Don't get intimidated by these khawarij who abuse Sahaba Who do muta Who abuse our mother Ayesha RA In shia lying is part of Deen Don't consider them to be Muslim at all. Rest Allah SWT knows best.
I found it strange that a religion that promise sex with 72 plump breasted virgins in Jennat is less dirty than the music of Mozart, Beethoven or JS Bach and so Haram. what kind of religion is that?
Very beautiful explanation. It is very important to understand what the package of music brings with it in your particular setup. I am from Bangladesh and as a Bengali much of my childhood and present life is intertwined with the Tagore Songs. Although he was not a Muslim, but most of his songs brought me so close to Allah that nothing else ever did in my life. His songs kept me close to Allah in the darkest periods of my life. It will be completely ungrateful for me to say that songs like those can be haram. For example, I mention lyrics from some of his well-known songs - Sample 1 - (Why we should not fear death when we are just returning to Allah) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- If today, in the empty room, on this moonlit night, You come with empty hands-- Why should I fear! I know, my friend, I know-- You have Your divine touch. The days have passed while searching and striving, Now the time has come to surrender myself to Your embrace. Darkness lurks in every corner, the sky veiled in blindness, Your divine presence resides in my heart. In the ebb and flow of life, I lost myself, Now life and death will encompass me, guided by Your divine hand. Sample 2- (This song implies how everything we do is a manifestation of divine power) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Within my being, in the depths of my heart, Your voice brings me liberation. The eternal celebration, the illuminating lamp of Your universe, I am but a clay lamp of Yours, igniting Your flame. Endlessly radiant, guided by Your desire. Just as in Your spring, songs are written, In every hue, on every petal, in every forest, in every direction, In the center of my soul, grant me a breath, a complete offering, Filling emptiness with Your blessings, let me rejoice in melody. Let obstacles turn into virtues, with Your skillful hand. Sample 3 - --------------- When life withers away, Come, O Compassionate One. When all sweetness hides, Come, in the nectar of song. When actions take a forceful form, Roaring and swirling in every direction, O Lord of Life, in the depths of my heart, Come, with tranquil footsteps. In your presence, I become humble, Lost in a corner, a soul without shelter, Opening the doors, O Generous Lord, Come, ascending the throne. When desires scatter in abundant dust, Blinding and wandering in ignorance, O Holy One, O Sleepless One, Come, in the light of Rudra.
But sunni scholars in sàudi Arabia wòuld call u a kafir .they don't even consider you a Muslim since you are bangladeshi Muslim who listens to a non Muslims songs. I know tagore he is a good person. But our scholars are people with frowns who don't smile. Why are we even part of this sect have you ever questioned .... Have you ever had the gits to question the stupidity of some Sunni scholars.
do you even know what shia's are? even if they are talented, they curse aisha, uthman, abu bar, (RA) and prophet said only one sect will go to paradise, that is those who hold to his sunna, thats why we are sunni, you are out of your mind, or either you are a shia being fake
When I hear the word "music" I imagine the amazing works of Vivaldi, Bach, Beatoven, Mozart, Chopin etc, which whenever I've heard them gives me what feels like divine inspiration as I imagine they also were created through divine inspiration. Why no comment on these exquisite classical works of art?
He actually mentions towards the end that there are some forms of music that do promote Godliness and positivity. The music of Bach & Mozart falls into this category.
@@AC-mp7cx ah As i said some shia scholars have certain rule for certain things, if you are shia need to check your scholars if not then I can't judge for following 4 dead scholars of your own mathabs
Thank you for this. As a convert from a very musically inclined family this is a question I have always struggled with. When I hear the whole "music is haram" thing it gets me on edge a bit. However, I'm always relieved to discover that it's only certain types of music that are prohibited. Most of what I already listen to and enjoy, even before I was a Muslim, does not really seem to fit under the category of being the type of music that would be played in a nightclub or pub.
I love, that you find relief. Be careful of these ,,this is haram" people. You have to spend years / half your life to understand / teach Quran and hadith. People nowadays want to be a teaching imam / mufti without spending their life on knowledge, because of their lazyness or others things. I know an ayat, that I can´t interpret because of my lack of knowledge, but I still wanna mention it, it says (as I kind of remember): ,,Don´t say, that things are haram or halal". Something like that. I dont know quran interpretation, but it seems, that its haram to say, that something is haram (kind of) haha. I also heard (maybe from a hadith): ,,He who speaks without knowledge is considered a liar". Very terrifying, but logical. Hope I helped. Allah bless you and your family to the best degree possible ^^
@@mohammad-bin-dajjalYou might be trying to get someone mad or something but that won’t work, you should simply now that I wish the best for you inshallah as a true Muslim I want you to go to heaven, therefore I hope that you simply open the Quran and read about ahadeeth and learn more about this topic, and in the end it’s your choice it’s your life and it won’t affect me
Same here!! I really only listen to classical music or choral music. I was a music major in my first degree and can’t imagine how instrumental music with no words could be haram. I am reverting right now and have found that classical music often leads me to thinking of the beauty of the world that Allah SWT created. Insha’Allah I will live according to the teachings of Islam and be faithful in my life and heart. ❤🤲🏻
Coz u like to listen to music that is why it makes sense to you Fact is music is Haram and that is how it has been always but todays world new halaal/haraam things are coming to misguide people be careful my brother May Allah guide us all🤲🏽
@@_-JB Islam is a beautiful religion, unfortunately Muslims are among some of the most ignorant on our planet. No facts, no sources, no logic, just emotion. haha
Of all the Ulama opinions on music I've listened to, this is the most fact based, rational, comprehensive presentation of this contentious subject and for me is the most reasonable and acceptable.
@@raypardillo6788 so the prohibitions in Islam became subjective huh wow. Out of all scholars, dozens of sahih hadiths. A learned Muslim anywhere from the west to the east of earth accepts music as haram expect for people who listen to their desires. Countless evidences and you choose your nafs.
@@momskitchen4014 salam first of all firstly i did say that i agree with my shiq fellows in lot of things...and i think the sunni islam has been unjust and quite tough and rough towards shia muslims due to many political and religious reasons obviously.. Which i condemn also it was from both sides in the history. But i would also say that i disagree with many things is shia islam as well just like in sunni islam....so yeah thanks for your comment but i am good thanks
Assalam o alaykum, With my little knowledge of music, I believe it can be broken down into 2 parts 1) Music - From instruments 2) Song - Lyrics To be fair and just to any topic, we should gather all Ayat and Hadees connected to it. There are famous Hadith which bans all musical instruments except one sided drum. I agree with the scholar that if a song does not have any Shirk, immodest, vain lyrics, it is fine and could be treated as another form of poetry. But we should also consider the aspect of musical instruments in it. I am not Alim but the scholar should not have left out this critical part. At the end of the day, We should try to find the correct answer rather than prove our opinion correct. May Allah protect and guide us all to the right path.
