What the Taiwanese Think of Japan | Street Interview
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 чер 2024
- We hit the streets of Taipei to find out what the Taiwanese think of Japan. We do not have any political affiliations and are neither left or right. The opinions expressed in this video are those of individual interviewees alone and do not reflect the views of ASIAN BOSS or the general Taiwanese population.
Check out our video on what the Taiwanese think of the US: • What the Taiwanese Thi...
0:00 - Intro
1:14 - What’s your impression of Japan as a country?
4:06 - Taiwan was colonized by Japan. Why is the relationship still positive?
8:06 - Experiences in Japan
10:52 - Japanese worrying that Taiwan could be the next place that China invades
12:56 - Do you think Japan would aid Taiwan if it was invaded?
15:33 - Message to the Japanese
Follow us on social media:
Instagram ► asianbossme...
Facebook ► / asianboss
Twitter ► asianbossmedia?la...
TikTok ► www.tiktok.com/@asianbossmedi...
![What Does Democracy Mean To The Chinese? [Street Interview] | ASIAN BOSS](/img/n.gif)
We have to remember that the relationship between every country is based on their own need and seeking of their own benefits.
Thank you captain obvious
@@_-_-936 Thank you for saying "thank you captain obvious", I just... for a second there, I felt like I was stupid and everyone was smarter than me.
Maybe Clair de Lune here thinks that we think that every country doesn't care about their own future and just wants everything to end, I don't know
It is obvious for their own benefit
That’s also human nature…. A lot of relationships are based on needs
TRUE
Not sure if true but one of my Taiwanese friends said that Taiwan-Japanese relations are good now because when Taiwan was colonized by Imperial Japan, it was under the control of the Imperial Japanese Navy who were more amicable than the Imperial Japanese Army.
Now that is something worth arguing, had jealous SK had the capacity to come up with it. Not just targeting all Japanese randomly. And it's annoying SK think they are Japanese and have a say in Japan politics. I am glad taiwan have sense and logic, no just some emotional rage syndrome.
I think so too, you may see a bit from japanese perspective from watching film Isoroku.
@@tiefblau2780 Said nothing about South Korea and here you are talking about South Korea.
@@oppaheimer88 I might have contacted a virus stran that makes me angry when I hear anything that "I" can relate or lead back to that certain country. It's an anger syndrome, you wouldn't understand... Unless...
@@tiefblau2780 Being angry over such silly things will only cause you unnecessary stress. You are worth more than you think you are. You have value.
I think it's important to give some context on Japan's colonization of Taiwan. Japan gained control of Taiwan from China almost 50 years before WW2, and during those first few years they were cruel and made themselves superior over the natives and Han Chinese. Many of those people who experienced the worst of it died decades ago. Japan's goal for Taiwan was probably similar to what they did with Okinawa, to create a Japanese identity in the people over time, they did this by teaching Japanese in schools and building more infrastructure and developing Taiwan. Amongst all the countries and regions Japan had previously colonized, Taiwan definitely gained the most through investments, but that's not to say that they treated all the people well. When Japan left, and Taiwan was handed back to China, you had the civil war and eventually KMT takes control over Taiwan, using Marshall law that lasted nearly 30 years. When KMT first arrived, it was not pretty between the refugees from China and the people who were already living in Taiwan. Taiwan was basically a police state for a few decades, mainlanders were treated better by the government and this caused a lot of clashes where each side would attack one another, I believe these incidents also play a role in how people view Japan, as these incidents were more recent, it held a lasting impression on the people, who had to adapt to the change and overshadowed any mistreatment from Japan. I think these answers from the public are probably very different if you were to ask a Taiwanese who whose family came from China only a one or two generations ago.
台湾人只要有一口饭吃就愿意源源不断的支援奴隶主去攻打自己的同胞，从此心怀感恩。真失望，
Interesting! Thank you for telling the history!
There's a famous Taiwanese movie called "City of Sadness" that tells the story of the life of a Taiwanese family as Taiwan went from Japanese rule to KMT rule, and showed how KMT rule in many ways was just colonization and oppression of Taiwanese all over again.
This is a fair summary for those who are not familiar with this part of Taiwanese history. It is also fair to say that the colonial Japanese investments, construction and infrastructure that many Taiwanese say they are grateful for were not made to benefit the Taiwanese. That includes all imperialist colonizers. If there's an exception, I'd like to know. From the Taiwanese perspective, if there are two "evils", one is Japan and the other is (unnamed but we can guess), the former is probably seen as the lesser of the two. But I haven't heard anyone I know in Taiwan outwardly express that, and I wish they would. They're too polite. At the end of the day, people will usually form opinions based on what is useful, beneficial, or convenient to themselves. That's just human nature.
I read: "The Fig Tree: Memoirs of a Taiwanese Patriot" by Wu Zhuoliu. Very much worth reading.
It doesn't surprise me that younger Taiwanese people view Japan positively but the elderly as well does surprise me. I have one uncle still living who was a schoolboy under Japanese occupation in Taiwan. He's now in his 80s. But growing up I never really sensed any anti-Japanese sentiment from my (Taiwanese) family, even from the ones who lived under Japanese occupation. I don't ever remember my grandmother saying anything about the Japanese. So I guess I shouldn't be that surprised.
1946 TIME(8 months after the “occupation” of KMT).
“confiscated by the Chinese Army that took over the island, under U.S. tutelage, last fall. But the resumption of trade with tropically lush, industrially rich Formosa was a sweet-&-sour business.
Formosans complained that the Chinese occupation army was looting stocks, letting crops, refineries, railroads and power plants go to rack & ruin.”
“Formosans greeted the few visiting Americans with: "You were kind to the Japanese, you dropped the atom on them. You dropped the Chinese on us!"
Thoughtful Chinese on the mainland began to agree with the Formosans. Said Ta Rung Pao, China's counterpart of the New York Times: "Fundamentally speaking, China was not qualified to take over . . . she lacks the men . . . technique . . . commodities . . . capital. She governs, but is inefficient. She takes, but she does not give. This is the government's shame."
Most foreign observers in Formosa agreed that if a referendum were taken today Formosans would vote for U.S. rule. Second choice-Japan.”
1949 TIME(the year KMT lost Chinese civil war and escaped to Taiwan）:
“In Washington, Formosa assumed an increasing prominence in discussions of future U.S. strategy in Asia. With the help of U.S. sea and air power it could be held against Communist attack. It flanked the line of a possible Communist advance across the South China Sea.
But Formosa had its drawbacks as an anti-Communist redoubt governed by Chinese Nationalists. Mostly these boiled down to the simple fact that 6½ million Formosans did not like the Chinese. Last week TIME Correspondent Wilson Fielder cabled this picture of the island in its new, unwanted role:”
“At night, electric lights -rare in rural Asia-twinkled from the modest huts of tiny villages. By day many villagers not needed in the fields worked in the small industrial plants that dot the island. Compared to mainland Chinese, the Formosans were well off. Nevertheless they were grumbling. In guarded whispers they spoke of the "good old days" of Japanese rule. The years since V-J day had taken with them much of the sting of iron-fisted totalitarianism. The islanders now remembered how Japan had given , order to their lives, while China had brought them to the brink of chaos. “
“Civilians and soldiers (1,500,000 in number) were refugees from the communism now flooding south across China. They were also a troublesome burden to a people who wanted their island home for themselves.”
