Bulla Ki Jaana Main Kaun Lyrics Meaning & Hindi Translation | Rabbi Shergill | Bulleh Shah

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 січ 2024
  • Bulla Ki Jaana Main Kaun, a crowd favourite song from the early 2000s in India and Pakistan, is one of Rabbi Shergill's most memorable songs ever. The origins of the song lie in a very old, a very philosophical and a very practical Sufi poem by Punjabi Sufi poet and philosopher Bulleh Shah.
    Rabbi Shergill did a wonderful job of converting the poem into a song that has enjoyed being in almost every Hindi & Punjabi speaking 90s kid's playlist at some point of time.
    Due to its lyrics, I find this song to be amongst the most meaningful and philosophical songs ever. In this video, I wanted to share the meaning of these words, written by Bulleh Shah and sung beautifully by Rabbi Shergill. The meaningful lyrics will definitely leave you with some food for thought.
    The core lesson of the song is around the topic of self awareness, using the age-old concept of neti neti. Check out the video for more. :)
    Here are the lyrics for your reference:
    ======
    Bulla ki jaana main kaun!
    Na main Moman vich Maseetan
    Na main vich Kufar dian Reetan
    Na main Pakan vich Paleetan
    Na main andar Bed Kitaban
    Na main rehnda Bhang Sharaban
    Na main rehnda mast kharaban
    Na main Shadi na Ghamnaki
    Na main vich Paleeteen Pakeen
    Na main Aabi na main Khaki
    Na main Aatish na main Paun
    Bulla ki jaana main kaun!
    Na main Arabi na Lahori
    Na main Hindi shehar Nagauri
    Na Hindu na Turk Peshawri
    Na main Bhedh Mazhab de paya
    Na main Aadam Hawwa jaya
    Na koi apna naam dharaya
    Avval aakhar aap nu jana
    Na koi dooja hor pacchana
    Mai ton hor na koi syana
    Bulleh shah kharha hai kaun?
    Bulla ki jaana main kaun!
    Na main Moosa na Pharoah
    Na main Jaagan na vich Saun
    Na main Aatish na main Paun
    Na main rahnda vich Nadaun
    Na main Baithan na vich Bhaun
    Bulleh shah kharha hai kaun?
    Bulla ki jaana main kaun!
    ======
    You can find the original song here - • Rabbi Shergill - Bulla...
    #philosophicalsongs #rabbishergill #sufisong #deepmeaning #lyrics #punjabisongs
    --------------
    Check out all of my work on my website -
    chetannarang.org/
    If you have a question for me, ask me here - chetannarang.org/ask-a-human-...
    For one-on-one personal sessions for life coaching, counselling & philosophical mentorship with me -
    chetannarang.org/nondual-phil...
    Subscribe to my channel here - / theunlearningplayground
    Find all my book recommendations here - chetannarang.org/book-recomme...
    Connect with me, Chetan Narang, on Instagram here -
    / nrng.chetan
    Checkout The Unlearning Playground podcast here -
    chetannarang.org/the-unlearni...
    Sign up for The Unlearning Playground newsletter here - chetannarang.org/newsletter/
    --------------
    Credits for the beautiful soundtracks:
    "Reaching Out" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
    creativecommons.org/licenses/b...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 174

  • @_Karanjot
    @_Karanjot 2 місяці тому +6

    I feel that
    "Avval aakhar aap nu jana,
    Na koi dooja hor pacchana"
    is commentary on how only you know best, who you are,
    No one else can truly know you

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  2 місяці тому

      Yes, quite true. In fact, that is one of the interpretations I considered in this video too.
      Starting here - ua-cam.com/video/rMzM9krTeWc/v-deo.htmlsi=g27y9is9vROeNRWq&t=769

  • @Inner.divinity
    @Inner.divinity 3 місяці тому +15

    Bulleh Shah is basically saying that he is still exploring himself / consciousness which is beyond all man made boundaries, identities and perceptions..

  • @sameetkhaldy7376
    @sameetkhaldy7376 5 місяців тому +6

    After 2004 when last year I listened to this song almost after 20 years. The song still holds power to transform and beauty of telling a lot about life in simplest way. Bulle Shah wrote this poetry such amazingly that it is still relevant and will be forevermore. Hatts off to Rabbi Shergill for singing it so beautifully. It's because of his voice that I'm in love with this song.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому +1

      Yes, I can totally relate to that sentiment.
      Also, welcome to The Unlearning Playground!

