For those who played Nier Replicant/Gestalt, you thought you were to fight the twins and ended up heartbroken again But instead, now, they help you. It gave you sense of hope instead of despair
the problem here is that you obviously did not understand what devola and popolas purpose were, they both had the mission to save humanity and they indeed helped The Shadowlord aka the Real Brother NieR but failed to do so. the devola and popola in replicant died. the Devola and Popola in Automata are the last Model version of them. and they knew what the previous model failed to do. So they do their last duty of saving humanity, they let the only trustworth android 9s and 2B/2A see the truth of humanitys fate. and yet here again in Replicant there was NO good and bad. it is instead very hard to tell what would have been the right decision, Helping the Shadowlord NieR to save Yonah and Humanity? or Help Replicant Nier to save yonah and his friends? maybe you should watch: Understanding "Song of the Ancients" - Joanathan Barouch. he explained it very well
I was like: “No... not a betrayal :( Poor 9S” When they ran past him: “Wait... what?” When I read their novel: “Noooo...Popola and Devola didn’t deserve this T-T”
@@aresrivera9744Yeah, but he also wasn't prepared to fight them at the time. He was so frazzled by their appearance that he cowered when they charged past him, lol.
If you read Anemone's mission report on the descent. you'll notice this scene refferences S21... And playing through the tower is like living A2's mission with anemone.
How how other video games aren't this good. Fuck this game really did me in. I beat it 4 months ago but I still can't put the game properly into words when explaining it in a minute or two . It's such an experience/ mind fuck.
en esa parte del juego, cuando ambas versiones de las canciones se van entremesclando, la version vocal y la 8 bit mientras hackeas lentamente y el como se entrelaza la musica poco a poco es glorioso
SPOILERS: i want some to honestly tell me that if they played the original if they trusted these 2. it makes to much sense to instantly suspect them given what happened in the original especially since devola is best girl in the original which made it worse for me. yoko taro is a genius cause he used those feelings against us and made us hate these 2 from first look only to explain how terrible its been for them and for judging them as the same people. this devola and popola were programmed to feel constant guilt over their failure to stop the world from ending(nier killing the shadowlord was a big fucking deal lol) when it wasnt even them. they didnt do anything wrong in fact they did all they can to help and no one will ever know that. as soon as i heard song of the ancients specially the hollow dreams version played when they help you into the tower it broke my heart because i feel in love all over again and knew i could trust these people. FUCK YOU YOKO TARO WHY MUST YOU DO THIS!?
I didn't trust them at first, ever since they were anounced to come back I thought they were going to antagonize everyone. And you are completely right about them doing the best they could for the world, it's just that since they antagonized Nier (even if he doomed humanity) it's harder to sympathize with them.
mirrormimi after learning everything I find it easy to sympathize with them. the other pair fucked up yet their entire line was blamed for it which is bullshit considering we know they developed their own personalities outside of their programming
The twins from the first game were not even the bad guys, you were the bad guy. The original twins fought to prevent the extinction of humanity at you the player hands. When you killed the original twins and went on to kill the shadow lord, guess what you set in motion the total extinction of humanity and this game is the fruit of YOUR ACTIONS.
Tysm for acknowledging and blending in the hacking/8-bit version. This game is the most beautiful and eye-gouging experience I've ever had the privilege to experience 😭
In Nier Replicant, Devola died first when they both tried to stop you. Popola died in her madness from her sister’s loss. In Nier Automata, Popola died first when they both tried to help you. Devola died in her grief from her sister’s loss.
I haven't even watched this yet, but yes. Lost Soul Aside is amazing not only as a game, but as a statement of what one person with a dream can achieve. It needs all the support it can get.
I loved this song in Automata, it was my favorite from all the OST, however, I always felt some melancholy from it that I couldn't understand. Later when I played Replicant, I found so wholesome to hear it again in the town... Boy did it hurt when I heard it again at the end of the game, it all made sense... 😭
Alright I am Ranking all song of the ancients versions Best Beginning before Vocals : Fate Best harmony & voice : ver 1.22 Best instrumental : Atonement Best drop : Atonement Best after drop : Fate In my opinion, Best Overall : Atonement
Nice work ^^. I find it hard to follow the story with so many branches but i know this is a big one ;3. Btw, think you can make a mix of End of the Unknown and Copied City? An odd request but i forget if the music was used for in the final fight with Adam?
Zaber177 Copied City was used throughout the area including the first and second phases for Adam. End of the Unknown was used for the final phase. Not sure if the two of them fit though. :)
i played automata, and i just started playing replicant, i didn't pay attention to this one song in automata, but now that i'm playing replicant, it is my favorite song
So, I know that you mention Automata route spoilers in the first second of the video, but the title /description has no mention of Automata, and the first line is kind of fast. As someone who played through Nier but is not done with Automata, I can't be the only one who was looking at the description of the video for the first few seconds then ignored the text, assuming to be watching some Nier 1 spoilers. I think it would be really great if you specified Automata in the description of the video title, as it is somewhat misleading. Regardless, I do appreciate the effort to prevent spoilers, and cool mix as well.
