love these 5 so much. Even without a win, they still smile and show appreciation to their fans. I got teary eyed omf. They didn't win an award, but they've won the hearts and loyalty of so many fans (like me who just became a part of the random). 4MINUTE FIGHTING!
+chatnoir60609 They won't be promoting this song anymore, they may perform it, but they are going back to the pre-comeback period. It's the last, hence goodbye, stage for the song.
chatnoir60609 Nono, even with wins every group has a set promotion period. 4minute sadly isn't as popular as they should be, even crazy had a pretty short promotion period and ppl loved that song.
Bina Bunnie Ohhh, got It. I had no idea. I can't believe they're not popular! Among the kpop fans here (Colombia) they're very popular. I particularly love their style and music. Maybe aegyo style isn't as popular here in latin america but seems to be very popular in Asia. Such a shame, because they're amazing.
They deserve a win. 4min's style is badass I don't want them to fall in the cute side I know it sells better but why can't people see how much effort they put in this? Like, really! And the hearts....If Hyuna does a heart and smile in front of me then I can die in peace
Act. 7 was a fantastic album...i love all of the song which is a rare thing..i know they were more popular internationally but still wished they'd get the same recognition in SK :/ 4minute FIGHTING
So much stage presence, especially from Hyuna. You could have told me this was their concert and not just a music show and I would have believed you. You don’t see this kind of music show performance anymore
i dont want 4minute to disband :(. if ever they'll disband, i have no reason to listen to any kpop songs. i am a 4nia since their debut and 4nia is my fandom. i don't want to hate g-friend for winning 15 times (i think?) but i don't have any reason to like them, too. it hurts me when they didn't win any. where the hell are their fans since hot issue era? where the hell are you when 4minute needs us?. I'm sorry to g-friend fans out there but i "think" they didn't deserve to win. I'm sorry. Please don't disband. :'(((( me and my co-4nia ph will support you all the way. We love you 4Minute ♥♥♥♥♥
My first kpop group. Due to them I got into this amazing world called kpop. And now not seeing them here is heartbreaking. They holded so much power, so much potential. I hate cube.
i was never a huge fan of 4minute up until crazy and this song which gave off a badass vibe p2 (because of crazy obviously). but these girls definitely needed recognition and i get it, people should have tried a little harder but it is difficult when one group (gfriend) sweeps up awards so quickly that there's practically no chance. so you guys, don't be sad about them losing, they just made the wrong timing to come back for everyone. be proud that they had an amazing comeback. be proud that they slayed on stage and are sending everyone hearts on this goodbye stage. you guys did the best you could and they're probably really happy about their fanbase. so let's let them go on a happy note instead of getting upset over conservative south korea and gfriend and winner and international fans.
SLAY 4MINUTE SLAY ❤️ But seriously, I still can't believe they didn't win anything with this absolutely incredible comeback. The song, choreography, outfits ... everything about it was amazing.
i liked it when hyuna changed the lyrics from " i hate you" to "i like you" aweeee 😔😭😭 it's just too sad that they didn't win yet. this song is literally beyond perfection! why don't some koreans don't appreciate this masterpiece? i'm so confused
HyunA's body looks amazing in this performance. it looks like cube are finally letting the girls look after themselves properly (no hate intended) this is the best I've ever seen them they look 😍😍😍
I wanna cry so bad :'( Hate is one of their best songs ever. Even Whatcza Doin Today won 2 awards against 2NE1 and SNSD but it's a shame that 4minute can't beat rookie group even tho that I love GFRIEND, 4minute will be always my ultimate group.
seriously there's so many things only korean fans can do for 4minute unlike international fans like us. If only they would let us vote and stream I know it'll be different.
THE LAST THING SAID ON STAGE BY 4MINUTE WAS "I LOVE YOU" AND IT WAS BY HYUNA, A LAST MESSAGE AS A WHOLE TO FANS AND HER MEMBERS, IM SOBBING
YOU JUST MADE ME CRY T_T
dude hyuna i cant see her anymore bc of hate ._.