  • @shivamv1440
    @shivamv1440 5 місяців тому +9

    Very well explained sir..Lyrical meaning of this sufi song seems analogous to Nirvana shatakam of vedanta philosophy in Hinduism...that's where we shed the boundaries of religions and merge into supreme consciousness....

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому +2

      I am glad this video resonated so well with you. Welcome to The Unlearning Playground. Keep sharing the love! ✌️

  • @denverfernandes2880
    @denverfernandes2880 4 місяці тому +5

    I heard it during my college days. And today its in my playlist and i listen to it daily..
    It has a calming effect.

  • @Ashishtiw
    @Ashishtiw 5 місяців тому +4

    Thanks bhaiya. I discovered this song and Rabbi Shergill when I was listening to “tere bin” then I saw his it’s from a album so I listened the whole album and I loved this because of it tune and lyrics then I searched for video this song then by surfing I got your video. But now I got to know that this song has so much meaning in it….❤

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому +1

      This was indeed the purpose of this video. Thank you for leaving this comment. Welcome to The Unlearning Playground! ✌️

  • @riyaankityadav1299
    @riyaankityadav1299 2 місяці тому +5

    Main aj bhi din main 4 5 baar sunti hu love this song

  • @shaza5856
    @shaza5856 Місяць тому +2

    Thanks for explaining for non native punjabi speakers. I have slightly different view on it.
    He is saying that he is an ordinary human first. He is not good, nor his is bad. He cant be differentiate by higher or lower class and cast. He is average. Last he says i only know myself better, and not anyone should judge him because he is smart enough to understand himself.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому

      Like all true wisdom, this song/poem has different levels to it. And what level resonates with you of course corresponds to the level of your consciousness at the moment.
      So, while what you are saying is right, there is a higher level it is alluding to, which is what I have tried to share in this video too.
      There is an even higher level in one sense, which is very hard to convey in words anyway, but I tried in one manner to talk about it in this video here - ua-cam.com/video/_7KHuItxuuo/v-deo.html
      Do check it out too, and I look forward to engaging more.

  • @PrashantZombade
    @PrashantZombade 5 місяців тому

    Superb explanation! I just loved it. Thanks a lot. This is one of my most favourite songs. Keep going 😊

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому +1

      Thanks. I am glad this resonated so strongly with you! Keep sharing the love! 🙂

  • @rajeshsharma8874
    @rajeshsharma8874 2 місяці тому +1

    Beautifully explained. My take is that we often love to characterize people and associate ourselves with certain things like class, race, religion, etc. Baba Bulleh Shah challenges these stereotypes, a sentiment that resonates with the view of the 14th-century Bengali poet Chandidas, who said, 'Shobar upor manush shotto tahar upore nai' ('Above all is humanity, none else').

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  2 місяці тому +1

      Beautiful! Thanks for sharing this here! 🙌
      Keep sharing the love! 💚

  • @shivangssinha1915
    @shivangssinha1915 4 місяці тому +2

    This was the video i was searching for thanks brother.

  • @dhirajchavhan3213
    @dhirajchavhan3213 День тому

    Sir, very well explained.
    Thank you

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  День тому

      You’re welcome. Glad this landed so well with you.
      Do share ahead with your friends and family too. ✌️💚

  • @rinti2k7
    @rinti2k7 4 місяці тому

    Thanks a lot for such explanation,great

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Thank you for your appreciation. Keep sharing the love! 💚✌️

  • @sarweshranjan2773
    @sarweshranjan2773 24 дні тому

    Listening 🎧 continuously yet

  • @harshadkulkarni5874
    @harshadkulkarni5874 6 місяців тому

    This was great Chetan! ❤
    One of my favorite songs and a great analysis

  • @samthesmith88
    @samthesmith88 2 місяці тому

    yesterday night i got intuition & i listened to my all time fav song and came to know it's meaning for first time. i was amazed that this was self enquiry.. wow..i loved it.. thanks for teaching it's meaning

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  2 місяці тому

      You're welcome. I am glad this landed so well with you.
      I run a dedicated playlist where I discuss more such meaningful songs, you can have a look at them here - ua-cam.com/play/PLGTAFgEsIneUbAkDLCNB1Kyu_Z3E7NP9u.html
      Keep sharing the love!

