Vocal Coach Reacts to Natalia Barbu 'In The Middle' Moldova Eurovision 2024

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 66

  • @KeatsLB
    @KeatsLB 9 місяців тому +66

    Natalia Barbu also represented Moldova at Eurovision in 2007 with the song Fight and I believe she placed 10th in the final

  • @salvatorescrofani1012
    @salvatorescrofani1012 9 місяців тому +60

    I think they (backing singers) are supposed to be her reflection

    • @alinacatalina9581
      @alinacatalina9581 9 місяців тому +9

      I believe the same, they all look alike and have the same movements

  • @inc00022
    @inc00022 9 місяців тому +36

    Basically the whole concept of the staging is that the other females are “copies” of Natalia (the middle singer) and that’s why the other girls are reproducing every move of her (even the lyrics so it seems like lyp syncing).
    And at the beginning I think you’re talking about Denmark’s performance.

  • @ace_reject
    @ace_reject 9 місяців тому +15

    Moldova are usually great at creative staging, so hopefully they’ll give this a big revamp for the finals!

  • @archie-runs
    @archie-runs 9 місяців тому +36

    Every element of the staging and every movement is intentional
    It’s a very rehearsed entry with a lot of thought put into it
    I find it very impactful and original

    • @andresvelara
      @andresvelara 9 місяців тому +4

      Here the same, but I am frustrated of the simplistic points of view that do not have the sensibility to perceive the evident. But well.

  • @Halliinnchuks
    @Halliinnchuks 9 місяців тому +31

    They are doing this as performance because of mirroring. 'mirror' is one of the keywords.

  • @benjischneider5511
    @benjischneider5511 9 місяців тому +10

    what a joy to hear this....love this entry.

  • @allie.ams10
    @allie.ams10 9 місяців тому +18

    100% agree with you; Natalia is great, but there are too many people on the stage without a purpose 90% of the song

  • @christianlyon6147
    @christianlyon6147 9 місяців тому +13

    I’ve watched a lot of reaction videos and you are the first to mention the staging issues. This insight is why you are my favourite!

  • @AddiVF
    @AddiVF 9 місяців тому +62

    Denmark is the country that overdubbed their performance. I have no idea why they did that, her live performance was great as it was!

    • @godanri
      @godanri 9 місяців тому +6

      It wasn't really too great, she sounded very pitchy especially on the low notes, but I'd rather listen to that than the studio version again...

    • @irenedavies144
      @irenedavies144 9 місяців тому +1

      Wow! I didn't know that, shame on them. no wonder I'm not a fan of that song.

    • @marekbp2245
      @marekbp2245 9 місяців тому +2

      At least the Danish Broadcasting Corporation's upload now clearly labels it as a "studio mix", whereas the performances of the 7 other finalists are labelled as being "live".

    • @CL21x
      @CL21x 9 місяців тому +1

      ​@@irenedavies144 It's not the first time Denmark has tampered with the audio for the UA-cam video. They never claimed it was a live performance in the title either. Saba had some in-ear issues, so that's probably why they did it. If you want to hear her vocals, you can always search for her after-party performance.

    • @HumanAfterAll5
      @HumanAfterAll5 9 місяців тому +1

      She had real trouble with her earpiece during her performance, so that's probably why they overdubbed it. She had to take it out while performing, so it definitely caused her trouble.

  • @zebras54
    @zebras54 9 місяців тому +4

    Agree with you on the staging. This awesome song and voice needs great staging.

  • @cemdenizsahin
    @cemdenizsahin 8 місяців тому +3

    I like the song, but this year not many people show enough love to Moldova , hope they can go to the final!!

  • @ellgee42
    @ellgee42 9 місяців тому +23

    Yeah it was Denmark’s entry that was overdubbed - it’s the live performance but they’ve put the studio cut over it for an official video I imagine. There is a winners performance with Saba singing live but the mixing is very bad that u basically can’t hear her unfortunately

  • @andresvelara
    @andresvelara 9 місяців тому +15

    I disagree, the staging is quite smart, but very artistic.
    The performance is about the leading performer being multiplied. Is clear from the first moment that the other girls are not like back singers or other voices; they are like other versions of her.. that is why they move the same, they dress the same, they move their lips while she moves their lips... but some of them move intentionally in different parts... well... that was clear for me... I did not notice confusion on her face while they were performing. For me was clear and perfect.