UnlimitedBrettWorks Thanks for the suggestion! I sincerely apologize if you were spoiled by anything. Will change the title, especially since it uses two tracks from Automata and one from the original NieR.
![Bipolar Nightmare (NieR: Automata) -Dual Mix- [Gameplay Spoilers!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vyd1MDdC2rQ/mqdefault.jpg)
For those who played Nier Replicant/Gestalt, you thought you were to fight the twins and ended up heartbroken again
But instead, now, they help you. It gave you sense of hope instead of despair
the problem here is that you obviously did not understand what devola and popolas purpose were, they both had the mission to save humanity and they indeed helped The Shadowlord aka the Real Brother NieR but failed to do so. the devola and popola in replicant died. the Devola and Popola in Automata are the last Model version of them. and they knew what the previous model failed to do. So they do their last duty of saving humanity, they let the only trustworth android 9s and 2B/2A see the truth of humanitys fate. and yet here again in Replicant there was NO good and bad. it is instead very hard to tell what would have been the right decision, Helping the Shadowlord NieR to save Yonah and Humanity? or Help Replicant Nier to save yonah and his friends?
maybe you should watch: Understanding "Song of the Ancients" - Joanathan Barouch. he explained it very well
I JUST GOT ENDINGS C, D, AND E A FEW HOURS AGO AND THIS GAME TORE OUT ALL MY FEELS AND CRUSHED THEM THEN SPRINKLED THEM IN FRONT OF ME LIKE SALT
I feel you man. Hope I got to help ;)
Hi Blue! :P
Oh hey look who it is!
You are everywhere ..
Well people dont say that Taro gets by on toying with emotions rather than good writing for nothing (I personally think it's both :p )
"Hey Yoko Taro, how many versions of this song do you want?"
"Yes."
AAAAA THE RYTHM OF BOTH SONGS BLEND TOGETJRR SO WELL
Actually 3
Never before has holding a single button been so hard to do....
yeah, all those items on the ground, lost . . .
Y’all thought you were gonna have to fight Devola and Popola again but instead they help you
I was like:
“No... not a betrayal :( Poor 9S”
When they ran past him:
“Wait... what?”
When I read their novel:
“Noooo...Popola and Devola didn’t deserve this T-T”
I honestly had no idea what was going on since I played automata before replicant
Since I played Automata before Replicant didn't know anything about them
9S probably would’ve won too
@@aresrivera9744Yeah, but he also wasn't prepared to fight them at the time. He was so frazzled by their appearance that he cowered when they charged past him, lol.
If you read Anemone's mission report on the descent. you'll notice this scene refferences S21... And playing through the tower is like living A2's mission with anemone.
And now we have the best possible version of this amazing song. Thank you
How how other video games aren't this good. Fuck this game really did me in. I beat it 4 months ago but I still can't put the game properly into words when explaining it in a minute or two . It's such an experience/ mind fuck.
en esa parte del juego, cuando ambas versiones de las canciones se van entremesclando, la version vocal y la 8 bit mientras hackeas lentamente y el como se entrelaza la musica poco a poco es glorioso
the beginning was sick mix between fate and atonement was six, then when the 8bit came in it’s even better
SPOILERS:
i want some to honestly tell me that if they played the original if they trusted these 2. it makes to much sense to instantly suspect them given what happened in the original especially since devola is best girl in the original which made it worse for me. yoko taro is a genius cause he used those feelings against us and made us hate these 2 from first look only to explain how terrible its been for them and for judging them as the same people. this devola and popola were programmed to feel constant guilt over their failure to stop the world from ending(nier killing the shadowlord was a big fucking deal lol) when it wasnt even them. they didnt do anything wrong in fact they did all they can to help and no one will ever know that. as soon as i heard song of the ancients specially the hollow dreams version played when they help you into the tower it broke my heart because i feel in love all over again and knew i could trust these people. FUCK YOU YOKO TARO WHY MUST YOU DO THIS!?
"You will feel ashamed of your words and deeds", Yoko Taro style.
I didn't trust them at first, ever since they were anounced to come back I thought they were going to antagonize everyone. And you are completely right about them doing the best they could for the world, it's just that since they antagonized Nier (even if he doomed humanity) it's harder to sympathize with them.
mirrormimi after learning everything I find it easy to sympathize with them. the other pair fucked up yet their entire line was blamed for it which is bullshit considering we know they developed their own personalities outside of their programming
Think of it like and entire race of people being blamed for the actions of a few of their own.
The twins from the first game were not even the bad guys, you were the bad guy. The original twins fought to prevent the extinction of humanity at you the player hands. When you killed the original twins and went on to kill the shadow lord, guess what you set in motion the total extinction of humanity and this game is the fruit of YOUR ACTIONS.
such a badass game if you own a PS4 this game is a must.
PS5 As well
Scroll down to not be spoiled and see all the spoilers in the comments instead
So you are telling me to scroll down to the comments to Spoil Myself?
Wow, this is totally not an April Fools video though. April 2 where I'm at now.
theultimateonejpsx you will do the dual mix of ($po!l&r)
emil/karma(nier & nier automata)?
so strange coming across this comment on april 2nd, 2019 after marathoning this specific song
@@yodamvpplayer same here!
