Canada Confronts India Over Alleged Assassination
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 вер 2023
- Warning: This episode contains descriptions of violence.
The relationship between two democratic allies fell to its lowest point in history this week, after Canada accused India of assassinating a Sikh community leader in British Columbia in June.
Mujib Mashal, The Times’s South Asia bureau chief, explains this stunning accusation - and what India’s reaction to it tells us about the era of its leader, Narendra Modi.
Guest: Mujib Mashal (www.nytimes.com/by/mujib-mashal), The New York Times’s bureau chief for South Asia.
Background reading:
• Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of Canada said agents of India (www.nytimes.com/2023/09/18/wo...) had assassinated a Sikh community leader, Hardeep Singh Nijjar, who was fatally shot in British Columbia in June.
• Mr. Nijar was a prominent advocate (www.nytimes.com/2023/09/19/wo...) of the creation of an independent Sikh nation that would include parts of India’s Punjab State.
• The charge, which the Indian government has strongly rejected, may fuel a rift (www.nytimes.com/2023/09/20/wo...) between Canada’s Sikhs and Hindus.
For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily (nytimes.com/thedaily?smid=pc-t.... Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.
It's deeply unsettling to witness the sheer audacity with which Canada, a nation that prides itself on its moral high ground, has been harboring and providing a safe haven to individuals with a notorious track record of terrorism. Hardeep Singh Nijjar was not just an "activist" as some Western media outlets would have you believe. He was a leader of the Khalistan Tiger Force, an organization banned in India due to its involvement in heinous acts of terror. The Khalistan movement has been responsible for the deaths of thousands of innocent civilians in India, including the tragic bombing of Air India Flight 182 in 1985, which resulted in the loss of 329 innocent lives.
India has, on multiple occasions, requested Canada to extradite such Khalistani terrorists. Yet, Canada has consistently turned a blind eye, prioritizing vote bank politics over global security. It's a blatant disregard for the countless lives lost to the terror perpetrated by these individuals. The question arises: Why does Canada, which claims to champion human rights and global peace, allow its soil to be used as a breeding ground for extremism?
The narrative that Nijjar was merely an activist is not only misleading but also a gross misrepresentation of the truth. It's high time Canada introspects its policies and stops its double standards. Sheltering individuals with blood on their hands, all while preaching righteousness, is a hypocrisy that cannot and should not be ignored.
For God's sake, what is a "credible allegation!?"
Five Eyes intelligence.
US intelligence actually worked with Canadian intelligence on this. And this is also why you see UK, Aus, NZ, and US talking about this matter first, rather than other allies of Canada like in NATO. Five Eyes is much closer, and they’ll trust Canada over India every time since it’s their own agents who likely know of this.
And if you think they’ll reveal their assets and informants to India, then you’re dreaming.
EDIT: Now even timesofindia admits the Five Eyes involvement in this now. Even they admit that Canada got sigint from "an unnamed ally" (obviously the USA for anyone with a functioning brain). Maybe now the Indian nationalist propagandists can shut up now since their own state-controlled media isn't even bothering denying it now.
@@asw654so?
@@asw654hope canada has strong evidences because if not india would be dragging trudeau to international court of justice for maligning india's image . I hope so .
It's like the "credible allegations" of the Trump-Russua election interference, only Canadian style, aye.
Fact that even the shooter is not caught, there is no proof. Its just a clown show
How can one expect an unbiased analysis from someone like Mujib Mashal a Pakistani agent
😂😂😂 Bringing Osama bin Laden's Islamic brother Mujib to talk about India...What a ridiculous joke these western media puppets are playing...NYT forgot about 9/11 committed by Mujib's Islamic brothers
sounds like bangladeshi ...but anyway its all the same
This fellow Mashal has been doing mischief for a long time...too long in fact ..
As an informed person, I just keep noticing subtle missed informations here. You dont have to make news balanced. You have to tell the truth.
This is partly why people have such different views from each other. They don't want to dig deep to find out what is actually happening. They look at one news source with omitted info and start arguing out their ass and that never leads to productive conversation.
As an informed person, if you’re going to contend that they are missing key subtext, you should probably support your assertion with an actual claim.
Otherwise you are essentially just arguing that their facts don’t conform to your opinion, which is a YP.
@@BLINDIAN1995😂ಂಥಂ
@@skillswiperfor one he missed the interpol red notice on nijjar. Second missed the vote politics of Justin while explaining of modi. Missed the killings of Hindus by khalistanis in india before indira was assassinated. And list goes on.