  • @constantinvorotneac8220
    @constantinvorotneac8220 9 місяців тому +3

    This song have a big potential. I can imagine what powerful will be in big stage in Malmo

  • @MalenaCPH
    @MalenaCPH 8 місяців тому +1

    I love this song so much! I love the 5 girls, I think it is cool.

  • @franzoldtimerhof1493
    @franzoldtimerhof1493 9 місяців тому +5

    Denmark is that country, that has the studio version over the live. But you can search for the original one too

  • @ZeljkoAnzulovic
    @ZeljkoAnzulovic 9 місяців тому +6

    Georgina, this was all over the place 😂

  • @lilianac4728
    @lilianac4728 9 місяців тому +1

    It's her reflection those girls in her background. Looks very interesting for me!

  • @PaulMarchombre
    @PaulMarchombre 9 місяців тому +6

    The singer is talented, the song is good and quiet catchy for me, the fact they are real violins on stage is great. But I would have liked a difference in the singer's outfit compared to the choir. I'm a little confused because they are all dressed the same.😊

  • @minimi870
    @minimi870 8 місяців тому

    I see your point, even if the parts you've noticed are intentional, that doesn't really matter. If it looks confusing or like they're making mistakes, it's bad staging.

  • @FearsomeCircle
    @FearsomeCircle 6 місяців тому +1

    Interestingly, many of the points that you made about the national finals were actually changed in the semi-final performance. In the semi-final Natalia is standing alone on the stage, she's noticeably louder and they have a different style of microphone to pick up both a vocals and the violin solo. She does stay pretty static during the performance but she does have a bit more movement in the arms. It's like they watch your video! It's a shame that the song didn't make it to the Grand Final though.

  • @Maxiecrest14
    @Maxiecrest14 9 місяців тому +7

    They supposed to be copying her movements exactly, including copying lip movements.

  • @Justine_Warsaw
    @Justine_Warsaw 9 місяців тому +2

    POLAND! :)

  • @2012onitsway
    @2012onitsway 9 місяців тому +1

    I know this is not related . I just watched the Madonna. I will survive video from you . Thank you for your input . I love to see more of these input of Madoona Thank you

  • @irenedavies144
    @irenedavies144 9 місяців тому +3

    I love the song, she has an amazing voice like you said but I have to take another look I never noticed the other stuff you mentioned about the backing singers, I hope they can make it better before May, it would be a shame if they messed it up.

  • @boredescfan3008
    @boredescfan3008 9 місяців тому +1

    Denmark overdubbed all the videos on UA-cam. If you need the live broadcasted version, I can send it to you :)

  • @yousseftiguidda8252
    @yousseftiguidda8252 9 місяців тому +1

    Raja's reaction to the songs of a singer in the Middle East called Samira Said

  • @evelyneliaz
    @evelyneliaz 9 місяців тому +1

    Hi, from Sicily Italy! 😊

  • @roh1912
    @roh1912 9 місяців тому

    File under Vocal Gymnastics. What an intricate song to perform. There seems to be a lot of ambience in the track so maybe all the mics were live for the violin section? (The bows need attached lasers!)
    I also reckon the inclusion of pre-taped audience reaction as why do we never see 'em. You are right that this has the appearance of being quickly thrown together without proper rehearsals. Best -

  • @esclad
    @esclad 9 місяців тому +1

    I think they are mouthing the lyrics because they are supposed to be four different mirror reflections of Natalia; so you will only hear one voice. The one 'In The Middle'.

  • @ElenaLupascuHandmade
    @ElenaLupascuHandmade 9 місяців тому

  • @AureWaxman
    @AureWaxman 9 місяців тому +4

    I guess they'll have a lot more budget in Eurovision.

    • @Snooopyy.
      @Snooopyy. 9 місяців тому +3

      She's also married to a millionaire so...even more budget

  • @Otsolintu69
    @Otsolintu69 9 місяців тому +1

    I'am from Finland and i'am very mad picouse Windows 95 winned

  • @esme6346
    @esme6346 7 місяців тому

    I thought they were actually replicas of her, but the harmonies didn't come through until the last part of the song.I'm not sure how strongly I like it. She can sing but I'll listen some more

  • @bagdii
    @bagdii 9 місяців тому +4

    those 3 ladies in the back was dancers and they were just moving lips but only one was a backing singer ( girl on the left side )

  • @mantasdegutis2679
    @mantasdegutis2679 9 місяців тому

    Now it's time for Lithuania please!

