@@kimchipudding63852019년 노래들 지금 나오면 차트 먹히긴 힘든 스타일이에요 빌보드는 그럼 당장 2010년도랑 2013년 차이 크고 2013년이랑 2016년도 차이 크고 2019년도 2022년 다 차이 나요 지금 발매하면 히트 못 치는 거 빌보드 계도 수두룩 합니다.
agreed !! .. people last comeback (especially k.netziens) were so mean and hateful saying 'why is she in the group ?' .. why is she the leader ?.. she is the most useless member etc.. they have all SHUT TF UP this time around ..
Jihyun's confidence and voice seemed way better for their last comeback. Her voice isn't as shaky as it used to be and her stage presence improved immensely.
I love hyuna too. she's so amazing. see in the end of the song. I love how she look at the camera. she's so lovely. I can't stop watching at this. 😍😍😍❤❤❤👍👍👍👍
I love how they can change the stage. no one can do that like 4minute. they slayyyyyyy. that's the best comeback in 2016 . 4minute is fair. go go go queens.
도입부부터 싸비 직전까지는 정마ㅏㄹ 신선하고 좋은 곡 ㅇㅇ... 포미닛곡중에서 남지현 파트가 오면 곡이 다운되는 느낌이었는데 이 곡은 1절 2절 초반에 나오니까 오히려 잔잔하니 좋었고 걘적으로 전지윤 파트도 좋고 컨셉도 포미닛이랑 찰떡이었는데... 싸비가 너무 호불호가 갈림 싸비 직전에 지르는 파트도 반응 많이 갈렸고... 많이 아쉬움이 남는 곡이긴했으나 걸크러쉬 컨셉 포미닛을 좋아하는 (나같은) 사람한테는 넘나 좋은 ㅎㅎ 곡임
Awesome committed performance from all .. Jihyun looked hot with a HUH throwback and the crowd showed amazing passion. I'm not happy with the audio .. the music wasn't loud and thumping like the MV and the vocals were too high .. made the dancing look too hard and unmatched with the music ...
ok so they prob turned down the backing track and turned up the vocal/mics cus 4m sang live unlike alot of others .. which is itself awesome and shows how legit they are ..
Jiyoon with curly hair look so freaking good. Everybody talks about Jihyun how beautiful she loos (and indeed she is stunning) but omg, Jiyoon is so gorgeous too with that hair.
+Mas cha yes. they are sing live. I'm so proud of them. 4minute song is the best comeback 2016. see how they can change in the stage and the style. they can do any style . they didn't need to be sexy or cute . they slayyyyyyyyy.
Jonathan Campos they can sing so good and dance so amazing. I don't know why they have hater. Are the hater fans for some other groups and they come her to say shit about our queen to make fan war or make 4minute down but I can say they are losers. They are never ever make 4minute down. 4minute slayyyyyyy here. This song is the best comeback in 2016. I can see that clearly.
감정 격해지는 부분에서 현아랑 전지윤이 앞에 나서서 다했음 ㄷㄷ 거기서 허가윤이 가슴 먹먹한 창법으로 감정선 살려서 노래에 감칠맛 더한게 정말 지림.. 권소현은 다른 멤버들만 있으면 너무 으른미, 카리스마만 가득해서 심심해질 수 있는데 뭔가 양아치 집단의 예쁨 받는 말괄량이 막내 느낌이라 다채로워져서 권소현 파트도 보는 맛이 있음ㅋㅋ 이런 거 보면 멤버 진짜 잘짠 듯. 이런 멤버들 아니었으면 현아는 그룹에 못섞이고 혼자 너무 튀었을 듯? 현아가 포미닛 현아로서 안정적이게 7년이나 머무를 수 있었던 이유는 멤버들의 역량 덕이 크다고 생각함
Show champ's audio wasn't that...good? It made the whole performance dull. But the girls did well! And yes, it is live :) lets look forward to other stages
enma ai and what you are saying is just sounding fun too,.. both shows are bashed and mnet as mcountdown is under is mostly bashed because of the PD's way of give each member and groups screen time
이름이때부터 권소현이 좀 잘보이기 시작하더니 싫어때는 남지현마저 정말 한 팀처럼 움직이기 시작함 사실 소현은 못한다기보다는 실력은 괜찮은데 뭔가 그 전까진 자기 색깔을 못찾다가 이름이부터 포텐 터진 느낌이고 남지현은 미쳐때까지도 조금 따로 놀다가 싫어때 표정 손짓 너무 자연스러워져서 놀랐음.. 근데 해체 시발 큐브야
and the thing is members are trying so hard to keep the group, but the company wouldn't let it because it thinks the group is not profitable for the company anymore. how sad.
