Wahoo Elemnt ACE Impressions - This or Garmin Edge 1050?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 114

  • @vengermanu9375
    @vengermanu9375 3 дні тому +71

    DC Rainmaker not so impressed

    • @NeilLavitt
      @NeilLavitt 3 дні тому +8

      I'm not surprised; it sounds like they have shipped an unfinished product. Not that Garmin wouldn't ever do that, LOL

  • @RyonBeachner
    @RyonBeachner 3 дні тому +10

    Be careful with the out front mounts on integrated bar/stems. This unit is large, and heavy, and if you go ahead and add a GoPro or headlight for riding in the evenings, you’ll want to check the user manual on the bars to verify that the bar is rated for the combined weight, or you risk ripping the threaded fittings out of the bar when hitting rough terrain or potholes. I run an Edge 1040, and when I add up the weights vs what my bars are rated for, I’m within 20g of the limit, so this thing would be a no go.
    Also, considering the weight is further out, it’s going to have even more leverage and reduce the rated weight by some amount.

    • @thrawed
      @thrawed 2 дні тому

      One thing to consider is with a light or gopro underneath is a gopro-finger extension piece that moves the weight backwards towards the stem so there's far less leverage acting on the mount.

  • @wsbygt
    @wsbygt 3 дні тому +8

    Even though the AERO data is very nice it´s way too big and heavy. I´ll keep waiting for a faster, lighter and battery durable new Roam. Thank you for the video!

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  3 дні тому +1

      I'm sure the Roam v3 will get some of these updates, the touchscreen and new menu layout and a long battery run time would be nice, that's all I really need right now

    • @wsbygt
      @wsbygt 2 дні тому

      @@davidarthur It needs a bigger CPU. The V2 struggles with reassessing courses along with a sizeable latency gathering on-the-fly data. And, so annoying having it restarting the resume several times when standing at traffic lights or just stopping.

  • @kainlestad
    @kainlestad 2 дні тому +3

    Garmin edge 1050 all the way baby!❤

  • @Endlessways13
    @Endlessways13 3 дні тому +3

    I just picked up a Wahoo Roam v2 for my first bike computer. I'm hyped to see the Ace!

  • @marcelsow5817
    @marcelsow5817 3 дні тому +7

    as I am watching your video about the new bike computer, I am getting an email from Wahoo Fitness "the wait is over. Meet ELEMNT Ace" 😂

  • @Bike4Coffee-Cake
    @Bike4Coffee-Cake 3 дні тому +2

    Sorry you haven’t been well - hope you are fully recovered!!
    Enjoyed the discussion about the wind sensor - I’m sure you could use it to optimise drafting in the short term.
    DC Rainmaker also has some good points on battery life and missing features, but I enjoyed both your review and his - good to get different perspectives!
    Thank you!

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 дні тому

      Thanks and yes fully recovered. The wind speed sensor is interesting remains to be seen how useful long term it really is, but definitely potential to optimise position and positioning

  • @robinsonsadventures2174
    @robinsonsadventures2174 3 дні тому +12

    Too big, might as well ride with my Mac book pro on my handlebars 😂😂😂😂

    • @RomanArzumanyan
      @RomanArzumanyan День тому

      Will work like charm until it starts to rain.

    • @KOL630
      @KOL630 День тому

      Have to say I don’t like these massive units. Look like an iPhone on the bike and that is proper kook territory right there 😂

  • @samrossnj
    @samrossnj 3 дні тому +4

    Everyone is getting their winter head cold so bad that the UA-cam guy is even sick. Get some rest and hydrate Dave!

  • @MacTech007
    @MacTech007 2 дні тому +2

    Great review. I have the Wahoo Element Roam v2.0. . Don't think I will go for this new Wahoo Element Ace. Will likely go for the Garmin 1050.

