The methodology here is suspect. Looking at only the top 15 softest and shortest is not giving you an overall picture, but simply looking at outliers. In order to get a real sense, you need to look at the overall rates of home runs under a certain distance and velocity for every ballpark and see which has the highest. Looking at only the most extreme outliers isn't giving anything close to the full picture.
@@UntitledKirk the classic “ I’m an idiot that thought sounding was right and now that I was proven wrong I’m going to pretend I knew the whole time” lol
As a yankees fan, I've been arguing this for years but didn't know the stats on it. The problem with calling Yankee Stadium the easiest park to homer in is way too fixated on the shorter right field. It doesn't account for 399 in left center and 408 to dead center
Couldn’t agree more. By the way I’m Ohtani fan but I also thought Yankee stadium hitter friendliness is overvalued. Sure it has very short distance in left field line and the so-called short porch in right, but the center field is larger than average (408ft like you said), and left center is 399 which is still similar distance to many ballparks in center, actually Yankee stadium’s left center is actually longer than Dodger stadium in center.
Yankee Stadium gets so much heat for ‘cheap homers,’ but the stats don’t lie it’s not even #1 for short dingers. Fenway and Great American are the real bandboxes. Guess it’s just easier to hate the Yankees!
I think this is all mlb stadiums tho im a Fenway native I think our right field shortest hr distance is about 303ft at the foul pole I swear I think my old fat behind could hit a dinger there off a pitching machine
They have a pretty deep fence even for the altitude, but all that does is provide more outfield space for the hitter. Coors has a huge outfield and some pretty tall fences making for lots of doubles
Yankee stadium leads all major league ballparks in home runs that would not be a home run in any other ballpark in the league. How does that available metric get overlooked? If you don’t want to accept that fact then fall back on the good old eyeball test. Yes, Dodger stadium gives up a lot of home runs but that’s in part due to the hot, arid weather in Southern California in the summer, not just because it was specifically designed to give up cheap home runs. Great American “small” park in Cincinnati is the only comparable park and yet even that one doesn’t give up as many home runs that wouldn’t be a home run anywhere else.
It's stupidly easy to hit a home run from left center to the left field foul line and same with right field. Your stats can say what they said but look how many home runs wouldn't be at other parks in yankee stadium. I don't agree with your argument or your reasoning on this matter with all due respect
The AL East have the easiest stadium. Those are the Tampa Rays, New York Yankees, And and the Boston Red Sox. Their fields are so easy to hit home runs in. Also in MLB The Show I hit bombs at those stadiums! Lol 🤣!
I played with the Red Sox on a franchise and made me wonder how the real Devers as a lefty doesn't put up Judge numbers in real life Also made me realize why Ortiz liked Boston much
im too lazy to google it... why don't they have regulation dimensions for baseball fields? now I kinda want every NBA court to have slight irregularities. give San Antonio a higher rim that only Wemby can dunk on. 🤣🤣
@@unknownactions1438imagine curry being on the team with the longest 3 point line and playing against a team with the shortest. He’d be out there shooting long 2’s
@ I’m a NYer (Mets fan) that watches the games. Yankees fans will admit this as well. Watch a few games yourself and add what you see to this statistical analysis. That will provide a fuller picture.
@ As a Mariners and Cardinals fan, (grew up in the St. Louis, have lived in Seattle for a decade+), even when my teams are doing poorly, I'm watching at least 12 games a week during the season. It's what I do on my commute, it's what I do after work, and it's what I do before bed. The reason statistical analysis exists is to remove the bias that comes from all over, including the stuff you hear all your life. If human perception was better than numbers at being accurate, we wouldn't use numbers.
@@AliceYobby Being that you are used to watching games in St. Louis and Seattle (worst hitter’s ballpark in MLB), you don’t see how the dimensions affect the way the game is played at [new] Yankees Stadium very often. Since I’m here, I get to see how it affects games. It even affects how rosters are constructed. That’s why I look at the data AND assess with the “eye test”. Ask Curtis Granderson the effect of Yankees Stadium on his performance and career earnings.
As a Yankee fan, but one who accepts objective reality, it isn't. We have the stats, you can look them up. Yankee Stadium is NOT the easiest to get cheap homers in.
