I love Christy’s version! The flow of her voice suits this song. Especially considering this was years ago. Along with the band her fluidity in this song is really a hit!!
Robbed of what? I love CCR but she was very generic but Katy has a very distinct voice. A ton of girls could sing it like CCR but hard to imitate KP. Katy Perry not Kim Possible. ;)
I Love Katy Perry, she is one of my favorite artists. Man oh man I would have chosen Christy's Voice for this song. I like this version way better, a little more clear or remastered and done.
Maybe I said it wrong for multiple ppl to think I was referring to Christy. I meant to say that maybe the reason Katy got Christy’s deal is probably because she slept her way to the top. Ppl really need to relax 😒
This version is a amazing! 💕 I live Katy, but I think Katy just started and didn't know how to control her voice Christy has more control of her voice 💕
Wow i actually like both , but ive somhow always noticed a different quality to broadway trained voices vs non broadway voices??? Its Not bad, but like, how they place their voices?? Katy goes into a speak like whisper not necessarialy flat but almost out side the melody , when christy hits the notes right on , which as i believe broadway artists are probably more expected to do idk?? As a choir/ classical singer myself, ive had to relearn a lot after singing more indie or pop songs?? Or am i just hallucinating lol
That’s honestly it! In musical theater, the music directors are usually so fierce with training and voice placement. Pop singing is way more chill I think but can have things like flat notes, not enough breath control etc. so all in all yes I agree!
@@cicinebula Aaaaahhhhh so im not just seeing things!! I honestly noticed because while none is better than the other but the note precision thing made me think this is why they said she is "cookie cutter" maybe? Its not true, i still think christys voice is great and unique, but because of her broadway background, i think folks in pop may want more messy vocals?? So to them it makes it seem cookie cutter to hit every note seamlessly, perhaps note precision is like not at prioritized in pop ?
Am I the only one that came here before the video from Christy? Lol Obviously Katy first (been a katycat since 2015) but this is still a great cover that I've put in one of my playlists here on UA-cam that I come to on occasion. Also a note: at 3:06 You can hear some of Katy's backing vocals haha. edit: I just saw the video on Christy's channel. Very interesting to hear from her perspective. Sorry it didn't end up working out for you!
Lyrics: So when my voice breaks Its called interoperation When I hold a note Its cause I want to Not cause I feel anything about you So don't flatter yourself thinking that I love you Make you emotional From major to the minor When I lose control I'm not trying to impress you Break it down and I get your attention But its just formula don't need your validation Validation This is just a song The music plays on then its gone again This is just a song The words don't mean a thing So every time I sang I loved you all along Remember, Remember this is just a song Now I feel nothing Yea I'm on auto pilot I have sung these words Even sung 'em while I'm sleeping Just cause you have showed up here to see me Doesn't mean I'm going home with you this evening I know December is the month we met But it rimes with remember Or did you forget I was only giving a performance I haven't noticed you were in the audience In the audience This is just a song The music plays on then its gone again This is just a song The words don't mean a thing So every time I sang I loved you all along Remember, Remember this is just a song Everybody knows that this is just a song And I don't feel a thing for you Everybody knows that rhythm, rime, and structure Doesn't mean that I love you Oh no This is just a song The music plays on then its gone again This is just a song The words don't mean a thing So every time I sang I loved you all along Remember, Remember this is just a song
I def prefer Even A Hero to show her range and grungey sound but this is great her tone is amazing and like the fact that she could sing Broadway and still sound like this
Am I the only person who listened to Katy's version and didn't like it at all, then came here and wondered how?? Lol, like dont get me wrong Katy has had lots of bops, and I know she was mad young when she recorded this but it was just not good at all to me I was surprised, then I listened to Christy's version and thought omg wow this is great, how did they not choose her?
I like this version better than Katy’s. Katys was nooottt easy to listen to, her voice was all over the place. Christy’s voice goes better with this music
Wasn't this written by Katy? I do like the raw delivery of Katy better. You can clearly see the Broadway training on Christy, which is not bad, but I prefer the grungy rock vibe of katy's
@@jfearless3420 Like a Target shoe imitating a designer essentially. It’s like a good singer without individuality or style. Like it’s just decent. Not outstanding
Anyone here after Christy's video talking about her singer career and mention this song?