  • @Waldorianer
    @Waldorianer 3 дні тому +7

    I really think this is the best way to sell more roams and bolts. I do not understand at whom this is targeted. The aero sensor is a cool gimmick but is irrelevant for training particularly if you use a power meter. Enthusiasts and even more so competitive cyclists already mostly chose the bolt over the roam for weight reasons. On the other hand, if you are not weight obsessed and only want navigation features, you could just use your phone. I am a wahoo fan and if the ace was more like the Garmin in the video dimension and weight wise it could have been interesting. Wahoo just went too far with the design for my taste.

    • @Mr_Zzzeee
      @Mr_Zzzeee 2 дні тому

      Bought a bolt a couple days ago lol

  • @zitzthesmartass7788
    @zitzthesmartass7788 3 дні тому +8

    This wind sensor is redundant. Wahoo tried to introduce something new, but they ended up with a heavy brick...

  • @fixxzitt
    @fixxzitt 3 дні тому +1

    Elmnt roam v2 user here. Cool gadget. Anyway to recalibrate aerospeed sensor as it get used.

  • @n22pdf
    @n22pdf 3 дні тому +3

    Looks nice, good review but still love my Bolt V2 and won’t be changing to this 😊 Pete 🚴🏻👍

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  3 дні тому +1

      The Bolt is so good. Only prefer the Roam as easier to see with my bad eyesight!

  • @davidhazelton5370
    @davidhazelton5370 День тому +1

    Very happy so far with my Coros Dura.

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  День тому

      Cool, good to hear. Plan to do some more testing in the NY with it now there have been more firmware updates

  • @londonbello95
    @londonbello95 15 годин тому

    Hi David. Can you please tell me what are your handlebars

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  14 годин тому

      Van Rysel RCR Pro handlebars

  • @francescobarabba1057
    @francescobarabba1057 День тому

    A technical question. Inside the wind sensor slot, insects and dust can enter, but especially with humidity and rain. Isn't the device damaged by dust and especially moisture that enters?

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  День тому +1

      That's a good question for long term testing. They say it can be cleaned out and left to dry afterwards but we'll have to see how it fares with real world riding over the coming months

    • @francescobarabba1057
      @francescobarabba1057 День тому

      @@davidarthur I also think it will be seen in the long term. I'm very curious. But I believe that we have already thought about something like this and have found an adequate solution. Anyway, nice technological challenge. Thanks for the reply

  • @lajosjuhasz4363
    @lajosjuhasz4363 2 дні тому

    I would like to have turn by turn navigation (it is useful when on unknown roads in a traffic where you cannot watch the map and we know that modern GPS devices can sometimes lead you the wrong way when they confuse the direction, a voice navigation might correct that).
    I am going to stay with my trusted Bolt 2 for a couple of years before I decide to upgrade to Garmin 1060 or Ace 2. (I am going to need a bigger screen size)

  • @NeilLavitt
    @NeilLavitt 3 дні тому +1

    The last time I heard about TFT screens was late 1990's laptop screens.

    • @drill_fiend1097
      @drill_fiend1097 19 годин тому

      All these cycling computers are using TFT presumably for viewing without backlights. But at this day I would rather see AOD style oled or color e-ink instead.

  • @markroe4952
    @markroe4952 День тому

    Do you have any ideas why I cannot sync either Strava or rideGPS despite doing authorisation on this device. This works fine on the Roam

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  День тому

      You've gone into the authorised apps menu in the wahoo app and given them permission? There's an auto-share in the drop down menu which is tied off by default.

  • @jeronerGaming
    @jeronerGaming 3 дні тому

    Thanks for the review! Just wondering, what computer mount did you show? I’m looking to replace my Canyon front light mount since the Ace won’t fit without scratching the handlebar/Ace.

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 дні тому

      The carbon one? Just a cheapo from amazon!

  • @wimbemong2375
    @wimbemong2375 2 дні тому

    Does it fit on the new super light mount from the new Scott Addict RC?