Very important to provide a proper context for this kind of discussion. This should include the fact that for the most part, music and the art of practising musicianship and song is by no means damaging nor does it entail adverse behaviours. That particular criticism may be relevant to a very small minority of cases only. Please provide a balanced discussion on such topics, including inviting people with diverse views and direct experience of the topic. That will be much more helpful.
There is music that drains you and music that empowers you. There is literally instrumental music that brings you closer to the Creator and inspires the will to righteousness, as well asmusic that brings you closer to hedonism and to shirk. It is not music itself, but the genre and type you choose to listen to. To put all sound waves, hence music, per se, in one basket, is like banning all liquids> coffee, alcohol, juices... they're all liquid but they're not all bad. Critical thinking is necessary in matters like these, as the quran often commands us. May Allah guide us all.
I believe it depends on the context. If the song is all about shaking big booties, consuming drugs, and driving expensive cars, it's obviously haram. But if it's about Allah or praising Allah, that would be halal.
If it has music in it It's completely haram irrespective of anything If it's vocal for Allah and for Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) it's allowed. No music in any way is allowed.
The companions unanimously agreed upon the prohibition of music and song but allowed particular exceptions specified by the authentic sunnah. many authentic narrations (aathaar) traced to the various sahaabah bear witness to this. Also, the four Khalifas, the fuqahaa among the saahabah such as Ibin Abaas, Ibin Umar, and Jaabir bin Abdullah as well as the general body of saahabah (may Allah be pleased with them all). Tafsir al-Qurtubi, Vol. 14, pp. 51-52
As Salaam Alakium. It is unbelievable that many refuse to stop conflating music with songs....... Music alone detracts only if the listener allows. Music WITH LYRICS applied can take one from the path of Allah. There is a difference, clear and simple. And until this distinction is presented at every opportunity, this unclear, confused and distorted article of faith regarding listening to music within the deen will ALWAYS be a source of and for contention. Songs minus music instruments is acapella speech and can be questioned depending on content. Music minus lyrics is sound vibrations, not a soul-stealing entity. Allah's word in the Quran says nothing of music being harasm. Allah desires ease for us. So apply common sense when it comes to the topic of music and songs. Stop focusing on the instrument because on its own, that intangible object is powerless (unless we give it power). Music containing lyrics which are songs can be held for critique and/or outright dismissal. May Allah guide us all to the path of righteousness and common sense approaches. As Salaam Alakium.
One of issues nowadays which has become an area of confusion is music being played on religious videos & tv channels, nasheeds, latmiya etc If we take what culture that music is played in or if it is played at haram gatherings it isn’t always clear it can become subjective. Especially where it is full blown music which is becoming common. I am not talking about a mild background we have full blown music even in Islamic kids programming. Do I want my children growing up with a taste of music being told well it isn’t played in haram gatherings. Will they always draw the right line when older even adults are confused? I don’t think we get the hard questions answered clearly it is left to subjective opinion. I see my kids bopping to kiddie music but can be said the programme educational. Will kiddie music be taken as bad culture or haram gathering? Probably not as it isn’t the music played in pubs & clubs etc. But kiddie can grow to like it show a preference to that over programs without
It depends completely on what the music and song contain If it something godly then it is ok but if it isn't then not It just happens that many music promote ungodly things but not all of them Some music is simple music Some music represent cultures Some music teach kids alot Some songs are about love and about good things And some are obviously about bad things So yeah.
@@Shia.Ahlulbayt Yoo am not such clearer in this video being said by that shia scholar. I just wanna ask if using light music in the background with an informational video is allowed or not?
Jzk Allah May Almighty Allah protect and bless all of people like you my dear shia brothers and sisters From your brother of sunni origin in the island of mauritius in the Indian ocean
Yes. Ayatollah khamenei and sistani say only the music suitable for gatherings of sin(alcohol and adultery) and other immoral music is impermissible. Others aren't
@@asleepandhappy what if the ones that aren’t used in those Haram gatherings but maybe have instruments like guitar and piano involved? Like I want to make travel scenery montages so need to add some sounds but worried I might end up causing sin
@@ufatemav4509 any instrumental music is haram, whether it has a guitar or a piano. It takes you away from Allah and also destroys your soul. I would suggest you to download "The status of Music In Islam" shekih saleem bhimji
I've never understood when people have told me music as a whole is haram. It always depends on context. There are a lot of songs of worship, spirituality, love, and the human experience in general from people who are honest but just love to make music. Not to mention the recitation of the Quran even has musical qualities to it, if it didn't have those musical qualities it would sound like spoken word, and never recited the way it always is. Everything about this world has a rhythm, the way a heart beats the way we walk, talk, laugh, the way birds sing, the way music effects how plants grow, or how water freezes. This is all a part of the creation. The only real explanation I can see for music being haram is in the form of idol worship (when people pretty much worship famous musicians) or in the context the Sayed mentioned which is music that takes you away from righteous behavior/consciousness.
not scholar who said it.. it was Abdulla Ibn Mas ood who said that" lahwal hadith" is music. A companion of the Prophet Muhammad S.A.W.. what ends the conversation is that, if we can prove that this is really not the statement of Ibn Mas 'ood.. otherwise as a muslim we have no other choice but to believ that music is haram.. we hear and we obey
I can't resist kishor Kumar voice, the old songs from india are soo beautifully made. I don't feel guilty of listening to such but i feel bad or guilty by listening to bad music/song
@@iramanhaiderzaidi6913 What are you talking, numbers matters, allah subhanawatala guides the majority. Its the fringe elements, misguided, rejectors of truth are a downgraded minority. Even during the period of our beloved prophet (s) munafiq (hypocrites) were in minority
It depends completely on what the music and song contain If it something godly then it is ok but if it isn't then not It just happens that many music promote ungodly things but not all of them Some music is simple music Some music represent cultures Some music teach kids alot Some songs are about love and about good things And some are obviously about bad things So yeah.
