The real story behind the Canadian Flag

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
  • Our maple leaf was raised over Parliament Hill in 1965, but not without controversy. Reg Sherren tells us the little known story of how the flag came to be.
    »»» Subscribe to The National to watch more videos here: www.youtube.co...
    Voice Your Opinion & Connect With Us Online:
    The National Updates on Facebook: / thenational
    The National Updates on Twitter: / cbcthenational
    The National Updates on Google+: plus.google.co...
    »»» »»» »»» »»» »»»
    The National is CBC Television's flagship news program. Airing seven days a week, the show delivers news, feature documentaries and analysis from some of Canada's leading journalists.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 664

  • @gothhedgehog
    @gothhedgehog Рік тому +28

    As an American I find the Canadian maple leaf beautiful & unique

  • @LapisPebble
    @LapisPebble 6 років тому +130

    The point of a flag is for it to be simple and recognisable, the Canadian flag is one of the best designed flags in the world in my opinion.

    • @user-kh3ev6vq1v
      @user-kh3ev6vq1v 6 років тому +7

      And also to mean something. The Canadian flag means nothing.

    • @AirkaMojo
      @AirkaMojo 6 років тому +10

      L
      Stop copy pasting the same message everywhere. Also, the flag does have a significance. The red symbolizes the sacrifice of Canadian soldiers in wars (The world wars especially). The red also symbolizes our nation's British Heritage and the white symbolizes our French heritage. The maple leaf has also been a symbol of Canada for centuries, (some say as far back as the 1700s)

    • @invalidcrazy7034
      @invalidcrazy7034 5 років тому +5

      @@AirkaMojo If we really wanted to add significance for the men who died in ww2 why remove the flag that represented them

    • @woahjen1513
      @woahjen1513 3 роки тому +1

      @@user-kh3ev6vq1v while you are right that it holds no inherent meaning, there's still meaning that can certainly be applied to the flag

    • @Funnybriton
      @Funnybriton 3 роки тому +1

      @@user-kh3ev6vq1v the maple leaf like the actual leaf has symbolized the "canadien ppl" for 300 years lol.

  • @SMC01ful
    @SMC01ful 6 років тому +61

    This is a truly iconic, beautiful, flag, but don't be bummed out about the old one being retired either. You can still wave it and be a proud Canadian.

  • @288theabe
    @288theabe 4 роки тому +66

    The only flag in the world that looks awesome on a hockey stick!

    • @TheovdGulik
      @TheovdGulik 4 роки тому +8

      The only flag in the world that looks awesome on anything.

    • @kittycubeenterprises7276
      @kittycubeenterprises7276 4 роки тому

      It looks even better on toilet paper

    • @coolguy467
      @coolguy467 3 роки тому

      I love how it looks on military vehicles especially jets

    • @xIBEASTYFUNK
      @xIBEASTYFUNK 3 роки тому

      Smack in the face of its mother country

    • @God_of_pain_2.0
      @God_of_pain_2.0 2 роки тому

      😇😇😇😇💖💖💖

  • @bentleyhicks7974
    @bentleyhicks7974 6 років тому +93

    The Maple Leaf has accompanied soldiers and civilians on peacekeeping, humanitarian, and peace-making operations around the world for over fifty years. Students and travellers - including myself - have sported it on our jackets, our hoodies, our backbacks, and other apparel when we go abroad. When I come home, whether by land or by air, and I see it flying, I am reminded that - despite all my own challenges with the country of my birth - that I am first and last and always a Canadian: with an identity still being forged by the lives and sacrifices and achievements of Aboriginals, Francophones, Anglophones, and countless others with yet a different heritage who have made this land theirs. We are not English; we are not French; we are not Europeans; we are not Americans - we are Canadians.

    • @BobJones-sd8eh
      @BobJones-sd8eh 3 роки тому +7

      The red ensign is what 100,000s of Canadians fought and died under its our true flag

    • @vivo-audio
      @vivo-audio Рік тому

      @@BobJones-sd8eh Hundreds of thousands of Canadians fought on behalf of a foreign Empire that still had control over Canada's foreign policy. The Maple Leaf makes much better sense these days. Progress is a good thing.

    • @Angelcynn-x9m
      @Angelcynn-x9m 6 місяців тому

      ​@@vivo-audio How does it make better sense you clearly lack any history knowledge. foreign empire? Canadians at the time still saw themselves as BRITISH look at the videos of the Queens tour in 1951 just before she became Queen it's not a Foreign Empire it was the Empire the Canadians helped make by literally being colonists😂

    • @Angelcynn-x9m
      @Angelcynn-x9m 6 місяців тому

      @@BobJones-sd8eh I agree the Red Ensign is a much more beautiful flag and has 3x the maple leafs

    • @vivo-audio
      @vivo-audio 5 місяців тому

      @@Angelcynn-x9m Just because the Queen toured there in 1951 doesn't mean that all Canadians saw themselves as British - since the 19th century, they have always regarded themselves as proud Canadians, most with heritage form all parts of Europe. Canada had dominion status, and the Statute of Westminster, 1931, affirmed Canada's independence from Great Britain.

  • @quanahhurtt1833
    @quanahhurtt1833 3 роки тому +22

    I love the current Canadian Flag.
    It shouts: CANADA!!!
    I am an American who descended from American colonial settlers (who arrived here up and down the colonies: 1650's - 1750's).

  • @CBCTheNational
    @CBCTheNational  9 років тому +58

    Canada's flag was raised over Parliament Hill in 1965, but not without controversy. Reg Sherren tells us the little-known story of how the flag came to be.

