As a musician, it bothers me that everyone is arguing who did what better. Music shouldn't be a contest all the time (aka The Voice etc.). They must have a love for the song and in my opinion do it beautifully. That does not take anything away from the original. More music, less arguing people. XOXO
Arguing about music is like arguing to a friend that you can love your wife better than he can love his. It's a preposterous discussion, that skills need not apply. Music is like a puzzle piece and each of us has a different-shaped void within ourselves that can be filled with the music of our choosing.
TheWoodsugar As an artist, it bothers me that people believe that it's impossible to criticize art. It's a fairly easy thing to do; though, in this case, it is futile.
retsea1 It's not that art can't be criticized, it's that sometimes it shouldn't be. It's important to know when to look at it with a critical eye and when to just shut up and appreciate it.
It's such a great song, but the essence here is the delicate harmony that these two created. They captured the imagination of the world for a short while. Duets are a tough act to maintain, with or without separate lives. They will always be magic. The magnetism they created in a close environment was breathtaking.
How is it that I’ve just found this now (10 years later)!! The civil wars are a fantastic duo, have listened to them for years wish I’d come across earlier, what a gem
Right now... I smile and almost cry when hearing this song. Been conflicted a lot lately with something... and this song just makes me hear a voice that makes me smile. -sigh- Civil Wars always do an amazing job with songs, covers or not... They put amazing emotion into them...
dont you see that it is always her staring with hope and longing.. the way he looks at her is to simply acknowledge her. in every video she stares at him the same way, and he doesnt seem to reciprocate it. personally, i find it distracting....
I figure I better put my sad sap story because it's not sad, actually very beautiful to me. I had a girl 4 or 5 years ago that I fell absolutely in love with and it was amazing. Then of course, the devastating breakup of a 16 year old kid with a big heart. So I went back to a band that reminded me of strong feelings when they played music, The Civil Wars. Well I already knew about Barton Hallow, but then the rest slapped me silly with every tear I didn't believe I could shed anymore resting on my lap. Well after a few years, a new gf, and a new reason to cry over strong music music but no longer being able to build them up, I found myself in disbelief. One of the most passionate songs, Between the Bars, was of course a cover and a video I had already seen but for me to forget about it, have a new gf that had that song as a favorite song and be the original version.. it's amazing that love goes around in the way it does. I know that's a weird thing to share but it just blew my mind cause of the sweet memories this time instead of the bad ones.
Bu grubu tanıdıktan sonra tek istediğim canlı bir şekilde dinlemekti. Ne kadar bahtsızsam artık kısmet olmadan dağıldılar.Her şarkıları ayrı bir güzel ben hayatımda bu kadar birbirine yakışan ikili görmedim.Keşke bir gün tekrar bir araya gelseler.
The beauty here is the continuation of a perfectly wrote song by Elliot. Not if they captured exactly what Elliot Smith did. This is the definition of a cover. Keeping it alive.
It’s those looks that have always made me think there was more to their partnership and more to their breakup. Not that I think anything actually happened but I really do believe they got so close that out of respect they parted ways
Of course he can! Might I remind you that this "Sirius Black" you speak of is actually renowned singer Stubby Boardman who was wrongfully incriminated for crimes he did not commit.
I feel like nobody in the comments understands what 'artistic interpretation' is, LOL. Whenever an artist puts their work out there, people are always going to interpret it in their own, personal way, and that's a given. If these musicians thought it sounded like a love song, there's nothing wrong with that. Let them express it however they want; this version is just as valid as the original. And calm the hell down.
amen dude! I'm not a fan of the Civil Wars, yet I adore Elliott's songs, but you're right on. It's a beautiful song, and they sing it really well the way they want to, so kudos to them. Also Ivacqua sounds like a guitar snob, like that's a relevant thing.
Drink up baby Stay up all night The things you could do You won't but you might The potential you'll be That you'll never see The promises you'll only make Drink up with me now And forget all about the pressure of days Do what I say and I'll make you okay And drive them away The images stuck in your head People you've been before That you don't want around anymore They push, shove and won't bend to your will I'll keep them still Drink up baby Look at the stars I'll kiss you again between the bars Where I'm seeing you there With your hands in the air Waiting to finally be caught Drink up one more time And I'll make you mine Keep you apart, deep in my heart Separate from the rest Where I like you the best And keeping the things you forgot People you've been before That you don't want around anymore That push and shove and won't bend to your will I'll keep them still
There are two problems that I have with this recording: 1) Whoever did the recording overdid the removal of background noise, and it made the quieter moments of the song sound "swirly". 2) The song lacks any of the latent spite of the original. I mean, does this sound like two people singing about resorting to drinking to forget their troubles? Sure, it's "beautiful," but that's not really the point. I mean, credit for trying, but they've turned a scathing song about giving up into a lullaby.