My Question is: Is it haram? I work as a Video Editor of a famous Indian Actor for his UA-cam Channel (Mostly: Travel Vlogs, inspirational Podcasts, Food Reels, Food Vlogs. To make the video engaging I do use Music as I instructed by team head)
Simply applies to people who go around cracking jokes for people to laugh, people who gather people to make mockery of others........... Mockery, jokes, Nick naming, club for jokes.......This wat I feel should be vain talk
All the imams that say music is Haram should really educate theirselves about music.... This is ridiculous. When Holy Quran came there were nor instruments or music as it is developed today. So all the hadith and the interpretations of ancient Imams are not really pointing to music that can lead you to Allah.... I see also people saying you can not call music that leads you to Allah music but Nasheed... Well my friends as a musician for 15 years I can tell you thats really a lie... And you should not lie to yourself.... To say music is haram is denying the laws of creation. I can even tell you a kind of music makes you feel sexual harassed... if you are truely muslim and you intend to use it in a halal way you can use this for medical purposes... You should not generalize all the terms for every case.... Please go listen to music it will make you a better person. As a muslim and professional musician and composer I really feel attacked by people who say music is haram... Will I go to hell? And if so who are you to judge that... Allah knows the best... If for you music is only about bellydancing and pathway to zina... I think your brains are poisoned and you should really ask yourself why am I thinking like this. There are even imams that say musicians have satanic rituals... I mean come on.... A fa la tefekkeroen.... A fa la tezekkeroen... Ya selaam... Ya selaam.
I have a question!!! Assalam u Alaikum! is music without any lyrics, like meditation music with a little bit instruments, halal or haram? like i use in my educational videos. JazakAllah!
I am a Sunni..............but that does not mean ALL of SUNNI HADITH are UNCORRUPTED ! You just need ONE ORIGINAL person to interpret the Quran or the actual sayings or INTENTIONS of Muhammad slightly different and everyone one of his students will FOLLOW through just like the BRANCH of a TREE........... If Music is 100% Haram in both the Quran or hadith, I have no problem with that........... But I am also terribly afraid of making something that is NEVER HARAM in first place into something that is 100% Haram ! This too is STRICTLY FORBIDDEN in Islam ! YES ! We need the hadith to know how to pray, However, we STILL need to decide for ourselves the TECHNIQUES of pray that are the most common from those HADITH too ! But the FACT is................EVERYONE agrees that it is HARAM not to pray, and it is even the command by Allah to pray too INSIDE the Quran ! Quran actually NEVER precisely STATE about the term MUSIC or at least it NEVER STATES a CLEAR sentence FORBIDDING Muslims to play ANY musical Instrument or WHAT TYPE of Instruments ! THERE IS however a clear HADITH that say that : Abu Bakar shouted at his daughter Aisha for listening to some girls playing Musical instruments and singing praising songs of Islam during the EID. He shouted at Aisha to stop listening because those DUFFS that the girls were playing are tools of the DEVIL. Prophet Muhammad who was just beside them told Abu Bakar that it was ok.............since it is the Muslim festival EID too by the way ! If something is TRULY FORBIDDEN and TOOL of the DEVIL, why then did prophet Muhammad NOT warn his wife Aisha immediately about this in the FIRST PLACE ? According to some HADITH, some very early scholars CLAIMED and SWORE that the term IDLE TALK in the Quran was in fact MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS that was forbidden in the Quran. BUT THIS IS THE MODERN ERA.............and MODERN MUSLIMS can have ACCESS to ALL HADITHS in the BLINK of an EYE too............. Very early SCHOLARS totally DID not have this kind of ADVANTAGE about all the SAYINGS of prophet Muhammad ! So in a way, we MODERN Muslims of today are probably EVEN more KNOWLEDGABLE than those very early scholars of HADITH. This is of course FACT ! But unfortunately, most of the traditional ULAMA of today never use BRAIN or LOGIC. =========== However, I will still try my best not to listen to music though because I PREFER to PLAY IT SAFE !
If the lady and the Syed are not mahram then I believe the best thing to do is to lower down their gazes or find a brother to replace her. It would be the best.
Salam alaykom Just a thought to chew on: I am only a student, but my assumption is that a scholar such as the Sayed himself would've taken these thoughts into account before agreeing to sit for these interviews. My conclusion (could be different from the Sayed's) is that the nature of their interaction in this video is of a professional and educational nature; thus not necessitating a replacement for the sister. We mustn't underestimate the discernment of our scholars. Allahu Alam Kind regards.
@@michaelgibbons4622 Salaam, Maybe the Syed or the sister didn't even look at each other, they could be looking abit to the side ( that's what I do while watching vids online) . When someone lowers their gazes for the sake of ALLAH, ALLAH increases his/her Taqwa and his sense of hayya keeps on increasing . Ask the people of Taqwa what is the Best thing to do not just what is permissible to do . May ALLAH increases you in taqwa for your good akhlaaq . WalaikumAsalaam
@@mrlion9404 you do realize it's on the way of your gaze lowering your gaze doesn't mean do not look means do not look lustfully. Secondly what about when non Marham would ask questions to the prophet wormen would come to the prophet to ask him .
Can someone please explain. So music/ songs that don't have any bad words in it and have good meanings is halal? So for example the song "Dandelions" is about a loved one and it doesnt have bad words. Does that make it halal.
a lot of talking and discussion but still, he didn't give a particular answer... what i got is that listing to motivational and good songs are ok and have no problem
you want 1 direct answer ok here it is, music/song is NOT haram, if its good positively used it is HARAM if used for bad negative purpose and bad lyrics. hope thats simple clean and clear.
Salam Brother, What allows us to suggest the two hadith one saying bait al-ghena, and the other saying "where instruments are held" are the same hadith? Also what about the ahadith where specific music instruments are named and condemned?
Reminds me of Hadith --- From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection." Sahih Bukhari 7:69:494v
Well said brother Jawad. No need more explanation than this. Music is Haram and will remain Haram. Don't be shy to say and accept it. Leave that for the disbelievers
Music is consist of two elements . Lyrics and instrument . If instrument is haram thn without instrument you cant have music . If lyrics are haram by saying something that is vain talk like talking about love of being more beautiful than God . (Naizubillah ) is also haram . Tell me by logic how is it halal ?
The Prophet (S.A.W) only let women use daf in weddings, not mixed with men Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): “[Allah said to Iblis:] And befool them gradually those whom you can among them with your voice (i.e. songs, music, and any other call for Allah's disobedience)…” [al-Isra 17:64] “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allah…” [Luqman 31:6] The scholar of the ummah, Ibn 'Abbas (may Allah be pleased with him) said: this means singing . Mujahid (may Allah have mercy on him) said: this means playing the drum (tabl). (Tafsir al-Tabari, 21/40) Al-Hasan al-Basri (may Allah have mercy on him) said: this ayah was revealed concerning singing and musical instruments (lit. woodwind instruments). (Tafsir Ibn Kathir, 3/451) there is also a lot more.
