Let’s talk about asylum seekers arriving in Ireland without documents

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 174

  • @franktrappe4916
    @franktrappe4916 Рік тому +12

    Hi Terry can you reference the document or article you are reading from please.

    • @terrygorry
      @terrygorry  Рік тому +4

      Frank,
      1. Research paper by ESRI www.esri.ie/publications/explaining-recent-trends-in-international-protection-applications-in-ireland
      AND
      2. Irish Times article by the researchers based on their peer reviewed research www.irishtimes.com/opinion/2023/05/30/fact-checking-the-claims-about-unvetted-migrants/

    • @franktrappe4916
      @franktrappe4916 Рік тому

      Sounded familiar 🤔 Thanks T. 👌

    • @wilfredwilde9559
      @wilfredwilde9559 10 місяців тому +3

      I listened to it in its entirety purely for the beautiful sound of the birds singing in the background 😊

    • @user-qd6iq7jp7m
      @user-qd6iq7jp7m 8 місяців тому +7

      Every Nigerian who ever got asylum here goes home every year for holidays to the country they fled

    • @sobraine123
      @sobraine123 6 місяців тому

      @@wilfredwilde9559 perfect place to pitch a tent !

  • @aidancoyle246
    @aidancoyle246 Рік тому +73

    Someone arriving into Ireland, which is an island in the North Atlantic is impossible to do without documents. If I, am Irish citizen tried to either enter or leave Ireland without my passport I would be charged with a criminal offense.

    • @asadm9522
      @asadm9522 Місяць тому

      They are charged if they arrive without docs.

  • @Sun-dh1ks
    @Sun-dh1ks Рік тому +65

    They got on the plane with documents but lost them by the time they got off the plane. We have advertised to the world that we are stupid and naive. So, we are being invaded because of it.

  • @brendancahill7328
    @brendancahill7328 Рік тому +53

    The Irish government and other European governments see this migrant situation as an opportunity to get cheap labour into their countries. I don't like the direction our country has gone in. I can see major troubles ahead especially for our younger generation.

    • @jimbobarooney2861
      @jimbobarooney2861 Рік тому +3

      The indigenous population of Europe and most western countries are declining, and declining rapidly with each generation, you grow your economy by growing your population and basically that's what these countries are doing, e.g. Ukraine, why let a bad situation go to waste, I have no problem with "helping" Ukrainians, ultimately its Ukraine that suffers in the end of this people grab tactics.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765Why are bigoted idiots like you unable to write coherently?

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 You are an bigot, you are repeatedly corrected and you continue to maintain your ignorant positions despite having been correct, therefore you are a bigot. I’m glad to help you better understand. ☺️ Also, you are shadow boxing again.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +2

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765You have been corrected, when I corrected you on Irish Liberal politics. You were bigoted by persisting in pretending that Irish government policy is not dominated by Liberalism.

    • @benhay100
      @benhay100 11 місяців тому +2

      Yeah if and when they get a vote they will vote for the ppl who let them stay. Not too mention they are housed and employed first

  • @davebutler6498
    @davebutler6498 7 місяців тому +4

    Terry enjoying his leafy surroundings and the peace and quiet and safety. I think Terry could accommodate quite a few so called refugees in that lovey garden.

  • @donore3
    @donore3 Рік тому +31

    In Canada there was the practice of putting asylum seekers in prisons until there claims were heard . I wonder how many asylum seekers would arrive in Ireland if this was the practice here?

    • @blueocean2510
      @blueocean2510 10 місяців тому +1

      It could become similar to Mumbai 2008 .
      The companies and institutions who support the Genocide in Gaza based in Ireland may become a target, similar to Mumbai and other places.

    • @patrickmurphy9597
      @patrickmurphy9597 7 місяців тому

      We need to do that in the United States 🇺🇸

    • @asadm9522
      @asadm9522 Місяць тому

      Bot and nt related to post​@@blueocean2510

  • @williamcannon7262
    @williamcannon7262 Рік тому +33

    The system is a sick joke! and endangering the Irish People.

  • @dazza9859
    @dazza9859 Рік тому +20

    Massive fines recently for airlines allowing people to depart without passports.

  • @cuurly86
    @cuurly86 Рік тому +32

    Is not an issue of arriving in Ireland without documentation, the issue is that you cannot board the plane without documentation, so why destroy your id before going to immigration in Ireland?

