Understanding China's transformation firsthand with David Moser
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 вер 2024
- Arriving in China more than thirty years ago with nothing more than an interest in Chinese culture and philosophy, David Moser ended up witnessing China's monumental evolution from a country just discovering Coca Cola to a wealthy, worldly, and confident nation. His experiences in China inspired his enthusiasm for cultural exchange, the importance of curiosity, and the necessity of dialogue to grow greater understanding of the country he calls home.
About NCUSCR:
The National Committee on United States-China Relations is the leading American, nonprofit, nonpartisan organization devoted to promoting constructive engagement between the United States and Greater China.
With over five decades of experience developing innovative programs at the forefront of U.S.-China relations, the National Committee focuses its exchange, educational and policy activities on politics and security, education, governance and civil society, economic cooperation, media and transnational issues, addressing these with respect to mainland China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. Our distinguished board of directors and individual and corporate members from around the United States represent many viewpoints, but share the conviction that ongoing public outreach, face-to-face communication and forthright exchange of ideas is essential for healthy Sino-American relations. Learn more: www.ncuscr.org....
David is a very rare talent from America work in China for last decades , he is objective and independent in his observations.
Ok, who is David Moser? No introduction, no bio… I assume he’s not the Swiss footballer?
30 years in china, he's basically chinese now lol
Modernization is not necessarily westernization . Don't mix this up .
westernization only works since 200 years.
Very true. The west adopted chinese inventions before becoming industrialized. The west modernized after adopting chinese inventions like printing, gunpowder, paper........on and on and on. The west did not "Chinanized or Asianized:)
Communism is a western concept. Where do you think the CCP came from?
@@Thinkofwhatno they just colonised and forced them to buy opium
@@308_Negra_Arroyo_Lane Precisely. Humanity learned and adopted ideas from one another. Just because Chinese adopted communism or socialism doesn’t Chinese is westernized and vice versa:)
When you learn the Chinese language, you learn Chinese vocabulary, expressions, and concepts, which come from their classics. In this way, you will naturally learn Chinese culture, values, wisdom and the Chinese way of thinking. I often feel that the Chinese people are very lucky because their language makes them a wise, collectivist, harmonious, cooperative, moderate, and moral people.
What is about luck it's about culture and sacrifice not slavery and credit score 😂😂😂
Really?
Chinese in Taiwan: Democracy and freedom.
Chinese in China: Great firewall of China.
@@308_Negra_Arroyo_Laneare you talking the opposite ?
@@Lim-212 You do realize how disgusting what he said was, right? "their language makes them a wise, collectivist, harmonious, cooperative, moderate, and moral people." Really? With the history of the CCP? Holy delusions.
You are perfectly right! I speak 5 languages and learnt about the culture and mentality of those people! Now I learn chinese which gives acess to a different mentality only looking at the structure of grammar, completely different from english, french, german etc! It is a very interesting journey and my dream is to be able to visit China, where the CCP showed the world how a political party, based on meritocracy, lifts its people out of poverty ascending to be a peaceful partner for all nations in the world!
China is more unified than many western countries. Diverse but not unpunished. All 56nethnic groups are allowed to keep their custom and dialectsl. A better life is priority for everyone. isn't it ?
Who wants poverty and foreign interference?
Life is freedom, not consumer goods.
Unless you are a Uighur
@@SK-lt1sofreedom is good but it not necessarily puts a meal on your table, there are many example’s worldwide
@@Manni793
Despotism produces food?
😆😆😆
You really are a CCP zombie!
Trust me the US is not ever going to see it like that.
Rational and reasonable people like him are so rare these days.
Lol. He said absolutely nothing.
Espically in the comments section of UA-cam and social media channels
@@308_Negra_Arroyo_Lane Did you even watch - listen to the video?
Watch some pro China guy that's been there for years is rational lol. Yeah we don't see it like that in the west.
Visited China several times over 20 years, and all i see and experience is progress. I wish my country could do the same. Kudos to China 🇨🇳
simple, when your country has stable govt. you get agreed planning and progress.
every parties minimize their rights for sake of political stability.
@@UKkenny how? you are in uk to prove something in china?
Then you should pack up and leave.
This man knows China, he truly understands the enormous complexity and diversity of China. Few people can catch this feature of China.
