The final chapter of Bakhmut story has started. Military Summary And Analysis 2023.04.06
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 тра 2024
- This video describes the military situation in Ukraine on the 6th of April 2023
Patreon: www.patreon.com/militarySumma...
Google doc: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
Rumble: rumble.com/c/c-1613003
Email: military.summary.info@gmail.com
BTC: bc1qnvmy699guqds5hyau038f4zk0mjdrlc6me8w0ww97lvrvsap8xgsyaw4d9
Help the channel: www.donationalerts.com/r/mili...
Help the channel: www.patreon.com/militarySumma...
Telegram channel: t.me/militarysummary
maps:
militarymaps.info/
liveuamap.com
militaryland.net/maps/deploym...
Patreon: www.patreon.com/militarySummary?fan_landing=true
Google doc: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/18WfJv1_DOlFOzvjh6iT1N8ltDvaCeWu1cPK_eaHKCR4/edit?usp=sharing
Rumble: rumble.com/c/c-1613003
Email: military.summary.info@gmail.com
BTC: bc1qnvmy699guqds5hyau038f4zk0mjdrlc6me8w0ww97lvrvsap8xgsyaw4d9
Help the channel: www.donationalerts.com/r/military_summary
Help the channel: www.patreon.com/militarySummary?fan_landing=true
Telegram channel: t.me/militarysummary
maps:
militarymaps.info/
liveuamap.com
militaryland.net/maps/deployment-map/
Did you miss some of the losses on the donetsk front line?
What about the mines you said was the reason why WAG didn’t just walk through buildings. De-mining doesn’t happen this fast.
Ukraine used 300(!) shells to kill 11 of its OWN soldiers trapped in a trench? Total garbage information...and show me evidence of the destroyed Bradley AFV. Some Bradleys will undoubtedly be destroyed by Russian forces, but show us some photographic confirmation of this.
I am an American Soldier who fully supports Russia's special military operation. I truly believe that President Putin singlehandedly prevented a genocide of the Donbass people. Love from America.
You probably also believe Trump saved the world
Thank you FRIEND❤️🙏
This American supports Russia 100% as well!
Throughout the war the Ukrainian have been rounding up ethnic Russians and commiting mass executions.
Same here from UK, slava Russia 🇷🇺
The Russian Minister of Defense Shoigu visited one of the factories, where we could see that the mass production of precision guided glide bombs had begun, which are converted from the massive FAB-500 and FAB-1500 stocks. It seems that the Russian tactics will be the same as in Syria, and they will crush the defense lines with overwhelming air power. In Syria, following the Russian intervention, the tide of the war was quickly turned, and the Syrian army regained control of 80% of the country under the command of General Sergey Surovikin. In Syria, Pro-government forces increased controlled territory four-fold from 19,000 sq km to 78,000 sq km after the Russian Air Force intervened. The Ukrainian leadership is already in panic because they have no defense against this. Will AFU have the same fate as the Syrian Rebels?
Yes and now we know Surovikin is in charge of Bakhmut command overall.
Mais pourquoi les russes n'ont-ils pas utilisés cette tactique des le début ?
@@aimen711 ça reste le territoire de Donetsk pro russe, et au delà toute l'Ukraine centrale et de l'est est ultra connectée à la Russie par des liens familiaux.
la France n'oserait pas avoir recours à l'artillerie lourde en premier recours contre la population belge par exemple
Da !
Four-fold? That's not true, Syria-Damascus always controlled its core territory. You may be referring to some specific area where they controlled almost nothing like the Aleppo-Idlib region or maybe the eastern Desert.
Also, without implying that the Russian air support was meaningless (it was indeed important), a very decisive factor also for Damascus was the strategical shift of Obama in his last year, when he allied with the NSF and ditched Erdogan. It was then when DAESH was destroyed and most of that was done by the Kurds+ with US air support. This did not directly increase Damascus' control but weakened in general the Turkish-backed Islamo-Fascists.
Both Russia and the USA (Trump) allowed Turkey and their terrorist goons to invade and genocide Afrin however.
If Russia encircles Bakhmut city, 15,000 soldiers "hide like rats" amongst the concrete buildings and Russia has to spend a month leveling the town and starving them out like Mariupol at Azovstal. They do not have this time. Instead, they push them out of the city and encircle the forces in the fields to the West of Bakhmut. Nowhere to hide. Ukrainian forces almost immediately get destroyed if they get stuck in these fields. I think a very serious loss to the Ukrainian army is building. If they try to evacuate Bakhmut all at once those 15,000 troops will get stuck in a massive traffic jam because the roads are narrow, and very poor. The fields are impassible mud for most vehicles. In such a situation artillery, aviation, mortars, and ATGMs will completely destroy the Ukrainian forces.
