No, the man on the right is Blösche. The scene in the film is a reenactment of a photo from April or May 1943. The soldier on the far left in the leather coat is actually unknown. Blösche is the man on the far right with the MP28 submachine gun. Two errors in the film: in the original photo, the soldier in the leather coat is carrying an MP40 and not an MP28. Blösche, on the other hand, was an SS Rottenführer at the time of the uprising and not, as portrayed in the film, an SS Unterscharführer.
@@mikewoletz2124 You are right. Sorry, my mistake. I just checked that. Blösche was also in other photo with jewish people in front with hands up. Among them was little boy who also got his hands up.
This Is the best Holocaust movie . The reason behind Is that Roman Polanski has been through all this and he knows how you feel when you are chased by monsters like the german nazis and their ukainian, romanians, hungarians, italian, french, dutch etc.collaborators. I personally know how you feel when you are chased by the arabs and i see no difference.
One of the people who actually fought in the Warsaw uprising (which took place some time later) was a young East-Belgian lad from the German-speaking community, Matthias Schenk. Despite his parents being German, he felt Belgian and had no desire to fight in the Wehrmacht. He applied for a job as a truck driver with some of his pals, but it turned out to be a trap so they could be forcibly drafted into the German Army. He gave one of the most detailed accounts of the Warsaw Uprising, and it was traumatizing to read. After everything he went through, Schenk decided he had had enough of it and deserted the Wehrmacht. Because he was still so young, a Polish family took him under his wing until after Germany had surrendered and he was free to return to Belgium. But after having been cared for by them for so long, Schenk always kept feeling Polish rather than German or Belgian.
Polanski was in the Krakow ghetto in the same ghetto as Schindler's List. From where he escaped in 1943 and was hidden by poor farmers in a village near Krakow. Only in the Warsaw was there an uprising.
I believe it was on purpose, while editing they decided viewers attention should remain focused on the person at the burning window, thus not distracting from the horror this person must have felt.
It’s always disturbing to think that many of these German men who committed these atrocities went on to live a normal life as “respectable citizens” (and receiving a soldier pension by the government) in postwar West Germany…
Like the American politicians that sold the war in iraq to the us soldier thay later regretted killing innocent iraqi and israeli government that sold the occupation to their citizen to fight
@@happybeingmiserable4668 Stalin never had any intention of helping the beleaguered Poles, no matter how much the Western Allies begged and pleaded with him. Stalin was ruthless and indifferent to the Home Army's fate because he already had his handpicked government of puppets (The Lublin Committee) to serve under him once Poland was consolidated under Soviet control.
As I'll quote our Warsaw tour guide: "Mad? No, the Nazi's weren't mad about the uprising. They were FURIOUS!" They honestly believed they could deliver hell upon a people for years and they would just passively accept. Even though their results were small, the resistance bravery was a huge F.U. and it signified that Germany's days were numbered.
The helmet was issued sporadically up until the end of the war when supplies of regular helmets ran short. Primarily to security and police units. Then to military units late in the war.
@@will-i-am-notComparing an American city to an occupied warzone in WW2 is what modern-day anti-American propagandists on the internet do. Why wouldn’t you just agree with him?
it's so incredible how people still think there was a chance they could be spared by the Germans as they were being thrown to the execution wall without charging with a fist fight being so up close
I don't think they did really believe it at any point up to then. You rise up against the German occupation forces? Death. Particularly in the East. And by then this was well understood. But just at the last moment, when there's nothing left to lose, to make one small gesture to make one final plea for mercy on the tiny chance it will be granted, is natural. No-one will give you a medal for dying defiant, whereas who knows? There may be a miracle and you may save your life.
Love how they got the famous picture of the germans, and the guy with the tommy gun standing at end. I believe he was tracked down after war and executed.
Unfortunately, however, a negligible number of criminals were incarcerated and sentenced to even symbolic punishments. Many of the criminals lived peacefully after the war, climbing the career ladder.
Assim como os japoneses, foram valentões e corajosos até o momento em que um adversário à altura os quebrasse as vértebras. Os italianos, pelo menos, nunca esconderam os covardes que eram.... Os alemães tiveram muita sorte de os soviéticos não os terem exterminado na proporção com que sua SS e seu exército fizera no leste.
@@dappert4730 It is not a Warsaw Uprising (1 Aug1944 - 2 Oct 1944) but events that transpired a year earlier - the liquidation of Warsaw's ghetto that culminated in Ghetto Uprising (19 April - 16 May 1943 ). That is why you see a wall seperating a place where fighting takes place with the rest of the city - which burned a year and few months later.
