If you think about an atom going through time and all of its energy is colliding inside of itself.... Imagine little bits of energy being lost over time..... That would be decay... Anyway that's why whenever you observe something it decays slower... Probably because your gravitational pull in your observation is moving much slower and it's much denser..... The more sporadic something as like a happy thought the faster it pulls on things around and speeding up their decay.... The more dense something is the slower it goes through time so...
This is a great idea for a full episode. I've always wondered experts opinions on how we, as a society based in technology, have designed and developed new tech based on Science Fiction pop culture.
@StarTalk Hope this isn't a rerun. Would love to see you guys back together again in the studio instead of video chat! The interaction together is so much better!
Always entertaining, Thank you! I was wondering if you all have seen the TV show The Expanse and what your expert opinions on how they do space life. I think It portrays gravity and life in the vacuum of space better than most other Sci-Fi shows, but I'm no expert (why I'm writing you). Your comment about communication across long distances in this episode of StarTalk reminded me of The Expanse communication signals taking a long time to reach their destinations. I also appreciate the way they portray movement and travel in the vacuum of space, (accelerating half way then flipping around and decelerating the other half), witch also creates more gravity on the ships. Also, like in Star Wars where the X-Wings flying in outer space look like we would see a fighter jet flying through atmosphere. The spaceships in the Expanse use thrusters and rocket power to float around and past each other more like boats but in 3 dimensions not just 2 like on water. They also have scenes with dangerous deceleration, air leaks and patching, and first aid troubles in low gravity. There is also a lot of Sci-Fi alien stuff that I love to explain the more crazy situations, but I'd love to see an episode of StarTalk about the more science based situations on a show like that. What are your much more expert opinions on a show like the Expanse?
Dr. Tyson clearly illustrated time travel during his award winning proformance in "Sharknato" #Fact Dr. Charles Liu ROCKS #RESPECT Lord Nice is the man #Fact Dr. Tyson is by far the world's greatest astrophysicist #RESPECT Big up from NYC
I really loved the editing and transitions on this one, like those cute little sharks! :3 Haha I agree with a lot of what Dr. Liu said, especially the superpower to keep oneself as mentally and physically stable and basically just live forever
I don't know about The Orville (and other sci fi shows/movies) but as Dr. Lui said Star Trek uses "subspace" for communications etc. You have to give Trek its props for coming up with actual reasons why they can communicate instantaneously across vast distances without time dilation etc.
There are so many clickbait’s about the universe and James Webb telescope on UA-cam, whenever I see something fishy, I come here on startalk with the great grandmaster Neil degrasse Tyson to know the TRUTH 100%!! Best show thanks keep up the good work
You guys missed the point of the first question-it was about instantaneous communication between people in different time streams, not light-speed delay. The crews of two relativistic spacecraft would experience doppler shift talking through subspace, probably to the point of requiring special equipment to identify the signal that would be on a very different frequency. There would in fact be a measurable, though not humanly noticeable, doppler shift between Pasadena and a Mars rover, due to both special and general relativity.
Apart from the patriotism of "regenerate the limbs of veterans...helping defend this country" - most if not all of the wars your country has been into, was started by...your leaders...your country (with the exception of Japan) - I loved this episode :) Cheers!
The evolution of Star Talk is very noticeable. I love this show. And besides the personal bias, the production quality has. Come a long way. Please do not stop this endeavor to give people like me "fun science". "Evolve Or die" - a Spider-Man comic I read. don't ask me to cite..😂🖤🖤
The only personal bias usually comes from Chuck. Neil usually is only talking about straight science but Chuck brings up religion, race, climate change, politics, etc
Neil talking about regenerating limbs reminded me of the scene in the TV show Heroes when "The Cheerleader" was watching a clip of a salamander regenerating it's limbs in science class and then went home and tried it on herself to test her healing powers.
They use an Ansible for communicating. Gosh, I thought you guys were scientific;) But the best title and concept for a sci-fi movie has to go to Killer Klowns from Outer Space. I still giggle at that idea. Thanks again for another great show.
for low speeds the shift in frequency is 2 times the Doppler shift in one direction from the source frequency, so even for a slow ambulance you can hear it decently, at least subtly so. because humans can hear a frequency displacement of a few % at most audible frequencies you would hear. try it :) get a frequency generator, or better yet a guitar, and bend a tone just a little bit and try to measure how small a shift in frequency you can actually notice, its pretty cool that at low tones we can actually notice less than a single hertz shift.
Since i saw the original episode this highlight was part of, i thought that it would be interesting for a lot of people to see more episodes that tackle the science of sci-fi movies and series.