Many more of him, now on social media
well he's chinese ! of course he understands !! lol
Success was not served on a Silver Platter but thru hard work, dedication, sacrifice, unity, educationd, zero corruptions and Government-People cooperations.
LMFAO. And a few Cultural Revolutions, Great Leap Forwards, Tiananmen Massacres, Forced Re-Education Camps, and Covid Lockdowns.
The West thinks it comes with the help of a handout. 😂😂😂
@@brianliew5901it did come from a handout. It's not something that's thought it's a proven fact. No WTO no Nixon and Kissinger bringing you nothing. You stay like North Korea.
I wish him and many rational, intelligent people could take command of the country instead of the current candidates.
This country controlled by warmongers,their politicians sponsored by them!That's why they love wars,conflicts,color revolutions....chaos etc etc
As a Chinese, I have to admit there are crazy Chinese like many of the American politicians. But they are not leading China to the feared domination. We do not want to become America.
You will never have a situation where the United States will allow anyone to surpass them and the world not suffer Thucydides trap
This UA-cam video presents the heart felt and truly sincere views of an academic, with deep love and appreciation of the Chinese culture and language of over 38 years of immersion inside China, wishing more of his fellow Americans would become more acquainted and familiar with China. Unfortunately the mainstream media follows the predominantly official US government view of China as a threat and have been constructing walls and obstacles along the paths of communicating and understanding between the American and Chinese people. I wonder how many Americans will actually see this UA-cam video. Perhaps China's recent 144 hours visiting China without needing a visa would actually generate more interest from the western countries of visiting China and becoming more interested in China once they realize that how far astray they have been led to believe about China by the mainstream media. Thanks for sharing this video and best wishes to Mr David Moser.
Visit both China and Taiwan to see how the exact same culture diverges with one becoming a liberal democracy and the other a communist dictatorship.
You think the American people see China any different than the American government? Oh boy, are you ever going to be disappointed. Nope we see them as a threat as well, we always will.
No wonder it is different, as ot is based pn Taoist, Buddhist and Confucianism principles, which are much older concepts . Chinese will be stronger onowing and living by these principles, not copying the West, as these are better for the well being of the humanity.
Understand that China and Taiwan are culturally identical, one chose to be a liberal democracy and the other a communist one party state. They could not be more different today.
@@308_Negra_Arroyo_Lane A bot that is being paid by the $500 million that US is paying for those spreading propoganda about China. Enjoy the money Negra Arroyo Lane and may you sleep peacefully.
@@robertlai8088
Surely you understand that just because something is propaganda doesn’t mean it is false. Look at the entire Party media apparatus.
Going back to China for the 11th time later this year. It's always a lot of fun and my videos show this. Having friends and relatives in China is much different than being a tourist. Living full time in China is something I could do but probably will not because there are too many responsibilities in the States.
It's always a lot of fun as a tourist. Not so much fun to become a "subject" of the CCP.
@@308_Negra_Arroyo_Lane Tell that to the subjects in the us enjoying crumbling infrastructure, rising inequality and growing designated street culture in many of its cities
@@sammygit9486 LMFAO. It's very easy to build a road that nobody needs when there is no accountability whatsoever. Only the 100 million party members benefit from sucking the blood of the masses in China.
@308_Negra_A
rroyo_Lane
How would you know??
You have 2 parties to really choose from, both with the same policies.
Your elections are a huge joke.
Why does the declining US empire spend so much time and money having them??😂😂
@@sammygit9486
Unlike in China, in the US if you don’t like where you live you can move to a more happening spot. Things are always booming and busting to various degrees in the US. I fully expect it to be the same in the PRC given its vastness but if it one monolithic economy, then year it stands to reason, given the rule that nothing in economics rises forever, the fall will be just as impressive.
We have modernised but certainly not westernised.
Gutter oil, dog meat LOL.
Our Chinese culture is very good. Respect for the elderly. The way we address our seniors n friends. We are polite and humble. Look at the gold medalist swimmer Pan Zhanie. He felt the west did not want to shake hands with him was an insult, quote" If l may say so" . He deserves all the praises. His record is first in the world. West are sore losers n wated to dope the Chinese participants in the Olympics.
The observation he shared regarding China has a completely different paradigm of and set of value relating to human/society/governance/etc. is very important, most Western countries are not aware that there are different possibilities of mankind, but addicted to a zero-sum game.