ITS ALREADY BEEN MONTHS AND I CANT THINK OF THE DISBANDMENT WITHOUT WANTING TO CRY :/
all of them said 'i love you' BUT YEAH :'(
@@starlight2622 no hyena changed the lyrics
Best goodbye stage ever. I love you, 4Minute!!!
+Mindy Thai goodbye ?
Yeah, their last performance for this promotion period.
Mindy Thai oh nooo...!
Hyuna changing the last lyrics. I love you too girl.
It seemed like Gayoon was about to cry at the start.Evem Nam jihyun had tears in her eyes at 1:57.I guess because of the disbandment thing.
Fighting 4minute!!!
For me 4minute won a million awards already
I am literally crying right now :, ((((((((((((((( they deserved a LOT attention for this, why is the world so unfair
Exactly 😭😭
+fneshat05 you mean "koreans"?
because the rest of the world is falling in love with this song
+fneshat05 Me too !!
4M always bring something exciting to the table. It's a shame to see this amazing comeback gets completely buried under the traditional, safe innocent concept.
+KpopNoodle PREACH IT OMG
Yup, no disrespect to Gfriend, but the innocent concepts are getting old.
+MrMugampi Its the last of the high school trilogy ¬¬
It's all about preference. I prefer Rough more than Hate, but Hate is still a great song.
+KpopNoodle People gave it a chance, they just didn't like it. You can't force Korean to like 4 Minutes Hate any more than forcing a Rap fan to like Nine INch Nail death metal. Again the most common complaints I heard is that the hook "bum ba bum ba bum." sounds like fart noise. THis was from younger Netizens fyi and keep in mind it's the young teens that consume anda are the deciding factors for all of these teams.
At the end when Hyuna said "I like you" instead of "Hate you"
Ohh when ??
+xPampixX chu 3:29
+xPampixX chu the last words she said in the song
I heard "Nana joda" or something I don't know if that means I like you.
+Caca Crumbs yes, that means "I like you" in korean ❤️
굿바이스테이지를 이렇게 개깔롱지게 해놓고 떠나면 어쩌란말이냐아아아
They deserve a win
yeah but Koreans are mean with them... if international fans could vote, 4minute would have at least 4 wins now and they wouldn't have the goodbye stage ;-;
they dont deserved disband
Just the fact that Hyuna was so happy seeing their fans made it alright that they didn't win anything. I was pretty upset that they won nothing for this song, but her smile reminded me that they do this for their fans, not awards. 4minute is truly one of the best girl groups and groups in general. They are so wonderful and humble and loving. I would rather have a Hyuna and 4minute that's smiling all the time over them winning award after award. 4mintue hwaiting!!!!
Finally 4MINUTE say 난 좋아 T_T . Bye and see you soon
+Su Gemini Hyuna is beautiful!
EuropeanAngel1995 all of them are
Su Gemini 4 minute
i don't know who was making the girls smile so much but, thank you ♥
The fans and all of their team watching for sure.
It's their last comeback before they disband so they want to thank everyone for the support
No one:
Literally no one:
UA-cam: it's time to put this on recommendation
True lol
Jiyoon always has an awesome hairstyle!
Alshea agreed
omg Hyuna 😍 the ending was too cute! ♡♡
So... goodbye stage. Please rest well and comeback soon, 4NIA believe in you and will be waiting for you. Thank you for Hate promotions, Act.7 was incredible.
허가윤~~너무 이쁘다!
Who ever it is thats making Hyuna smile.... Gammsahmida!! :)
SuperNovah fans and staff since this is their last comeback and this isn't an official competition so they could play around with the hate lyrics and change it to love~♡
even though I didn't become a fan until after their disbandment, it makes me so sad to think that they won't release more music. I really love them. they give of such a different feel from must girl groups
Omg i'm so angry.How in the hell they didn't win anything with this AWESOME SONG?
+Andreea Mazalu What I'm seeing is kpop/fans seem to prefer representations of female idols with a mental age of maybe 13 - all the plush toys I see them with - wtf? Portraying women as powerful ain't generally what's wanted is my take on this.
They didn't win because Koreans didn't like the song and style.