The Ukrainians are finished. At this rate, the Russians will conquer them in.....200 years.😂😂
+100
@@VK-hi6jf Wars have periods of "slow" and periods of "Fast".
In WW2, Allies moved extremely slowly in Italy after Sicily, Yet in 1944 they took all of France back. Just because portions of the war go slowly doesn't mean it will always be. At some point some army will crack (most likely Ukraine) and everything will fall apart rather quickly.
@@VK-hi6jf People doesnt realize Russian does the wise war. They are not USA like carpet bombing civilians and cities destroying the infrastructure like USA did in Iraq. Russia doesnt have to hurry. they can wait... and when their war science meters turn to green, there will be a massive strategic attack. End of Ukraine army. Maybe the summer time but before the autumn for sure if it going to happen this year.
what about the tunnel dima mentioned few days ago?
Bakhmut has served Russia well.........a literal funnel for Ukrainian troops to be concentrated into a kill zone. You never fight static positional battles against an enemy with superior artillery power. Its suicidal.
unless you want to fix the enemy's forces somewhere while you launch an attack somewhere else. It is an old strategy, called "fixation".
@@SDOne-or6vm Ah, you mean when the Russians fixed 80k Ukrainian troops in Kiev with their 30k, while the rest of Russian army took the land bridge in the south?
That would be true, but artillery's still a major factor in Bakhmut and Russia has the clear Advantage there. Plus, Ukraine has major supply issues.
@@dr.embersfield1551
The Russian attack towards Kiev wasn't a feint, it was a legitimate rush to try and take the capital and overthrow/capture/kill Zelensky and his government. It was a failed operation and the only way pro-Russian hacks can justify it is by saying it was a feint to tie up Ukrainian troops.
In the end it did succeed in tying down Ukrainian forces that could've been used elsewhere just that the cost was high and included losing some of Russia's best troops in the process.
20,000 Ukrainian soldiers died in bakhmut during the fighting, according to the media here in Russia.
The information was also confirmed by the adviser to the acting head of the DPR Denis Pushilin, Yan Gagin, whose data I will certainly discuss on my channel in the next update..
@@adamw126 Yea sounds rather plausible, given that Wagner with Russian regular forces support, have an overwhelming superiority in artillery power. But I guess more Wagner soldiers died as a result of the fact that they’re firing more artillery shells at Ukrainians when Ukraine is running out of ammo?😂😂😊
@@AJolie009 They don't have ghost of Kiev. That's why.
"according to the media here in Russia" = let's make up a number
@@adamw126 Russians can replace loses Ukrainians cannot
@@croissants1280 More reasonable than whatever ukraine says.
There is no glory dying to line men's pockets with gold and blood, pray for peace in Ukraine.
I see those recent gliding shovels from the RuAF in Bakhmut made some impact on the outcome there.
They need to increase the gliding shovels production by 1000 fold.
This is a geewddd werkkk Dima!
When Russia needs to name a new weapon- I really hope they'll name it The Shovel.
Ultimate troll for a new missile...
🎉🎉😂🎉🎉
I would go with "the laundromat". Sounds more russian
I hope they have a shovel parade during victory day
Nothing more troll than Xi Jinping calling Macron a tourist today and that tourists are always welcome in China. That was the answer to Macron's warnings and threats to China that he expressed today.
When Russia needs a new weapon. They should call it a miracle😂😂😂
Russia's tactics are like a Red River flood on the prairies. Slow, relentless unstoppable in the end...
🇷🇺 Bakhmut 🇷🇺 is now significant ❤️🇷🇺❤️
Remember saying this. How things change😂😂😂
Thanks Dima. I'm trying to stay positive but with the evil winning over and over here in America it's just overwhelming..