Everyone lol
Yup lol
Yes indeed lol
Yes
Everybody! 😂
Wow, it's actually still here. There's a lot I'd do differently singing it today. Was an interesting time when I recorded this...
Love this!!!! Heavy on the nostalgia 😂😂
love u!!!! just saw your video.
This literally just popped on my feed not long after I watched your vid
Just watched your video and immediately searched for it! Love it!!!
Your 2021 version would be awesome!
Who is here after Christy’s latest video? 😂✊🏼
🙋♀️😊
I ran as soon as she said the name
Me too!! I’m a die hard Katy fan but I like Christy’s better!
Saaaame
Mee
Christy, if you ever read this, I think you have a lovely voice! 🥰
I actually like Christy's singing voice, sounds natural and just chill.
Omg. They dropped the ball!! Ugh. This is gorgeous
I love Christy’s version! The flow of her voice suits this song. Especially considering this was years ago. Along with the band her fluidity in this song is really a hit!!
i’m sure the person who uploaded this is so confused. 🤣 (FOR CONTEXT TO THE OP: Christy Carlson Romano posted a video and she lead us here)
I’m sure they figure that out early on from the “christy Carlson Romano’s version is better “ comments
Another great underrated singer, those vocals😍
Here after watching Christys video. Such a great song and love her voice!
Dang 😻 I would totally buy an album like this from her! Definitely my vibe.
same
Christy's version is 1000 x better and really moves you! Wow! Awesome talent!!!
Here after Christy Romanos recent video post! And glad I did! Totally a gem!
This was the better and easier to listen to version, very great disney hit material I love it!
Beautiful voice!!! Record deal 2021 do it!!
Dude this is sick!!!!! Yes, christy!
Wow the soul and passion from Christys performance is breathtaking!
Beautiful vocal range from Christy Carlson Romano.
Wow your voice is so beautiful christy. I wish this single came out
i love this so much. i wish she could have became a pop star but things happen for a reason i guess 😭
Give the woman a deal now but not with any of these soul sucking creepy producers
Why am I crying!!!!!"
I love her voice!!!
This was a great pop song, Christy was robbed!
Robbed of what? I love CCR but she was very generic but Katy has a very distinct voice. A ton of girls could sing it like CCR but hard to imitate KP. Katy Perry not Kim Possible. ;)
@@JayD06 opinions, opinions.
This sounds great! Love it!
I’m literally shook!!!!!
I love her voice! ❤️
I like
Dude this hits
Beautiful!!
Christy’s voice suits the song more!! Love katy btw
Came here from the vlog, I love Christy’s version more, Katy is good but this one really gets the better!
Super awesome!!
I Love Katy Perry, she is one of my favorite artists. Man oh man I would have chosen Christy's Voice for this song. I like this version way better, a little more clear or remastered and done.
I think this sounds better than Katy, honestly.
She might’ve slept her way to get the deal.
Edit: Referring to Katy
@@aishariel9924 She made it very clear in her video she didn't wanna do that.
Dang, this sounds soooo much better
@@aishariel9924 lol why would she do that??? You're obviously aware many people don't want to do that kind of stuff. Gosh you must be bored
Maybe I said it wrong for multiple ppl to think I was referring to Christy. I meant to say that maybe the reason Katy got Christy’s deal is probably because she slept her way to the top. Ppl really need to relax 😒
The beginning hits different.
This version is a amazing! 💕 I live Katy, but I think Katy just started and didn't know how to control her voice Christy has more control of her voice 💕
Not me being nosy af after she posted about this song 😂👀
Amazing!
Wow i actually like both , but ive somhow always noticed a different quality to broadway trained voices vs non broadway voices??? Its Not bad, but like, how they place their voices?? Katy goes into a speak like whisper not necessarialy flat but almost out side the melody , when christy hits the notes right on , which as i believe broadway artists are probably more expected to do idk?? As a choir/ classical singer myself, ive had to relearn a lot after singing more indie or pop songs?? Or am i just hallucinating lol
That’s honestly it! In musical theater, the music directors are usually so fierce with training and voice placement. Pop singing is way more chill I think but can have things like flat notes, not enough breath control etc. so all in all yes I agree!
@@cicinebula Aaaaahhhhh so im not just seeing things!! I honestly noticed because while none is better than the other but the note precision thing made me think this is why they said she is "cookie cutter" maybe? Its not true, i still think christys voice is great and unique, but because of her broadway background, i think folks in pop may want more messy vocals?? So to them it makes it seem cookie cutter to hit every note seamlessly, perhaps note precision is like not at prioritized in pop ?
