Kia Saheh BUKHARI 100 % hi SAHEH hai ??? An ILMI Reply to GHAMIDI Sb. (Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 чер 2017
- An Important Video CLIP from 175-a & b-Mas'alah [ A Special & Critical Q & A Session (Duration : 06-Hours & 15-Mints) recorded on SATURDAY, 10-June-2017 (The Night between 14 & 15-Ramzan-ul-Mubarik 1438 Hijri) at Qur'an-o-Sunnat Research Academy Jhelum City, Punjab PAKISTAN ] Link of Complete VIDEO : • 175-a-Mas'alah (Part-1...
![[Full Video] The Genius - Motivating Life Story Of Imam Al Bukhary](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/y69f-_CasAw/mqdefault.jpg)
He speaks very logically but I do not agree comparison of Holy Quran with Sahih. Holy Quran is Allah's dialogue and Sahih are written and narrated by Humans. Wrong comparison.
sahih bukhari ka narrator ki story parho muqadma of sahih bukhari jo aaj kal ki kutab me kha chukay hein
aap ko idea ho jaye ga k kis had tk sahih hai bukhari
He is a sunni. Has to defend bokhari and. Muslim. Sunni moulvis worship bokhari as much as holy Quran
Only meaning fault
@@smaalqadri9425 you'll never be able to understand the Qur'an as it should be understood without ahadiths
@@smaalqadri9425 lots of people do not have the same logic so how can we depend by the logic of people when interpreting the Qur'an?? That's why we need hadiths, we need to see how did the prophet Sallahu Alahi Wassalam himself and his companions understood the ayats
قرآن پاک کے سوا انسانوں کی لکھی ہوئی ہر کتاب میں غلطیاں ہو سکتی ہیں
100% right 💯☑️☑️
Ghalti ka imkan hy mgr authenticity pe bh ummat ka ijma hy
True
Zeby Shah : yehi baat to Ghamdi sb kehte hein jisper log unhein munkarin e hadees kehte hein
@@smshafique9873brother ya sb Bs Insano ki banai kitab Pr Itna bharosa krta K Quran ko pichy chor diya h
قرآن اور حدیث کا کوئی مقابلہ نہیں۔
قرآن حفاظت شدہ ہے اور الفاظ اللہ ہے۔
جبکہ احادیث کو لوگوں نے بیان کیا ہے جس میں غلطی کا بہت امکان ہوتا ہے۔
درست ھے کتابوں کی لکھائ غلط ھوسکتی ھیں حدیثوں پر نہیں کتابوں پر تنقید ھوسکتی ھیں
Happy to see muslims are not being blind followers and capable of criticising with respect. Love you Ummah...❤️
قرآن مجید میں کوہی شک نہیں ہے ۔
Sirf QURAN E PAAK main koi shaq nahi.
@@MuhammadFaisal-ed6zx aur Hadith?
@@adnanamin3068 jee Hadith main shaq hai. Kiyun koi insan ghalti say paak nahi
Isliye hadees k background main aur aagay quote kernay main ghalti ho sakti hai.
Beshaq
Beshak
قرآن اور انسانوں کی لکھی ہوئی کتاب میں زمین آسمان کا فرق ہے
Shah Zain bhai unho ny yehi baat kahi ha k sird hadees 100 percent sai han
لکھی نہیں- بلکہ جمع کی گئ کتاب ہے۔ حدیث خود سے کوئ نہیں لکھ سکتا-
Zohaib Ahsan
جمع نہیں سُن سن کر لکھی
جمع وہ ہوتی ہے جو پہلے کہیں موجود ہو
@@shahzain7207 حدیث حضور ﷺ کے زمانے سے لکھی جا رہی ہے--
مزید معلومات کے لیے محاضرات حدیث کتاب کا مطالعہ کریں
One of the best thing about His Videos is there are no Ads.
Me ek dafa tariq masood sab ki vedio open ke..is qadr start me bahoda add aya jo aaj tk me ne you tube ki Kse vedio pr ni dkaha.add tha ek app ka k aap b GF banain.tender type..r mrd orat vedio call pr bat kr rhy thy or jtna bahoda libas tha us orat ka.aaj tkk Kse add me nhi dkah you tube k..r ek lmhy ko mjy lga k me ne shaid koi or vedio open kr de hai add khtm hoa.skip kya to tariq masood sab ki taqreer ai🤨🤨😧😧☺️
I realised now
Oh really I too realised now
@@uzmakashif4131 his channel is not monetized
he earns 0 from his channel
@@Basit7729 : his viewer ship is so high he can earn more than 4 crocres per year ,if he monitizes his channel ,but he said ,he is earning more than that for akhira ... insha'Allah
Jazak Allah khair
We are not exempted from making mistakes.
Our lives are test and tribulation
May Almighty Allah swt protect us
بے شک اللہ کا قرآن اور نبی محمد صَلَّى اللّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّم کی حدیث مبارک حق اور سچ ہیں
حدیث کے حق ہونے پر شک نہیں ہے مگر حدیث کے حدیث ثابت ہونے پر بحث ہے
بھائی قرآن سچ ہے اورسنت رسول اللہ ﷺ پر عمل کرو اور نبی کریم صلی اللہ وعلیہ وسلم کا ہر عمل قرآن کے مطابق تھا اور ہم ایسی حدیث کیسے مان جائے جو قرآن سے ٹکرائیں الله تعالیٰ ہم سب کو رسول ﷺ کے اسوہ حسنہ پر چلنے کی توفیق عطا فرمائے آمین
@@maulanasyedabbasbaqarioffi6719 Exactly
یہی تومسئلہ ہےجب کوئی بات کرتا ہے حدیث کی Authentcity پہ تو لوگ فوراً منکرین حدیث کہہ دیتے ہیں جب کو وہ سنت اور حدیث کا منکر نہیں ہوتا بلکہ وہ تحقیقی گفتگو کر رہا ہوتا ہے کہ یہ حدیث ہے بھی یا گھڑی گئی ہے۔
@@maulanasyedabbasbaqarioffi6719 اسما الرجال کا مطالعہ کیجئے
@@quranaurahlulbait11395 Bhai 1400 saal Baad kaisay pata chalay ga k kon asma o rajjal k mutabik sahi hai
(إِنَّا نَحۡنُ نَزَّلۡنَا ٱلذِّكۡرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُۥ لَحَـٰفِظُونَ)
[Surah Al-Hijr 9]
وہی تو
علی بھائی نے مایوس کیا
Sahi baat.
اس مرزا حرامی خبیث شیطان کے پیشاب کے غلیظ کیڑے کے آگے " خنزیر تے شے ای کوئی نہیں۔۔۔۔
@@candkdaram5019 علی بھائ نے بلکل نیوز کیا قرآن محفوظ ہے پر اللہ نے قرآن میں کہیں نہیں کہا کہ احادیث بھی محفوظ ہیں احادیث لوگوں سے سن سن کر آتی ہیں اور لوگ جتنے بھی نیک ہوں غلطیاں کر سکتے ہیں جھوٹ بول سکتے ہیں لوگ کوئ فرشتے تو نہیں۔احادیث جعلی بھی آئ ہیں بہت
@@AliRaza-cp6rs tou phr aese tou saari hi ahadees ghalat hain, kyun ke agr insaano ne likhein hain tou sahi nhi hongi, tou jb koi kisi masle mein phans jaaye aur Quran use satisfy na kare tou woh bs phr haath pr haath rkh kr beth jaaye kyun ke maulana ke paas jaaye ga toh woh bhi insaan hai ghalti kr sakta hai, isi tarah uski bhi kisi baat ki guarantee nhi, mtlb aap ki baat se yeh baat nikaal sakte hai ke Allah ne jo Quran mein kaha hai ke "Aaj ke din mein ne tmlogon ke liye yeh deen mukammal krdiya hai" ghalat hai kyun ke agr koi cheez mein Quran mein na mile tou hadees pr yaqeen kr nhi sakte kyun ke woh tou insaano ne likhein hain ghalat bhi hoskati hain??
Allah says in Quran that if a book is been written by human , you will find contradiction in the book. Saying Bukhari is 100% correct is against Quran.
Reference of ayat?
@@zubairahmad4462 31-6,7
Estagfirullah, the ahadees is by Muhammad (saw) the final messenger of God. How can you say that wrong?
@@Farhan_mft7 45-6
@@thecallerOO7 wa atiullaha wa atiul-rasool... isn't this is the verse of quran?
Quran is 100%word of allah azzawajal and Allah promises to safeguard the authenticity of Quran but Hadis may be Sahi but not comparable to Quran not at all 👍
Baat Quran aur hadees k comparison ki nahi h..
Ilmi tor par Hadeeso k andar jo waqiat hn uske andar contradictions paida hoti hn k ye waqiat insani jazbaat aur insani akal k mutabiq kya fit bethte hn? unke baare m sahi aur galat acceptable & non acceptable raae kaayam ki jaati h isilye k wo insani akal k mutabiq fit in nahi hote..
Usi tarah Ali bhai ne kaha agar ye apki daleel h hadeeso ko radh karne ki to ye rule aap Quran par kyu nahi lagate? Aise kai waqiaat Quran k andar bhi mojud hn par waha nahi karenge.. Kyu..? Kyu k wo ALLAH ki kitaab h isilye.. To mere bhai ye bhi to Nabi ki hadeese hn jo khud ALLAH ki taraf se hn wo konsa Nabi ne apni marzi se baate ki hn.. Baat to ek hi h..
