John Byrne's Techniques and a Visit to Canada - Comic Tropes (Episode 12)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
  • This week I visited Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. So I cover Canadian writer/artist John Byrne and his work on Alpha Flight, a Canadian superhero team. Includes a visit to Comicshop and I eat a Canadian snack for each trope I come across!
    / comictropes
    / comictropesshow

КОМЕНТАРІ • 578

  • @ComicTropes
    @ComicTropes  6 років тому +125

    Important correction: when I list John Byrne’s trope of dense crowd shots, I incorrectly used an image drawn by Dave Cockrum.

    • @johnminehan1148
      @johnminehan1148 6 років тому

      I remember being disappointed when Byrne took over Uncanny X-Men . . . .

    • @Shiznaft1
      @Shiznaft1 6 років тому +16

      I remember being excited that he took over Uncanny X-Men ...

    • @Mitsuraga
      @Mitsuraga 5 років тому +2

      You are absolutely right that the ads make up some of the best parts of old comics.
      About the foods... ketchup chips have been available in the States, but I haven't seen them in many years. We do have cream soda, but not Crush brand. You absolutely can find Kinder eggs and similar products with toys embedded in chocolate, but it's very uncommon, usually only sold in specialty import stores and novelty shops.

    • @KTF0
      @KTF0 5 років тому +1

      You should burn that Spider-Man Chapter One issue. Terrible.

    • @jamesburke3413
      @jamesburke3413 5 років тому

      Thanks for covering John Byrne and Alpha Flight. It'd be really killer to see a video on a limited series he did entitled Next Men and a related graphic novel (I think) entitled 2112. Keep up the great work, Comic Tropes.

  • @rbiznezz2
    @rbiznezz2 4 роки тому +56

    Byrne is unquestionably one of the greatest ever. Disregard his wack attitude, lets celebrate the work.

  • @LanceAnderson77
    @LanceAnderson77 5 років тому +127

    "There's never gonna be an Alpha Flight movie, I can tell you that!" -- I'm bookmarking this video to see what you have to say in a few years. :)

    • @jeetkuneluke
      @jeetkuneluke 4 роки тому +9

      If Guardians of the Galaxy got two (soon 3) movies and the Inhumans and Agents of SHIELD got TV shows, why not an Alpha Flight movie?

    • @catwhowalks99
      @catwhowalks99 4 роки тому +12

      @@jeetkuneluke I just hope that if they make an Alpha Flight movie, they at least feature the original members from the John Byrne run, and don't remix the team.

    • @marqosmarqos1201
      @marqosmarqos1201 4 роки тому +1

      @Steve Funderburg absolutely because all heroes should be Caucasian and male.

    • @albertagibinik8883
      @albertagibinik8883 4 роки тому +1

      Gamma flight?

    • @conjugationsm8528
      @conjugationsm8528 2 роки тому +4

      @@catwhowalks99 worked for Guardians. Trust me, I was a "Those aren't MY Guardians of the Galaxy" old man until I saw the first movie. Sometimes remixes work better than the original in today's world.

  • @nohvarr13
    @nohvarr13 6 років тому +55

    I love John Byrne. His art style is solid and pleasing to look at and he had great runs on the Fantastic Four and Superman.

  • @EGA83
    @EGA83 4 роки тому +29

    Don't really understand why AF never got the love. I thought it was great.

    • @Myrdden71
      @Myrdden71 2 роки тому

      The X-Men/Alpha Flight crossover (2 issues) with Loki was awesome!

  • @Tang-qi6zw
    @Tang-qi6zw 7 років тому +101

    Insects and bugs are animals, though very small types of animals. They certainly aren't plants, plankton, fungi, or Protozoa. They aren't mammals or reptiles, but bugs are still animals.

    • @bencamp79
      @bencamp79 6 років тому +11

      Yeah, I couldn't let that one slide when I heard it. You prevented me from making my own comment though. Lol

    • @richpotter
      @richpotter 4 роки тому +5

      That bugged me (heh) too.
      I've corrected a number of people on this over many years. I don't know if anyone actually cares.

    • @juliaeaves8306
      @juliaeaves8306 4 роки тому

      There are only 3 kingdoms: plant,animal , and fungal.

    • @illwill1991
      @illwill1991 3 роки тому +1

      @@juliaeaves8306 are there really? I'm not a biologists so I'm not trying to correct you but then how would you categories single cell organisms? Or wat about like microscopic life like viruses and such? Are viruses animals?!?!?!

    • @juliaeaves8306
      @juliaeaves8306 3 роки тому

      @@illwill1991 if its not a plant or fungus then it belongs in the animal kingdom.

  • @docsamson198
    @docsamson198 4 роки тому +29

    I love John Byrne. But I would die for John Byrne when Terry Austin inks him.

    • @marqosmarqos1201
      @marqosmarqos1201 4 роки тому +3

      Terry Austin made his art look magical.