Good effort. Nothing ever will compare to Elliott, but those who try are brave. Us Elliott fans can be ruthless when people cover him poorly (or at all)
Of course, nothing can ever amount to Elliot Smith's original of this song. As much as I love The Civil Wars, Elliot Smith just did this so perfectly, as it WAS his own. But no one can deny that this cover is beautifully done (as The Civil Wars have a tendency to do that). It's a great cover.
Is anyone really saying she wasn’t in love with him? Watch this video. She couldn’t stop looking and he REFUSED to look at her. Probably also a sign that he knew what he was doing....
I always hate listening to new songs by artists I love for fear that it won't be like their other stuff and I'll be disappointed. Not with The Civil Wars. All their music is so great!
they cancelled the rest of their current tour because of "internal discord" but they said they plan to make more music together in 2013 i think they'll work it out because of their amazing chemistry i think they're just having a rough time right now joy recently had a baby and she and her husband probably just want some rest time at home with their baby
Drink up, baby, stay up all night With the things you could do, you won't but you might The potential you'll be that you'll never see The promises you'll only make Drink up with me now and forget all about The pressure of days, do what I say And I'll make you okay and drive them away The images stuck in your head People you've been before that you Don't want around anymore That push and shove and won't bend to your will I'll keep them still Drink up, baby, look at the stars I'll kiss you again, between the bars Where I'm seeing you there, with your hands in the air Waiting to finally be caught Drink up one more time and I'll make you mine Keep you apart, deep in my heart Separate from the rest, where I like you the best And keep the things you forgot People you've been before that you Don't want around anymore That push and shove and won't bend to your will I'll keep them still
As a musician, it bothers me that everyone is arguing who did what better. Music shouldn't be a contest all the time (aka The Voice etc.). They must have a love for the song and in my opinion do it beautifully. That does not take anything away from the original. More music, less arguing people. XOXO
Arguing about music is like arguing to a friend that you can love your wife better than he can love his. It's a preposterous discussion, that skills need not apply. Music is like a puzzle piece and each of us has a different-shaped void within ourselves that can be filled with the music of our choosing.
***** god damn that was beautiful.
Sawyer Tilley well thank you!
TheWoodsugar As an artist, it bothers me that people believe that it's impossible to criticize art. It's a fairly easy thing to do; though, in this case, it is futile.
retsea1 It's not that art can't be criticized, it's that sometimes it shouldn't be. It's important to know when to look at it with a critical eye and when to just shut up and appreciate it.
Always gives me chills... How synced they are ... How dark they take their covers... Or shall I make that past tense...
These two were magnetic. No one can argue that. Not even them. Which is why it hurt to much when it was over.
damn, i miss them together.
At least a couple times a month I still go through that. One can only hope that someday they can work everything our and work together again.
Elliott Smith was such a genius of a songwriter, but hearing it in two-part harmony really adds a new dimension to it.
I thought that when i watched Elliott with Rose Melberg on "biggest lie" 2-13-96....beautiful....:)
Parvenu? Vous êtes française par hasard?
British hahaha ;) just appreciate french
I love the guy in the background trying desperately to hold his brains in his head.
I guess he is the sound engeering trying to listen in his headphone.
I guess he is the sound engeering trying to listen in his headphone.
Love this comment!
LMAO thanks for bringing this to my attention
*edit: typo
I miss them so much. Their split still breaks my heart. 😢
12/2023 and I still miss them 😢
R.I.P Elliot Smith.... You are one of the best.... May you live in peace.....
I love the Civil Wars. They have a hypnotic, haunting sound that I can't get enough of. They're the best duebt since Johnny and June, simply amazing.
This is so powerful. Great cover miss you guys
John Paul is so mesmerizing. His voice, his face, his personality.... everything.
It's such a great song, but the essence here is the delicate harmony that these two created. They captured the imagination of the world for a short while. Duets are a tough act to maintain, with or without separate lives. They will always be magic. The magnetism they created in a close environment was breathtaking.
How is it that I’ve just found this now (10 years later)!! The civil wars are a fantastic duo, have listened to them for years wish I’d come across earlier, what a gem
Right now... I smile and almost cry when hearing this song. Been conflicted a lot lately with something... and this song just makes me hear a voice that makes me smile. -sigh- Civil Wars always do an amazing job with songs, covers or not... They put amazing emotion into them...