And US just keeps piling on that evil....Baltimore Maryland just released a 4 year investigative report that over 600 children were sexually abused, tortured, and trafficked by over 150 priests, church officials and officials. It has been going on for decades and the crimes were covered up and criminals moved around to avoid detection or prosecution. The Maryland Prosecutor says it's the tip of the iceberg. Journalist said it was horrifying to read what went on in the 400 plus page report. ABC News and Fox News reported but alternative News Investigative journalist uncovered this first and made a Net Flix documentary on this sexual abuse priest ring.
it is not winning! How do you define winning? It is all part of cleansing. Don't forget about the universal law of polarity governing the world. Don't interpret everything negative as evil, just as rain is not evil. Don't expect the sun to shine all the time. There is a huge leap of consciousness happening on the planet, which is eradicating a lot of elements of the old system. Many people are sent to heaven but they will reincarnate... People inflict too much suffering onto themselves with fears, worries, anxieties etc. unwilling to see that there is so much more beauty and good in the world than evil. Change your perspective or put off your black glasses and you might notice how there is no such thing as good vs. evil
And here in uk. They now are engaging in a war on God. Burning churches. Such ignorance over here.
Evil is losing big.
That is true. And only Russia is sacrificing their kindred souls to fight this epic battle.
Thank you Dima 😊
Jaeger brigades, cross markings on their tanks, ss alike insignias.. Putin knows what he is talking about
That would be lightning runes. Not the iron cross.
@@daffyduck780 - Precisely. The iron cross is a non-Nazi icon still used in Germany.
Support to Russia and hope the peace will come quick as possible. Greetings from Finland.
Finns hate Russian people aye?
Hope that too, Finland now is in the first line of fire thanks to your stupid gvt.
You are not Finnish
The Finns will be the next set of fools, to do the Yankee's bidding.
Morning Dima. Lots of points this morning. Have a good day. J.
Thank You, Dima for Your detailed update. Greetings.
Mother russia winning the war with shovels 🐻 🫡
Glory to the Russian federation for liberating Bakhmut with only shovels 💪🇷🇺
Homeless drunks off the street and prisoners are truly terrifying fighters
Slava Shovorossiya
😆😆😆
Evening turtle 👍
@@xblade11230 That makes it much more funnier they're defeating a NATO standard Army trained for 8 years with Billions of dollars of funding and multiple countries backing it.
COPE HARDER KOHOLS
Almost at a 100 k subscribers! Congrats Dima!!!
Thank you Dima.
SHOVEL POWER 💪🇷🇺
Impressive shoveling
the commander of the UKR battalion "Kraken" burned alive subordinates for refusing to go on the attack,
UKR fired up to 300 shells at the location of captured compatriots near Avdiivka.
yup. And Kraken came out of the sea to witness it and provide this info for "Russian media" :-)
@@firestormuayeah because Ukraine has never shelled it's own POWs while they were housed in a Russian POW camp before. They don't even use their blocking detachments to keep their troops from retreating under threat of being shot either. 😂😂😂 They would never do that. Not with HIMARS signed off on by US operators and "contractors" that killed cooperating Azov POWs or anything. No that has never happened before. Never!!! 😆😆😆🤡🤡🤡
@@firestormua narzee TRASH
@@paulramsey1255 yes, exactly. This Kraken comment is
@@theprinceofcrows8691 So you got wealth of likes for extraordinary statement with 0 proof. Bots!
Neveer encircle your opponent. By giving them a corridor, you can direct their movement. Denying them this exit, will cause unnecessary loss on both side. Don't corner a wounded animal.
The Art of War by Sun Tzu mentions something along those lines, always leave a way out for the enemy that they will think is safe to escape through, the enemy becomes an easy target there...
Oh yes , some sieges of towns , castles can take months , years and might take few tries . Better keep bombing Bahmut , while letting them support , and slowly push .
Enjoyed you on the gonzalo panel today dima, lovely to see you weeb union and history legends together, 3 best channels!
ROFLMFAO...all three are bought out by western media....
Levan Gudadze, Scott Ritter, Douglas McGregor, Alex Mercouris are far better then any of them....
Agreed; was a great panel and lovely to see those guys together! :)
@@Slimedog1963 Those guys have a different focus, geopolitics in general. These are mappers which is quite different! :)
@@Slimedog1963 They're all good. Dima and Weeb focus more on map movements while Scott/Douglas focus more on the geopolitical side.
🦌 Fiends. Great video with Gonzalo today.
05:55 Ukraine fights for the Western values. Yeah sure.
Fantastic news! I look forward to hearing that the city has been liberated from US proxy forces in the coming days!
Thank you for putting headlines.
Missed opportunity to write:
"Thank you for Putin headlines."
Hello our dear friend!
Thanks Dima 👏👏👏
Thanks Dima.
I hope the people of donbass can live in peace once the Ukrops get pushed far away.
Love from California
Great update and great show with Gonzalo lira.