    • @comicbookninja5268
      @comicbookninja5268 4 роки тому +6

      I also think Joe Ruebenstein was a pretty decent inker for John Byrne . Their run on Captain America is pretty classic.

    • @marqosmarqos1201
      @marqosmarqos1201 4 роки тому +1

      @@comicbookninja5268 what year was that? Id like to pick up those issues

    • @comicbookninja5268
      @comicbookninja5268 4 роки тому +2

      @@marqosmarqos1201 Captain America #247- #255

  • @RobinDale50
    @RobinDale50 4 роки тому +23

    Fun fact: in an interview back in the day, Byrne stated that his paycheck bonus for Alpha Flight #1 (based on sales over a certain amount of issues) was $29 GRAND (US).

  • @brianfleetwood9742
    @brianfleetwood9742 6 років тому +23

    I like Alpha Flight precisely because it was hanging out off by itself.

  • @____2080_____
    @____2080_____ 6 років тому +58

    John Byrne is one of the best for me.

    • @burkeharris9699
      @burkeharris9699 4 роки тому +3

      I grabbed xmen 108 off the newsstand when i was a kid and it kindled my love of Bryne's work and comics.

  • @stefanavic6630
    @stefanavic6630 5 років тому +11

    14:35 I think it's actually pronounced Samsquamch.

  • @HCC788
    @HCC788 7 років тому +47

    Here's something weird. Shaman, as John Byrne drew him in this issue, looks a *lot* like Spirit from G.I. Joe. Alpha Flight's Shaman first appeared in 1979 (according to Wikipedia). John Byrne drew a few covers for the G.I. Joe comic book. In Canada, the code name for Spirit was "Shaman."
    Coincidence? Almost certainly.

    • @ComicTropes
      @ComicTropes  7 років тому +19

      Unfortunately, the truth may simply be that fictional Native Americans weren't always that diverse. Because I think you could also argue that Apache Chief from Superfriends looks the same too.

    • @neanderthalsnavel7411
      @neanderthalsnavel7411 6 років тому +3

      Watch the G.I. Joe Netflix episode of The Toys that Made Us. Those white guy designers were probably thinking cowboys vs. indians.

  • @Rometiklan
    @Rometiklan 7 років тому +28

    Love this vid. I was a huge Byrne fan, and collected Alpha Flight until Byrne left the book. Still a fan of his art but in recent years, Byrne has been like the grumpy old guy down the street who is always talking about the good ol' days and telling you "to get a haircut, ya hippy!" Love his diatribes though...definitely has an ego, lol.

  • @plismdp
    @plismdp 4 роки тому +12

    So hard on Alpha Flight! If You told me 10 years ago that Ant Man or Guardians of the Galaxy would have stand alone movies I would have laughed in your face, yet I think they did a good job with the films. And the Alpha Flight characters are pretty interesting. If they did a wolverine reboot I wouldnt be against including alpha flight as an introduction to a stand alone

  • @Cantonavader
    @Cantonavader 7 років тому +15

    The old man is from the Occupy Tundra Movement. Last holdout.

  • @sbyrstall
    @sbyrstall 4 роки тому +2

    I don't know if you read more of the AF, but Aurora has a split personality.
    Couple other non-comic notes: you can get Kinder Surprise in Michigan with no problem. I think we are the only state in the union. I don't know exactly when you made this but the most popular flavor is Fully Dressed. It's an awesome taste. It's not quite the same in the US.

  • @ThatCreepyReading
    @ThatCreepyReading 2 роки тому +7

    I know this video is old but I rewatch videos a lot from creators I love. Oddly enough I never subbed since I google the channel alot. Anywho, @ComicTropes mentions "Flying cross legged is a weird way to fly" There is actually a bit of a dark history behind that. Flying while cross legged is associated with various "Spiritual" and *religious* connotations outside of jeudaochirsitan mythology. In fact the Aum Shinriko "That weird Japanese cult that did the serine bombings" was started by Shoko Asahara who depicted himself flying in a very similar manner which is how he got people to join the cult in the first place. The stance is short hand for "Spiritual" but over the years has a bit more of an ominous culty vibe to it.

    • @naysmith5272
      @naysmith5272 2 роки тому

      this is a great video - out and about on location, lol. The chips and gravy and cheese is also good which I need to recreate in the UK tomorrow for lunch,.

    • @Kal_g
      @Kal_g Рік тому

      Hey! I didn't know you were a fan of Chris's work! Great to see you, Creepy!!

  • @fearlessskrull8286
    @fearlessskrull8286 6 років тому +9

    I love John Byrne's work on She-Hulk. It's funny that he and Dan Slott are both notoriously cranky, yet they brought a lot of humor and joy to that series.

  • @petitio_principii
    @petitio_principii 4 роки тому +26

    I had never heard Byrne was "controversial." I'd think he's almost the opposite, generally approved by large majorities.

    • @travisralph5284
      @travisralph5284 4 роки тому +4

      controversial in his views on creator's rights, after fighting with Kirby(somewhat famously) Kirby skewered him in his new book, Destroyer Duck, right after he left marvel.