The way they look at each other omfg
Right! Its what I dream of!!! XD
Emily Harris and yet they say there was only passion of music between them nothing romantic. .....
+Hahn
dont you see that it is always her staring with hope and longing.. the way he looks at her is to simply acknowledge her. in every video she stares at him the same way, and he doesnt seem to reciprocate it. personally, i find it distracting....
sounds lame, but its proof that love can be made with music.
God, I love this duo. The chemistry.
Didn't think it was possible to make Elliott's already beautiful song even more amazing
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhh, Joy and John Paul are so breathtakingly talented. I love this so much.
one of my favorite covers. Elliot wouldve been proud.
EmilyN/A i didnt know you knew elliott smith and how he thinks.
I've yet to listen to a Civil Wars song and not be completely enthralled. Beautiful, just beautiful.
Gorgeous rendition. Quality mimicry with an added element of respect.
His voice is so soothing, love this!
I've fallen in love with this duo... I thought no one could do Elliott justice but these guys come very VERY close.
my favorite cover of all time!!
so beautiful cover ,their voices are really nice
I figure I better put my sad sap story because it's not sad, actually very beautiful to me. I had a girl 4 or 5 years ago that I fell absolutely in love with and it was amazing. Then of course, the devastating breakup of a 16 year old kid with a big heart. So I went back to a band that reminded me of strong feelings when they played music, The Civil Wars. Well I already knew about Barton Hallow, but then the rest slapped me silly with every tear I didn't believe I could shed anymore resting on my lap. Well after a few years, a new gf, and a new reason to cry over strong music music but no longer being able to build them up, I found myself in disbelief. One of the most passionate songs, Between the Bars, was of course a cover and a video I had already seen but for me to forget about it, have a new gf that had that song as a favorite song and be the original version.. it's amazing that love goes around in the way it does. I know that's a weird thing to share but it just blew my mind cause of the sweet memories this time instead of the bad ones.
alot of they live sessions like this always seem to have so little to no people watching. they don't know what they missing out on.
my mom went to high school with joy williams! my mom got me into her music & the civil wars & i absolutely adore them!!❤️❤️❤️
Still missing them.
Bu grubu tanıdıktan sonra tek istediğim canlı bir şekilde dinlemekti. Ne kadar bahtsızsam artık kısmet olmadan dağıldılar.Her şarkıları ayrı bir güzel ben hayatımda bu kadar birbirine yakışan ikili görmedim.Keşke bir gün tekrar bir araya gelseler.
The beauty here is the continuation of a perfectly wrote song by Elliot. Not if they captured exactly what Elliot Smith did. This is the definition of a cover. Keeping it alive.
These guys see truly amazing!
Beautiful. Brings justice to a beautiful song by an amazing man.
I love this cover. It's Amazing -
Such beautiful music,so glad they are together!!
When i first found out they are both happily married with kids to other people, i was amazed. Their chemistry is so real and wonderful.
It’s those looks that have always made me think there was more to their partnership and more to their breakup. Not that I think anything actually happened but I really do believe they got so close that out of respect they parted ways
Didnt know sirius black could sing
HAHA, right?!
Haha. Good one bro.
Of course he can! Might I remind you that this "Sirius Black" you speak of is actually renowned singer Stubby Boardman who was wrongfully incriminated for crimes he did not commit.
I didn't know Sirius Black was Johnny Depp.
THIS COMMENT
I wish Elliott was still here!
Beautiful music!
Oh man ! Elliot Smith !! The Civil Wars...nice job ! What a song !!!
i adore the way she looks at him in the beginning.
I miss their voices together so much😭
The connection they have is astonishing! I hope one day they get back together!
I miss these two. I hope they resurface soon.
gave me goosebumps, outstanding.
absolutely flawless and beautiful. Love them.
Lovely rendition, has the rhythm of waves, of being out at sea, drunk on love...
09/2024 i still miss them
Love this version!
Oh lord this is beautiful
I feel like nobody in the comments understands what 'artistic interpretation' is, LOL. Whenever an artist puts their work out there, people are always going to interpret it in their own, personal way, and that's a given. If these musicians thought it sounded like a love song, there's nothing wrong with that. Let them express it however they want; this version is just as valid as the original. And calm the hell down.
I got the chills
I'm obsessed with them.
Gorgeous harmony.
I would love to hear them cover Jeff Buckley. that'd be an awesome treat
Love this, and how they are so good! I wish I had the guts to sing more often....love the style
I love it how they look at each other and smile(:
Two amazing talents by themselves, God sent, together!