+Ruru 4Nia It had nothing to do with Gfriend. Even if they weren't promoting the chance of 4minute winning was low. Koreans simply didn't like the song.
+Doug guoD I'm pretty sure it's the style of music they just don't like. It's very western sounding.
+Ruru 4Nia 我也很喜歡四分鐘這次的歌,但是關GFRIEND什麼事啊,就算沒有她們這次米妮也沒有進一位候補啊😏還有值不值得不是你說得算~~~~~
02:43 hyuna smile kills me😍😍😍
HyunA changed the lyrics at the end instead of shireo- chowa (love)
i wanna go to their concert
:)
+Becky Lee Man if they had been at Kcon with crazy last year, I would ahve bout a ticket to go see it.
+Becky Lee *IM SO EXCITED FOR THE DREAM CONCERT !!*
+Becky Lee I love your profile foto x
+Becky Lee Well... now it's always just gonna be a dream for you to go to their concerts 😭💔
지윤님 ~♡소현님 ~♡ 너무 귀엽고 이쁘 ~ 저 분들 너무 소중한 사람들 ᆢ 드라마같은데서 많이 나와줬으면 좋겠따 ~
진짜 간지다... 요즘엔 이런 컨셉이 없어 ㅜㅜ
4minute was the first kpop group I ever listen to back in 2013
Same
me too
Lyfe being a Monbebe Kihyun oh my your profile pic 😂
You know Jiyoon is you bias bc the way she does the heart in the end
"NA NEON CHOA" at the end really killed me, omfg hyuna
What's the meaning?:)
Original line says "I hate you"
goodbye stage line said "I like you"
I love this song. I love this album. I love you 4minute. Come back soon, please. I need you in my life.
Hyuna's smile is life😊😊
현아 저 끼 진짜 미친다..
Hyuna is my spirit animal ! ♥
+Ibtehal Aaliyah Jiyoon is mine.
awesome goodbye stage! I'll miss them :( and they're so cute with all those hearts and Hyuna's 'Nan Neo Joha' at the end
Robert Louis very late but
She said ‘na neon choa’
4nias will always support 4Minute
Hyuna smile during the song Whyy!!! the song don't need a smile ..there is something hhh😎😎
+BTS 2015 It's their goodbye stage :(
4Minute always in heart 4NIA ❤❤❤
im so sad. they deserved so much more with this comeback. i really hope they don't disband
+joshy77777 If they do disband they can no longer use 4 Minutes songs, but their new company and let them make NEW songs. Songs that they have full creative control over. Cube though Skrillex would be a huge hit in Korea. THey were wrong. Even 4 Mintues felt a bit off with this concept but they decided to make it work.
TBH they're a main source of income for CUBE, so I don't think they're gonna disband. But ofc this is wishful thinking.
+Mohammed Ansari BEAST and 4minute are thinking to leave their company for a better one, who works more for the a good of their careers, promotions, their fans, concerts and all...the example is G.na, she ends this year her contract like them and she leaves (confirmed) and Beast and 4minute can leave. If they stay they have a lot of conditions in their hands... Better promotion is one, Cube lack a lot of that.
Cube in the last year are more interested in Btob and CLC for something... because if 4minute and Beast left Cube, they will lost a lot.
+Vitalia Aravena Figueroa Yeah but some companies are unethical... Cube sucks but at least they treat our girls well. It's their choice but I just want them to be treated to well. But you're right.
+Vitalia Aravena Figueroa and even CLC got a great debut but their comebacks and promotion are so weak... cube really needs to make their artists shine
Why is youtube recommending me this in 2019.. Do you want me to cry or what? Do you think I dont miss 4Minute? Huh?.... I'm gonna watch it either way and cry
4Minute's last stage of HATE : (
4Minute fighting!!!
4minute, my girls have to be strong, this happens in every group, there are times when we must say ready we go again. with more force, but for me I am the best and I love this song, I wish only to present the stranger out to see that his followers love them and will always do so, I encourage 4nias.
encourage 4minute
we can make this the best of the best. as it has always been. Hate, hate, hate, all the time in my head. my girls I love them.