Imagine if you were Thanos AND actually got all the Infinity Stones. It will simply be GAME OVER but Thanos being just another typical dummy foolish villain, we ended up with a whole pile of illogical (even by the "fantasy" standards) time travel shenanigans.
Was dissapointed that this topic wasn't more time consuming, with more in depth exploration. Found what little was there very intriguing and entertaining.
Great episode as always guys🙂. But i think you missunderstood the first question or at least I interpreted it in a different way. I believe it wasn't about the Doppler effect but rather with the different perseption of time in different conditions (speed and gravity). Like in the siblings experiment, where you send one sibling in space and the other stays on earth, the one on earth ages faster (i am sure doctor Tison is familiar with it). If you were to somehow let them comunicate in real time, the sibling on earth would hear the other in slow-mo.For the 5 seconds it takes the space sibling to say a sentence, 7 seconds would have passed on Earth, so the Earth sibling would hear the sentence for 7 seconds, which would sound weird. The opposite would be happening for the other sibling, he would hear his sibling talking faster. I thing this is also a facinating aspect of the question. I hope you read my comment and I would love to hear if you agree with it. And if not i think it would make for a great explainer 😉.
Pretty sure they got it right: The time discrepancy between Earth and space is negligible for conversations. It's not 2 seconds faster, more like 2 nanoseconds faster.
@@FlushGorgon In extreme conditions like a fast moving spaceship or high gravity it could be much more than 5 to 7 Ratio. In Interstellar 1 hour on the planet near a black hole equaled 7 years on earth. And every planet and speed you move at has a different persieved time.
@@GeorgiDimitrov-w5e Interstellar's ratio was immensely exaggerated to make a good story, and high speeds would have to be nearly speed of light, so none of these cases are practical. Granted, the crushing gravity case is still theoretically interesting. The speed one... if you travel at light speed, why would you send a message that doesn't travel faster than you ?
My favorite would have to be a toss-up between Futurama and Rick and Morty. There's a few video games that have a touch of science that I love too. My top would be Toejam & Earl. That's literally how I learned what a wormhole was 😂
What I want to know from sci fi movies is does artificial gravity in space exist? How close are we to that? It always seems to be enabled or disabled easily in film but that is not accurate, right?
The Doppler effect is not based on distance but is based on speed or approach or traveling away. Hunger Games clocking the arena, Truman show etc....... They have adaptive cameoflage.
The army did develope a light refraction 'cloaking' device prototype for ground troops not long ago but it was deemed tactically non-feaseable due to its size and weight not being ideal for someone to carry
‘’Good golly Jupiter Batman!!!!I’m afraid we have no spray to beat this team..’’…’’’looks like Gotham has been stunned again Robin,not even our super accelerator bat serum can decipher if it’s a fruit or a vegetable’’🤓
My favourite is Transformers, Age of Extinction. The iron from other planets formed natural robots with intelligence and their material can assemble and resemble to change into different shapes and patterns, much like quantum probability and shows that there is information stored in raw materials like iron, also, the movie mentioned about the seed ; much like the beginning of life on Earth except this seed is from another planet.
Hmm idk whatever you saw in that movie has no such explanation besides calling the element Transformium. A sci fi element that has no relevant scientific level possibilities.
I'm with you Chuck, I'd be a super bad guy too. "SuperJoker 5.0"! Adaptive defense shielding. Superman strength. John Wick fight skills. Superman x-ray vision. Aquaman powers Exo-atmospheric, and atmospheric fight, and respiratory ability. Impervious to diseases.
In Batman 1966, When Batman re-constituted the UN members, he placed each of the powders on their seats within test tubes. The test tubes were held on Retort stands. When he added the heavy water, where did the retort stands go? Up their wazoos?
What's your favorite piece of Pop Fiction?
Every time when Enterprise went to warp, they should arrive ahead of the event they went to investigate!
The fact that the team of interstellar asked scientists and depicted a black hole before we ever saw one…. Got to be it!
Zero point tech in Ultraviolet
Scarlet Johansson
If you think about an atom going through time and all of its energy is colliding inside of itself.... Imagine little bits of energy being lost over time..... That would be decay... Anyway that's why whenever you observe something it decays slower... Probably because your gravitational pull in your observation is moving much slower and it's much denser..... The more sporadic something as like a happy thought the faster it pulls on things around and speeding up their decay.... The more dense something is the slower it goes through time so...