@ yes it is and idc what you say…I’m speaking off stats and personal experience….for one it’s 3rd in home run….1.Cincinnati with 128 hrs allowed in that stadium this yr….second was dodgers with 122 and 3rd of course was my beloved Yankees….you know why??? Because it’s 314 down the lines….smallest dimensions in baseball….so small that in my showcase all I did was hit upper deck shots….shit I threw it out from home plate over the wall at Yankee stadium….however….i couldn’t do it at chase stadium in Arizona….no upper deck nor could I throw it out from home plate….again Yankee stadium allowed the 3rd most home runs this season
@@whoishec7615 yeah yeah and when I played for the Red Sox, hitting it over the green monster was easier than short porch at Yankee Stadium, and Im a lefty 😂
The methodology here is suspect. Looking at only the top 15 softest and shortest is not giving you an overall picture, but simply looking at outliers. In order to get a real sense, you need to look at the overall rates of home runs under a certain distance and velocity for every ballpark and see which has the highest. Looking at only the most extreme outliers isn't giving anything close to the full picture.
red sox fans in shambles finding out their #1 argument is incorrect in every statistical category
no one has ever accused red sox fans of being smart
Literally every single thing you said is wrong.
@@tmazz85 what’s wrong about it?
Still fun to piss y'all off by saying it though lmao.
@@UntitledKirk the classic “ I’m an idiot that thought sounding was right and now that I was proven wrong I’m going to pretend I knew the whole time” lol
As a yankees fan, I've been arguing this for years but didn't know the stats on it. The problem with calling Yankee Stadium the easiest park to homer in is way too fixated on the shorter right field. It doesn't account for 399 in left center and 408 to dead center
Couldn’t agree more. By the way I’m Ohtani fan but I also thought Yankee stadium hitter friendliness is overvalued. Sure it has very short distance in left field line and the so-called short porch in right, but the center field is larger than average (408ft like you said), and left center is 399 which is still similar distance to many ballparks in center, actually Yankee stadium’s left center is actually longer than Dodger stadium in center.
It’s always been Boston, most batting champs most double leaders crazy close at the corners
Jbanksey needs to see this video.
😂
Bro he’ll just say we will need to test our players 😂
Left field walls in the old trop or Angel stadium: “ACT. NATURAL.”
Lol
Yankee Stadium gets so much heat for ‘cheap homers,’ but the stats don’t lie it’s not even #1 for short dingers. Fenway and Great American are the real bandboxes. Guess it’s just easier to hate the Yankees!
I think this is all mlb stadiums tho im a Fenway native I think our right field shortest hr distance is about 303ft at the foul pole I swear I think my old fat behind could hit a dinger there off a pitching machine
How does park factor account for disparity in pitching talent from team to team
What about coors field
Easily the best hitters park, but not for home runs funny enough. They really have made it bigger in recent years dimensional wise
They have a pretty deep fence even for the altitude, but all that does is provide more outfield space for the hitter. Coors has a huge outfield and some pretty tall fences making for lots of doubles
Longer distances in Coors field but the altitude will do the trick, even with humidor it’s still hitter park. Lots of doubles and triples too.
I do wonder how Fenway and Great American fair vs Coors Field the 90s version when it comes to homers and runs scored.
I always wondered why Fenway never got nearly as much guff as it should for its dimensions
It’s way overblown bc of Yankee haters. their are plenty of other ballparks that are easy to hit homers
This feels incomplete. Why dont the dimensions align with the stats being produced?
Straight away right field is a joke in Yankees stadium.
This is the problem with baseball fans. Youre looking at stats instead of what is right in front of you
Coors should have showed up into the conversation.
Its real and no stats are going to convince anyone otherwise.
Straightaway right at Yankee stadium is ridiculous but it’s far from the biggest bandbox in baseball
its also such a niche spot. Most balls are not getting pulled directly down right field.
@ it’s not really right down the line that’s kind of ridiculous but more right over the right fielders head
Didn’t u make this like a week ago?😂
He makes Yankee hater videos every week so easy mistake
@ ehh not as much as italkstudios but I swear he made this and had to redo it
seems like he reuploads videos that dont do well at better times
@@Someone-hi1nt prolly right
@@thenewyorkgamer Is there anything wrong with that? 😂
Yankee stadium leads all major league ballparks in home runs that would not be a home run in any other ballpark in the league. How does that available metric get overlooked? If you don’t want to accept that fact then fall back on the good old eyeball test. Yes, Dodger stadium gives up a lot of home runs but that’s in part due to the hot, arid weather in Southern California in the summer, not just because it was specifically designed to give up cheap home runs. Great American “small” park in Cincinnati is the only comparable park and yet even that one doesn’t give up as many home runs that wouldn’t be a home run anywhere else.