  • @user-xr4jf9iz5n
    @user-xr4jf9iz5n 4 місяці тому

    I was searching for this song meaning...thanks alot ❤. Please make more such videos

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Thank you for your motivation.
      This is a dedicated playlist on my channel. You can find it here - ua-cam.com/play/PLGTAFgEsIneUbAkDLCNB1Kyu_Z3E7NP9u.html&si=iE0fv7xWqnC796c2
      Welcome to The Unlearning Playground.
      Keep sharing the love! 💚

  • @Samir12357
    @Samir12357 3 місяці тому

    Man . great video.. i woke up today and was about to play a song and there was this video on recommendation. Glad i clicked it. Thank you UA-cam for the recommendation and thank you brother fir the explanation. Now Subscribed to your channel. Will be checking your videos as well...❤❤

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому

      This is the first comment I am reading today, and you just made my day. Thank you for saying what you said, and a very warm welcome to The Unlearning Playground.
      Looking forward to seeing more of you here. ✌️💚

  • @MazharKhan-ui3rw
    @MazharKhan-ui3rw Місяць тому

    Thank you
    You explained it so well

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому

      You’re welcome. I am glad you liked it.
      Keep sharing the love! 💚

  • @vaishnavibhargava3584
    @vaishnavibhargava3584 2 місяці тому

    Amazing Content ❤❤❤ All the very best

  • @asifurrahman1040
    @asifurrahman1040 3 місяці тому

    Very meaningful Sufi song, thanks sir

  • @madhabroy1824
    @madhabroy1824 3 місяці тому +1

    I was searching for bulle sah poems and found this masterpiece song (minimum praise).
    Thanks for explaining the actual meaning .
    Please make analysing videos on other Sufi songs like ...
    ---arziyan
    --kun Faya Kun
    --ishq sufiyana
    ---bhar do jholi

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому +1

      Thanks. I am glad this resonated with you.
      And thanks also for the recommendations. I will add them to my queue.

  • @Naveenarora2110
    @Naveenarora2110 Місяць тому

    Bahut badiya bhai ❤

  • @ravindergulati1075
    @ravindergulati1075 4 місяці тому +1

    Thanks a lot for telling us the meaning of the song Bullah ki Jana

  • @user-ji8rs3pg5k
    @user-ji8rs3pg5k 2 місяці тому +1

    in the word of coca cola tu, iam glad Bulla Ki Jaana exists, his bilqis song is another masterpiece

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  2 місяці тому

      I appreciate that sentiment.
      And thanks for the recommendation, will check it out! 👍

  • @ashutoshsinha5561
    @ashutoshsinha5561 4 місяці тому +3

    Matlab nahi chiye Dubey ji ... mei yaad karlenge .. I'll memorize it

  • @dr.hiteshkumarmakwana1108
    @dr.hiteshkumarmakwana1108 22 дні тому

    It's nothing but a conversation btw. Arjuna and Krishna btw the battle and lord Krishna explain it very nicely ❤radhe radhe ..

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  22 дні тому

      You’re right that the core message is the same in this song and in the Bhagawad Gita.
      Also, I would advise you to focus on the “nothing but” in your sentence above. “Nothing but” makes it seem like you’re belittling something in favour of something else. If both are the same, let’s consider improving our language to not belittle any one.
      Hope this lands well with you.
      Peace out.

  • @Alok91183
    @Alok91183 3 місяці тому +1

    I just came across your channel through this song. Must say, very beautifully explained. Great work brother and please keep it coming.
    One request, not sure if you have covered it, but will love your explanation of 2 below mentioned songs:
    1. Kun faya kun from Rockstar
    2. Arziyaa from Delhi 6.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому

      Hi Alok, Welcome to The Unlearning Playground. Thanks a lot for your positivity and your recommendations. I will definitely add these to my queue.
      Looking forward to interacting more.
      Keep sharing the love! 🙌💚

  • @rahult5753
    @rahult5753 4 місяці тому +1

    This has changed by perspective about life, about human being and about everything.....🫡

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Well, thank you for saying that. Welcome to The Unlearning Playground. I'm sure you'll find more videos here that will make you say this many times over. Keep sharing the love! 💚

  • @KishorSharmaExploringLife
    @KishorSharmaExploringLife 6 місяців тому +2

    Amazing explanation ❤👍😊

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  6 місяців тому +3

      Thanks. I am glad it resonated with you!
      Keep sharing the love! 💚🙂

  • @Eternalsoul6079
    @Eternalsoul6079 3 місяці тому

    Brother you've explained it very well. It was helpful indeed. And in my opinion this song's lyrics is very helpful in spiritual journey..this relates to the question " who am i " and tells us about our true nature that we are not this body, not even our mind, We are not what we identify ourselves with. We are the one and only pure consciousness/ soul/Atman ❤🕉️🙏