Such a great song
Omg their voices are so beautiful :-)
These lyrics are really beautiful
best explanation of their talent ever.
Beautiful Voices
One of my favorites.
Elliott Smith was an amazing artist and they seemed to make this song their own. I think Elliott is smiling down on this version.
This is amazing!
I love you guys.
The guys kinda reminds me of johnny depp...lol
So lovely
I miss this..
How are people dissin on this? This is amazing.
Hopefully they get back together someday
1:58, look where his eyes shift to, and listen to the verse. Wow. It's shocking these two never got married.
amen dude! I'm not a fan of the Civil Wars, yet I adore Elliott's songs, but you're right on. It's a beautiful song, and they sing it really well the way they want to, so kudos to them. Also Ivacqua sounds like a guitar snob, like that's a relevant thing.
Very nice! :) But is t me or does the beginning seem a bit off beat or is it supposed to be that way??
Yes very beautiful!
2019
why did they fell apart??? or are they still making music together? anyone??? Thanks
No one knows the real reason that make them apart but sadly they arent make music together anymore.They work separated
I love it
I've been waiting for this.
Drink up baby
Stay up all night
The things you could do
You won't but you might
The potential you'll be
That you'll never see
The promises you'll only make
Drink up with me now
And forget all about the pressure of days
Do what I say and I'll make you okay
And drive them away
The images stuck in your head
People you've been before
That you don't want around anymore
They push, shove and won't bend to your will
I'll keep them still
Drink up baby
Look at the stars
I'll kiss you again between the bars
Where I'm seeing you there
With your hands in the air
Waiting to finally be caught
Drink up one more time
And I'll make you mine
Keep you apart, deep in my heart
Separate from the rest
Where I like you the best
And keeping the things you forgot
People you've been before
That you don't want around anymore
That push and shove and won't bend to your will
I'll keep them still
Thank you 🤩🙏🏼
There are two problems that I have with this recording:
1) Whoever did the recording overdid the removal of background noise, and it made the quieter moments of the song sound "swirly".
2) The song lacks any of the latent spite of the original. I mean, does this sound like two people singing about resorting to drinking to forget their troubles? Sure, it's "beautiful," but that's not really the point. I mean, credit for trying, but they've turned a scathing song about giving up into a lullaby.
Thank you for making me feel better. Now I can rest easily =)
This was an amazing cover
Perfect
Beautiful 😍
Good effort. Nothing ever will compare to Elliott, but those who try are brave. Us Elliott fans can be ruthless when people cover him poorly (or at all)
more more more !!!!
i love the civil wars but the original song is so perfect that is very hard to forget
Of course, nothing can ever amount to Elliot Smith's original of this song. As much as I love The Civil Wars, Elliot Smith just did this so perfectly, as it WAS his own. But no one can deny that this cover is beautifully done (as The Civil Wars have a tendency to do that). It's a great cover.
Is anyone really saying she wasn’t in love with him? Watch this video. She couldn’t stop looking and he REFUSED to look at her. Probably also a sign that he knew what he was doing....
I always hate listening to new songs by artists I love for fear that it won't be like their other stuff and I'll be disappointed. Not with The Civil Wars. All their music is so great!
You DID capture the beauty :)
What is wrong with the camera man?
her voice is so great...it almost sounds like a musical saw at times
they cancelled the rest of their current tour because of "internal discord" but they said they plan to make more music together in 2013 i think they'll work it out because of their amazing chemistry i think they're just having a rough time right now joy recently had a baby and she and her husband probably just want some rest time at home with their baby
This song is about alcohol addiction I wonder if them producing it this way was intentional like you’re hearing it in this trippy hazy kinda way
Drink up, baby, stay up all night
With the things you could do, you won't but you might
The potential you'll be that you'll never see
The promises you'll only make
Drink up with me now and forget all about
The pressure of days, do what I say
And I'll make you okay and drive them away
The images stuck in your head
People you've been before that you
Don't want around anymore
That push and shove and won't bend to your will
I'll keep them still
Drink up, baby, look at the stars
I'll kiss you again, between the bars
Where I'm seeing you there, with your hands in the air
Waiting to finally be caught
Drink up one more time and I'll make you mine
Keep you apart, deep in my heart
Separate from the rest, where I like you the best
And keep the things you forgot
People you've been before that you
Don't want around anymore
That push and shove and won't bend to your will
I'll keep them still
amazing.
God I miss these two together.