Assalam o alaykum, With my little knowledge of music, I believe it can be broken down into 2 parts 1) Music - From instruments 2) Song - Lyrics To be fair and just to any topic, we should gather all Ayat and Hadees connected to it. There are Hadith which bans all musical instruments except one sided drum. I agree with the scholar that if a song does not have any Shirk, immodest, vain lyrics, it is fine and could be treated as another form of poetry. But we should also consider the aspect of musical instruments in it. I am not Alim but the scholar should not have left out this critical part. At the end of the day, We should try to find the correct answer rather than prove our opinion correct. May Allah protect and guide us all to the right path.
Music is music. Like, if someone gives you a piece of bullshit, he arranged it with great aroma, covered by cake and it tastes great, would you eat that thing? You'll say bullshit is bullshit, whatever you put in it it's still harmful for me. Just like that, however music is presented, it's music, instruments. So it's haram. I also thought that musics of Maher Zain, Sami Yusuf etc are ok to listen. At least those are positive and islamic. But then I realized these "islamic musics" are just pulling me away from Allah. I hope you understand.
How can you say that words of Allah the Quran are vague. Wow guys pay attention if you want to do bad you will always find someone that will justify it. It is on every individual to decide, this does not abstain you from the sin. May God string us all dow with the truth.
Asalaam u Alaikum! Syed I have listened to your lecture and What I have taken from it is that any music that would deviate you from the Almighty or ethical norms is Haraam other wise it is Halal. This is what I've taken from it , this does not mean this is what you intended. The thing that has been bothering me is that every Marja and other school of thought unanimously believe that manufacturing and Selling of any musical Instrument is haraam. Right. If even manufacturing is haraam then how come the state after manufacturing i.e playing them becomes halal regardless of the intention. This is a genuine Query I really hope you would not take this as a challenge to your understanding. I just want to live according to the teachings of Holy Prophet p.b.u.h and his Ahlebayt a.s, and just don't want to go against any of their commands, when they are explicitly stated to refrain from the Musical Instrument.
What about cussing in every video movies clips and everything in west now days to the point that young generation have got so used to it they think it normal and not bad. Anymore can you please make a speech specially about this matter thank you.
I am also sunni, but I have found Syed Jawad Ahmad so logical in his discussions. Thank you so much ❤
brother lets refer to ourselves as ahl as-sunnah wa l-jamāʻah
bro we are muslim the prophet never said we are sunni the sunna was the teaching of the prophet and Allah teached to the prophet to tell us
Don't get intimidated by these khawarij who abuse Sahaba
Who do muta
Who abuse our mother Ayesha RA
In shia lying is part of Deen
Don't consider them to be Muslim at all.
Rest Allah SWT knows best.
I found it strange that a religion that promise sex with 72 plump breasted virgins in Jennat is less dirty than the music of Mozart, Beethoven or JS Bach and so Haram. what kind of religion is that?
Very beautiful explanation. It is very important to understand what the package of music brings with it in your particular setup. I am from Bangladesh and as a Bengali much of my childhood and present life is intertwined with the Tagore Songs. Although he was not a Muslim, but most of his songs brought me so close to Allah that nothing else ever did in my life. His songs kept me close to Allah in the darkest periods of my life. It will be completely ungrateful for me to say that songs like those can be haram. For example, I mention lyrics from some of his well-known songs -
Sample 1 - (Why we should not fear death when we are just returning to Allah)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If today, in the empty room, on this moonlit night,
You come with empty hands--
Why should I fear!
I know, my friend, I know--
You have Your divine touch.
The days have passed while searching and striving,
Now the time has come to surrender myself to Your embrace.
Darkness lurks in every corner, the sky veiled in blindness,
Your divine presence resides in my heart.
In the ebb and flow of life, I lost myself,
Now life and death will encompass me, guided by Your divine hand.
Sample 2- (This song implies how everything we do is a manifestation of divine power)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Within my being, in the depths of my heart, Your voice brings me liberation.
The eternal celebration, the illuminating lamp of Your universe,
I am but a clay lamp of Yours, igniting Your flame.
Endlessly radiant, guided by Your desire.
Just as in Your spring, songs are written,
In every hue, on every petal, in every forest, in every direction,
In the center of my soul, grant me a breath, a complete offering,
Filling emptiness with Your blessings, let me rejoice in melody.
Let obstacles turn into virtues, with Your skillful hand.
Sample 3 -
---------------
When life withers away,
Come, O Compassionate One.
When all sweetness hides,
Come, in the nectar of song.
When actions take a forceful form,
Roaring and swirling in every direction,
O Lord of Life, in the depths of my heart,
Come, with tranquil footsteps.
In your presence, I become humble,
Lost in a corner, a soul without shelter,
Opening the doors, O Generous Lord,
Come, ascending the throne.
When desires scatter in abundant dust,
Blinding and wandering in ignorance,
O Holy One, O Sleepless One,
Come, in the light of Rudra.
But sunni scholars in sàudi Arabia wòuld call u a kafir .they don't even consider you a Muslim since you are bangladeshi Muslim who listens to a non Muslims songs.
I know tagore he is a good person. But our scholars are people with frowns who don't smile.
Why are we even part of this sect have you ever questioned
....
Have you ever had the gits to question the stupidity of some Sunni scholars.
Al Hamdulillah
i am a Muslim i Love listening to Sheikh Qazwini ❤
I am a Sunni but I love this Shia brother because of his valent discussion May he live long
bruh
Amin
@@AC-mp7cx 😂😂
do you even know what shia's are? even if they are talented, they curse aisha, uthman, abu bar, (RA) and prophet said only one sect will go to paradise, that is those who hold to his sunna, thats why we are sunni, you are out of your mind, or either you are a shia being fake
Why does the sister flaunt her face like a westerner, 47 thousand views, 10s of thousands of men are looking at her face, such a farce
What an intellectual talk!
Just loved it.
Every muslim adults needs to listen this.
When I hear the word "music" I imagine the amazing works of Vivaldi, Bach, Beatoven, Mozart, Chopin etc, which whenever I've heard them gives me what feels like divine inspiration as I imagine they also were created through divine inspiration. Why no comment on these exquisite classical works of art?
He actually mentions towards the end that there are some forms of music that do promote Godliness and positivity. The music of Bach & Mozart falls into this category.
@@LoyalMinion it depends on the scholar you follow for shia follower
some scholar has given permission for classical music and some not
exquisite in who's opinion? Lol
@@AC-mp7cx ah As i said some shia scholars have certain rule for certain things, if you are shia need to check your scholars if not then I can't judge for following 4 dead scholars of your own mathabs
@@iphone-xf9xk dead scholars.......?