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому +1

      I am glad this touched you so well, and I appreciate your appreciation!
      Keep sharing the love! ✌️💚

  • @pushpinderkaur2537
    @pushpinderkaur2537 5 місяців тому

    Amazing brother 🙌

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому

      Thanks. I am glad you liked this.
      Keep sharing the love! 🙌💚

  • @svatantrasena3666
    @svatantrasena3666 Місяць тому

    One great poet......neti neti neti

  • @niharikagupta3475
    @niharikagupta3475 Місяць тому

    beautiful interpretation

  • @tusharguptamusic
    @tusharguptamusic 6 днів тому

    Beautiful ❤️

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  6 днів тому

      Thanks. Glad this landed well.
      Do share with your friends and family too! ✌️💚

  • @sudarshan3965
    @sudarshan3965 6 місяців тому

    Great explanation

  • @heenatiwari0102
    @heenatiwari0102 3 місяці тому

    This is amazing

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому

      Thanks. Glad this resonated with you.
      Keep sharing the love! 🙌

  • @user-ri1fh6po5v
    @user-ri1fh6po5v 4 місяці тому +1

    I know not who I am
    Vulla ki Jana me kuan❤

  • @akshatvikramsrivastava1786
    @akshatvikramsrivastava1786 Місяць тому

    “In Dino” song from Life on a Metro..its about self love...

  • @SachinKumar-ud2ye
    @SachinKumar-ud2ye 3 місяці тому

    Thank you Sir.

  • @attaullahk.1986
    @attaullahk.1986 3 місяці тому

    Thanks!

  • @sumittandon1148
    @sumittandon1148 5 місяців тому

    Great brother

  • @TannuSingh-mk6ty
    @TannuSingh-mk6ty 2 місяці тому

    Ye song mujhe mere Naveen sir ne search krne ke liye kha tha such m bhut acha h ye thank you eska meaning smjhne ke liye

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  2 місяці тому

      You’re welcome!
      I am glad this resonated so well with you! ✌️

    • @TannuSingh-mk6ty
      @TannuSingh-mk6ty 20 днів тому

      सर आप पटाखा गुड्डी सॉन्ग पर भी वीडियो बना दे।

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  20 днів тому

      Noted. Sure. 👍

  • @shantonusarker9684
    @shantonusarker9684 2 місяці тому

    Love from Bangladesh brother ❤

  • @satyamray2113
    @satyamray2113 3 місяці тому

    Pura humanity ko pahuch na hai "bulla ki jana main kaun" wale state pe.
    As our current state is we may disagree at the superficial level at few points but apne core meaning ko ache se deliver kia.
    I would like to see more of these kind of song review videos.
    Keep brightening your inner light. More people will join your channel as the urge to get at the roots of their existence grow in them.
    Very very few channels are doing this.I am not saying you are perfect or trying to over praising you but this is needed for our civilization as most people just watch the song without never understanding that they must understand the meaning behind it as it gives meaning to their existence.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому

      Thank you for your message. I appreciate it. In essence, yahi purpose bhi hai The Unlearning Playground ka. Glad to see such resonance with you.
      Do share with your friends & family and help spread the word.
      Looking forward to seeing more of you here.
      ✌️

    • @samthesmith88
      @samthesmith88 2 місяці тому

      yes true

  • @asifhassan4980
    @asifhassan4980 2 місяці тому

    He is addressing the three fundamental Questions that human being has been troubled with
    1. Who am I ??
    2.Where I come from ??
    3. Where I go from here ???

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  2 місяці тому

      Yes, quite true. And the fact is that there are answers available for everyone who is willing to listen. ✌️

  • @prometheus91147
    @prometheus91147 5 місяців тому

    Very thought provoking interpretation. Hope you get what you deserve.. appreciation from Pakistan

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому

      Thanks a lot for your comment. Keep sharing the love! 💚

    • @prometheus91147
      @prometheus91147 5 місяців тому

      @@ChetanNarangOfficial Always brother. Also Your other video about journaling gives me a push to start journaling again and it helped to keep me calm and less anxious and now i just hope ke ye jo thora bht existential crisis bacha h khtm hojaey I'm dealing it for a long period of time.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому

      Glad to know the messages are reaching you so well. Do let me know if I can help out in any way.