    • @lululiga333
      @lululiga333 10 місяців тому

      Exactly. Also how come there’s always a luxury bus waiting and the exact amount of beds ready in a luxury hotel or other kind of building and translators ready and whole teams set up to settle these guys into free welfare and a promise of housing? If people are fleeing war or terrible unbearable circumstances. They don’t arrive in parties of 100 all around the same age with fancy suitcases nice clothes mobile phones etc. Absolute scam going on. So many people making a fortune out of it too. Check out the nationalities of these asylum seekers. Hardly any are coming from countries where there’s a war going on. As for then being landed into buildings with blacked out windows into safe towns and communities where resources are at their lowest. In large numbers. Is all beyond reckless and completely unacceptable.

    • @Ann-bm5qg
      @Ann-bm5qg 9 місяців тому +3

      They destroy it when they get off the plane.

    • @lululiga333
      @lululiga333 9 місяців тому +2

      @@Ann-bm5qgLeo Vradker says people traffickers collect the passports on the plane and still Ireland allows this and we then often fully take care of these economic migrants. I don’t believe for one minute that they’re strictly vetted at all. How then would Puska have been allowed stay in Ireland. Coming from a non conflict country and having come here with a previous child sex offence record. He was also given welfare free housing etc.

  • @edmondopowell
    @edmondopowell Рік тому +15

    What about the ones that fail over 90 percent and the ones told to leave but don’t? Why even have a asylum system if their is not a deportation system and most fail don’t leave!!!

  • @patrickmurphy9597
    @patrickmurphy9597 7 місяців тому +2

    I'm sure if I showed up without documents as a pasty ruddy faced white guy. I would be turned around.

  • @skmotorcycles8123
    @skmotorcycles8123 6 місяців тому +2

    Isn’t that called a scam artist.? By destroying governments documents and giving false information their already commuting a crime

    • @asadm9522
      @asadm9522 Місяць тому

      International law and irish law allows for context, vetting surveys, interviews ascertain this. Perhaps listen to video for goodness sake or educate yurself.

  • @staffofdagda6238
    @staffofdagda6238 Рік тому +23

    There is a big difference between an asylum seeker, refugee or economic migrant. Perhaps, you may have defined the those concepts more clearly.

    • @Liam25025
      @Liam25025 Рік тому +7

      ​@Mike McGrath-Bryan There's a difference between Irish people who went to work and economic migrants coming from safe countries to where they get the best deal on social welfare.

    • @Liam25025
      @Liam25025 Рік тому +2

      ​@Mike McGrath-Bryan They're not coming to take our jobs that's for sure, because they don't want or need jobs here. They are absolutely coming for "our dole" and it doesn't take much to figure that one out. It's also going to be the ruination of our small soft touch country much quicker than it was in Sweden for example. You know, the once safe country that is now one of the most dangerous in Europe. Not to mention the rape capital of Europe too. Who care about the native European people though when you have billions of people from Africa and the middle east to worry about isn't that right.

    • @HH-hd3gs
      @HH-hd3gs Рік тому +2

      ​@mikemcgrath-bryan2765 🤣🤣🤣 Look at the size of Ireland compared to the US, Australia or Canada.

    • @doloresaquines1529
      @doloresaquines1529 Рік тому

      ​@@Liam25025Well said Eddy. And btw ignore the troll! It isn't interested in rational discussión. Just trying to get a rise, sniggering there in his basement.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      ⁠@mikemcgrath-bryan2765>Outside of our jurisdiction
      What on earth are you drivelling on about?

  • @timheavyable
    @timheavyable 6 місяців тому +1

    Im irish born and bred. I was in a relationship with an American girl for 5 years,We wanted to marry. She has a masters in social work, We tried to get her to live here but when we went through all the correct avenues and she was denied the right to live here. She had to go back to America and our dreams were smashed. Now we have illegal migrants arriving and they cant even speak the language but are welcomed and put in hotels. My partner was a highly educated woman and my country denied her the right to marry me and live in ireland. Its a joke, she may as well just come illegaly and she would get in. Its a damn joke of a system.

  • @skmotorcycles8123
    @skmotorcycles8123 6 місяців тому +2

    Also their not seeking refuge in the nearest safe neighbouring country if their coming from India Pakistan Zimbabwe Somalia Ukraine theirs plenty of safe countries between these even for Ukrainians Germany France England Poland etc are safe .

  • @mairedaly4926
    @mairedaly4926 5 місяців тому +1

    I had a friend trafficked into Ireland (She was a Christian from Pakistan & had suffered personal, targeted religious persecution). The Traffickers dropped her off at a Garda station a few miles from the airport and promptly drove off never to be seen again. The traffickers kept her documents, we suspect, so she couldn't be deported quickly. I suspect traffickers also keep passports to reuse them to traffic others, I could be wrong but that's my theory.

