@@justincummings8557 Oh shit, we got another anti-CGI hipster XD No, the CGI presented in this is NOT more realistic than modern CGI. It was impressive for its time but it's clearly showing its age now. Just look at BBC's Ice Age Giants if you want to see realistic-looking CGI fossil animals. Hell, even their Planet Dinosaurs has better rendered and more realistic dinosaurs. Take off those rose-tinted glasses XD
2:00 Walking With Dinosaurs: Has diplodocus have at least 3 feat on the ground to distribute the dinosaurs weight. Also Walking With Dinosaurs: *Has Diplodocus stand up and sometimes walk on two.*
"Pterosaurs on the ground don't look anything like things alive today" Bats: Am I a joke to you? I also find it funny that they rejected the little "hopping" locomotion idea at 2:33, considering the fact that not only do we now know that pterosaurs _could_ do that, but that a similar movement was likely how they _launched._
dear bbc, i'm just beaging for : 1.walking with dinosaurs/beasts/monsters 2 2.a walking with dinosaurs trilogy 2: air monsters 3.walking with dinosaurs special with 2 more episodes 4.baland of big sue (a big t-rex skeleton, the biggest) But made with the old style and not like planet dinosaur. Yes we all know that planet dinosaur was made in a computer so it had less than the half money but walking with dinosaurs was much, much better. Is bbc going to make something like that i said or at least something differend made with the old style?
I liked how they showcased Planet dinosaur and went in details on how dinosaurs hunted but I'd also like another documentary with the same style as wwd
We now know that most if not all pterosaurs were VERY competent walkers. Scarily so, in fact. They were also pretty good runners, jumpers and swimmers.
It would be so freaking cool if we could simulate the locomotion using things like reinforcement learning, which would enable simulation of optimal locomotion by assigning a reward task (like moving forward or jumping), or making the algorithm try to learn skills on their own, just by giving them a muskuloskeletal model. Sure, deep reinforcement learning is really difficult to actually implement, because they wouldn't be able to find that global optimum for the weight functions, but it would be so cool to try it and make a documentary about it. I'm seriously starting to consider doing this on my free time....but I'm not convinced that I have the enough programming skills to do so, because I've only implemented these algorithms using a predefined framework and modifying the internal functions. I'm kind of hyped to do this.
I demand an updated version of this documentary. With the same passion and dedication, modern animatronics and modern animation and most recent scientific data!
@@Zimzilla99 He didn't forgot The Walking with Series is just like any other dinosaur media - they just want cool size stimates based on overreacting scientists than on reliable and already established estimates that Liopleurodon is merely just 7 meters long.
I think that walking with dinosaurs got the movement down better than any other documentary/series before or since.
What about Prehistoric Planet?
Thank you!! Usually CGI is stressed a lot but not nearly enough importance is put on animation/movement
One by one, the statues were coming to life.
Woooow, ❤️😘
Yea, they really nailed that scene and soundtrack.
When I was a kid watching this I didn’t understand a whole lot of it. Watching it now is a totally different experience!
That fully orchestral version of Spirits of the Ice Forest is spine chilling
I wish there'd be a WWD with the same quality but with updated knowledge and CGI (not discarding the non-CGI 'puppet' stuff though).
hamfranky yeah, that would be awesome
I don’t know about the upgraded CGI part, since the CGI honestly looks more realistic than modern CGI. Maybe that’s just me. I don’t know.
@@justincummings8557 Oh shit, we got another anti-CGI hipster XD No, the CGI presented in this is NOT more realistic than modern CGI. It was impressive for its time but it's clearly showing its age now. Just look at BBC's Ice Age Giants if you want to see realistic-looking CGI fossil animals. Hell, even their Planet Dinosaurs has better rendered and more realistic dinosaurs. Take off those rose-tinted glasses XD
Prehistoric Planet 2022: Allow me to introduce myself!
2:00 Walking With Dinosaurs: Has diplodocus have at least 3 feat on the ground to distribute the dinosaurs weight.