Isilye jo cheeze Quran k andar milti hn agar aise waqiaat hadeeso m sahi sanad k saath mil jae wo bhi mainstreams ki books m to unko manne ki bhi wahi hesiyat h jo Quran k waqiaat ko manne ki hesiyat h..
Sir hadis ki kitaab ko hadis ki kitaab sy compare karen
Quran ki hifazat to Allah krta hai
Donkeys will never understand this. Allah aur bukhari, barabar nahin hai !
Kya zabardast baat kari bhai aapne , subhan Allah. Aapki is behen ( from uk 🇬🇧) ki taraf se bohot duaen .
@@f.b.i5639 bachho ka ni h bado ka h
@@f.b.i5639 😇 bhai bukhari aur muslim me
6000 tak hadith h unme se zada se zada 10 pe hi ikhtalaf hota h ki ye fabricated h
Bhai hadith ko manna zaroori h( jo quran se na takrati ho aur sahi sanad ke sath ho) kyoki allah tala ne farmaya
ALLAZI ALLAMA BIL QALAM
allah wo hain jisne qalam ke zariye ilm sikhaya h (ab aap ye bataye ki sirf qalam ke zariye ilm sikhaya h allah tala ne )
یہاں تو انجنیئر صاحب کسی طریقے سے بھی مطمئن نہیں کر سکے.. قرآن الہامی کتاب ہے اور اس میں جو کچھ بھی ہے اس میں کوئی اختلاف نہیں ہے... انجنیئر صاحب سے سوال کرنے والے بھائی کو سلام
انجینر صاحب قران مجید کے بارے میں بغیر علم کے بحث نہ کریں حضرت مریم علیہ سلام نے درد زہ کی وجہ سے کہا تھا کہ میں مر چکی ہوتی اور بھولی بسری ہو گی ہوتی
Sahi baat hai.mirza saab sahi mutmain ni ker sakay.
نہ نہ انجینٸر صاحب کہانی بیان نہ کریں
ایسے تو حضرت ابراہیم ع کے بارے میں کیا کہیی گے ۔
@@jaleesansari4486 SAHIB :::
1.......,,, ALI MIRZA SAHIB COSIDER HIMSELF GREATER AALIM THAN ALL SAHABAS EVEN PROPHETS , THIS IS WHY HE INSULTS OF THOUSANDS OF SAHABAS SOME TIMES OF GOD AND MOHD PBUH......
2......,,,, HE INSULTS BIBI MARYAM TOO THAT MARAYAM SHOULD NOT HAVE SO AND SO...
3. GOD MAY GUIDE ALI MIRZA OVER THE THE RIGHT PATHS OF ALL PROPHETS AND SAHABAS AND SALEHEENS.... AAMEEN ::::
Illogical logics, Engineer sb. The point is very simple: A hadith are narrated by humans, and may have the chances of errors, while Quraan is revealed by Jibraeel AS from Allah (SWT) Prophet (SAW), so there is no obection at al. Also, even Bukhari's compilation a couple of hundred years after the Prophet (SAW). So, we need to connect Islamic history and jurisprudence involving our tabeen and Aimma karam as well who were born and raised well before the Imam Bukhari (RA). May Allah give us understanding and forgive our sins.
I dont know why people in the comments totally missed the point of his arguments. Damn bois, Atleast understand his arguments before making a fool out of yourselves
Bhai konsa paimans ikhtiyar karoge......
Har insaan apni awqath samajhna chahiye warna patha chala ke aakhurath me bhatakte phirrahe ho....
Huge respect for Mirza Engineer. Why are we arguing about things that we don’t have knowledge.
قرآن میں عقل کے خلاف کچھ بھی نہیں ہے۔۔ استغفر اللہ۔۔ گھڑی گئ احادیث کا دفاع اس طرح کرنا افسوسناک ہے
جنہیں صحیح احادیث رسولﷺ اپنی عقل کے خلاف نظر آئیں وہ اپني عقل کا علاج کروائیں
V good
Gharri gai ahadees ka difa koi nhi kar rha, sahi hadees ka difa kr rhy hain.
ان سارے سوالوں کے جواب قران میں موجود ہیں ڈرامے نہ کر تیرا ایجنڈا ہی یہی تھا مسلمانوں میں بے یقینی پیدا کرنا
اب یہ تو ہوگا
Maulvi please be respectful when discussing prophets and other holy personalities. You were very rude while speaking about Hazrat Marium.
Agreed plz be respectful
right bro , I was about to say same
bahi zara is key baat ko poreee tajaha say sono phair bolo
Rude nahi the vo aap smjha rhe h Jo hadith ki book nahi mante or y ki maan lenge to unki sari baat chahe vo namahrm se hath milane ka waqia h ya JoJo sare izma k khilaf Jo bol rhe h vo sare baat apne aap khatm ho jaegi AGR hadith maan lete
Soon Mr maulvi going to claim himself above all ulama . Apny hr lecture m fakhria andaz m khta h " maira yai lecture lakhoon logon n dkha h kici ko itny views nhi milai "" Bly o Bly molvi sab
ماشاء اللہ اللہ تھجے لمبی زندگی دے تاکہ مسلمانوں کی اصلاح کرتا رہے
میں حیران ہوتی ہوں اتنے سخت اور تیكهے الفاظ کا کتنے آرام سے answer کرتے ہیں یہ scholler ..
ye fitna parast han
@@ShabirAhmad-vw3hy
Q kia yeh kehta hai k Quran Direct paaro gy tuu ghumrah ho jow gy?
Kia yeh bolta hai k Qabber ki poja kro?
Kia yeh ap ko bolta hai, k iss k pichy logo?
Aik banda ap ko Quran o sahih Hadees say jorr raha hai, orr app babbi log uss k Dushmen ho gy ho..
I'm also ex-Brailvi, ex Deobandi, ex Wahabi,
Now just a simple Muslim,
Just follow Quran and Sahih Hadees. Alhumdulilah
Deen ka ilim hasil krna her Musalman mard o orat per faraz hai.
Ya Allah marey ilim main ezafa kr.
Ya Allah madad.
Alhumdulilah
@@YaAllahMadad101
Bhai jan
Apki niyyat achi hai.
Qur'an o Hadees parhain us par amal karein.
Ap shyd pehlay kisi firqay say thay magr main Ali bhai ko sunnay say pehlay hi is natijay par pohnch gya tha kay sirf Muslim hi rhna hai aur Muslim hi marna hai.
Mera aapko bradraana mashwara hai kay Ali Bhaee ko sunain aur zaror sunain.
Magr baqi sab ko bhi sunain. Molana ishaq,Tariq Masood,Dr Israr Ahmed,Javaid Ghamdi,AssimAlHakeem,Mufti Rashid, is kay ilawa bhi jitnay molvi hain unhe bhi suna kerein.
Warna yeh aise hi hai kay aap kisi aik Imam ki taqleed say nikal kar dosra banday Ali Bhaee ki taqleed mai lag gaye.
Alhamdulillah hamara yeh aqeeda hai kay ambiya kay ilawa koi bhi masoom nahi hai. Lihaza Ali bhaee ko sunta hua yaad rakhein kay anjane main in say ghalti honay ka andesha hai aur yeh har banday kay liye siwae ambiya kay liye rahy ga.
ضعیف احادیث اور راویوں کے دفاع میں قرآن کی آیات کا اس طرح موازنہ ضعیف احادیث کے متن سے کرنا بالکل سمجھ سے باہر ہے۔
Aap ya ahle hadees faisla karenge kya ? K konsi hadees zaeef hai aur konsi qawi
Correct
Ye zaeef nahi mustanad hadeesen hain
Bukhari Shareef main koi Hadees zaeef nahii
@@jawadshaikh135 اسناد کے ساتھ ساتھ متن پر بھی غور کرنا چاہئے۔
Absolutely wrong comparison of Quran with the books of Hadees. Quran e Majeed is a 100% divine book revealed by Almighty Allah.
but we cant ignre also imprtnce or ahadess...
u r rit but sir topic is clearnce of hadess book writ wrong
100% right.
I think you haven't listened what he said at the end
I agree with you. Don't follow blindly anyone.
Thoda ehtiyath karo bhi apne aapku turrm khan na samanjhen.....
Dimagh istemal karo laikin logon ku bhatkao nahin....
Tum insaan ho farishte nahin ho.....
Brother he isn't comparing Quran with hadees but the topic is using our thoughts or wishful thinking with the hadees ....
He 's saying if u use ur thoughts on hadees use ur thoughts on Quran too...... Which u can't.........