  • @alirlandes2238
    @alirlandes2238 Рік тому +8

    The system is broken and is attracting scammers in their droves. Even when people are denied refugee status, they might well be given "subsidiary protection" and sure if they don't qualify for that, they can just get "permission to remain" because they have been in the system for so long. This is wrong and it needs to stop.

  • @thet1375
    @thet1375 Рік тому +10

    Ireland today is unrecognisable. Flanagan, Coveney, Varadkar etc involvement in signing the UN migration pact in 2018 set the ball in motion, opened the door to the Ireland we are witnessing today. Unvetted men coming from safe countries and planted in towns and villages all across Ireland. This is a plantation and if Irish people oppose this they are labelled. Soon Ireland will have no identity of who we are as a people because it is being taken from us. The Irish pub is dying also, no atmosphere in a pub in Ireland anymore mainly because the woke brigade killed any craic incase it offends the minority. Also alcohol price hikes and pushing non alcoholic beer (why any pub in Ireland is going along for this is madness) many pubs having to close their doors also is by design.

    • @Stephengrimes1972
      @Stephengrimes1972 Рік тому +3

      None of this is by accident,much worse is on the way.

  • @RedOakCrow
    @RedOakCrow Рік тому +22

    The no documents trope is irrelevant imo, we simply don't have the capacity to house these men long term given the lack of will from the government to either build or facilitate the building of housing on any significant scale. For the people that are providing the industrial units and refurbished pubs, it just seems to be a money racket, they don't seem to have any scruples about warehousing these men in substandard conditions so long as they get their government money.

    • @dazza9859
      @dazza9859 Рік тому +3

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765tax payers money .When we in a cost of living crisis.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +3

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765​​⁠We have capitulated to Liberals and have done for at least 3 decades. Liberalism dominates all policy across the West and has done for 3 decades. Anyone claiming that “conservatism” is somehow to blame for the West current policies and policies of the last 30 years is simply a bad faith actor trying to find a scapegoat to blame.
      Also, the money to provide these homes, simply does not exist, it is a fantasy. Even if all the wealth of Ireland’s wealthiest were to be seized. There would barely be enough wealth to fund the building of 75,000 homes, which would not meet demand.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому

      ⁠​⁠@mikemcgrath-bryan2765Ireland have and have had for many years now, successive government who have implemented and maintained Liberal economic policy, and more recently Liberal foreign policy particularly with the Irish government’s stance on Ukraine.
      How on earth have you come to the conclusion that the failures of Liberalism are the failures of conservatives?

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765Every single Irish government for the past 30 years has been dominated by Liberalism and have enacted Liberal policy.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому

      ⁠​⁠@mikemcgrath-bryan2765>”The cost of living crisis isn’t the fault of immigrants”
      Who is blaming the cost of living crisis on immigrants?
      The cost of living crises is caused by successive governments who have put in place or maintained liberal policies including liberal immigration policy.

  • @wolfiezane637
    @wolfiezane637 Рік тому +26

    Anyone can read from a script... What your saying is pure Waffle .. It certainly is not like that in reality on the ground ... Can imagine where you got your statistics .... Ask some people in Sweden... I'm sure they'll relate the reality of what happens .. their country and culture has been destroyed... Why go on with such tripe

    • @lululiga333
      @lululiga333 10 місяців тому +1

      Yes he’s totally making it up pretending we have a thorough vetting system. He couldn’t be more wrong.

  • @jameswilde3203
    @jameswilde3203 8 місяців тому +2

    defending the indefensible and it is not scary mongering it is a fact

  • @jodojodo8558
    @jodojodo8558 Рік тому +10

    The wider geopolitical reality is relevant and shouldn't be overlooked or reduced in importance when considering thissituation - in particular the motivation driving those whose objective it is, is to gain legal residence in our countries - the reasons for their seeking entry into our countries.
    Naturally SOME of the people already admitted asylum and SOME of those who will be admitted in the future WILL be affiliated and associate with anti-western ideologies - and it is absolutely reasonable that people should point out this irrefutable and very unfortunate reality....
    There IS an ideological conflict between the West and the objectives of many of the religions and cultural groups which are in power in the native countries of, and therefore highly influential in the personal development of, those who are born and raised under such extremist, anti-western philosophies in such places.... And it is absolutely reasonable to assume that a certain percentage, albeit perhaps a low percentage, though nonetheless a certain percentage of those who attain asylum in our countries are here for nefarious intents - such a line of reasoning would not be classifiable as racist as there is ample historical evidence which would bear out this conclusion.
    And there is also the worry that those amongst those who are permitted asylum might be radicalised by ideological extremists after they have gained asylum due to their being housed in closed quarters with such individuals.
    A brief an honest appraisal of the fundamental tenets of the religious beliefs and ideological premises of these systems which form the basis of the personal development of especially the young men leaving such culturally distinct regions should be appraised without the bias that to do so is to exercise racist or discriminatory thinking.
    A few bad apples is all it takes to spoil the lot.
    Cultural assimilation is all well and good when the motivation is pure....