"My only regret is I still don't know if you're a fruit or vegetable." 😂😂😂😂
Chuck: "Now you do realize that you can say, "no" to these projects?" 🤣
Love seeing everyone together again! The conversations flow much more smoothly than over video call.
this is old
Please bring back this format again. You interactions face to face are missed...😢
I love episodes with Dr. Liu. He is awesome!!
This is a great idea for a full episode. I've always wondered experts opinions on how we, as a society based in technology, have designed and developed new tech based on Science Fiction pop culture.
I believe the full episode is on the podcast. Came out just recently, i think.
This was but a podcast highlight. Watch the full podcast here: ua-cam.com/video/5NnnrTcb1jc/v-deo.html
Chuck's reaction to Neil's jaw-expanding idea at 10:50 is hilarious! 😂
And then Neil's face when Chuck said he'd go for a life of crime 🤣
Did she say "suck-" lol
Chuck will be the funniest Super Villain ever! 😂😂😂😂 “I’m tired of stealing cars from people that FART 💨 all the damn time!”
@StarTalk Hope this isn't a rerun. Would love to see you guys back together again in the studio instead of video chat! The interaction together is so much better!
Damn!! Remember when they used to be the same room together. I miss this 😢
5:58 Man, I love Chuck 😆
Love all of ST episodes! But the episodes with Charles Liu in them an extra special place in my heart. 🥰
Always entertaining, Thank you!
I was wondering if you all have seen the TV show The Expanse and what your expert opinions on how they do space life. I think It portrays gravity and life in the vacuum of space better than most other Sci-Fi shows, but I'm no expert (why I'm writing you). Your comment about communication across long distances in this episode of StarTalk reminded me of The Expanse communication signals taking a long time to reach their destinations. I also appreciate the way they portray movement and travel in the vacuum of space, (accelerating half way then flipping around and decelerating the other half), witch also creates more gravity on the ships. Also, like in Star Wars where the X-Wings flying in outer space look like we would see a fighter jet flying through atmosphere. The spaceships in the Expanse use thrusters and rocket power to float around and past each other more like boats but in 3 dimensions not just 2 like on water. They also have scenes with dangerous deceleration, air leaks and patching, and first aid troubles in low gravity. There is also a lot of Sci-Fi alien stuff that I love to explain the more crazy situations, but I'd love to see an episode of StarTalk about the more science based situations on a show like that.
What are your much more expert opinions on a show like the Expanse?
2:29 Thank you for this clip, Neil 😂
Any episode is great with Dr. Chuck
Hi guys, love your work, long time fan! Great wee sub subject. Enjoying the new wee editing bits too. Keep it up. Love from Scotland x
I love how much geeking out there is in this video. I bounced my body along when they sang "attack of the killer tomatoes."
The 3:28 advert for the Marvels was hilarious... LOL
Thanks guys love watching your every thing you put out always informative and fun!
Dr. Tyson clearly illustrated time travel during his award winning proformance in "Sharknato" #Fact
Dr. Charles Liu ROCKS #RESPECT Lord Nice is the man #Fact Dr. Tyson is by far the world's greatest astrophysicist #RESPECT
Big up from NYC
How do you rate your astrophysicists ?
Now I'm just imagining a world with intelligent sharks that have their own version of NATO. SharkNATO. Maybe they'd have Shark United Nations, too!
Speaking of Cameo at 5:21 LoL... Neil when is your next album gonna drop???
Omg love seeing you guys back live in person again!
The most important subject and so few videos on this. When will there be video on The Expanse?
I really loved the editing and transitions on this one, like those cute little sharks! :3 Haha I agree with a lot of what Dr. Liu said, especially the superpower to keep oneself as mentally and physically stable and basically just live forever
how nice to see you again all together in the studio. the dynamic is so much nicer, as opposed to the remote-screen presentation
I totally agree but this is actually an old episode that was from years ago before the pandemic.
@@jfreshh330 oh really?! i was looking at the upload date and it's very recent....
2:29 - probably my favorite Star Talk moment ever 🤣
that can be a meme tbh
2:29 how does an induction motor start ?
Always best with Chuck Nice
Can we make Chuck Nice and Dr Liu regulars together!
Great Episode. This reminds me of science shows I used to watch as a kid. We need more of this. Thanks guys. You're benefitting society.
Chuck's priorities are rooted in real life ☝️😌
ok again I have to pause and say thank you Uncle Chuck, you really are knocking out my anxiety spells
Probably one of my favorite episodes.
I don't know about The Orville (and other sci fi shows/movies) but as Dr. Lui said Star Trek uses "subspace" for communications etc. You have to give Trek its props for coming up with actual reasons why they can communicate instantaneously across vast distances without time dilation etc.