Allay has said القرآن - سورۃ نمبر 15 الحجر
آیت نمبر 9
أَعـوذُ بِاللهِ مِنَ الشَّيْـطانِ الرَّجيـم
بِسْمِ اللّٰهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ
اِنَّا نَحۡنُ نَزَّلۡنَا الذِّكۡرَ وَاِنَّا لَهٗ لَحٰـفِظُوۡنَ ۞
ترجمہ:
بلاشبہ ہم نے { الذکر } اتارا ہے اور بلاشبہ ہم ہی اس کے نگہبان ہیں
Engineer sahab ki Nafsiyat ka andaza bari achi tarah say ho rha hai.. "Tera kutta kutta, mera kutta tommy." Sari Zindagi dusron ky babon ki tazleel karnay ky baad ab apnay Babay kay difah ky liye Quran aur Allah ky Nabiyon ki Tauheen kar rha Hai.
think before speak i used to listen your vidoes and was very imoressed but now the way u explained Quranic waqaiat and about messenger and maryam A.s, it is really hurting please be carefull while talk about great personalities
Hey brother his Panjabi Panjabi dialects come when can't express ur urdu expression in Panjabi tu wu are not abusive language bro
Nomaan mehdi what do you mean by that? If he cannot address his accent he should shut the hell up. He is making none sense comparison.
You look idiot
He said something at the end.. Plz listen.
I think ur brain is located inside ur butt
Kindly be careful and respectful while talking about prophets and their wives and mother
Also be careful when talk about ahadees, sahaba, tabe tsbaeen muhaddiseen etc......
If anyone think 🤔 that engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza is wrong then he/she is the real gustak e rasool
Very right
I was thinking so.
@@mohammadhamiahmed2980 تمہاری بات سے ایسا لگتا ہے کہ تم انجینئر کو اللّٰہ کا رسول مانتے ہو نعوذباللہ۔ کسی کو گستاخ رسول کہنا ٹھیک بات نہیں۔
Informative discussion! Mashah Allah
" مولوی ابلیس کو بھی ورغلا کر بیچ دے
اس کی خوشی بختی کہو کہ سامنے نہیں آ تا"
حضرت علامہ ناصر عباس صاحب قبلہ ،
مجالس خطیب الایمان ص 8
اللہ پاک کا شکر ہے کہ مجھے حافظ ابو یحی نور پوری صاحب کے یو ٹیوب پر اصلاح میڈیا چینل پر کلپس دیکھنے کا موقع ملا اور ذہن میں انجینر مرزا محمد علی صاحب کے پیدا کئے گئے شکوک و شبہات کا اللہ پاک کے فضل و کرم سے خاتمہ ہوا۔ اللہ پاک انجینر مرزا محمد علی صاحب کو بھی بد گمانیاں پالنے کی بیماری سے نجات عطا فرمائے۔ آمین۔
بخاری انسانی کوشش ھے غلطی اس میں کیوں نہیں ھو سکتی۔۔۔۔۔۔
There can be. But the question is how do you determine whether a narrative is authentic or not. Our classical scholars have developed a systematic scientific method to do so( study the science of hadith for details). Whereas people like ghamidi suggest that we should outright reject a hadith just bcz it apparently goes against our intellect. Problem is that you cannot apply tge same methodology in case of Quran. Many Quranic verses SEEM illogical, intellectually unacceptable but we still accept them. It’s just that human brain isnt perfect and we cannot fully trust it to authenticate the sources.
وہاں ہو سکتا ہے. لیکن سوال یہ ہے کہ آپ یہ کیسے طے کرتے ہیں کہ کوئی روایت مستند ہے یا نہیں؟ ہمارے کلاسیکی علماء نے ایسا کرنے کے لیے ایک منظم سائنسی طریقہ تیار کیا ہے (تفصیلات کے لیے حدیث کی سائنس کا مطالعہ کریں)۔ جبکہ غامدی جیسے لوگ تجویز کرتے ہیں کہ ہمیں کسی حدیث کو صریح رد کرنا چاہیے کیونکہ یہ بظاہر ہماری عقل کے خلاف ہے۔ مسئلہ یہ ہے کہ آپ قرآن کے معاملے میں وہی طریقہ استعمال نہیں کر سکتے۔ بہت سی قرآنی آیات غیر منطقی، فکری طور پر ناقابل قبول معلوم ہوتی ہیں لیکن پھر بھی ہم انہیں قبول کرتے ہیں۔ یہ صرف اتنا ہے کہ انسانی دماغ کامل نہیں ہے اور ہم ذرائع کی تصدیق کے لیے اس پر مکمل اعتماد نہیں کر سکتے۔
حضرت عائشہ کى 9سال عُمر ميں شادى کسى طرح ممکن نہيں.....
يہاں تاريخى غلطى ہوئى ہےپورى اُمت سے...
غامدى صاحب کى تاويل قدرےبہترہے
پوری امت سے غلطی ہوئی ہے؟؟؟ کچھ تو خیال کریں یہ ناممکن ہے.....
Please don't compare book of Allah with a book of a person however pious he may be.
It’s so hurtful to hear this.
Yeh gumrahi ka rastey hai.
I never watch his videos...
But someone had sent me this link... & it is unforgivable,
Just stop following him...
For the simple reason that the process of collection of hadis started generations after the holy prophet, regardless of which source a particular hadis belongs, it can never equal the Book of God itself in the level of certainty and authenticity.
If a person stucks in any problem and Quran doesn't satisfies him, where would he go for his answer
And why is that shia people believe hadees that are only in favour of them and reject which are not in favour of them
And on which base do shia people believe those hadith when you are saying the process started genertaions after Nabi saw, it clearly shows you are denying words of Prophet saw, and if they are not authenticated how can you say that you follow sunnah, after all at some place you would also take help ftom hadith
قرآن تو کلام اللہ ہے. آپ ایسی بات نہ کریں
Yah banda qadyani hAaa
@@nawazhussain8198 لعنت ہے تم پر
بھائی ایسی کونسی بات کی ہے انہوں نے؟😑
@@nawazhussain8198 Bhai mai is mamlay mai engineer say ikhtalaf rkhta hun mgr apka yay kehna munasib nahi hain
HADIS kisi ARABI NE LIKHI HAI AUR MOHAMMED S.A.W. K KITNE SAAL BAAD LIKHI GAYI HAI ??
Age of Ayesha (RA) was most likely 19 when married. And it's not to please anyone but a mere fact.
Don’t be a blind reader, comparison of authenticity for Quran and Hadith is foolish.
Hadis is the collection of people after a gap of several generations based on their memory.
It if full of mis quotes and even against ayat of Quran itself.
Agreed
اس مرزا حرامی خبیث شیطان کے پیشاب کے غلیظ کیڑے کے آگے " خنزیر تے شے ای کوئی نہیں۔۔۔۔
Qur'an sits on judgement over hadith....
Ali bhai is mamle me main apse differ karta hun....
Qur'an ko Allah protect karte hain....
Lkn hadith agar Qur'an ke khilaf he ga to wo hadith galat hai....
YAAR JAISAY GHUSTAKHI E RASOOL KA MAMLA HAY USMEI QURAN KI AIK AYAT HAY SURAH NISA MEI JISMEI ALLAH PAK FARMATAY HAY KAY JO GHUSTAKHI MAZHAB KI YA DEEN KI KARAY AP USKAY SATH NA BETHO PAR HUMARAY MOLVI IS AYAT KO REJECT KARAY GAY AUR QATAL PAR ZORR DEGAY.AGAR UNSAY KAHA JAYE TOH WOH HUMAY HEE GHUSTAKH KARAR DEDAY GAY
@@hamzaiqbal2950 .. Mulla se hi to bachana hai deen ko ... in ko har woh hadith jis mein maar kutai ho aur aurat discuss ho rahi ho bahut pasand hai ..... usi se in ki dukaan chalti hai ... agar yeh sab na ho to in ki dukaan band ho jaye gi ... Hadith is a man made research work with full of fake stories and mistakes. Hadith ek history book to ho sakti hai magar deen se koi talluq nahi hai .... Quran is the divine revelation and word of God.
نبی کا یہ آرگیومنٹ مشیت الہی کے تحت تھا کہ دنیا جان جائے کہ اللہ نے چاہا تو عمر درمیان میں حائل نہیں ہوتی
NABI pak s.a.w.w or ahly baiet a.s py lakhon darood o salaam....💚🌟🌹❣
شان حضرت مولا علی علیہ السلام احادیث رسول صل اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کی روشنی میں.