I flipped my shit when this song played!
when the excavator arm attacked?
Tysm for acknowledging and blending in the hacking/8-bit version. This game is the most beautiful and eye-gouging experience I've ever had the privilege to experience 😭
Wow 4 all those voices overlapped and it still sounds perfect
In Nier Replicant, Devola died first when they both tried to stop you. Popola died in her madness from her sister’s loss.
In Nier Automata, Popola died first when they both tried to help you. Devola died in her grief from her sister’s loss.
I haven't even watched this yet, but yes. Lost Soul Aside is amazing not only as a game, but as a statement of what one person with a dream can achieve. It needs all the support it can get.
Devola, Popola, 22B and she's partners, you may now rest in peace...
I'm kinda interested in a triple mix of all three versions of Emil, the karma, sacrifice, and despair versions 👌
this is so damn cool + so well synced ^-^ nice job love it
How sad that this is so underrated, great job dude!!! I appreciate it :D
Nice mix. This version really tore away my heart to pieces cos of its beauty yet sadness. Yoko-san why those two have to die again??!!!! T.T
I loved this song in Automata, it was my favorite from all the OST, however, I always felt some melancholy from it that I couldn't understand. Later when I played Replicant, I found so wholesome to hear it again in the town... Boy did it hurt when I heard it again at the end of the game, it all made sense... 😭
RIP Devola and Popola, you (Possibly) Crazy, *badass* , Medics.
Drakengard, Nier and now Nier Automata.
thanks Yoko Taro!
Can you do a Quadruple mix, with all of these songs and the Drakengard 3 version?
You're a fucking genius. Why has no one done this yet? *Triple btw. Quadruple means 4.
Professor Emil Adding the drakengard 3 version of the song too this triple remix would make it a quadruple remix.
Fuck that, Septuple mix. Throw this, Drakengard 3, Devola, Popola, and The Duet versions!
@@mrgbf8891 Today, I learned I can’t count.
Alright I am Ranking all song of the ancients versions
Best Beginning before Vocals : Fate
Best harmony & voice : ver 1.22
Best instrumental : Atonement
Best drop : Atonement
Best after drop : Fate
In my opinion, Best Overall : Atonement
The twins are such tragic characters.
Great mix, thank you very much !
My best friend, Great video. Love your channel. Keep up the excellent work!!! Wonderful upload! Keep it up! +thumb up3!
Nice work ^^. I find it hard to follow the story with so many branches but i know this is a big one ;3.
Btw, think you can make a mix of End of the Unknown and Copied City? An odd request but i forget if the music was used for in the final fight with Adam?
Zaber177 Copied City was used throughout the area including the first and second phases for Adam. End of the Unknown was used for the final phase. Not sure if the two of them fit though. :)
True. Sorry about that. Still love your work. Hey do you ever see yourself doing a triple mix of Mass Destruction?
Zaber177 Lets see if I get a bit more cash after Tuesday. ;)
Understood. No pressure. It was just a thought. I love seeing your different videos.
No one stops...
one word beautiful.
Longest hack in the game ;_; "This pain..."
i played automata, and i just started playing replicant, i didn't pay attention to this one song in automata, but now that i'm playing replicant, it is my favorite song
Atonement
this its beautifull depressing
Such a great song...
Sooooo excited 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Que pro ❤❤❤❤❤ osT hermoso amo nier automata quiere jugazo la música está a otro nivel
So, I know that you mention Automata route spoilers in the first second of the video, but the title /description has no mention of Automata, and the first line is kind of fast. As someone who played through Nier but is not done with Automata, I can't be the only one who was looking at the description of the video for the first few seconds then ignored the text, assuming to be watching some Nier 1 spoilers. I think it would be really great if you specified Automata in the description of the video title, as it is somewhat misleading. Regardless, I do appreciate the effort to prevent spoilers, and cool mix as well.
UnlimitedBrettWorks Thanks for the suggestion! I sincerely apologize if you were spoiled by anything. Will change the title, especially since it uses two tracks from Automata and one from the original NieR.
So, how about a quintuple mix? With Devola and Popolas individual songs
You can shoot with your pod while hacking and help them btw
gotta love them running like Naruto
I am obviously alone with this, but the twins are hotter than 2B or A2, but equal to commander White.
Commander can't reach that level. Twins are on a whole high ass level lol
Disagreed
They're not even real people, y'all are sad
Came back after hearing the same thing from the anime (not lying)
1.25 speed makes this song absolutely godlike.
I cried like a lil bitch in this fight
What was his promise?
To not die alone
So, gonna stick all these mixes into a playlist?
THEY DID NOTHING WRONG!!!!
Penta Mix with the two versions from Gestalt???
*GLORY.........TO MANKIND!!!!*
Meh said that to FUCKER NIER AND CAIM PLEASE 😒
I only have endings A & G.
that's shit is tuff
How did you edit these songs together?
you mean "warning, Intense feels"
So sad :(
😌
This is porn to my ears
can you make a mix with the ultra sans the underfell san and hardtale sans?
And now add this: ua-cam.com/video/8DTSgPnCEyg/v-deo.html xD