@@andrewroberts7428True. It was called total war or "Volkssturm". Everyone slightly capable of fighting was called to arms, old men, women, children. And many really did this or people who refused were shot.
@@gogogadgetGlock The descendants of the survivors of the Warsaw Ghetto (Eastern European Jews) have now put another race in a ghetto and are wiping them out. It makes complete sense if you think about it for 2 seconds.
Free them from what? They've clearly been "free" enough to have the capability to start, then lose wars continuously with Israel since 1948. Even after almost 100 years, the Palestinian Arabs cannot bear the thought of sharing their land with Jews. Sad....
A small part of something much bigger. 11 million people were killed in the Holocaust - about 6 million Jews and 5 million others. Why do we only ever yhear about the Jewish victims?
big difference - hamas, hezbollah and palestinians (even if just a minority, but still) did whats happening to themselves. could have already released remaining hostages and stop everything, but no they blaim the consequences for their own actions on others...
At 3:43 right to left: Josef Blösche, Heinrich Klaustermeyer, Karl Kaleske, Jürgen Stroop, unknown SS-Soldier.
Josef Blösche is on the left
No, the man on the right is Blösche. The scene in the film is a reenactment of a photo from April or May 1943. The soldier on the far left in the leather coat is actually unknown. Blösche is the man on the far right with the MP28 submachine gun. Two errors in the film: in the original photo, the soldier in the leather coat is carrying an MP40 and not an MP28. Blösche, on the other hand, was an SS Rottenführer at the time of the uprising and not, as portrayed in the film, an SS Unterscharführer.
@@mikewoletz2124 You are right. Sorry, my mistake. I just checked that. Blösche was also in other photo with jewish people in front with hands up. Among them was little boy who also got his hands up.
@@mikewoletz2124 He was also wearing goggles on his helmet.
I watched this movie at least three times. This is undeniably the most thoughtful work I've ever seen.
This Is the best Holocaust movie . The reason behind Is that Roman Polanski has been through all this and he knows how you feel when you are chased by monsters like the german nazis and their ukainian, romanians, hungarians, italian, french, dutch etc.collaborators. I personally know how you feel when you are chased by the arabs and i see no difference.
This man just can't sleep, everytime he is about to sleep the offensive neighbour keep making noise
One of the people who actually fought in the Warsaw uprising (which took place some time later) was a young East-Belgian lad from the German-speaking community, Matthias Schenk. Despite his parents being German, he felt Belgian and had no desire to fight in the Wehrmacht. He applied for a job as a truck driver with some of his pals, but it turned out to be a trap so they could be forcibly drafted into the German Army. He gave one of the most detailed accounts of the Warsaw Uprising, and it was traumatizing to read. After everything he went through, Schenk decided he had had enough of it and deserted the Wehrmacht. Because he was still so young, a Polish family took him under his wing until after Germany had surrendered and he was free to return to Belgium. But after having been cared for by them for so long, Schenk always kept feeling Polish rather than German or Belgian.
he fought in the Warsaw uprising in 44 not here in the ghetto
@@oxvancool8310 Excuse me. I will clarify it right now
whats the point of this comment?
@@PH-wc8llIf you read it, you learn something new. How crazy is that?
Probably woke up one day feeling Congolese.
The fact that Polanski himself went through all this is insane
now polanski making pianist from gaza
Polanski was in the Krakow ghetto in the same ghetto as Schindler's List. From where he escaped in 1943 and was hidden by poor farmers in a village near Krakow.
Only in the Warsaw was there an uprising.
In his honour they named the country after him
My boss's wife's mother was in the French underground back then as a young Jewish woman . She survived and died here in Miami of Alzheimer's .
Sound editor messed up at 3:10 and didn't provide a gunshot sound for the German soldier firing his rifle from the -left- right side of the street.
That's because the soldier was on the right side of the street.
@@Waterford1992 Oops, you're right. Damn dyslexia!
I believe it was on purpose, while editing they decided viewers attention should remain focused on the person at the burning window, thus not distracting from the horror this person must have felt.
😂😂😂
It’s always disturbing to think that many of these German men who committed these atrocities went on to live a normal life as “respectable citizens” (and receiving a soldier pension by the government) in postwar West Germany…
Wait until you hear about the atrocities that modern day soldiers commit.
@@thelonecabbage7834 You mean like Hamas? We're well aware.
@@yayayoma bigeest getto then warsaw ......Gaza
like the american soldiers????