حدیث :- 1
"علی کا چہرہ دیکھنا عبادت ہے"۔
حوالہ :- (مستدرک الحاکم جلد 3 صفحہ 11)
حدیث نمبر :- 2
"علی کا ذکر عبادت ہے"۔
حوالہ :- ( کنز العمال جلد 11
صفحہ 601)
حدیث نمبر :- 3
"علی کو مجھ سے وہی نسبت ہے،جو موسی کو ہارون سے تھی سواے اس کے کہ میرے بعد کوی نبی نہیں"۔
حوالہ :- ( صحیح بخاری جلد 3 صفحہ 1142)
(صحیح مسلم جلد 31 صفحہ نمبر 5931)
حدیث:- 4
یوم خیبر ، "کل علم اس کو دوں گا جو اللہ،اسکے رسول کا محبوب ترین ہوگا"۔
حوالہ :- ( صحیح مسلم جلد 31،صفحہ 5917)
حدیث:- 5
"میرے بعد جو چیزیں باعث اختلاف ہوں گی ، ان میں علی کی عدالت سب سے بہترین ہے" ۔
(کنز اعمال جلد 13، صفحہ 120)
حدیث نمبر:- 6
"علی تمہارے درمیان بہترین حاکم ہے"۔
(کنز اعمال جلد 13،صفحہ 120)
حدیث نمبر:- 7
" میں سردار فرزندان آدم ہوں، (علی) سرور عرب ہے"۔
حوالہ :- (مستدرک الحاکم جلد 3، صفحہ 123)
حدیث نمبر:- 8
"یوم خندق ضربت علی, ثقلین کی عبادت سے افضل ہے "۔
حوالہ :- (مستدرک الحاکم جلد 3 صفحہ 34)
حدیث نمبر :- 9
"علی کے گھر کے علاوہ مسجد نبوی کے اندر کھلنے والے تمام دروازے بند کر دیے جائیں" ۔
حوالہ:- (مستدرک الحاکم جلد 3،صفحہ 125)
حدیث نمبر:- 10
"علی مجھ سے ہے اور میں علی سے ہوں"۔
حوالہ جات :- (مسند احمد ابن حمبل جلد 5،صفحہ 606)
( صحیح ترمذی جلد 13،صفحہ 168)
حدیث نمبر:- 11
لشکر روانہ کرتے وقت فرمایا، "خدایا مجھے اس وقت تک موت نا دینا جب تک علی کو دوبارہ دیکھ نہ لوں ،راوی ام ایمن " ۔
حوالہ :- (صحیح ترمذی جلد 13 صفحہ 178)
حدیث نمبر:- 12
علی حق کے ساتھ ہے اور حق علی کے ساتھ ہے۔ حوالہ :- ( صحیح ترمذی جلد 31،صفحہ 166)
حدیث نمبر:- 13
اہل سنت کے مفسر امام جلال الدین سیوطی نے تفسیر در منثور میں درج کیا ہے جب قرآن کی یہ آیت آئی کہ :-
اے رسول ! پہنچا دیجئے اپنے رب کی طرف سے جو آپ پہ نازل ہوا... (سورہ مائدہ 67)
اس آیت کے بعد آخری حج سے واپسی پر خم غدیر کے مقام پر رسول (صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم ) نے سوالاکھ صحابہ کرام کے مجمعے میں علی (علیہ السلام ) کا ہاتھ بلند کر کے اعلان کیا :- "جس جس کا میں مولا ، اس اس کا علی( علیہ السلام ) مولا
حدیث نمبر :- 14
"جس نے علی کو ستایا ، اس نے مجھے ستایا" ۔ حوالہ :- (مسند امام احمد ابن حمبل جلد 4 صفحہ 534)
حدیث نمبر:- 15
"جس نے علی سے دشمنی کی ، اس نے مجھ سے دشمنی کی"۔
(مناقب علی ابن ابی طالب صفحہ 192)
حدیث نمبر:- 16
"اے علی ! مومن کے علاوہ کوئی تم سے محبت نہیں کرسکتا، منافق کے علاوہ کوئی تم سے بغض نہیں رکھ سکتا"۔
حوالہ :- (صحیح ترمذی جلد 13 صفحہ 177)
حدیث نمبر:- 17
"علی کی دوستی برائیوں کو یوں کھاتی ہے جیسے آگ لکڑی کو" ۔
حوالہ:- (کنز العمال جلد 11،صفحہ 125)
حدیث نمبر:-18
"اے علی ! جو ہماری اطاعت کرے گا اس نے خدا کی اطاعت کی"، راوی ابوذر غفاری
حوالہ:- (مستدرک الحاکم جلد 3،صفحہ 123)
حدیث نمبر:- 19
(میرا پروردگار مجھے رات کو آسمان لے گیا اور علیکے بارے میں مجھے 3 چیزوں کی وحی کی )
"علی پرہیز گاروں کا پیشوا ، مومنین کے ولی ، اور نورانی چہروں کے رہبر ہے"۔
حوالہ:- (مستدرک الحاکم جلد 3،صفحہ 138)
حدیث نمبر:- 20
میں علم کا شہر ہوں اور علی اسکا دروازہ ہے۔
حوالہ جات:- (کنز العمال جلد 13 صفحہ 148)
(مستدرک الحاکم جلد 3،صفحہ 127)
حدیث نمبر:- 21
مواخات مدینہ ، "اے علی تم دنیا آخرت میں میرے بھائی ہو"۔
حوالہ(تاریخ ابن کثیر جلد 3،صفحہ 223)
😘😘😘😘
O mere bhai..jahan bat ambiya e karam ki chal rhi h aur tum Ali e ibn abi talib ko ly aye ho jy sahabi hain..Nabi nh hain
@@musicgiants9365 hahahaha yehi nishani ha bughaz e Haider ki. Jo b bat chal rahi ha to bhai ne konsi galat bat kr di Allah k Rasool saw ki bat he to ki ha bhai ne Allah k Rasool saw ki ahadees he to bayaan ki han koi apni traf se nayi bat to ni kr di phr kiun mirch lag gai ha apko
Ali ka zikar ibadat nh ha ibadat khalisatan Allah ki hoti ha
اور حضرت علی حضرت فاطمہ کے ہوتے ہوئے ابو جہل کی بیٹی سے نکاح کر نے والے تھے۔
اگر ان جیسے عالموں کی مجلس میں شرکت کرو گے تو دل قرآن اور انبیا"سے رہی سہی محبت وعظمت سے بھی فارغ ہو جائیں گے
zafar Iqbal 😂😂😂Shi kha
اس کو عالم کہنا علم کی توہین ہے اس کو نہ قرآن کی پروا نہ امہات المؤمنین کی پروا
ایک چھوٹے سے کمرے میں بیٹھ کر ویڈیوز بنا کر اپ لوڈ کرواتا ہے
Are bhai dekho toh Zubaan kaisi chala raha hai yaar
محمد علی صاحب کی وجہ سے میں دین کے زیادہ قریب آیا ہوں۔ جزاک اللہ خیراً۔ لوگ ان کی بیباکی کو گستاخی گردانتے ہیں جوکہ درست نہیں کیونکہ انہوں نے جو باتیں کی دلیل کے ساتھ درست ہیں۔
@@khurram41 pagal ho yaar tum ghaur se video dekho uska kaisi chaku ki tarah zubaan chala raha hai
Yar ye banda bohot zabardast or logical hai, lykin hadees k mamly main iski logic pta nai q ghas charny chali jati hai k insaan ki likhi hui kitabo ko Quran sy compare kr ra hai.
Exactly! The only matter he turns off his intellect is when it comes to authenticity and the general ideology of Hadiths..
.. more like he's scared to admit. Because 99% of his arguments are based on Sahih Hadiths.
Javed Ghamidi sahab has the perfect ideology of Hadiths, he knows how much percent really is actual Sunnah preserved in it, and what percentage has nothing to do with Islam.. a lot of Hadith are the source of misguidance in Muslims, esp the 73sect one.
I hope one day intellectual people like Engr Mirza and Dr. Zakir Naik would reflect upon this.
Islam = Qur'an and Sunnah only.
Bahot khub kiya misaalon se samjaya he aap ne
Alhamdulillah Allah aap ko or din ka fyhem ataa kare or dunya k shariron se hifazat kar Aaneen
Qur'an ko rassi ki tarah pakad lo,aur dusri kitabon SE sirf dispute hi Hoga ,Qur'an ek complete kitab hai.
Koi hadees Sahi hai ya galat ye Allah hi janta hai.
Toh phir tum namaz main Surah fatiha kyun parhty ho Woh toh Hadees main Likha hai ke Surah fatiha parhni hai Quran main toh nhi Likha aur purri namaz Ka tareeqa toh ahadees main hai Quran main toh Iska bilkul tazqirah Nahi siway iske ke namaz Qaaim Karo
@@jhalcricket2376 namaz parhanay ka tarika Hadith main bhi Nahin.
Kindly share with me that Hadith ! Open challenge to you.
Namaz hum nay sunnat say seekhi hai.
@@muslimpakistani6325 sunnat Kahan se sekhi hai?Zahir hai sunnat Hadees main hi hai
@@muslimpakistani6325 Sahih bukhari kholo 8th number pe namaz Ka chapter hai
Quran ko rassi se pakad lo matlab ? Quran ka matlab ap samjhayenge ? 😂
Bukhari Manmade book hai
Quran Allah ki book hai
samjhe Engineer Sahab
Agree
Na Quran man made hai na Sunnat-o-Hadith. Lekin Quran vi insano ne kitab ke sakal me mahfuj ki hai aur hadith vi. Lekin Hadith ko uski sanad aur quran par kabul kiya jaiga. Nabi (SAW) ne jo farmaya agar koi muslim usko na mane to o muslim hi nahi. Quran furqan hai. Is liye hadith ko quran se match kiya jaiga. Agar hadith Quran se takraye to hadith ko kabul niye kiya jaiga.
Listen from 13:41 please.....hahaha
@@yasinbaidya2814 bukhari sharif aamin be recited loudly after surah fateh but as per quraan offer nimaz neither loudly nor complete silently surah israeel
Bhaijaan aap ak word ko pakarkar usse sabit karna chatehe ke hadith nahi manna chahiye? Accha muje ak baat ka jabab dijiye. Quran loudly nahi silently nahi to kitna awaz se parna chaiye ??? Aap jab namaz jamat se parte hai us waqt imam saheb ki awaz sunai deti hai??? Aur konsa awaz loud hai aur konsa loud nahi hai bata dijiye Quran se.