Thank you for this. As a convert from a very musically inclined family this is a question I have always struggled with. When I hear the whole "music is haram" thing it gets me on edge a bit. However, I'm always relieved to discover that it's only certain types of music that are prohibited. Most of what I already listen to and enjoy, even before I was a Muslim, does not really seem to fit under the category of being the type of music that would be played in a nightclub or pub.
I love, that you find relief. Be careful of these ,,this is haram" people. You have to spend years / half your life to understand / teach Quran and hadith. People nowadays want to be a teaching imam / mufti without spending their life on knowledge, because of their lazyness or others things. I know an ayat, that I can´t interpret because of my lack of knowledge, but I still wanna mention it, it says (as I kind of remember): ,,Don´t say, that things are haram or halal". Something like that. I dont know quran interpretation, but it seems, that its haram to say, that something is haram (kind of) haha. I also heard (maybe from a hadith): ,,He who speaks without knowledge is considered a liar". Very terrifying, but logical. Hope I helped. Allah bless you and your family to the best degree possible ^^
Only Halal music is 💥Kaboooom💥
@@mohammad-bin-dajjalYou might be trying to get someone mad or something but that won’t work, you should simply now that I wish the best for you inshallah as a true Muslim I want you to go to heaven, therefore I hope that you simply open the Quran and read about ahadeeth and learn more about this topic, and in the end it’s your choice it’s your life and it won’t affect me
Same here!! I really only listen to classical music or choral music. I was a music major in my first degree and can’t imagine how instrumental music with no words could be haram. I am reverting right now and have found that classical music often leads me to thinking of the beauty of the world that Allah SWT created. Insha’Allah I will live according to the teachings of Islam and be faithful in my life and heart. ❤🤲🏻
yeah, them love songs make you, mmmm... the touch of your skin, oh yeah, the warmth of your lips on my skin. nice songs.
This is probably the best explanation I have heard on this topic. Thank you.
Coz u like to listen to music that is why it makes sense to you
Fact is music is Haram and that is how it has been always but todays world new halaal/haraam things are coming to misguide people be careful my brother May Allah guide us all🤲🏽
check Dr. Zakir Naik
@@_-JB Islam is a beautiful religion, unfortunately Muslims are among some of the most ignorant on our planet. No facts, no sources, no logic, just emotion. haha
Of all the Ulama opinions on music I've listened to, this is the most fact based, rational, comprehensive presentation of this contentious subject and for me is the most reasonable and acceptable.
First of he's not a scholar
Second music is haram.
@@believer0001 you're entitled to your own oppinion as others to theirs. You don't enforce it on anybody.
only in the shia madhab tho
@@raypardillo6788 He isn't forcing. He merely mentioned his opinion.
@@raypardillo6788 so the prohibitions in Islam became subjective huh wow. Out of all scholars, dozens of sahih hadiths. A learned Muslim anywhere from the west to the east of earth accepts music as haram expect for people who listen to their desires. Countless evidences and you choose your nafs.
Thank you brother and sister, wisdom travels across differences to a Sunni here.
I am a sunni but I love my shia brothers and sisters....infact I actually with them in many things ...❤💙💜
Thank you brother it means so much to me and the Shia community to hear that ❤️💯🤝
Why to delay then!
Accept the true islam (shia islam)
@@momskitchen4014 salam first of all firstly i did say that i agree with my shiq fellows in lot of things...and i think the sunni islam has been unjust and quite tough and rough towards shia muslims due to many political and religious reasons obviously.. Which i condemn also it was from both sides in the history.
But i would also say that i disagree with many things is shia islam as well just like in sunni islam....so yeah thanks for your comment but i am good thanks
I don’t understand these branches of Islam, I thought there was only one type of Muslim, ☪️
@@illuminateconfirmed989 today there are 72 sects and there’s a Hadith that says when 73 come the end times will too
Outstanding information. Please consider making more episodes to benefit us and those who come after. Thank you.
If the lyrics doesen't promote bad language then that is okay. The issue is the using of Instruments. Allah Swt, knows best.
I think it depends on the person and what you’re listening to.
May God bless you and the other sister. Very helping mini but pivotal episode.
Assalam o alaykum,
With my little knowledge of music, I believe it can be broken down into 2 parts
1) Music - From instruments
2) Song - Lyrics
To be fair and just to any topic, we should gather all Ayat and Hadees connected to it. There are famous Hadith which bans all musical instruments except one sided drum. I agree with the scholar that if a song does not have any Shirk, immodest, vain lyrics, it is fine and could be treated as another form of poetry. But we should also consider the aspect of musical instruments in it. I am not Alim but the scholar should not have left out this critical part.
At the end of the day, We should try to find the correct answer rather than prove our opinion correct.
May Allah protect and guide us all to the right path.
Aleykumselam verahmetullah
could u share the hadith where it bans all musical instrument except the drum or is it just the interpretations of the salalfis?
Well explained in a simple and comprehensive way....
What an excellent reply to a complex question.
I am not Shia but I like this Sheikh, he is logical in his talks ❤
Very important to provide a proper context for this kind of discussion. This should include the fact that for the most part, music and the art of practising musicianship and song is by no means damaging nor does it entail adverse behaviours. That particular criticism may be relevant to a very small minority of cases only. Please provide a balanced discussion on such topics, including inviting people with diverse views and direct experience of the topic. That will be much more helpful.
Truth will set us free, Allah bless you sheik.
There is music that drains you and music that empowers you. There is literally instrumental music that brings you closer to the Creator and inspires the will to righteousness, as well asmusic that brings you closer to hedonism and to shirk. It is not music itself, but the genre and type you choose to listen to.
To put all sound waves, hence music, per se, in one basket, is like banning all liquids> coffee, alcohol, juices... they're all liquid but they're not all bad. Critical thinking is necessary in matters like these, as the quran often commands us. May Allah guide us all.
I believe it depends on the context. If the song is all about shaking big booties, consuming drugs, and driving expensive cars, it's obviously haram. But if it's about Allah or praising Allah, that would be halal.
If it has music in it
It's completely haram irrespective of anything
If it's vocal for Allah and for Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) it's allowed.
No music in any way is allowed.
Correct, context matters. Music in general is not haram, the message within is what matters.
Sheeeeeeen, whoosh, (dropping sound)
This is the music of Islam 🤪
The companions unanimously agreed upon the prohibition of music and song but allowed particular exceptions specified by the authentic sunnah. many authentic narrations (aathaar) traced to the various sahaabah bear witness to this. Also, the four Khalifas, the fuqahaa among the saahabah such as Ibin Abaas, Ibin Umar, and Jaabir bin Abdullah as well as the general body of saahabah (may Allah be pleased with them all).
