It has never been sold in any Macys ultas or sephoras near me so I’ve unfortunately never tried it i called chanel and they said it’s only sold in specific regions
I only have the Jimmy Choo Man Ice and it does smell pretty good. Performance is not great but for the price its worth it for sure (NOT from macys). I am sure the other two are solid too.
Nice it was on fragbuy last week for $168 a lot of people were telling me but I’m not the biggest fan of the Parfum I enjoy the intense more personally
I gotta disagree on the performance take on man ice it last around 7hours for me and dior homme cologne is better performance it acctualy suprised me it lasted almost 9 hours more then dior sauvage edp somehow dont ask how im also shocked either way man ice is super simila r and im getting that one
Wow that’s some crazy performance your getting. Glad they work like that for you but they are known across the frag community as short lived. Most colognes are and Jimmy choo man ice is known to be only a couple hour fragrance. But hey if it works for you that’s amazing
I prefer Mercedes Benz cologne because of that slight more citrus kick and performance. DH cologne close second as it’s the best blended and you can tell the quality is just a step higher and lastly choo ice as it’s a good easy pull but falls short in every category in comparison. I think eau de Rochas and commodity bergamot are better than ice.
I agree commodity bergamot is better than ice I just didn’t add it as these three are the closest in dna and it was a request I do really like all of them tho
See I already did that comparison a few weeks ago somone wanted a battle of the high heat it was DHC vs Eau givree vs light blue Eau intense. These vids are just based on what people ask me to do not personal choice I just threw that in because a sub asked me to
For me DHC is the best because it smells like DHC 😂 the others are very similar but they're not exactly the same, and DHC was the one I fell in love with when I first smelled it years ago. I have another clone, Zara Vibrant Leather Summer, which is pretty good. But again it's not DHC. Chanel Allure Homme Sport Cologne is also excellent but that has some definite differences in comparison to DHC. They'd be my top two in the ballpark though.
I see a lot of comments about Chanel allure homme sport cologne…. I can see the appeal but to me I remember it having a bit more of a green edge and having a more mature touch to it sorta like Dior eau sauvage…..
It’s def not I’m actually not the one that brought that up it was a huge convo in one of my lives earlier in the summer a bunch of people were saying that their ultas were still using the 2013 testers and they didn’t like it so I went to my ultas and the one was the 2021 tester the other was the 2013 and I tried it and disliked it. They def have a very different smell my wife was super turned off and I even did another live with a video of me testing it next to the 2022 version and I really disliked it. I made a purchase on fragrance net of it that had the picture of the 2021 but it came and it was the 2013 version and again I disliked it and they allowed me to return and I got the 2021 from joma. Then Jeff from SoCal scents said he had the same issue and does not like the 2013 version but loves the 2022. The one has grapefruit blossom and the new one is orange blossom at least from the breakdowns online but with that said it wasn’t necessarily the floral component I didn’t love it was the fact that the 2013 version was slightly powdery and less Citric and off putting to me not sure if it’s grapefruit blossom or what it was as I’ve never smelled that before. If u think they smell the same that’s great I’m glad they both work for u but they definitely are not the same after numerous upon numerous comparisons I’ve personally done and again other reports that brought me into the convo
I'm with you, they smell the same to me, I've had them on side by side. But I guess we're all different so other people might see it differently. I can't tell any difference. For other people it may also smell different due to one bottle being older so it may have changed a little over time in comparison to the new bottle. I'm pretty sure it was always supposed to be just a bottle change to fit with the rest of the current lineup though.
None of the 3! Channel AHS Cologne or Cremo Iced Citron & Driftwood for the budget option, lol 😂😂! All kidding aside, love these battle videos! 👍 Keep ‘em coming Randy!
Not similar! Dior Homme Cologne is very lemonade type, whereas Man eau fraiche is starfruit which is like sweet and sparkly! I own both! Both are good in their own way. I would not mind picking up both if I have to.
@@FlorinToader ya I judge most of my frags based off yes the scent and performance but also the price I paid and for $70 I feel like it was a great deal. And $150 for a 200ml isn’t bad either especially at retail
Man I let a friend of mine get my bottle of Mercedes cologne about 4 months ago and I still haven't got my money yet. Do chanel bleu versus sauvage. Man also email chanel and tell them we want a new one asap. I'm telling you man I love chanel allure homme sport cologne. Longevity is okay but it is a freshie though
I have all 3 and love all of em. Chanel Allure Homme Sport Cologne is the originator of that scent profile and it does it the best imo.
It has never been sold in any Macys ultas or sephoras near me so I’ve unfortunately never tried it i called chanel and they said it’s only sold in specific regions
@@FragranceDOUDhe's right Chanel is the best iteration of this DNA. The quality of Chanel is undeniable. 🔥
Had Man Ice and Mercedes at the same time, sold the Mercedes as I preferred Man Ice. Now I’m regretting it because it’s getting high in price.
Ya I regret it as well i always hate when things get discontinued and I don’t grab
Very good review,these battles videos are Great,I've never MB,or ice,I can't remember really what Dior smelled like when I was at Ulta.
I only have the Jimmy Choo Man Ice and it does smell pretty good. Performance is not great but for the price its worth it for sure (NOT from macys). I am sure the other two are solid too.