  • @Enzo575
    @Enzo575 День тому

    I think the wind sensor thingy made this design a lil to big. Most riders have weight priorities and i don't think this would sell as much. Probably for MTBs maybe . If they have a Version 2 in the future get rid of the unnecessary sensor and bring back the LEDs

  • @danielt91
    @danielt91 2 дні тому

    Pro tip: Cover the wind sensor with your hand during cycling to get extremely aero... at least according to this gimmick feature

  • @bwtms
    @bwtms 3 дні тому +1

    I have a K-Edge mount, which is basically Wahoo Bolt sized, can it be fitted or is it too long to fit?

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  3 дні тому

      Without testing that exact combo I'm not sure but provided there's adequate clearance to the handlebar it should be fine - that's a small issue with both the Ace and 1050, some integrated out front mounts barely allow the bigger computers to fit

    • @dmitrymyronov
      @dmitrymyronov 3 дні тому

      ​@@davidarthur Hi David, I was wondering if you were able to successfully mount Ace to your new Aeroad?

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  3 дні тому

      The Aeroads both went back to Canyon a while ago so can't check that for you I'm afraid. The Edge 1050 did fit so I would hope the mount also has space for the Ace, but I do think there will be some bikes where it might not fit

    • @dmitrymyronov
      @dmitrymyronov 3 дні тому +1

      @@davidarthur thank you for the prompt reply and a review!

  • @uberamd
    @uberamd 3 дні тому +1

    It seems like a couple rides in the mud, especially if you're following a group, will result in that unservicable air port getting completely clogged. You should give this a test on some mountain bike singletrack in the winter to see just how dirty it gets. Puzzling design decision to be honest, but I guess I understand why their marketing materials don't really push this feature much beyond mentioning that it exists.

  • @onghay
    @onghay 3 дні тому +1

    No mention about the bell?

    • @Pilgrim13090
      @Pilgrim13090 2 дні тому

      Because it’s an other gimmick, just use your voice to signal and keep your hands ready on the brake levers if it is not enough

  • @Mistadonthecyclist
    @Mistadonthecyclist День тому

    Wahoo just released a cell phone. That looks like an OG HTC

  • @olishobbyscene1643
    @olishobbyscene1643 2 дні тому

    what mount are you using?

  • @ataricommodore
    @ataricommodore 2 дні тому

    Tell me please, no one shows how many data fields fit on the map. Are there 6 fields available like ROAM? And if it also has 6 fields, is the map still useful - visible.

  • @eriknoren7078
    @eriknoren7078 3 дні тому

    Can you download routes from Garmin Connect to a Wahoo Ace?

  • @vongdong10
    @vongdong10 2 дні тому +1

    They can piss off with that price. Literally not far from 'good' smartphone prices.

  • @sherwinpais
    @sherwinpais 2 дні тому

    Love the flycatcher

  • @funnights74
    @funnights74 2 дні тому

    As hyped as i was about a bigger screen with touch function the missing strava live segments and poor route profile (even though its on the box) its a no from me. A good unit thats not quite ready is how i see it and at that price point it really should be ready.

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 дні тому

      Those features and others are planned for firmware updates next year and other ones too so guess maybe wait until they’ve been added before taking a closer look? All the core functionality is in place though and works well in my experience so far, but agree shame all the features aren’t here. Guess they wanted to get it out for Christmas sales?

  • @denisspratt926
    @denisspratt926 2 дні тому

    This is for those that do racing and especially TTs I think.
    Cause most people don´t really need all the functions on this.
    I ride for the fun of it, don´t really care how fast I am going or how much power I put out.
    I would love a computer with a screen this size.
    But i don´t need all the functions on it.
    I mostly want it to have a bigger screen for the maps.
    So wish they would make a budget version with the screen and the basic functions.
    Like how long of a ride you've done and maybe max. speed and average speed.
    But that´s all I need.

  • @juanhidalgo7043
    @juanhidalgo7043 22 години тому

    I was going to get it but I am not. The biggest for me the ace is too thick and if you look at the screen wahoo is not utilizing the full screen. At the bottom by the keys there is a big black gap! Why?