Glory to Russia 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 🇷🇺
Support Russia from Africa
And stay in Afrika .Europa🤡
Thanks for the update as always. Good stuff.
Time to end this war.
Ban gliding Washer machines and precision guided shovels
😆😆😆
No can do. That ban would drive them to the black market. Garage sales of new and used equipment would be impaceted negatively.
How about:
1. Increase the age limit for legal purchases.
2. Make getting permits harder for such dangerous tools.
3. Limit the hours of the day such tools may be used.
4. Put sanctions on Acme Fireworks so they cannot get material to build these things.
5. Shorten the range of these things by clipping the wing feathers slightly.
6. Ban painted racing stripes which encourages reckless use.
7. Require higher insurance rates for use of these dangerous Washers and Shovels. They have a record of harming people and breaking things.
Nice
Just a thought...
Ukraine have claimed and I must say by their actions showed they tried to hold Bakhmut, it was important.
IF Ukraine have a lot of troops, ammunition and material for an offensive.
WOULD THEY NOT HAVE REINFORCED BAKHMUT?
In my "brain" they would have.
No point in losing it, letting Russia establish themselves AND THE RETAKE IT.
Conclusion (for me) the much talked about "Ukraine offensive" can not be any major thing, if it exist at all.
Uks lied about all situations in Bahmud . Zielenski na$$is commander he sacrificed own people ,young soldiers....he choose genocide for own army. He is doing what he is told. The crimi$$$al like Polpot in Kampucha....like hit$$$$r in Germany
When you defend you kill way more enemies than what you are losing. Bakhmut has been basically the end of the Wagner army, they are slowly retreating while causing the best damage.
Your "brain" should suggest you Ukraine will attack where the russians are not ready to defend, they will take more ground, kill more enemies and lose less forces.
They did divert some troops to the area but most reports say that the new troops did not make it into the city due to the roads being mostly blocked. What was sent is outside the city, or in reserve.
“In war the losing side talks about future battles and future victories, while the winning side talks of their actual gains.” Col McGregor
They'll just bury 30000 Ukros and start shedding crocodile tears about the "poor Ukrainians" in the MSM, then force the Clown to the negotiation table, unless Poland decides to intervene directly.
The Russians are about to steam roll the Ukrainians! The weather is getting better and the Russians are about to show the world how it's done on the battlefield! I love it!
Russians so far have shown how not to fight in 21st century. USA army knows how to kick ass, albeit I am not a huge fan of them either.
When is this going to happen?
What a heartless act by Ukrainian forces intentionally killing their own soldiers.
• Sad condolences to their families.
What about Russians killing Ukrainians and destroying their homeland?
They do it all the time. It's in the criminal nature of the Maidan regime.
If true. This and all similar claims - from both sides - should be documented carefully.
@@nodrinkingproblemhere9095 whatabout is not an excuse, IF the claim here is true it is an atrocity.
@@fred4687 Nah, it is all about Russians killing, destroying, committing atrocities and dying in an unsuccessful landgrab attempt. Pointing fingers at ukies is a bit desperate from the point of Russian propaganda. But they have been detached from reality from day one.
Don't ever think you can just run up in these comments living however you want. If he tells you to have a good day that's what you have to do.
Well, I'll work at having a g'day, but no promises.......
Just subd let’s go 100k!!
Excellent update, thank you.
With only shovels? Dayum!
When the greatest unblocking attack will start, there are fair chances that there will be nothing to unblock.
True the strategic attack.
some day this war is gonna end....
The Great Unblocking ? A pint of Guinness and a Curry usually does it for me.....
And then before you know it, youre on the throne and Zelensky appears?
bro luv your channel can I ask where are you getting the maps I can't find western source map or Russians only u give both sides
From Washington based Institute of Study of War (ISW)
Sounds like the Russian "Ukrainian Flame Roaster" is working.
When you say they stepped back, is that a polite term for saying they ran away. 😮
When talking about today or the day before yesterday or something like dies ❤
The clown Zelenskyy said that it was more important to save his troops, yet he sent waves.😂
The age and Glory of Russia has emerged. Also, Russia and the collective West is divorced at least for many decades to come and for a century at most.
Dima, I like your Work! Tips on correct pronunciation: Kinzhal is called Dagger, with a "D", not a "J", so not like Mick Jagger of Rolling Stones fame. Also, a Jäger Brigade is pronounced as If it was a "Y" sound, so Yaeger.
what i dont understand is, i thought wagner were pulling out over a week ago, but they're still there taking big swaths of land in the city
Disinformation to confuse ADVERSARIES.