Two comments: 1. when you praise/compliment a Chinese, he/she says nonononono, I am this or that not good, this is not sense of inferiority, but modesty required by Chinese culture;
2. CN gov never presents to the world that CN has only one voice/thought, diversity and differences between regions/ethnicities culturally, economically and politically are always acknowledged. There is great tolerance in China towards diversities (co-existing with the fact that it is an almost homogenous society w/ 92+% Han--the tolerance might be due to the long term co-existence and co-mingling of different races/origins/regions, the basic bottom line is you can do whatever, so long as you don't bother others.)
The Western MSMs/thinktanks try very hard to depict China as a country having no freedom, particularly, no freedom of speech, freedom of religion etc., which are myths. If you go to any Chinese social media or wechat group, you'll see the diverse political views, criticism, insults of or even attacks on CN gov, views different from the official stances, but they won't be bothered at all unless certain redlines are crossed, typically relating to stability/social unrest/etc.
Religions are freely practiced but they are not allowed to be used to organize crimes/incite social unrest or being used to interfere with Chinese internal affairs by external forces, religious groups are required to register according to law, also you are not allowed to preach to/convert minors (terrorist attacks in China in the past 30 years were always associated with people funded/directed by external forces), all adults can practice their religions openly/freely/lawfully.
David's suggestion is valuable, i.e., have more ppl go over to get to know China (even from your treating China as a threat perspective)--if you know China well, you'd understand Chinese are inner focused, they don't like to expand territories to take on others' problems, they don't like wars let alone starting wars. So the Western accusations of China becoming a hegemon/trying to dominate etc. are pretty much BS. Chinese like to be left in peace, work hard and make money...
Also the allegation that Chinese don't have values is false. If there is any value that is universal, this should be it: "don't do unto others what you don't want done to you" --all the rest is imposition of one group's value upon others.
May there be understanding, mutual respect, equality, integrity of sovereignty and peaceful co-existence, may there be common development and common wealth for the mankind.
Who can play spot the bullshit? In this well written and seemingly reasonable post, the writer slides in a steaming pile, i.e. (para. 6 line 4) "China doesn't like to expand territory" Tibet, Vietnam, India, South China Sea, Taiwan, etc. (essentially most its neighbors) may have something to say about this. Furthermore, the mass push to build a military capable of taking Taiwan by force by 2027, Xi's words, not mine, show continued violent intent akin to Russia's attack on Ukraine.
This post is an excellent example of the increased sophistication of the CCP narrative using the "two truths, one lie" method. I used to play this game with my Chinese students who were generally amazing wonderful people I'd like to add. My beef is with the CCP not the good ppl of China.
@@TPratchettAll those you mentioned belong to China from the Qing dynasty, just because China was weak and doesn’t like wars doesn’t mean unity and sovereignty of territory is not important.
@@TPratchettthe white spotted. tibet was invaded by the steppes in 12th century, before that it was following china. when kublai invaded china and moved to china he made the steppe give tibet up and from then on tibet became part of china.
vietnam is the same people as china and was following china until france invaded and colonised it.
the territory that india is claiming waa invaded by the british, whites again, which china never gave to them. same like vladivostock and parts of siberia which was invaded by the russians, whites again
taiwan? are you serious? hahahah go and check who invaded it and then come back whitey
Only westerners will imagine that China has a monolithic, homogeneous culture. No, the CPC never pushed that line. Educated Chinese understood that their country is one of the most diverse and multicultural in the world. They only have to talk to another Chinese from a different region and be reminded, if they needed to be reminded, that even the Chinese language is highly diverse.
So don't know whers you got the idea that the CPC had tried to present a homogeneous culture. Yes, it did push unity, but unity in diversity. Just watch a Spring Festival Gala which has the backing of the government. The variety there is astounding rven without the contributions from places like Africa.
Who cares, F the CCP.
Not long after Mr. Moser landed in China, I landed in the USA as a student, ultimately returning to Shanghai in 1995. Remarkably, I read Gödel Escher Bach in English (was a hot book in my Berkeley science circle) so it is most amusing to learn Mr. Moser translated it - sorry, have not read it in Chinese. What a great discussion, thanks for posting this.
I am pretty sure you understand the Chinese deep enough, since you understand the phrase 韬光养晦。
Mr. Moser is not wrong when he said Chinese people don't have one single view all together. Chinese people do have many different opinions about many things. But, pay attention, Chinese people will come together very quickly to achieve a common goal focusing like no other nation can. And that's why China has achieved such shocking modernization and industrialization so quickly in human history.