    • @uncannyzee7391
      @uncannyzee7391 4 роки тому +17

      LOL. I discovered and joined the John Byrne Forum about 15 years ago, so excited to be able to speak to my idol. I asked my first question about the industry, telling Byrne how highly I thought of him. His response to my question about comic art was (paraphrasing)"Do we really have to have this discussion again? Bored already with you."

    • @Bonzulac
      @Bonzulac 4 роки тому +12

      He's so cantankerous on his forum, they sell t-shirts at comic conventions that read, "John Byrne thinks I'm an asshole."

    • @rockinrecords4081
      @rockinrecords4081 4 роки тому +5

      Uncanny Zee what a Scrooge. If he felt that way, he shouldn’t have even bothered responding. Why would you say something so rude to a person who just praised your work?

    • @jeffh8094
      @jeffh8094 4 роки тому +6

      @@uncannyzee7391 Yep. That's Bryne to a "T". I've seen him do that to many commenters on his forum over the years who were there simply to compliment him. Why do that? He also never misses an opportunity to toss dirt on Chris Claremont, 40 years after they worked together, for meaningless and nonsensically petty things. I find that when Byrne does this to Claremont it lowers him (Byrne) in my eyes and not Claremont. It is unprofessional at best for him to being doing this and outright childish, and petty at worst. He's still my favorite artist, though--just not my favorite person in comics.

  • @aldi404
    @aldi404 7 років тому +13

    This was one of the first Marvel Comics I read like 30+ Years ago :-)

  • @timmeyer9191
    @timmeyer9191 4 роки тому +4

    It is too bad we won't see alpha flight on the big screen. A really diverse team. Puck would be awesome. Well, if Guardians of the Galaxy can get a movie, why not alpha flight?

  • @CrashLanden
    @CrashLanden 5 років тому +8

    16:16 A lot of artists aren't John Byrne, they're just influenced by him (like Dale Keown, Todd McFarlane, Ethan Van Sciver, among others).

  • @theamericanwordsmith2670
    @theamericanwordsmith2670 3 роки тому +7

    Going back and watching older ComicTropes videos. Chris makes the best comic content on UA-cam.

  • @YujiUedaFan
    @YujiUedaFan 6 років тому +9

    Weird coincidence! I'm actually reading some of Byrne's comics now! I went to Wikipedia and looked what he did and saw he did the Champions 11-15 and 17!

  • @steve_bal4
    @steve_bal4 4 роки тому +8

    As a Canadian kid back in the day when Alpha Flight hit the stands I was overjoyed to see a team of heroes representing our country, and having John Byrne, the hugest comic book creater of the day doing it, was sheer bliss. I loved his run on the book and it's disheartening to hear it wasn't something he enjoyed because I never got that from his work. I suppose the title never took off simply because they were somewhat removed from the US, where 98% of stories and characters hail from (even the DC universe feels very American, despite the fictional city names). Unfortunately, I don't think anyone ever did the team or book justice again precisely because they weren't Canadian writers or artists (that I know of). With each re-launch of Alpha Flight it just got worse, imo. I'd love to see someone who cared deeply for the team to pick up the torch and run with it again one-day.

  • @pulsarstargrave256
    @pulsarstargrave256 7 років тому +15

    I agreed with John Byrne on that particular issue. Work for hire means precisely that. Having said this, without getting into a long harangue, I also think treating creators like travelling hobos (journey men and women) and not offering at least a fraction of benefits that the secretaries and printers get, is also problematic.
    BTW
    The character "Aurora" was a split personality who bounced back and forth between a Stern teacher and a flirty vixen!

    • @terrorzilla
      @terrorzilla 6 років тому +4

      Exactly and not only that, I seem to recall the other key point made was when Kirby has his own imprint he didn't treat anyone working for him differently--work for hire was work for hire under him as well.

    • @CelestialWoodway
      @CelestialWoodway 5 років тому +1

      Nah he was an ignorant dickhead.

    • @paulheap1982
      @paulheap1982 5 років тому +4

      @@CelestialWoodway no. He was being realistic. Kirby and others were well aware of the industry and the contracts they were entering into.

  • @RWSCOTT
    @RWSCOTT 2 роки тому +2

    Alpha Flight is the Firefly of Marvel comics. Wonderful quirky characters & situations. If DC could pull off a Doom Patrol TV series, Marvel could definitely do Alpha Flight.

  • @litfrenzy3345
    @litfrenzy3345 3 роки тому +2

    My two favorite artists were John Byrne and George Perez. Both were amazing class A egotistical pricks but that being said both are unmistakably talented to the nth power... unbelievably sharp! Another trope, More Shaph gin!!!

  • @aznsketcher
    @aznsketcher 6 років тому +27

    you totally forgot his NAMOR run! how can you forget his awesome run on Namor as the 90s rolled around.....