@@BLINDIAN1995 Everyone wants an echo chamber that will support their own prejudices.
The media person says all things are wrong 😂😂😂
America shooting down osama bin laden in pakistan without informing them . West :- 👍
India doing the same . West :- 😱😭death of democracy.
Wait. So are you saying India did assassinate this guy? Because America never denied it killed Bin Laden. Maybe that is the major difference. America owns up to what it did. India doesn't have the courage to do so.
As a Canadian I found this quite informative. The Indian reaction is therefore somewhat predictable. Canada as a nation of immigrants and trade often gets caught in the middle of the geopolitics of larger nations like the US, China , India and Russia. Canada's case would be better if clear evidence was provided.
Canada is a cucked country owned by the British empire and the NWO....
Trudeau makes me thankful for Biden!
@@stephenlambert6407 KEEP THINKING THAT INTO YOUR GRAVE.
@@user-zu7bo3yg6ikeep typing in caps boomer
It's convenient how you forget the US is a country made of immigrants and puts up with the same shit , far more than your country does. We don't share our geopolitical problems with you guys, you just decide to stick your noses in and get involved and are usually wrong when it comes to information. Btw, you can keep the illegal aliens in your country because we have more than Canada's population of them in our country, already!
The host was very careful with details he chose to reveal or hide for Nijjar. For example, went into detail about Nijjar’s political activities which is what Canadians want to highlight but for the Indian side all the accusations were put under umbrella of criminal activities. He also seemed to paint Nijjar as upstanding Canadian citizen while failing to mention he was repeatedly rejected for citizenship and no one knows how he finally got his citizenship.
Was naively hoping for an unbiased coverage from NYT
Married a Canadian citizen to get automatic citizenship. That Pannu or whoever crawls out of the woodwork must have advised him.
Nijjar was involved in bomb blast in punjab cinema hall and also in many murders in India. We asked the Canadian government to extradite him. But they said no. Now trudeau is crying like Pakistan was crying during the assassination of osama bin laden in Pakistan by USA. Canada has freedom of expression so now he can freely cry on shoulders of his allies.
3rd world countries acting like savages whats new
This is the US and Canada shouldn't open their doors to immigrants in certain countries because the residents true citizens of the US and Canada are involved just because of default. Many of these countries are still uncivilized.. India Democratic.. laughable the way you treat your own people, woman are questionable and so forth telling.. US and Canada needs to mind their business and stop trade, stop allowing them to enter into our countries.. ridiculous that they feel they can come to a country as killers, not law enforcement, not military but independent thugs taking the law into their own hands.. These same people are horrible in their own countries and get away with everything that they do as a mob of vigilantes. Because Canada didn't bend to India's command the India thugs did exactly what MBS did to the reporter in a Turkey Embassy from Saudi Citizens. Thugs are thugs , paid Hitmen working underground. If they're proud don't hide, stand strong with your 10 toes planted and show yourself like a true hero would. No because they're really cowards and immature children playing war games, and cops and robbers in real life Mission impossibles...
When did they present legal evidence and file for extradition in court? That is how everyone else does extraction.
@@AceMoonshotEverything was done. Interpol red notice was also issued. Trudeau is a lapdog of Jagmeet singh, a khalistani
@@AceMoonshot India has extradition request with evidence for atleast 20 criminals and terrorists using Canada as a safe haven and launch pad. Canada has failed to act on these requests and that's the point.
To my all dear friends in canada.
1. Every 5 years elections happen in Punjab state, and this year 1/117 seats have been won by pro khalistani.
2. They make claims of land which was under Sikh empire in 18th century. If such claims are made then neither America nor Canada must exist and earlier natives must be given the land. Also the empire was spread significantly to Pakistan with capital being in Lahore. There was population of 1.67 million sikhs in Pakistan Punjab which now is only 21000. Yet these people dont ask for that Punjab. This shows who supports them.
3. We Indians do support freedom of speech, but its clear that this movement is supported by Pakistan and perhaps China. Pakistan is host of terrorism, hence for India it becomes more than freedom of speech issue. Just imagine the consequences if USA starts supporting Anti Canada things. I would be even more worried than what China is currently doing and freedom of speech may go down the drain.