Actually no, the girls had the option to renew their contracts and only Hyuna did. The others didn't renew. So if anything, it's their own fault. The company would've kept promoting them, had they renewed their contracts. I understand how you may wanna say the girls wanted to keep the group together, but if they REALLY wanted to, they would've renewed their contracts. They clearly didn't wanna keep the group together THAT badly, or else they would've renewed. Hyuna was smart for renewing her contract, cause with or without 4minute, she's the most popular. Her solo career can grow with or without the group, so it was in her best interest to renew her contract. If the others wanted 4minute to continue bad enough, they would've renewed, but they didn't. So the only persons at fault here, are them. The company gave them the chance and they turned it down.
+Zombie Mittens you should understand the most only had eyes for hyuna it was more hyuna should be the main the lead vocal etc. and they dont win anything etc. it was hard bc hyuna !
But even before no one paid any attention to any of the members except Hyuna she was always in the spotlight. Besides they weren’t doing good as a group chartwise and money wise which was a shame since there songs are amazing. I honestly think they were smart enough to leave. Similar thing happened with 2ne1 and Minzy.
2:44 portion was legit my most favorite of HyunA scenes ever. That moment she looked so gorgeous and the presence was no joke. JiHyun improved so much and her style this time is so damn pretty and suits her so much. GaYoon's verse @ 2:11 stole my heart. EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS COMEBACK IS ON POINT - like finally CUBE got their game together after years of 4NIA screaming at them demanding the HUH & IMYMEMINE era back. Back then few years ago, possibly What's Your Name era or somewhere around there, CUBE actually held a competition and told 4NIA to write in our suggestions / what should 4MINUTE next comeback be. And i truly think they did listen and read our submissions - therefore the emerging of the REVAMP series - CRAZY & NOW HATE! (Obv CUBE could see the hit of CRAZY and naturally if they are smart they should know this is what we like from 4MINUTE ehe.
![[SHOWCHAMPION] EXID - L.I.E l EP.189](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qBv0t4wakz8/mqdefault.jpg)
그라데이션 분노같음ㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋ
남지현은 데뷔 몇년차인데 아직도 어색해보이냐 ㅋㅋㅋ
날아라닭고기 인정.. 근데 연기하는 거 보니까 완전 배우던데... 왜 아이돌하고 있었는지..
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅅㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
전지윤이 싫어 !싫어 ! 하는 부분 진짜 ㄹㅇ 싫음을 넘어서 극혐하는 말투 같아서 개좋음 진짜
싀르어! 싀르어!
@@ynead9974 전지윤이 누구지 했는데 이댓보고 바로이해함ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
lastater 귀여웤ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㄲㅋㄱㅋ@@이채린-k5h
공감합니다🤣😃 싫어 라는 가사 딱 들을때마다 정말 속시원한것같아요
2:56 누가 입으로 호루라기 소리내냐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
개웃기놐ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
쉬밬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ개웃기넼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
전지윤 존나 인재인데 지금봐도 아깝다 좀 더 밀어주지
아마 큐브에서 현아 다음으로 제일 많이 밀어줬을 거예요. 현아 푸쉬가 압도적이어서 그렇지 데뷔 초 전글라스 이미지에 언프리티 랩스타에.. 노래도 랩도 춤도 무대 매너도 다 가지고 있는 본투비 댄스가수죠!
끼나 실력은 있는데 매력이 없음.. 와 진짜 잘한다 싶은데 덕후몰이 할만한 그런 포인트가 없어
@@minyuna4438맞음 굳이 사진갖고싶은 그 아이돌 특유 느낌 없었어요
@@minyuna4438전지윤이 매력이 없다라… 포미닛 리얼리티 예능에서 ㅈㄴ 웃기고 털털하고 분위기 메이커던데… 다른 예능에서는 비교적 얌전히 있었어서 그런가
아 저 옷맞춘거 너무 이쁨 취저 흰티에 배기팬츠 ㅜㅜ ㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠ 4M 딱 써있는데 간지촬촹
4m그 스카치테이프아닌가 아님 4미터라는건가
진짜 저 무대 포미닛 무대 통틀어서 최애무대였는데ㅠㅠ
카드값줘체리 4minute 이요
저때도 3M 베낀거 아니냐고 말많았어요..ㅋㅋ 앨범아트에 나온것도 너무 똑같아서
아 진짜 인정 ㅠㅠ 진짜 ㄹㅈㄷ ㅠㅠ포미닛 그리워ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
남지현이 진짜 몇년만에 어색함을 버린 싫어인데... 다음 무대는 더잘했을건데ㅠㅠㅠ
진짜 예쁘고 꽤 자연스러웠는데 ㅠㅠ
지금봐도 전혀 촌스럽지 않다 노래도 너무 좋고 안무도 멋있고.. 투애니원이랑 더불어 너무 그리운 걸그룹임ㅠㅠ
아니 2019년댓글같은데 ㅋㅋㅋ 이노래 나온지 3년후 댓글인데 촌스럽고 자시고 따지는게 웃기네
@@kimchipudding6385 3년이면 트렌드가 얼마나 바뀌는데ㅋㅋㅋ 감탄한 거 가지고 걸고 넘어지냐
@@스포티걸신나리-u7y 그래서 님은 2019년 노래들 촌스럽게 느껴지나요?