    • @MrWilly-mb1qz
      @MrWilly-mb1qz 9 років тому

      Hola r

    • @tommacintyre8489
      @tommacintyre8489 6 років тому

      Britain didn't put their flag over top of the Scottish one. Britain only first existed around the time that flag was created. Also, Britain never invaded Scotland as Britain didn't even exist during the war between Scotland and England.

    • @riograndelocos9639
      @riograndelocos9639 5 років тому

      why the channel doesn't even get top comment

    • @zelda401
      @zelda401 4 роки тому

      @@tommacintyre8489 Isn't BRITAIN referring to the entire 4 entities and does not refer to any INDIVIDUAL entity. BRITAIN is a congregation of 4 countries in their entirety.?

    • @FreedomLovingLoyalistOfficial
      @FreedomLovingLoyalistOfficial 3 роки тому +1

      Boooooooo

  • @JP-bw7uo
    @JP-bw7uo 4 роки тому +26

    As a young boy living on my grandfather's farm in Nova Scotia, I remember the controversy over having a new Canadian flag. My grandfather was dead against it. And as a young boy I couldn't understand why at the time. The Ensign was the only flag I'd ever known and that was okay with me not realizing the reasons why. I mean what kid knew anything about politics in those days? Because of my grandfather, that's what influenced me into believing there was no reason to change our flag at the time. Now I'm old enough to understand why there was so much resistance. It was the resistance to CHANGE! It only takes time and in this case it was good. We needed our own flag and it distinguishes us as no other in the world. I feel blessed to be born Canadian and proud of our flag. It's our flag and distinctly Canadian eh!

  • @realamazingworld6756
    @realamazingworld6756 6 років тому +68

    I want the Maple Leaf Forever to be our national anthem

  • @loranddeka
    @loranddeka 3 роки тому +15

    This is how you teach history. The nuance, the context and expanded points make for a story that sticks in the mind.

  • @canadianmonarchist6357
    @canadianmonarchist6357 6 років тому +27

    as a Canadian i prefer the red ensign

    • @hammadsheikh6059
      @hammadsheikh6059 5 років тому

      I wonder why🤔🤣

    • @tricksterdac4216
      @tricksterdac4216 4 роки тому +6

      God save our Queen and heaven bells the maple leaf forever!!!!! We need the RED ensign back

  • @idcraw
    @idcraw 4 роки тому +14

    I loved the Red Ensign but this was a better idea for Canada to have its own flag

  • @wheelzwheela
    @wheelzwheela 9 років тому +49

    It's very recognizable.

  • @ΣαμπλεΤεξτ
    @ΣαμπλεΤεξτ 6 років тому +44

    We will never let the old Flag fall, for we love it the best of all! 🇧🇲

    • @Michformer
      @Michformer 6 років тому +4

      Σαμπλε Τεξτ Out of curiosity, where did you conjure up that Red Ensign emoji?

    • @dile183
      @dile183 6 років тому

      Michformer ^

    • @VV_PaVria
      @VV_PaVria 5 років тому +12

      But that's the flag of Bermuda.

    • @BicyclesMayUseFullLane
      @BicyclesMayUseFullLane 5 років тому

      @@VV_PaVria Big oof

  • @TheSkunkNetwork
    @TheSkunkNetwork 6 років тому +17

    It's funny to me that the original had thirteen points and the one they changed to has eleven. It was ahead of it's time haha

  • @hayhay_to333
    @hayhay_to333 3 роки тому +9

    I almost wept watching this video. I love Canada.

    • @God_of_pain_2.0
      @God_of_pain_2.0 2 роки тому

      💞💞💞💞😭😭😭😭💞💞💞

  • @slightlyvisible8448
    @slightlyvisible8448 9 років тому +5

    How many people here know that Canada's colours are red and white because those colours represented Frenchman and Briton warriors during the crusades. Canada was born of Europe.
    www.pch.gc.ca/eng/1363628125362/1363628203744

  • @bradjames891
    @bradjames891 3 роки тому +10

    Thanks for being a good neighbor, Canada!

  • @gideonhorwitz9434
    @gideonhorwitz9434 7 років тому +87

    The old flag was better

  • @rr7firefly
    @rr7firefly 6 років тому +9

    Among the criteria that George Stanley wrote for the design of the new Canadian flag was this: "it should be clean cut and not cluttered." I wonder what he thought about the American flag -- 50 stars and 13 stripes. Tripartite layouts always look more graphically refined to many graphic designers and artists.

    • @thenorthowl2033
      @thenorthowl2033 5 років тому

      Noe Berengena he created a logo for a beer can instead of a crest for a flag

  • @robman2095
    @robman2095 4 роки тому +5

    I think all countries that used to be members of the British Empire go through the stage of wanting to get rid of the union Jack from their flag as they grow up. Australia went through that stage too, but did not get around to doing anything about it. With the state of the world today and recent developments towards globalisation over the last few decades many Australians are increasingly proud of their British origins and there is now not quite the same need felt by many people to change the flag to get rid of the Union Jack. Of course there are many who still want to change the flag and become a republic but these aspirations have been put aside for some time now. In fact If there was a referendum to change the flag I don’t think it would be approved. New Zealand recently made a brave attempt to change their flag and they had a competition to select the new design but all the designs were so bad they eventually decided to stay with the current flag with the union Jack on it. I think the Canadian flag design is really good but so far neither Australian nor New Zealand have come up with anything in the same league as it as a possible alternative design, so that might be another reason why we haven’t changed the flag yet.