4. Hence, i just wish that India Canada relations are not jeopardized by some 3rd country.
Fully agree with what you are saying except for #3. I'm a big fan of Modi's economy and anti-corruption. But c'mon, he has severe issues with free speech. There is no evidence at all to suggest the Khalistani movement is supported by Pakistan and China. As you yourself said Khalistan barely exists in India. Modi government has arrested people who call themselves separatists even without committing a crime. IT SHOULD NOT BE A CRIME TO JUST SUPPORT KHALISTAN MOVEMENT. That is part of free speech. Allow people to say what they want, even when you disagree with them or think them stupid.
Modi was severely anti-free speech during the farmer's protests. Jack Dorsey, the former CEO of Twitter, admitted he had 100s of emails from the Modi government to suppress speech during this time. If he didn't comply his offices and employees in Delhi would get raids committed to them.
And they banned the BBC documentary. It is not the government's duty to decide what is misinformation or disinformation. Indians are smart enough to decide for ourselves.
In all PM Modi has lots of strengths. Free speech is not one of them.
The point is: This incident is just another proof that India doesn't care about international rules. What is good for India gets Indias support (Russias invasion in Ukraine), what is bad for India evokes an aggressive reaction. That is not hiw rules work.
One Earth, one People, one Future!
@@juliarichter6987Obviously if proof is made public that India was involved everyone will criticize India correctly.
But I don't get the criticism of India for Russia. Whether India condemns Russia or not nothing will change. And the cheap oil India is getting from Russia has helped a lot of Indian people. Isn't it the job of the government to do things for the benefit of the Indian people??
@@ragnong9680 I am talking about International Law. International Law exist exactly for the reason, that governments CAN'T do what is best for their people NO MATTER WHAT. If all countries would have sanctioned Russia, the war would be over by now and the world community would have shown to all "governments" in the world that there is no gain in invading your neighbour. India could have cheap oil without the ghost of the killed Ukrainians haunting them.
Just a thought.
@@juliarichter6987 There is no fairness in international law when only 5 countries have veto power in UNSC. So just chill and work for your own people thats the least a government can do for its people.
Punjab doesn’t constitute of Sikhs only. There are people of other religions also live there. Secondly the major part of Punjab is in Pakistan . Why not ask Pakistan for Punjab. Punjab is an integral part of india. What if the ever growing Sikh population in Canada begins to ask Canada for a separate land
Fair point. I like to hear these perspectives because Western media hides it.
Then UN should gave them their country on Canadian soil. After all that's what happened with Israel.
these are the problems you get when all the land in the world has been claimed by someone even though no one's living there. people can't have their own space there will be conflict. maybe the UK should give up some land because they basically ran India as a business for hundreds of years.
Why not send them to South Pole, no one lives there
you are attempting to unscramble the scrambled egg. the Sikhs asked for separate state after independence. Nehru sweet-talked and coerced the various kingdoms to accept the arrangement but failed to make good on the arrangements.
don't forget, Modi was barred from entering US under Obama for his treatment of Moslems in his state. nothing has changed except Modi was elected as head of India. US attempt to use India to contain China never changed, from US sanctioned India for nuclear proliferation to suppression of Moslems. we merely put more lipstick on the pig.
Trudy's description of Canada, is what Canada was before his tyrannical government showed up.
If you think the government of Canada is tyrannical you’re spoiled and a child. And for your sake, I hope you never face real adversity or oppression.
I’m in the US and so don’t follow Canadian politics. Can you please describe what has been done, specifically, to cause you to say that Canada is tyrannical?
@@catherineromero1862 Trudeau's government is tyrannical, and all you have to do is a UA-cam search or a Google search and you'll find out exactly what's going on I'm not going to type a book to educate you.
@@catherineromero1862Illegal COVID lockdowns and prosecutions
@@catherineromero1862there's many free speech issues
2:51
This lady has been living under a rock 2:58
Defending terrorists is weird
Not all Skhis want a separate state. It is only a small faction . As usual The Daily is maligning india. Shame
Why India is so afraid from small group of people. I don’t understand that.
@@sitalpur It is not. More because these are essentially pawns at the hand of powers. Also remember these khalistani militants bombed Air India and killed our PM Indira Gandhi. So they essentially are terrorists much like Bin Laden. Does that ring a bell?
@@sitalpuronly a few people killed those 400 people in the kanishka bombings in 1985.
Only a handful of people did the attacks of 9/11.
This interview is a height of hypocrisy and cover up.
Nobody tells how Nijjar an illegal immigrant in canada, got Canadian citizenship
when it's public that he was denied citizenship by authorities and court and yet mysteriously he's deposed as a citizen and that
it's surprising why a Canadian citizen is demanding for a separate State in india?