Ji hyun stands out here no matter how the others try to be better .-. She's gorggg
Loved this performance
I'm crying :( They deserve a win!!
몇년째인지 요즘 이런 통있는팬츠 구할수없나요? 미치도록 갖고싶다
jiyoon slayed this performance in particular
BEST goodbye stage ever! This song is perfection but they never won anything. :(
I think they won once in inkigayo cuz of Whatcha Doin Today?
They've won a LOT of shows in the past, and they got so many fans and popularity! There is no reason why Hate wasn't as well received as their older songs :(
Ramyeon Han Too hard hitting for most Koreans I guess. Seeing a female Kpop group sing/rap about hate is basically unheard of. I think Act. 7 would have done better if Canvas was the title track. None the less they went out in the best way possible with a truly unique concept. Never sold out and did the super sexy concept like many girl groups have to do to scrape by.
WNCIEWNCE BCDWCB So true, there couldn't have been a better album to end with
4minute was way more than just Hyuna. Im a blackjack and 4minute was on their own league loved all 4 minute songs from Hot issue to Hate.
As they now drop off the top 10 list here in inkigayo, finally its a wrap up. Hope they will comeback bigger and really capture the attention of the masses. Act.7 is still an amazing album. Loved every song in it!
Awwwn so teary ;____;
I want them to comeback again soooon !!!
4minute has such a complicated relationship with their fans. One minute they're saying how they hate them then they put up so many hearts. WHICH IS ITTTT
I love these 5 so much. Even without a win, they still smile and show appreciation to their fans. I got teary eyed omf. They didn't win an award, but they've won the hearts and loyalty of so many fans (like me who just became a part of the random). 4MINUTE FIGHTING!
hyuna look so good i love her
I'm so glad that every member looks stunning and shining here.
thank god SBS didnt cut down the song, So that i can enjoy their goodbye stageT^T i will miss all of them 4Nia forever
+vivian L What do you mean with "their goodbye stage"? Please tell me! :(
+chatnoir60609 They won't be promoting this song anymore, they may perform it, but they are going back to the pre-comeback period. It's the last, hence goodbye, stage for the song.
Oh, got it, and you know why is that? because they didn't win? It's so sad. Thanks for the reply!
chatnoir60609 Nono, even with wins every group has a set promotion period. 4minute sadly isn't as popular as they should be, even crazy had a pretty short promotion period and ppl loved that song.
Bina Bunnie Ohhh, got It. I had no idea. I can't believe they're not popular! Among the kpop fans here (Colombia) they're very popular. I particularly love their style and music. Maybe aegyo style isn't as popular here in latin america but seems to be very popular in Asia. Such a shame, because they're amazing.
I still don't get why they didn't win yet.. This song is just perfection!
+티유마 you are Queen's ??
+tien ngoc I'm Queen's haha
+Xian Lopez (MisterFanboy) me too, C Queen's ???
They deserve a win. 4min's style is badass I don't want them to fall in the cute side I know it sells better but why can't people see how much effort they put in this? Like, really!
And the hearts....If Hyuna does a heart and smile in front of me then I can die in peace
Act. 7 was a fantastic album...i love all of the song which is a rare thing..i know they were more popular internationally but still wished they'd get the same recognition in SK :/ 4minute FIGHTING
Hyuna , Love you ♥
So much stage presence, especially from Hyuna. You could have told me this was their concert and not just a music show and I would have believed you. You don’t see this kind of music show performance anymore
Gayoon 💙 💚 💛 💜
It is already goodbye, stage?? 😭😢 I will miss them so much. One of the kpop best group...
i dont want 4minute to disband :(. if ever they'll disband, i have no reason to listen to any kpop songs. i am a 4nia since their debut and 4nia is my fandom. i don't want to hate g-friend for winning 15 times (i think?) but i don't have any reason to like them, too. it hurts me when they didn't win any. where the hell are their fans since hot issue era? where the hell are you when 4minute needs us?. I'm sorry to g-friend fans out there but i "think" they didn't deserve to win. I'm sorry. Please don't disband. :'(((( me and my co-4nia ph will support you all the way. We love you 4Minute ♥♥♥♥♥
They have disbanded... I'm sorry.
if only the group was more important than the money. gosh T_T
포미닛 음악좋다
Hyuna looks amazing in this era and crazy
Hyuna is so beautiful! She's really the prettiest!