  • @billwilliam253
    @billwilliam253 4 роки тому +9

    Nice to see the best prime minister Canada ever had who passed while in office may god rest his soul LESTER B. PEARSON

  • @FreedomLovingLoyalistOfficial
    @FreedomLovingLoyalistOfficial 4 роки тому +9

    the red ensine saved us

    • @ozvulcan
      @ozvulcan 4 роки тому +2

      The red ensign was a symbol of dominance by your former British masters.

  • @CaptainMorgan113
    @CaptainMorgan113 5 років тому +7

    Stop whining about the old flag, move to Britain if you feel more British...

  • @JorgeHenrique-dt1zv
    @JorgeHenrique-dt1zv 4 роки тому +9

    Thanks for the beautiful flag. God bless Canada

  • @24jontracey
    @24jontracey 4 роки тому +11

    I live in Canada and it's awesome

  • @SNFDNSD
    @SNFDNSD 8 років тому +17

    A FUCKING LEAF.

    • @dunkydog1676
      @dunkydog1676 7 років тому

      yeah should used a douglas fir tree instead

    • @glen6945
      @glen6945 7 років тому

      FK YOU DIRT BAG

    • @RunningP123456
      @RunningP123456 7 років тому +3

      Yes. the same maple leaf that is on the soldiers grave stones.

    • @abcdfg4281
      @abcdfg4281 7 років тому +3

      Japans flag is just a dot, the US is just stars and stripes

  • @mikemccallion636
    @mikemccallion636 4 роки тому +6

    I spent Five years as a Royal Canadian Navy Sailor from 1957 thru 1962; (The Term of Enlistment was Five Years at the Time). My military expereince bouncing around the North Atlantic as Canada's Navy maintained a Monitoring Role on The Russian Fishing Factory Ships serving the dual use as a Relay Station for Transatlantic Radio Messages to and from the U.S.A. and Canada with the state of communications at the time.
    I am proud of My Service under the Canadian Ensign, as it was then. I am also proud to be a Canadian and recognize the Pride and Love of Country for all native born and legal immigration efforts to become a Canadian Citizen. Over the last couple or three generations of Using the single Red Maple Leaf design on a White Background with Two Broad Red Bands at each side it is become a permanent part of My English Language Culture.
    However when the design as described above was under discussion there was at least one of several versions which was not felt to be yet another effort by the then well recognized Bureaucracy Prime Minister Lester Bowles Pearson maintaining his preferred Liberal Party of Canada; the described as the N.G.P.P [ Natural Governing Political Party ] and P.M. Pearson refused to bring forward a Design which was quite similar as above except the Two Wide Bands of Red also shared a Blue Band on each side representing the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans of the Second Continent Wide North American Continent Country.
    I believe after couple or three generations of Using this other design will be loved as much as the Liberal Only White & Red colours.

    • @Funnybriton
      @Funnybriton 3 роки тому

      i see your point but red and white have been the national colours of canada since it was so designated by King George V in 1921. Red for british Roya;ty and White for the colour of the French royalty. So thats why it is red and white.

  • @chikeh1
    @chikeh1 8 років тому +106

    One of the most beautiful and simplest flags ever.

    • @vanders4198
      @vanders4198 7 років тому +3

      ᜃᜌ̥ᜋᜅᜄ̊ charlie You got simple right...

    • @obi-wankenobi9201
      @obi-wankenobi9201 6 років тому +1

      OoOoOooh MY god So, I don’t know if you realize this, but Britain is an island. Scotland is part of that island. They were British to begin with, so think about that. Also, typically when you invade someplace, you don’t add their flag to yours, you just fly yours. The UK flag represents the union of England, Scotland, and N. Ireland. That’s why it’s called the UNITED Kingdom.

    • @Funkoh
      @Funkoh 5 років тому

      *laughs in anime*

  • @mrpersianality6363
    @mrpersianality6363 8 років тому +74

    I think it's one of the most beautiful flags, very simple, distinct and symbolic of the nation.

  • @amessenger4664
    @amessenger4664 3 роки тому +4

    So You can actually be on a list to receive the flag that is flying over the peace tower. Wow thats cool but 48 year wait could be gone by then.

  • @Prairielander
    @Prairielander 8 років тому +109

    So because some foreigners didn't like our flag we changed it. Figures. Typically Canadian attitude. Why not erase all symbols of all our history because some group in the world will find offence to it.

    • @jabawockez333
      @jabawockez333 8 років тому +3

      Aye

    • @robin-bq1lz
      @robin-bq1lz 8 років тому +1

      Lol 😔

    • @RunningP123456
      @RunningP123456 7 років тому +23

      How dumb are you lol. It made life harder on peace keepers. We're our own country, with our own Identity. We are not British

    • @maximeschmitt6589
      @maximeschmitt6589 6 років тому +9

      Only English foreigners like you like the Union Jack. If you want that British symbol on your flag, just go back to England.

    • @mjag2834
      @mjag2834 6 років тому

      +Maxime Schmitt Maybe the Union Jack should be red, gold and black?! Royalties colours!