Ya if u have ice u really don’t need the others
FYI: A NEW BATCH OF DIOR HOMME PARFUM 3.4OZ JUST HIT MERCARI FOR $209!!!!😱👍👍I PURCHASED 2 BOTTLES😍😍😍
Nice it was on fragbuy last week for $168 a lot of people were telling me but I’m not the biggest fan of the Parfum I enjoy the intense more personally
Damn now I’m enjoying it a bit more that I got it for 160 lol
I gotta disagree on the performance take on man ice it last around 7hours for me and dior homme cologne is better performance it acctualy suprised me it lasted almost 9 hours more then dior sauvage edp somehow dont ask how im also shocked either way man ice is super simila r and im getting that one
Wow that’s some crazy performance your getting. Glad they work like that for you but they are known across the frag community as short lived. Most colognes are and Jimmy choo man ice is known to be only a couple hour fragrance. But hey if it works for you that’s amazing
I prefer Mercedes Benz cologne because of that slight more citrus kick and performance. DH cologne close second as it’s the best blended and you can tell the quality is just a step higher and lastly choo ice as it’s a good easy pull but falls short in every category in comparison. I think eau de Rochas and commodity bergamot are better than ice.
I agree commodity bergamot is better than ice I just didn’t add it as these three are the closest in dna and it was a request I do really like all of them tho
@@FragranceDOUD oh for sure those 3 r the best to put head to head against eachother spot on
I felt that based on Y Eau Fraiche being juniper-based “cologne” I think of Terre d’ Hermes Eau Givree being more interesting contender here.
See I already did that comparison a few weeks ago somone wanted a battle of the high heat it was DHC vs Eau givree vs light blue Eau intense. These vids are just based on what people ask me to do not personal choice I just threw that in because a sub asked me to
For me DHC is the best because it smells like DHC 😂 the others are very similar but they're not exactly the same, and DHC was the one I fell in love with when I first smelled it years ago. I have another clone, Zara Vibrant Leather Summer, which is pretty good. But again it's not DHC. Chanel Allure Homme Sport Cologne is also excellent but that has some definite differences in comparison to DHC. They'd be my top two in the ballpark though.
I see a lot of comments about Chanel allure homme sport cologne…. I can see the appeal but to me I remember it having a bit more of a green edge and having a more mature touch to it sorta like Dior eau sauvage…..
Ya I never tried it and I already know it wouldn’t fit into what this video was trying to accomplish since all 3 are similar
@@FragranceDOUD 💯
Jimmy Choo is my choice here
As far as price for what u get I can’t argue
Which Mercedez is it?
Jimmy Choo Man Ice definitely uses cheaper oils than the other two. It smells like its cheap. Weaker than other two as well.
Ya I def agree with that much weaker and does smell cheaper up close
i like benz cologne the best cause of the ginger
Both versions of Dior Homme Cologne are exactly the same. Same note breakdown. I have both versions. Its always been the same scent.
It’s def not I’m actually not the one that brought that up it was a huge convo in one of my lives earlier in the summer a bunch of people were saying that their ultas were still using the 2013 testers and they didn’t like it so I went to my ultas and the one was the 2021 tester the other was the 2013 and I tried it and disliked it. They def have a very different smell my wife was super turned off and I even did another live with a video of me testing it next to the 2022 version and I really disliked it. I made a purchase on fragrance net of it that had the picture of the 2021 but it came and it was the 2013 version and again I disliked it and they allowed me to return and I got the 2021 from joma. Then Jeff from SoCal scents said he had the same issue and does not like the 2013 version but loves the 2022. The one has grapefruit blossom and the new one is orange blossom at least from the breakdowns online but with that said it wasn’t necessarily the floral component I didn’t love it was the fact that the 2013 version was slightly powdery and less Citric and off putting to me not sure if it’s grapefruit blossom or what it was as I’ve never smelled that before. If u think they smell the same that’s great I’m glad they both work for u but they definitely are not the same after numerous upon numerous comparisons I’ve personally done and again other reports that brought me into the convo
I'm with you, they smell the same to me, I've had them on side by side. But I guess we're all different so other people might see it differently. I can't tell any difference. For other people it may also smell different due to one bottle being older so it may have changed a little over time in comparison to the new bottle. I'm pretty sure it was always supposed to be just a bottle change to fit with the rest of the current lineup though.
Have you tried allure Homme sport cologne?
Yes, allure Homme sport cologne is really good as well and smells almost exactly like Dior Homme Cologne & Mercedes Benz Cologne.
None of the 3! Channel AHS Cologne or Cremo Iced Citron & Driftwood for the budget option, lol 😂😂! All kidding aside, love these battle videos! 👍
Keep ‘em coming Randy!
My favourite fragrance is Versace EAU Fraiche. I read that Dior cologne smells very similar. How do they compare?
Not similar! Dior Homme Cologne is very lemonade type, whereas Man eau fraiche is starfruit which is like sweet and sparkly! I own both! Both are good in their own way. I would not mind picking up both if I have to.
@@koustavpoddarthank you. I don't think i like lemonade fragrances. But i am still tempted to try a sample.
Ysl Y Eau Fraiche 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Lol I do love the Eau Fraiche like a lot it would prob be my #1 if it was on this list
Dior Homme Cologne costs an arm and a leg and is pißwasser in terms of performance.
It’s $70 on discounters and I get around 5 hours
@@FragranceDOUD well i def wasn’t able to get it for that, granted i did get the big 200ml for about 150
@@FlorinToader ya I judge most of my frags based off yes the scent and performance but also the price I paid and for $70 I feel like it was a great deal. And $150 for a 200ml isn’t bad either especially at retail
@@FragranceDOUD this was euros, and I found it really cheap at some discounter
Man I let a friend of mine get my bottle of Mercedes cologne about 4 months ago and I still haven't got my money yet. Do chanel bleu versus sauvage. Man also email chanel and tell them we want a new one asap. I'm telling you man I love chanel allure homme sport cologne. Longevity is okay but it is a freshie though
Your friend sucks.
Already did chanel vs sauvage my first vs video. Any other requests maybe club black vs Althair Vs most wanted Parfum?
@FragranceDOUD Yes that will work