    • @prometheus91147
      @prometheus91147 5 місяців тому +1

      @@ChetanNarangOfficial Sure! Thanks

  • @EEnglis_and_hindi_learning666
    @EEnglis_and_hindi_learning666 4 місяці тому

    Sattshriakaal Maalkon! mannya jaanda hai ke jeda insaan hai naa, o dharti te shresht praani hai. E gal changi vi hai attee mandi vi. Assin jiss zariyee naal Communicate kar raheenhan aadmi di hi saugaat hai. Magar phir vi aadmi hunn tak, apaneaap noo naheen samajh sakiya e kahendeenee Baabba Bhullee Shaah Ji. Dhanyavaad Ji Huzooron!

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Well said! And yahi awareness badhana purpose bhi hai iss channel ka! ✌️

  • @manav2059
    @manav2059 4 місяці тому

    Rabbi shergill have very beautiful and meaningful songs one of my fav is talash it is really a good song u should check it out

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Nice. Thanks for the recommendation. I will definitely check it out. 🙂

  • @ashishsrivastava5885
    @ashishsrivastava5885 3 місяці тому

    It's highly deep and philosophical.
    This is not for beginners nor badshah and honey Singh's audience.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому

      Haha there is some truth to what you’re saying.
      I would also say that the messages here are for anyone who is ready, and that CAN be Badshah’s or Honey Singh’s audience too.
      Hoping this reaches more eyes and ears.
      ✌️

  • @hariomsolanki_9580
    @hariomsolanki_9580 6 місяців тому +1

  • @pavannathani637
    @pavannathani637 3 місяці тому +1

    Sant kanwar ram ne bhi aisa gana gaaya hai jiske bol hain ,kian reejayan tokhe kian parchaya das ko daav.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому +1

      I see. Please do share a link if you have it handy. I would love to go through it.

  • @WePrepMeal
    @WePrepMeal 3 місяці тому

    Great content! I am so curious to know the books in your background. I have similar collection but couldn’t make out some of them. May you share the names?

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  3 місяці тому

      Hey, thanks for the appreciation. I am glad the content is landing so well with you.
      To your question - the books in my background are available in:
      1. The book reviews playlist I run here on youtube. Here you go - ua-cam.com/play/PLGTAFgEsIneVKswD2eQthRrCLLvmYbQES.html
      2. My book recommendations - chetannarang.org/book-recommendations/

  • @NitinKashyap-pe5vw
    @NitinKashyap-pe5vw Місяць тому

    ❤❤

  • @gurkamalsingh4037
    @gurkamalsingh4037 5 місяців тому +1

    Bulleh Shah is Punjabi ! We can conclude this by the language of his poetry

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому +1

      Yeah, his language seems to be very much old-school Punjabi influenced by Urdu too of course.
      But I hope that is not the chief point you drew from this video! 😉

  • @advait_sant
    @advait_sant 6 місяців тому

    ❤😊

  • @nishantnicesongkalaskar9805
    @nishantnicesongkalaskar9805 4 місяці тому

    Nice

  • @user-cu3ll8gs9y
    @user-cu3ll8gs9y 6 місяців тому +4

    अच्छी व्याख्या की पर बुल्लेशाह जी को जानने के लिए उनकी जमीन पर ही जाना होगा।
    ये अनुभूति की व्याख्या है।
    सरल होना, पानी बहते पर पत्ते समान होना

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  6 місяців тому +1

      "Avval aakhir aap nu jaana, na koi dooja hor pechaana"
      Har vyakhya ke liye sach hai.

  • @ravisaah-ruhani8746
    @ravisaah-ruhani8746 4 місяці тому

    🙏🙏🙏

  • @Nishant-ESP256
    @Nishant-ESP256 Місяць тому

    You should watch some videos of Prof. HS Sinha. You will have a better grasp of philosophy and understand these concepts.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому

      Thanks for the suggestion.
      You should watch more of my videos to better understand my philosophy & understanding.
      Looking forward to seeing more of you in the comments section on The Unlearning Playground.

  • @lohithakshasuvarna345
    @lohithakshasuvarna345 Місяць тому

    It happens only in india❤

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому

      What exactly?