  • @gianfrancocapitoli4020
    @gianfrancocapitoli4020 3 роки тому +5

    I'm Gianfranco Capitoli living to Sulmona Italy born to Windsor Ontario Canada and proud of be a Canadian

  • @fgjhham89
    @fgjhham89 9 років тому +87

    It's a beautiful flag

    • @jakedeane5304
      @jakedeane5304 8 років тому +23

      The old one is so much more powerful though

    • @CanImperator
      @CanImperator 8 років тому +14

      Few people know what it is though. The point of a national flag is to be distinctive and the maple leaf flag is one of the most distinctive in the word

    • @RunningP123456
      @RunningP123456 7 років тому +1

      not at all

  • @hilarydoucette8080
    @hilarydoucette8080 9 років тому +13

    Canada Canada Canada wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Canada rule's

  • @southenglish1
    @southenglish1 5 років тому +10

    The red ensign represented whom? Some Canadians or all Canadians? The red ensign represented British Canadians. The Maple Leaf is representative of all Canadians. The red ensign would not be recognized throughout the world. The red ensign would be confused with all the other flags which have the Union Jack positioned in the hoist. The Maple Leaf is recognized through out the world as the symbol of Canada!!

    • @thenorthowl2033
      @thenorthowl2033 5 років тому +6

      mark hollingsworth ignorant. The red ensign crest represented English, Scottish, Irish and French as the founder of this country. The flag clearly represented the British control of the country but also the important representation of founding groups. Now look at the leaf, what does is represent? A common leaf of the land that we’re on, no history, no respect for the generations and generations of people who built this country and fought for it in multiple wars. I’m not even part of the group on the crest but the Red Ensign is superior by far.

  • @clementlee2121
    @clementlee2121 7 років тому +13

    A lesson to be drawn from Stanley was that he persevere through difficulties and believes in what he is doing, he ultimately succeeded. While everyone has a right to their opinion about the previous Canadian flag, I’m so glad of the one we have now. To me it is a potent symbol that stands for equality, freedom and I’m damn proud of it.

  • @darkfox3891
    @darkfox3891 2 роки тому +4

    This flag is very close to all Canadians hearts now and it is hard to think that back then we (or the Canadians) were fighting against it then. “Go Canada”

  • @raymondmallais6375
    @raymondmallais6375 6 місяців тому +2

    Un jour j'irai voir ça y paraît que c'quelques choses à voire j'ai fait application pour le drapeau de la tour de l'est ya plusieurs années j'ai une modite hâte de le recevoire je trouve que ça prend vraiment dû temps pour le recevoire

  • @Syeal7
    @Syeal7 9 років тому +37

    3:34 "Looks like a beer-label."
    Haha, I'll sooo use that next time I meet a Canadian. Hopefully he/she has a sense of humour.

    • @ulanastrylecki9632
      @ulanastrylecki9632 4 роки тому

      Beer me lol

    • @malachideath2550
      @malachideath2550 4 роки тому +5

      We wouldn't be offended, not as seriously patriotic as the US

    • @PaulRudd1941
      @PaulRudd1941 4 роки тому +1

      I'll be sure to pass you a molsen by the fire sir. That comment made my evening.

    • @288theabe
      @288theabe 4 роки тому

      Nowadays, that’s a compliment 🤣

    • @God_of_pain_2.0
      @God_of_pain_2.0 2 роки тому

      😂😂😂😂

  • @DaL33T5
    @DaL33T5 6 років тому +15

    Maybe as a Yank, I shouldn't be telling our neighbors upstairs what flags they should use, but Pearson had the right idea - the new flag is unique, easily recognizable, and affirms Canada as an independent country.
    There's many, many, *many* flags that follow the "British Ensign" format of a Union Jack canton and a seal on a blue/red flag. All of them are virtually indistinguishable from a distance, the Red Ensign included. They don't so much give the impression of proud, independent nations as they do continued colonial dependencies, because the only thing that most people are going to be able to recognize from the distance is the British Flag.
    The way I see it, the Red Ensign defines Canada in relation to the bygone Empire, while the leaf flag defines Canada simply as itself - which as what every good symbol (or flag) should be able to do.

  • @Mike12522
    @Mike12522 7 років тому +10

    Why is there no mention that there was a national open competition in 1964-65 to submit designs for a new flag ? 3,541 designs were submitted. We simply thought Stanley had won the competition fair and square. But perhaps his design was picked in advance as the ' winning ' design. At the time, a lot of Canadians didn't like Stanley's design, but soon almost all of us grew to love it, as we do today.

  • @CB-dn9vx
    @CB-dn9vx 8 років тому +104

    I think the old flag was much better but you Canadians fly your flag high and proudly

    • @localdude3702
      @localdude3702 7 років тому +36

      The old flag meant the British still had dominion over us. We are independent now.

    • @trexkiro9200
      @trexkiro9200 7 років тому +6

      You're British i presume?.Understandable.

    • @moose5265
      @moose5265 7 років тому +29

      I'm Canadian- but sometimes I think that the old flag was much better. It was so lovely with so much symbolism- Perhaps I'm too much of an anglophile- however I don't see that as a fault- but rather a blessing. God save the Queen, and heaven bless the Maple Leaf Forever.

    • @dvferyance
      @dvferyance 7 років тому +15

      I wonder why Australia and New Zealand haven't changed theirs yet.

    • @StephEWaterstram
      @StephEWaterstram 7 років тому +1

      I think the Retired Red Ensign could cover all of North America (except for Mexico because that's Habla Espanol) It isn't clear if the Red Ensign was an official Flag. It is an offshoot of the Queen Anne Red Ensign very much like The Stars and Stripes had been fabricated from. The American Insurrection is an overrated folklore! There is much evidence in history The British decimated The Young USA in the War of 1812 but had struck a deal to help reconstruct but it was Conditional like all contracts to help get someone on Their feet persay. I speak with the ENGLISH Language, the De Facto language of The United States of America. The nation has more Rules, Regulations, Laws & Taxes than any other on Earth, so remind Me How the USA is a "Free Country" again!