    • @CelestialWoodway
      @CelestialWoodway 5 років тому +1

      Can't mention everything.

    • @dabigdikdangler
      @dabigdikdangler 5 років тому +2

      It was good until he lost me with the Head Hunter reveal, a ruthless corporate raider apparently murders and mounts the heads of her enemies
      in her office, but they're really drugged and still alive with their bodies hidden behind the wall...weak sauce

    • @nr-dx4zz
      @nr-dx4zz 4 роки тому +1

      Its namor

  • @louiscyfear878
    @louiscyfear878 6 років тому +10

    I ordered the Marvel app for my phone found out that they had no John Byrnes Comics from west Coast Avengers to Fantastic Four or even the X-Men.
    Threw up- deleted the app and wrote a scathing review.

    • @ComicTropes
      @ComicTropes  6 років тому +2

      I could have sworn they had a bunch of the FF and X-Men stuff but it's been a while since I had the app. I wonder if Marvel will start pushing that stuff more, now that Disney has acquired the movie rights.

    • @louiscyfear878
      @louiscyfear878 6 років тому +3

      skunkape last year, they didn't & I need my John Byrnes.
      His _"Overpowered drop-dead gorgeous women leading to the destruction of team unity"_ tropes were instrumental in turning me into the socially inept nomadic recluse that I am today.😏

  • @CT68
    @CT68 5 років тому +4

    I respect what Dave Cockrum did, but when I think of X-Men, I think of the Claremont/Byrne era.

  • @hulksmash1357
    @hulksmash1357 8 років тому +24

    Byrne created Alpha Flight initially

    • @AmedeeBoulette
      @AmedeeBoulette 7 років тому +2

      X-Men 120/121.

    • @Cantonavader
      @Cantonavader 7 років тому +10

      X-Men 109....Weapon Alpha AKA Vindicator, AKA Guardian. The First Alpha Flight.
      Why is he a dick? Well intelligent people are scientifically known to have fewer friends. Who wants to argue with the stupid?
      John, you were my childhood hero and at 47 you still are. Thanks for all you did.

    • @MrSafior
      @MrSafior 6 років тому +2

      So for you, people who are dick to other people are genius?

    • @Shiznaft1
      @Shiznaft1 6 років тому +7

      I think what he was saying is that genius is often accompanied by an inability to cope with ignorance. (Geniuses are dicks, but not all dicks are geniuses.)

  • @canaan_perry
    @canaan_perry 4 роки тому +6

    Life changing art and storytelling for me. I think he used up the good girl gone bad story line too much though.

  • @marqosmarqos1201
    @marqosmarqos1201 5 років тому +4

    Can you do a video on George Perez and his run on the new teen titans one of my favorite books of the early to mud 1980's?

  • @kgmlb2
    @kgmlb2 6 років тому +10

    Hey Chris! I really like your channel. I was just looking through stuff about Rob Liefiled and came across you. Then I looked at your other episodes. Good stuff man. I'm on board.

  • @JetBlakNinja
    @JetBlakNinja 6 років тому +10

    Actually, Byrne never wanted to do the book since AF was only created to survive a fight with the X-Men. But Marvel begged him to do it and he did. However you can tell, especially n the first twelve issues, that his heart wasn't in it - like he was with his runs on FF and Superman.

    • @jonbodhi
      @jonbodhi 4 роки тому +1

      I’m one of those fans. I LOVED Alpha Flight, especially when they broke up at the start of their series, then we followed individual meme bets over the next year (or something like that )

  • @wdcain1
    @wdcain1 5 років тому +6

    John Byrne's run on _Fantastic Four_ still remains in my top favorite comic series of all time. It's the true definition of Marvel's first family.

  • @misterrea861
    @misterrea861 Рік тому +2

    Another John Byrne trope is big square jaw lines with warm smiles. I'm convinced half his popularity as an artist is because all the characters seem so happy to see you

  • @Rometiklan
    @Rometiklan 7 років тому +14

    Always wanted to get a John Byrne commission done. Huge, huge fan. He was one of my favourite artists growing up, and heavily influenced my own art. I've seen some original pages of Byrne's from X-Men and Fantastic Four pop up on eBay every now and again going for astronomical bids.

  • @montygatwick1829
    @montygatwick1829 6 років тому +6

    I’m glad to see you’re embracing Canadian culture! This video made me quite happy as a proud Canadian 🇨🇦

  • @philv2529
    @philv2529 6 років тому +5

    7:44 that kid's shirt is another trope of Byrne, reviving old Kirby stuff. Notice the directional drop shadow. Kirby used to do that and change where if falls based on the lighting. No other artist did that until Byrne revived it intentionally referencing Kirby. Ultimately nobody noticed either time.