“Pigs Just Eat. This resentment is grounded partly in the psychology of a colonial people whose standards of living, general educational level and technical proficiency were raised well above the standards of their mainland Chinese brethren. The Japanese, for example, trained 30,000 Formosan doctors, more than the number in all the rest of China. But when the mainland Chinese took over the island, they did not even treat the Formosans as equals, but as "liberated" inferiors. The result is that even thoughtful Formosans now say: "We think of the Japanese as dogs and the Chinese as pigs. A dog eats, but he protects. A pig just eats."
Many Formosans want complete independence for their island-to be gained by revolution or any other means. Others talk of "autonomy under a good Chinese government," neither Nationalist nor Communist. A third group favors a U.S. mandate.”
Im Korean and I love japan and Japanese people
The Japanese helped build Taiwan....
@@cooliipie 日本也屠杀台湾
Many elders Taiwanese were considered by they self as Japanese.
The comments section always tells me that world peace will never be possible.
At least not in East Asia
I'm Korean and spent some time studying and working in Taiwan. I learnt so much about Taiwanese history and its relationship with Japan. It was interesting to learn how Taiwan experienced Japanese colonialism completely different to Korea so people's perception of Imperial Japan was quite different as well. I hope we can all work towards a peaceful relationship in the future :)
하지만 대만인에게 한국인의 목숨은 야구경기 점수 1점보다도 가치 없지요 ㅋㅋㅋ
@@ActivaVita-ub6le 뭔 개소리에요 좋은 말에 이런 악플로 초치면서 한국인 망신좀 시키지 말아요
@@hong3840 개소리라니요 대만 안가보셨습니까? 그리고 댓글들 안보여요?
@@ActivaVita-ub6le 대만에 가봤더니 그래 한국사람이면 불을 켜고 욕하려고 쫓아오던가요? 방구석에서 혐오자료같은거나 보고 그렇게 생각하지 말고 그냥 인간대 인간으로 상식적으로 생각을 합시다 좀.. 그저 댓글로 ㅋㅋ거리고 싸우고 집단으로 나눠 혐오하는 그 습성좀 버리구요 다들 이성적으로, 발전적으로 이야기하는 와중에 한국댓글 달린거 보면 질떨어지는게 왜이렇게 많은지 짜증이 다 나요 저급한 사이트들이 많아서 인터넷 문화가 개판이라 자기들이 잘못하는줄도 모르고 저급하게 싸우는거밖에 할줄 모르니 진짜.. 집단혐오가 뭔지조차 모르고 다른나라 그런 류들 욕은 실컷 하면서도 완전히 그들하고 똑같이 행동하고..
because they treat Koreans like dogs and they wanted to make Taiwan their own country. I guess it's down to who was the governor. British treated different colonies different as well look at hong kong and India
It gives me so much hope to see young people informed and having their own perspectives on such important issues. With thought out and intelligent polite responses .
Learned a new thing today thank you for the video such a complex relationship.
As a Taiwanese with Taiwan-Japan mixed relatives, my grandparents and relatives can speak Japanese well, especially grandma speaks Japanese better than chinese, they told me when I was little that Japanese government was way better than chinese government in every way, although not everyone thinks so but I think only the elders from the past, who truly experienced both can have honest opinions.
Japanese people are actually ok. The issue is after world war 2, the right winged government was not replaced by the usa because they were against the soviets. As a result, many of the post ww2 leaders of japan were juniors of their ww2 counterpart. Even as recently as 10 years ago, Japan's pm shinzo abe is the grandson of a war criminal. Why the USA did not replace the govenrment of japan, you can research more : operation reverse course
Japanese believe that Taiwan is the closest friend to Japan. Japan and Taiwan have helped each other when there are earthquakes.
the girl with the blue hoodie jacket and grey shirt seems intelligent and very well informed, i enjoyed listening to her
As a Chinese lives in Australia, I'm a little surprised by the opinions of the elder people. I used to travel in Japan and Taiwan. I like both of them. No matter what the politicians say, common people just want peace.
But ur a Chinese communist spy
@@VitaminProtein4256 I’m not into the government but I have to say China want peace.
@@VitaminProtein4256 All Chinese people love peace.
@@VitaminProtein4256 也不要一杆子打翻一船人吧
@@VitaminProtein4256 instead your USA daddy would give you peace
Most neighboring countries don`t have good relationships and Japan is not an exception. But Japan and Taiwan is different. Taiwan is our ONLY neighboring country that we can call them a friend. That is why most Japanese think Taiwan is important to us. That is why we do not want Taiwan to be part of China because if Taiwan becomes part of China we lose our only neighboring friend.
台日友好！
Back in 2012, during one of my many visits to Taiwan, I was in Hualien. A Taiwanese friend took me to a local festival (Just Googled it and think it was the Hungry Ghost Festival). We were making a short film together at that time so we went there with our film camera to experiment with lighting and shutter speed etc. The festival we went to was elaborate where locals played games and distributed food to everyone. They then took out a procession and we started following it. On our way we walked through a small village, where people looked a tad bit different from the Taiwanese I knew. A friend of my friend who happened to be there told me that these people were in fact Japanese who decided to stay back after WW2. The sight was surreal. After so many years I still remember that evening vividly.
so they married taiwanese women and settled down?
@@lyhthegreat They probably hid within the local indigenous tribes.
@@BBarNavi real ninjas
@@lyhthegreat I'm trying to respond to your comment by sharing a link to more information that I found online, but UA-cam is deleting my comment. As far as I know, I think all those I saw were ethnic Japanese, some might've married into Taiwanese people, but I can't say for sure.
事实证明日本在台湾的种族灭绝很成功，日本占领台湾时敢于反抗的成年人都已经被日本人杀光了，然后日本人教导顺从的台湾人说日语教他们如何成为忠心的仆人。 而当时国民党在台湾迫害的是少部分有钱人和共产党，伤害了部分台湾大家族的利益，又没有彻底灭绝他们的家族，现在那些以前日本人培养起来的大家族的后代掌握台湾的政府，自然要远离国民党和中国，教导台湾人喜欢日本人和美国人。
One of the best interviews that I’ve seen on here
I have been Japan and Taiwan and I prefer Taiwan, most of my Taiwanese friends go to Japan at least once a year for travel ( before covid )
It is important to differentiate between the relationship of the people and the countries politics, some of the questions blend them together a bit too much, making some of the answers a two sided sword. Of course nobody trusts politicians, but how the communities hold together (and possibly demand change the politics in favor of their relations) is something else entirely.
Another reason Japanese colonial rule isn't remembered so negatively is because just after the Japanese left dictator Chiang and his KMT army from China came to Taiwan, Chiang's rule to many Taiwanese was seen as just as brutal and unjust as Japanese colonial rule, if not worse, so its more fresh in our minds. In Taiwan there's a saying 狗去豬來; "the dogs left. The pigs came"
They butchered all those that didn’t want Chaing and his ilk there.
This channel is a bit of a joke and probably NED backed.
Well at least the pigs are more related by blood than the dogs that left.
@@johnnyhshify good job making a ethno nationalist fascist talking point.
@@johnnyhshify It's complicated. I'm sure you understand the intricacies of the problem that Asian Boss totally ignores.
Actually, the Japanese were far worse as compared to the early era of the KMT administration. Over 600,000 Chinese and Aboriginal inhabitants of Taiwan lost their lives to the brutal Japanese atrocities. The Tapani and Musha incidents are notable examples.