Hopefully Startalk returns to this way of doing the show, everyone in the room. Much love from California Dr. Tyson, Lord Nice, and Dr. Charles Liu.
6:22 The James Bond movie is "Die Another Day" not "Die Another Way"
11:15 Confirmed Neil will soon be Dr. Connors from The Amazing Spider-Man. 😂
Seriously hope we can do this one day.
There are so many clickbait’s about the universe and James Webb telescope on UA-cam, whenever I see something fishy, I come here on startalk with the great grandmaster Neil degrasse Tyson to know the TRUTH 100%!! Best show thanks keep up the good work
I love watching you three.
I believe that first question was referring to time dilation. As a result of different speeds of the two different sides of the conversation.
6:26 The actual movie title is "Die Another Day".
You guys missed the point of the first question-it was about instantaneous communication between people in different time streams, not light-speed delay. The crews of two relativistic spacecraft would experience doppler shift talking through subspace, probably to the point of requiring special equipment to identify the signal that would be on a very different frequency. There would in fact be a measurable, though not humanly noticeable, doppler shift between Pasadena and a Mars rover, due to both special and general relativity.
"Watch Out For The Cliff" is a great title for a future NDT book.
Apart from the patriotism of "regenerate the limbs of veterans...helping defend this country" - most if not all of the wars your country has been into, was started by...your leaders...your country (with the exception of Japan) - I loved this episode :) Cheers!
Don't ever doubt Neil Tyson's patriotism.
The evolution of Star Talk is very noticeable. I love this show. And besides the personal bias, the production quality has. Come a long way. Please do not stop this endeavor to give people like me "fun science". "Evolve Or die" - a Spider-Man comic I read. don't ask me to cite..😂🖤🖤
The only personal bias usually comes from Chuck. Neil usually is only talking about straight science but Chuck brings up religion, race, climate change, politics, etc
@@jfreshh330 I meant to clarify. I'm talking about my own personal bias when it comes to praising the show. Because outside of that it's a great show.
The dream team are back again! Always the most entertaining episodes.
10:31 there is already a movie on that concept (loosely) and it's called "The Man from Earth"
Good to see the guys back in the office
Neil talking about regenerating limbs reminded me of the scene in the TV show Heroes when "The Cheerleader" was watching a clip of a salamander regenerating it's limbs in science class and then went home and tried it on herself to test her healing powers.
They use an Ansible for communicating. Gosh, I thought you guys were scientific;)
But the best title and concept for a sci-fi movie has to go to Killer Klowns from Outer Space. I still giggle at that idea.
Thanks again for another great show.
Super villain is the way to go, Chuck! It pays more! 😂
I love this show 😊
for low speeds the shift in frequency is 2 times the Doppler shift in one direction from the source frequency, so even for a slow ambulance you can hear it decently, at least subtly so. because humans can hear a frequency displacement of a few % at most audible frequencies you would hear. try it :) get a frequency generator, or better yet a guitar, and bend a tone just a little bit and try to measure how small a shift in frequency you can actually notice, its pretty cool that at low tones we can actually notice less than a single hertz shift.
I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate
props on sharknado, that is pretty cool.
This is a rerun. There is no way Chuck would wear that sweater again.
We LOVE Charles!
Like how chuck casually mentions princess babblegum as if the two other there knows her lol.
Where can I submit a question for the cosmic queries
StarTalk and Marvel?!?! Thank you for this!!!
Since i saw the original episode this highlight was part of, i thought that it would be interesting for a lot of people to see more episodes that tackle the science of sci-fi movies and series.
Imagine if you were Thanos AND actually got all the Infinity Stones. It will simply be GAME OVER but Thanos being just another typical dummy foolish villain, we ended up with a whole pile of illogical (even by the "fantasy" standards) time travel shenanigans.
I love that Adventure Time was mentioned.
With regards to invisibility. They forgot about the best superhero and their invisible car. An Alien whom goes by the name... MEGAMIND.
Hey Chuck! Love your Direct TV commercial. Hilarious!
Was dissapointed that this topic wasn't more time consuming, with more in depth exploration. Found what little was there very intriguing and entertaining.
Chuck Nice as a super-villain sounds like a great idea
3 cool science pals would be perfect secret identities.