  • @astrocitizen
    @astrocitizen 6 років тому +8

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the weirdo was supposed to be this archaeologist that an Inuit goddess kidnapped from a dig site, and produced Snowbird with him. Unfortunately, this experience, plus finding that years had passed during the night in "god-land", caused him to go crazy, hence his summoning of Goz -- er, uh, I mean, Tundra. The two characters were drawn very much alike but the people who compiled OHOTMU did not pick up on this, writing that Snowbird's father ran away in hysterics never to be seen again, while leaving Tundra's summoner as an unidentified man.

    • @jimcat68
      @jimcat68 3 роки тому

      It was one of those things that they left for the readers to figure out for themselves

    • @johnrussellpelt9091
      @johnrussellpelt9091 3 роки тому +1

      @@jimcat68 I can understand leaving it unsaid in the AF series, but OHOTMU is supposed to compile and explain as much as it can.

  • @ganjjabarsmedium2347
    @ganjjabarsmedium2347 4 роки тому +4

    I feel like not enough people appreciate his Next Men run. Some of my favorite art of his and story!

  • @TheLili1598
    @TheLili1598 6 років тому +6

    7:10 I love those old ads. I think it was in an early X-Men annual where I came across one for a compressed air rifle for kids. Ah, America...

    • @ComicTropes
      @ComicTropes  6 років тому +5

      The old ads are the best part of reading old issues for these reviews. But they can sometimes be a real distraction from me when I need to focus on writing a new episode's script!

  • @electrojones
    @electrojones 4 роки тому +4

    "It's odd. Artists don't use cross-hatched speed lines these days." (Holds up a 35 year old comic book).

  • @christianninsananda9626
    @christianninsananda9626 6 років тому +6

    John Byrne and Terry Austin were my peanut butter and jelly growing up.

    • @marqosmarqos1201
      @marqosmarqos1201 5 років тому +2

      They were Gods among men. I also enjoyed George Perez's art on the new teen titans

    • @davelanciani-dimaensionx
      @davelanciani-dimaensionx 4 роки тому

      Terry's inks were so critical to John's pencils. They cleaned up the images, which I think his art needed.

  • @Shiznaft1
    @Shiznaft1 6 років тому +2

    @ComicTropes It's odd that you mentioned he doesn't like to kill characters, he kills Vindicator in issue 12 of Alpha Flight. 17:59 You mentioned that Snow Birds observation is not grounded in anything. In the panel above it we see the land erupting and splitting apart as a result of Vindicator blasting Tundra.

  • @pmg585
    @pmg585 8 років тому +16

    Big Red is a popular brand of red cream soda in texas.

    • @ComicTropes
      @ComicTropes  8 років тому +3

      Never heard of that one. I'll remember it in case I visit Austin some time.

    • @KasumiKenshirou
      @KasumiKenshirou 7 років тому

      Big Red is sold in WA, too.

    • @UnlimitedProduction1
      @UnlimitedProduction1 6 років тому +1

      Maybe that's why I was surprised he never heard of it. It's everywhere here in TX

    • @SciFiFan2012
      @SciFiFan2012 6 років тому

      UnlimitedProduction1
      I've had Big Red in Arkansas but, it was a long time ago.

    • @davidhanson4909
      @davidhanson4909 6 років тому +2

      We have Barq's Red Cream here in Louisiana. Used to have Big Shot too, but I haven't seen one of those in years.
      I've also had Dad's Blue Cream...somewhere (AK maybe). Looks like Windex.

  • @SamGuthrie1977
    @SamGuthrie1977 7 років тому +9

    Good video. As a writer, Byrne only has one trope: time travel!

    • @sirperybLakeney
      @sirperybLakeney 4 роки тому +2

      I would think the most glaring Byrne authorial trope would be'fixing' older stories to make them more believable or to attempt to rationalize continuity.

  • @AdamBladeTaylor
    @AdamBladeTaylor 4 роки тому +1

    Poutine for the win!
    That and the cocaine that Tim Horton's puts into their coffee. lol
    Had a friend with a wife who lived in the US (was working on immigrating but had work and such to figure out so it took a while). But when she first came up to Canada, she had her first TIm's coffee. After that she was going through like 5-6 coffees a day. That shit is addictive as hell. lol

  • @HalfassDIY
    @HalfassDIY 4 роки тому +3

    I've been dipping my fries in gravy for years !

  • @petitio_principii
    @petitio_principii 4 роки тому +1

    Nothing wrong with "speed lines." They're nothing but a graphical semi-symbolical representation of motion blur. If it has "cross-hatching," or lines roughly aligned with the object that moved, it represents a slower movement, kind of like how those multiple faded-out spider-men in one panel represent "slow motion camera," but without being a slow motion. It's like a contour of the object that it's kind of still there in the after-image as you see a movement, versus the "entire frame," as in actual "slow motion" panels. I've always thought it was something kind of intuitively universally understood. Sad that it's gradually being lost as the "graphical vocabulary" of comics, makes it a poorer medium, reducing its resources in a world where it has to compete more and more with games and film/video.