As a Taiwanese, I am very interested in the "Pro- Japan" vibe, too. Here are some experience and opinion.
My family members are all very pro Japan because this is what we have been taught as a kid. (My great grand paretns lived in Japan for over 20 years) So I was a pro Japan guy for a long period of time. However, as I get older and has traveled more and meet more people from different countries, I think that the way we think of Japan is too narrow. The media is a big part of this mind set because most of the news about Japan is relatively positive. People in Taiwan like Japan because everyone likes Japan. It is just a trend. I still like Japan and is still one of my favorite countries, I have lots of Japanese friends that will share their actual culture and more importantly their "mind-set" with me and not just anime and subculture. So in conclusion, I hope that Taiwanese people can have better critical thinking skills and not just follow what the media says.
Don’t forget Taiwanese government was ruled under KMT for 50 years.
KMT is from China and it hates Japan. However the most people of Taiwan like Japan out of comparison. It can’t be fooled from the people’s experiences.
Taiwanese people were taught to hate Japan from 1945 to 1990s, but failed. Why?
@@raistlin906 I'm Korean and I think Korea should stop making dramas that portray the Japanese villians.
@@ns-4438 As long as Japan don't come clean proactively like what the Germans did, most countries that were invaded by them will hold those negative views. The annual visit by their political leaders to the Yasukuni Shrine (paying respect to class A,B,&C war criminal) is another sensitive topic. Even the past 2 Japanese emperors never visited that Shrine for some reason. Also the names of thousands of men from Taiwan and Korea killed while serving with imperial forces are also recorded at Yasukuni. Some relatives want their names removed coz this brands them as collaborators against their own countrymen.
Taiwan is still China
@@ns-4438 ..... You do realize they killed your people right... Though I agree you should stop portraying Chinese as prostitutes or use actors that looks old and ugly for Chinese
1:15 is the best & most intricate answer of all, very well said
I have been to Japan and Taiwan. Nice food and memories.
Nice to see some love, respect, and not hate. Also some critical thinking and common sense, not being pulled by emotions. Nice interviews
Yeah, unlike South Korea...
Nice Report! We can see all kinds of people from Taiwan. wish world PEACE and LOVE , I'm from China.
Incredible how international relations change so fast.
Its common thing actully..
US nuked Japan in 1945
And Japan bombed pearl harbor and killed many people in 1941
But after 1950 they have good realationship. You see things can just changed in 5years.
But Korean people dont seem to get over their colonial history.
As a Korean this part is really sad
may be my English is poor... but l want to know you are view to China,what's view of Korean mostly?
It just stuns me to see Taiwanese's point of view towards their colonial history. School education literally shapes the opinions of a whole generation.
Look at the young generation of america. They hate America because of the education and social media
As bad as past events were between nations, it shouldn't be a deciding factor in how anyone views the entirety of a country, its people, culture, etc. Focusing on these things is just going to breed more hatred & animosity when instead we should be learning from past events and working towards not repeating things and doing things that'll be better for the future.
You also should not assume 'all' people of any country is a certain way; even if you have personal experience.
this is happening to the philippines right now. many western people (commonly americans) have been pulling out of commissioning filipino artists because of the current political state in the country, with the elections turning out to be a sham and the son of a former dictator being elected as president. i’ve seen screenshots on twitter where they basically said they cannot be associated with us, stating it was a risk because of the recent event, and one even said (non-verbatim): “i can’t really support fascism, i thought you were better than that but i cant really force you to be different.” essentially branding every single one of us as fascist because several knockheads decided to put that guy in power. it’s so frustrating how they’re talking to us like this and act as if they’re being woke when it’s literally just performative activism hiding their racism and discrimination. many professional contractors have also pulled out of big projects. it’s terrible and the more i think about it, the more my heart hurts. we’ve been nothing but cordial with them and they give us this in return. it sucks, man. it’s not even them who might potentially suffer under this new regime, it’s us. will they be there when we’re going to be in a terrible condition fearing for our lives, livelihood and economy with the possible second coming of a dictatorship? it sucks. it really sucks.
@@hellbunniez3 Cry a river, you can’t accept what the people want 😂
In general, you are right, but most Taiwanese are very contradictory and dualistic. Those words are only adapted to Japanese, but the vast majority of Taiwanese generalize Koreans and hate Korea. Like the comments on this video, most Koreans say The taiwanese like Japan as 'wierd' and 'do not understand', but do not hate Taiwan just because they like Japan. However, most Taiwanese hate Korea because Koreans hate Japan. Taiwanese are really contradictory.
@@Helghast73 oh look, a bbm supporter. i’m seriously wondering how anyone in their right minds would vote for someone who witnessed bloodshed at the hands of their father? how ignorant can you be of our country’s history? all for instant gratification and empty promises? at least with leni, we can see that she was working hard even if she was getting bullied by her colleagues in the government left and right. eh ano ginagawa ng pamilya ng binoto mo? history erasure at pagkokolekta ng kayamanan at pera mula sa taumbayan? anong sunod, second dictatorship? eh proven na may halong msg yung documents ng achievements ni bbm. kung nasa isip talaga ni bongbong yung pilipinas, sana hindi na siya tumakbo. ang dating lang ngayon, hindi makaletgo sa pagcontrol sa pilipinas.
kuya, medyo apolitical ako, pero alam ko na dun makipartida sa tao na walang bahid ng dugo ng ilang pilipinong pinatay at sinalvage noong 80s. ewan ko nalang sayo. sana sagipin ka ng bbm mo kung magkandaleche-leche na tayong lahat dito sa pilipinas.
@@hellbunniez3 as a French guy I would not accuse anyone of fascism. I am skeptical about Duterte's politics to develop his country, but concerning his war on drugs I think he did some positive things. In my country, the situation is getting out of control with politics not moving their fingers mainly to avoid being called fascists or racists. Drug is a plague for any country.
My Taiwanese grandparents had positive memories of Japan too. They were treated well and often reminisce of those times. They didn’t have good memories of the Kuomintang, however and often spoke of their brutality.
Honestly it must have been a shock to 'return under Chinese rule' and find out that Chinese rule was, uh, not all that pleasant.
Would you have preferred the CCP?
they're both brutal so i dont think our ancestors are gonna like them either way if ccp lost instead of kmt
I'm Japanese. I love Taiwan and Most of Japanese ( I think 99% of Japanese) love Taiwan.
Taiwan has always been helping Japan, like March 11th 2011 earthquake.
But Taiwanese people always say that Japan helps Taiwan.
I hope that this great relationship will last forever.
Our relationship is strongly connected.
Next time we Japanese want to help Taiwan.
일본이 대만을 사랑한다고요? 웃기시네 ㅋㅋㅋ 대한민국, 대만을 식민지로 삼은 너희 나라의 범죄를 먼저 사죄하는 것이 인간의 도리이다. 이 웃긴 녀석아.
As a Taiwanese, I don't really need your help as a Japanese.
Please don't arrogantly assume that, after colonizing Taiwan for 50 years, mistreating and killing us, and using us to harm our own compatriots, Japan can now exploit us again to counter the mainland.
Japanese just want to see China divided, and they don't genuinely care about us Taiwanese. Many Okinawans also don't consider themselves Japanese, and Japan should focus on its own issues.