Gradually the West will begin to understand the extraordinary dynamics of the hugely diversified population of the Middle Kingdom !
Who keeps telling you that lie? If they surpass the United States, you will witness Armageddon.
Somebody from the outside needs to investigate US Gov't "Clock Work Orange" type practices. Millions are explicitly and implicitly involved.
It will be foolish for the western societies to try and isolate a culture that was around for more than 5,000 years.
Especially that this new China of 1.4 Billions people are fast developing into a modern industrialized country.
You (particularly the USA) need to make peace with China and share this planet of Gaia.
As Americans,learning a little Chinese can change our lives for the better. 外孙女，我爱你。爷爷，我也啊爱你。❤ If you’re Chinese, learning a little English will do the same.
There are 1.4 b people of course there are diverse opinions.
Really? What are those opinions? Prove it, without getting arrested by the CCP.
Seems to me the Party’s hegemony fans encourages one view only.
It is not just the Chinese who have a civilisational concept of unity amongst their peoples. The ancient Indian and Chinese civilisations were deeply interconnected and much of the Indian Vedic works were preserved in written form by the Chinese. Confucianism was born in China from these extensive interactions. A lot of this material was lost in India from successive invasions from the Turks, Afghans, English, Portuguese, Dutch and French who came to plunder and conquer. The loss of Nalanda University in India, for example, was incalculable to human civilization. But China was able to recover later from the devastation of the odium trade. India’s recovery has been a lot slower.
I would love to learn more about the "different concepts of Chinese human nature", about "the different starting off point for ethics " and about how Chinese perspectives challenge "Western perceptions".
I also think we in the West have a lot to learn about how to build a culture and a people who can work as one. I would love to learn more about this.
To be honest, these were the subjects I thought I was going to get a glimpse of in this video, but the interviewer's questions were too basic for the interview to get anywhere.
If anyone out there can offer books, podcasts, or videos on the above, I'd appreciate the recommendations.
There was a time in 60s when what every thinking person needed.. were food, shelter, warmth n clothes for winter ...afterwhich, the other natural stuffs like what all people wanted in luckier n more advanced countries.
.
Very good observations.
I am a professional translator and I disagree: AI has done a lot of damage to the profession. The wages of translators has decreased by a good 50% since I started in the late 1980s while the cost of living has increased several folds during the same time period.
@serriajohn In your dreams.
@serriajohn My bank account balance disagrees.
@serriajohn Nature does not care about efficiency. Nature cares only about survival. Photosynthesis in plants is only 4% efficient. However, plant can remain efficient at a relatively wide range of temperatures which is how they ensure survival, I.E: they sacrifice efficiency for survival.
Meanwhile, we seem to forget that we live on a finite planet with finite resources. That being the case, increasing efficiency inevitably leads to a faster depletion of resources which inevitably leads to a decreased ability to survive. What will efficient AI robots produce once most resources have been efficiently exhausted?
@serriajohn Birth control exists since the 1960s from which time the human population doubled. So good luck with that.
I am not sure what you are arguing about anymore. The purpose of industrialisation, including AI and computers, has always been to eliminate humans -- that are invariably unable to work as hard as machines, prone to making mistakes, generally unreliable due to sickness, regularly complain and require paying -- in order to maximise efficiency and profit. But as already pointed out, nature does not select for efficiency but for survival. In other words, human efficiency will be eventually eliminated by nature because it threatens survival. If you think humans are stronger and consequently can escape the laws of nature, you are deluded.
There is no such thing as unlimited energy and resources on a finite planet. Meanwhile, AI and robots are unconscious machines and, as such, do not give a damn if they survive or not. We do.
@serriajohn Complete BS. The Earth natural carrying capacity is 5 million humans as evidenced by the number of hunter-gatherers populating the Earth during the best part of 300,000 years.
Civilisation is a death-denying thought experiment that only started 10,000 years ago with the adoption of agriculture. Since then, the human population slowly increased to reach 2 billion people by the 19th century. It is only when we started using fossil fuels to power millions of machines that the human population skyrocketed to over 8 billion in just over a century: an unprecedented growth of any species ever seen on planet Earth in such a short time. Meanwhile, conflicts, wars and widespread pollution have increased exponentially to a point where every ecosystem is impacted some of them to the point of total extinction.