@@kimchipudding63852019년 노래들 지금 나오면 차트 먹히긴 힘든 스타일이에요 빌보드는 그럼 당장 2010년도랑 2013년 차이 크고
2013년이랑 2016년도 차이 크고 2019년도 2022년 다 차이 나요 지금 발매하면 히트 못 치는 거 빌보드 계도 수두룩 합니다.
5년지났는데 지금봐도 안촌스럽네ㅌㅋ
뭔가 이곡은 컨셉이랑 분위기랑 스타일이 지금나왓우면 뭔가 더 잘어울렷을거같은 느끼뮤ㅠㅠㅠ ㅇ뭔가 그때는 파격적이라는 느낌이 강햇는데 지금은 리얼 노래 잘뽑앗당..
현아가 독보적인 캐릭터라고 해도 포미닛 안에 있을 때 더 세련되게 빛났는데 아쉽다. 포미닛 같은 걸그룹이 앞으로 있을까 싶고...
현아 춤 졸라잘춤
사실상 kpop 전성기
아이들
CLC-(여자) 아이들
근데 씨엘씨 애들 포미닛만큼 소화 못해서 안타깝ㅠ
진짜 포미닛 혁신적인 아이돌그룹이었는데... 빡빡한 아이돌시장에서 살아남으려그랬지만 사랑받을려하는 아이돌 사이에서 이렇게 독보적인 음악과 퍼포먼스를 보여주는 그룹이 얼마 없었는데...ㅠㅠ
jeong min chu 진짜..ㅇㅈ 요즘얘들은 걍 꽥꽥이들 밖에 없음..
맞아요 특히 포미닛 씨스타
포미닛 씨스타 투애니원 이렇게 멋지고 새로운애들은 다 해체하고ㅠㅠ
그럼 포미닛보단 트에니원아닌가...?
와이지는 투애니원을 블랙핑크에게 주고 큐브 포미닛은 씨엘씨에게 준거같은데 씨엘씨가 활동을안혀
노래 좋다 ㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 포미닛은 이런 걸크러쉬 팡팡 터지는 명곡들 많았는데... 미쳐랑 볼륨업도 좋았고..
새우 인정이요ㅠㅠ 걸크음악들
새우 인정해요ㅠㅠ
QUEENS
ㅇㅈ
지윤이랑 현아 끼 쩌는 듯
딱 그 둘만 음악함ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 나머지는 배우로빠지고
보통 메보는 그룹 해체해도 가수 계속 하는데 허가윤은 배우로...ㅎ
@@user_skxk93jfnd7e 허가윤 음색도 좋고 노래는 잘 부른데 끼는 모르겠음...
@차호 송지은은 가창력 있는 걸 못 들어봐서,, 솔로곡도 예쁜 나이 25살 이런 곡이라..
@@삐키쭈뚜 시크릿 라이브영상 아무거나 보고오셔도 시크릿은 ㄹㅇ 실력파란거 알 수 있음
전지윤이 왤케 멋있냐 3:07 때 가슴 칠때 존멋.. 파마머리도 힙해보임
소화안되나봄
@@성이름-d3d뭐야 이겈ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ갑자기 훅들어와서 더웃기네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 무대 잘 살리는 듯 개멋있으
ㄹㅇ 무대천재네
@@성이름-d3d ㅇㅈㄹㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅅㅋㅅㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
전지윤 개멋있네 끼가 타고났구만 포미닛에서 랩하는애 언제나 멋지다 생각했었는데
하지만... 포지션은 보컬...