    • @lohithakshasuvarna345
      @lohithakshasuvarna345 Місяць тому

      @@ChetanNarangOfficial bulleshah being born in abrahamic religion realizing self it's quite rare in Islamic world and not acceptable

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому +1

      Hmmm I see. There is some truth to what you say. Quite often, people awaken despite of their life situations and not because of them.

  • @Indianculturalstyle
    @Indianculturalstyle 2 місяці тому

    💙💙💚💛👌👌✌✌🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @ompsikaria8075
    @ompsikaria8075 4 місяці тому +1

    आप जबरजस्ती बुल्ले शाह की इस कविता को नेति-नेति से जोड़ कर प्रस्तुत कर रहे है। न+इति (नेति) में इति का मतलब अंत (end) होता है। बुल्ले शाह इस कविता में सभी ज्ञात ज्ञान और मजहब को नकरारते है, और यह नकारना सत्य को जानने का अच्छा तरीका है। इस कविता का मेरा अनुवाद नीचे दे रहा हूँ, सहमत होना या न होना आपकी इच्छा है।
    बुल्ला क्या जाने मैं कौन हूं?
    न म मस्जिद में खड़ा मुसलमान हूं,
    न मैं काफिरों के रीतिरिवाज हूं,
    न मैं पतितो के बीच कोई पावन हूं,
    ना मैं वेद किताब में हूं,
    ना मैं भांग शराब मे हूं,
    ना मैं शराबी की मस्ती में हूं,
    ना मैं सुख हूं, ना दुःख,
    ना मैं पवित्र हूं, ना अपवित्र,
    ना मैं जल हूं, ना पृथ्वी,
    ना मैं अग्नि हूं, ना पवन,
    ना मैं अरबी हूं, ना लाहौरी,
    ना भारत के नगर नागौर का हूं,
    ना मैं हिन्दू तुर्क या पेशावरी हूं,
    ना मैंने धर्म के सत्यार्थ को जाना,
    ना मैं आदम और हब्बा से उतपन्न हूं,
    ना मैंने कोई अलग से अपना नाम चलाया.
    आदि से अंत तक मेरा प्रयास,
    खुद को समझने का रहा है,
    कभी किसी दूजे को नही जाना.
    मैं कोई और स्याना नही हूं,
    बुल्लाशाह यह आदमी जो खड़ा है,
    वह कौन है?
    बुल्ला क्या जाने मैं कौन हूं?
    ना मैं हजरत मूसा हूं,
    ना फिरौन हूं,
    ना मैं चेतन हूं,
    ना नींद ही हूं,
    ना मैं अग्नि हूं, ना पवन,
    ना नादानों के बीच से हूं,
    ना मैं शांति हूं,
    ना क्रांति,
    बुल्लाशाह यह आदमी जो खड़ा है,
    वह कौन है?
    बुल्ला क्या जाने मैं कौन हूं?

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Jiss sense mein aapne upar iss gaane ke baare mein do lines likhi, and jiss sense mein maine "Neti-Neti" word ka use kia hai, usme kuch difference nahi hai.
      Shabdo ke khel mein mat jaao, asli bhav samajhne ki koshish karo.

    • @ompsikaria8075
      @ompsikaria8075 4 місяці тому

      ​@@ChetanNarangOfficial बुल्ले शाह इस कविता में अपने ऊपर से सारे लेबल उतार कर फेंकना चाहते है, लेकिन आप खामाखा उन पर संस्कृत उपनिषद के नेति नेति का लेबल चिपका रहे है। आप पुराने सारे मजहबो और पुस्तको को भूल कर अपना दीपक स्वयं बनिए, यही शुभकामना है। अप्प दीपो भवः।

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Mera “Neti-Neti” word use karne ka purpose bas itna tha ki iss gaane ka aur “Neti-Neti” ka bhav same hai. Bas. Na maine iss gaane ko koi label dia, na uss kavita ko, na Bulleh Shah ko.
      Agar aap dhyaan se dekho to yaha koi labelling kar rha hai vo aap khud ho. Iss baare mein thoda meditate karo, aur meri aur videos dekho. Iss channel ka naam hi “unlearning” ke around hai. Hum labels ko “unlearn” karvate hain, and apni ulat-fer thinking se hui attachment ko bhi. Thoda dhyaan lagao.
      Galat hona fir bhi theek hai. Galti na maanna zyada galat hai. ✌️