  • @Engström33
    @Engström33 9 місяців тому +2

    She’s amazing. She participated in 2007 with a powerful song called Fight.

  • @mariana400
    @mariana400 8 місяців тому

    In the recent years Moldova was great. This year thecsong it's interesting, but I don't know if they will qualify this year in the Grand Final.

  • @myrhapsodyqueen
    @myrhapsodyqueen 9 місяців тому

    Hey Georgina what accent u have ? English not my mother lang ao im curious

  • @chriswald7700
    @chriswald7700 8 місяців тому

    I actually like this kind of static choreography. Makes it kind of unique in the competition. The lip synching never bothered me. I think there's still plenty of time to perfect this.

  • @Atheist2006
    @Atheist2006 9 місяців тому

    Germany?

  • @kimmovuorinen2710
    @kimmovuorinen2710 9 місяців тому

    So sorry if she dont sing live...😢

  • @Rik77
    @Rik77 9 місяців тому +1

    I actually think it’s intentional that they are lip syncing, since they are dressed like the singer and copying her, but trouble is it’s a bit confusing and static and as you say, doesn’t quite work.

  • @jermuhh3359
    @jermuhh3359 8 місяців тому

    I think the performance polish and the technical stuff like mixing aren't as good as it will be at Eurovision because Moldovan national selection is lower budget and smaller compared to many countries so I think it's gonna be amazing in the actual show.

  • @213luiz
    @213luiz 9 місяців тому +1

    Song is decent, singer is amazing (returning from 2007, getting 10 in the semi but also 10th in the final, which is amazing) but staging/choreo is really bad.
    They need to revamp the staging and choreo, but Moldova's national tend to be kinda low budget.

  • @vince_saint
    @vince_saint 9 місяців тому

    Greatest reaction ever 😅 laughed so hard 😅😅

  • @XivSara
    @XivSara 9 місяців тому

    Story .............. going on
    🤔

  • @emokter8577
    @emokter8577 9 місяців тому +1

    I can't help, but apply your comments (how you like a group on stage, harmony of vocals, violins, coordinated dance moves, hands movement) to Estonia's act 😂 just visioning it in my head.
    Moldova this year is rather dissappointing. I like the idea, but the execution is letting them down, i also don't like her voice, and how she sings: she sounds struggling and off at some points. Last year's song was my favourite, still listening to Pasha Parfeni.

  • @raduion7014
    @raduion7014 7 місяців тому

    This is cool. Although not well produced. Moldova however always surprises with quality stuff. Just not winning stuff though.

  • @MrCrayEgg
    @MrCrayEgg 9 місяців тому +2

    Okay but realistically they dont play the instruments live anyway on the big stage!

  • @alexcelbun8603
    @alexcelbun8603 9 місяців тому +4

    This reaction was almost impossible to watch to be honest
    I agree the staging isn't perfect and seems a little bit poorly rehearsed, but you've been fixated on it SO MUCH and paused the video for a zillion times to point it out
    It was irritating
    I respect your opinion
    It's just that you could get over things you don't like much easier and smoother, so we could watch the actual video of the performance a little bit more.

  • @hwmaldonado
    @hwmaldonado 9 місяців тому +2

    There are not 5 women singing or playing, it is 1 woman singing and playing and 4 replicants, it is a threatical expression saying that the only real thing is right IN THE MIDDLE, as the song is entitled. Why you don’t get that?

  • @Livoha
    @Livoha 9 місяців тому

    Way to static

  • @TheBadVideoMaker
    @TheBadVideoMaker 8 місяців тому

    I think that this is probably quite a good song, but I find the performance, production and arrangement to be so flat that it is probably my least favourite of this year's entries.

  • @JörgBauch
    @JörgBauch 9 місяців тому

    Its not the best moldovan entry.

  • @rasimas1
    @rasimas1 9 місяців тому

    Sadly Moldova didn’t go without scandal, then this woman was singing half way in the song, the jury announced her a winner of Eurovision competition, Soviet style, like last year Polish voiceless Bianca’s father bought her ticket to the Eurovision final