  • @CartoonCritter1985
    @CartoonCritter1985 2 роки тому +3

    So proud of our Canadian Flag!
    Imagine if Pearson hadn't been persistent in creating our own flag! We probably wouldn't have the maple leaf today! 🇨🇦

  • @Yeandle31
    @Yeandle31 4 роки тому +4

    As of October 2020, the waiting time for the Peace Tower flag exceeds 100 years.

  • @Mallory-Malkovich
    @Mallory-Malkovich 9 років тому +4

    Do they really put a brand new flag up every single day? Doesn't that seem kinda wasteful?

    • @bobdole7127
      @bobdole7127 9 років тому +3

      Not really. Used flags are purchased from people on that massive, 48 year long waiting list. So really, it's no different than stores stocking their shelves with it and people buying it from there.

    • @madisontrumley8447
      @madisontrumley8447 9 років тому +2

      +Bob Dole It created a job for someone :)

    • @ckom0007
      @ckom0007 8 років тому +3

      Uh, each one of those used flags is given, free, to a person on the wait list. I get mine in approximately 33 years! Wonderful tradition!

    • @romant142
      @romant142 6 років тому

      ckom0007 What’s the difference between that one and the one you could buy at a store?

  • @abozt6397
    @abozt6397 6 років тому +6

    Why didnt they hold a referandum on it like they did in NZ

    • @markbenjamin1703
      @markbenjamin1703 5 років тому +6

      Because it would of been rejected

    • @histman3133
      @histman3133 3 роки тому

      @@markbenjamin1703 Exactly! Hastily run it through Parliament before the people even have a chance to gave a say. Hahahaha typical policy making in this country. We don't want it being rejected now do we?

  • @dunkydog1676
    @dunkydog1676 9 років тому +55

    liberal flag..should remained british!

    • @lainefrajberg7780
      @lainefrajberg7780 8 років тому +7

      The vote was 163 in favour 78 against.So...if you accept democracy,that's the flag our people wanted.

    • @sanspeter9925
      @sanspeter9925 8 років тому +9

      that was the flag parliament wanted not the people

    • @lainefrajberg7780
      @lainefrajberg7780 8 років тому +4

      Except that in a parliamentary democracy the people elect representatives to govern on their behalf.So in that sense it's the flag the Canadian people wanted.

    • @sanspeter9925
      @sanspeter9925 8 років тому +8

      Laine Frajberg no it should have been a referendum for something as major as changing the flag

    • @tintinsmythe5837
      @tintinsmythe5837 7 років тому +1

      dunky dog agreed

  • @doylejodi7502
    @doylejodi7502 5 місяців тому +1

    I’m going to fly the old one. To me, it represents a time in history when Canada was ‘different.’

  • @mafmaf6417
    @mafmaf6417 4 роки тому +9

    I hope we never forget our roots, French and English. I am glad Canada has our own flag unlike other members of the Commonwealth. The Canadian flag just looks great. The Red Ensign was
    nice to.

    • @TheovdGulik
      @TheovdGulik 4 роки тому +5

      If you want to remember your English roots, you may want to start writing the language properly.
      **too*

    • @mafmaf6417
      @mafmaf6417 4 роки тому +6

      @@TheovdGulik I am well versed in the English language. Unfortunately my phone is not.

    • @TheovdGulik
      @TheovdGulik 4 роки тому +2

      @@mafmaf6417 Fair enough :-)

  • @amasha88
    @amasha88 3 роки тому +4

    Emotional story ❤️

  • @broznar1019
    @broznar1019 8 років тому +90

    i'm by no means a staunch supporter of the monarchy, but purely esthetically speaking, i think the previous flag, crest on red background and union jack was a nicer flag. it envokes history of where we came from. the modern flag of the maple leaf is only a symbol of the national tree.

    • @computergames5
      @computergames5 8 років тому +29

      Yes but us the French and new Canadians weren't so fond of it, so Pearson wanted a symbol that everyone could use and give Canadians an identity. When you mention "it envokes history of where we came from", not everyone came from the UK dude, Canada's a country built off different tribes of people. So whether you like it or not, the maple leaf was the best choice for a new Canadian symbol.

    • @broznar1019
      @broznar1019 8 років тому +7

      computergames5 i disagree, the old flag has the crest where you can find the british lion, irish harp, scottish lion, flours de lys and maple leaf to represent ethnic groups. the canton union jack to remind we are part of the commonwealth. but i do recognize that it was an unpopular flag especially with the french, given the political times, i also understand the urgency and pitch for a more unifying symbol...

    • @computergames5
      @computergames5 8 років тому +7

      indeed, but that really doesn't justify it when you have a union jack that dominated a good chunk of the flag and that really didn't appeal to lots of people back in the day.

    • @broznar1019
      @broznar1019 8 років тому +4

      computergames5 well, i would counter argue that Canada remains in all ways a constitutional monarchy, with the queen acting as head of state (symbolically of course!) In that context, a flag bearing the Union Jack is appropriate. Changing the flag to do away with our ties to the British Empire ignores that fact. Were it to me, a flag change is applicable once the country opts to become a republic and turns the page on its British Colonial past. In Canada's case this was window dressing since it chose not to reform its parliamentary system.

    • @computergames5
      @computergames5 8 років тому +9

      +Jeddaz EightyOne so every country that is monarchy to Elizabeth II should bare a Union Jack? Not really, once again, it wasn't just English people and scots that occupies the land, and every country deserves a symbol. And even if Canada is a monarchy, most people don't even care about the monarchy as a whole, it's just a symbol. Even then, Canada's British ties is over and it's been like that a long time ago, it's commonwealth memberships grants no extra power to the UK and the queens role as a monarch is completely different than the UK's role. Canadians wanted an identity, and they've created one of the most recognizable well known flags out there.