저도 전지윤이라는 가수에게 매력을 많이 느껴지네요~ 해체가 너무 아쉬워요 ㅠㅠ
이노래 완전 좋았었는데 망할 큐브 진짜 실적 안 나왔다고 몇년이나 된 포미닛을 해체시키냐..... 신인들은 그렇게 잘 밀어 줬으면서;;;;;어이가 없어서
와 진짜 공감이요ㅠㅠ 솔직히 이런 컨셉으로 좀만 더 밀고 나왔어도 더더 떴을거에요ㅠㅠ 이 때 한창 많은 여성분들이
걸크러쉬 대표로 포미닛 언급할 정도로 컨셉 진짜 좋다고 많이들 그랬었는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 좀만 더 밀었었으면 더더욱 떴을거에요ㅠㅠ 아쉬워요 정말
포미닛 음반이 안팔리는데
똑같이 음반안팔릴꺼 현아 솔로에 투자한듯ㅠ
계약기간끝난게 클걸요 해체시켯다기보단.. 이런컨셉 시작한지 얼마안되고 해체된건아쉽네요ㅠ
근데 그..포미닛 멤버들은 재계약 원했는데 ㅈ같은 큐브에서 현아만 쏙 빼간게 해체된 원인중 가장 큰 거 아닌가여...?....진짜 큐브 부숴버리고 싶다...
차라리 탈뀹이 답이였는디 포미닛은
여자팬이 많아서.....
와 진짜 개미쳤다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 컨셉 소화능력 대박임;;;와...이런 여돌 또 나오려나...특히 현아 전지윤은 아예 무대를 장악해버리네 진짜 멋있다...
회색 바지에 흰티 완전 요즘 안무영상들에서 많이 입고 나오는 스타일.. 존예다...
역시 현아는 솔로일때도 빛나지만 포미닛일 때가 제일 빛나고 좋다 ㅠㅠ 그리고 포미닛 해체 아직도 너무 아쉽.... 각자 좋은모습 보여주다 재결합 해 줬으면 ㅠㅠ 언니들 늘 응원해요♡
HATE(싫어)
이곡은 너무 빨리 나와버렸음..
너무 아까운 음악..저런 이미지 강한포스
나올수 있을까 포미닛뿐이 소화 못한다 정말 ㅠ
역시 믿고 보는 쇼챔 카메라랑 포미닛
여자아이들 퀸덤에서 이곡해도 괜찮을듯
은갈치 허러럴 각이닺
헐허헐헐헐 소연아 이거다!!!!
와 ㄹㅇ 비슷해서 잘어울렸을듯
헐 완전 찰떡이다
ㅂㄹ
WOW!!!! Jihyun is actually present...like she is part of the group...FINALLY!! Love the outfits and their hair.
She's always been present.
But if you're talking about the line distribution, there's Mirror Mirror
K-POPChannel [APINK&*HIATUS* MONTH] i mean having a stage presence.
+changmin oppa
I think it's because she didn't have that many lines before.
She mostly only had lines on the bridge (the line after the second chorus)
+Fikri BTS (Kim Seok Jin) she deserves more, her voice is very sweet and flattering to the ears. She also looks beautiful in blonde :)
Did sth happen to her?
걸그룹계의 위너 아이콘 같은 느낌 있는 그룹이었는데 수많은 그룹 중에 뜬 데는 다 이유가 있는 법이란다 큐브야 신인 지나도 안 뜨는 너네애들 챙길 시간에 포미닛 더 신경써줄 것이지
위너 아이콘이 후배에요.
네아이들떴죠~~~
@@주기범-g1l 씨엘씨 말하는거
씨엘씨.. 할말하않
차라리 씨엘씨를 해체시키고 포미닛을 더 밀어주는게... 하...
전지윤 표정진짜미쳤다....
That person screaming in the background is me 😂😂
+ellie yip (elliexpika) The scream is funny ~
Literally me behind my iPad. Im screaming at my poor screen and my poor family has to put up with my shit.
+Kim Youngil 😂😂
+ellie yip (elliexpika) STOP that.. its fuckin annoying.. trying to hear this song properly!
+ellie yip (elliexpika) Hahaha I thought the same :')
Omg the song, outfits, and dance have officially slayed my life.
agree
totally agree
***** everyone has her own style. No one is better that the other. Everyone is so perfect . I love 4minute.
+Jess Wang JIYOON LOOKS SO GOOD WITH THE SHORT CURLY HAIR LOML
Jihyun's black outfit reminds me of HUH era
남지현 그나마 무대에 적응하기 시작했는데 마지막 앨범이 될줄 누가 알았겠냐구.. 드디어 무대가 알차지나 했더니...