Isn't that demand a threat to India's sovereignty?
How in the name of freedom of expression khalistanis demand assassination of Indian diplomats and extend grave threats to other persons of Indian descent.
A Canadian citizen criticizing the Indian government isn't justification for the Indian government to have them assassinated on within Canada's borders. It's wild that people are trying to justify this.
Its wild that the shooter isnt even caught and the turdo is making tall claims about proof
@@Breadbored.oh you mean how it wasn’t justification then (by your logic) for the US to kill Bin Laden on Pakistani soil? How about several Iranians? This Nijar guy was the mastermind behind several terrorist attacks in India and Canada. But rules for thee but for me right?
@@s_fashionloverComparing Jihadis to Sihks? Touch Grass.
@@Breadbored. Another Khalistani was killed today by a gang member. It's suspected that the other guy was killed the same way. Making random claims without proof is not going to fly. "Credible allegations" mean jackshit. Trudeau is in bed with Khalistani terrorism supporter Jagmeet Singh who is propping up his government and that's the sole reason he made these accusations. Things will come out, just you watch!
Indian confidence? What is right and wrong here?. Kettle calling pot black.
Mujib Mushal is factually wrong to say that the demand for Khalistan dates back to India's independence and partition. This demand started sometime in the 70s and had, and continues to have very little support
These so called experts don’t understand or do any research, just talk because they are leftists and get away with lying…
What is their stance on Pakistan and its religious persecution of minorities in their country? Mum is the a word…
True
Correct
His comments are accurate. Sikh people wanted to have their separate state during the partition of British Raj, just like the Bengali people wanted a nation state for them. Both proposals didn't materialise in 40s.
@@shoshankosen1280 Rubbish. During Indepedence the Sikhs were called to the table along with the Hindus and Muslims. The Sikhs represented by their undisputed leader Master Tara Singh and the Akali Dal willingly decided to merge with India. The Khalistanis were a very small minority then as they are now.Do not demean the sacrifices of Sikhs and Bengali Hindus in the freedom struggle. If you count the militant revolutionaries executed by the British will probably find that the number of Sikhs, Bengali Hindus and Maharastrians is the highest. The Muslims of Punjab and Bengal did not want to be a part of India and they got what they wanted.
There are Khalistanis everywhere in US, Australia, UK and in Europe but nowhere such type of movements are observed or squashed by their government. Its only Canada where this is flourishing. Hope that tells something about Trudue.
Without lies islam dies.
India was begging for Nijjars extradition and other extremist but canada due to internal politics ignored it altogether.
They could not blame this on the truckers?
He was killed by a
Drone Attack®️
Neither country has anything to lose in this conflict. They can keep it on ice for as long as they want.
Neither to lose? They are no better than the USA allowing SA assassinate a journalist in the USA.
Yes, but what this Olympic Prize winning idiot called Trudeau has done is put a number of other countries in an uncomfortable position in the pursuit of his petty personal interests.
How cleverly they hid the fact, that this Nijjar was wanted in several blasts like Ludhiana (6 killed several injured) , and several targeted killing of prominent RSS leaders.
"Hid" is a very strange way of saying "explicitly mentioned at 12:52 in the very video under which this comment appears"
As an American, Trudeau constantly embarrassing himself is an absolute win between the sh!tshow we've been having here for the past 8 years
They got a Muslim propagandist to talk about India/Modi.
Yeah I can’t wait for Trudeau to have a Donnybrook with Tunak Tunak
Just like Kulbushan Yadav..who qas caught in Baluchistan ( Pakistan) by Pakitani intelligence ..KY was heavily involved in terrorism.
Yadav was in Iran trying to operate business exports, not in Pakistan. The Pakistani ISI brought him to a town bordering Iran under the pretext of showing some goods and kidnapped him and brought him across the border and then "fabricated" evidence. against him.
Everyone know what the "world's Number 1 Spy agency", which cannot protect its own Army men from Balochi rebels and the TTP is capable of doing.
Engaging in "baccha baazi" (paedophilia with young boys for those who do not know the term used in Pakistan) and keeping scores of mistresses - remember the former ISI chief whose wife shot him in the butt after catching him sleeping naked with another one of his keeps?. The other Army Officer who misused money to run a pizza chain in Pakistan. That's the level of Pakistani army intelligence.
“You’re big meanies,India!”
-Trudeau
"Piss off TURD" - India
From what we have seen , it would seem that they are rather abrupt and suspicious.