That might have been normal rotation of personnel..
Ukraine is losing really badly now
how long has Russia been trying to take Bakhmut?
@@croissants1280 the question should be how much in manpower and equipment has it cost Ukraine to defend Bakmut - a place that was considered irrelevant by pro Ukrainians a few months back
@@croissants1280 how long as ukraine been attempting to dislodge russia out of ukraine? answer: 13 moths...progress so far...none , if we want to measure it by their litlte attack by kherson ahd kharkiv ok..then at that rage..should take about 20 years....and millions of losses ..ukraine will have long run out of manpower within a year or 2 , unless the children get sent up
@@croissants1280 🤡🤡
@@croissants1280 You keep coping using that fallacy, but you fail to realize that haste is not important in a war of attrition.
It would seem that Zelensky's breakout Hollywood role "Bakhmut" will not make it to production. However he will still be receiving the films funding
Are those tanks real or Czech-made inflatable decoys? I have some doubts about Ukraine being able to deploy so many actual tanks, really.
It would help me if estimated numbers of soldiers and weapons were given. For example, how many tanks are in a tank brigade?
Good question, it depends on the availability and trained men. And they probably have a different composition to adjust to losses
A brigade might have X when at full strength, less if losses are taken or parts are detached or men desert. There is no set number you can count on.
It took me some search time but (in the USA, which is typical reference) "An ABCT [armored brigade combat team] includes 87 Abrams [tanks], 152 Bradley IFVs, 18 M109s and 45 armed M113 vehicles", I believe all the latter are not tanks but auxiliary armored vehicles instead.
Google it?
@Luis Aldamiz so the Ucs have half of one American ABCT in terms of tanks ( western ) and the rest is soviet or western equipment put together
Thought so.
Hope you learned your l
unstoppable
Yes next 150 years potato ruska army will get next some town in Ukraina 🤡
I doubt that the Ukrainians would attack into Russia on a bigger scale than DRGs. The tanks are precious and the Russians have reserves near the border. Such an action could also increase the pressure on Putin to mobilize even more reservists - which Kiev absolutely doesn´t want.
Perhaps they believe that they can to a quick offensive on their own in that region, just like last year, but on a smaller scale.
were is the tunnel in Bakhmut located
I'm sad for these soldiers they should try to get them out😢
I had no idea there was a prison in the center of the city. Maybe I misunderstood what was said. But it sounded like there was a prison in the center of the city next to the cathedral and near the railway station.
I’m wondering if it’s possible that the prisoners are still in there. If they are that means they would be guard still in there?
Don’t know what kind of prison but I’m thinking the last thing you want is a bunch of harden convex exiting the prison gates in the middle of a fight.
Wagner Army will offer them a job. I am sure many would take that job offer just to get revenge on Ukraine for locking them up. 😊
They'll immediately join Wagner!
of Intro
Dima it should be called a MIG 17 "monument" I think a statue usually refers to a statue of a human or a horse and human.
An airplane is pretty much like "a horse and human", just with wings.
Can you show the chechen warriors position,,love to hear their bravery
What actually happened to the prisoners in Bakhmut prison? Were they evacuated, or are the butchers from Kiev taking advantage of the moment to dispose of a few hundred convicts under artillery fire?
Why doesn't Wagner try to mine the exit roads from Bakhmut? My understanding is this is done with a special kind of artillery. Then when the AFU stops to demine they hit them with artillery. WIth the ground so muddy the mines would tend to sink into the ground, also hidden after snow. It seems like an obvious tactic.
Present
Sorry it looked like I was first, Iam sad!
🏆🥈
@@AZ-bp5zo ahaha no problem!
around the 6 minute mark you talk about that Ukraninan friendly fire incident. Can you post on your telegram where you got that info? I am seeing alot of twitter ukraninan channels posting a video of that incident but sayng it was russians. cant zoom in enough to see armbands but uniforms look like ukranians
Sometimes because rotation keep happened Ukraine didn't know other unit is stationed nearby and ended up in fire figth with each other
Hello my dear France!
So there are "new" mechanized and tank brigades appearing at the fronts. Would it be possible that those reserves were taken from the planned offense groups - or fists as Dima call them? If so - is it possible that the great offensive is off the table. If that's true than this is really the last effort to defend east Ukraine. That would also explain why there is more talk about diplomatic solutions and negotiations.