    • @ompsikaria8075
      @ompsikaria8075 4 місяці тому

      @@ChetanNarangOfficial वेद शब्द "नेति-नेति" और बुल्ले शाह की इस कविता का आशय एक नही है। आपको मेरी बात से असहमत होने का अधिकार है, इसमें कुछ गलत नही है। सीखना, सीखे हुई बेकार बातों को त्यागना और दुबारा से सार तत्व को सीखना यह आपके जीवन मे घटित हो यही मेरी शुभकामना है। हिंदी लिखने के लिए देवनागरी लिपि का प्रयोग करना सीखें।

    • @Antivenom158
      @Antivenom158 4 місяці тому +1

      हिन्दी लिखने के लिए देवनागरी लिपि का प्रयोग करना सीखें इज हीलेरियस😊

  • @ravindraautee2448
    @ravindraautee2448 28 днів тому

    English song का विश्लेषण करो सर

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  27 днів тому

      Kia hai Sir. Iss playlist mein Hindi aur English dono songs ke "vishleshan" hain - ua-cam.com/play/PLGTAFgEsIneUbAkDLCNB1Kyu_Z3E7NP9u.html

  • @krishnakrish9247
    @krishnakrish9247 3 місяці тому

    Plz break down sant kanwar ram kean reejayen

  • @drneelimashilotri8440
    @drneelimashilotri8440 4 місяці тому +1

    All philosophers are forever in identity crisis 😅

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Haha, good one! The solution however is not to ignore philosophy, but rather to transcend it. There is simplicity on the far end of that complexity! ✌️

  • @parveshkumar3638
    @parveshkumar3638 4 місяці тому

    Na bhai bullah say i know who i m and nothing else . He saw himself with his soil eyes

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      I did mention this pov in the interpretation of the last stanza

  • @litilraistar
    @litilraistar 5 місяців тому

    बाजार फिल्म की गजल दिखाई दिए यु

  • @parveshkumar3638
    @parveshkumar3638 4 місяці тому

    He come out from his physical body

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  4 місяці тому

      Elaborate this more please.

    • @parveshkumar3638
      @parveshkumar3638 4 місяці тому

      Sir ji bullah come out from his body means his shuksam body come out from his physical body

  • @buyaka4782
    @buyaka4782 Місяць тому

    This version is god mode level good: ua-cam.com/video/jA49Sjolgw0/v-deo.htmlsi=ZXRap1fTXfMeRqVU

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому

      Thanks, I will check it out too.
      I have seen some of his work and I do appreciate him!
      Keep sharing the love! 💚

  • @anujssf567
    @anujssf567 4 місяці тому

    भईया ये गाना किस भाषा में लिखा हुआ है?

  • @rishikeshwagh
    @rishikeshwagh 5 місяців тому

    Ye sach ya woh sach? Sirf tum sach.

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому

      Sach?

    • @rishikeshwagh
      @rishikeshwagh 5 місяців тому

      ​@@ChetanNarangOfficial 'The Truth'

    • @rishikeshwagh
      @rishikeshwagh 5 місяців тому

      ​@@ChetanNarangOfficial It is an ancient Vedantic anecdote

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  5 місяців тому

      Sahi hai. I understand where this comes from. I was merely trying to question ki kya sahi mein “sirf” tum sach? But theek hai, most probably wordplay zyada ho jaega than what I like to engage in.

    • @rishikeshwagh
      @rishikeshwagh 5 місяців тому

      @@ChetanNarangOfficial Sachi Muchi

  • @soulshadow1048
    @soulshadow1048 4 місяці тому

    He was agnosticism.
    but i find my self in quran..who i m

  • @mohdzeeshan1282
    @mohdzeeshan1282 Місяць тому

    Kufer mtlb Atheist nhi hota h

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому

      Ok, maybe. But I hope ki tum iss video ki bhaavna ko samajh paaye. If yes, inn 1-2 shabdo se farak nahi padta.

  • @irshadahadnajar1506
    @irshadahadnajar1506 Місяць тому

    Khud ko bada ni samjte the..balki apne aap ki nafi yani apne aapko wo hakeer samjte Thea.. unkind puri bio pado ..aise toa koi kuch b bol deta hai

    • @ChetanNarangOfficial
      @ChetanNarangOfficial  Місяць тому

      I don’t think tumne video sahi se dekhi bhi hai.
      Ache se thande dimaag se dekho.
      Aur fir comment delete karne ka mann kare to kar dena.

  • @user-nj1ov2zk4m
    @user-nj1ov2zk4m Місяць тому

    Shukriya Bhai