허가윤 진짜 개좋아했는데... 이기광이랑 해투 나온 것도 다 챙겨보고 직설 화법 너무 좋아서 허가윤으로 포미닛 좋아하게 된 케이스
2:56 That fan's strangled scream LMAO
Sorry i got excited
Omg i laughed so hard xD it looks like someone was being raped or something
+luisa regina OMG IMAO
jajajajajajaja X'D
I was looking for this comment 😂
회색바지!! 저때 코디가 젤이쁘다ㅎㅎㅎ
I'm so proud of Jihyun I see more improvement in terms of singing and dancing and not to mention her confidence compare to crazy promotion.
agreed !! .. people last comeback (especially k.netziens) were so mean and hateful saying 'why is she in the group ?' .. why is she the leader ?.. she is the most useless member etc.. they have all SHUT TF UP this time around ..
+4mExid 4ever lmao maybe because she really was bad.....
+Yeri Bae yeah .. see that intense hate from her comming out the screen ... its direct at you ..hehe
4mExid 4ever lmao you're naive af
+Yeri Bae i feel sorry for you ..
전지윤 미쳤다 포스개쩔고 개열심히하네
싫어 싫어 난 너 싫어 할 때 전지윤 목소리 발린다 ㅠㅠㅠ최고
Jihyun is so beautiful this comeback! I mean she's always beautiful, but she looks hfdfjhjdhg! She seems more confident I think
Yes I agree with you, she also lost a lot of weight, she's gorgeous💕
also I like her hair like that
+Joseph Poole yup matching with her
+Arina Arinza she's a goddess O_O
namji Goddess
싫어 나왔을때 진짜 여덕들 엄청 좋아서 난리났었는데ㅜ.ㅜ
진짜 싫어하는 사람한테 들려주고싶다.
보고싶다 다들뭐하고산대
왕왕 지금쯤 자고있겟지
@@종국햇반 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ기출응용
포미닛이 앞으로 계속 걸크러쉬로 나가면 좋겠다 젤 잘어울림
Kyungha Kim ㅓ
@@무찌기-s4p 저 지굼 들어와서 내가 단 댓들이 있었던 것에 한번놀라고 댓글이 달린거에 놀라고 (지금은 해체한거 압니다)
댓글단줄 모르고 또 걸크러쉬라고 글 쓰고갈 뻔 했어욬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
알려주어서 감사합니다♡
그리고 헤체
Jihyun's confidence and voice seemed way better for their last comeback. Her voice isn't as shaky as it used to be and her stage presence improved immensely.
남지현이 드디어 늘기 시작하자 해체 해버림
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ아니안늘었어..어색해ㅜㅠㅠ
그래도 다른 활동때보다 싫어때가 컨셉 소화 제일 잘됐음 ㅠㅠ
ㄴㄴㄴ 안늘었어 물과기름같은 존재였음 ㅋㅋㅋ
아미친ㅋㅋㅋㅈㄴ웃겨 ㅠㅠ
린아 남지현이 누구에요?
hyuna unni is the bestttttt 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
I love hyuna too. she's so amazing. see in the end of the song. I love how she look at the camera. she's so lovely. I can't stop watching at this. 😍😍😍❤❤❤👍👍👍👍
she is by far my favorite out of all then she's gotten much better as an artist both solo and group over the past like 4 or 5 years
Joseph Poole me too. I really love my queen. She slayyyyyyy always
love hyuna alwayss
I love her too she's the only k-female artist I stan and 4minute is the only k-female group I stan. Yeah I'm a loyal fan to her
전지윤 저 빠글빠글 머리가 어떻게 저리 예쁘면서 간지나게 소화하는건지.. 이거 생각나서 보러올때마다 저머리 너무잘어울리는거 같음 더불어 랩실력도 진짜 미쳤,,
와 이걸 이제 듣네 드랍비트 개오짐 시대를 앞섰구만 반전매럭 쩐다 미쳐랑 같이 이거 지금 나왔으면 엄청 인기 많았을듯ㅠ진짜 멋있다ㅠㅠ
isn't it supposed to be badass? then why is hyuna so cute at the end😍😍😍
Hyuna is badass cutie 😍
+kasia .jabłoniec totally😍
+Karla Emmeline She's the only one that is able to pull off this combination. lol.
+Javiera Morales and without fail.