Like the American politicians that sold the war in iraq to the us soldier thay later regretted killing innocent iraqi and israeli government that sold the occupation to their citizen to fight
Stroop's inner circle is meticulously portrayed
Damn fine movie about a very real individual and the events he was swept up into!!👍👍
This moment serves as a stark reminder of the atrocities of the Holocaust and the strength of those who resisted. Truly haunting and unforgettable
More of a reminder that the Red Army stood on the outside just watching lol
Apparently the holocaust is now justified based on what I’ve read. Shame.
@@happybeingmiserable4668 They wanted the two to destroy each other, filthy communists
@@happybeingmiserable4668 Stalin never had any intention of helping the beleaguered Poles, no matter how much the Western Allies begged and pleaded with him. Stalin was ruthless and indifferent to the Home Army's fate because he already had his handpicked government of puppets (The Lublin Committee) to serve under him once Poland was consolidated under Soviet control.
2:04ここで7.5 cm leIG18とかいうレアな歩兵砲が出てくるってすげーな('ω')
ok uwu
The most disturbing but important scene of one of most important films.
Great movie I had the DVD.
As I'll quote our Warsaw tour guide: "Mad? No, the Nazi's weren't mad about the uprising. They were FURIOUS!" They honestly believed they could deliver hell upon a people for years and they would just passively accept. Even though their results were small, the resistance bravery was a huge F.U. and it signified that Germany's days were numbered.
When you play tanks and commanders and just sit back and watch your gameplay battle unfold 😂
3:31 where’s iBuild Minecraft?? XD
Some of the SS wear a Great War helmet, that's absolutely inusual in 1944.
Which minute and second?
The helmet was issued sporadically up until the end of the war when supplies of regular helmets ran short. Primarily to security and police units. Then to military units late in the war.
I assume you didn’t know that was an actual thing?
Fake
The old equipment was used by police and rear units of the Nazi Germany, as well as the unused Bergmann MP28 submachine guns pleasant in the scene.
Looks just like a typical day in South Central Los Angeles.
😂
I very much daubt that, but it is a comment one would expect from an American, who has never been anywhere except los Angeles
LA Police raiding the hood.
in LA you are raided by black mobb, we were raided by animal Nazis XD
@@will-i-am-notComparing an American city to an occupied warzone in WW2 is what modern-day anti-American propagandists on the internet do. Why wouldn’t you just agree with him?
2:56 what are the signs
Warning: risk of epidemic. Entry prohibited.
1. **Achtung!! Seuchengefahr Zutritt Verboten** (German)
- **Translation:** Attention!! Danger of epidemic. Entry prohibited.
2. **Baczność Niebezpieczeństwo Chorób Zakaźnych Wejście Wzbroniocne** (Polish)
- **Translation:** Attention: Danger of infectious diseases. Entry forbidden.
it's so incredible how people still think there was a chance they could be spared by the Germans as they were being thrown to the execution wall without charging with a fist fight being so up close
I don't think they did really believe it at any point up to then. You rise up against the German occupation forces? Death. Particularly in the East. And by then this was well understood. But just at the last moment, when there's nothing left to lose, to make one small gesture to make one final plea for mercy on the tiny chance it will be granted, is natural. No-one will give you a medal for dying defiant, whereas who knows? There may be a miracle and you may save your life.
How do you know they thought they could be spared?
@@kbanghart you mean why I thought they would NOT be spared?
Nice movie..., good director 😮👍👍
Imagine how scary it must have been.
Love how they got the famous picture of the germans, and the guy with the tommy gun standing at end.
I believe he was tracked down after war and executed.
Tommy Gun? Not to be a nitpicker...But that's an MP 40.
That's an mp28 furry
He was not tracked down.
Unfortunately, however, a negligible number of criminals were incarcerated and sentenced to even symbolic punishments. Many of the criminals lived peacefully after the war, climbing the career ladder.
@@radbilcz you mean the soviets and Americans right?
Keren bro 👍👍👍 itu mengangumkan
What is missing from the scene is the Red Army watching from the outside laughing and cheering for both sides.
In 1943?
Where did you hear that?
You’re thinking of the later Uprising in 1944. This was the Ghetto Uprising the prior year.
the Red Army was some 1200 km away from Warsaw in the spring of 1943
This is ghetto uprising in 1943, not Warsaw Uprising 1944
So they really just would see someone shot next to them and jump over their body huh? No comradeship? Did they expect the same lvl of treatment
Assim como os japoneses, foram valentões e corajosos até o momento em que um adversário à altura os quebrasse as vértebras. Os italianos, pelo menos, nunca esconderam os covardes que eram.... Os alemães tiveram muita sorte de os soviéticos não os terem exterminado na proporção com que sua SS e seu exército fizera no leste.