  • @bstrut3796
    @bstrut3796 9 років тому +68

    As a Canadian of only 27 years of age, I regard our Country's current flag as a 'Liberal Flag'. It doesn't swell any Canadian pride within me. Its predecessor is preferable.

    • @slightlyvisible8448
      @slightlyvisible8448 8 років тому +9

      +B Strut I mixed on the issue. On the one hand they tried to erase Canada's heritage. On the other, hand
      www.pch.gc.ca/eng/1363628125362/1363628203744
      They literally created a flag whose colours find their meaning from England and France whose colours where taken from the crusades. Which is kinda awesome.

    • @Prairielander
      @Prairielander 8 років тому +6

      +Gar Yeah it was settled by parliamentary closure. We didn't even get to vote on it. If we had it would have never came to be.

    • @lainefrajberg7780
      @lainefrajberg7780 8 років тому +3

      It's the flag our parliamentarians voted for in 1964.Don't like?Become the PM and change it back to the Red Ensign.(3 versions to choose from)

    • @slightlyvisible8448
      @slightlyvisible8448 8 років тому +3

      Prairielander
      Same with the anthem. Liberals do not listen to the people.

    • @lainefrajberg7780
      @lainefrajberg7780 8 років тому +4

      Same remark as to B Strut.Become the PM and change the anthem back to God Save the Queen.(It's still the Royal Anthem by the way.)

  • @randymogk1683
    @randymogk1683 5 років тому +6

    Defienbaker was a coward

    • @mikemccallion636
      @mikemccallion636 4 роки тому

      Canadian and recognize the Pride and Love of Country for all native born and legal immigration efforts to become a Canadian Citizen. Over the last couple or three generations of Using the single Red Maple Leaf design on a White Background with Two Broad Red Bands at each side it is become a permanent part of My English Language Culture.
      However when the design as described above was under discussion there was at least one of several versions which was not felt to be yet another effort by the then well recognized Bureaucracy Prime Minister Lester Bowles Pearson maintaining his preferred Liberal Party of Canada; the described as the N.G.P.P [ Natural Governing Political Party ] and P.M. Pearson refused to bring forward a Design which was quite similar as above except the Two Wide Bands of Red also shared a Blue Band on each side representing the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans of the Second Continent Wide North American Continent Country.
      I believe after couple or three generations of Using this other design will be loved as much as the Liberal Only White & Red colours. _____ By the way the standard Liberal Bumpf which allowed Randy MOGK to take a cheap shot against a long dead Prime Minister is truly part of the last couple or three generations of the (proven) corrupt in so many decades Liberal Party of canada. Prime Minister John Diefenbacker; the only Prime Minister of Canada not having a surname which is ancestral to a British or French name.
      P.M. John Diefenbacker is also the only Internationally recognized Statesman of Canada. Do not be fooled by the Liberal Bumpf of Pearson; the Honour coming his way from the Suez Canal foolishness of Britain & France is because the President Eisenhower's Administration wished to ease the affront to Britain and France which was at the time only about a decade after the tremendous loss of Lives by W.W.Two. ___ P.M. Diefenbaker was the Commonwealth Leader and unltimately the World Leader to back down the United Kingdom in supporting South Africa's Apartheid Regime and the cruelty which came out of this. President Mandela, after serving Twenty Three [ 23 ] years imprisoned by the South African Government, became South Africa's First Black President. It was because of John Diefenbaker after decades of N.G.P.P. Liberal Party Government who led the movement to Free all of the Black Political Prisoners and the base for eliminating Apartheid in South Africa. President Mandala travelled to Canada during Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper's Administration for President Mandella to Honour Canada and be Honoured by Canada as a Canadian Citizen.
      ( Please do not mock Randy MOGK for His ignorance of Canadian History). This; as was the selection of the colours used in the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag just only the standard Liberal Party propaganda manipulation of information. It is part & parcel of the N.G.P.P. Liberal Party___ collusion with Canada's version of the Victorian Era Privy Council Office. The P.C.O. fights to retain its Power Position as the Final Arbiter of all activities with ferocity. Might even increse the impediments I expereince in trying to bring forward 'the other side of the story' which You as semi-Sovereign Ordinary Average Person will never be told with their control of the smearedia.

    • @roberteaston6413
      @roberteaston6413 3 роки тому

      Diefenbaker was not a coward when he defended the civil rights of Japanese Canadians in 1942. When Japanese Canadians were put into internment camps during WW2 Dief protested. That was one of the most courageous stands in Canadian history. Pearson was a wimp. He did whatever John Kennedy wanted.

  • @hifijohn
    @hifijohn 8 років тому +5

    I like canada but she is right , it does look like a beer label, or a cigarette label.

    • @CaptainMorgan113
      @CaptainMorgan113 8 років тому +7

      +hifijohn Nope, its all those beer and cigarette labels who look like the Canadian flag.

  • @ALuimes
    @ALuimes 3 роки тому +5

    What would Canadian businesses and local sports teams use in their logos if it weren't for the maple leaf?

  • @constantius4654
    @constantius4654 Рік тому +1

    The Canadian flag ought to contain some blue and thus be red, white and blue like those of its sibling Anglo-Saxon countries, the UK, USA, Australia and NZ. Blue would also reflect the red, white and blue of its important French heritage and also the dark blue of the lovely blue and white flag of Quebec. There is still time to add blue to the Canadian flag, perhaps with a blue rimmed Maple leaf?