I love how they can change the stage. no one can do that like 4minute. they slayyyyyyy. that's the best comeback in 2016 . 4minute is fair. go go go queens.
전지윤 진짜 아깝다 솔로 더 내쓰면 좋겠다
이 노래 너무 좋음 싫은 인간 생각날때마다 이노래 들으러 옴 무대도 넘 멋있고 싫어 너 싫어 하는데 속이 편안해짐
The only two who can make pigtails look badass: CL and Hyuna
couldn't agree more
Eva Glasell what is "pigtails"?
yulinda widi its a hairstyle where you part your hair in two ponytails on each side of your head. Also the hairstyle Hyuna has in this video
Eva Glasell oh okey thanks
yulinda widi no problem :)
개 멋찐데 와 왜해체함 이런 파란상자.... 비스트도 빡치는데 포미닛까지 깨치고 비투비 재계약한걸 다행이라 생각해야하나 진심 큐브 소속아이돌 펜타곤 빼고 다 덕질해오고 있는사람인데 계속깨지니까 빡친다...ㅠㅠ
HYUNA SLAYED
도입부부터 싸비 직전까지는 정마ㅏㄹ 신선하고 좋은 곡 ㅇㅇ... 포미닛곡중에서 남지현 파트가 오면 곡이 다운되는 느낌이었는데 이 곡은 1절 2절 초반에 나오니까 오히려 잔잔하니 좋었고 걘적으로 전지윤 파트도 좋고 컨셉도 포미닛이랑 찰떡이었는데... 싸비가 너무 호불호가 갈림 싸비 직전에 지르는 파트도 반응 많이 갈렸고... 많이 아쉬움이 남는 곡이긴했으나 걸크러쉬 컨셉 포미닛을 좋아하는 (나같은) 사람한테는 넘나 좋은 ㅎㅎ 곡임
이 곡이 마지막 포미닛 곡인게 아쉬움일뿐... 해체전에 완전체 곡 하나만 더 풀어주고가지..
근데 약간 싸비 요즘 스타일 앞서나간 느낌 아니에요? 약간 블랙핑크 풍도 느껴지고요 외국인들이 좋아하는 이유가 그거인 거 같아요
@@낫낫낫 ㅇㅈ
근데 진짜 현아는... 어떤 무대를 봐도 눈이 확간다 독보적인듯
Awesome committed performance from all .. Jihyun looked hot with a HUH throwback and the crowd showed amazing passion. I'm not happy with the audio .. the music wasn't loud and thumping like the MV and the vocals were too high .. made the dancing look too hard and unmatched with the music ...
ok so they prob turned down the backing track and turned up the vocal/mics cus 4m sang live unlike alot of others .. which is itself awesome and shows how legit they are ..
+4mExid 4ever Yess! I'm not the only one who thought of HUH with Jihyun's outfit
Why do so many people think this isn't a strong comeback? IT'S BOMB!!
Seriously! And their mini album is really solid too!
+jsaz25 yes!!
+jsaz25 yeah I actually stated up all night until it came out so I cold listen to the whole thing
IKR!!💕✨
노래가 진짜 꽉 차있고 심심할 틈 없이 까리함 이때 진짜 아이돌들 전반적으로 노래퀄리티 대박이였는데..그립다
전지윤 진짜 재평가 시급함... 목소리 톤 너무 좋고 춤선 너무 예쁘시다.. 그 시절 몰라봐서 미안해요😭
다시봐도 멋있다.아쉽다못본다는게
포미닛이 해체 막판에 낸 앨범들이 걸스힙합이었는데 정말 너무너무 맘에 들었는데 지금들어도 너무 좋네요
다시보고싶네여 ㅠㅠ
Jiyoon with curly hair look so freaking good. Everybody talks about Jihyun how beautiful she loos (and indeed she is stunning) but omg, Jiyoon is so gorgeous too with that hair.
Dude the fanchants were on the highest pitch. Daebak!!!!!!! 4minute jjang!!!!!! This is the road to contract extension!!!! LOL
is this live? ._. i think it's not :'(
+Mas cha yes. they are sing live. I'm so proud of them. 4minute song is the best comeback 2016. see how they can change in the stage and the style. they can do any style . they didn't need to be sexy or cute . they slayyyyyyyyy.
Yes they sang live . Cube stated during crazy era that 4 minute is now a non-lipsync group .