جو لوگ مرزا انجینئیرصاحب کی تمام باتوں کا جواب قرآن و سنت کی روشنی میں سننا چاہیں وہ مفتی راشد رضوی صاحب کو ضرور سنیں
Thnx for this highly decorated explanation.... Well done 👌
قرآن کو عقل کی کسوٹی پر مت پرکھیں علی بھائی کیونکہ قرآن عقل سے بہت اوپر ھے
قرآن مجید کاترجمہ پڑھنے سے پتہ چلتا ہے اور ہمارے مولویوں نے ترجمہ اگے تشریح اپنے مطلب کی لکھی ہیں اور ساتھ کمزور حدیث لگاتے ہیں اور گالیاں شروع ایک گاؤں میں اگر ایک فرقے کے لوگ تھوڑے ھو دوسرے فرقے کا مولوی ضعیف حدیث پڑتا ہے اور کافر کافر ساری رات لوگ ڈرےھوے رات سوتے نہیں یہ قرآنی تعلم نہیں اگر کوئی مجلس سے بتادے مولوی صاحب دوسرے لوگ تھوڑے ہیں مگر لڑاکے ہیں تو کہتے ہیں پہلے بتانا تھا
I follow you from the UK and you only made sense to me but truly disappointed to hear this. You always declared , “na me wahbi na me babi etc” and now you are defending Bukhari putting Quran to test? Listen Nabi ASs were humans ok, and that really is the point. They behaved like humans whats wring in that? Do you know even Maryam (AS) whole situation? yes you are right because that was in QURAN therefore ALLAH is entitled to reveal the way HE wants. ALLAH inly can do such a thing even Zaid bin Harsa RA’s case.
But NO HADEETH OR BUKHARY ETC, cannot be matched with Quran neither their authority can match to Qurans. You are giving an answer actually you know when you say that because it is in Quran we believe. Yeah right BECAUSE THAT IS QURAN Not Hadeeth that has been written by humans later! Quran has been preserved by ALLAH not the rest of the books.
WeLLsaid.... First Time I Disliked Ali Bhai 's 'Video and absolutelY illogical Comparion ......... the examples He shared are also misunderstood by him.....😔
Pls follow dr.zakir nike
He never questioned the Quran ... did you watch the whole video ? He agreed to the fact that not all of the Bukhari is correct and that there are broken chains or no chains or generally daeef ahadees in it.
Watch till last I think You dinn't Watch Full video
I just watch engineer Mirza for entertainment. I get my knowledge from ghamidi sahib
My dear Ali Bhai, there is huge difference in the authenticity of Quran and Hadees,
Mullah will never agree that Hazrat Ayesha was about 18 years old, as they would make this case for themselves and keep open way to marry under age girls.
علی بھائی ضعیف احادیث کا موازنہ قرآن سے نہ کریں. امام بحاری سے احادیث جمع کرنے میں غلطی ہو سکتی ہے..
aap galti to saabit karo. Yehi to Ali bhai keh raha han
@Gamer boy bhai insaan hai hadees krny waaly log ALLAH nahi jo QURAN sy compare karein😀
@@mohsinrehman3026 Nabimazallah khud kushi keliye jate they(mazallah). Is se bari kya misal chahiye?
@@raiaon8754 bhai sahih bukhari ki sirf ahadees sahih han Ali bhai nay samjhaya abhi aap kaan khol kar video sun lo
@@mohsinrehman3026 Ahadees me bhi masle hain. Iman e Abutalib wali. Tab Janab Ibn e Abbasؓ ki age maximum 3 sal banti hai. 3 sal ka bacha kese riwayat kr skta hai?
قرآن کی کوئ ایک مزکورہ بات بھی عقل کے خلاف نہیں ہے
علی بھائی اللہ پاک آپ کو قیامت والے دن بغیر حساب کے جنت میں داخل کریں آپ بہت اچھا کام کر رہے اللہ آپ کا اور سینہ کھولیں اللہ آپ کو اور توفیق دے پاک آپ کے ماں باپ کو تندرستی دیے بیوی بچوں کی حفاظت کریں
علی بھائی آپ کو گمراہ کررہے ہیں آپ کی آنکھوں میں نمک ڈال رہے ہیں عقل کے ساتھ دین کو سمجھیں اندھی تقلید سے اپنے دین کا سودا اور اپنی آخرت کو تباہ ہونے سے بچائیں یہ نیم رافضی شعیہ ہے گرگٹ سے بھی ذیادہ یہ مرزا رنگ بدلتا ہے
Asslam o alikum
Ali bhai konsi sahih bukhari app hum parh sakte hai
Janab pls change ur attitude, good n soft way of talking is more fruit full mirza sb
Bhai yeh fruit atiuteude nai mante yeh babi aur wabi hain bhai
inko apna naam kamana hai or kuch nahi
Tariq jamil sb bohat methe hein pr wo ye batein ni krte ye batein ase he attitude se ki ja skti hein
Gamdi sahib bohat pyaar se baat karty hain phir kya Bralvi Deobandi ahdle hadees shai un ko maanty hai?
Quran is from ALLAH. The rest of the books are written by humans. Humans make error ALLAH is above error. Please dont compare Quran with any other book
Quran ki hifajath ki jimmeedari khud Allaah ne leli ..Allaah ne Sahi Bukhari ya kisi doosri kithab ki hifajat ki jimmedari nahi lee ! ... Injeel ki hifajath ki jimmedari nahi lee. Isliye maujuda jamane ki Injeel[Bible] tabdeel ki shikaar hogayee !
Anwer sarhandi Apne 100 percent sahi kaha
Quraan Ka Kya Tumhare Upar Utara Hai Ya Allah Ke Rasool Tumhe Khud Apne Hatho Se Quraan Deke Gye Hai Quran Bhi To Sahaba Ne Zama Kiya Hai Na.
@@Way__To__Jannah Oh saheb ap zara sochlo k ap bol.kya rahay ho sahaba ki jooti ki dhool bhi hum se zyada pak saaf hai aur agar yeh sahaba ne tehreer kiya hai tau kya ghalat kiya hai? Iss baat ka jawab do bus zara sahi se Islam ki history parho phir koo baat karo
@@Way__To__Jannah Apne Engineer sahab ko bachane k chakkar main kaheeb apne emaan se hi hath na dho bethna khayal karo
He speaks logical but at some point he forgets that Koran was totally memorized by sahabas and compiled by third caliphate Hazrat Usman bin affan Razi Allah tala, where hadees was written after 200 years..
یہ علمی قابلیت ہےمرزا کی۔۔ کوئی حال نہیں۔۔ایسے سوال سکولرز جواب دے سکتے ہیں یہ تھرا چھاپ مولوی جب ایک چیز کو نہیں سمجھ سمجھا سکتے تو کیوں وضاحت کی کوشش کرتے ہیں😊
Quran is a word of GOD, while Hadith is neither word of ALLAH (in absolute term) nor proven word of Rasulallah (in its healthiness.
Therefore, your opening statement of this video comparing and safeguarding HADITH vis a vis QURAN is an act of aggression and an outcome of material desire.
Please take care and agree that HADITH will always invite suspicion when it will not be harmonious with QURAN. (MUSHTAQ AHMAD KHAIR)
Yes it's absolutely right
hey now..hey now better migate or you may be killed!Molvi Zindabad
When the hadith go against the word of quran it's not a correct hadith & every hadith is selected with references to other hadiths & matching them
The words uttered by prophet Muhammad pbuh is through wahi. This is stated in Quran. therefore without hadees Islam is incomplete. your argument that Hadees is irrelevant is shallow n goes against Quran.
@mohammad khan who told you its fabricated. all the authentic hadees have been verified n zayeef hadees have been classified as such. before collecting those hadees in print form every one used to memorise n follow them. That's why Allah says " Follow Allah and His messenger".
9 سال والی شادی کی بات نبی پاک ص ہر تہمت اور الزام ھے۔۔۔۔
بخاری اور مسلم آسمانی کتابیں نہیں ہیں اور نہ ہی نبی پاک ص نے خود لکھوائی ہیں کہ ان کو غلط کہنا کفر ھے
bukhari muslim asmani kitab nahi hai laikin os mai jo ahadees hein wo Nabi ki hi btai hui hein lagi smjh!....
@@mohammadarslan1713 nahi bhai nabi(sa) nai khud nahi likhwayi
@@haiderchangezi hadees ko hifz kia gya huzoor k door m rr 99 hijri m jb sahaba ka door ikhtamam hua jb Mohammad bin Abdul Aziz n likhwaya wo bhi bhut mehnat kr kkk
@@Ahsankhan-dk1jx phir bhee ye kehna galat ha k ye kitabein 100 % durust hein , han quran se koi aisi bat mil jaey jo ye saabit kare k ye dirust hein 100%
Bhaai haqeeqat ko tasleem karna chahiye
Ali Bhai You're so knowledgeable and so logical. It shows you are on the next level of research and studies... Love your arguments and discussions. Hussain from Brisbane, Australia
Knowledgeable? Seriously? He can be knowledgeable for people like you.
@@wassiansari Please open your eyes... real hero isn't the one who writes hero infront of his name... It takes lots courage and wisdom to be recognized as a HERO 🙂
@@hussainakhtar1094 are we talking about this person on the video or about me ?