Every civilisation has collapsed at some point either due to climatic changes, to conquest or to decadence. Industrial civilisation will be no exception and will probably be the most short-lived of all due to its extreme lack of resilience and the rapid depletion of vital resources resulting from unprecedented levels of mindless consumption. Meanwhile, a single deadly virus can bring the whole construct down in only a few months and there is nothing we can do about it. The recent Covid pandemic provides a blatant proof of that as it brought most countries to a grinding halt... and the virus is not particularly deadly.
Being in the grey. To be in the grey is to be comfortable with ambiguity and uncertainty, so that we are open to new ideas😅
The government is not concerned of visitors see/feel Chinese culture, they are afraid of seeing the ugly side of the government!
Is there any places in city or country side you can’t go or not allowed to go as a tourist to see? Don’t be so empty in your comments please.
Chinese democracy is different from that of US definition. Respect the culture and social system of other nations is the basis of healthy bilateral relation.
China does not have any form of democracy. It is a one-party totalitarian authoritarian system.
A secular, humanistic, and rational society is essential for understanding Chinese culture, which, according to recorded history, dates back over 2,000 years to the time of Confucius at the latest. In contrast, Western societies today still remain predominantly semi-secular and semi-religious, despite advancements in science and technology and the so-called Enlightenment of the 16th century, which occurred less than 700 years ago.
Still Chinese young kids have more manners and politeness every parents was to instill in their kids.
You don’t think this is an universal issue? Why single out China when you knew this is happening everywhere. In fact, considering China’s huge population, I’d bet on China enjoying a better index in this regard!
people and culture is not the question or point，but the system in control.
和諧, Héxié; harmony
Does English have a word with the same very ancient origin, hush?
Harmonious; from Ancient Greek, with some English influence?
harmony(h)ush
From Wiktionary:
possibly related to early Indo-European, *her- (“to join, fit, fix together”)
I did my 10 years in China. That was enough. The one thing you need to understand about China is that everything Moser said about it is true, and yet, not true.
One has profound respect for this gentleman's views that are based off of his lived experience in China over three decades. That said, the mindset of the party and the politburo does not necessarily get reflected in the masses. China's people have historically had limited voice in the corridors of power.
Watch Jerrys take on china 😊
They have a different culture. The chinese pretty much lived under an authoritarian figure all the thousands of years in their civilization, it is all they know and want. The chinese believe that as long as that authoritarian figure protects them, and allows them to live a life that is safe and have the oppurtunity to have a family, home and earn their living, they will support that authoritarian figure, they are willing exchange some individual freedom for them.
They are a communal society and community and nation trumps individual needs. You are using your prism to judge them, why don't you just allow them to be themselves, as they allow you to be yourselves without judgement?
There is also an embeddedness problem here. He can’t really bad mouth his employers/employing country.
@@rap3208 LMFAO. And what about the Chinese in Taiwan?
@@308_Negra_Arroyo_Lane What about them? Do you knoe that they also had an authoritarian government up to the late 90s and begasn relaxing their control at just about the same time as the mainland?
You laugh because you don't know anything. MUTED!
orville shcell should bow to this guy.
A refreshing tots unlike indian news
GEB is a great work that was translated in China in the early days. Amazing you have helped the translators.
understanding China is easy understanding CCP that's another thing. For CCP there is only one China, One Party and one way to love the country
To keep the country intact.
he had said chinese doesnt use spelling words, so cant be good in technology.
Understanding the ordinary people of China, their culture, language etc is one thing. Understanding the current system of governance is another. It is the latter that emits all sorts of evil unto the world. It is this that provided the imperative to have its people under total surveillance and control. It is this that needs to be confronted firmly and decisively.
Firstly.... look at your own backyard...."emits all sorts of evil unto the world"...."people under surveillance and control"...."confronted firmly and decisively".....c"mon man...FJB.
IMHBO China will go to great lengths to understand Americans because they need your business.
But you as you said understanding sensitivities and nuances in countries becomes critical so as to not unintentionally offend your business associates.
Things like sitting on the floor and keeping your legs on the table are common place in America but considered poor and offensive respectively in India.
The bottomline is that you have to always find way to send a good,bad or ugly message to anyone with being rude and angry. Thats called putting F in Finesse.