Does the stat accounts for horrendous offensive that is Yankees lineup bar Soto-Judge?
This video was sponsored by a Yankee fan.
The opposite of Dodger Stadium 🙃
Yea but does this factor in poor/good pitching staffs?
No
It's stupidly easy to hit a home run from left center to the left field foul line and same with right field. Your stats can say what they said but look how many home runs wouldn't be at other parks in yankee stadium. I don't agree with your argument or your reasoning on this matter with all due respect
The AL East have the easiest stadium. Those are the Tampa Rays, New York Yankees, And and the Boston Red Sox. Their fields are so easy to hit home runs in. Also in MLB The Show I hit bombs at those stadiums! Lol 🤣!
did you watch the video?
I played with the Red Sox on a franchise and made me wonder how the real Devers as a lefty doesn't put up Judge numbers in real life
Also made me realize why Ortiz liked Boston much
im too lazy to google it... why don't they have regulation dimensions for baseball fields? now I kinda want every NBA court to have slight irregularities. give San Antonio a higher rim that only Wemby can dunk on. 🤣🤣
Because baseball is old, their stadiums would be built in the middle of a city so they were all different.
Imagine if some courts had a farther 3 point line or shorter, it would definitely be interesting
Soccer pitches are also variable, even within the same league.
But not to the extreme of MLB parks.
@@unknownactions1438imagine curry being on the team with the longest 3 point line and playing against a team with the shortest. He’d be out there shooting long 2’s
Real one skins this is a reupload
Under 20 min
Only in RF. Any pop-ups over 2B are HRs. Little League dimensions out there.
maybe watch from 2:00 on and re-evaluate that statement
@ I’m a NYer (Mets fan) that watches the games. Yankees fans will admit this as well. Watch a few games yourself and add what you see to this statistical analysis. That will provide a fuller picture.
@ As a Mariners and Cardinals fan, (grew up in the St. Louis, have lived in Seattle for a decade+), even when my teams are doing poorly, I'm watching at least 12 games a week during the season. It's what I do on my commute, it's what I do after work, and it's what I do before bed. The reason statistical analysis exists is to remove the bias that comes from all over, including the stuff you hear all your life. If human perception was better than numbers at being accurate, we wouldn't use numbers.
@@AliceYobby Being that you are used to watching games in St. Louis and Seattle (worst hitter’s ballpark in MLB), you don’t see how the dimensions affect the way the game is played at [new] Yankees Stadium very often. Since I’m here, I get to see how it affects games. It even affects how rosters are constructed.
That’s why I look at the data AND assess with the “eye test”.
Ask Curtis Granderson the effect of Yankees Stadium on his performance and career earnings.
It's Cincinnati
It’s Colorado isn’t it ?
@@JohnM-sw4sccolorado lets the balls get hit further not the pop ups going out
As a Yankee fan yes it is…. Cincinnati Colorado and Cubs as well….oh can’t forget Houston
As a Yankee fan, but one who accepts objective reality, it isn't. We have the stats, you can look them up. Yankee Stadium is NOT the easiest to get cheap homers in.
@ yes it is and idc what you say…I’m speaking off stats and personal experience….for one it’s 3rd in home run….1.Cincinnati with 128 hrs allowed in that stadium this yr….second was dodgers with 122 and 3rd of course was my beloved Yankees….you know why??? Because it’s 314 down the lines….smallest dimensions in baseball….so small that in my showcase all I did was hit upper deck shots….shit I threw it out from home plate over the wall at Yankee stadium….however….i couldn’t do it at chase stadium in Arizona….no upper deck nor could I throw it out from home plate….again Yankee stadium allowed the 3rd most home runs this season
@@whoishec7615 yeah yeah and when I played for the Red Sox, hitting it over the green monster was easier than short porch at Yankee Stadium, and Im a lefty 😂