  • @wildsurfer12
    @wildsurfer12 3 дні тому +1

    It seems awfully big for a bike computer. Couldn’t they just update the roam with a touchscreen?

  • @pj9375
    @pj9375 3 дні тому +1

    Brick!!!! I ride a 5kg bike no way I’m strapping that big boy on, and not on the bike either 😂

  • @lukeoneil2341
    @lukeoneil2341 3 дні тому +31

    the only review that matters is DC Rainmaker

    • @davidegai7264
      @davidegai7264 3 дні тому +2

      Totally agree

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  3 дні тому +29

      Glad you came onto my video and write a comment to tell me that ;)

    • @theenthusiast7987
      @theenthusiast7987 3 дні тому +7

      What are you doing here then? 😂😅

    • @NeilLavitt
      @NeilLavitt 3 дні тому +4

      Not true, it is good to hear different viewpoints. I will also be interested to hear GP Lama's view. The fact that he hasn't posted yet doesn't bode well as he often holds back when a unit isn't ready. He's been burnt by Shimano in the past.

    • @funnights74
      @funnights74 2 дні тому +2

      Yes, I fear DC might have killed this baby in its crib, he was scathing. Wahoo need to do the necessary upgrades asap and not " some time next year" 😮😮..simply not good enough.

  • @jazzfan7491
    @jazzfan7491 2 дні тому +1

    Not sure why I wouldn’t just use my phone which I’m already carrying anyway

  • @russford2802
    @russford2802 3 дні тому

    I think its a bit too big and heavy in relative terms for the weight conscious riders out there. Seems to be of more use to the longer distance traveller rider that isn't trying to justify every last gramme on the bike. On a separate item was that the Fairlight you were riding towards the end of the vid? As always nice work and get well soon.

  • @SignorLuigi
    @SignorLuigi 3 дні тому

    The only thing that's bigger than the price on these bike computers are the gigantic, empty black bezels. If a company made smartphones or tablets with bezels like this, they would go out of business.

  • @KeatB
    @KeatB 3 дні тому

    DC Rainmaker says it’s not finished and shouldn’t have been released until next year. Loads of missing functionality (Strava segments etc,..)

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  3 дні тому +3

      The core functionality, which I mainly tested, all worked fine during my couple of weeks with it. I must confess I don't use stuff like Strava segments but I do know Wahoo has more firmware updates planned over the coming months so I'll do an update in the new year and test out a few other features - any specifically you're interested in?

    • @KeatB
      @KeatB 3 дні тому

      @ no thanks. I was more interested in the form factor. Sadly they’ve still made it clunky with large bottom bezel. I got rid of my Roam v2 for that reason. 1040 solar is found the job at the moment.

    • @NeilLavitt
      @NeilLavitt 3 дні тому

      @@davidarthur, battery life was one of my biggest concerns. It sounds like the unit is not optimised yet. That being said, I stopped buying head units at release after being burnt by my Edge 1040, which frankly struggled with buggy software at release.

  • @se9741
    @se9741 2 дні тому +2

    Wahoo electronics and products in general are overpriced trash. Buy garmin you won’t regret it.

    • @jou3708
      @jou3708 День тому

      Bolt v2 and Roam v2 are 2 best bike computers for great price, used by many many sutisfied customers.

  • @edittide9842
    @edittide9842 2 дні тому

    First impressions so I guess not a fully baked opinion. The size and heft of this thing astounds me. May as well put a desktop on your handlebars. Wahoo has miss read the market here I think.

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 дні тому

      Yes very much first impressions, I focused on the core functionality but there are features missing which Wahoo are adding next year, but arguably should be here now (depends how important those other features are to you, not everyone uses Strava Live Segments for example) - I'm guessing they wanted to get it out for Christmas...

  • @alantait5968
    @alantait5968 14 годин тому

    Wahoo really missed a trick here it’s all very well making a bigger screen but this is 2024. The screen should be edge to edge like a mobile phone or at least close. This unit look too big bulky and heavy real shame as I do think Wahoo has one of the better interfaces.