  • @atarikid6719
    @atarikid6719 4 роки тому +1

    Perhaps The Reason Sasquatch Reminds You Of A Hairy Hulk Is Because His Powers Are Also Gamma Ray Related.

  • @AlohaBlade
    @AlohaBlade 4 роки тому +4

    I wonder which other “edibles” were harmed during the making of this one. Great show!

  • @PsychoBible
    @PsychoBible 4 роки тому +2

    How you gonna discuss Byrne's art and not mention his signature style of drawing eyes?

  • @whokilledlaura1404
    @whokilledlaura1404 5 років тому +1

    Good piece and it was fun to look at this issue again. Poor Dan Smallwood, she ain't coming back. One thing: "Aurora and Northstar's costumes have a 'maple leaf thing going on'? Dude, they're stars. As for other stylistic tropes, he loves the overhead establishing shot, and has frequently drawn male characters with upper lips to indicate they're gay.

  • @silverbeernuts4229
    @silverbeernuts4229 4 роки тому +1

    Hi Chris/Comic Tropes, I'm new to your channel so I apologize if my next question covers an earlier video you've made. Have you ever thought about doing a review of an inker that made John Byrne's X-Men unique especially when you compare inking by Byrne? Terry Austin, has always had a low profile in his career but his work speaks volumes. I wonder if Austin has retired. I don't see much of his work anymore. Love to hear your comments. Thank you

  • @chrisw6164
    @chrisw6164 2 роки тому +1

    I don’t care if John Byrne is cantankerous. Byrne Fantastic Four, Superman, and X-Men rule. I loved just about everything he did through Next Men.

  • @johnburwood6692
    @johnburwood6692 2 роки тому +1

    Alpha Flight was a top seller for Marvel through out Byrnes time making it. Issue 22 for example was 3rd in direct market sales behind X-Men 193 and Web of Spidey 2.

  • @comicbookninja5268
    @comicbookninja5268 4 роки тому +1

    The original Alpha Flight run ran from 1983 to 1994 for 130 issues so I don't really understand why you say they never "caught on". They weren't super popular but they were certainly popular enough to be published for 11 years. That's a pretty good run.

  • @marioozzie
    @marioozzie 4 роки тому +1

    What do you mean, no Alpha Flight movie? They just cast Peter Dinklage to play Puck and Melanie Laurent from Inglorious Bastards to play Aurora for the Falcon and Winter Soldier show... :)

  • @MrSeanPiggott
    @MrSeanPiggott 3 роки тому +1

    ‘It never really caught on’? If 130 issues over 11 years, 83-94, on its first run = ‘never really caught on’ I’d love to see your reaction when the Guardians of the Galaxy movie was first rumoured.

  • @marioozzie
    @marioozzie 4 роки тому +1

    Cream Soda in Canada is delicious and is usually white-coloured. The bottle you`re drinking from is a strawberry-flavoured variant, much like cherry coke is. I do remember Jimmy Kimmel mentioning poutine in a favourable way on his show once, and it is odd it hasn`t caught on in the States all this time...No offense but there are questionable foods you can buy everywhere in America, and a heart-attack inducer :) like poutine shouldn`t make anyone blink...just kidding about heart attacks. I do love poutine, but moderation...
    I`m surprised you tried kinder surprise which isn`t even Canadian in origin, but you didn`t go for Cadbury cream eggs?

  • @wendigo1619
    @wendigo1619 4 роки тому +1

    I don't have to look for alpha flight issue number one, because i own it since my older cousins gave me all their comics spanning from 1975-2001 and i still have them

  • @jpmcpheemcphee2695
    @jpmcpheemcphee2695 4 роки тому +1

    You should have went for the "coffee crisp" candy bar, I'm not a candy guy, but they are AWESOME

  • @ryan1976
    @ryan1976 4 роки тому +1

    Byrne didn't want to do an Alpha Flight book. He never put much thought into them beyond costumes and powers. He said they were just created to fight the X-Men. That's why he left so soon. He wasn't feeling it.

  • @foreverinteriors
    @foreverinteriors 4 роки тому +1

    I don't think you're really in Vancouver. I think you are in Seattle. Both cities look the same, both cities have mountains in the back, both smell the same. your in Seattle.

  • @wendigo1619
    @wendigo1619 4 роки тому +1

    Wait, you don't have Cream Soda in the states? Thats just wierd but you should have gotten Pop Shop though since its the first Canadian soda company