  • @marylight9700
    @marylight9700 6 років тому +6

    That's so sweet!

  • @imisstoronto3121
    @imisstoronto3121 Рік тому +1

    I am old enough to remember the flag controversy, I was in Grade 5 at the time. I remember what was a famous Duncan McPherson cartoon about it: all the major players, Pearson, Diefenbaker etc were drawn as toddlers playing in a sandbox trying to put their version of the flag on top of a sand castle. Hysterical!!

  • @dch2896
    @dch2896 7 років тому +16

    This story put a smile on my face. :)

  • @gomezmagno
    @gomezmagno 8 років тому +30

    That is a beautiful flag. Not like the potential new flag of New Zealand.

    • @mathieust-louis2893
      @mathieust-louis2893 8 років тому +2

      +Magno Gómez I respectfully disagree.

    • @aaroncarson1770
      @aaroncarson1770 5 років тому

      Which potential do you find objectionable? I'm seeing three potential options. There's one with a fern leaf, one with a green spiral and one with a sort of triangle. I think the first two look nice but the third option is a little boring. They're probably considering a change, because the current one is very suggestive of the empire.

    • @keithwatson1384
      @keithwatson1384 5 років тому +4

      @@aaroncarson1770 nothing wrong with the Empire!

    • @aaroncarson1770
      @aaroncarson1770 5 років тому

      @@keithwatson1384 nothing wrong at all but you could see how they might want something distinctive.

    • @keithwatson1384
      @keithwatson1384 5 років тому

      @@aaroncarson1770 yes well I can see that! Thankfully they voted to keep it though!

  • @danlalonde2751
    @danlalonde2751 10 місяців тому +1

    I was 17 when they raised the new flag at the Parliament building . I remember that when i first seen it up there i felt a strong feeling of Canadian pride . Good for Lester B Pearson for hanging in there ,because we needed our own beautiful flag .

    • @Angelcynn-x9m
      @Angelcynn-x9m 6 місяців тому

      Canada had its own Beautiful flag same as New Zealand and Australia he was to scared to have a referendum because he knew he would lose

  • @robdewey317
    @robdewey317 8 років тому +5

    Neat story!

  • @galanthusknits
    @galanthusknits 7 років тому +8

    I wonder if there are still people who are upset about the new flag.. I'm sure there must be some older people who remember the change and still hate it to this day..

    • @lainefrajberg813
      @lainefrajberg813 6 років тому +6

      Plenty of people who disliked-and still dislike- the new flag have commented right on this forum.

    • @ericsteele6941
      @ericsteele6941 5 років тому +9

      I prefer the Red Ensign

    • @karenwesley332
      @karenwesley332 5 років тому +3

      @@ericsteele6941 I do as well.

    • @Reynaertphotos
      @Reynaertphotos 4 роки тому +2

      17 and hate it

  • @juhaszmario800
    @juhaszmario800 8 років тому +4

    really help me with my heritage fair project

  • @theequalizer2007
    @theequalizer2007 4 роки тому +2

    Probably inspired by the Peruvian flag.

  • @mrstopanimationguy
    @mrstopanimationguy 6 років тому +9

    The old flag is vastly superior. This one is nothing but a joke which was imposed upon the people with no choice

  • @brianadeva4560
    @brianadeva4560 5 років тому +3

    Would not mind having a beer with the maple leaf label.

  • @SamuelAdkins-j1h
    @SamuelAdkins-j1h Рік тому +1

    A sad day in Canadian history.

  • @serpentsfix
    @serpentsfix 4 роки тому +5

    🇧🇲

  • @zelda401
    @zelda401 4 роки тому +3

    I love our Canadian Flag and I'm 75!

  • @masteroflife4667
    @masteroflife4667 8 років тому +3

    They need a bigger Flag, just make it bigger! So People see it better!

    • @TheovdGulik
      @TheovdGulik 4 роки тому

      The flag over the Peace Tower is already quite large (7,5 x 15ft or 2.3 x 4.6 meters)

  • @patrickwoo1990
    @patrickwoo1990 5 років тому +8

    Pearson’s beach towel

  • @shotta2201
    @shotta2201 4 роки тому +2

    There’s no real history on this flag weakest flag ever

  • @bobdabuilder1376
    @bobdabuilder1376 3 роки тому +2

    Does anyone know if the flag debate had a public referendum or were they just changed by lawmakers?

    • @johncabrera4171
      @johncabrera4171 3 роки тому +1

      It was changed by lawmakers, no referendum.

  • @randymogk1683
    @randymogk1683 5 років тому +4

    Well done cbc

  • @Nicolas___
    @Nicolas___ 2 роки тому +1

    In my opinion the flag should be green and white according to the older coat of arms. Red and White is used so often in national flags.

  • @tracymartin3398
    @tracymartin3398 6 років тому +5

    I love our Canadian flag🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦

  • @hilarydoucette8080
    @hilarydoucette8080 9 років тому +8

    Canada Canada Canada wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Canada rule's

  • @ryanthebuizel1692
    @ryanthebuizel1692 7 років тому +2

    The Maple Leaf looked too real until George change 11 points

  • @codesmccheese2172
    @codesmccheese2172 5 років тому +3

    Most beautiful flag ever raised

  • @vanguard6498
    @vanguard6498 4 роки тому +6

    BRING BACK THE RED ENSIGN

    • @rogerloger1935
      @rogerloger1935 3 роки тому

      Ok BUF sympathiser, should we bring hack God save the Queen too?