If Canada call these Kalistani terrorists as activist, then Osama bin ladin should be also called as activist.
Doubt india really is shaking in their shoes, lol
Asia is a land of tigers, dragons and grizzly bears, the west constantly keeps poking these great creatures and ussually get humiliated by the trashing they receive.
If Trudo wanted to sleep with terrorists for his electoral gain, that is his problem and the fate of Canada. But if he patronise them and protect them in the guise of freedom and free speech and in turn these terrorists threaten balkanisation of India,attck hindus and temples in canada, attack its embassy and diplomats, threaten assassination of Indian leaders, that is totally unacceptable. Sikhs in India are very peaceful and dignified people who indulge in no violence. But under Trudos patronage, atleast a minority of Sikhs has turned to extremism. Terrorists are like Frankenstein,it will turn against its patrons eventually,that is what happened in Pakistan. All nation has responsibilty to eleminate terrorists as there are no good terrorists or bad terrorists. Trudo does not understand it as his minority govt will fall if Khalistani withdraw support. Trudo interfered in Indias internal matter when he made a political statement supporting farmers agitation two years back. And the same Trudo is accusing other countries of interfering in Canadas internal affairs. What a hypocrite.
You fail to mention he was a labelled terrorist by gov of india and a red collar notice was issued for his extraction which was not honnered by canada and now accuse us of his killing.
I dont know if govt was involved but if its then also its ok
Canada vs India, Ukraine vs Russia, US vs China and NATO joining each war besides Ukraine and Russia
Imagine NYT referring to killing of Osama Bin Laden inside Pakistan being referred to as -
"Today Pakistan accused America of killing a Pakistani Citizen inside Pakistan"
That's how absurd and convenient twisting of context NYT is doing in this podcast by referring a person declared as a "terrorist" by Indian Government as just a "Canadian Citizen".
Not true because Osama claimed credit and was CONVICTED not the case here , you can go killing other citizens in other countries
The expert has no idea what is he talking about India, Modi, Khalistan, Sikh etc……
How so? TIA 🧁
Exactly, understanding of a 5 year old.
Talk about journalism in the west
😂😂😂 Bringing Osama bin Laden's Islamic brother Mujib to talk about India...What a ridiculous joke these western media puppets are playing...NYT forgot about 9/11 committed by Mujib's Islamic brothers
This is “TOP NEWS” lol
Canada is not Trudeau. Call it as it is. Trudeau confronts India. Not Canadians confront.
So you're cool with foreign nations committing murder on your soil?
For real. The words "canadian" and "confront" typically never appear together.
Just as modi is not india.
@@Ak-wv7dtIt's not Modi. It's India as whole. Khalistani are a threat to India.
@@Ak-wv7dt lol 😂😂😂 . Every party including opposition party has supported indian government. The political parties who literally fight like cats and dogs are united against Trudeau . 😂😂😂😂
Why aren’t you talking about the atrocities by Sikhs on Hindus in Punjab or about the atrocities on Hindus in Canada and Australia. Your analysis is biased
So india and Russia start a new currency and all of the sudden this happens. 🤔
In the BRICS conference last month, several countries' petitions for full membership were approved (effective 1-1-24). Chief among them was Saudi Arabia, who will almost certainly openly accept the new BRICS currency, instead of just via bilateral trade deals.
The Petrodollar is a dead man walking; buckle up, because things are only gonna get spicier.
"Enjoy the show"- Q
I continue to urge all my Canadastani neighbor's to let Turdeau go hangout in the forest, indefinitely.
Multi-Cultural Diversity is your Strength 🍁
WTF does Trudeau know about free and open society? That’s a stretch.
Also, this kind of thing happens all the time by the USA, on its own citizens no less.
why don't you go live in Palestine? then you can come back and talk about free and open societies.
@@phobos258Hahaha you're so brainwashed you don't even know it 😂
@@phobos258maybe you should show the way. Move first.
Two wrongs don’t make a right.
@@biderdooI don't think he's the one trashing u.s.a and Canada, are you stupid?
A NYT podcast host was "shocked and surprised" that the diplomatic row with Canada would not have any adverse domestic political impact on PM Modi.
These guys simply have no clue of how India works.
NYT is full of woke idiots...they think nationalism and patriotism are bad words. I am proud of the way the country comes together at these times - ruling party, opposition, majority, minorities, left, right, centre. I remember that time during the Kargil War when wives of soldiers on leave from the front put tilak on their husbands and then sent them back...Country needs you, go back.