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +3

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765Do you agree that it is morally wrong to accuse someone of racism who is not racist?

    • @jodojodo8558
      @jodojodo8558 Рік тому

      @mike_mcgb
      We on this island can generally agree to disagree....
      That's the major difference - would you like to get into the minors??

    • @patrickmurphy9597
      @patrickmurphy9597 7 місяців тому

      Dido! If you aren't willing to embrace the Western tradition and cultural norms, don't come to the West. The sticky point is with Islam ☪️. Islam, in its traditional form, does not separate the political from the religious. It does not separate church and state. Even in the high middle ages in the west, there was a distinction between the state and church. Islam, in its authentic expression, is a political-theology. Now, that's not to say all Muslims adhere to this, but a significant % do adhere to this idea.

  • @MrNicholasPower
    @MrNicholasPower Рік тому +19

    Thank you Terry for trying to bring some context to this important discussion. However I sense a strong bias in your comments regarding the opinions of concerned Irish citizens about this issue. They may not be as well informed as you regarding the legalities but their concerns are just as legitimate. You completely ignore the social issues which are already of grave concern as a direct result of our governments immigration policies. When did our government prior to allowing documented or undocumented migrants enter the country carry out a detailed audit of our capacity to do so? Why has this turned into a “nice little earner” for certain people with a spare office block or hotel to fill their bank accounts? And most importantly why does our government not prioritise the housing of our homeless population first? There is major social unrest developing in our country as a result of this inept government policy, yet you seem to conveniently disregard this in your opinion.

    • @dazza4345
      @dazza4345 Рік тому +1

      Tax payer will pay for it 😂

    • @johnos2765
      @johnos2765 Рік тому +3

      Because he absolutely is bias.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765Why is it that uneducated bigots like you, who lack a basic understanding political economy, seek to ignore the problems of liberal immigration systems by being a bad faith actor?

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 I don’t understand why you are so angry. You are a Liberal, it is Liberal foreign policy Liberal economic policy and Liberal immigration policy that has created this crises. This is what you support.
      I and all good people appose your politics of destroying the lives of ordinary people and then forcing ordinary people to pay to pick up the pieces.
      You have got what you want, now own it.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +2

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 >”I suppose you’re just…”
      You are shadowboxing again.

  • @deet1558
    @deet1558 Рік тому +8

    No they destroyed there documents on purpose in most cases,pre talked about before entry and therefore the best way to manipulate our system.

  • @aviewoftown
    @aviewoftown 7 місяців тому +1

    These are economic migrants.

    • @aviewoftown
      @aviewoftown 4 місяці тому

      @mike_mcgb like the Irish, no way. The Irish got nought for free, earned every cent with their own hard work and sweat.

  • @derekmannion4390
    @derekmannion4390 Рік тому +10

    Im not a solicitor or far from as educated as your goodself Terry but have you any idea as in how many refugees we let into our small island im not far right but what exactly is our full capacity limit at

    • @deet1558
      @deet1558 Рік тому

      blah blah blah

    • @frankmccabe9085
      @frankmccabe9085 Рік тому

      And more BLA

    • @johnos2765
      @johnos2765 Рік тому

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 Doesn't mean shit. We don't pack it with the third world.

    • @johnos2765
      @johnos2765 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 What are they fleeing? What are the men of Georgia fleeing? Why on earth is it all bus loads of military aged men fleeing?? Where are the women and children going? ?
      You need to ask these questions instead of wanting to appear as a nice guy.
      Mass immigration of unskilled people who will not work and cost the taxpayers billions in the long run is a complete disaster.
      Once they are in it is permanent. We owe nobody nothing and charity begins at home.

    • @johnos2765
      @johnos2765 Рік тому

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 cut the bullshit and answer the question

  • @nicolarse-stubborn
    @nicolarse-stubborn 9 місяців тому +1

    One of your own caused this ,cheap ryan air flights made it easy ,and from airports that no one from ireland or the uk would ever think of travelling to

  • @interestedpart2650
    @interestedpart2650 10 місяців тому +5

    Even a Solicitor like Gerry who seems intelligent, discerning and reasonable can lack the ability to see a larger geo-political Meta view, which needs understanding of the United Nations, the World Economic Forum and other large Stake holders, in order to grasp the sheer magnitude of the changes that are coming down the tracks.