Soviets only won because of Hitler´s bad choices and numeric superiority. It was pure luck.
@@eltioneganv8359 let's not forget HUGE American support as part of Lend-Lease program. Without it, Soviets would fight with bare hands.
@@kamilksiazek8019 You're right Buddy, but Russians and Pro Russians are very prideful to accept that.
best uniforms i’ve ever seen
Lo spaccato della città e’ un vero documento di arte pura!
Normaler Tag in Berlin
I guarantee those krauts weren't laughing and cheering a few months later
Oy vey rabbi
@@billywatts4689 Based
@@billywatts4689containment breach
detected
@@BayouBoy2443 what you on about Joo lover?
Oy vey
Jaded wojak treating to rough neighborhood outside like it’s noise:
1944年じゃないか？
そう，ワルシャワ蜂起 は9月1944年に終わりました
あ，すみません．9月じゃない，10月でした
@@dappert4730 It is not a Warsaw Uprising (1 Aug1944 - 2 Oct 1944) but events that transpired a year earlier - the liquidation of Warsaw's ghetto that culminated in Ghetto Uprising (19 April - 16 May 1943 ). That is why you see a wall seperating a place where fighting takes place with the rest of the city - which burned a year and few months later.
Was it? Huh, forget there was an earlier uprising in the Ghetto, thought this was the general uprising. Fair enough, stand corrected
And now…the victims are the perpetuators.
Looks like Gaza
More nonsense.
Estão pagando essas atrocidades lá no inferno!
Это снято в секторе Газа или Ливане? Я просто не слежу за новостями.
🙆♂️🙆🙆♀️ 🙋♀️🙋♂️🙋
In Ukraine
Germany has not paid Poland anything!
October 7
modern-day Gleiwitz Incident
Whats the problem even if it was true, they are partisans
1:20
Those fighters were hiding among the civilian population.
They’re partisans, Of course they were.
Yeah and that's a warcrime and makes them not protected by the Geneva convention. The Germans couldn't do anything other
they were the civilian population, because the civilian population were treated like combatants by the nazis
@@andrewroberts7428True. It was called total war or "Volkssturm". Everyone slightly capable of fighting was called to arms, old men, women, children. And many really did this or people who refused were shot.
🙋🙋♂️🙋♀️
It looks like what's happening in Gazza today...
Szpilman was a coward
Awful to watch
✡︎✡︎✡︎✡︎✡︎✡︎✡︎✡︎✡︎
And yet these German international marauders lost the war.
Y ahora los isrealies lo replican en Palestina
Warsaw Ghetto,Gaza today
No....to even compare the two is a disgusting cheapening of the Holocaust
The descendants of the victims here went on to do it to others a couple generations later. Shame.
Majority are from Arab world
Palestinians arent desecendended from germany or poland so what you said makes no sense.
@@gogogadgetGlock The descendants of the survivors of the Warsaw Ghetto (Eastern European Jews) have now put another race in a ghetto and are wiping them out. It makes complete sense if you think about it for 2 seconds.
@@TarekRamara Majority of who?
@@WilkinsMichael Israelis
free Palestine
From Islam
Free them from what? They've clearly been "free" enough to have the capability to start, then lose wars continuously with Israel since 1948. Even after almost 100 years, the Palestinian Arabs cannot bear the thought of sharing their land with Jews. Sad....
Never happened
Freaking troll
Yeah ok 🤡
Based
A small part of something much bigger.
11 million people were killed in the Holocaust - about 6 million Jews and 5 million others. Why do we only ever yhear about the Jewish victims?
@@jonahtwhale1779 Check out Germar Rudolf. Those numbers have been grossly exaggerated.
Yahudi propagandası .
Sure whatever you say Goebbels
From zionsit.
😂😂 what? 😂😂
comically bad battle scenes. and why does the media always show goose stepping german soldiers?
They must repent for a thousand years for what their ancestors did.
Deep
El ejército israelí ha visto muchas veces esta película.
War saw ghetto is now the Gaza strip 🇦🇺🇦🇺
big difference - hamas, hezbollah and palestinians (even if just a minority, but still) did whats happening to themselves.
could have already released remaining hostages and stop everything, but no they blaim the consequences for their own actions on others...
@@schobi791 exactly the same people fighting against the invaders of their homeland just to be free🇦🇺🇦🇺
Germany attacked Poland 🇵🇱
@@gooser__43 European Jews attacked Palestine 🇦🇺🇦🇺
@@schobi791 they had a hostage deal but netanyahoo wanted to keep the war going