Tafsir al-Qurtubi, Vol. 14, pp. 51-52
As Salaam Alakium. It is unbelievable that many refuse to stop conflating music with songs.......
Music alone detracts only if the listener allows. Music WITH LYRICS applied can take one from the path of Allah. There is a difference, clear and simple. And until this distinction is presented at every opportunity, this unclear, confused and distorted article of faith regarding listening to music within the deen will ALWAYS be a source of and for contention. Songs minus music instruments is acapella speech and can be questioned depending on content. Music minus lyrics is sound vibrations, not a soul-stealing entity. Allah's word in the Quran says nothing of music being harasm. Allah desires ease for us. So apply common sense when it comes to the topic of music and songs. Stop focusing on the instrument because on its own, that intangible object is powerless (unless we give it power). Music containing lyrics which are songs can be held for critique and/or outright dismissal. May Allah guide us all to the path of righteousness and common sense approaches.
As Salaam Alakium.
There's plenty of wholesome lyrical music, much even praising God. You just need to dig a bit to find it as it never gets mainstream attention.
@@jannahm1788I listen to pleasantries and I can agree in this statement
So does this mean it is halal to listen to music only?
One of issues nowadays which has become an area of confusion is music being played on religious videos & tv channels, nasheeds, latmiya etc
If we take what culture that music is played in or if it is played at haram gatherings it isn’t always clear it can become subjective. Especially where it is full blown music which is becoming common.
I am not talking about a mild background we have full blown music even in Islamic kids programming.
Do I want my children growing up with a taste of music being told well it isn’t played in haram gatherings. Will they always draw the right line when older even adults are confused?
I don’t think we get the hard questions answered clearly it is left to subjective opinion.
I see my kids bopping to kiddie music but can be said the programme educational. Will kiddie music be taken as bad culture or haram gathering? Probably not as it isn’t the music played in pubs & clubs etc. But kiddie can grow to like it show a preference to that over programs without
It depends completely on what the music and song contain
If it something godly then it is ok but if it isn't then not
It just happens that many music promote ungodly things but not all of them
Some music is simple music
Some music represent cultures
Some music teach kids alot
Some songs are about love and about good things
And some are obviously about bad things
So yeah.
@@chillyroom8159 yeah still all subjective. Why not just stear clear of it all to be on safe side.
@@Shia.Ahlulbayt Yoo am not such clearer in this video being said by that shia scholar. I just wanna ask if using light music in the background with an informational video is allowed or not?
@@PainOfLoveAndWar according to him yes as long as that music isn't played in a club or somewhere they do Haram like dancing, singing, drinking
SubhanAllah, very well said
I may not completely agree with him but I think he handled the question quite nicely. It's the first time I heard a shia' speaker. Only love.
This is a great video.
Jzk Allah
May Almighty Allah protect and bless all of people like you my dear shia brothers and sisters
From your brother of sunni origin in the island of mauritius in the Indian ocean
wonderful intellectual talk
In Turkey its much worse to escape from music than in Germany.
mashaallah. watching from pakistan
I’m pretty sure I read a Hadith that said the prophet saww said music is allowed depending on which “aura” it creates :/ imma search it now
can you send link
Yes. Ayatollah khamenei and sistani say only the music suitable for gatherings of sin(alcohol and adultery) and other immoral music is impermissible. Others aren't
@@asleepandhappy what if the ones that aren’t used in those Haram gatherings but maybe have instruments like guitar and piano involved? Like I want to make travel scenery montages so need to add some sounds but worried I might end up causing sin
@@ufatemav4509 any instrumental music is haram, whether it has a guitar or a piano. It takes you away from Allah and also destroys your soul. I would suggest you to download "The status of Music In Islam" shekih saleem bhimji
@@قادةالإمامالمهديwhy do you use smart phone asshole!! doesn’t smartphone take you away from Allah
what about only the musical instruments like piano, string music.
salmun alaykum
what about instrumental music that contains no vocals and no word to be unGodly or not?
please have this topic continued
@@tabasumfatima3880 I’m also interested
@@Mohdzn Me too
@@قادةالإمامالمهدي 😊🤣
Obviously it's not haram
Aleykumselsm verahma
I've never understood when people have told me music as a whole is haram. It always depends on context. There are a lot of songs of worship, spirituality, love, and the human experience in general from people who are honest but just love to make music. Not to mention the recitation of the Quran even has musical qualities to it, if it didn't have those musical qualities it would sound like spoken word, and never recited the way it always is.
Everything about this world has a rhythm, the way a heart beats the way we walk, talk, laugh, the way birds sing, the way music effects how plants grow, or how water freezes. This is all a part of the creation.
The only real explanation I can see for music being haram is in the form of idol worship (when people pretty much worship famous musicians) or in the context the Sayed mentioned which is music that takes you away from righteous behavior/consciousness.
So that means motivational songs, patriotic songs and love songs for spouse are okay to listen?
I am confused.
Yh im confused to. I think he address music that is generally more so about haram things so idk
Yes they are ok
Only music that is immoral or suitable for immoral gatherings is haram. This is the fatwa from ayatollah khamenei and sistani
Yeah motivational music is completely halal as long as it motivates you to do the right thing
if its taking u to right path then it is right...
I love her voice
She looks like TAPSI PUNNO the hindi actress
Thanx so much
That man John Coltrane wrote "A Love Supreme" as the truest form of love that exists in this reality which is love for the Creator.
not scholar who said it.. it was Abdulla Ibn Mas ood who said that" lahwal hadith" is music. A companion of the Prophet Muhammad S.A.W.. what ends the conversation is that, if we can prove that this is really not the statement of Ibn Mas 'ood.. otherwise as a muslim we have no other choice but to believ that music is haram.. we hear and we obey
100%
I can't resist kishor Kumar voice, the old songs from india are soo beautifully made.
I don't feel guilty of listening to such but i feel bad or guilty by listening to bad music/song
From Durban, South Africa, Subahan Allah, the best explanation about music. Nareeeeeh Haidariiiii, Yaaaaa Aliiiiiii.
love from PAKISTAN / GOOD VIDEO TITLE
Music per say is not haram
How we can sends our questions to you????