    • @adelinekeys6582
      @adelinekeys6582 2 місяці тому

      Oh that's just a conspiracy theory! 😂

  • @BrianPatrick-rj3bm
    @BrianPatrick-rj3bm Рік тому +4

    Would an applicant be allowed into Ireland after committing a triple murder in the country they fled

    • @terrygorry
      @terrygorry  Рік тому +1

      If she meets the criteria for asylum 😉

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +3

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765You have reimagined OP’s comment as OP imagined a situation so as to give reason to be angry, so as you give yourself reason to be angry.
      Do you see why you are in the wrong?

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 OP isn’t shadowboxing. You are the only person here shadowboxing.
      Shadowboxing is a common place liberal tactic, often employed when pretending that they are fighting a non existent threat such as a supposed racist threat, fascist threat, far right threat. Conservatives very rarely use the shadowboxing tactic.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 What of my usage of the term Liberal do you not understand? I will do my very best to educate you.
      Also, please try to write coherently, I realise you are getting desperate but you keep writing incoherent nonsense. Perhaps take a moment to collect yourself, calm down and try again.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 No you is a debating strategy and you are attempting it.
      You have tied yourself up in knots, it is always fun humiliating uneducated bigots and bad faith actors like you. And with that in mind, let’s keep the pressure on you, so. Tell us where OP is shadowboxing. Hint, you won’t be able to.

  • @write2pras84
    @write2pras84 Рік тому +1

    Thank you for providing this important context and information to the public discourse. Often times, people have either a skewed or partial or complete mis understanding of the situation.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +4

      We need to provide relevant context, for example spreading awareness that Irish culture is indeed being displaced as a result of liberal immigration systems. We should also seek to stamp out common Left wing falsehoods, by spreading awareness and recognise that Liberal foreign policy generates refugees.

  • @jacquelineleathem3407
    @jacquelineleathem3407 Рік тому +7

    Fea so quick they leave any women and children behind ??? 😮 pull the other one these are simply opportunist ..

  • @jimmymcjimmyvich9052
    @jimmymcjimmyvich9052 Рік тому +7

    I am gonna destroy my parking ticket)))

  • @liammacaodha4783
    @liammacaodha4783 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for tidying up some of the confusion.

  • @seanhart5533
    @seanhart5533 11 місяців тому +2

    Nice and safe in your bird singing garden surly he have room in your garden no didn't think so,! Don't take this old clown seriously

  • @davejmanning544
    @davejmanning544 Рік тому +5

    Thanks Terry, but the waters are muddied. It's breeding xenophobic racial divide and frustration. For example, why take in a refugee when you take in an Irish homeless person. There in lies the existential rub.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +3

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765>”We have more than enough resources”
      No you do not.
      >Scapegoat
      Where? Where is there any significant political movement, body, organisation across the West that blames immigrants? Hint, it doesn’t exist, it is just a scapegoat that you employ.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому +1

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765Notice how you are, yet again, shadowboxing in your above comment.

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 Answer the question…Where is there any significant political movement, body, organisation across the West that blames immigrants?

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765 Are you unable to name a significant political movement, body or organisation across the West that blames immigrants?

    • @suburbanyobbo9412
      @suburbanyobbo9412 Рік тому

      @mikemcgrath-bryan2765Answer the question.

  • @MICHAELCAMPBELL69
    @MICHAELCAMPBELL69 10 місяців тому +1

    Say it’s in his interest to have them.

  • @mrsuperger5429
    @mrsuperger5429 Рік тому +1

    How many asylum seekers are you taking in. ?

  • @johntaylor3940
    @johntaylor3940 Рік тому +3

    BLOOD TEST THEM ALL

  • @rabapatrick8906
    @rabapatrick8906 Рік тому +1

    Elephant in the room hahahaha

  • @ApinderSingh-b2c
    @ApinderSingh-b2c 10 місяців тому

    Why only Ireland why not bigger country like Australia

  • @Allegedly2right
    @Allegedly2right 11 місяців тому

    Didn’t listen did they haha well you are proper knackered now Mister fleeing France,let’s build them some nice houses so as when they come out the Hotel they can settle in Haha money in it Boyo.

  • @stevozrepto5558
    @stevozrepto5558 Рік тому +2

    Only 3 per 1000 a week month year
    Come on man 😴😴😴😴🇵🇸🇵🇸

  • @stevozrepto5558
    @stevozrepto5558 Рік тому

    RYAN AIR 😂😂😂
    .