@@cicinebula Lmao getting chorus flashbacks to hit the notes really clearly and right OOF
Better than Katy in my opinion,
Am I the only one that came here before the video from Christy? Lol Obviously Katy first (been a katycat since 2015) but this is still a great cover that I've put in one of my playlists here on UA-cam that I come to on occasion. Also a note: at 3:06 You can hear some of Katy's backing vocals haha.
edit: I just saw the video on Christy's channel. Very interesting to hear from her perspective. Sorry it didn't end up working out for you!
Christie should go the route that mya has gone now! The independent route!
You sound beautiful girl 💜
You actually sound a lot like the lead singer of the band Plumb
Lyrics:
So when my voice breaks
Its called interoperation
When I hold a note
Its cause I want to
Not cause I feel anything about you
So don't flatter yourself thinking that I love you
Make you emotional
From major to the minor
When I lose control
I'm not trying to impress you
Break it down and I get your attention
But its just formula don't need your validation
Validation
This is just a song
The music plays on then its gone again
This is just a song
The words don't mean a thing
So every time I sang I loved you all along
Remember, Remember this is just a song
Now I feel nothing
Yea I'm on auto pilot
I have sung these words
Even sung 'em while I'm sleeping
Just cause you have showed up here to see me
Doesn't mean I'm going home with you this evening
I know December is the month we met
But it rimes with remember
Or did you forget I was only giving a performance
I haven't noticed you were in the audience
In the audience
This is just a song
The music plays on then its gone again
This is just a song
The words don't mean a thing
So every time I sang I loved you all along
Remember, Remember this is just a song
Everybody knows that this is just a song
And I don't feel a thing for you
Everybody knows that rhythm, rime, and structure
Doesn't mean that I love you
Oh no
This is just a song
The music plays on then its gone again
This is just a song
The words don't mean a thing
So every time I sang I loved you all along
Remember, Remember this is just a song
This definitely has Liz Phair vibes!
Liked it better than Katy's tbh. Maybe just needed more variables in tone but she could hit it.
Wow
I def prefer Even A Hero to show her range and grungey sound but this is great her tone is amazing and like the fact that she could sing Broadway and still sound like this
That was amazing!!
There’s some Gwen Stefani vibes in her voice.
Soft and beautiful, mature growth.
I like this one better.
Am I the only person who listened to Katy's version and didn't like it at all, then came here and wondered how?? Lol, like dont get me wrong Katy has had lots of bops, and I know she was mad young when she recorded this but it was just not good at all to me I was surprised, then I listened to Christy's version and thought omg wow this is great, how did they not choose her?
Her voice is so much better than Katy’s voice tbh
Oh wow. Even though Katy’s verses were stronger delivered, Christy ate her up and her tone is better
eh..i prefer ms. christy's version. plus, she's cuter.
Anyone else think it sounds a lot like "just a dream" Carrie Underwood??
I actually like Katy’s version more but I want to like christys more because I love her personality more than Katy’s lol 😅
I like this version better than Katy’s. Katys was nooottt easy to listen to, her voice was all over the place. Christy’s voice goes better with this music
Getting major Alanis Morissette vibes
I came here after seeing Christy’s video about Katy Perry lol
Honestly, they probably chose Katy because her style was more interesting at the time. Popstars have a whole brand to consider.
Everyone is saying this version is better than katys and im ngl I disagree. They're both good but I like katys version a little more
Wasn't this written by Katy? I do like the raw delivery of Katy better. You can clearly see the Broadway training on Christy, which is not bad, but I prefer the grungy rock vibe of katy's
Better than Kay Perry's version but voice is more generic.
What does that mean?
@@jfearless3420 Like a Target shoe imitating a designer essentially. It’s like a good singer without individuality or style. Like it’s just decent. Not outstanding
@@CharleyChioma I disagree but we all appreciate things differently.
It’s weird because I do like this version better too, but I get what you mean that it’s not as unique maybe
I feel that this could’ve been a great way to propel her career. This could’ve been a stepping stone.
Wow this version is waay better than Katys
‘Calrson’ like damn put respect on a queens name with correct grammar
now I see why she didn't get a deal, sounds like a backing singer for Gwen Stefani.
Gross