Labbaik ya Hussain..🙌🦁😭❤🌹
Shirk n bidah
@@sarahnassar8833 you know nothing...wallahi..nasbi
@@iramanhaiderzaidi6913 same with u, break away groups damned, doomed n are in.minority world wide
@@sarahnassar8833 numbers doesnt matters matters is the truth...whos with truth...u even dont know the truth...or seems to lie
@@iramanhaiderzaidi6913 What are you talking, numbers matters, allah subhanawatala guides the majority. Its the fringe elements, misguided, rejectors of truth are a downgraded minority. Even during the period of our beloved prophet (s) munafiq (hypocrites) were in minority
It depends completely on what the music and song contain
If it something godly then it is ok but if it isn't then not
It just happens that many music promote ungodly things but not all of them
Some music is simple music
Some music represent cultures
Some music teach kids alot
Some songs are about love and about good things
And some are obviously about bad things
So yeah.
My Question is: Is it haram?
I work as a Video Editor of a famous Indian Actor for his UA-cam Channel (Mostly: Travel Vlogs, inspirational Podcasts, Food Reels, Food Vlogs. To make the video engaging I do use Music as I instructed by team head)
Many thanks
Simply applies to people who go around cracking jokes for people to laugh, people who gather people to make mockery of others........... Mockery, jokes, Nick naming, club for jokes.......This wat I feel should be vain talk
What is actually contemporary Islamic law?
And music dear sister is not gray area at all, let’s not make lawful that what is not..
This video also began with music. How about that?
Kinda foreshowed the rest of the vid
Good stuff
Can you do a relating video covering “is dancing haram?” Since the two usually go together.
Ye literally its haram
Terimakasih:= thank you
thanx very match cheikh
All the imams that say music is Haram should really educate theirselves about music.... This is ridiculous. When Holy Quran came there were nor instruments or music as it is developed today. So all the hadith and the interpretations of ancient Imams are not really pointing to music that can lead you to Allah.... I see also people saying you can not call music that leads you to Allah music but Nasheed... Well my friends as a musician for 15 years I can tell you thats really a lie... And you should not lie to yourself.... To say music is haram is denying the laws of creation.
I can even tell you a kind of music makes you feel sexual harassed... if you are truely muslim and you intend to use it in a halal way you can use this for medical purposes... You should not generalize all the terms for every case.... Please go listen to music it will make you a better person.
As a muslim and professional musician and composer I really feel attacked by people who say music is haram... Will I go to hell? And if so who are you to judge that... Allah knows the best... If for you music is only about bellydancing and pathway to zina... I think your brains are poisoned and you should really ask yourself why am I thinking like this. There are even imams that say musicians have satanic rituals... I mean come on.... A fa la tefekkeroen.... A fa la tezekkeroen...
Ya selaam... Ya selaam.
the lady looks so mesmerized like shes hypnotized hahaha
I have a question!!!
Assalam u Alaikum! is music without any lyrics, like meditation music with a little bit instruments, halal or haram?
like i use in my educational videos.
JazakAllah!
It's not haram. It is haram when it takes you away from Allah. If it talks about good thing it's good.
@@saniatamanna7763 JazakAllah❤️
Sorry I didn't reply to your greetings. Walekum Salam brother
@@saniatamanna7763JazakAllah sister
Aleykumselam verahmetullah
I am a Sunni..............but that does not mean ALL of SUNNI HADITH are UNCORRUPTED !
You just need ONE ORIGINAL person to interpret the Quran or the actual sayings or INTENTIONS of Muhammad slightly different
and everyone one of his students will FOLLOW through just like the BRANCH of a TREE...........
If Music is 100% Haram in both the Quran or hadith, I have no problem with that...........
But I am also terribly afraid of making something that is NEVER HARAM in first place into something that is 100% Haram !
This too is STRICTLY FORBIDDEN in Islam !
YES ! We need the hadith to know how to pray,
However, we STILL need to decide for ourselves the TECHNIQUES of pray that are the most common from those HADITH too !
But the FACT is................EVERYONE agrees that it is HARAM not to pray,
and it is even the command by Allah to pray too INSIDE the Quran !
Quran actually NEVER precisely STATE about the term MUSIC
or
at least it NEVER STATES a CLEAR sentence FORBIDDING Muslims to play ANY musical Instrument or WHAT TYPE of Instruments !
THERE IS however a clear HADITH that say that :
Abu Bakar shouted at his daughter Aisha for listening to some girls
playing Musical instruments and singing praising songs of Islam during the EID.
He shouted at Aisha to stop listening because those DUFFS that the girls were playing are tools of the DEVIL.
Prophet Muhammad who was just beside them
told Abu Bakar that it was ok.............since it is the Muslim festival EID too by the way !
If something is TRULY FORBIDDEN and TOOL of the DEVIL,
why then did prophet Muhammad NOT warn his wife Aisha immediately about this in the FIRST PLACE ?
According to some HADITH,
some very early scholars CLAIMED and SWORE that the term IDLE TALK in the Quran
was in fact MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS that was forbidden in the Quran.
BUT THIS IS THE MODERN ERA.............and MODERN MUSLIMS can have ACCESS to ALL HADITHS in the BLINK of an EYE too.............
Very early SCHOLARS totally DID not have this kind of ADVANTAGE about all the SAYINGS of prophet Muhammad !
So in a way, we MODERN Muslims of today are probably EVEN more KNOWLEDGABLE
than those very early scholars of HADITH. This is of course FACT !
But unfortunately, most of the traditional ULAMA of today never use BRAIN or LOGIC.
===========
However, I will still try my best not to listen to music though because I PREFER to PLAY IT SAFE !
Sahi Al bukhari 5590 strictly prohibits instruments tho
If the lady and the Syed are not mahram then I believe the best thing to do is to lower down their gazes or find a brother to replace her. It would be the best.
Salam alaykom
Just a thought to chew on:
I am only a student, but my assumption is that a scholar such as the Sayed himself would've taken these thoughts into account before agreeing to sit for these interviews. My conclusion (could be different from the Sayed's) is that the nature of their interaction in this video is of a professional and educational nature; thus not necessitating a replacement for the sister. We mustn't underestimate the discernment of our scholars. Allahu Alam
Kind regards.
@@michaelgibbons4622
Salaam,
Maybe the Syed or the sister didn't even look at each other, they could be looking abit to the side ( that's what I do while watching vids online) . When someone lowers their gazes for the sake of ALLAH, ALLAH increases his/her Taqwa and his sense of hayya keeps on increasing . Ask the people of Taqwa what is the Best thing to do not just what is permissible to do . May ALLAH increases you in taqwa for your good akhlaaq .
WalaikumAsalaam
@@mrlion9404 you do realize it's on the way of your gaze lowering your gaze doesn't mean do not look means do not look lustfully. Secondly what about when non Marham would ask questions to the prophet wormen would come to the prophet to ask him .