JIHYUN IS THE PRETTIEST IN MY OPINION
After 3 years still 4NIA! Still love jiyoon as much as i love her from debut
Same here
4MINUTEEE PLEASE DONT GO ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️😭😭😭😭😭
One of the few girl groups that have "powerful" as description....
My first kpop group. Due to them I got into this amazing world called kpop. And now not seeing them here is heartbreaking. They holded so much power, so much potential. I hate cube.
i need them to WIN AT LEAST ONE WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Damn!
They look soo good *cries* ....why ohh god why didn't they already win 1000 trophies for this D,:
I think it's mostly bc this type of song isn't really popular towards the Korean fans, it's more popular with International fans instead
김현아 나도 좋아!!! 😭💕
나도
This is their last live :'(
i was never a huge fan of 4minute up until crazy and this song which gave off a badass vibe p2 (because of crazy obviously). but these girls definitely needed recognition and i get it, people should have tried a little harder but it is difficult when one group (gfriend) sweeps up awards so quickly that there's practically no chance. so you guys, don't be sad about them losing, they just made the wrong timing to come back for everyone. be proud that they had an amazing comeback. be proud that they slayed on stage and are sending everyone hearts on this goodbye stage. you guys did the best you could and they're probably really happy about their fanbase. so let's let them go on a happy note instead of getting upset over conservative south korea and gfriend and winner and international fans.
SLAY 4MINUTE SLAY ❤️
But seriously, I still can't believe they didn't win anything with this absolutely incredible comeback. The song, choreography, outfits ... everything about it was amazing.
HyunA changed the lyrics at the end instead of shireo- chowa (love)
and HyunA-Sohyun soooo cute
Thank u god, for giving us jiyoon with bangs
Hyuna's laugh *-*
goodbye (i'm crying so much)!!!!
aw when hyuna smiles hearing her name in the fan chant
I'm in love with Hyuna's hair ❤
Hyuna it's the BEST !
Jihyun 😍😍😍😍😍😘😘😘😘
WE LOVE YOU TOO 4MINUTE~
JiHyun! Nam goddess💕🙆🏻👑
OMg they're all so cute throwing up hearts throughout the song
If this song was made in 4th gen, IT WOULD HAVE WON SO MANY FUCKING TIMES AND IM NOT BACKING DOWN FROM THAT.
i liked it when hyuna changed the lyrics from " i hate you" to "i like you" aweeee 😔😭😭 it's just too sad that they didn't win yet. this song is literally beyond perfection! why don't some koreans don't appreciate this masterpiece? i'm so confused
HyunA's body looks amazing in this performance. it looks like cube are finally letting the girls look after themselves properly (no hate intended) this is the best I've ever seen them they look 😍😍😍
Wow bad ass. And I can see why Hyuna gets a lot of fame and recognition, she has a lot of charisma around her. But they're all amazing
갠적으로 소현이 입은 저정도 통크기가 좋네
지금봐도 다들 멋있어
I wanna cry so bad :'( Hate is one of their best songs ever. Even Whatcza Doin Today won 2 awards against 2NE1 and SNSD but it's a shame that 4minute can't beat rookie group even tho that I love GFRIEND, 4minute will be always my ultimate group.
너무 보곳싶어요 언니야~ 우리는 너 사랑해~ 감사합니다 포미닛~
*보고싶어요
The tears in their eyes 🥺
Jihyun and Sohyun slayed this.
Jiyoon's elbow heart
Still a wonder why they haven't won.. They freaking slayed all their performances! Omg love 4M. Y'all are winners for us ❤️
jiyoon💜💜💜❤❤❤❤❤♥😘
Goddess Jihyun 💜
seriously there's so many things only korean fans can do for 4minute unlike international fans like us. If only they would let us vote and stream I know it'll be different.
0:03 멍HyunA 2:08 goddess HyunA