We don't accept your hypocrisy. Our relationship with you is only one of colonizer and colonized.
In the nearly 1000 years of history, Japan has repeatedly violated Taiwan. For me, the credibility of the Japanese people is zero, and the painful history tells Taiwanese that Japanese people can never be friends.
If, as you say, "next time you help us," please directly engage with the mainland. We won't accept your military landing in Taiwan, and Taiwanese people won't allow Japan to turn Taiwan into a battlefield.
@@user-ie6ns1mc1l絶対に謝らない😂一生おばあちゃんのために泣いてて！笑うから
日本政府が大金を費やして誘致した熊本のTSMC工場は毎年、熊本県民が使用する生活用水の何十倍もの水を汲み取り有害な水として排水してる、雇用の代償に水資源を渡すのはちょっと…
我是台灣人，我也愛日本🇯🇵🇹🇼
I am Taiwanese and I love Japan
When I was in Taiwan taking a tour, the Taiwanese tour operator kept praising Japan for helping build their infrastructure. He kept dissing China though.
Stockholm Syndrome at it's best.
He was never thought during 50 years Japanese occupation in Taiwan Island hundred thousands of Han Chinese and indigenous people were slaughter. world world 2 Japanese conscripting Taiwanese men to invade south east Asia. Japanese Imperial army also force Taiwanese and Korean women as military sex slaves. These atrocities were never formally apologized by Japanese government. He choose not to know this dark chapters in purpose.
I can feel what u said. I live in both place long time.
I think it’s come from media and education.
In Taiwanese education which wrote by period of Kuomintang occupied,Japan help to build the island in the history, and the mainland China is a place need to be liberate by ROC.（ In Chinese civil war，Kuomintang occupied taiwan island ，while CCP occupied mainland. So In other words, China is still in a civil war between the two parties.）
But now Taiwanese all know it’s impossible win if PROC and ROC has war. So their ruling party DPP use the way Anti-China policy to get more voter.
In fact there are 40% economic of taiwan relay on the mainland of China， that‘s why Putin said ，if China wants to solve taiwan problem no need War.
From the video the interviewee said
In War II, Japan use Taiwan as the back supply station to attack China. U can feel something about their relationship.
And in most of Chinese memories, the history of Japan invades China is really bad.
@@czoe6733 it's pretty sad that most people in Taiwan still has this sort of post-colonial mindset, isn't it?
@@choualberto885 Nah, I think it's sadder for people who be stuck in the past.
I am Taiwanese, I think Japanese are our best friends
多謝！我愛台灣🇹🇼
@@S32033 我愛日本😊
i am chinese american, i like both japan and taiwan, i've been to both places. But i still love china way more :P
@@levelazn Thank you😊
I enjoy this interview video, especially it covers people across different ages and genders. From what I know, many elderly in TW could speak Japanese quite well, even outside the capital city. Maybe you could try to have interviews outside Taipei next time! 😊
Thank you for this! I wish there were further discussion about the imperialist past but it makes sense that people generally think of Japan in terms of politics and travel.
If you have a chance, I wonder if it'd be possible to cover something about Southeast Asian migrant workers in Taiwan and simultaneously also showcase Southeast Asian perspectives on family members going abroad for domestic work.
That's a good idea, I want to know about that too. Asianboss please make it possible.
I also want to see your suggestion
That would be interesting
The young woman wearing the blue sweatshirt and blue mask is very intelligent. She has insights that many younger people would not be aware of. She should get into politics, her thoughtfulness and logic can be beneficial to Taiwan
no thanks
It doesn't matter Taiwanese like Japan or Japanese. In fact, the vast majority of Koreans do not say 'I don't like Taiwan because I like Japan', but they do not say 'I don't understand' or 'I don't understand'. If there are any Koreans who hate Taiwan, it's because they know the impressions Taiwanese have on us and what they say about us. However, in Taiwan, quite a number of Taiwanese claim that they hate Korea 'because Koreans hate Japan'. ridiculous. And I'm pretty sure she's like this too.
@@ActivaVita-ub6le I was fortunate to be raised in San Francisco where we have so many different cultures and a very large LGBTQ community. The one main thing I learned is that there is no reason to hate a culture, religion, people of color, sexual orientation. Be cause there are very good people from all different walks of life. But there are also very bad people from all different walks of life. SO, the why question is..."Why waste time hating?"
Agree
She is the only one knows history. XD
Should do one on how Japanese feel about Taiwanese too!
Very positive, so long as we respect each other and love 💕. Japan loves everyone, try being nice to everyone and have 1 person reject you.
At long as most Japanese even know where Taiwan is...🤣
@@JohnWick-cz3ph that was not a nice one we of course do👍
@@tiefblau2780 Not sure about "Japan loves everyone", ask a Japanese person what they think about Chinese or Koreans and they will be full of hate
@@gkky-xx4mc certainly
do it yourself would be my advice. As I think positive of Taiwan
Hey look! People capable of expressing politely a nuanced point of view and with some knowledge of their own history! How refreshing!
I personally feel the reason many Japanese like Taiwanese / Taiwan is simply because many Taiwanese are fond of Japan, and maybe vice versa.
Sometimes simplicity would overwhelm something logical.
I just hope the good relationship will last forever.
Wth???? Bro do you not know anything about these politics Taiwan loves Japan sadly not vice versa at all
@@user-cn3gd7gf7v
When it comes to the politic, as you mentioned, I admit that there is another aspect and we could see somehow different story from what I said.
But, as just one of the sense of ordinary people in Japan, I felt our relationship in that way.
Former colonial subjects loving their former colonial master. No surprises here. Result of a COLONIZED mind. Smirk..
@@ELGtheMAN true we can also see the effects in other countries that have been colonized for quite along time. Hong Kong, Indonesia, and many more
@@user-cn3gd7gf7v
In some way, Taiwan was colonized by “China”, after WWII. Out of comparison, China was worse than Japan of ruling Taiwan.
The response given at 9:45 is spot on.
I'm a half Japanese and living in Japan too but I don't hear people talking about politics much. I think we tend to have middle-ground mindset in most of the problems . I've traveled to South East Asian countries and they too have positive view to us . Maybe it's because Japanese companies are offering jobs to them ? Idk , but it's interesting because our history with the neighboring countries wasn't good in the past . I'm glad that I got to speak with them . They're more open about their opinions on the world's politics than most of the Japanese .
i think it’s because of the soft power (jpop, japanese products especially appliances, japanese food, and of course, anime) that japan has cultivated over the years spreading through globalization. when the country had the bubble boom, it essentially jumpstarted the whole love affair of the world towards japan. my country doesn’t feel the animosity towards japan now (i’m half filipino, half japanese but living here in the philippines) because of this, and the several instances of alliance with japan in regards to different aspects were effective. it’s kind of commendable to a degree, really, especially in part when you know the terrible things japn has done here in the 2nd world war (e.g. comfort women). i think it’s also because filipinos as a whole aren’t really vindictive and don’t dwell on the past. we’re too busy living our own lives in a shitty economy right now and earning our keep to live, so it’s just kind of “not minded (?)” by the current generation even though schools still teach the history of our connection.
@@hellbunniez3 You're right . Japan's image outside of Japan is generally based on those aspects . I felt instant relieved when they started talking about anime , entertainment , cars , etc. That way we can have a decent conversation even if I'm not very fluent in the language . I've become more aware of our past as I'm familiar with the neighboring people now . It's scary but it's eye-opening . At the same time , I'm glad that we have changed and move on .