+Mas cha i think it was live the fans came to support them ♡♡♡
Jonathan Campos they can sing so good and dance so amazing. I don't know why they have hater. Are the hater fans for some other groups and they come her to say shit about our queen to make fan war or make 4minute down but I can say they are losers. They are never ever make 4minute down. 4minute slayyyyyyy here. This song is the best comeback in 2016. I can see that clearly.
Hate was so ahead of its time. Definitely wouldve been a hit if this was released in today's time.
진짜진짜 다시보고싶은 걸그룹 ㅠㅠ 지금 나왔어야할 그룹같음 ㅠㅠ 넘 그립다..
감정 격해지는 부분에서 현아랑 전지윤이 앞에 나서서 다했음 ㄷㄷ 거기서 허가윤이 가슴 먹먹한 창법으로 감정선 살려서 노래에 감칠맛 더한게 정말 지림.. 권소현은 다른 멤버들만 있으면 너무 으른미, 카리스마만 가득해서 심심해질 수 있는데 뭔가 양아치 집단의 예쁨 받는 말괄량이 막내 느낌이라 다채로워져서 권소현 파트도 보는 맛이 있음ㅋㅋ 이런 거 보면 멤버 진짜 잘짠 듯. 이런 멤버들 아니었으면 현아는 그룹에 못섞이고 혼자 너무 튀었을 듯? 현아가 포미닛 현아로서 안정적이게 7년이나 머무를 수 있었던 이유는 멤버들의 역량 덕이 크다고 생각함
권쏘 포지션 설명 진짜 잘했다… 권쏘 좀 빛 좀 보려고 할때 끝나버려서 너무 아쉽
볼륨업이랑 하트투하트 진짜좋아했는데ㅠㅜㅜ
파워풀한거 짱~
Everyone said hyuna is best dancer in 4minute. But I really think that jiyoon actually best dancer in 4minute since I saw her in crazy mv
this is 2021....and there is still no group that have a stage presence..energy like them
im so sad
btsvelvet Me too.. Lets talk about it 😭😂😭
btsvelvet same... I miss them
mood
Why you sad?!
alexandra t. the song
that girl that keeps screaming and screaming every word is me hahahhahah
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO NOTICES THAT OML AND SAME
4년 전인데 왜 이리 세련됨;;
바지 안에 거 살짝 보이는 거랑 노래랑 찰떡이야,,
2023년 6월에 들어도 존나 의상 노래 트렌디 해요.. 아니 요즘 노래보다 더 좋아요
Jiyoon is the best❤
Yes she's my bias❤
Jiyoon is life👑
Jiyoon 😻
Jiyoon 💓
Jiyoon’s deep voice has me feeling some way
마지막에 현아가 뾰로퉁하고 팔짱끼는거 귀여움ㅋㅋㅋ
Jihyun was pretty good this time 👍👏👏👏👏
진짜가윤 너무이뻐ㅜㅜㅜㅠㅜ언니
시대를 잘못타고남
포미닛 지금 데뷔했으면 세계투어 다녔을듯
HyunA is killing everybody tonight!
2015
4M : Crazy
Taeyeon : I
Twice : like ohh ahh
2016
4M : Hate
Taeyeon : Why
Twice : TT
Brown và Cony Taeyeon onetop.
2ne1 Pilots Actually Goodbye is 2017
I LOVE HOW THEY SCREM EVERYTIME JIHYUN'S PART COMES UP OMG ♥ SHE IS SO BEAUTIFUL
i cant get over how pretty Jihyun is!!!
지금 보고있는사람?-?
지금봐도 너무 좋다 무대..
Hyuna got like 6 bundles in each pigtail. YAS mom
lool
LMFAOOOO! SERIOUSLY
what? lol
OMFF YASS I KNOW WHAT YOU MEAN trust 😂😂😂😂😂😂 #Dead
Snatched
who's here after hearing that theyre disbands
me
me
Me😢
Me 😩😩😩😩😩
+Tatiana Silva me
예전엔 왜 중간에 노래가 바뀌지 했는ㄷ 지금들으니까 세련됐다
Show champ's audio wasn't that...good? It made the whole performance dull. But the girls did well! And yes, it is live :) lets look forward to other stages
Show champion is known for bad audio quality but great stages while m countdown is known for great audio but (a bit) lacking stages
4minute slayyyyyyy the stage here. I love how they can change the stage. no one can do that like 4minute. that is so perfect. 😍 ❤ ❤ ❤ 😍 👍 👍 👍
nattenshusfreaken lol you have to make a sacrifice good stage bad audio or bad audio and good stage .
enma ai and what you are saying is just sounding fun too,.. both shows are bashed and mnet as mcountdown is under is mostly bashed because of the PD's way of give each member and groups screen time
I LOVE THE WHITE STAGE! EVERYTHING ABOUT IT! Outfits, actual stage, EVERYTHING! LOVE IT! ❤️
이거 처음 들어보는데 후렴구 부분 안무랑 스타일 좋다!! 현아한테 찰떡
They put WAY too many extensions in Hyuna's pigtails LMFAOO She's 80% hair.