  • @Rangersly
    @Rangersly 6 років тому +19

    "It never really caught on" What?!? Never caught on? The original series had a run of 130 issues, it lasted more than 10 years! (from 1983 to 1994) Plus two annuals, a X-Men/Alpha Flight 2 issues limited series (1985) ... Then, a second volume of 20 issues in 1998, the Alpha Flight/Inhumans Annual of 1998, the second X-Men/Alpha Flight 2 issues limited series (1998)... And then. there was also the third run of 12 issues in 2004, a 9 issues limited series in 2011, a few other special issues and guest stars in other series, reprints issues, TPBs and hardcover collections... I would not say that it "never caught on". I will say this, the only time it sold really well or was any good was when John Byrne was doing it. The problem is that Alpha Flight never got a really good creative team that seemed to care or even just get the hang of the characters. Aside from Byrne, both X-Men/Alpha Flight 2 issues limited series (1985 and 1998) were very good, and had talented people doing it (Chris Claremont with Paul Smith in 1985, and Ben Raab and John Cassaday in 1998). The 2011 limited series also came close to capturing the spirtit of John Byrne's original Alpha Flight (by Greg Pak, Fred Van Lente and Dale Eaglesham. I think the fact that it is a 100% Canadian team, based in Canada is one of the reason the series doesn't really get the recognition it deserves, or a movie deal, or a tv series. Americans in general are not really interested in other countries (know of any other national team other than Canada who had such a long run in an american comic series?). Also, for some reason, Alpha Flight never got it's most popular member back in team. The most popular canadian superhero at Marvel, Wolverine was at a time both an X-Man and Avenger, or was part of multiple mutant teams at the same time, and even a member of the Fantastic Four, yet he was never back as at Alpha Flight as a member, only as a guest-star in a single issue in Byrne's run. Can you imagine Captain America never being part of the Avengers? That is what it feels for us Canadians that Wolverine never made it back to Alpha Flight, even if for only a short while, or part-time, or reserve member.

    • @Rangersly
      @Rangersly 6 років тому +1

      BTW, Cream Soda is usually clear or foamy white, not red colored. I think only Crush makes it red because Crush is usually colored (orange, grape, etc.)

    • @Ektalon
      @Ektalon 6 років тому

      Rangersly I believe Fanta sold both a clear and red cream soda back in the day.

    • @Rangersly
      @Rangersly 6 років тому

      I'll take your word for it. I grew up and live in the province of Quebec, Canada, and the The only Fanta I ever saw was orange, it was the rival soda pop of Orange Crush. Foamy white cream soda almost seems to have vanish from the supermarkets. It used to be very popular when I was young, especially with older people.

    • @slothbaby2104
      @slothbaby2104 5 років тому

      What Alpha Flight comics do you suggest? PLEASE ANSWER ME

    • @Mattg1616
      @Mattg1616 5 років тому +1

      @@slothbaby2104 I actually liked the original BUT the later issues were MUCH better! Aurora had a mental breakdown....Box got the bends and couldnt leave BOx, warchild and Beta flight....man Alpha Flight was SERIOUSLY underrated!

  • @Shinmsl
    @Shinmsl 6 років тому +3

    Disney may not have been able to even use Alpha Flight due to their connections to mutants and Wolverine, but now they're getting the mutants back from Fox we may see them pop up in tv form in the near future...

  • @jalderink
    @jalderink 6 років тому +2

    John Byrne is my absolute favorite! The Dark Phoenix saga, in my opinion, is Marvels greatest tale. Marv Wolfman and George Perez, forged DC's greatest, The Judas Contract.
    Both tales are sublime!

  • @Tinkering902
    @Tinkering902 4 роки тому +1

    You should have got a coffee crisp instead of the kinder Surprise, which aren't even Canadian.

  • @anthonynyman167
    @anthonynyman167 4 роки тому +1

    I loved the mention of Mr Byrne's dislike of nic names. Brings me back to an 80's FF issue where Spider-man feels he has to correct little Franklin for calling him "Spidey-Man!"
    Something about regretting allowing the old show "The Electric Company" refer to him as Spidey.

  • @themajordudes8194
    @themajordudes8194 3 роки тому +1

    The only thing better than poutine is butter chicken poutine; the best dishes from Indian and Canadian cuisine combined into one.

  • @aaroncasteel2281
    @aaroncasteel2281 4 роки тому +1

    Don't care for Byrne,... but thumbs up for the culinary tour.

  • @Snailbarf
    @Snailbarf 6 років тому +3

    Here's some you missed:
    Characters at 3/4 angle with their bottom jaw jutting out. Usually talking.
    Action scenes with no background but a solid color.
    Disembodied heads on a splash page or flashback to tell you who else is/was involved.
    Still great shit.

    • @Snailbarf
      @Snailbarf 6 років тому

      More:
      on side view every character looks like they forgot their dentures.
      At times characters look suddenly Asian.
      Characters that make one appearance are drawn with more care than the main cast.

    • @jC-kc4si
      @jC-kc4si 4 роки тому

      That's how he was able to get 4 pages of artwork done per day or 4 issues a month.

  • @scottanderson8167
    @scottanderson8167 5 років тому +1

    We didn’t see the Byrne Hold, where a villain holds a good guy or hostage up in the air by the neck.
    We didn’t see She-Hulk in a cheesecake pose.

  • @ajhunter7283
    @ajhunter7283 4 роки тому +1

    you run a comics you tube channel and wonder how comics are priced. pay no attention to your industry much?