Wagner is using the new teleguided uranium shovels
Hail hydra !
Slava shovels !
It is not wise for a farmer to let few rats to survive for they will go back and multiple if I was them I get more farmers encircle and eliminate better to get rid of them now than later
They are letting a few ants head back to the colony so they can locate the colony with the queen and eliminate the colony. 😉 Just keeping in line with your animal kingdom metaphor.😄
@betseyhemmelgarn1230 well it's also not wise to speak too truthful anymore after all the eye of Sauron is watching its five eyes are set ever higher so it can watch and see our every move .
They are almost concentrated enough for Russia to drop 50 glide bombs on the center.
Does anyone know how many soldiers are fielded by the two sides? And is there a reliable source for number of casualties so far in this war?
It's really difficult to count real casualties during the conflict. But it's no so difficult to count soldiers and, as i know, in last summer there were almost a ~700k-1mil soldiers is UAF because of mass mobilization and ~180k-220k on the Russian part of the frontline, but since then Russia also mobilized ~300k reserves and hired Wagner PMC so now its ~1mil Ukrainians vs ~560k Russians if we ignore casualties
Overall maybe 800,000 by Ukraine and some 300,000 by Russia. In the general Bakhmut sector 80,000 by Ukraine and 60,000 by Russia.
God is the only one who has the accurate count.
Every one else is counting through the fog of war as best as they can.
Short answer is no
There doesn't seem to be a reliable source for casualties. For Russians I've heard their KIA's are in the tens of thousands while Ukrainians are in the hundreds of thousands with 8 to 10 Ukrainians dying for each Russian that dies.
there is one thing that baffles me. How come that the russians (and us) knows when a brigade is moved to a new location. Also why don't they smoke them during the movement/transportation. They are moving tanks with semis ? anybody can shed some light ? thx
ever heard of satellites and air defense?
much respect and love for russia
much respect and love for russia, greetings from the USA
Glory to Ukraine for being part of mother Russia 🇷🇺!
Ukri loss 500 per day, that means 15.000 per month, at least.
Only 500 ruskie potato ?Say 1500 why not 🤡
@@kanclerz9045 hi, it would be slightly unethical.
@@lorenciandrej Yes Sasza..🤡
😢
Look like Russian and Ukraine discussion all information with you
Im scared
Most smart people are scared.
India will always support Russia and no country can dictate our relationship with Russia ❤
I support Russia against the fascist regime.
From India.
I hope the Russians/ Wagner have closed down the tunnel to and from Chasiv Yar. Any updates, Dima?
Nato have supplied vast amounts of equipment to Ukraine so what happened to the night vision glasses ??
Sold on the black market
Glory to Russia ❤ from India 🎉
-Z-🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍀
Captured and latter killed while protected in a trench? Then the captured must wear electronic beacon that potray their location automatically!
AMAZING STILL RUSSIAN
I hope that the Russia is going to use more TOS-1 shovel lauchers
Well, we see what we see, and we have what we have .. Russia moving forward despite all the NATO power ..
if there was no Zelenskiy would Ukraine still be at war
I guess no. Does people still remember the time of peace negotiations and diplomacy...
Is that a question or what?
Nope
NATO or the US would just install another puppet. That is why Zelensky is still alive, Russia sees no point in killing him. He is actually doing Russia a favor because Russians got more than they bargained for due to Zelensky's mistakes. "Never interrupt your enemy when they are making a mistake" - Napoleon
Yes, US Leadership and CIA; they would just pay to put another willing puppet figure head in his place. 1. 2010 US Geological studies revealing Eastern Ukraine has enormous gas fields. 2. 2014 Remove Russia aligned Ukrainian President in US sponsored Coup d'eta and put US aligned Ukrainian President in Power 3. Put Hunter Biden and former CIA operative Cofer Black and Devon Archer (former J Kerry Staffer) on Bursima Board of Directors 4. Get new US aligned Ukrainian President to change laws of state oil and gas ownership to allow privatization and give all those rights to Bursima. 5. Then Bursima gives 50 year Fracking rights of Eastern Ukraine to US Chevron and Royal Dutch Shell .......civil war breaks out; corporations can't move forward with Gas production until Ukraine wins the Donbas back where 80% of Gas Fields are located...Yuzivska Gas Fields, Sheblynka Gas fields, Donbas Foldbelt. US will push every Ukrainian, NATO and US soldier to fight and die to try and get those gas fields back. Almost every US war was over Gas and Oil. Gas&Oil&War=$$$$$$$