Hyuna: **80% hair** looks amazing
Me: **80% hair** looks like a hairy potato that has mold on it
Kat Roo I think its cute but badass
that elephant on taehyung's arm 😂😂😂😂 same 😂😂
that elephant on taehyung's arm I'm deas😂💀
Best comment yet
이름이때부터 권소현이 좀 잘보이기 시작하더니 싫어때는 남지현마저 정말 한 팀처럼 움직이기 시작함 사실 소현은 못한다기보다는 실력은 괜찮은데 뭔가 그 전까진 자기 색깔을 못찾다가 이름이부터 포텐 터진 느낌이고 남지현은 미쳐때까지도 조금 따로 놀다가 싫어때 표정 손짓 너무 자연스러워져서 놀랐음.. 근데 해체 시발 큐브야
Black and white. i like this stage!! next week must win!
너무 이쁘다 진짜 완전 이쁘다 이뻐이뻐이뻐이뻐어어어 ㅠㅠ 이번 무대가 짱인데 진짜
This crowd really doesn't know how lucky they are to have been able to see this performance live 😭
i always love jiyoon and hyuna..
It's so hard to see them as a group now that they officially have disbanded. 💔
and the thing is members are trying so hard to keep the group, but the company wouldn't let it because it thinks the group is not profitable for the company anymore. how sad.
Actually no, the girls had the option to renew their contracts and only Hyuna did. The others didn't renew. So if anything, it's their own fault. The company would've kept promoting them, had they renewed their contracts. I understand how you may wanna say the girls wanted to keep the group together, but if they REALLY wanted to, they would've renewed their contracts. They clearly didn't wanna keep the group together THAT badly, or else they would've renewed. Hyuna was smart for renewing her contract, cause with or without 4minute, she's the most popular. Her solo career can grow with or without the group, so it was in her best interest to renew her contract. If the others wanted 4minute to continue bad enough, they would've renewed, but they didn't. So the only persons at fault here, are them. The company gave them the chance and they turned it down.
gave them a chance lmfao
+Zombie Mittens you should understand the most only had eyes for hyuna it was more hyuna should be the main the lead vocal etc. and they dont win anything etc. it was hard bc hyuna !
But even before no one paid any attention to any of the members except Hyuna she was always in the spotlight. Besides they weren’t doing good as a group chartwise and money wise which was a shame since there songs are amazing. I honestly think they were smart enough to leave. Similar thing happened with 2ne1 and Minzy.
진짜역대급 곡에 역대급 컨셉..ㅠㅠㅠㅠ이런 거 소화할 그룹이 또 나올까 너무 좋아했는데
4Minute are now officially filling the vacant "Fierce Girlgroup" spot that 2NE1 left. Good job on that, girls!
4minute was fierce back in the days already (HUH / Superstar and so much more~) this is just back to the basic & we're all lovin it ♡
2NE1 never left. No need to try and throw shade on other groups just to complement 4Minute
I would think that their MAMA appearance would be enough for you to realize that 2NE1 are going NOWHERE. They will always have that badass spot.
+SunnyUnnie oh girl don't start a fight, leave both fandoms alone
4minutes been doing fierce girl group for a while; volume up and huh?
Hyuna
왜 눈물나지ㅠ .. ㅠㅠ
2:44 portion was legit my most favorite of HyunA scenes ever. That moment she looked so gorgeous and the presence was no joke. JiHyun improved so much and her style this time is so damn pretty and suits her so much. GaYoon's verse @ 2:11 stole my heart.
EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS COMEBACK IS ON POINT - like finally CUBE got their game together after years of 4NIA screaming at them demanding the HUH & IMYMEMINE era back.
Back then few years ago, possibly What's Your Name era or somewhere around there, CUBE actually held a competition and told 4NIA to write in our suggestions / what should 4MINUTE next comeback be. And i truly think they did listen and read our submissions - therefore the emerging of the REVAMP series - CRAZY & NOW HATE! (Obv CUBE could see the hit of CRAZY and naturally if they are smart they should know this is what we like from 4MINUTE ehe.
watching this with a heavy heart...