Beautiful response
Are you crazy?
Can someone please explain. So music/ songs that don't have any bad words in it and have good meanings is halal? So for example the song "Dandelions" is about a loved one and it doesnt have bad words. Does that make it halal.
a lot of talking and discussion but still, he didn't give a particular answer... what i got is that listing to motivational and good songs are ok and have no problem
you want 1 direct answer ok here it is,
music/song is NOT haram, if its good positively used
it is HARAM if used for bad negative purpose and bad lyrics. hope thats simple clean and clear.
@@whitelivesmatter7709 Yes, that is what I said
Salam Brother,
What allows us to suggest the two hadith one saying bait al-ghena, and the other saying "where instruments are held" are the same hadith?
Also what about the ahadith where specific music instruments are named and condemned?
Reminds me of Hadith ---
From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."
Sahih Bukhari 7:69:494v
Those VAIN TALKS are NOT MUSICAL instruments...................BUT ARE ACTUALLY TALKS FROM PEOPLE LIKE YOU ..................
Javed Ghamidi view is more logical in this issue.
Mansha Allah 💕
Coming here after nak controversy
I need WhatsApp of this great scholar
Can you do a video on nasheeds because I’m confused about which ones are halal ?
Everyone I’m Sunni but… we are just Muslims like the last first prophet and the last prophet pace be upon them
Proud to be a Shia Muslim.
Proud to be a Muslim and we're one Ummah! 💪🙂
@@driftx8827 Yes and we pray to Allah swt that may he lift his mercy from her. In other words we Laan (which is Dua to Allah SWT for lifting mercy).
Respected beloved molana
Male should interview male
Female should interview female
What Islam says about this?
Why does it matter if the gender of two people in the interview are not the same?
And they ended the clip with music.
Shek i want to qoshtin balther sonny was now qierhn with music and songs that speak to allah
There is also many Islamic music , patriotik music, romantic music, are these also haram
Music is haram I aggree but not all music. Infact some are haram and some are halal
Well said brother Jawad. No need more explanation than this. Music is Haram and will remain Haram. Don't be shy to say and accept it. Leave that for the disbelievers
I love the Shia positions on everything.
Come to the true path.
Lijtinaab doesn't mean Haram. If it's haram allah will use the word haram..
Salaam, you didn't come back to what if that music speaks about beauty and God or love for family and love ones? subhanAllah
Music is consist of two elements .
Lyrics and instrument .
If instrument is haram thn without instrument you cant have music .
If lyrics are haram by saying something that is vain talk like talking about love of being more beautiful than God . (Naizubillah ) is also haram . Tell me by logic how is it halal ?
The Prophet (S.A.W) only let women use daf in weddings, not mixed with men
Allah says (interpretation of the meaning):
“[Allah said to Iblis:] And befool them gradually those whom you can among them with your voice (i.e. songs, music, and any other call for Allah's disobedience)…” [al-Isra 17:64]
“And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allah…” [Luqman 31:6]
The scholar of the ummah, Ibn 'Abbas (may Allah be pleased with him) said: this means singing . Mujahid (may Allah have mercy on him) said: this means playing the drum (tabl). (Tafsir al-Tabari, 21/40)
Al-Hasan al-Basri (may Allah have mercy on him) said: this ayah was revealed concerning singing and musical instruments (lit. woodwind instruments). (Tafsir Ibn Kathir, 3/451)
there is also a lot more.
Assalam o alaykum,
With my little knowledge of music, I believe it can be broken down into 2 parts
1) Music - From instruments
2) Song - Lyrics
To be fair and just to any topic, we should gather all Ayat and Hadees connected to it. There are Hadith which bans all musical instruments except one sided drum. I agree with the scholar that if a song does not have any Shirk, immodest, vain lyrics, it is fine and could be treated as another form of poetry. But we should also consider the aspect of musical instruments in it. I am not Alim but the scholar should not have left out this critical part.
At the end of the day, We should try to find the correct answer rather than prove our opinion correct.
May Allah protect and guide us all to the right path.
@@syedmdismail7478aleykumselam verahmetullah
@@Mert-fk4yg Walaikum assalam wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatahu brother
These are many forged ahadeeths in your sunni books which mock rasoolla and the sunni don't protest.
Music is Halal
Zanaa is an act of worship
Alcohol make u smart
That's what the people you follow say
Nooo!!!
So my Q is what if you use music for therapy??
Ur video is on music is haram but in Ur video u r also added music
if we arent being pulled away from allah is it haram? and if its a positive song is it still haram?
Music is music. Like, if someone gives you a piece of bullshit, he arranged it with great aroma, covered by cake and it tastes great, would you eat that thing? You'll say bullshit is bullshit, whatever you put in it it's still harmful for me. Just like that, however music is presented, it's music, instruments. So it's haram.
I also thought that musics of Maher Zain, Sami Yusuf etc are ok to listen. At least those are positive and islamic. But then I realized these "islamic musics" are just pulling me away from Allah. I hope you understand.
How can you say that words of Allah the Quran are vague. Wow guys pay attention if you want to do bad you will always find someone that will justify it. It is on every individual to decide, this does not abstain you from the sin. May God string us all dow with the truth.
He doesn’t really answer the question
Asalaam u Alaikum!
Syed
I have listened to your lecture and What I have taken from it is that any music that would deviate you from the Almighty or ethical norms is Haraam other wise it is Halal.
This is what I've taken from it , this does not mean this is what you intended.
The thing that has been bothering me is that every Marja and other school of thought unanimously believe that manufacturing and Selling of any musical Instrument is haraam.
Right.
If even manufacturing is haraam then how come the state after manufacturing i.e playing them becomes halal regardless of the intention.
This is a genuine Query I really hope you would not take this as a challenge to your understanding.
I just want to live according to the teachings of Holy Prophet p.b.u.h and his Ahlebayt a.s, and just don't want to go against any of their commands, when they are explicitly stated to refrain from the Musical Instrument.
Do you want my recommendation? Do not interrupt over other people.
Without the ahaadith we would never come to the conclusion that the Luqman verse is about music.
It's actually easier to condemn music than vain talk.
VAIN TALK is even more WORST !
I’m trying to unite Sunni and Shia but it’s hard…
Kakakakaka
Music basically hits our brain badly because it has sur and taal, and makes human greedy, selfish, which we saw our society is now a days
What about cussing in every video movies clips and everything in west now days to the point that young generation have got so used to it they think it normal and not bad. Anymore can you please make a speech specially about this matter thank you.
If u have to ask this question…. Then …
Allahuma sali ala muhamd wa Ali muhd wajjil farzahum shreef
Subanallah