Great episode as always guys🙂. But i think you missunderstood the first question or at least I interpreted it in a different way. I believe it wasn't about the Doppler effect but rather with the different perseption of time in different conditions (speed and gravity). Like in the siblings experiment, where you send one sibling in space and the other stays on earth, the one on earth ages faster (i am sure doctor Tison is familiar with it). If you were to somehow let them comunicate in real time, the sibling on earth would hear the other in slow-mo.For the 5 seconds it takes the space sibling to say a sentence, 7 seconds would have passed on Earth, so the Earth sibling would hear the sentence for 7 seconds, which would sound weird. The opposite would be happening for the other sibling, he would hear his sibling talking faster. I thing this is also a facinating aspect of the question. I hope you read my comment and I would love to hear if you agree with it. And if not i think it would make for a great explainer 😉.
Pretty sure they got it right: The time discrepancy between Earth and space is negligible for conversations. It's not 2 seconds faster, more like 2 nanoseconds faster.
@@FlushGorgon In extreme conditions like a fast moving spaceship or high gravity it could be much more than 5 to 7 Ratio. In Interstellar 1 hour on the planet near a black hole equaled 7 years on earth. And every planet and speed you move at has a different persieved time.
@@GeorgiDimitrov-w5e Interstellar's ratio was immensely exaggerated to make a good story, and high speeds would have to be nearly speed of light, so none of these cases are practical.
Granted, the crushing gravity case is still theoretically interesting. The speed one... if you travel at light speed, why would you send a message that doesn't travel faster than you ?
Got to love Chuck Nice!!
"you do realize you can say no to these projects?" Hahahahahaha Great Chuck !!
Hello there everyone :D
Howdy partner
I’m with Chuck…super villain
FYI, these are reuploaded clips from old episodes.
I wish you guys would return back to Neils office! I’m tired of seeing low quality pixelated 720p webcams every episode
are these old clips?
Please do an episode on the science in the movie “Everything, Everywhere, All at Once”
I LOVED attack of the killer tomatoes cartoon!
I need you guys to do a review on Tenet by Christopher nolan
You have Frodo's magic elven cloak, similar to Harry's
Neil and Chuck for 2024
Maybe not Chuck if he goes on his life of being a super villain. ;-P
My favorite would have to be a toss-up between Futurama and Rick and Morty. There's a few video games that have a touch of science that I love too. My top would be Toejam & Earl. That's literally how I learned what a wormhole was 😂
The cameo was epic lmao
Charles is my hero
Lord Nice with wings is an interesting proposal.
What I want to know from sci fi movies is does artificial gravity in space exist? How close are we to that? It always seems to be enabled or disabled easily in film but that is not accurate, right?
My understanding of general relativity is that that's logically impossible-even time travel is more likely. They'll be spinning a lot.
Rerun or are you back to in person?
Charles = Wolverine/Death Strike/Deadpool superpower, awesome movie 😅
Neil wants "Deadpool", #RyanReynolds #wrexham
The Doppler effect is not based on distance but is based on speed or approach or traveling away.
Hunger Games clocking the arena, Truman show etc....... They have adaptive cameoflage.
Love to see u guys back in person.. i was really struggling with the zoom episodes..
The army did develope a light refraction 'cloaking' device prototype for ground troops not long ago but it was deemed tactically non-feaseable due to its size and weight not being ideal for someone to carry
‘’Good golly Jupiter Batman!!!!I’m afraid we have no spray to beat this team..’’…’’’looks like Gotham has been stunned again Robin,not even our super accelerator bat serum can decipher if it’s a fruit or a vegetable’’🤓
In movies you can hear most of the explosions in space. I saw a movie where it was without sound - spooky.
My favourite is Transformers, Age of Extinction. The iron from other planets formed natural robots with intelligence and their material can assemble and resemble to change into different shapes and patterns, much like quantum probability and shows that there is information stored in raw materials like iron, also, the movie mentioned about the seed ; much like the beginning of life on Earth except this seed is from another planet.
Hmm idk whatever you saw in that movie has no such explanation besides calling the element Transformium. A sci fi element that has no relevant scientific level possibilities.
I was certain they would talk about the movie "The Martian". The sci fi bits are few AND mostly things engineers claim will be possible at some point.
I'm with you Chuck, I'd be a super bad guy too. "SuperJoker 5.0"!
Adaptive defense shielding.
Superman strength.
John Wick fight skills.
Superman x-ray vision.
Aquaman powers
Exo-atmospheric, and atmospheric fight, and respiratory ability.
Impervious to diseases.
10:27 Sounds similar to the movie the Man from Earth which is agreat movie btw!
The guy who lives forever and the guy with the snake jaw needs to stop the super villain that has beetle wings and super strength.
What's your opinion on the movie Donnie Darko?
In Batman 1966, When Batman re-constituted the UN members, he placed each of the powders on their seats within test tubes. The test tubes were held on Retort stands. When he added the heavy water, where did the retort stands go? Up their wazoos?