  • @robcramer7477
    @robcramer7477 5 років тому +1

    There will be an Alpha Flight movie. Just wait.

  • @theunironicboomerang
    @theunironicboomerang 2 роки тому +1

    John Byrne is responsible for so many Comics that I loved as a kid. Iron fist, Captain America, I bought fantastic four just because he was drawing it, and of course his run on the X-Men is by far my favorite

  • @Mitsuraga
    @Mitsuraga 5 років тому +3

    I'm surprised you didn't cover one of his most well-known tropes, that being his bizarre and very difficult to ignore love of romantically pairing female characters with significantly older male ones.

    • @saiberunato
      @saiberunato 2 роки тому

      I think Mike Grell sorta dies that too.

  • @dragonlordthekingofdragons6373
    @dragonlordthekingofdragons6373 5 років тому +1

    I can imagine John Bryne sounding like a grumpy old man and blickering

  • @bobbyhulll8737
    @bobbyhulll8737 4 роки тому +1

    as a Canadian I was stoked when this cam out in the 80's still have the collection of the first run...i haven't checked but Bill bill Senkiewicz was a big fav as well for his run on Moonknight kind of the opposite of Byrne much more complex.and sketch like .and Michel Golden on Micronauts was mind blowing very original comic book style could always tell a Golden cover like a Norman Rockwellesque style to me

  • @crazyguyinmak77
    @crazyguyinmak77 5 років тому +1

    There was a panel full of rubble. Missed trope?

  • @ARMIV4
    @ARMIV4 6 років тому +3

    Absolutely love Byrne's work. It has been an influence on me ever since I first saw it as a kid.
    Cannot say the same about his...strong...opinions on things.

  • @ericthemovieguy
    @ericthemovieguy 4 роки тому +1

    There was a Alpha Flight Easter egg in Deadpool 2 an advertisement on top of the cab.

  • @salum75
    @salum75 5 років тому +3

    alpha flight was always a favorite of mine, in my opinion a wasted potential from marvel, due to pure localism

  • @grrravy
    @grrravy 7 років тому +2

    Is it really fair to call title resurrection a trope in this case? John Byrne was one of the hottest artists in Marvel. Certainly they were pressing him to move new and reintroduced titles. Great episode though, and Alpha Flight will always be a favorite! Thanks Mr. Byrne!

  • @dfcsons
    @dfcsons 5 років тому +2

    Funnily enough, I remember seeing a version of poutine in NYC at a diner called 'disco fries'.....it was fries, gravy and melted velvetta. YIKES.....no greater basratdization could there be....
    And you're not the only one who has sought out back issues of Alpha Flight, kind sir..!

  • @DrMadd
    @DrMadd 5 років тому +1

    Alpha Flight hilariously is like most Canadian media, we just generally don't care about it and flock to the American stuff instead.

  • @doujinloverXD
    @doujinloverXD 2 роки тому +1

    John Byrne was the final villain of Arrow!

  • @catwhowalks99
    @catwhowalks99 4 роки тому +2

    Most painful statement I've heard related to comics in a long, long time: "There's never going to be an Alpha Flight movie, I can tell you that." :(

  • @phillyfrenchy6053
    @phillyfrenchy6053 4 роки тому +1

    OK, so I guess I'm a weirdo but I love Alpha Flight and loved it as soon as it came out. The cross stories with Wolverine, Guardian, the X-Men... I don't know, I just really like this team.

  • @GodLovesComics
    @GodLovesComics 6 років тому +1

    I didn't remember it being over Kirby but I assume you're talking about the infamous "Cog In The Wheel" essay from ComicScene where Byrne happily proclaimed himself a company man. Frank Miller responded with his own essay stating how ignorant it was to choose to give all your creations and rights away to a corporation. It's ironic how Miller is still such a big name in mainstream publishing now and Byrne has been marginalized. I wasn't aware of Byrne's other feuds but don't begrudge a guy for standing on principle and not being a kiss-ass if he has a logical stance. Of course, if the Cog in the Wheel logic is applied to all his subsequent debates then its questionable.

  • @SkotNealey
    @SkotNealey 5 років тому +1

    Ketchup chips are sold in NC. Also, Pickle flavored chips.

  • @NickBartolo
    @NickBartolo 5 років тому +2

    Byrne's X-Men run remains one of the greatest achievements in comic art history.

  • @Bonzulac
    @Bonzulac 4 роки тому +3

    "Insects and animals are very different...." Insects are animals. Did you think they're vegetables?

  • @TheDungeonDive
    @TheDungeonDive 4 роки тому +1

    I LOVED Alpha Flight back in the 80s. Alpha Flight and Excalibur were my favorite comic books in the 80s. What can I say? I guess I’ve always liked the underdogs.

  • @saiberunato
    @saiberunato 2 роки тому +1

    You left out men missing their lips 😆

  • @anttmann6123
    @anttmann6123 4 роки тому +1

    Loved Alpha Flight as a kid. And agreed the Maple donut is amazing.