@@wassiansari come on brother.. you talked about both in your first statement and now asking me? Anyways, its not good to argue unnecessarily.. what I meant is that Engineer Ali Mirza bhai speaks after deep study and research which is why he is so much acknowledged... it is really very easy to comment on the videos..However, it does take alot of gutts to come infront and lead.. be happy and stay safe...
ہماری مال جان اور عزت نبی ص پر قربان
آج محمد علی صاحب نے ، مایوس کیا ۔۔۔۔۔کسی بھی اعتراز کا مناسب جواب نہیں دے سکے۔۔۔۔
Bhai shuru me jawab diya to hai kiyon ki kai ak sawal ka jawab sawal hi hota hai
اگر اعتراز کو آپ اعتراض لکھتے تو شاید آپ کو کوئی اعتراض نہیں رہتے! 😂
@@faizanbadardi صاحب قرآن اجماع سے منتقل ہوا روایت کو یہ خاصیت حاصل نہیں، اگر روایت کا علم قطعی ہو جائے تو لازماً آپ کا اعتراض درست ہوگا مگر ایسا ہے نہیں
مرزا جی! آپ کا لہجہ اکثر اوقات بہت تکلیف دہ ہوتا ہے۔ قرآن کریم میں مذکور واقعات کے بارے میں آپ کا بیان بشمول اندازِ بیان میرے جیسے شخص کے لئے بھی دل آزاری کا سبب بنا ہے۔ احتیاط کیا کریں۔ تکبر میں نقصان ہی نقصان ہے؛ یہاں بھی اور وہاں بھی۔ اللہ کریم توفیقات سے نوازے۔
English-hindi mein likhen...bahut ko urdu nhi aati,mujhe bhi nhi aaati urdu
Mirzaji aap ka lahja aksar auqaat bahot takleef deta hai
Shi bat h bhai ye doosro ko khte hain ki lfz ka istemal shi karen aur bazwaqt khud bhi gusse me kuch bhi kh deye h
sorry mujhe to is video my loi lehje ka masla nahi laga!
آپکی بات بالکل صحیح ہے
Had a lots of misunderstandings about this topic, thank you for clearing it up.
Hamari aqal itni nhi ki ham har baat samajh sake
قرآن لازمی ٹیسٹ سے گزرتا اگر یہ راویوں کی شرارت ہوتا اور مزل من اللہ نہ ہوتا
@@increasingofficial nhi ghlt aqeeda he apka , quran nabi ke dor hi me likha ja chuka he jnb
@@abdullahtaqi43 Aap ne sahi kaha.
@@maghauri1 allah ap ko hush rkhe .😊
@@increasingofficial hazrat Usman r.a na likhwa kar jahan jahan Muslims tha wahan tak puhnchaya ha likha gya ha hazrat Muhammed s a w ki nigrani main 🙏
قرآن مجید تو عقل کی بات ہر جگہ کرتا ہے کہ عقل والوں کے لئے نشانیاں ہیں مرزا صاحب آپ کے دلائل ناقص ہیں
to aap koi aqal ki baat to karein , hum bhi faizyaab ho jai ge
حدیث انسانوں کی لکھی ہے قرآن اللہ تعالیٰ کا کیسے موزانہ کرسکتے ہیں آپ موضوع حدیث ضعیف حدیث جبکہ قرآن حرف بہ حرف صحیح ہے
@@sibs8859 صیح حدیث بھی وحی ہے
suchi baat to yah ha k baz ahadees man gharrat lgti hn..kun k wo kisi zmanay ma fit nahe ati..
No comparison between Quran and book of Ahadeth also no one can guaranteed the 100% authenticity of Ahadeth book of any sect but Quran is 100% correct. Not agree on this with Ali bhai
You are right
Unfortunately, his arguments are not correct this time. I invite him to repent for asking to test Quran. Ahadees needs to be tested because they are recorded and coveyed to us by men and women who were not prophets. By the way no body, including prophets can see angels in their original form unless Allah makes it possible. All prophets mentioned in Quran who saw angels, they saw them in human form. Therefore they argue with them untill angles revealed them their identities. PLEASE REPENT.
Very true💯
Angels should carry an ID card.
View the video again to understand the way he makes his way to the logical answer he is to give. He doesn't doubt the Quran but instead a certain group of objecting people.
If someone has doubts about the Quran he is no Muslim, that's for sure.
Meray bhai wo phakko di unhon ne Unhon ne ye ni kaha ke syi main aisa kru
Allah ne Quran ko mahfooz rkhne ki responsibility ki hai
Hadees toh kitne 100 saal bad ai thi
Hadith ka matlab b pata he? Ha likhi 200 saal badh gy he par ravi te sahabio k olado me se he.
We can't compare quran with hadith ....Quran is the word of almighty creator , while hadees is just written by human , some degree of distortion is present coz human can be perfect.....
Allah SWT ne quran ki hifazat ka wada kra hai , hadees ki nhi !
First listen Full Video then comment your Opinion. please!😇😇
قرآن مجید اللہ پاک کلام ہے ۔ اس پر تم انگلی بھی نہیں اٹھا سکتا
Engineer ney to utha di.
O jahil insan wo misal dy ra ha tera taya
اللہ تعالیٰ تیرے شر سے محفوظ رکھے آمین یارب العالمین
Jo bhe baten aap Qur'an k hawaly say kr rahy ho un sab Ka jawab ghulam Ahmed pervez Sahab nay boht achy tarikay say wazeh ki he jawab deya he
The traditional narrations, which have been recorded & communicated by the people over a long period of centuries in most cases (except Mawatta Imam Malik) and are attributed to the sayings of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) as "Ahadees", are important (if authentic) in the understanding of Islam and Sunnah.
But, Ahadees cannot be considered in equal status with Quran e Majeed because of the elements of Human errors (by chance mistakes or deliberate falsification) in the chain of communication. Only the Quran e Majeed which has been revealed and preserved by Almighty Allah is the absolute truth and a standard to check the authenticity of Ahadees, not any other human being like Imam Bukhari or Imam Muslim or others etc.
Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) life and Sunnah was 100% based upon the teachings of Quran e Majeed through its practical demonstration. So, Quran e Kareem is not only the Divine Book descended by Allah Almighty but it also explains the Sunnet e Rasool of Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH) in vast detail.
The problem is our Ulma e Deen more rely on the traditional sayings attributed to Prophet (PBUH) i.e. Ahadees rather than Quran e Kareem.
Assalamu Alaikum... I have started Sahih Bukhari authentic series. With the completion of project, InshahAllah u will be completely go through Sahi Bukhari. U can visit my channel for more information. If u like it, subscribe for daily ahadees . JazakAllah
Khalidmajeed,
Yes, the Quran is, undoubtedly, unquestionably the divine words of Allah and is protected, preserved by Allah.
No Muslims (outside Indian subcontinent) believe SAHEEH Hadiths are words of Allah or divine.
Hadiths are collections of Rasul sa., works, advices, actions, and his consent.
And to understand, obey, follow Quran precisely, accurately, we Muslims definitely need Saheeh Hadiths. Without Saheeh Hadiths - you can not understand or obey, follow Quran.
For example -
Quran says pray NAMAJ.
How will I pray NAMAJ without Saheeh Hadiths?
Quran says perform HAJJ.
How will I perform HAJJ, and in which months, date, rules without Saheeh Hadiths?
Quran says, pay Zakat.
How, how many percentage, yearly or 6 monthly, how much property on which Zakat should be given etc?
And,
NAMAJ, HAJJ, ZAKAT ARE FOUNDATION DOCTRINES (THERE ARE MORE - One God, All Rasuld, all kitabs, hell, heaven, QIYAMAT, takder , Angels, etc).
If anyone denies, refuses Saheeh Hadiths, he refuses, denies Quran according to the Quran -
Quran 4:115 -
"" If anyone opposes, denies, rejects Rasullah, after hedayet is clear to him and follows a path different from man of faith ( Sahabas , Imandar Muslims), I, Allah will direct him towards the same path (wrong path, deviated path). And I will burn him in fire of JAHANNAM - what a destroying place to stay. "" "".
Quran 33:21 -
"-For believers (Momin), there are excellent examples in Prophet Mohammad sa" ".
Quran 4:80 -" those who obey, follow Rasul, as if they follow Allah - - - "".
Quran 4:65 - " - - those (munafiq) CAN NEVER BE MOMIN, MUSLIM unless they obey, follow, agree with You (Mohammad) as arbitrator, judge, decision maker, ruler of whole disputed, conflicting, contradicted issues, matters, topics, problems.
- - -" ".
This is new fitna- Ahle Quran, Munkare Hadiths. It is dangerous for Iman.
May Allah save all Muslims from all these new fitnas ( Qadiani Munkare Hadiths, Ahle Quran, Bahai, Kabar puja, etc).
@@michaelalan5520
As per authentic historical record, Ahadees were not written under the guidance and supervision of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) neither endorsed or verified by Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) himself. Similarly, Muslims don't have a single book or originally collected record of Ahadees which was written by any closely associated Companions of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) like Abu Bakar (R.A.) or Umar (R.A.) or Usman (R.A.) or Ali (R.A.) or any other notable Sahabi e Rasool (RA).