@@usagi009 yep, filipinos love japan so much lol. anime is extremely big here, and it’s generally more accepted to be an otaku here than in other places. what i don’t get though is people holding other people of that nationality accountable because the government made severe decisions that affected how they were seen. that right there breeds hostility and discrimination, which is awful to think about especially when the time we live in now is about looking forward to the future, acceptance, and cross-border unity.
@@hellbunniez3 On the contrary, China, which was a very civilized and friendly country before, is now an objectionable troublemaker.
類が友を呼んでいるだけです
主語を大きくしないように
好喜歡這個訪談，謝謝你做這個主題！
I think it will be fun to see the day you guys are celebrating 4 million subscribers. I sure as hell will.
I like and get along with Taiwanese. I wish Taiwan a good future.
Last year when China tried pressuring Taiwan over pineapples, everyone in Japan started buying Taiwanese pineapples intended for China. People in Japan also remember the pro Japan sentiment of leaders like Lee Tenghui and support for Japan after earthquakes. News coverage in Japan of Taiwan is overwhelmingly positive. I think it is a shame Japan as a nation can’t be as openly friendly to Taiwan as it feels out of PRC sensitivity but I’m glad the two are such good friends.
lol japan is just another usa's satellite country after skorea
@@manishgrg639 Sure - that's an arrangement that has worked out well for both countries.
Please keep buying
2013年我刚刚为中国贸易机构工作的时候，中国制定了一条针对东南亚国家柑橘进口的技术贸易壁垒（TBT），来保证台湾的柑橘能热销大陆。我相信没有台湾媒体会报道这件事，也没有台湾人感谢大陆。
去年在台湾禁止了一堆大陆企业后，中国决定对台湾的农产品进行制裁----我可以向你保证，只要想查，就一定能在水果中检查到禁止的昆虫，这点是日本政府最常用的本国农产品TBT。只是禁止了菠萝和莲雾，台湾媒体和政府就疯狂地指责大陆政府。
为更好表达，我用中文写的，以下是翻译：
When I was working for a Chinese trade agency in 2013, China formulated a technical barrier to trade (TBT) for citrus imports from Southeast Asian countries to ensure that Taiwanese citrus can sell well to the mainland. I believe that no Taiwanese media will report this, and no Taiwanese will thank the mainland.
After banning a bunch of mainland companies in Taiwan last year, China decided to impose sanctions on Taiwan's agricultural products -- I can assure you that as long as you want to check, you will be able to check the banned insects in the fruit. This is the Japanese government. The most commonly used domestic agricultural product TBT.
Just banning pineapples and wax apples, the Taiwanese media and government frantically accuse the mainland government.
Japan has recently returned Taiwanese banana because of pesticide problem. It has been openly friendly with Taiwanese by promising the military assistance in case of a war. I bet mainland China will not ban your pineapples if they are of good quality... It is such a little trade that mainland China does not even care, I am surprised that Taiwanese still feel the sentiment. Just let the green medias say whatever conspiracy theories they have and ignore their problems. Tbh they will never report how much effort mainland China has done to promote better relations between two areas, like tons of communication events in mainland these days. Making Taiwanese hate PRC brings PRC no benefit if they want them to be a part of PRC in the future. I guess Taiwanese should really open their mind and try visiting the mainland China and see if you will disappear haha
Taiwanese people are so well educated and well spoken!
Yeah .....
The difference between the Taiwanese and mainland Chinese is greater than night and day
not surprised they don't have bad relationships with Japan. Yes, occupation happened but that was then and now is now. At least they are not harassing anyone unlike what are russians doing to us ever since the war was over.
Japan couldn't harass anyone even if they wanted too. Macarthur and his demilitarization policy was a huge blow towards Japanese rearmament. On the other hand, there were no formal restrictive measurements places against the Soviet Union and what is now Russia.
@@missalicesmiles 嫌がらせなんてしたくないわ。日本の事分かった気になってコメントしないでね
If one of the worst things that can be said about your country is that it’s “boring”, then I think you’ve done something right.
yeah.. u.s.a not "boring" at the moment
@@levelazn it’s a damn party 🎉
@@alvinyang8677 fkn clown show.
well, thats quite a retarded thought if you ask me. It comes down to influence. Size, ressource, population, technology, infrastructure, capital, location, culture, and actions can shape the opinion and view of a country.
Thats, ofcourse, is just the general, common narrative accepted opinion that will result out of it.
If you ask an individual about a country, and they would say its boring, you have actually no clue about the reasoning, background of the person, or knowledge of said topic is. They could also just lie, which could also have various reason why they would.
But with that logic, nazi germany was surely boring i guess.
Fun fact) Japan was the first Asian country to break off diplomatic relations with Taiwan and establish diplomatic relations with China.
你說得對。當時田中總理優先利益。
I wrote this as a report for a history class in university more than 10 years ago....poor English though....
1. Because of the population, Taiwan was easier to control than Korea peninsula.
2. At that time, Taiwan was only an island of Qing. Most of all, Qing didn’t value it before attacked by the big powers (Europe countries and Japan), so the link between mainland and Taiwan was weak especially Qing was not established by the Hans. On the contrary, whole the Korea is a country; their conscious of sovereign was stronger than Taiwan.
3. Nowadays, Korean people regard Japan-Korea Annexation Treaty as a fake treaty. It seemed peaceful, but actually is not. While Taiwan was ceded by Qing due to the defeat of Sino-Japanese War.
4. Big area certainly becomes more problems to dominate.
iv. Other differences
First, after Japanese colonial period, Taiwan was ruled by Publican National Party (Kuomintang, KMT), but not for Taiwanese to build for themselves a new bright nation. However, people in Taiwan were respecting the new government from China with joys, but by the international rule (Treaty of Peace with Japan), it was not rational at all. How to deal with Taiwan after WWII, should be decided by the winner side just America but not KMT from China. When KMT government came to Taiwan, they ruled Taiwan in barbarian way, more violent than before under Japanese rule and they rooted out people who before were close to Japan. That caused many Taiwanese to prefer to the former government. However, Korean after Japanese colonial period were setting up a temporary government by Korean themselves. That would be more comfortable than ruled by other country. With this point, we can find that Korea is not same to Taiwan. People in Taiwan were continuing the lives which exploited by another political power and even worse than the former.
Second, Taiwan is more like a migration country. Furthermore, there are various kinds of people in the island of Taiwan. It was something like multiple cultures in Taiwan already, so there is not so strong national consciousness in Taiwan. On the other hand, in Korea is totally different.
So Chiang was not a victor of WW2?
@@reintaler6355 Temporary government of Taiwan was needed after Japanese goverment left, so Chiang controlled Taiwan *temporarily*.
1945 Janpan left Taiwan, and China(KMT) came as a members of victorious allies to take charge *temporarily*.
1949 KMT was defeated by CCP and fled to Taiwan *permanently?*.
@@godaininja This part "protect Taiwan against the Communist Party" is totally not true though.
CCP was not intreseted in Taiwan at that time. CCP even urged Taiwan people to fight KMT so KMT would be defeated quickly (Taiwanese can also establish their own country).