  • @CaravanNoobs
    @CaravanNoobs 6 років тому +1

    And I thought Americans were overly attached to their flag.

  • @prince_bankz
    @prince_bankz 2 роки тому +1

    I hope they don’t change it we will feel empty if they do

  • @dunkydog1676
    @dunkydog1676 7 років тому +2

    just like whole country is not behind the cbc

  • @arlinearzuca1479
    @arlinearzuca1479 20 днів тому

    As a little girl i first saw Canadian flag at age of 12, during my geography class, offered to do research, present study to my class, got fascinated with Canada all my life, buy anything was made in Canada…..at age of 40 immigrated here, love Canada with all of my heart! Go Canada Go!!!💖💖🇨🇦🇨🇦💖🇨🇦🇨🇦💖💖🇨🇦🇨🇦💖💖🇨🇦🇨🇦💖💖🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦

  • @jamesalcock5840
    @jamesalcock5840 Рік тому +1

    There should have been a referendum.

    • @Angelcynn-x9m
      @Angelcynn-x9m 6 місяців тому

      They knew they would lose so they did it undemocratically New Zealand had a vote a few years ago and they voted for their ensign

  • @bergsteinnhardarson3273
    @bergsteinnhardarson3273 3 роки тому +1

    Winnibeg Falcons in Holland 1920 had the mabel Leaf on the shirt. It was red in the middel.same as the canadian flag

  • @SF7PAKISTAN
    @SF7PAKISTAN 5 років тому +3

    What's the point of having the mark of your slave master remain on your forehead? Canada is a free and independent country and so should be its colours #MapleLeafForever

    • @invalidcrazy7034
      @invalidcrazy7034 5 років тому +4

      What are you talking about.. the British did not enslave Canadian citizens. In fact the British were the first to abolish slavery. Also no one denied Canada was independent.

  • @jeanbally4751
    @jeanbally4751 3 місяці тому

    Québec had his flag since since 1948. The fleurdelisé representing the nation of Québec. Since Canada doesn’t have any core identity , it took much longer time.

  • @tommysieng2788
    @tommysieng2788 4 роки тому +2

    Great story !!.. After a long trip oversea, see our flag.. Now we know we are home !!!..

  • @toonmag50
    @toonmag50 6 років тому +1

    Let's remove the Christian Crosses let's replace them with a.... .. leaf.

  • @hannailkinpromopage-canada4958

    The biggest cross lifted in the Zone of Hannan…not one person was normal after lucifer. 1000 media people injured
    Prophet Hanna face lifted-lost all frontal teeth
    skull lifted autopsy
    in the new land of god - kanada

  • @kevinfelix2543
    @kevinfelix2543 3 роки тому +2

    got shivers as a canadian

  • @tadwilson9563
    @tadwilson9563 4 роки тому +3

    The Canadian flag is very beautiful

    • @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions
      @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions 4 роки тому

      New Zealand should do the same, I'm not sure how it'll go down but Canada did it without a referendum.
      EDIT:
      I guess either I made a mistake or the user above changes their picture to a different British ensign on the regular.

    • @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions
      @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions 3 роки тому

      @AC
      British dominion? What is this 1900? New Zealand is a Commonwealth realm, it has nothing to do with the British other than legacy, but didn't stop Canada and most other Commonwealth realms from adopting autochthonous flags instead of continuing with British ensigns.
      Or what you don't think Canada is proud of its British heritage? They have the Union Jack, officially known as the Royal Union flag, as an official flag for symbolic purposes like being raised during Commonwealth day.

  • @Mrskateboardboy
    @Mrskateboardboy 6 років тому +4

    Why is red and white "traditional"? I remember the same thing with blue borders, which I thought was more representative of the two oceans on either side of Canada.

    • @amarminhas202
      @amarminhas202 6 років тому +1

      I can't answer that exactly but it's something about a king saying red and white were Canada's colors, and they were used basically everywhere

    • @davidfreeman3083
      @davidfreeman3083 5 років тому

      The problem is... It just looked weird with blue sides instead of red ones.

  • @robb.c.7407
    @robb.c.7407 5 років тому +7

    Our true National flag was and will always be The Red Ensign, Our true National anthem was and will always be The Maple Leaf Forever.

    • @ElliottDuster
      @ElliottDuster 5 років тому +3

      Rob B.C. Old anthem and flag shows more royalty, but I love the current flag and anthem, more simplicity on it. Nonetheless, they’re all amazing in their own way.

  • @GregoryBoyce-w3i
    @GregoryBoyce-w3i 3 місяці тому

    My father served in ww1 1914 to after 1980
    His will and funeral request was Union Jack not the red left flag

  • @Ben-3984
    @Ben-3984 4 роки тому +5

    🇧🇲

    • @Ben-3984
      @Ben-3984 4 роки тому +1

      MatSCan yeah closest I could find

    • @RealDose200
      @RealDose200 3 роки тому

      That's the Bermuda flag

    • @Ben-3984
      @Ben-3984 3 роки тому

      @@RealDose200 So it is. Maybe because it was the closest thing to the old Canadian flag.

    • @RealDose200
      @RealDose200 3 роки тому

      @@Ben-3984 actually the only flag with the red ensign

    • @Ben-3984
      @Ben-3984 3 роки тому

      @@RealDose200 Exactly

  • @PlayedOutPosts89
    @PlayedOutPosts89 3 місяці тому

    There was a contest in shubenacadie residential school who could design the flag. The contest was won by edward bowl Augustine’s