You don't need to understand ANYTHING about Chinese culture to understand China. You only need to understand how the CCP functions and what it wants.
But that didn't happen for the llast the 30 years ? China was open and in 2010 China was the draw for students and business. Its different now
Don't know if it is still up, but Moser's essay on learning Chinese is one of the funniest things on the internet.
Thank you David for wanting to know us 😊
Hi Dave! When does a harmless fetish become a pathological malignancy? How would you know?
If you live under ground all your live, light is a scary thing.
And yet you believe in Tao Ying and Yang which is very much the epitome of how Chinese culture is.
@@grouchypatch9185 : Look a little more closely. 😎
@@grouchypatch9185 : Do I? Look more closely.
The PRC just needs to tear down the firewall and allow the people to connect directly without government concerns.
Years ago I had an online tutoring exhange where was offering free English conversations in a exchange for free Mandarin lessons anonymously.
VERY difficult for me to do that these days.
The Chinese don't exist for your benefit. The firewall is just like the Great Wall of China, to keep barbarian invaders out.
The China he knew is not the same China today. The people over there are also very different from the last few decades. The years when China wanted to be more open, having more dialogue, exchanging ideas are gone, and so as business opportunities, so why go at all?
Your guys may have difficulty to understand Chinese. China is deeply rooted in Han empire bc 200 - ad 200 when China system and spirits were solidly formed. They prevail all Chinese.
30 years? that would make him chinese already !!! lol
Interesting…
??????
Hmmm… having fun with 2 Taiwanese women with tongue twisting..
4:55 maybe you need to know more about your own, only then you get to know better about their knowing , e.g. 《美國反對美國》😂😂😂
Now that AI is here, there's no need to be FIXATED on any one language. Get a fix on the LIFE.
If you want to understand a nation, you have to learn the language. There are no shortcuts. If you're just interested in visiting a country as a tourist, AI will do.
@@vaska1999 good, settle down in each country for 6 months!
Shill gave himself away with the first statement. 🤦 Get all the government talking points off right at the gates. Good Lord you are all soooo bad at this!!! 😂
Edit: Major General Mao Xinyu approves this nonsensical video. 👃☝️
This guy had two TW girls when he was in HS.... lol the OG yellow fever guy
Guess he wasn’t indoctrinated, sorry, vaccinated like you?
Mao is great, well except maybe for those 40M people….
Is not the people but the in-charge. Just ask the people in HK. You disagree with the government, under the national security law, you will be arrested n charged.
Yea, you try to over throw the govt, you get charged with sedition and jailed in the USA.
你在偷换概念，国安法只针对违法的人，而不是有不同意见的人。你可以有不同意见，但不可以煽动反政府的行为，这在任何国家都违法。
Yeah, right. 🙄
Stooge for CCP.
I appreciate the earnest attempt he makes at balance and generosity in his answers to the questions, but my experiences in China have taught me most fundamentally that China under its current leadership is a threat to Western hegemony. The rest of the things that make China and its people "different" are just details that while often interesting are of secondary importance for the Westerner to understand.
Lol you guys would not even let your own kind rise to the top, let alone a country In the east
Western hegemony is well past its prime time and rapidly declining. However the white racists won’t compete but try to trip China’s progress.
Your system is a threat to the whole world. First, masquerading as a Christian nation but doing the exact opposite to what the Messiah taught. Second, your voting on first past the post doesn’t take into consideration those who voted against and those who didn’t vote at all when the sum of these two is greater than first past the post. Unless you changed the form pf governance to suit all voices of the people, your dork of democracy is a joke. Thirdly, what are the KPI to measure what your politicians promised during every election? It’s all rhetoric and most times people are sold a lemon. The bottom 50% of Americans are still stucked in time with more joining their ranks. The world doesn’t need an abusive and self appointed police kneeling on our throats, you can keep this practice in America.
Why should the west even support hegemony in the first place and cause themselves to have a constant fear or feel threatened. There should be more generosity to share power and learn from and tolerate each other as well as have more geo political democracy and less interference in other countries.
Hegemony is not a good thing, whoever is the top dog.
🙄👎
I haven't learnt anything new. China is big and diverse? China culture is different? Duh!
You have been there long enough?
@@grouchypatch9185 Yes, 20 years
改革開放is dead, David.
I am pretty sure you understand the Chinese deep enough, since you understand the phrase 韬光养晦。