The true is KMT just used Taiwan as a base to fight against CCP. If KMT didn't come, Taiwan was safe and no need to fight against China(CCP).
So where is the "Self-determination" for Taiwanese after WW2?
America and China(KMT) were good friends as you said, victorious in WW2, so America didnt say anything about this. Thats why no one cares about Taiwanese people.
I wish I saw this earlier. This answer deserves all the thumbs up after all those horrible takes.
I'm very happy to hear this. Let's all just be friends.
Both as former Japanese colonies, why is Taiwan more pro-Japan than Korea is?
As a Taiwanese with grandparents who have always been nostalgic for the Japanese era, I think there are two possible historical reasons:
1. Korea became a normal country whereas Taiwan came under the occupation of KMT-China (ROC).
This is a major one if you really look into the history. In Korea, the nation-building process was heavily based on an anti-Japan campaign. There was a strong reason (& justified) to hate Japan to unite the nation. Yet, Taiwan was not given the same right to self-determination. The succeeding Republic of China (ROC) treated the Taiwanese far worse when they first forced themselves onto Taiwan after 1945. For example, "Chinese exploit Formosa worse than Japs did" was the headline of the Washington Daily in 1946. The local Taiwanese was shocked by the significant drop of education level, government efficiency & living standard. There was also systemic discrimination, 228 massacre & White Terror to kill off the elites and silence the local Taiwanese populace. The common saying "The dogs leave and the pigs come" refers to this period of horror. Under 38 years of ROC martial-law control, that generation used nostalgia for the Japanese era as coping mechanism as they internalised this trauma. This nostalgia passed down and translated into a more pro-Japan sentiment in the later generations. Some might say it's Stockholm syndrome, but the older Taiwanese only had a far worse experience with the authoritarian KMT-ROC, not unlike the Japanese, brutally imposed their culture and language (Mandarin Chinese) on the local population.
2. Taiwan was indeed better off compared to other Japanese colonies. (but it doesn't make it right)
After annexing Okinawa in 1879, the addition of Taiwan to the Empire in 1895 was Japan's first major expansion. At the time, as a multiethnic society with various southern Sinophone settlers and a resilient Austronesian Indigenous population, Taiwan hadn't really formed a strong unifying culture or political identity. So Japan faced far less resistance in Taiwan than they did in Korea. Also, Japan was aspired to make Taiwan the 'model colony' to show the West that they can colonise too (and from the coloniser's point of view, colonise well). As a result, the Taiwanese were discriminated, but still treated much better compared to other colonial subjects in the Japanese empire, i.e. Korea. The older generation looks back to this period of stable time fondly as they enjoyed social security, job opportunities & access to education. Unfortunately, this difference in colonial experience can also make some Taiwanese blind to the atrocity Japan committed elsewhere in WW2.
Whether you Taiwanese like Japan or hate it, it's up to you Taiwanese. Taiwan's historical experience should be respected, isn't it Korea's historical experience? Should Koreans be 'guided' by Taiwanese? Some of the elderly in Korea and some of the conservative right-wing political forces say, 'I feel grateful to Chiang Kai-shek' to express 'kindness' according to their standards when they meet Taiwanese. If you're 'Taiwanese', you can get angry and tell them to correct thier mistakes. But,' Taiwansese' forcing Koreans to say 'Koreans should also like Japan'. This is nonsense!
wrong. Elderly people over the age of 80 who have experienced the Japanese era in South Korea are Japanophiles. South Korea's anti-Japanese was made after the war. When Japan lost the war, the aristocratic class, who had fled to Hong Kong, returned to South Korea and re-executed the government. They broke up with Japan and conducted thorough anti-Japanese education to complete the present South Korea. Therefore, 80% of Koreans in their teens and 20s still hate Japan. The education system has not changed, and even now, Japanese dramas and music cannot be broadcast on terrestrial television or radio in South Korea.
I’m a Korean and enjoyed reading tour comment. I was always curious of how the Taiwanese friends I met had such a good reflection on their colonial hostory and your view wa helpful to better understand the context. Geographical proximity and size of the country may have also been factors behind Colonial Korea and Japan’s tension.
@swn y 급발진 자제점..
@@swanshon 영상이랑 댓글 보고도 그 소리가 나오는 님이 더 궁금한데요 니네는 왜 일본 싫어하냐고 뜬금없이 훈계하는게 정상입니까?
I’m honestly amused that the Japanese are worried that Taiwan might be invaded out of good will
I'm Indonesian. I love Taiwan and Japan. Taiwan is wonderful country
Thanks, Indonesia is also a wonderful country.
1450 pay you🧐
@@dky7090 LOL
even though u don't know the real name of that wonderful country🤔
please call me Republic of China
"What's your impression of Japan in 2022?"
"Ramen" 😂
The Taiwanese often preserve or even use its colonial-time houses, statues or facilities like most notably the Presidential Office Building rather than smash or remove them. That like-minded attitude is interpreted very positively by the Japanese people. Of course, such can never be generalized to address the entire bilateral relations, but it's a good implication.
It was more out of practical necessity than a desire to preserve. The KMT destroyed a lot of Japanese landmarks and replaced them with ugly concrete. Taipei Main Station was one of them.
@@missplainjane3905 you're asking too many Qs. Overall I hold a moderate positive view for Japan (6-7 levels). For 4) I'd say, resilience and sensibility. The society is not divided or polarized, not yet while it hardly goes extreme or revolutionary.
@@BBarNavi Whatever effort or reason behind, I feel the preservation turns out to be rightful. I simply like and value Taipei's landscape with diverse cultural heritage.
@@missplainjane3905 My quick res is yes, though I'm not sure about what exactly constitutes a first world country. Japan is not "the" first nor "the" greatest, but belongs to the top tier group (say, the top 10-20% of all countries in the world in several key indices). I think it will continue to do so.
@@missplainjane3905 The Japanese do vary, so do their characteristics. Diversity is becoming a key idea in public and media discourses. Personally I don't care much about anti-Japanese critics. At least, in Japan they won't be poisoned or detained for "re-education" when they speak out :) You're of course welcome to come see things by yourself.
Really good one. The clever young lady at 6:01 gave the pure comments; thoughtful, insightful, natural, honest. Really good people on this one. Congrats. Also, lovely to see that Taiwan likes & respects Japan and vice-versa. This is so important. PEACE & LOVE 💚
Japan developed Taiwan and treated its people relatively leniently. They also invaded Taiwan only once in history. In Korea, they've invaded us multiple times and the general in charge of the Korean invasion was way more anti-korean than the general who invaded Taiwan was anti-Taiwanese.
Mashitta said: "We have to remember that the relationship between every country is based on their own need and seeking of their own benefits." Not quite true! The benefits must be equally mutual to guarantee a long-term relationship. History has shown that many countries, based on their own need and seeking their own benefits have plundered and invaded other countries in what we term colonialism and imperialism.
Where did u find these people …
I understand Asia boss tried to present the “ many different points of views”, but honestly if you interview Taiwanese people , I dare to say 8/10 of us are very positive about Japan. Not many people will ever stand aside China than Japan. So at least one of your question is very wrong.
I think you may have hand picked opinions that are not particularly friendly toward Japan , in many very friendly interviews. But I am very surprised it is presented as the video here as a Taiwanese.
If u check the video about interviewing Shanghai locals, the problem is the same, Asian Boss like to present 'different views', however the facts indicating some views actually only a few follow
Asian Boss is run by a Korean named Steven Park. Koreans hate Japan, so this channel almost never features positive content about Japan.