Calling India democratic?
I totally oppose Modi and BJP. But on this I support govt. Of India.
How that baised media😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
dont know what sort of person hired her for this job hard to listen
😂 damn ww3 gonna be crazy
Is india still changing its name?
What about trudeau's political agendas? And I don't BJP and Modi. But you have crossed a line while publically announcing Indians as assassins.
Damm!! New channel people don't know it was CIA and UK intelligence services that briefed Canada about the issue!!
Probably never know, eh? 🤷
You can't make such a serious allegation of the basis of who whispered to whom. Prove it! And if you can't keep your mouth shut! What your PM has done is proved once again that he is a fool and unfit to hold office. "Just Trudeau being Trudeau" as so many sane Canadians who are wiser than you have commented.
Look at the western folks in this podcast waterdown and downplay the Khalistani threat to India. No discussion by them of this narrarive from the Indian perspective or even an unbiased perspective for that matter. Violent threatening speeches, posters and videos by Khalistanis....where is all that discussion? And instead....Modi is painted here as someone who is assuming threats to come across as a 'protector'.
Nijjar is not a Sikh leader. He is a criminal and drug dealer who escaped Indian law and used the pretext of "political asylum" first and when it was rejected, maried a Canadian woman to acquire Canadian citizenship.
Calling Nijjar a "Sikh activist" is like describing Osama Bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahiri as "Muslim activists" or calling Joaquín Guzmán or members of the Sinaloan cartel as "Mexican activists".
We don't hear you describing them that way do you? You just run with the narrative that a White government sets for you, without doing any research..
If it's true there it should be told
Narrative building starts up by NYT which they are good at ! 😂 nijjar was terrorist accused of bomb blast !
My comment in NYT on the subject, hope this will be helpful to those who tend to be biased either way, please read, thanks.
Read carefully JT's words as reported: "Canadian security agencies have been actively pursuing credible allegations of a potential link between agents of the Government of India and the killing of a Canadian citizen, Hardeep Singh Nijjar," The PM's statement is carefully worded and reflects unproven accusations of the isolated pro-separatist Khalistan forces operating in Canada. JT only says his govt intelligence is 'pursuing' 'allegations' that could only be 'credible.' He apparently seeks cooperation of the Indian govt too, to get to the bottom of this accusation. Seeing his leadership of the party threatened, his coalition precariously dependent on the support of Jagmeet Singh's NDP and repeatedly snubbed by the Modi govt for allowing anti-India activities on the soil of Canada, JT is in a bind. He wants to forge a permanent link with JS and lock it into an abiding political alliance. One sure way is to serenade the separatist Sikh supporters of JS. Jagmeet himself has extended veiled support to the cause of Khalistan incurring displeasure of the Canadian Sikhs who aren't sold on separatism. Politicians in a democracy make unproven allegations against anyone if this action attracts a sizable chunk of voters. This is not new. JT has done a good job of cheering up the pro-Khalistan elements in Canada at the same time keeping his allegation against India vague. He knows a clear accusation of this nature could drag him into the ICJ where he would have to prove the charges.
[52 Recommend]
Reply:
Anwar Mumbai @Binoy Shanker Prasad Is it so easy to lie in parliament? And mislead for vote bank politics?
[1 Recommend]
Binoy Shanker Prasad @Anwar In this case, Justin Trudeau is not accused of lying in parliament, although politicians in high positions lie all the time. He was simply amplifying "fears" of a section of Sikh Canadians who suspected a "potential" link between the assassination of Mr Nijjar and the Indian intelligence agencies. It wasn't a definitive finding of the Canadian intelligence and that's the reason Justin Trudeau's govt "would pressure India to cooperate with the investigation into the killing.."
[3 Recommend]
www.nytimes.com/2023/09/18/world/canada/canada-india-sikh-killing.html?campaign_id=0&emc=edit_cr_20230919&instance_id=0&nl=comments-notifications®i_id=70286035&segment_id=0&user_id=6d4c1374527c6cac1d89b3e55965b7ea#commentsContainer&permid=127829988:127829988
Sorry man JT just made it worse for himself. Here is his new statement today:
"There are credible reasons to believe that agents from the government of India were involved in the killing of a Canadian on Canadian soil."
ua-cam.com/video/gJsug7OHSwY/v-deo.html&loop=0
Still no evidence though!!!
The US should inquire into this as well. India has come on against Canada strongly, and it raises suspicion of them.