Also Walking With Dinosaurs: *Has Diplodocus stand up and sometimes walk on two.*
"One by one, the statues were coming to life" 👏
"No dinosaurs move like animals today"
Oh come on just look on your chicken
"One by one, the statues were coming to life."
RIP mike Milne
I am son of a missed geologist, that gave to me passion for dinosaurs
I'm surprised that people loved to see films or tv series with the combination of effective storytelling, animatronic, and CGI.
"Pterosaurs on the ground don't look anything like things alive today"
Bats: Am I a joke to you?
I also find it funny that they rejected the little "hopping" locomotion idea at 2:33, considering the fact that not only do we now know that pterosaurs _could_ do that, but that a similar movement was likely how they _launched._
dear bbc,
i'm just beaging for :
1.walking with dinosaurs/beasts/monsters 2
2.a walking with dinosaurs trilogy 2: air monsters
3.walking with dinosaurs special with 2 more episodes
4.baland of big sue (a big t-rex skeleton, the biggest)
But made with the old style and not like planet dinosaur. Yes we all know that planet dinosaur was made in a computer so it had less than the half money but walking with dinosaurs was much, much better. Is bbc going to make something like that i said or at least something differend made with the old style?
that would be asome
Χρήστος Τσίκλης its so true..
And bottom gear
I liked how they showcased Planet dinosaur and went in details on how dinosaurs hunted but I'd also like another
documentary with the same style as wwd
Prehistoric Planet with David Attenborough.
I learned Softimage 3D was the first computer animation software that the BBC crew used before Autodesk Maya.
I like that the statues are coming to life such as Diplodocus,Stegosaurus,Tyrannosaurus,Iguanodon and ornithocheirus
3:59 epic moment 💪💪
1:27 the animators joking in the background. Ha ha ha!!
i'm surprised they didn't reference vampirr bats on how pterosaurs moved on the ground
It's because of their wing structure being a complete difference to the one in pterosaurs
It's a bloody miracle that that pterosaur can walk if you ask me....
We now know that most if not all pterosaurs were VERY competent walkers. Scarily so, in fact. They were also pretty good runners, jumpers and swimmers.
When I watched this the music had a lower pitch
It would be so freaking cool if we could simulate the locomotion using things like reinforcement learning, which would enable simulation of optimal locomotion by assigning a reward task (like moving forward or jumping), or making the algorithm try to learn skills on their own, just by giving them a muskuloskeletal model. Sure, deep reinforcement learning is really difficult to actually implement, because they wouldn't be able to find that global optimum for the weight functions, but it would be so cool to try it and make a documentary about it.
I'm seriously starting to consider doing this on my free time....but I'm not convinced that I have the enough programming skills to do so, because I've only implemented these algorithms using a predefined framework and modifying the internal functions. I'm kind of hyped to do this.
In fact we can and this is exactly how the motion of the dragons in GoT was made
@@alfadvestidvadtzattri8439 Wait, really??
Apparently if you put a butt plunger on the tail feather of a chicken, you get a t rex walking pattern.
The elephants that Mike Milne's animation team used for sauropod movements were Asian elephants.
They didn't use Penguins and Sea lions for Liopleurodon with their flippers.
I demand an updated version of this documentary. With the same passion and dedication, modern animatronics and modern animation and most recent scientific data!
I like to see dinosaurs at the Natural History Museum.
What about birds? They are descendants of dinosaurs
First. I take it quite a lot more has been leant since WWD has been made?
jamesaellis it’s been almost 20 years, we’ve learned quite a lot.
3:58 Name of Soundtrack please
departure of the Muttaburrasaurus
The layopiorodon is not big. It's frimly small.
Sillyguydefender its pretty big
you mean Liopleurodon ;)
Sillyguydefender totally forgetting that this documentary came out in 1999
@@Zimzilla99 He didn't forgot
The Walking with Series is just like any other dinosaur media - they just want cool size stimates based on overreacting scientists than on reliable and already established estimates that Liopleurodon is merely just 7 meters long.
@@DanielCorpuz223 ok