你以為西門町會找到真正臺灣民調嗎
History should be remembered forever, but hate can not solve all issues.
It’d be interesting to hear the opinions of other countries who were under the Japanese colonization. If Asian boss has already covered some, please lmk
I am from Myanmar. For most of us Japan is an inspiration. It was respectable how Japan grow from WWII. There were a lot of propaganda movies about how despicable and primal Japan was during the war but they never stick because the Japan nowadays is completely different from how it was portrayed in these movies. So, we only hate MAL Junta.
This is so informative for someone living in Europe...
I have had easier time understanding Korean stance, as the nazi or Russian rule in central and Eastern Europe was viewed similarly - even after WW2 and closing of the concentration camps there were still attempts at erasing patriotism, ethnic identities, free thinking etc. The German occupation until '45 did have a few economic good outcomes like better infrastructure, but the price for the people was high, so none would mention the good points. The Russian occupation had only downsides - people were oppressed and the economy ruined at the same time. This is still echoing in some people, as there's some grandparents left who were born in 30s and 40s, and our parents lived in the ZSSR-controlled state. I remember my grandma who was surprised my dad can be friendly with a German coworker to the point of visiting each others with families. So it is very interesting seeing even those older Tawainese to talk about that time with knowledge but no more than some skepticism in their attitude.
You don't have to compare them, cause all countries have different history, mentality, problems, backgrounds etc. It's seems like the same, but everything is quite different.
If you have a bad neighbor now, would you still dislike someone who hurt you before?
Taiwan Japan, way better than China.
Back then Taiwan became Japan’s territory, people received Japan-styled education. When it’s turned back to R.O.China, the administration was less functional and education was bad (which was also why the communists in mainland was seeking to establish better administration) so it didn’t remove people’s positive views towards Japan as “former Japanese citizens. ”
台湾人太天真了，哪个国家会对哪个国家真心好呢？ 都是利益关系，日本这个国家表面礼貌，但是对历史的认同很扭曲，竟然认为二战是荣誉，不思悔改，这很可怕，这也是为什么韩国人也讨厌日本人的原因吧。
UA-cam is illegal in your country wumao. Go back to Weibo or whatever app your people use
@ノｱｲｯ 那是令人欣慰的，两国人民都过好自己的生活，没有战争再发生。
@@user-mt4yb1tv2k
There’s the right wingers
there`s even a staute of japanese man yoichi hatta in taiwan to thank him for all the things he did in for taiwanese
I think one of the reasons that wasn't mentioned that explains why Taiwanese people generally have positive attitudes towards Japan, is because Taiwan was heavily oppressed by the Nationalist Party regime (Kuomintang/KMT) when Japanese colonialism ended in Taiwan. Compared to Japanese rule, the KMT was much more oppressive, with the 228 incident that led to decades of martial law, where tens of thousands were imprisoned, tortured, killed, etc. Of course Japan as a colonialist regime oppressed Taiwanese people (there are lots of records of the brutality against aboriginal folks in Taiwan, as an example), but I think the lasting legacy of Japanese colonialism in Taiwan was generally positive, both in terms of the improvements it introduced in education, infrastructure, farming, irrigation, etc., but also because of the "backwardness" of KMT soldiers and rule in comparison. When you are suddenly under a new regime that is much more oppressive, no matter how restrictive the previous regime was, in some sense it provides folks with a sense of positive retrospect.
Indeed. KMT is a lot worser than Japan.
japan is bad but KMT was worse.
Totally agree. It all comes down to relativity.
@@ta0304 REALLY? I doubt it.
Former colonial subjects loving their former colonial master. No surprises here. Result of a COLONIZED mind. Smirk..
Those 2 girls are so cute! Absolutely loved them, hope they’re doing well :>
They left Taiwan for Korea to become Kpop trainees...
@@MaximSupernov Incidentally, the shirt worn by the girl on the left belongs to a Japanese rock band named Macaroni Enpitsu.(マカロニえんぴつ)
@@S32033 Good to know👍👍👍
as a hker,i can say it's the same our attitude to UK🇬🇧
Many Taiwanese people I've met, are friendly to Japanese. Maybe, its Anime and Pop culture.
I have met some Taiwanese people saying that they rather have Taiwan come under either American or Japanese rule than Chinese one.
Even tho they themselves are Chinese
From a historical point of view in Taiwan today, the more fun Japan plays me, the more I like Japan。
Which is kinda sad when you think about it.
love japan
Help them once (donate when Japan 311 earthquake), they show their gratitude every year.
Help China countless of times (donated when earthquake/flood and etc), they send their military plane to threat Taiwan every month.
Japan is the hope of Asia.
Asian hope with US military base LOL.
Much better than a China military base like in Sri Lanka.
In fact, that military base protected the entire east Asia including Taiwan from being invaded by China, your motherland.
@@ECWM3322 FUN FACT: USA invaded more than 20 countries and threw tons of bombs over the world after WW2, and they just bombed Somalia, but in your mind, it's the PROTECTOR. China, didn't even fight any war since 1979, but you claim it is INVADER. Like the meme: 'A glass of water is going to rape me!'
BTW, the only oversea military base of China is in Djibouti, where also got bases of Russia, US, France, Japan etc. all of them are protecting Horn of Africa, that is what you call PROTECT. When you talking about the Sri Lanka, I can see obviously you no nothing about your imaginary enemy. Keep going on.😁
As a Japanese national who has lived and worked in Taiwan for a short 14 months, I really appreciate this particular AsianBoss video because it not only coincides with what I felt about Japan's true colours in the Taiwan-Japan relationship but also reassured me that at least the people featured in this interview were not playing lip service to Japan, their past oppressors/current allies. I hugely respect those who expressed negative or critical opinions about Japan, too; they were honest and straightforward, didn't exaggerate, and remained thoughtful and composed throughout the interview. I think they could have said more critical things about Japan that I probably would've agreed with, but I realize that wasn't the intent of AsianBoss. There was a good balance of Taiwanese perspectives from different people and different generations in relation to their experience with Japanese people. Some folks tended to speak more about the consumer side of things; others spoke more on nuanced subcultural aspects or had a more global view of the Taiwan-Japan ties. I think I'll watch it again later with my Taiwanese friends. We need to see more civilized discourse on important issues. And listening to the interviewees here gives me hope. Thank you, AsianBoss!
This video is garbage.
Omg, your English is too good to be a Japanese.
Just kidding XD
@@chrispeng8417 No, you’re right. Why is it offensive to say that? Since when is English synonymous of intelligence or education? Anyway Japanese national just means he/she has Japanese citizenship. You don’t know their background. Also, a minority of Japanese people decide to learn English to an advanced level, it can be for a variety of reasons. From what I could see, many of those who learn it “just as a hobby” tend to be weirdos who want to feel superior and/or use English for anti-social communication on the internet, but you can’t generalize.
I saw your playlists. You're not Japanese. There are too little Japanese contents and Japanese people do not watch videos of Japanese lessons.
@@mattiamele3015 It can be taken as offensive because he is implying Japanese being poor at English. It's joke but actually some people will still say it's a poor joke. Anyways, that's why it's offensive.