Have you ever considered that maybe after making a fool of himself your PM and his cronies are spreading this rumour just to save face at least partially in front of the home audience: "Look, folks, so and so told us but they are refusing to come forward because they have things cooking with India so......"
@@anshu_1601 It is more likely that India's government is aggressively compensating with its constant antagonist actions. Guilt is a probable certainty.
Well your govt should also take notice of Canada providing safe heaven to Khalistani terrorists. If Niggar was Sikh activist than Osama bin Laden was Islamic scholar. Don't have double standards for defination of terrorism
@@rudiruttgernah west has a habit of letting terrorist go especially palestinian one’s until 9/11 happened
Please show the proof. You are already assuming that India has killed Nijjar. This is fake accusations against India. Nijjar was killed by inter gang rivalry. Canada has been most insincere nation. They never helped India in investigation of kanishka air india flight 182 that killed 329 passengers. Now Canada is dictating India on cooperating to self implicate itself on fake accusations.
Who was raw agent Kulbhushan yadav who was caught in Balouchistan by Pakistani armed forces?
"honor killings" are accepted
Is karima baloch get justice?rule of law apply in this matter?
'Dragged them out of their house, lit some on fire, hacked the rest to pieces' Yup. Sounds like hindutva
He was also wanted in terror activities in India.
You gotta be kidding me?!
@@runnergo1398 No, this is true. Canada has a history of sheltering terrorists.
Its a basic problem everywhere moment u get any muslim speaker biased talk against modi and against india government is guaranteed forget truth and unbiased opinion comeon man grow up atleast try to talk truth beyond some cheap poletics amd present the truth like it was pakistan that started khalistan moment after getting bangladesh being created and comeon people like us might not be modi supporter but ur ranting against modi do makes us believe modi do need next term...
as one sided as it gets, sounds like hate against modi is the main agenda here by male speaker😂
modi ur papa
Okay, I am not pro-modi but this video was so biased. Downplayed Trudeau’s political political intentions here and the Khalistani’s provocations in Canada.
Mujaib and the host not one word about khakistani attack on hindus. Nyt is blatantly hinduphobic
2019 modi was struggling 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Such a biased podcast. Incredible
Because they were not worshipping at the feet of India?
What the name of these people who are talking about these events ?? Are they historians what gives them the right to speak on this topic , and why are they not showing their faces ??? Let’s go back to the Bombing of the Air India flight in the 80s that killed 300+ Canadians was it done by peaceful protesters ??? No it was Khalistan supporters !!!
You dont want to listen you dont have to.
Trudope kilt that man
Canada confronts lol yeah sure, when did they start that??
Last was in 1800s or so when they got their own country. 🍁
To all Canadians, do not forget who orchestrated the biggest terrorist attack.
Remember Kanishka Air India Flight 182 Bombings ?
These are the same Khalistani culprits !!
All listeners the person your hearing is Pakistani jourlist mujib so no credibility of this video
Heads up on WEF subterfuge
Israel has done it to Iran.
I do not support targeted killing by a government in another country. But how is it different from say USA killing its citizen, Anwar al-Awlaki in another country? Or Israel killing Iranian scientists and others in another country.See the movie 'Munich' by Steven Speilberg
India was created not on the basis of religion but a place for all regions who hold idea of Bharat. It's bigger than each one of us
Then why do you have a Hindu first agenda & persecute religious minorities?
Sadly that was true in the past..not anymore..It's gotten worse for minorities..
Nobody cares about that. India has no right to order assassinations in other countries
Minorities including Muslims vote for Modi in significant numbers. 67% of Muslim women support reforms Modi is pushing for their freedoms and rights. I would say it is less of a Hindu first agenda and more of an “idea of a modern India that values its history and traditions” first agenda.
Indian confidence? What is right and wrong here?
Wait a minute this guy was on interpol since 2018 fleeing India since the bombing attack …. Why is this presenter not speaking the truth who Mr Nigar was a known person of interest wanted in India ??? This podcast is lacking in Facts and is filled with false narratives
Wait a minute, bjp/rss I.T cell paid WhatsApp university graduate andhbhakth troll pointed ☝️😂🤣☕️👍🙈🙉🙊
Oh the New York Slimes Communist PROPAGANDA RAG!!!!
Stop massacre and Free JAMMU And KASHMIR! 😢 STOP KILLING and torturing of Sikh people!! 😭
虐殺を止めてジャンムー・カシミールを解放しましょう！ 😢 シーク教徒の殺害と拷問をやめてください!! 😭😭😭!!!