First compilation of the collection of Ahdees was written nearly 150 year after the death of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Whereas, the collection of Ahadees which are allegedly claimed to be as the most authentic or Sahih Ahadees like Al-Bukhari, Al-Muslim and other books of Sihah e Sittah were written after a period of 250 years to 450 years after the death of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
Each Collector of the Ahadees had his own personal criteria based on his likeness, opinion or preferences for the collection of Ahadees, dependent on the people to people communication spanning over many centuries.
Now, coming to your points which I summarize below with my own responses:
Micheal Alan:
(i) Ahadees are the words/ sayings of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and the denial/ rejection of Ahadees is the denial of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
Me:
Not agreed. Your claim seems to be a fanatic and biased one based on the ignorance, against the logic and historical record.
In reality Ahadees are the collection of narrations which are traditionally associated with the Verbal Sayings of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) through the chain of people memories over a period of multiple centuries. The criteria of the collection of Ahadees of each Collector was highly personalized, opinion based, inconsistent and unreliable since it was largely dependent on the individual personalities i.e. person to person communication (mostly non-written and verbal) over a period of multiple centuries. Neither Quran e Majeed, nor the established facts related with the era of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) were considered as the most significant or major contributing factors in the careful selection of Ahadees. Rather, individual personalities were given too much emphasis in the selection and collection of Ahadees.
As declared by the Almighty Allah, the ultimate criteria (Furqan) to identify or judge the Haq (Truth) mentioned in the previous Books like Torah, Zaboor and Anjeel etc is the Quran e Majeed (Furqan e Hameed) because of the man-made alterations and corruption (Tahreef) done in those previous Books.
Almighty Allah also ordered to the Prophet Muhammad PBUH that all matters of conflicts/ crimes committed by the Muslims or Non-muslims i.e. Jews, Christian and Pagans (if they reach to the Prophet Muhammad PBUH for resolution) must be decided by him in accordance with the Law and Justice Rules mentioned in the Holy Quran (Furqan e Hameed).
Therefore, a Hadees is a traditional narration for which it cannot be said with 100% certainty that these are the actual Words or Saying of Prophet Muhammad PBUH. The ultimate criteria to judge its reliability/ authenticity is the Holy Quran (Furqan e Hameed).
A Hadees can be considered as "Reliable" or "Authentic" in its conversational meaning if it meets the teachings, commandments and message of the Quran e Majeed (Furqan e Hameed) along with the established facts related with the era of Prophet Muhammad PBUH. If any Hadees meets above two conditions even then we cannot claim with 100% surety that a Hadees is the actual Saying of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), as the Prophet didn't leave with us any endorsed written record of Ahadees, rather, he handed over complete written record, carefully checked, verified and endorsed Book of Divine Revelation - Quran e Majeed.
Similarly, any Hadees which oversteps the defined boundaries by The Quran or contradicts against the message, commandment or teaching of the Quran e Majeed must be considered as fabricated, false and un-authentic Hadees regardless the claim of its Collector as a Sahih Hadees whether it belongs to Al-Bukhari or Al-Muslim or from any other source.
Micheal Alan:
(ii) Without Sahih Hadees you cannot understand, follow, obey Quran.
Me:
Quran e Majeed has been descended upon Prophet Muhammad PBUH by the Almighty Allah in an easy to understand prevalent language of Arabs in the conversational style. It was very easy to understand by the Non- believers whatever Quranic message was communicated to them by the Prophet Muhammad PBUH. However, there are few places in the Quran which are surely difficult to understand without Sahih Ahadees. So, I partially agree with you. However, at large your statement is misleading.
Micheal Alan:
We need Ahadees since we have learnt from Ahadees how to perform Namaz (Salah), Zakat, Hajj and other obligations and rituals etc. Quran e Kareem does not provide us details how to perform these obligations.
Me:
Muslims have learnt how to perform different religious obligations like Namaz (Salah), Zakat, Hajj directly from the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
Our beloved Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) gave us "Practical Demonstration (which is called Sunnah e Rasool)" of how to perform religious obligations and rituals along with the minute details. All Sunnah e Rasool (PBUH) have been preserved and transferred through a continuous process of "Practical Demonstration" to all parts of World generations after generations by the Companions of Rasool (RA), by the Ahl al-Bayt of Rasool (AS) and by the later followers of Deen e Islam. These Practical Demonstrations related with the obligations of Deen (Sunnah e Rasool) are still well intact in all major Sects/ Schools of Thought of Muslims with minor differences.
As far as the Ahadees are concerned, Ahadees cannot be considered comparable to the Quran and Sunnah (Sunnat) e Rasool (PBUH). However, all those Ahadees which are in conformity with the Quran along with the established facts may be considered and utilized as Sahih Hadees. Such Ahadees are very important and useful reference material to understand the life and teachings of the Prophet Muhammad PBUH and Quran e Majeed.
I really appreciate and love Engineer Ali Bhai for the real services to Deen e Islam he is doing. I have a question though, how can one compare Saheeh Bukhari & saheeh Muslim with Qur'an (Quran is divine revealed by Allah )while all books of ahadees are anyway narrated by human beings
💯
Imam abu hanifa k shagirdo k bhi shagird hain imam bukhari
اللہ ھم صل علی محمد و علی آل محمد کما صلیت علی ابراھیم و علی آل ابراھیم انک حمید مجید اللہ ھم بارک علی محمد و علی آل محمد کما بارکت علی ابراھیم و علی آل ابراھیم انک حمید مجید
Ahadees kay Numbers bi display kya kren na Jo Bukhari mn Ghalat rivayat hain.
quran is the book of Allah
without any nuqs
bukhari is written by people who can do error
انجینئر صاحب نے یہاں پر آکر اپنا علمی لیول بالکل گرا لیا ہے ناقص ترین دلائل اور قرآن پر حملہ کر دیا راوی بابوں کی محبت اور دفاع میں ۔
Exactly
Spot on
بلکل آپ صحیح کہہ رھے ہیں ، پر انسان شھرت کا بھوکا ہے اس دنیا کی چاہت نے اتنا اندھا کردیا ہے قرآن کی اھمیت ہی ختم کدی اور اس قرآن کا بدترین دشمن بن گیا ، ایسے شخص پر اللّٰہ کی اور مومنین کی لعنت ہو،
O bhi wo rawi babe thora hi hain apke babon ki man Len or Jo hadess ki asal kitabain chor dein jis mein ap saw ki Zindagi or namaz ke tariqe or bohat si chezein thi wo Kahan se loge😅
@waleedmansoor9839 Muslims learn those things by seeing not by reading hadiths
I am not saying hadiths should be completely reject but there are hadiths which talks things outside of the Quran while the Quran itself is complete.
First time I saw him very illogical and ghamdi sir is very aunthetic
Ghamdi is better
Ghamdi may be secretly a marzai
@@ameerhamza1112 bakwas kar rahe ho
@@imkhalidd1 very high chance
He looks pretty marzai and his opinion on hazrat eesa A.S is also same as marzai ppl
@@ameerhamza1112 maaf karda bahi .
علی بھائی آپ سے کچھ سوالات کرنے ہیں کونسے فورم پہ بات ہوسکتی آپ سے
جو اللہ پاک کے چنے ہوئے لوگ ہیں ان کو نہ دنیا میں کچھ ہوا ہے نہ آخرت میں کچھ ہونا ہے صرف لوگوں کو سمجھانے کے لیے تاکہ قیامت والے دن اللہ سے کوئی گلہ نہ کریں تاکہ ہمیں بتانے والا کوئی نہیں آیا
To hold fast to Islamic injunctions, the Muslims have three things: First, the Holy Quran. Secondly, the practice of the Holy Prophet (saw), which is called the Sunnah. The third source of guidance is Hadith.
Hadith and Sunnah should not be considered as one and the same thing. They are distinct, Hadith is one thing and Sunnah is another.
By Sunnah we mean the practice of the Holy Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be on him), to which he adhered and which appeared along with the Holy Qur’an and will accompany it. In other words, the Holy Qur’an is the Word of God Almighty and the Sunnah is the practice of the Holy Prophet (pbuh).
Ahadith are those traditions which were compiled from the statements of diverse narrators a century and a half after the demise of Holy Prophet of Islam (pbuh).
It has ever been the way of God that the Prophets bring the Word of God for the guidance of people and illustrate it in practice with their conduct so that no doubt should remain in the minds of people with regard to the Divine Word. They act upon it and urge others to do the same. Sunnah is a continuous practice which was started by the Holy Prophet (saw). It is only next to the Holy Qur’an in its certainty. As the Holy Prophet (saw) was commissioned for the propagation of the Qur’an, he was also commissioned for establishing the Sunnah.
As the Holy Qur’an is certain so is the continuous Sunnah which he practised. Both these tasks were performed by the Holy Prophet (saw) as his duty. For instance, when the Prayer services were made obligatory, the Holy Prophet (saw) illustrated by his action how many rak‘as were to be performed in each Prayer service. In the same way, he illustrated the performance of the pilgrimage. He thus established thousands of his companions on his practice. The practical illustration which has been continuous among the Muslims is the Sunnah.
On the other hand, the Holy Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be on him) did not have the Hadith recorded in his presence nor did he make any arrangement for its compilation. When the time of the companions of the Holy Prophet(saw) had passed some of their successors thought of compiling the Ahadith and they were compiled.
It is true that even if the Ahadith, which were collected after a long time, had not been compiled this would not have affected the real teaching of Islam for the Holy Quran and Sunnah had fulfilled this need.
