Patreon: patreon.com/newhistoryspain Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/newhistoryspain REFERENCES: Baydal, Vicent, and Cristian Palomo Reina. Pseudohistòria contra Catalunya: De l’espanyolisme a la Nova Història. Eumo Editorial, 2020. Palomo Reina, Cristian. “Noves perspectives per a una qüestió no resolta: Per qué Catalunya fou un principat i no un regne?” Anuario de estudios medievales 50.1 (2020): 323-352. Palomo Reina, Cristian. Identitat i vocabulari polítics a Catalunya durant la guerra de successió. 2018. Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, dissertation.
@@newhistoryspain I am very impressed by the story of Berenguela. So much smarter than her grandmother, yet so much less know. Before, we visited in 2021, my daughter and I watch a good UA-cam series that ran from her to the rise of Trastamara. We went many places but I made a point of going to the Cathedrals in Murcia and in Seville where respectively two parts of Alfonso X are interred.
Soy Valenciano y como esta comunidad antiguo Reino de Valencia dentro de la Corona de Aragon a secas de hecho en la acta de union con el Condado de Barcelona se especifico que apareciera primero y digamos como nombre del reino como Corona de Aragon como sabras mi region fue su " padre fundador" el gran Jaime l de Aragon " El Conquistador" saludos
He has a series o podcasts called “the history of Spain” which goes over the entire history in-depth with numerous episodes that probably average over 40mins in length
They do speak the same language yeah, although in the Valencian region for instance the use of the language has substantially declined. They just developed different identities as they didn't belong to the same political entity (the Crown of Aragon is just how we refer to all the possessions under the same monarch, but they barely shared common institutions, unlike the Crown of Castile). So you could argue it is the same as an American and British not considering themselves the same even though they speak the same language.
@@newhistoryspain In the western part of the autonomous community (CA) of Catalunya it's mostly spoken the same dialect as the CA of València. The north-western dialect is like tortosian valencian spoken until near Castelló de la Plana. Nothing changes when you cross the Sènia river but the Spanish province and the CA.
All Valencians I know are socially and politically fed up with Catalonia. They want nothing to do with the idea of "the Catalan Countries" that here in catalonia I hear about so much. As an outsider, it's funny to watch.
Yes! This kind of principality is similar to a republic but with hereditary prince or count. The sovereign had to swear the laws in order to access the position. If not he didn't became count of Barcelona.
Patreon: patreon.com/newhistoryspain
Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/newhistoryspain
REFERENCES:
Baydal, Vicent, and Cristian Palomo Reina. Pseudohistòria contra Catalunya: De l’espanyolisme a la Nova Història. Eumo Editorial, 2020.
Palomo Reina, Cristian. “Noves perspectives per a una qüestió no resolta: Per qué Catalunya fou un principat i no un regne?” Anuario de estudios medievales 50.1 (2020): 323-352.
Palomo Reina, Cristian. Identitat i vocabulari polítics a Catalunya durant la guerra de successió. 2018. Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, dissertation.
I love Spain and you bring really unique information. I hope your channel grows.
Thank you Robert!
@@newhistoryspain I am very impressed by the story of Berenguela. So much smarter than her grandmother, yet so much less know. Before, we visited in 2021, my daughter and I watch a good UA-cam series that ran from her to the rise of Trastamara. We went many places but I made a point of going to the Cathedrals in Murcia and in Seville where respectively two parts of Alfonso X are interred.
He has been doing UA-cam videos for years and has other channels.
Soy Valenciano y como esta comunidad antiguo Reino de Valencia dentro de la Corona de Aragon a secas de hecho en la acta de union con el Condado de Barcelona se especifico que apareciera primero y digamos como nombre del reino como Corona de Aragon como sabras mi region fue su " padre fundador" el gran Jaime l de Aragon " El Conquistador" saludos
Very nice. I would like to hear more about the politics of the 1650s to 1720. Thank you.
He has a series o podcasts called “the history of Spain” which goes over the entire history in-depth with numerous episodes that probably average over 40mins in length
I've often wondered why the Valencians or Baleares don't consider themselves to be Catalonians. They speak the same language, no?
They do speak the same language yeah, although in the Valencian region for instance the use of the language has substantially declined. They just developed different identities as they didn't belong to the same political entity (the Crown of Aragon is just how we refer to all the possessions under the same monarch, but they barely shared common institutions, unlike the Crown of Castile). So you could argue it is the same as an American and British not considering themselves the same even though they speak the same language.
@@newhistoryspain Gracias 🙂
@@newhistoryspain In the western part of the autonomous community (CA) of Catalunya it's mostly spoken the same dialect as the CA of València.
The north-western dialect is like tortosian valencian spoken until near Castelló de la Plana. Nothing changes when you cross the Sènia river but the Spanish province and the CA.
Very simple, they speak similar languages, but are not catalán, same as Nigerians are not British and they speak english.
All Valencians I know are socially and politically fed up with Catalonia. They want nothing to do with the idea of "the Catalan Countries" that here in catalonia I hear about so much. As an outsider, it's funny to watch.
ok cool video
very well explained. very informative. good use of examples too. thank you.
I recommend you to check other videos in the channel, like the story of an influential Spaniard in the Kingdom of Hawaii 😊
Yes! This kind of principality is similar to a republic but with hereditary prince or count. The sovereign had to swear the laws in order to access the position. If not he didn't became count of Barcelona.