I’m just disgusted it wasn’t their president
Full propaganda about modi. Do u know opposition is totally backing modi on this
You are cheating your self if you are concidering your self news reporter.your title of subject is irritated to essence of issue.
Modi would be well served to see how Canada handles internal separatist movements. They are not imprisoned, tortured, or killed. They are encouraged to form their own political parties and seek independence in a democratic and civilized manner.
Modi can take his uncivilized violent tyrannical approach and get the hell out of Canada.
STOP inhaling your own farts and getting high!!!
No, he has a better example in United States. Canada is not a serious country. It is a rogue banana republic where black on black violence and brown on brown terrorism is not only condoned but actively encouraged by callous White politicians. Old colonial policy of divide and rule.
Separatists in Canada are not committing bombings, arson, and assassinations in Canada.
Which is exactly what these terrorists are doing in India and is the reason why they have been classified as terrorists in accordance with international law.
You are ignoring that tiny little detail.
So India should overlook the bombing and the murders in India by Canada based Sikhs.
I do not support targeted killing by a government in another country. But how is it different from say USA killing its citizen, Anwar al-Awlaki in another country? Or Israel killing Iranian scientists and others in another country.See the movie 'Munich' by Steven Speilberg
@@joecombs7468 Mr Nijar - the Canadian murdered in Canada - had not committed any of these crimes and was certainly not a terrorist. He was a plumber living in a suburban Vancouver neighborhood.
Very nice indeed … balanced , comprehensive …
Agreed
I don't need to look beyond your converted last name to understand why you would find this report accurate 😂.
Never fails to surprise. 😅
Agree science and sharia makes plane fly
Why anyone still pays attention to ANYTHING by ANYONE at The New York Slimes is beyond belief!
Your here ...
@@nodi1217you’re*
THey are still more reputable that anything you have to say.
What’s up with authoritarian right wing leaders assassinating people abroad. Putin Bin Salman Modi Kim Jong Un Trump.
The ny slimes is the worst.
He is lying , I'm Welcome you to verify your self
Trudeau as a backbone.
Need to confront them about all the damn scam calls I get
The Canadian Government is not as innocent as portrayed in the media. Recently, there was a massive protest in India funded by the Canadian government. There is always another side to the story, but Western media often only presents one side of the story and history. Regarding the issue of immigration from India, Indian immigrants play a crucial role in driving Canada’s economy, which would have collapsed without them. Additionally, Canada’s real estate-based economy would have experienced a significant decline.
The Canadian government lacks sufficient evidence to support its case. In contrast, in India, we have abundant evidence and proof of Canada’s involvement in our domestic affairs, masked behind the veil of freedom of speech
Why the ukraine colors?
This video getting 50x the normal amounts of views for a NYT [podcast episode tells you the Indian troll/bots are out in force!
For God's sake, what is a "credible allegation!?". Trudeau as a backbone..
After going through this message, “my children’s planning to go for higher study in Canada has been cancelled…,”
If my money is being used to disturb my mother land by Canada political administration, I don’t want to send my kids to Canada..,
The study loan may be more than 1.5 crores. If this money is going there. The part of money will be or may be used against my nation’s integrity. My mother land is more important than my children’s studies at nonsense country..,
My country is more important for me than my children’s studies..,
Let every Indian parents should rethink before sending their kids to Canada for higher studies.
Jai Hind..,🙏😊
The events that this man was allegedly murdered for happend 40 years ago. This truly is the worst timeline.
He was murdered by rival gang
Interesting and even discussion. Canada has opened its arms to not only Sihks but many indians and itvis always sad to see the violent and prejudicial bebaviour brought to our shores. Believing in a safe place for those left behind shoyld never include violence. Modi is certainly pumping this up to his own warped benefit
The Canadian Government is not as innocent as portrayed in the media. Recently, there was a massive protest in India funded by the Canadian government. There is always another side to the story, but Western media often only presents one side of the story and history. Regarding the issue of immigration from India, Indian immigrants play a crucial role in driving Canada’s economy, which would have collapsed without them. Additionally, Canada’s real estate-based economy would have experienced a significant decline.
The Canadian government lacks sufficient evidence to support its case. In contrast, in India, we have abundant evidence and proof of Canada’s involvement in our domestic affairs, masked behind the veil of freedom of speech.
@@buddyone1884go home 😂
@@buddyone1884could you elaborate on this massive protest in India, funded you allege, by the Canadian government?