The divine mission of the Prophet-hood of the Prophet of Islam Muhammad(pbuh) was to practice and preach the message of the Holy Quran. He was ordered by God Almighty to follow only the clear path of the Holy Quran in the matter of religion:
(Holy Quran 45:20-21) Then We set thee on a clear path in the matter of religion; so follow it, and follow not the evil inclinations of those who know not. Verily, they will not avail thee aught against Allah. And as for the wrongdoers, some of them are friends of others; but Allah is the Friend of the righteous. This Book contains clear evidences for mankind and is a guidance and a mercy for a people who possess firm faith.
Hazrat Ayesha(ra), when asked to describe the Prophet’s character, answered that his character was the Quran (Abu Dawud). What Holy Prophet(pbuh) did was what the Holy Quran taught; what the Quran taught was nothing else than what he did.
A saying or a practice of Holy prophet of Islam (pbuh) can not be against the message of the Holy Quran. A prophet never goes against His revelation. God Almighty has mentioned in reference of the Holy Prophet of Islam (pbuh):
(Holy Quran 69:45,47): '''And if he had forged and attributed any sayings to Us, We would surely have seized him by the right hand, And then surely We would have severed his life-artery''.
A true Muslim, after reading this verse of the Holy Quran, can not appraise that Holy prophet of Islam(pbuh), in the existence of this warning of Allah Almighty (if he had falsely attributed the smallest thing to God, He would have severed his jugular vein) had practised or preached something that had been forbidden in he Holy Quran.
The correct way, therefore, is neither to treat the Ahadith as having greater authority than the Quran, and not to prefer the statements in the Ahadith which are contradictory of the Quran ; nor to regard the Ahadith vain and false. The Quran and Sunnah should judge the Ahadith and those that are not opposed to them should by all means be accepted.
If we come across a Hadith which is opposed to the text of the Holy Quran, and it cannot be interpreted in any other way, we would reject it as spurious, inasmuch as God, the Glorious, has said:
''The revelation of this Book is from Allah, the Mighty, the Wise.'' [45:3]
''These are the Signs of Allah which We rehearse unto thee with truth. In what word, then, after rejecting that of Allah and His Signs will they believe?'' (Quran 45:7 )
This means that if the Holy Quran is conclusive and positive about a matter and its meaning is clear, a believer should not accept a Hadith which is clearly opposed to it. The same message is in the verse: '‘In what thing will they believe thereafter?'’(Quran 7:186).
According to these verses a true Muslim must accept the Book of Allah without condition and should accept a Hadith conditionally. (Ruhanikhazain)
What bla bla bla.
How do you know SUNNAH WITHOUT HADITHS?
How do you know Ayesha's statement about the character of Prophet Mohammad sa? You were not born then? Definitely, you are quoting a Hadiths that is collected later.
And Hadiths, by definition, is what Prophet himself did, what he said other to do, and what Sahabas did and Prophet consented (not prohibited).
Quran 4:150-151 -
Those who deny, refuse, oppose Allah and his Rasul and create division, separate between Allah and his Rasul, these are TRUE KAFEERS.
How do you know SUNNAH?
Definitely, from Saheeh Hadiths.
Keep your deviant, perverted, bizarre thought to yourself.
Quran 4:61 - when it is said to unbeliever to accept, believe to what Allah has revealed and accept, submit, obey Rasul, then you (Mohammad) will see those who are hypocrite, unbeliever, avoid,
by pass, detour, reject you (Rasul) in aversion.
So, if you reject Saheeh Hadiths (Sunnah), you thereby reject Quran
and you are outside the fold of Islam.
PERIOD.
Can you quote a Saheeh Hadiths that oppose Quran, as you are cunningly claiming?
Go ahead, produce your proof, evidence.
بھائی آپ اپنا لہجے اور طریقے پر نظر ثانی فرمائیں۔
بات جتنی بھی اچھی ہو اگر طریقہ یاُ لہجہ نہ ٹھیک ہو تو اس کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں۔ جَزَاكَم الله خَيْرً!
Lala Baloch o bhai bilkul thek lehja he ak kam kren ap tohed pr unlogo pr tbleghe kren jo shirk krty hen 10 sal bad ap bhi aesay hi bat krengy.
Agree
Lala Baloch Phir Kya Baat Hai Quran Ki Randi Bazar
Bilkul teek kha
Great
I will be grateful to you if you Please explain sahih bukhari vol 1 book 2 no.25
قران شریف سے کئی اعتراض نکل سکتے ہیں مگر آپ مانتے نہیں ،
The language used in this clip is extremely inappropriate. Please watch your words and the way you talk
Cz Engg could not get any way to satisfy audience
Yes he used rude language for Prophet Yaqoob AS and Maryam AS
@@Aman_Bhatti981 HM MUSALMAAN HAI QURAN MEIN ALLAH NY BHI AESY NAHI BOLA ENGLISH KO ANGREZON K LIYE REHNY DO
Eng. Sb. Take backe your steps, use your senses, you are loosing yourself in overconfidence, becareful.
Rasul allah sari umar aayashi krte rhe sex krte rahe londiyo se tum logo ko dukh lagra hai
مرزا صاحب!! میں بھی مکینیکل انجینئر ھوں ۔آپ کے کلپس بڑی قدر اور دلچسپی سے دیکھتا ھوں۔آپ بہت اچھی دل کو چھو لینے والی مدلل باتیں کرتے ھیں۔لیکن قران کے حوالے سےکی گئ بحث اور تنقید سے میرا آج پہلی دفعہ بڑادل دکھا ھے۔ مجھ سے یہ برداشت نہیں ھوا۔ میں نے وڈیو درمیان میں ھی فورا بند کر دی ۔یہ عام انسان کی لکھی ھوئی کتاب نہیں جس پر آپ انگلی اٹھا سکیں ۔یہ کلام الہی ھے۔ آپ کو اللہ تعالی سے اس گستاخی کے لئے توبہ کری چاھیے ۔
Ahmad Sohail ...he is a paid servant of america
Watch full clip and then conclude
اس بدتمیز کی گندی زبان سے صحابہ کرام اور انبیا علیہ السلام بھی محفوظ نہیں کیا اصحاب رسول اللہ اور انبیاء علیہ السلام کا تذکرہ اس بدتمیزی سے کیا جاتا ہے علم کا تکبر اس کو لے ڈوبے گا
true....conclusion the last 2 mins...must listen
Asslam Alaikum, Engineer sahab
Jawaz aur Nikah me kiya fark hai?
Inallaha wa ina ilaihi rajeun. I am extremely sorry for His views about Quranic incident about Prophet Ibrahim alaihi salam and Maryam Alai Salaam. I am extremely regretful for His interpretation of those incidents.
According to Him, arguments and reasoning is not good but Prophets of God are extremely wise, reasonable and logical. They never doubt about God and His affairs but since they are fan of God's wisdom and ways, in order to acquire knowledge, they ask God, How God would do it? Angels then reply, it would be by out of the equations or conventions.
They were not wrong! Our ways to religious interpretations have been wrong very seriously. Hence Proven.
Secondly, Hadith are not as perfect as Quran. Stop comparing Hadith with Quran.
Hadith is secondary to Quran. There is no doubt about it.
These are not views of engineer Muhammad ali mirza , he is stating the views of munkireen e hadith answering them in their own language.
Absolutely right bro.
Sir plz. HAZRT MARIYM ko "tu" keh k na bulaye ziyada jazbati na hon wo ap or mujh se ziyada ALLAH k qareeb th....
Books .on.donkey
bhai wo language ka issue hai har jagah k hisab se us baat ko dheyqn na do sachchayi ketni h wo dekhen
Islam mein shayad hi Hazrat mariyam se ziada kisi or orat ka rutba ho .
Mery bhai bt samjhany k liye misal deni perti hy log Allah ko b tu kr k mukhatib krty hain k Allah tu rehem kr to kya ye gustakhi hy nhi Allah sy bara to koi nhi to usy app tu kehty ho bhai aqal sy kam ly lia kro
j tu kisi paghal ka bacha hay me mirza ku mulvi manta hein nahein najanay keya mazhab hah mirza ka
جب اللہ کسی چیز کو نشانی (نشانی) بناتا ھے ۔ تو ضرور قرآن میں زکر کرتا ھے۔ اللہ کا قول سچا ھے ۔ سوال حدیث کا بھی نہیں اور دین کا بھی نہیں مگر سوال مذہبی کتب کا ھے ، یعنی انسانی دسترس کا ھے ، کتب کے لئے مواد ،انتخاب اور معیار چونکہ انسانی دسترس میں ھے اور انسانی دسترس (وسائل) کبھی بھی معیاری اور قدیمی نہیں۔ اسلئے "اللہ اور اسکے رسول بہتر جانتے ھیں ". مسلمانوں کے لئے سند صرف اللہ اسکا رسول ، کتاب اور عترت اہلیبیت ھے ۔
Accept Hadeeths only from those Muhadiths in Sahih books who were well know lovers of Ahl-e-Bayt and reject the hadeeths quotes by those who had hatred for Ahly-e-Bayt.
In context of this question in the video, i would suggest to read Hadith al-Thaqalayn to get more clarity and avoid confusion.
Mirza g mola pak ap ko hidied da or ap ko hak samjna ke tofiek ata farmy