The island used to have been colonized for a long time even before the japanese colonization, they already used to being colonized by other countries and not much trouble with Japan. And the government were set up by the people from mainland who may not have much cared about the history or the suffer in the past...
...... you don't know us.
You don't understand our culture, workplace, family, or even LGBTculture
I'm working in japan for 3 years, and yea they had different treatment to taiwanese and korean, they got better treatment compare to chinese people.
Very good and interesting interview. I liked a lot the part when the man talked about his grandfather and father.
Ale je jeho názor.
that part is rediculous for me lol, what do u think
As a Taiwanese, I’m agree that the past is the past, we only remember the history for not making the same mistake, but we should not let hatred block our view..
well thats the thing, taiwanese-japanese history isnt just mistakes and genocide like with other asian countries. there is actually alot of good in there too, like the people in this video said.
是的。我們要向歷史學習以免重蹈覆轍。
Thanks!
🔥
I skimmed through the comments section. No one mentioned former President Lí Ting-hui, Mr. Democracy...
He achieved democracy without shedding blood and trained the leaders of the ruling and opposition parties. He is without a doubt Asia's greatest political leader.
Taiwan is a country
All north eastern states should have been independent and l believe they will be when the chicken neck is cut.
@@stevencher9968 bruh
@@stevencher9968Why don't you ask them if they consider themselves indians? You would be surprised when you find out the truth.
Well I have Japanese friends they said Taiwan is Japanese friendly country. Many Taiwanese can speak at least basic Japanese
Coming from someone living on the other side of the planet (Québec, Canada) this is extremely insightful. It's fascinating to try and understand other cultures and the relationship between them. I'm really enjoying this channel. I would be curious to know what Koreans, Japanese, and Taiwanese think of my country. Merci beaucoup for the great content.
This channel is a mere South Korean promotion.
Generally Taiwanese have good impressions about Canada.... many people immigrated there ...but if you're talking about Québec then I guess we don't know very much except it once tried to get independence from Canada, and the fact that people there speak French 😅 myself know that french spoken in Québec is said to be quite different from those in France, but I don't know french well enough to tell the difference
And compared to the United States, there is no problem with the proliferation of guns.
@@emeraldbreeze5204 ? I thought this channel was Chinese..
@@emeraldbreeze5204 왜냐면 다른영상보니깐 딱히 한국의 좋은점만 인터뷰 하는것도 아니여서요
Gosh, Taiwanese have so much patience and understanding, even allies don't help them, they say "we understand, it's your self interest after all, it's your rational decision". What a respecting nation! 👍
That's just because China is strong, which makes the Taiwanese give up the idea of resistance. The Taiwanese accepted the fact that other countries were unwilling to help.
Well i guess this is not about country but every one who can think logically know this is the truth
Well, Taiwanese women are usually pretty independent and progressive in thought compared to other countries in Asia.
@@MaximSupernov lol it seems like our impressions on Taiwan are totally different
@@ryanc.3997 Oh really? What is your impression then?
Japan and Taiwan, 2 favourite countries and leading democracies of asia.
Sorry as an Asian my favourite country is Korea , Singapore and Thailand.
leading democracy my foot. Japan ruled by same party for 70 years
很遺憾日本在亞洲沒有起到領導作用。
Democracy is flawed
It's no secret that most Taiwanese love Japan. You can't underestimate the power of Anime.
Taiwanese have enjoyed listening to kpop for over 30 years. But they hate and hate Korea and Koreans second only to the Chinese in the world. It is more reasonable to view it as a historical and political reason.
Taiwan education had changed a lot from what I heard from the younger generation.
I love both countries. Taiwan and Japan have the same vibe, They're like one country.
Yes, Taiwan should incorporate into Japan
@@honkhonk6359 bring your US soldiers to help us, plss
Japan will cease to exist with the rise of China. So will Taiwan as an autonomous region. So they will both cease to exist in fact.
@@nitaseely6830 haha message Biden.
@@nitaseely6830 no Taiwan needs to reunify into china, your original daddy.
US dropped two nuclear bombs in Japan and now Japan is one of US's Strongest allies. So the pro-Japan vibe is not a difficult thing to imagine. We Asians are short-sighted.
Japan and South Korea are always badly conflicting, but Japan and Taiwan are always friendly countries.
People don't know this fact.
Everyone knows that and based on totally different history background. Taiwan didn't have identity and strong history and they must have very appropriate what japanese troops set up the infrastructure while korea having strong identity and history and culture, japanese troops were invaders and harsh attacters.
@@sarang757 South Korean history education is full of anti-Japanese lies. South Korea has been developed with Japan's economic assistance. South Koreans do not know this fact.
@@sarang757 You never know a true history.
@@azurecliff8709 I know and you know as well. You don't want to accept it because you know what you japan had done to korea. Dehumanising and abusing sexually and physically. You know it. You try to cover up to hide and dig it up to find what korea had done wrong but you know it. And the discrimination does keep carrying on your country.
Propaganda cause this.
Sun Yat-sen is also famous in Japan. He studied politics in Tokyo.
Cambodia and Laos is under Vietnam rules since the late 1970's. Pls also cover this same topic for that region.
Girl who said the past is the past just move to peace is the smartest person in the whole video .
5:52 Wow, I'm really impressed that she knows so much. She must either major in history or is much older than she looks.
yea, among all these interviewees, she really understands what the interviewer ask.
I'm even more surprise that the women in Taiwan knew about all of that when women around me are usually apolitical. There's so many things they get caught up to and politics are definitely the last thing they would care.
Imagine myself been interviewed, I'm not sure if I can answer these questions in such an organised speech with a clear perception of history.
@@knock-knockwhosthere9933 That's the difference between 西門町 & 台大
@@knock-knockwhosthere9933 Taiwan is one of the highest ranked country in gender equality with 42% of legislators being a woman. Taiwan president is also a woman and before her there was already a woman VP. That said, there are plenty of women, and men, who don't care about politics especially with Taiwan politics since we all know there is not much we can do.
"Boring" LOL I just learned a new Taiwanese Chinese word.
wonderful cultures love visiting.
Love that one lady's reaction to Japan. The first thing that came to mind was ramen lmao!...🤣
Actually, back in the day, the Japanese used Taiwan as a laboratory to experiment many ideas on engineering, infrastructure, social policies, that would later be adopt in Japan. As the long-haired girl said in the video, Korea was a military base while Taiwan was an outpost. One of the reasons why the Taiwanese are generally fond of their Japanese heritage.
did you say heritage?? wow
Not really.. the anti Japanese sentiment was big thing in Taiwan as much as in Korea right after Wwii and during the occupation.
The reason why Korean people(Im korean) dont like Japan is basiclly their insane nationalism.During the dictatorship in Korea,Korean president tried to make Korean people nationalist by teaching biased history and had to worship the country,while taiwan was just doing good with Japan
"Japanese heritage" This alone makes sense and simply answers all the questions.
They are proud of their genocidal ancestors you mean?
@@jctai100 i think it's more like culture, there are alot of japanese loan-words in taiwan mandarin like kanban and ringo or ichiban..also the taiwanese hotels are very similar to the japanese ryokan with tatami mats.
2 things:
1. getting a job > losing 3 family
2. That japanese considerd me a weirdo bc he mistaken me for chinese.
the interviewer made a mistake when she said "reunite", i think she meant to "unite" because you cant reunite if you were never united in the first place. taiwan has always been taiwan and china has always been china.