  • @thomasreese5000
    @thomasreese5000 3 дні тому

    wow that screen is huge

  • @madrapperdave
    @madrapperdave 23 години тому

    Aero sensor is the possibly the least interesting feature. I just like the bigger screen real estate.

  • @Irnbruist
    @Irnbruist 3 дні тому

    Was considering to switch from Garmin to Wahoo for the nicer display, small size and the awesome led lights - everything is gone in the new Ace, so definitely waiting for a Roam V3

  • @freebird61885
    @freebird61885 3 дні тому

    The weight isn’t ideal, but what is it, 40g heavier than the 1050? Come on people…

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  3 дні тому

      Interesting isn't it, weight has never been a factor with computers but this one is getting some serious flak

    • @Waldorianer
      @Waldorianer 3 дні тому

      I would agree, but wahoo should know that cyclists spend fortunes to save 40g on a wheel set or frame. I know that this does not matter for the average recreational cyclist but unless forced to do so no pro will every use this.

    • @NeilLavitt
      @NeilLavitt 3 дні тому

      @@davidarthur a mouth full of water heavier.

  • @MauroErazo
    @MauroErazo 3 дні тому +1

    heavy and expensive.

  • @dominikhinterreiter603
    @dominikhinterreiter603 3 дні тому +2

    nice

  • @the-portuguese-guy
    @the-portuguese-guy 3 дні тому +3

    This device no make any sense to be released.
    The people if having a aluminium wheel... needing buy a carbon wheel because aluminium is too heavy, but now with 200gr plus gps device is no problem ? Wahoo need to go sell this fish on another harbour 😅

  • @huibsmeets8564
    @huibsmeets8564 2 дні тому

    Just too big, the 1050 is on the border, the Ace crossed it IMHO.

  • @EmmanuelNataf
    @EmmanuelNataf 3 дні тому

    When I see the lag as you navigate, my brain says "no". Sadly both Wahoo and garmin still suck - it's the price of an iPhone without the design or software. It's even heavier! Massive bezels, painfully slow, hardly any innovation… There's still space for someone to do something far better in this space.

    • @NeilLavitt
      @NeilLavitt 3 дні тому

      I doubt it. The Karoo was probably the option and yet the Karoo 3 is what we got.

  • @Yazzie95
    @Yazzie95 2 дні тому

    The Hammerhead is far better and lighter

  • @Andy_ATB
    @Andy_ATB 3 дні тому

    If I want to know what the wind is like, I'll just look out the window or my weather apps. Why would you need a wind sensor? More nonsensical tech.......

  • @weiweiensheff9322
    @weiweiensheff9322 3 дні тому

    That’s way too heavy

  • @rayF4rio
    @rayF4rio 2 дні тому

    The Edge 1050 is large, the Wahoo ACE is obese. No go for me.

    • @davidarthur
      @davidarthur  2 дні тому

      I always thought the 1050 was too big but the Ace managed to make it feel small!

  • @rhenceocampo3253
    @rhenceocampo3253 9 годин тому

    Never buy a promise

  • @lindysbabylon
    @lindysbabylon День тому

    To big. Looks like my iPhone Ill stick to my Bolt

  • @vitapumpkin4732
    @vitapumpkin4732 2 дні тому

    Nah~ pass~

  • @andysteadman8851
    @andysteadman8851 2 дні тому

    A load of expensive unnecessariness

  • @jozeskufca2255
    @jozeskufca2255 2 дні тому

    Too big and heavy

  • @tony5269
    @tony5269 3 дні тому

    Yup I got the Email 📧 also I’ll be getting it will have to save up for it.

    • @NeilLavitt
      @NeilLavitt 3 дні тому +1

      Saving is probably a good option, as they'll have the software sorted by then.

  • @philko4486
    @philko4486 3 дні тому

    Looks like a brick.

  • @artt3231
    @artt3231 3 дні тому

    It’s gigantic!!! 🫣